It’s hard to know if that person really was an asshole, or if the person writing the review was the asshole. The only way to know is to accumulate a bunch of separate reviews and maybe try some complicated ML algorithm on the intricacies of the messages/find trends in a person’s reviews (if everyone around them is negative, it’s probably not other people), but...if you start to get to a point where someone has an obvious trend, they’ve probably been through loads of partners, and people looking for dating and not hookups generally don’t want someone who’s churning through new partners constantly.
If you have a solution to this problem, divorce attorneys around the world would pay you for it. It’s way more valuable than a dating app.
Jesus christ HN. Not everything is a datapoint to be gamified and exploited.
I wouldn't trust a testimonial from your ex-wife (because either she will hate you or, if you're such a great person as she says, why did she leave you after so long?)
And I wouldn't trust a testimonial from you previous exs, back in the late 90s, early 2000s, because you probably changed a lot since then.
At the opposite end of the spectrum, if I was looking for a long-term relationship, I'd be very wary of anybody providing me with many testimonials of ex-boyfriends from the last 2 years.
This certainly doesn't match my experience.
Among the people I've known, people who don't mind interacting with previous partners are anomalies.
Apps can then strictly filter according to those preferences (some allow disclosure, all have fuzzy filtering at best).
I don't think the core idea in the post would work, though. Scarcity would only be present in the app, genders that enjoy a natural abundance of choice would probably open the other apps after swiping left on everyone in this one.
That's the algorithmic match and the human match. I am X looking for Y, etc.
> Monogamy status
And then of course every single dating site lets you write custom descriptions. (Though IMO it's fair to assume monogamy since that is the overwhelming majority. [1])
[1] https://www.npr.org/2019/02/18/695731314/the-new-sexual-revo...
My argument is that it is actually not (edit/evidence: the prevalence of cheaters), as identifying any other way is met with being a "cheater" or a "slut." Encouraging people to truthfully and shamelessly admit what they are will likely be better for everyone in the long run. Granted, this is a societal problem, but many apps have had an impact on society.
for what it's worth, I've never really encountered issues with people outright lying or seriously misrepresenting themselves on dating apps. the people I've met up with were more or less "as advertised". I think the problem is more that a couple pictures and a short bio just aren't a lot to go on for judging compatibility. also in my experience, people tend to have a list of things they definitely don't want in a partner, but don't actually know what they do want. all my successful long-term relationships have been with people I knew for a while before I ever considered dating them. I never considered them an obvious match upon meeting them.
Then both sides are trying get to simultaneously evaluate the other person (aka "get to know them") while trying to make a good first impression (aka "just be your self" and "act confident")
There's nothing shady about this and there's nothing sad or inhumane or unromantic about this either. It's just human nature
"oh but there are so many companies where the employee/employer balance is totally skewed" I hear you say?
Sure Google will make you run some 6 month long gauntlet. Have you ever tried hitting on the hottest person in a bar when the ratio is already skewed against you?
What about if you are John Carmack or Peter Norvig? Do you think they had to invert a binary tree on a whiteboard?
Just as there is someone out there who will find you the perfect match for them (but they just haven't found you yet) so too is there the perfect company/team out there for you too.
The problem is discovery. Imo tinder was best in a lot of ways simply because by being the one most people used, you had the greatest diversity by virtue of pure numbers
So you could find that person who is a liberal but eats meat daily and knits while watching UFC
You can probably test for those skills. I'm curious how.
Of course, you also need compatibility. But I have a hunch that's both overrated and easier to check for on a date.
That's true to just about every problem, to be honest
A real innovation would be to solve this problem of asymmetric information in dating in a similarly robust, yet scalable fashion.
For example:
* Credible testimonies from ex-partners
* Certification of claimed characteristics (photos, age, weight, income, educational achievement, ...)
* ???
* profit
I don’t know how to achieve these - I’m pretty sure blockchain is not the solution, but something might be possible in that space.