https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starlink_(satellite_constellat...
btw the amount of satellites is staggering and this is just a tiny batch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRz3988El7Q&t=116s (Warning: hilarious commenter)
Note, this section was added June 03 2019.
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Starlink_(satelli...
> From Table 1 it is clear that since 1985 the annual mean number of trails has risen from 2.5 to 2.9 in a 60 minute exposure, an increase of 16%; the number of spacecraft on orbit has increased by 39% in the same period. Since the trail rate data comes from a set of plates not selected for time of night of exposure, the trail rate is averaged over an entire night. Since trailing is most frequent in the two hours after sunset and before sunrise, it would be expected that the trail rate would not increase as rapidly as the spacecraft population. However, the trend is such that it supports the view that plate trailing is caused by spacecraft and large debris and not by debris more generally. The figures suggest that the satellite population is doubling approximately every 14 years at present launch rates. The concern of the astronomical community is that due to the advent of large satellite constellations such as IRIDIUM and, further in the future, a TELEDESIC network, there will be a sudden increase in the numbers of satellites capable of causing trailing. The time available to find a solution is thereby reduced.
It even foresees SpaceX's "solution" that they are trialing:
> The Space Agencies could also assist by reducing satellite albedos.
It's also discussed in similar terms in "Adverse Environmental Effects on Astronomy", D. McNally, 1992.
You can find early 2000's complaints about Iridium-spoiled optical observations.
You can find late 1960's papers analyzing the impact of satellites on optical astronomy... that point to exactly where we are now.
It's hardly a "surprise to the optical astronomy community." If there's any surprise, it's that people are actually willing to listen to their concerns.
"Now, that being said, even I was confused why this would cause a problem. The satellites are in low earth orbit, so low that they won't be able to reflect the sunlight, since they are in earth's shadow. Only during twilight and dawn will satellites be in the right position to reflect the sunlight back to the ground off of some panel.
Now, these are not prime observing hours for many people, since it is still not as dark as it could be. So most people point into the darkest parts of the sky (up) rather than at parts where there is still twilight (like nearer the horizon).
But for some types of observations, like near earth asteroids, you want to point into the evening sky to look for them, since that is one of the places you want to look, and the sky conditions should be good enough. In these pictures you'll get streaks of light as the satellites pass through."
It's just not a thing that seemed like it would actually happen. I can very much imagine that it didn't get a lot of attention until they actually started going up.
It would be awesome if Starlink would donate bandwidth for the Greenland and South Pole EHT telescopes. Right now there's no "first look" capability for them.
If I have the opportunity, I’ll mention your suggestion.
(Also, why do I get a feeling the two of us talked about using satellite constellations and interferometry on HN before?)
Thanks for remembering!
>. “We want to make sure we do the right thing to make sure little kids can look through their telescope,” she said. “Astronomy is one of the few things that gets little kids excited about space.”
Photon shot noise is sqrt(N) though, so even after the subtraction you're left with more noise along that line than elsewhere. So that's not ideal. But increased noise is less of a concern that "totally ruined data".
Another caveat is that the lines have to not be so bright as to saturate your CCD, otherwise you truly have lost data that subtraction won't help with.
Edit: it turns out astronomers take many shorter exposures [1] and simply reject the pixels that are too far away from the mean in any given exposure when combining them. This seems mostly better than what I was proposing, though it does mean increased readout noise since you read out multiple times and so for very sensitive measurements I would still expect astronomers might want to do true single long exposures.
[1] https://www.skyandtelescope.com/astronomy-blogs/imaging-foun...
OTOH you can just ask SpaceX or the Air Force where they have been in the past, SpaceX uses GPS and the Air Force radar is accurate enough for knowing where they were.
I also know a lot of people directly involved in SSA and all of them are very concerned with how much these new constellations are going to increase the risk of collisions, and they all think it’s completely irresponsible when the SpaceX cultists just dismiss the concerns with, “space is a big place,” or, “they’ll deorbit in 20 years or so.”
In fact they petitioned the FCC(?) to lower the constellation's altitude for the very reason that, in the case of a malfunction, the satellite's would orbit would degrade more quickly. A carefully tracked constellation of satellites would be much easier to avoid than the random chunks of shrapnel left behind by other mishaps.
EDIT: a few typos
If there is just one (non-stationary) satellite in your sky, the geometry is probably pretty crummy, so light-speed delay is greater. Also, link budget is worse, so probably data rate is lower too.
Yes, once you have a ton of satellites, adding more doesn't improve latency much.
One very important market they're going after is global arbitrageurs.
It’s almost like a Gibson or Stephenson novel.
My only evidence is a very basic evaluation of their publicly stated capabilities.
> I work in algorithmic trading/finance and I'm relatively certain that this isn't true.
It sounds like you have a much better informed opinion than I do.
With my limited knowledge, I see no reason why SpaceX wouldn't aggressively go after that market, but like I said, my knowledge is limited.
550km vs 1,150km might not matter, but it matters a ton vs 40,000km. Even without the bandwidth limits, I wouldn't be able to use geostationary internet for my normal usage.
If Musk was a charlatan, we wouldn't have this problem. Musk would have failed to put spacelink satellites in orbit and we wouldn't have this problem.
The reason why we have this problem is precisely because Musk isn't a charlatan.
> I also know a lot of people directly involved in SSA and all of them are very concerned with how much these new constellations are going to increase the risk of collisions
Just because they are concerned doesn't mean they are against SpaceX or Musk. Every venture is open to concern.
> SpaceX cultists
Is NASA and the US government SpaceX cultists? You act like Musk just sent this satellites up there without any warning or government approval. He didn't.
All you've done is toss ad hominems at Musk, SpaceX and those who support this venture.
And to clarify, the SSA folks I was referring to are against these types of constellations particularly in the context of the speed and lack of oversight (and no, FCC/ITU spectrum approval has nothing to do with oversight and regulation of the physical objects in orbit) of these ventures.
Why aren't you talking about any of the other constellations that are being built? They're all planning huge numbers of satellites, many of which are larger or in higher orbits than SpaceX's satellites. You can't single out Elon Musk's companies just because of a personal vendetta if you're actually trying to be fair and attack this from a technical perspective.
I'm not a fanboy by any means but the guy built two companies and launched a car from his factory into space from a rocket his other business built. He's personally spearheading the early stages of commercial space exploration. I don't know that I'd describe him as a charlatan.
Maybe 'charlatan' is unfair, but he's certainly more of a sales-and-hype man than a real engineering type. I don't understand why so many technical people are snowed by his razzle dazzle.
Regardless of how we characterize Musk, however, reducing the issue at hand to a pro/anti Musk ad hominem argument is a distraction and a waste of time. It is suddenly relatively cheap to put a huge number of small satellites in low earth orbit. This creates a conflict with astronomical interests. What remains is a policy debate worth having.
SpaceX's statement may be ignorant, erroneous, or even deceitful. I have no doubt that the astronomy community identified the problem immediately and has been trying to bring it to public attention. However, as with light pollution at both optical and radio frequencies, they are relatively powerless compared to the interests with which they are in conflict. If the FCC is the arbiter of how many satellites a company can launch into LEO, they have already lost. This was a regulatory and legislative battle that they needed to be fighting, and probably were fighting, and basically had very little chance of winning unless they were somehow able to mobilize public support for earth-based astronomy against the telecommunications industry.
Acting like he hitched his flag to an already successful company is disingenuous.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PayPal#Early_history
> In October of that year, Musk made the decision that X.com would terminate its other Internet banking operations and focus on the PayPal money service.[25] In the same month, Elon Musk was replaced by Peter Thiel as CEO of X.com. The X.com company was then renamed PayPal in 2001,[26] and expanded rapidly throughout the year until company executives decided to take PayPal public in 2002.
But I dislike your assertion that just because SV companies feel free to rewrite their history, we should consider that canonical.
It's totally valid to point out that Musk wasn't a founder, though using it as some kind of slight is juvenile.
eBay is free to claim it was invented to sell Pez dispensers and we're free to point out that's PR spin. Neither side is in the wrong.
I was just explaining how to not embarrass yourself.
Oh Really?
In 1979, NASA founded the Orbital Debris Program to adopt mitigation measures for space debris in earth orbit.
Apparently heaven forbids a web search on Astronomy & space junk. Or checking with astroimagery software to detect & mask frames contaminated with existing satellites streaks
SpaceX's constellation is already specifically set at a low orbit to prevent buildup of space debris. That impact was absolutely considered and mitigated from the start.
I really have trouble believing that nobody mentioned adding thousands of satellites would go unnoticed. It is damn near impossible to take any image of the night sky without having a satellite streak through the frame. I have plenty of images with multiple satellites visible at the same time. In wide angle timelapse sequences, they are just small dots that move against the natural movement of the stars. In longer lenses/telescopes, they appear as long straight lines totally ruining the image.
The first time I heard about thousands more of lower altitude satellites, my first thought was about this very thing. We had already had the discussions from the giant disco ball that was launched. It was planned to be short lived, but it caused quite the stir. Saying people at SpaceX didn't think about it is one thing, but to claim nobody in the astronomy community didn't is hard to take. Maybe they didn't have any way to voice those thoughts in a way that SpaceX could hear.