News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by downrightmike on Sunday December 08, 2019 @12:27PM (#21736962)
Software should be able to account for this. If photoshop can remove people from photos, why can't astronomy software remove satellites? Orbit is already pretty cluttered and we can't remove much that gets stuck up there already.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by takk309 on Sunday December 08, 2019 @01:32PM (#21737313)
This isn't just about astrophotography, this has to do with real science too. Remember, most science work is already on a tight budget and now they will have to waste some of that budget sorting through the added visual clutter.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by La1n on Sunday December 08, 2019 @03:56PM (#21738254)
Yes, and SpaceX seems to be actively downplaying that fact.

>. “We want to make sure we do the right thing to make sure little kids can look through their telescope,” she said. “Astronomy is one of the few things that gets little kids excited about space.”

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by kerng on Sunday December 08, 2019 @02:08PM (#21737561)
It's like with nature on earth, tech pollutes things. It's not really anything new.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by pretendscholar on Sunday December 08, 2019 @02:46PM (#21737813)
its literally a new additional problem which is why its being discussed
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by krastanov on Sunday December 08, 2019 @01:27PM (#21737288)
Software can make a picture look pretty, but it has very limited use when you are fighting against the limits of information theory. You want an actual new measurement, not a guess of what a reasonable measurement would look like based on past measurements.
[dead]
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by doubleunplussed on Sunday December 08, 2019 @02:39PM (#21737756)
It's not a dot, in a long exposure photograph, it's a line. You don't delete it spatially, you'll want to subtract off the extra photon counts along that line so you can retain whatever was in that part of the image. Now, I think that's possible - find lines one diffraction-spot wide, fit to its brightness and subtract it off. They should be damned near straight lines of constant brightness given how fast satellites move, and the transverse profile should be exactly given by your telescope's point-spread-function, so you should be able to locate them and model them for subtraction very well. I think it can be done.

Photon shot noise is sqrt(N) though, so even after the subtraction you're left with more noise along that line than elsewhere. So that's not ideal. But increased noise is less of a concern that "totally ruined data".

Another caveat is that the lines have to not be so bright as to saturate your CCD, otherwise you truly have lost data that subtraction won't help with.

Edit: it turns out astronomers take many shorter exposures [1] and simply reject the pixels that are too far away from the mean in any given exposure when combining them. This seems mostly better than what I was proposing, though it does mean increased readout noise since you read out multiple times and so for very sensitive measurements I would still expect astronomers might want to do true single long exposures.

[1] https://www.skyandtelescope.com/astronomy-blogs/imaging-foun...

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by jdashg on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:52PM (#21738999)
You can't just subtract a bright signal and hope to see the weak signal underneath it, or we'd just subtract daylight during the day.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by doubleunplussed on Sunday December 08, 2019 @10:27PM (#21740175)
Depends how bright, I do it every day in a different context and it can work pretty well. The brighter, the more of that noise I was getting at. Sunlight is very, very bright , but satellites less so. I'd need to know how bright to know if the resulting noise would swamp the signal. Perhaps the fact that astronomers aren't doing this is evidence that it does.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by buboard on Sunday December 08, 2019 @01:47PM (#21737410)
since starlinks may change positions autonomously it's impossible to predict their positions. and they are so damn many
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by dnautics on Sunday December 08, 2019 @01:51PM (#21737447)
You don't need a position prediction to remove an anomaly.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by cbanek on Sunday December 08, 2019 @02:33PM (#21737714)
Actually, you kind of do, because how do you know it's an anomaly and not something you want to observe? Especially if it's just occluding things in its path, and you can't see it. It's really helpful to know where everything is.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by dnautics on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:51PM (#21738992)
Optical signature.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by nradov on Sunday December 08, 2019 @04:55PM (#21738645)
Starlink satellites are too small to do much orbital maneuvering. They only carry a small supply of krypton gas for their station keeping thrusters.
Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by greglindahl on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:03PM (#21739061)
They have enough propellant to change their orbital height by quite a lot, more than the typical satellite (other than GTO-to-GEO thrusters.)

OTOH you can just ask SpaceX or the Air Force where they have been in the past, SpaceX uses GPS and the Air Force radar is accurate enough for knowing where they were.

Re:SpaceX working on fix for Starlink satellites so they don... by londons_explore on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:33AM (#21741183)
If the astronomer community requested it, I'm sure spacex would give them a real-time (or even a few minutes ahead of time) feed of satellite positions accurate to less than a pixel on these telescopes.