News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by habosa on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:25PM (#22172436)
I tried to do a Sign in with Apple integration on Android (wanted the app to have the same options across platforms).

Testing on Android was next to impossible. To test I needed an Apple ID with 2FA. But SMS 2FA was not good enough, you need the hardware-based 2FA. To get that you need a recent macOS or iOS device. As an Android developer I have no reason to own either of those.

Eventually I just had a friend who owns an iPhone try my app a few times.

Besides that, the Apple interface guidelines are nearly impossible to follow on Android because Apple doesn't provide the logo or font assets you need to comply. There is no SDK whatsoever, just a spec.

Seems like a nice sign-in option for iPhone owners but it's a portability disaster.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by ehsankia on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:36PM (#22172576)
Apple continues to not give any care whatsoever to anything outside their walled garden. For the longest time you couldn't even preview songs on iTunes store without having iTunes. Want to watch their biggest WWDC live? Had to use Safari until last year. Obviously iMessage and FaceTime are complete no-gos outside their walled garden too.

This is how they keep people in. They have to close down their walls as tightly as possible, to force people in. And once you're in, they make it as hard as possible to leave.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by coldtea on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:11PM (#22174060)
>This is how they keep people in. They have to close down their walls as tightly as possible, to force people in. And once you're in, they make it as hard as possible to leave.

I call old wives tales. I'm a close-to-20-years Apple user. The walled garden has never been a problem, more of a strength (integration, cohesion, etc).

Especially today where everything is a subscription, there has never been LESS of a walled garden in that regard. I can move anytime (and I do use also Windows and Linux) and I wont have any issue with OS X/iOS.

I just wont have my apps -- which has been the case for every OS ever.

My music is in Spotify and Apple Music, my video is Netflix and Amazon Prime and Apple+, my email is Gmail, my eBooks in Kindle for Mac and iOS, I talk with friends with Skype, Facetime, Messenger and Whatsup. Even my iCloud apps (Calendar, email, etc) are available from any browser.

Some "walled garden".

The reason I don't want to move from OS X/iOS is cohesion and usability. Despite BS like the 3+ years MBP keyboard fiasco or the not-really-useful BS touch strip, it's still the best HW/SW combo for my kind of computing (programming, lots of UNIXy stuff, lots of video and music as well).

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by StavrosK on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:24PM (#22174767)
> My music is in Spotify and Apple Music, my video is Netflix and Amazon Prime and Apple+

Does Spotify somehow integrate with Apple Music and Netflix with Apple+? Because, if not, your counterargument is just "there's no walled garden because I'm outside it".

Spotify, Netflix, Google, Kindle, etc work on both platforms. Apple stuff doesn't. That's the definition of "walled garden", that you can't use Android and still use any Apple stuff.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by denkmoon on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:42PM (#22174918)
FWIW Apple Music does work on android, reasonably well too. I switched to that when it became apparent that Google Play Music is a dead product, soon to be sent to the glue factory.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by thewebcount on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:36PM (#22175873)
Do you know if Apple Music is available on Windows? I know iTunes has been on Windows for years, so I assume it supported Apple Music initially, just like on the Mac?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by denkmoon on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:48PM (#22175966)
They currently have a web player beta going, https://beta.music.apple.com/, but personally I use https://vusic.site/ because the apple beta is a little unstable and it suits my needs.

iTunes for windows does support Apple Music, but iTunes is still a pig and best not installed on your PC.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by recordlabel on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:49PM (#22175976)
I believe iTunes for windows is still a thing and it supported apple music when I tried it last year.

iTunes as a software is horrible though

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by haecceity on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:19PM (#22175271)
Why do people use Apple Music over Spotify?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by thewebcount on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:36PM (#22175866)
One reason I use Apple Music over Spotify is that Apple Music is entirely supported by paying customers rather than by ads. This aligns thier incentives more closely to mine.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by rootusrootus on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:43PM (#22175447)
Spotify was a hassle when I tried to sign up for an account (I don't recall exactly, it's been a few months, but some sort of technical glitch), and I didn't have enough desire to chase it down just so I could give them my money. So I've stuck with Apple Music because I can't justify to myself or my wife (we have a family plan) how Spotify would be an improvement. I was willing to try it out because my Tesla has a built-in player for Spotify, but I've just been using the Tesla streaming instead (when not Apple Music) and I'm happy with it.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by jbc1 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:49PM (#22177538)
I was using it because it had voice command support and Spotify didn't. Was pretty important when 100% of my use was while driving. I think that's changed and Spotify has support now but I don't know how smooth that is.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by denkmoon on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:27PM (#22175337)
I don't use spotify for a few reasons. Primarily being I can't add my own music to my library and stream it (you kinda can but it's sub-optimal), second being comfort and usability. You can't easily rearrange your play queue in spotify, while apple music and GPM make this quite easy (including "play next" and "play later" for adding to the front and back of the queue). I find radio stations much better on Apple Music and GPM, Spotify's radio stations/algorithm just don't do it for me.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by tekknik on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:43AM (#22178599)
no ads plus much much more music, especially if you’re into subgenres of electronic music. i haven’t found a song yet that i haven’t found on apple music. they were one of the (if not the) original music store after all
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by coldtea on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:11AM (#22180607)
>Does Spotify somehow integrate with Apple Music and Netflix with Apple+? Because, if not, your counterargument is just "there's no walled garden because I'm outside it".

No, my argument is "there's no walled garden because with subscriptions there are no walls to close you in".

Apple Music is a subscription, you move to Spotify or Pandora or Youtube Music or whatever and that's that. You don't have the loss of your music or whatever locking you down to either OSX/iOS or even Apple Music alone as the parent said. That would be an argument back when music was DRM files you have bought and which would have stopped working outside Apple's ecosystem.

Ditto of course for Netflix, Mail, etc.

The closest you can get to the "walled garden" is iBooks -- Kindle wont display books you've bought there. But you can trivially just use Kindle app on macOS/iOS and problem solved. Apple's not forcing you to use iBooks.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by MagnumOpus on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:41AM (#22182519)
> You don't have the loss of your music or whatever

You just lose playlist and ratings

> you can trivially just use Kindle app on macOS/iOS

Except Apple cripples features of the Kindle app (you cannot buy books through the app because if you did, Apple would demand a 30% cut that represents all of the Amazon profits) that are not crippled in Apple's own offering.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by coldtea on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @01:04PM (#22183750)
>You just lose playlist and ratings

Yes, so peanuts (most people don't even use ratings according to some article I've read - it's for the OCD music nerds, not the millions who just listen to hits and might or might not add some playlists - of which they don't really obsess over).

>Except Apple cripples features of the Kindle app (you cannot buy books through the app because if you did, Apple would demand a 30% cut that represents all of the Amazon profits) that are not crippled in Apple's own offering.

That would be Amazon's crippling it, as it's their choice. They could pay that 30% cut. They themselves demand a 65% cut from authors and publishers at worst case, and 30% (same as Apple) at best.

And again, both very ho-hum example of barriers to move platform.

If stuff like "I'll lose my playlists" is what prevents someone from leaving Apple, then that's the most open walled garden ever...

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by thewebcount on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:37PM (#22175878)
AppleTV+ is also available on the web and on Roku and Samsung TVs. So again, not a walled garden even when using their products.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by StavrosK on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:43PM (#22175929)
Oh okay, if it's on Samsung TVs that's pretty much FOSS levels of openness, I agree.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by oneplane on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @08:50PM (#22176386)
Your reply here seems to try to twist the thread to a point where all uses of 'open' or 'non-walled' has to equate FOSS or EFF ideals, while you probably know that is neither feasible nor what is being discussed. It feels like you're intentionally acting obtuse at this point.
[dead]
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by coldtea on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:20AM (#22180708)
>No, it was sarcastically reducing the argument to an absurdity.

No, it was just a snark with no point. Reductio ad absurdum is a totally different mechanism.

Besically you just shifted the goalposts from the original claim that you're locked to Apple's platforms if you use Apple TV music.

to,

[it might be available on other platforms] but it's not FOSS, haha

when it was pointed to you that your original claim is false and Apple TV is available for platforms like Roku and Samsung.

The rest, accusing the parent of trolling, is just rude. He provided a counter-argument with actual information (that Apple TV is also available in Samsung and Roku).

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by tekknik on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:45AM (#22178612)
actually it looks like you’re the troll, and copping out to the “not gonna reply cause i’m obviously wrong and lack further supporting arguments” statement. apple is opening their walled garden up, both music and apple tv plus are available on other platforms now. for the majority this gives us confidence in buying into their platform, knowing we can take our content with us should we decide we no longer want their devices.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by tekknik on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:41AM (#22178589)
how about the $5k or so in media i have in googles ecosystem? their apps are literally garbage on ios and i had to resort to using youtube to watch content i paid for. even this didn’t work after some time as i have so much media even the youtube app started timing out when loading my purchases. there is no compatible format for ios, so you gotta use their garbage apps. it became such a huge problem that i bought everything that moviesanywhere didn’t already give me over again on itunes store just so i could have an actual file and, you know, actually watch the content i bought. google is substantially worse in their walled garden attempts
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by coldtea on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:13AM (#22180628)
>how about the $5k or so in media i have in googles ecosystem? their apps are literally garbage on ios

I've never seen any Google app being a problem on iOS, much less garbage. It just doesn't have the native look due to Material theming.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by tekknik on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @01:19PM (#22183948)
read my post again, you clearly don’t have enough media to be a problem. on all devices both the google play app and youtube timeout or lock the device up due to the amount of media i have. garbage is an understatement considering how much i spent with them and that I can’t even view any of it anymore without watching on a full desktop / laptop
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by miloignis on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:51PM (#22174448)
I feel like reason you can move is because you haven't put all your eggs in their walled garden, not that they don't have one. I know people who either won't or have regretted switching from an iPhone because they have trouble talking to their friend who only use iMessage. I think Apple is only increasing their walled garden into more areas by expanding into music streaming, TV, etc. You can still use their hardware and OS without fully buying into their walled garden though and maintain more freedom, as you seem to do!

edit: I should mention that while I don't like their walled gardens in general, I don't mind them for other people except iMessage. iMessage makes me fairly angry because they're using & dividing people's social connections for profit.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by rubyn00bie on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:29PM (#22174813)
iMessage is the greatest thing to happen to text messaging since text messaging itself. I refuse to use any Facebook owned product to communicate; so, that pretty much only leaves me SMS and iMessage.

I think you should be pissed at bottom barrel Android manufacturers putting shitty messaging interfaces on Android phones more than Apple for having a good messaging system.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by bdamm on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:33PM (#22175376)
I have Facebook Messenger, Messages (iMessage), WhatsApp, Signal, Hangouts, Slack & Discord all installed on my iPhone. Why hold back?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by rootusrootus on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:48PM (#22175491)
Every app is another opportunity to get a tracker on your phone. I like to limit how many native apps I have installed whenever possible.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by noelsusman on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:57PM (#22175077)
iMessage has done more to hold back messaging in the US than anything else. Even if Google was competent at messaging it wouldn't matter because iOS users wouldn't switch and Apple refuses to open up iMessage to non-Apple devices.

I'm still using SMS for most of my messaging, and I primarily blame Apple for that.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by rootusrootus on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:49PM (#22175505)
Are you asking for Apple to pay for infrastructure for non-customers to use? Or even further, that Apple design and support an Android iMessage app?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by noelsusman on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @12:47PM (#22183504)
Yes, and I am a customer. I own a Macbook, and I would love to use iMessage on it, but doing so would mean losing all of my messages as soon as I pick up a different device. That makes iMessage (and most Apple services) completely useless to me, a paying customer.

Their decision to wall off iMessage actively hurts their own customers by preventing them from seamlessly communicating with the most popular mobile OS using modern technology. They get away with it because they're Apple and they make good products, but that doesn't mean I have to think it's good.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by TurningCanadian on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:23PM (#22176575)
Google's messenger apps work on iOS..
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by rubyn00bie on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @10:30PM (#22177059)
Google makes money from advertising, Apple does not...

Google's incentive is to keep you using their platform across any device; because, that is what is in their best interest, they make their money from billions upon billions of small advertising interactions across a vast ocean of interconnected platforms and devices.

Apple sells physical devices, it's their incentive to make sure the experience is great for whoever bought that device. They make their money from selling billions of devices...

Apple's focus is on the "user," and Google's focus is on the "platform." Both have different types of lock-in, but have different reasons why.

I still lost how it's Apple's problem that the standard interface of SMS/MMS is just totally shitty and not capable of doing what people want. Complain to your telecommunication, handset, and operating system providers/vendors to build or enable a better open standard (like RCS or whatever it is).

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by jonathankoren on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:11PM (#22177342)
If iMessage is a walled garden, then pretty much every other messaging system is also a walled garden since the death of XMPP. Can anyone build a a third party client for WhatsApp or any other popular messaging system in 2020? Im unaware of any. In fact the top result for “third party whatsapp client” is “Use a third party WhatsApp client and be banned for life”. [0] Hardly the behavior of an open system.

What your real complaint is that there isn’t an client for a nonApple operating system. It’s reasonable to not want to switch OSes, but there are many apps that are iOS exclusive, as there are many android exclusive apps, but I wouldn’t call them “walled gardens”.

Also, iMessage doesn’t make money. It an e2e encryption app with sms support. Because it’s provided by Apple, a company that famously makes money on hardware rather than services, there’s no incentive to mine your (and your connections’) data for profit, like say WhatsApp, or the others, so it is incorrect to claim they are “using & dividing people’s social connections for profit”. If anyone is dividing their connections based on iMessage, it’s your friends.

[0] https://www.cultofmac.com/314343/use-a-third-party-whatsapp-...

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by miloignis on Thursday January 30, 2020 @03:13PM (#22195020)
A bit of a late reply, but there were a couple of points that I wanted to respond to. The first is that I'm not holding up WhatsApp as a great example! I use, promote, and have done a bit of development on Matrix, a true open messaging system. If XMPP or IRC floats your boat, I'm all for that as well, and I'll be able to chat with you over the XMPP and IRC Matrix bridges because all 3 are open systems. Second is how high the wall of your walled garden is matters, and matters a lot. Sure I can't write my own WhatsApp client, but I can download the app relatively easily on both Android and iOS. To communicate with people over iMessage I would have to buy a different phone and accept everything that comes with it (including the rest of the walled garden, appwise, oswise, etc). Finally, when I said they were doing it for profit I meant that the fact that iMessage only works with Apple products makes it such that if you want a good communication experience with your Apple-only friends you also have to buy into the ecosystem, and once you have it's hard to get out because you might lose those connections.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by anoncake on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @04:20AM (#22178776)
> If iMessage is a walled garden, then pretty much every other messaging system is also a walled garden since the death of XMPP.

No whataboutism please.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by thephyber on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:11PM (#22174666)
iMessage is backwards compatible with SMS.

Are you talking about the unwillingness of users to migrate their chats to WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, etc? That’s not a walled garden - that’s the natural hesitance to leave any comfortable/familiar system that any social media / network effect site/app has. It’s more like a psychological moat. And even the app you want Apple users to migrate to has it.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by StavrosK on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:25PM (#22174771)
He's talking about the fact that iMessage only runs on Apple hardware. That's what a walled garden is.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by tekknik on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:47AM (#22178624)
ok? and googles messaging app only runs on android. the app doesn’t require the recipient to have imessage, however if they do you get benefits (like increased message size) over sms due to limitations in sms.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by anoncake on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @04:17AM (#22178766)
Which one? Hangouts runs on iOS. The one for SMS and MMS does not but does Apple even allow that?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by tekknik on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @01:13PM (#22183878)
hangouts is dead, so again can i run googles sms app on an iphone? further google killed xmpp support which would’ve allowed 3rd party clients to use their message services
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by anoncake on Wednesday February 05, 2020 @06:57AM (#22245988)
I admit I haven't checked what Google's messaging offerings are this month.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by oneplane on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:26PM (#22175326)
iMessage with macOS works fine on non-Apple hardware. Perhaps you intended to write iOS and the iOS version of iMessage only runs on Apple hardware? Or was it more a point of legality? Or end-user acceptance? Or availability to the general public?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by StavrosK on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:31PM (#22175360)
Is there an iMessage app my mom can install on her Android phone? It feels like you're intentionally acting obtuse at this point.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by oneplane on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @08:49PM (#22176375)
No, I'm just stating facts. iMessage runs on multiple Apple operating systems, and while you can't run the iOS family reliably on anything but Apple hardware, you can run macOS on non-Apple hardware.

I'm intentionally trying to point out that the generalised statement was wrong without context, while at the same time providing wording that would probably match the intended message instead of the one that ended up getting posted.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by StavrosK on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @08:58PM (#22176433)
No, the statement was plenty right, I just wasn't expecting someone to read it in bad faith and then waste a bunch of time by nitpicking. If you're a mobile app manufacturer who owns a large platform, and your app doesn't run on the other large platform, you're a walled garden.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by tekknik on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:49AM (#22178633)
no it’s wrong and given your precious posts you’re obviously an apple hater. i hope you realize you’re not special and anytime an apple story comes out, your type crawls outta the woodwork to express their jealousy or whatever is the driving force behind your valueless comments. please go back to your android / windows / linux / haiku / whatever world and leave the rest of us in peace
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by e_y_ on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:43PM (#22176737)
Sure, you can climb in and out of a walled garden with a grappling hook, but that's not really the point.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by nemothekid on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:44PM (#22174934)
>iMessage makes me fairly angry because they're using & dividing people's social connections for profit.

Can you point me to a company that doesn't do this? I would think "but $hardware to use $network" is preferable to "use $network for free, but sell everything you put on the $network"

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by ehsankia on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:53PM (#22175999)
Cohesion does not force you to lock your software to a single device. Why can Google Duo be available on iOS and Android, while FaceTime is locked to iOS? You know full well it's to force you and your family to stay inside the garden and stop you from leaving. Has nothing to do with cohesion.

> I'm a close-to-20-years Apple user. The walled garden has never been a problem.

Obviously it's not a problem to people inside the garden, that's the whole point. It's meant to be a problem to people who are outside, to get them to come in.

As someone who has never had any Apple product, every time I come anywhere near anything by Apple, it's nothing but issues. As mentioned above, any time I'm linked an iTunes album page, I can't do shit with it. I'm not going to install iTunes just to listen and purchase the album. Is it cohesion to force me to download and install a program to purchase an album?

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by skinnymuch on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:39AM (#22180301)
I haven’t been able to get any one to use Google Duo. Isn’t it still only 1 on 1? Yes, it’s cross-platform, but if the cross-platform apps aren’t that good (Hangouts feels bulky, some other apps have more hoops to go through), that’s also saying something.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by grawprog on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:32PM (#22174837)
>The walled garden has never been a problem, more of a strength (integration, cohesion, etc).

>My music is in Spotify and Apple Music, my video is Netflix and Amazon Prime and Apple+, my email is Gmail, my eBooks in Kindle for Mac and iOS, I talk with friends with Skype, Facetime, Messenger and Whatsup. Even my iCloud apps (Calendar, email, etc) are available from any browser.

How do you actually benefit from the 'cohesion' in this situation, more say than my KDE/android setup which provides fairly seamless integration between my phone and computer?

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by ryanbrunner on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:25PM (#22175783)
One really egregious and incredibly frustrating example of a walled garden by Apple is the fact that I can't accept an invitation to view a shared iPhoto library unless I accept that invitation from Apple Mail. I'm using a Mac, I have iPhoto installed, there's no reason other than consumer-hostile behaviour to not allow me to accept that invite from Gmail in a browser. Hell, make me copy the link and paste it in iPhoto if I need to. Forcing me to use a particular e-mail client is just ridiculous.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by ljm on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:46PM (#22173327)
And what company does care about the open web, no strings attached? Google and Facebook sure as hell don’t.

I’m not going to apologise for Apple, but I thought this sign in feature was iOS specific. They’re offering to proxy your email on their own account and buying an iPhone pays for that. It’s a privacy feature so that you can protect your personal email, it’s not federated auth.

A better example is that I think the Apple Music API is pretty robust now. That’s been some time in the making.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by enos_feedler on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:57PM (#22173448)
110% - Google wouldn’t let me use Safari for youtube TV or for Stadia. The open web is a total mirage.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by Nullabillity on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:17PM (#22174118)
Goes both ways. It shouldn't be too surprising that people don't bother testing against the only browser that isn't just a download away.

For all of IE's/Edge's faults (and there are tons), at least they offer public VM images.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by thewebcount on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:42PM (#22175914)
> It shouldn't be too surprising that people don't bother testing against the only browser that isn't just a download away.

What does that mean? If you want to test Safari you only need a Mac or an iPhone, which Google has plenty of since they make native software for those platforms. If they want to test Chrome on a Mac, they can also test stuff with Safari on that same Mac.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by culturestate on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:51PM (#22175991)
> people don't bother testing against the only browser that isn't just a download away

Considering that a) Stadia officially supports macOS and b) most Google engineers use Macs, I don't think that's really a valid argument here. They just want people to use Chrome, full stop.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by skinnymuch on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:41AM (#22180317)
That does not apply to Google though.

Didn’t the Homebrew creator give some huge stat number for amt of Google employees who use Homebrew (so Mac) during the drama of him not being hired?

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by ehsankia on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:57PM (#22176026)
Most Google apps are available on both iOS and Android unlike Apple products. Compare Duo to FaceTime, Hangouts to iMessage, etc.

Stadia is still very early tech, it doesn't even support 90% of Android phones, let alone other devices and browsers. YTTV works on iOS, but yes the lack of Safari support is a bit shitty. Still, most of the limitation are technical, not forced.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by jonas21 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:00PM (#22173966)
If this feature were iOS only, how would you ever switch to a non-Apple device? Would you just have to leave all of your accounts behind?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by ljm on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:50PM (#22174436)
I think this is meant for apps that ask for emails without really requiring them for the app to run. If you want to sync across devices, this is the wrong solution, because your random email isn’t random any more.

It’s not oAuth or SSO.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by oneplane on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @08:52PM (#22176396)
It's account federation, so no. You are still going to be able to log in with a local account or another federated authentication system.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by dcolkitt on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:30PM (#22173177)
Isn't this kind of in the DNA of the company? Even going back to its first decade, what distinguished Apple from other early PC companies was that its O/S was only meant to run on its hardware, and its hardware was only meant to run its O/S.

This obviously didn't work out for it in the late 80's and 90's. But its fortunes changed by the mobile device era. One challenge of this model is that you have to maintain execution excellence in not one, but two separate areas. Both your hardware and design execution, as well as your software engineering, have to be industry leading. If either one falls short, it brings down the other.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by oneplane on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:10PM (#22176490)
Ironically it didn't work out both ways: for a short time you could run Mac OS on non-Apple hardware, licensed and stuff, but all it did was hurt hardware sales while not making enough money to cover software engineering for the OS. Then again, a ton of stuff went bad for Apple at that time.

NeXT on the other hand was always intended to run on diverse architectures, not sure on the timeline vs. Windows NT, which had the same model (with the HAL, multiple kernels etc.). It's pretty sad to see that go away, but it also makes total sense; modularity and USP-as-a-service doesn't pay off and doesn't make users (the mass of them) happy. Loosely coupled but highly cohesive systems work best, it's why classic Mac OS completely failed in at the end of its life, and why all the other projects at Apple were a dead end compared to the *nix projects (and of course buying NeXT). It's also why NT worked, and why at some levels Android fails miserably. (but Google notices and started to fix the cohesion issue at the OS level with Android One and their patching methods vs. complete monolithic OS upgrades which then needs vendors to back port)

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by pfranz on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:54PM (#22172778)
For this and many examples I think it's more ignoring those use-cases than maliciously blocking them.

> For the longest time you couldn't even preview songs on iTunes store without having iTunes.

I'm confused what the use case for this is?

> Want to watch their biggest WWDC live? Had to use Safari until last year.

Keynote streaming has had a long, weird history over the past decades. Even when Quicktime was dominant, they would only occasionally stream it live. My understanding over the past decade or so has been they've used "standards" to stream, but just the standards Safari had implemented. I just don't think they cared that much about getting it to any home users live.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by favorited on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:04PM (#22172893)
> My understanding over the past decade or so has been they've used "standards" to stream, but just the standards Safari had implemented.

It's just HLS, which Chrome didn't support

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by Uehreka on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:09PM (#22172949)
I’ve long wondered why Chrome doesn’t support HLS (HTTP Live Streaming for those who don’t know) given that it’s been standardized for a while.

I get that we’ve got stuff like MPEG DASH and Web RTC now and so the use case for HLS is mostly fulfilled, but having a couple different options for streaming live video with low latency to massive audiences is nice and allows folks like me who have worked in this space to offer multiple options when designing a streaming systems.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by saurik on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:50PM (#22173366)
Well, Chrome also "doesn't support" MPEG DASH: all of Chrome, Firefox, and IE11+ instead chose to support the Media Source Extensions API, which allows you to, with very little JavaScript glue, support any of these other standards you want, as well as new standards or custom streaming solutions. Apple, always the ecosystem's asshole, hardcoded HLS support into their browser and provided no way to implement any alternative as they refused to implement Media Source Extensions.

So no, Chrome should really not support HLS nor should it support MPEG DASH: Safari should just support Media Source Extensions. Apple finally did support Media Source extensions at some points on desktop Safari, which makes some sense as they effectively lost the war for the browser on macOS: no one was going to go to the ludicrous cost to support HLS (which would require you storing not just extra copies of all of your assets but also storing many copies of your audio as I am pretty sure HLS doesn't support separated streams) for Safari users given the existence and already-dominance of Chrome.

(FWIW, the cost of the duplicate storage was such a "bottom line" reason for websites to not support HLS that Apple finally decided to break a bit and support the MPEG DASH fragment files in Safari 10. It still is an extra implementation burden to support this hard coded spec and hobbles the entire industry to "whatever capabilities are sort of supported by HLS" instead of "whatever can be imagined on top of Media Source Extensions", but it no longer isn't "a major cost of our business operations is going to more than double".)

But, they still have not implemented it on iOS, because there they have control over the browser (disallowing any alternative) and are also a force in the mobile market you can't ignore (which is why this should be illegal). This means that you are forced as a content provider to support HLS so you can target iOS users (and before Apple lost, macOS Sadari), and that's the only reason anyone cares at all about HLS. HLS offers absolutely no advantages to MPEG DASH to anyone but Apple, and so would be dead if it weren't for Apple's active resistance to Media Source Extensions.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by oneplane on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:04PM (#22176459)
Keep in mind that while everyone always thinks that Apple does things to be an asshole or 'special' or whatever, it's far more likely that it was just coincidence or bad timing. Apply hanlon's razor and the wold is a whole lot less shitty.

Regarding HLS vs. the rest: HLS was developed around 2008 and published somewhere in 2009 IIRC, while MSE was at least 5 years later. At the same time; MSE has been supported since Safari 8 (macOS) Around 2015, according to WikiPedia, which is the same year FireFox gained support for it. Not sure about iOS.

Practically: Apple supports MSE and some DRM natively on the desktop just fine, and YouTube, Netflix etc. are using it at least since 2015 or thereabout. Also, most embedded video players in HTML5 just load a simple player framework that switches to the best available option. That might be MSE or HLS, but in the past it would also switch to Flash, RTSP and that windows media stuff.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by cpeterso on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:06PM (#22174616)
btw, Chrome on Android supports HLS (for compatibility with lots of mobile HLS video content targeting iOS users). Pre-Chromium Edge supports HLS on Windows desktop.

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/archive/blogs/ie/simplified...

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by realityking on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:32PM (#22175839)
Interestingly, Media Source Extension support was added in iPadOS 13 but not iOS.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by izacus on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:15PM (#22173024)
HLS can be rather readily supported with a JavaScript library that works just fine on Chrome.

Imagine if Google would just "forget" to keep supporting H.264 on YouTube and only served VP9 unsupported in Safari and iOS.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by pfranz on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:22PM (#22174192)
I didn't want to get into it, but I was going to make the YouTube/Google comparison to keynote streaming an Apple. When YouTube moved off of Flash and added hardware acceleration, Chrome got first and best support with codecs and features compared to any other browser.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by 1-more on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:58PM (#22174534)
I did recently get a ticket where hls.js failed to render something that safari can play just fine, but it's the first time that's ever happened and the scale we're talking about it is massive. I kind of want to file a bug with hls.js
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by favorited on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:57PM (#22173445)
Oh there are Chrome extensions which inject JS HLS libraries, adding support to Chrome.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by ehsankia on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @08:01PM (#22176049)
> I'm confused what the use case for this is?

I want to buy an album by an obscure artist that decided to only put their songs on iTunes. There is literally no way for me to by said album without downloading and installing a giant program.

They've seen fixed their web store and also split iTunes into pieces, but that was an issue for many years.

> Keynote streaming has had a long, weird history over the past decades

Sure but I'm not talking about decades ago, but even 2 years ago. In 2017.

> I just don't think they cared that much about getting it to any home users live.

Right, that's my point, they don't care about anyone outside their ecosystem.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by oneplane on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @08:56PM (#22176421)
Why would they care? What do they have to gain? While they are not the typical shareholder-directed company you'd normally see they are definitely still in it for the money. And since the market has shifted to services, ecosystem and larger user bases, there is no money or benefit to be gained from an investment to include people that are not your target audience.

That has shifted slightly since as a services company you can now make money without selling devices, and as other standards have become available (HLS was an Apple-only thing in the past, the rest had to use either Adobe or MS streaming stuff, unless you were into QTSS from 1995).

While there are plenty of things to like and dislike about Apple and what it produces, in the end, they are not going to care about people that will neither deliver money nor increased brand status.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by ehsankia on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:50PM (#22176776)
Why does Google make Duo and Hangouts work on iOS and Android?

I'm sorry but outright making it hard for a non-significant subsection of people to buy music on your music store is just plain stupid. The only way to justify it is that losing such customers is worth it if it helps them keep their walled garden tight.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by oneplane on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:13PM (#22196371)
Because Google makes money by harvesting data and providing paid services to as many users as possible, while Apple makes money by selling a UX. It's much harder to sell UX to every possible market segment than to have varying degrees of UX and still make money off of just that. That's why the business models between them differ (just like Microsoft differs from both of them yet again - even if there are a lot of comparable practises).
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by WA on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:35PM (#22174853)
> This is how they keep people in.

But sometimes, it also keeps iOS users out of stuff. For example, in Germany, Android has a market share of 70%. Hence, iMessage is useless here, because the majority can’t be reached. Thus, WhatsApp has the biggest market share for messaging services.

Now, it probably doesn’t matter for Apple, but it prevents the iMessage experience for most iPhone users in Germany, because it’s kinda useless here. I guess the same is true for most European countries.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by FabHK on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:40PM (#22174887)
> And once you're in, they make it as hard as possible to leave.

Nonsense. On my Mac, I can export all my pictures from Photos as jpeg (or several other formats); contacts as .vcf; calendars as .ics; documents in several portable formats; my music is in iTunes as (unencumbered) mp3 or m4a, nicely organised by Artists and Albums; emails are in traditional .mbox files, unless I'm mistaken, but at any rate mailboxes can be exported; even Messages are available in some directory in the Library folder, though in an ugly XML-y format; etc.

I don't know how easy other OSes make it to "leave", but you can't really argue that Apple is trying to make it hard (except by making the garden more beautiful, safe, and well organised than the others).

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by pier25 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:49PM (#22172715)
I use a mix of Apple and non-Apple devices. It's a shame that I can't, for example, use Safari on Windows or Android.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by wolco on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:12PM (#22172990)
Firefox might be the answer or cross platform applications. Always good to get out of the ecosystem when you can.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by pier25 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:41PM (#22175910)
I've been using Firefox for the last couple of months but I'm not satisfied with it. I'm using Brave now but it only syncs bookmarks... I'm using a password manager but it doesn't sync extensions, autofills, settings, etc.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by jonathankoren on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:17PM (#22177392)
What are your problems with Firefox?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by pier25 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @12:28AM (#22177747)
Major issues:

1. Lack of multilingual spell checking (without having to manually switch languages). For non English natives this is a must since we write in at least 2 languages every day. There is an extension that tries to solve this but it is quite slow to the point that I've had to disable it.

2. It just feels slower than Chromium browsers and Safari, at least on macOS. In Windows it's blazing fast but I have a Ryzen 3700X there.

3. On my MBP I get random CPU spikes from time to time and I'm forced to close and reopen FF. I haven't seen this in my iMac or Windows machine. I've never experienced this with any other browser.

4. On Android FF seems to be a battery hog. I haven't done any serious measuring but since I switched to FF my battery has gone from 3-4 days between charges to 2-3 days.

Minor issues:

1. I think the UI is inferior to all other browsers

2. I've had sync issues. I try to login to a website and for some reason FF will not write the credentials unless I manually sync. This has happened in iOS and Android.

3. I've had several minor issues on iOS. For example yesterday there was a weird bug in Twitter with the keyboard suggestions. I know it uses WKWebView under the hood but Chrome for iOS does not have those issues.

4. For some reason Mozilla decided to remove an extension that I use very frequently called UI Stack.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by jonathankoren on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:27AM (#22232960)
I don't think major 2 is objectively true. Firefox is faster than Chrome in every benchmark test I've seen for two years now.

As for minor 4, the blame is with developer. The API that was eliminated was EOLed long before they removed it, and it looks like he's doing some security violation https://github.com/gigobyte/ui-stack/issues/6

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by freehunter on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:02PM (#22172874)
There used to be a Safari for Windows. No one used it so Apple dropped support.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by K0SM0S on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:49PM (#22173364)
More specifically, Apple never made it good enough compared to alternatives, so no one used it. It eventually died at the hands of its maker.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by wlesieutre on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:40PM (#22174341)
IMO what killed it was the text rendering. They brought their font smoothing over from Mac OS and that's not what Windows users are acclimated to.

It might be more "correct" in some ways, especially from a graphic design / typography standpoint, but it looks fuzzy when you put it next to ClearType on the same screen.

https://damieng.com/blog/2007/06/13/font-rendering-philosoph...

https://blog.codinghorror.com/whats-wrong-with-apples-font-r...

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by mavhc on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:29PM (#22174246)
Well, there was Mac GUI toolkit for Windows, which Safari and iTunes used, wasn't really Safari for Windows
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by sul4bh on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:20PM (#22173071)
I would rather have a delightful user experience than multi platform support. Worst service to ever come out of Apple is Apple Music because it is multi platform. Their desktop app is just a shell around their BETA web version. Sluggish UI, memory usage goes up to 4GB easily...They didn't even try...all in the name of making it easier to support multiple platforms.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by mehhh on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @11:59PM (#22177593)
Sounds like they did not make a modicum of effort to support any platform.

iTunes was multiplatform (Windows & OS X), if Apple wanted they could invest the resources to do so for Apple Music. Apparently it is not a priority tho

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by reaperducer on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:38PM (#22172593)
wanted the app to have the same options across platforms

I guess this is the part I don't understand. How did you plan to test across platforms if you don't have an iOS device with which to test?

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by espadrine on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:05PM (#22172902)
I don’t know the author, but in a typical company, a project that is meant to work on iOS and Android will be dispatched to separate teams.

In this case, the author might be part of the Android team, instructed to make Sign in with Apple work on Android, and they may not even be in the same physical location as the iOS team.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by alistairSH on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:41PM (#22173278)
But, if he's at a company with the resources for 2+ mobile dev teams, surely he could convince his manager to purchase an iOS device? We have several drawers full of mobile devices for testing our web apps. Our mobile dev teams have their own piles of devices. It's a cost of doing business.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by SlowRobotAhead on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:22PM (#22176566)
>In a typical company, a project that is meant to work on iOS and Android will be dispatched to separate teams

Truth. And why cross platform tools like React and Flutter are just getting more popular.

I’m right in the middle of making that choice right now. But it’s definitely clear I can’t support true native apps.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by codemac on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:45PM (#22172675)
They might mean their website rather than iOS.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by jakobegger on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:41PM (#22173281)
> To test I needed an Apple ID with 2FA.

Apple make it such a pain in the ass to get Apple IDs. For example, they block emails from small domains. So I can't use my company email address to get an apple ID.... and I found that out by googling cryptic error messages, they don't even tell you.

They don't want you to have multiple Apple IDs, so you need to store the credentials of your main Apple ID on your build server if you want to notarize apps (which is required for distribution). Also, the notarisation service doesn't support 2FA, so you need to get an app-specific-password that bypasses 2FA.

It's ridiculous. Their security system is so complex and full of holes...

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by no_wizard on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:05PM (#22176474)
You should be using this:

https://support.apple.com/guide/apple-business-manager/what-...

https://support.apple.com/guide/apple-business-manager/creat...

Not the consumer Apple IDs. This lets you programically generate the Apple IDs (you can even set permissions on them).

Works great.

Not that they've made it straightforward to make it explicit who should use what, or anything, but they do have solutions for this. It also has other perks (like being able manage distribution of your app)

To be fair to anyone, the Developer Documentation does not talk one bit about this, at all, as a solution.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by jakobegger on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:19AM (#22179693)
I guess this also requires an organisation/business account? Because I can't get that either, because Apple doesn't allow sole proprietors like myself to get a business account. I can only get an individual account. Which means that I can't add my employees to my team.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by no_wizard on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:28AM (#22202915)
Only a DUNS number, IIRC, which any registered business can get for free
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by bloody-crow on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:45PM (#22173848)
This is news to me. My apple ID is on my personal domain (Google Apps) with only one email address on it, and it works fine. Could it be a recent change?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by benhurmarcel on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:15PM (#22174106)
About 6 months ago I was unable to use my email on a personal domain to create an Apple ID. I had to create an @icloud.com address. And I don't think it's an issue with my domain, it's been fine for the last 9 years.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by Marsymars on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:49PM (#22176772)
FYI you can normally change the email on an Apple ID after creation, without the domain restrictions that are present for initial creation.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by benhurmarcel on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:01PM (#22185137)
Great to know, thank you
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by Marsymars on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:47PM (#22176761)
In my experience it's randomly prohibited by some algorithm.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by pcl on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:33PM (#22173751)
> SMS 2FA was not good enough, you need the hardware-based 2FA

OT, but Apple is doing the right thing here: SMS is not a robust 2FA solution. A recent discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22016212

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by Andrew_nenakhov on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:13PM (#22174077)
Their approach is still ridiculous. I once tried to log into a brand new iOS device in a shop, and has unpleasantly learned that I absolutely can't log in using my regular Apple ID, cause, you know, they are showing a popup with code on my Mac which is 50km away.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by Klonoar on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:20PM (#22176558)
That's... how 2FA sans texting works in the Apple ecosystem, yes. It's working as designed.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by Andrew_nenakhov on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:05AM (#22178422)
That's exactly what I am complaining about: it is designed badly, I didn't ask for this and I can't turn it off.. I didn't ask for this, and still can't turn it off.

On the other hand, Google does even worse: sometimes it requires 2FA with SMS when I have specifically turned it off, knowing I'll be abroad without SMS connectivity. Still, Google doesn't give a shit on disabled settings and still demands 2FA auth on connects from previously unused addresses. The only reliable way to circumvent this is to use a VPN with a fixed address, so Google always thinks it's a 'same' location.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by rhacker on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:08PM (#22172939)
PSA: If you're going to implement Sign in with Apple, PLEASE implement Sign in with Google (and vice versa).

This is the EXACT issue we had when Apple Pay/Android Pay came out. The solution was for POS vendors to just implement both, always.

SO, that's the solution here.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by rootusrootus on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:16PM (#22173598)
But Apple Pay and Android Pay both use identical underlying technology, don't they? I.e. it's not possible to support one without the other, because they are the same.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by pwinnski on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:35PM (#22173767)
By default, supporting one means supporting the other, but in practice, several large chain stores deliberately disabled ApplePay specifically at first, hoping to choke it off. That seems to have failed, and I can't remember the last time I saw a place that took contactless payment but not ApplePay, but it was a thing for a while.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by bcyn on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:40PM (#22174344)
Do you know of a source where I can read more about this (particularly about the stores disabling Apple Pay)? I'm interested in learning more. I was under the impression that any terminal that accepted contactless payments would also work with ApplePay.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by comex on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:33PM (#22174847)
https://www.macrumors.com/2014/10/25/cvs-disabling-nfc-apple... mentions Rite Aid and CVS disabling all contactless payments, after previously supporting them, shortly after Apple Pay launched.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by rootusrootus on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:31PM (#22175366)
Yeah, it's all or nothing, they disabled all NFC-based contactless payment just to stop Apple Pay from working.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by gamblor956 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:55PM (#22174491)
in practice, several large chain stores deliberately disabled ApplePay specifically at first, hoping to choke it off.

This is FUD spread by Apple after poor uptake of Apple Pay. The reality is that many retail chains and restaurants either hadn't enabled the NFC chips in their payment terminals, or were using old terminals that didn't even have NFC functionality, and thus did not work with Apple Pay. Retailers that supported NFC payment prior to the launch of Apple Pay supported Apple Pay at launch.

Retailers are not about spending millions of dollars to upgrade working point-of-sale machines just to make Apple more money.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by comex on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:32PM (#22174833)
According to news reports from the time, both Rite Aid and CVS initially supported NFC payments (at least at some locations), then proceeded to disable them shortly after Apple Pay launched:

https://www.macrumors.com/2014/10/25/cvs-disabling-nfc-apple...

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by gamblor956 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @07:28PM (#22175804)
Rite Aid and CVS disabled NFC payments because their POS terminals weren't configured to handle NFC payments and they didn't want to spend the resources on a store-by-store basis trying to work out the kinks.

Notably, CVS did not restore NFC payments until 2018, 2 years after CurrentC had failed, because that is when they had NFC-ready POS terminals in all stores. (RiteAid started accepting NFC in 2015, since more of their stores had NFC-ready POS terminals.)

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by comex on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @08:52PM (#22176399)
> Rite Aid and CVS disabled NFC payments because their POS terminals weren't configured to handle NFC payments and they didn't want to spend the resources on a store-by-store basis trying to work out the kinks.

Do you have evidence for this claim? (Do you have inside knowledge?) It seems to have worked well enough for reviewers before it was cut off after Apple Pay's official launch. [1]

According to a New York Times article [2]:

> The problem is that under the terms of their MCX contractual agreement, they are not supposed to accept competing mobile payments products like Apple Pay, according to multiple retailers involved with MCX, who spoke on the condition of anonymity. If these retailers break their contracts, they will face steep fines for doing so, these people said.

In [1], MCX's CEO was asked to address that article's claim, and responded that the exclusivity requirement did exist (albeit lasting "months, not years"), yet MCX had not "ordered CVS to turn off Apple Pay". But he "speculated that CVS might have simply done so because it had signed the exclusivity policy". It's hard to make sense of these seemingly contradictory statements. If the exclusivity policy included Apple Pay and other NFC mobile wallets (which you'd expect it to, since there weren't any other major competitors), what's the distinction between a contractual requirement and an "order"? Was it just that CVS had the option to continue accepting Apple Pay, but at the cost of paying fines? If the exclusivity policy didn't include Apple Pay, then why would he "speculate" that it was the reason CVS had disabled NFC?

Regardless, it was indeed "months" after that interview when MCX members started enabling Apple Pay: first Best Buy in April, then Rite Aid in August. Notably, when Best Buy did so, Ars Technica received this statement from MCX: [3]

> While all MCX merchants do agree to exclusivity, those provisions are designed to expire and as such as are limited in both time and scope.

This strongly implies that the "exclusivity" was indeed a requirement to not support Apple Pay, and that it had expired.

As for CVS, they responded to the death of CurrentC by starting their own mobile payment platform, CVS Pay, in 2016. So they still had a competitor to promote, which explains why they waited until 2018 to enable NFC payments.

Target and Walmart, two other former MCX members, each did the same, and both of them still don't support NFC payments today, even though at this point they've had many years to replace their POS terminals. Walmart, for example, stated in 2018 that "Walmart Pay is the exclusive form of mobile payment accepted at Walmart and we have no plans for that to change" [5], strongly implying that the reason they don't support NFC is to preserve that "exclusivity", not due to technical limitations.

[1] https://www.vox.com/2014/11/4/11632560/what-are-the-anti-app...

[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/29/technology/apple-pay-runs...

[3] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/04/best-buy-will-accept...

[4] https://techcrunch.com/2016/08/11/cvs-pharmacy-launches-its-...

[5] https://www.macrumors.com/2018/08/21/walmart-no-plans-to-acc...

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by raisedbyninjas on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:48PM (#22174976)
CVS, Walmart & many others created CurrentC to avoid the CC merchant fees through a NFC & ACH scheme instead. CurrentC failed by 2016, which is probably when CVS started accepting Google Pay and Apple Pay again.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by rootusrootus on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:30PM (#22175353)
IIRC, CurrentC was not NFC, it was based on an app with a QR code.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by pwinnski on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @03:55PM (#22185705)
Best Buy supported NFC payments generally until Apple Pay launched in 2014. After that I saw the NFC logo on their terminals still, but every time I tried to use Apple Pay, it would report an error. Cashiers told me each time that "Google Pay" would work, but not Apple Pay.

Perhaps they were lying, or mistaken.

But you were specifically calling out my claim of chain stores deliberately eschewing Apple Pay as FUD, which is weird, because they were quite open about it at the time. Walmart has kept up their QR-code-only approach, while the others gave up on CurrenC eventually.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by hadtodoit on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:03PM (#22173490)
You seem confused. Apple Pay works using the exact same tech as contactless payment cards, a widely supported standard.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by parliament32 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:36PM (#22174317)
Doesn't matter, you can configure the terminal to block certain issuers, like when you try to tap your Amex and get the "no supported applications" message. ApplePay is considered an issuer like the others.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by gamblor956 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:02PM (#22174575)
This is false...

The store chooses which credit cards to accept (at the birds-eye level, i.e., Amex, Discover, Mastercard, Visa), and the POS sends the transaction to the appropriate card processor based on the identifying digits in the card number (the first 4).

Apple Pay transactions are identified as Visa transactions, so Visa would handle the transaction...if the POS terminal is configured to accept NFC cards. Most older ones don't even have NFC functionality, and until 2 years ago even terminals with NFC functionality didn't have it enabled because they were shipped before NFC payments was a thing. Today, almost all POS terminals come with NFC payment built-in and enabled.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by Marsymars on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @09:53PM (#22176795)
> Doesn't matter, you can configure the terminal to block certain issuers, like when you try to tap your Amex and get the "no supported applications" message.

What's the deal with that? I've pretty much given up even trying to tap with my Amex because of how frequently it gives that message.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by sehugg on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:41PM (#22172628)
Doing it through Firebase might be easier: https://firebase.google.com/docs/auth/ios/apple
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by pier25 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:46PM (#22172684)
Maybe I'm missing something but isn't that iOS only?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by plexicle on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:49PM (#22172721)
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by pier25 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:51PM (#22172742)
Ah thanks!
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by dfrey on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:48PM (#22172711)
> Seems like a nice sign-in option for iPhone owners but it's a portability disaster.

So basically it's like everything that Apple makes

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by eugeniub on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:53PM (#22172771)
Not to be that guy but you can get a used iPhone SE for $75, and it should last you a couple years for testing purposes.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by dylan604 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:21PM (#22173644)
Really, you need an iPhone model with each of the iOS versions you want to support on that hardware. If you want to go back to iOS11 up to current, then you need that many devices. Otherwise, because it works on that hardware and iOS combo doesn't mean it will work on a different combo. So it's $75 multiplied by the number of variations you want to support. It adds up quickly. As others have stated, it's just part of the cost of doing business.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by munk-a on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:39PM (#22174878)
And you can't forget - you need to get at least one with the silly notch in it.

Oh, and don't even consider emulators - the iOS device emulators are trash.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by habosa on Thursday January 30, 2020 @11:40AM (#22192719)
Edit: a lot of people are asking how I am working on a cross-platform app but I can't afford an iPhone / Mac to test on.

To be clear I did resolve this situation with the Apple ID by asking an iOS-focused teammate of mine to test the app for me, that's somewhat besides the point though.

I was trying to add a feature, Sign in with Apple, to my Android app. This is supposed to be possible. It turns out it is, but it was significantly harder than adding any other form of authentication to my app than I've ever tried.

If they want it to be developer friendly they could:

  * Allow the creating of "testing" Apple IDs without the 2FA requirement

  * Have docs that actually mention best practices on non-iOS platforms

  * Maybe even provide a basic SDK
I wasn't calling Apple evil or saying I couldn't afford a Mac, I was just calling out a bad developer experience.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by dep_b on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @01:53PM (#22172763)
> As an Android developer I have no reason to own either of those.

Of course you do: Please implement this iOS application/feature in Android.

Not being able to run an application from Xcode onto an iOS device severely hampers your career. I have to deal with so many Android developers and their output I absolutely cannot afford the luxury to not run Android apps from Android Studio.

I don't think Sign In With Apple will be a huge hit on Android anyway. But perhaps you could share your code on Github for people that run into the same requirements?

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by burkaman on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:17PM (#22173042)
Anyone with a computer can get Android Studio for free in 5 minutes. You can't download a free iPhone.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by dep_b on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:51PM (#22173377)
The Simulator comes free with Xcode. And it's actually pretty usable in terms of performance compared to the Emulator you get with Android Studio.

Either you get a $75 iPhone SE or you have something for free with your MacBook. Anyone with a computer still wants to use a hardware Android device for any serious testing. And then there's the differences between all of the builds between the brands. I bet you want to test on a Xiaomi before you want to declare that push notifications work.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by burkaman on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:58PM (#22173452)
> your MacBook

Yes, this is the expensive part. Obviously if you are developing for iOS or porting an iOS app then you need the hardware. But it seems like an unusually high barrier for implementing a "sign in with" button.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by folli on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:00PM (#22173971)
I hate that I can't use Xcode on Linux.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by dep_b on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @10:16AM (#22181388)
The real problem is that it's origins are making NextStep applications which you would typically do from a NextStep workstation. Still every Xcode update is coupled to the OS version because of that. I guess we need to be grateful that we don't need to install macOS betas to target the beta version of iOS.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by Dayshine on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:02PM (#22172879)
I have no idea what you're trying to say. Is the comment on career an insult or genuine?
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by dep_b on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:22AM (#22179710)
If the only thing you want to do is pull really detailed tickets from a JIRA queue and work on that until they go to the QA, that's fine. But you're stuck on medior level.

As soon as you're going to be involved in designing or building back-end API's and features that cross a lot of layers not being able to run applications from Xcode and Android Studio and understanding the other platform no matter if you're an iOS developer or Android developer limits your career.

I need at least to see what my Android developer did for me before I can accept his or her work. That's what happens when you go up the ladder. That's why I have the full toolchain on my computer and obviously bought an Android phone.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by criley2 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:09PM (#22172947)
This isn't really a fair comparison because any OSX user can just download and run Android studio for free, while your average Android programmer would require over a thousand dollars (to get a bottom-level Apple device with the worst specifications, or closer to two thousand+ to get competitive hardware) and then a yearly subscription to XCode at $100/year, and that's without having any actual iPhones to test on as well.

So it makes sense that for you, spending $0 to test on Android makes sense, but on the flip side, Apple has intentionally engineered their developer program to have a four figure entrance fee, and frankly most indie developers can't shell out potentially several thousand dollars on OSX/iOS devices and licenses just to do some testing, especially when as the developer above said, "they can ask a friend to test".

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by bobwaycott on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @06:13PM (#22175215)
> ... and frankly most indie developers can't shell out potentially several thousand dollars on OSX/iOS devices and licenses just to do some testing ...

Sounds like these so-called “indie devs” who cannot afford to build for iOS devices should not tackle projects/clients that require building for iOS. Or, if a client is in the mix, bill the client a large enough fee to cover the cost of testing on real devices. That’s not a problem Apple is responsible for solving.

I would never rely on developing, testing, and releasing an Android app on a simulator alone. I don’t want to buy a bunch of Android devices. So I don’t take on work that is meant for Android, or I hire people who can properly test on devices. Pretty simple—and it’s both my choice and a matter of professional responsibility and accountability to ship work I can stand behind.

Apple isn’t going to change any time soon. I’m so tired of the disingenuous moaning from “indie devs” who want to take on projects for and make money from iOS, but can’t be bothered to get over their own personal anti-Apple feelings to buy a device.

The ecosystem of Apple devices are hardware and software. The simulators and build tools are never enough. You wouldn’t ship an app for Apple Watch without testing it on a watch, would you? Or would you ship it relying only on having one friend with an Apple Watch test it? Sounds lazy and unprofessional—and if an indie dev can’t do the job right, they shouldn’t take on the job.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by clay_the_ripper on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:39PM (#22173262)
How much revenue will you generate from supporting Apple users or implementing Apple features? Bottom line is you run a business as a developer and if you can’t afford to spend, maybe a couple hundred bucks then you probably shouldn’t be in business anymore. Companies have no obligation to give you things for free.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by folli on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:05PM (#22174010)
As a hobbyist, thank you for your sympathy
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by criley2 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:17PM (#22173614)
On the flip side, 80% of all devices sold are Android and Android devices are the majority of sales, web usage, etc so there is no obligation for any developer to support the minority of devices and users at extreme cost when they can already achieve mass coverage.

That razor cuts both ways, and I'd point out that this situation is very similar to how OSX comes with Windows bootcamp, but a Windows 10 machine can't run OSX. If you run OSX, running Windows is something that you might just have to do. But if you're a Windows user, outside of walled garden development, there's not much point to OSX

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by avianlyric on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:46PM (#22173857)
Yet despite all that, we’re still having this conversation and a single iOS feature has hit the top of Hacker News.

While Android may make up the majority of devices worldwide, Apple devices are still very popular among wealthy clients (anyone living in the west would meet this criteria), which is ultimately the part of population business care about most.

Simply put, supporting Apple devices is very profitable. No company is going to leave money on the table due to niche ideological concerns.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by axoltl on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:57PM (#22173941)
That's slightly dishonest, as iOS has a ~50% market share in the US. Ignoring half of the US market seems a poor choice.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/266572/market-share-held... https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/united-sta...

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by dep_b on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:23PM (#22174194)
> On the flip side, 80% of all devices sold are Android and Android devices are the majority of sales, web usage, etc

That's nice if the only thing you do is selling eyeballs with adware. If you're actually looking to make money in sales you'd be a fool to not support iOS. I'd call it an obligation to your wallet.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by dep_b on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:18PM (#22174130)
Xcode can be downloaded for free, developer accounts are also free. What isn't free is shipping stuff to users in any form unless you're part of a development team.

My first MacBook (used for Xcode that is) costed 250 dollar coupled with a 200 dollar iPad 2 around 2013-2014. The iPad 2 was stolen and the MacBook 2008 kept working until around 2018 but was replaced in 2015.

But the grandparent simply needed to test a login feature that required iCloud. Any iPhone would do.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by eropple on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:23PM (#22173099)
You don’t need a subscription to test iOS code, FWIW.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by derefr on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:38PM (#22173252)
> while your average Android programmer would require over a thousand dollars (to get a bottom-level Apple device with the worst specifications)

A new one, sure. You could buy a 2012 MBP on Craigslist for $200, and a refurbished iPhone 6 for $50 or less.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by briandear on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:57PM (#22173442)
Professionals in all fields have to spend money on tools. That’s business.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by criley2 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:18PM (#22173625)
Interesting justification/rationalization for the extraordinary cost of supporting the minority of users. Paying the Apple Tax is a cost of doing business in the Apple garden, but for folks outside of that walled garden, the extraordinary costs of Apple hardware (often sold at 3 times or more their cost!) usually isn't going to make business sense.

If you're going to be a mobile developer, supporting the android 80% is far cheaper and easier than supporting the iOS 20%. It then shouldn't be a surprise if the 80% get better support than the 20%.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by clay_the_ripper on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:36PM (#22173226)
You’re an engineer who wants to implement Apple features, yet you don’t want to spend maybe, what, $200 for a test phone? These kinds of complaints are really irritating and disingenuous. My interpretation is that you’re more interested in complaining and finding problems than just buying a test phone and being done with it. It’s not that hard.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by looperhacks on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:41PM (#22173277)
Why should anybody need to buy an iPhone to develop an android app? Using an API that is supposedly supported on android and shouldn't need an apple device?

Btw $200 is not throwaway money for everybody.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by capableweb on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:45PM (#22173324)
> Why should anybody need to buy an iPhone to develop an android app?

You don't, you can perfectly develop an android app without owning an iphone

BUT, if you're using features from another ecosystem, let's say something like an authentication system that has requirements, you have to fulfill those requirements, otherwise skip the feature.

Same goes if you want to support hardware-level U2F, you're gonna have to buy a key then.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by ubercow13 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:55PM (#22173421)
It's different having to buy a device to test a product you are developing for that device. Apple is just gatekeeping access to their API to developers who buy one of their otherwise unrelated products.
Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by capableweb on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @03:50PM (#22173888)
> Apple is just gatekeeping access to their API to developers who buy one of their otherwise unrelated products

I don't know how that's news for anyone, Apple has been doing this forever and they explicitly chase that goal as far as I know.

If you're saying "yeah, I want to support iOS/Sign in with Apple/AirDrop/Screenshare/Any other Apple feature" then you're entering the need of having more things to do with Apple. That's the cost of joining and leaving the ecosystem they created for themselves.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by LanceH on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @04:33PM (#22174291)
Depends on how you look at it, really.

End users say, "I would like to be able to sign in with xxx." Developers say, "Your OS vendor doesn't want you to."

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by jakobegger on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:46PM (#22173337)
If I want to add "sign in with github" I need to read some docs, get an api key, implement the feature, done.

If I want to add "sign in with apple", I need to read some docs, then read a bunch of forum posts because the docs are incomplete, then go out and buy a used iphone somewhere, and you think that is completely normal??

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by ubercow13 on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:41PM (#22173270)
My interpretation of this situation is that as an Apple user, Apple has done me a disservice by putting artificial barriers up that make it harder for third-party developers to provide me, an Apple user, good service.

I don't see any reason to defend that, it seems to be only in Apple's best interest, not mine.

Anyway, it's not $200 for a test phone, it's $200 just for a 2fa device. Meanwhile Yubikeys are $20 and have better battery life.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by mobilemidget on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @02:40PM (#22173269)
Well to be fair he wanted the app to have the same options everywhere. So regardless if he had a test iPhone, he wanted apple sign in to work on android. And probably vice versa too, google login on iPhone.

Personally not a fan of either, separate email/passwords everywhere is what I prefer. But I cant say I have come across a non-apple service/site that offered apple login.

Re:How Popular Is “Sign in with Apple”? by munk-a on Tuesday January 28, 2020 @05:44PM (#22174933)
For the purposes of authentication the closest equivalent Android side is "Sign in with Google" which can be done with 0 dollars and is a pretty straightforward and well documented API call that has specific SDK support in a lot of languages and settings.