I think you're vastly over estimating the barrier of entry to marriage.
There’s noise as well as signal for sure but I maintain that marriage is absolutely a useful fitness filter. At the very least, at least one other person has agreed to enter into a long term relationship with them. It will filter out unsocialized basement dwellers, for example.
Sure, there are drunken Vegas marriages to strangers which fall apart 24 hours later, but I think those are the exception.
That's still a very low barrier to entry: sure, they managed to get married, but they apparently can't commit to a long-term relationship.
Re:RFC: Let's Disrupt Dating Apps
by floatingatoll on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @11:17AM
(#22414383)
It’s a very high barrier relative to “no barrier”. (Also: remember that open long-term marriages do exist with the voluntary consent of both parties.)
What I mean is it only weeds out a few true negatives, but produces a ton of false negatives and false positives.
It seems like a plausible business model too, since presumably cheaters aren’t expecting long-term relationships and will be back for more.