News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by supernova87a on Wednesday February 27, 2019 @09:06PM (#19268481)
SNCF is fiddling with the wrong things.

It doesn't need to separate train operations from rail track network maintenance. It doesn't need to open up the network to competition.

What it needs to do is cut the number of excessive public sector workers, reduce costs, and stop running the business like a political arm of the government.

I can bet that the reason they think they need to do all these things is that cost pressure is rising on them, and they think they need to branch out / cut off compartments of the business to make it better. But this is tinkering rather than addressing the fundamental issues (inability to fire people, change cost structure, etc. due to political interference).

Public rail is a money-losing venture, in every country (except Hong Kong). That's what "public" means. But it's important to have. Just how much money-losing depends on the political environment and skill of the management. UK tried this sort of thing and it left everyone with a shittier experience, though they could claim that they successfully privatized the industry -- everyone knows that's a total lie.

At least France has a history of pride in the speed of the trains, so that will keep things in check a bit. They'll pay through the nose for it though.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by rswail on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:34AM (#19269427)
"Public rail is a money-losing venture"

So are public schools, public hospitals and national defence. But they are enablers of everything else that we do and the actual purpose of government and taxes.

Public transport needs to be as efficient as it can be while providing the services needed. There are additional benefits like providing a training environment for trades, ensuring that a heavy engineering skillbase is maintained, social cohesiveness and equality of opportunity to remote populations etc.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by taneq on Thursday February 28, 2019 @03:07AM (#19269812)
So you're saying that a publicly funded utility should provide some kind of beneficial service to the public? Like it's some kind of public service?
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by dsfyu404ed on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:57AM (#19271005)
The government should not be engaging in money losing ventures to provide services that private companies will provide at no cost (other than point of service cost) to taxpayers.

If they want to run a jobs program then fine, run a jobs program. Don't pretend your jobs program is an infrastructure program though.

I have no problem with the government spending tax money on things, that's kind of its job, but resources are not infinite (eventually you run out of other people's money). I know this is a much hated opinion among the HN demographic and I won't win internet brownie points for saying it but government should not be spending taxpayer money on services private entities are willing to provide. Government should spend its money on things private industry won't do (like social safety nets, education and funding R%D for things private industry doesn't care about).

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by black_puppydog on Thursday February 28, 2019 @08:11AM (#19271066)
> services that private companies will provide at no cost to taxpayers

Like the private train companies that run around handing free rides to everyone?

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by dsfyu404ed on Thursday February 28, 2019 @08:18AM (#19271108)
>Like the private train companies that run around handing free rides to everyone?

Well good for them that they've found an alternate way to be profitable.

If said profitability comes from a poorly spec'd out contract that somehow lets them screw the government out of money instead of charging people for the service then that's a corruption and integrity of public officials problem

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by Silhouette on Thursday February 28, 2019 @09:39AM (#19271544)
I have no problem with the government spending tax money on things but resources are not infinite (eventually you run out of other people's money) and in lieu of that they should not be spending taxpayer money on services private entities are willing to provide.

What if private entities are willing to provide an essential service, but due to effects like lack of effective competition or economies of scale, most/all people wind up paying more direct to the profit-making private entity than they would via tax to a publicly funded service?

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by speedplane on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:14AM (#19269592)
> Public rail is a money-losing venture, ... But it's important to have. Just how much money-losing depends on the political environment and skill of the management.

Arguably, all public rail should lose money. Quality transportation is a huge economic driver of regional economies. If a rail service is making money, it likely means governments are underinvesting in their own economies.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by atoav on Thursday February 28, 2019 @03:17AM (#19269859)
It usually also means that public transport is too expensive for those who are in need of it the most (e.g. people who can’t afford a car or for whom owning a car doesn’t make any sense — which is arguably more common in Europe than the US)
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by kmlx on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:14AM (#19270545)
> TOKYO -- East and West Japan Railway have both forecast record profits for the fiscal year ending March 2018, anticipating more bullet train passengers and higher income from real estate and other noncore operations. > West Japan Railway said Friday it expects a group net profit of 109 billion yen ($978 million) for the fiscal year through March 2018, up 19% on the year.

Full article: https://asia.nikkei.com/Editor-s-Picks/Japan-Update/JR-East-...

JR East annual report: https://www.jreast.co.jp/e/investor/ar/2018/pdf/ar_2018-all....

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by skriticos2 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:18AM (#19270824)
Yes, but Japan also has trice the population density of France and most of the people are focused in the gargantuan city landscapes like the greater Tokyo bay area. Makes it a lot easier to saturate the trains while maintaining a reasonable timetable.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by adev_ on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:55AM (#19270994)
JR rails makes an important part of its benefits from the huge commercial centers (Atrée & others) they run in their stations. That's a model that works in Japan, but cannot run everywhere. Not every country is a tiny island with such a dense urbanisation.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by Silhouette on Thursday February 28, 2019 @09:47AM (#19271606)
I read an interesting article about this a while back.

Something distinctive about the Japanese rail culture is that they build lots of communal facilities right next to their stations. For example, people routinely stop and do their shopping on the way home from work, even though they're getting home by train (though this idea isn't just about shops).

Compare that to typical Western railway stations, where a huge amount of the prime real estate right next to the trains is used for giant car parks, and you can see that the success of their model is no accident. Of course, we couldn't trivially adopt the same strategy in the West. Unlike the Japanese, we haven't been designing our towns and cities around this principle for a long time, and as the parent comment notes, we also don't have the same density. That means we do need ways for people to get to the station from the surrounding area.

Often good alternatives to the car are still lacking in the West, which then creates an unfortunate chicken and egg scenario. But that doesn't mean the Japanese model isn't potentially better than ours, if only we could find a viable path from one to the other.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by magduf on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:08PM (#19272885)
It's not just Japan. German train stations are also mini-malls, frequently with grocery stores in them, along with restaurants, clothing stores, etc. (depending on the size of the station of course).
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by close04 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:44AM (#19270179)
It usually does. Actually I am not familiar with one example where public rail actually makes a profit, in real terms. All public rail systems I know or have read about are subsidized by the state either directly or via subsidizing the fare for the traveler (or both).
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by atoav on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:23AM (#19270355)
I think we should stop counting profit as “how much tickets you sold” minus “how much money you spent”, but look at the effects of a public train system on the whole economy.

I grew up in the Alps and I can guarantee that certain very profitable touristic locations wouldn’t even remotely work if there was no affordable and reliable train network that connected them to a airport, unless you want to turn some alpine area into a huge parking lot. On the same line that connects that spot to the cities there might be ten completely uninteresting villages whose population kinda relies on these trains to e.g. go to school, go shopping in the city etc. Some lines might not have any touristic benefit, but they raise the value of the whole network because it increases the destinations you can reach via train.

In nations that have high petrol prices and where train networks already exist, train networks can be unprofitable and still boost economy as a whole.

The question is: should everybody finance everybody elses mobility to a certain degree when it benefits economy as a whole?

For me the answer is quite clear. I grew up in small village in some valley in the alps. Without affordable public transport I would have been devastated as a teenager. A profitable train network usually takes that profit from somewhere and that somewhere is typically public.

I’d rather have an unprofitable train network that works, paid by my taxes than a profitable that doesn’t work even if I were prepared to pay for it. Same goes for Internet, Mobile networks, Water, Electricity.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by close04 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:55AM (#19270465)
That wasn't my point. I only highlighted the fact that indeed they operate at a loss and the companies themselves or the price of the ticket are partially funded/subsidized by the state. This is why I suggested they don't make a profit "in real terms", meaning actual profit in the company's financial report, not indirect effects. You don't seem to contradict this despite the downvote.

The point was not to debate whether this is a good move or not, if it stimulates an economy or not, etc. I live in a country here the rail system is heavily subsidized and I'm happy for it as it is.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by atoav on Thursday February 28, 2019 @08:31AM (#19271191)
Sorry if I read something into your post that you didn’t intend to say. Lack of profit is often used as an argument against public transport in discussions, especially from people who grew up in places where cars ar the norm, petrol is cheap and there is no real public transport (e.g. the US).

Sorry if I misrepresented your post.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by Gibbon1 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:59AM (#19270235)
Years ago I read an article where the author argued that between network effects and indirect beneficiaries of transportation services markets are extremely sub-optimal. Also the value of the service varies widely as well. One box contains a toaster anotherbox contains a vital part needed to get a machine shop back up and running.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by Zombiethrowaway on Wednesday February 27, 2019 @11:24PM (#19268934)
The French government passed a law in mid-2018 that ends the special "cheminot" contract for new hires. It will effectively grandfather the old way in 10-20 years, and make it smaller every year.

So I don't think this is fair or accurate: "rather than addressing the fundamental issues (inability to fire people, change cost structure"

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by ldng on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:06AM (#19270273)
Nor did that changed anything. Most employees are contractors nowadays.

French politics must stop playing with trains and grow up. And fire the management that's been there for 10 years and made it worst.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by jillesvangurp on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:16AM (#19270552)
Public rail is only a money losing venture if you consider that ticket sales is the only benefit it provides and that those need to fully cover the exploitation. If that were the case, rip out the subways in any US city, shut down the airports, break up the highways (who pays for those?), etc. Most of that kind of infrastructure does not happen without tax payer money.

The reality is that the economic side effects of connecting cities with each other such that people can travel easily between them facilitates a lot of business to happen. Having access to infrastructure such as working internet, good housing and health care, public transport, etc. are per-requisites for running any successful business.

In France, the high speed rail network which has been there for decades now has meant that a lot of business trips to major French cities can be done in a single business day without requiring lots of planes to fly. That makes a lot of difference for cities that are far from Paris. Also it means that getting to Paris from anywhere in France is typically easy and straightforward.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by jdietrich on Wednesday February 27, 2019 @09:37PM (#19268600)
>UK tried this sort of thing and it left everyone with a shittier experience, though they could claim that they successfully privatized the industry -- everyone knows that's a total lie.

Passenger volumes have more than doubled since privatisation, after a long period of stagnation under nationalisation. While walk-on fares have increased above the rate of inflation, advance fares are substantially cheaper. The supposed problems of the British rail network resemble that Yogi Berra quote - "nobody goes there any more, it's too crowded".

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-21056703

https://www.stagecoach.com/media/insight-features/the-facts-...

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by NeedMoreTea on Wednesday February 27, 2019 @11:36PM (#19268978)
That's really not a fair reflection.

Privatisation came after nearly 20 years of Tory under investment and far from adequate under several administrations previously. It was, by the time of Major, a very predictable and well-worn trope. What better way to "prove" your lawn needs a private mowing service than barely mowing the lawn for a decade or two? It's quite easy to see why rolling stock was far beyond expected life.

There was plenty wrong, many of which would have been resolved with adequate funding for newer rolling stock, routes, electrification and capacity. Investments that have come painfully slowly outside the South East, mostly with public funds, since privatisation. The cliche of terrible sandwiches was often true - well if you're being deprived of funds better to keep the train running than the sandwiches fresh. The meals in dining cars managed to stay pretty damn good. Far better than having a trolley service only, for instance.

Major's privatisation was a case of "anything but this". Separating track, rolling stock and station building into three different companies was nuts. Public subsidy plummeted after privatisation, until inadequate maintenance was identified as cause of the Hatfield crash. Then reached never before seen peaks. They're still fiddling around to try and remove the systemic consequences of how it was privatised. Nothing that even slightly resembles the integrated transport The Netherlands can manage.

Season tickets have increased in line with inflation, only because they were pegged by statute to inflation +/- 1%. On the day tickets, which didn't get that protection, have increased vastly in real terms. Don't forget the UK rushed to the car far more than European neighbours - Beeching etc - it's little surprise to see rail growing faster now we have gridlocked roads, having been pruned to almost non-existence.

After 20 years it's not the disaster it might have been - mainly "thanks" to Hatfield - but it's far from a success. Especially outside the South East and on prices. Heaven help you if you ever use the trans Pennine.

Seeing as this is on an article about TGV, just how is UK doing with high speed rail? Northern Powerhouse? Double decker trains?

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by jabl on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:01AM (#19269541)
> Separating track, rolling stock and station building into three different companies was nuts. Public subsidy plummeted after privatisation, until inadequate maintenance was identified as cause of the Hatfield crash. Then reached never before seen peaks. They're still fiddling around to try and remove the systemic consequences of how it was privatised. Nothing that even slightly resembles the integrated transport The Netherlands can manage.

Just curious, what are they doing in the Netherlands?

One argument I've heard from people who seem to know more about railroading than me (not a very high bar to meet, but...) is that superficial similarities aside, tracks + trains as a business is very different from roads + vehicles. The track-train "interface" is much tighter and there are much bigger advantages to vertical integration (same entity owns and operates both tracks and trains). For a simple example, what is the "optimal" penalty that the train operator should pay to the track operator if a train breaks down, causing chaos in the entire network? I.e. how do you structure the incentives for the different companies so that the outcome for the entire system is optimal? For roads this isn't much of a consideration, if a truck breaks down other traffic can pass it.

If so, it would mean the EU & UK approach of separating the track and train companies is very foolish.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by dingaling on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:03AM (#19270503)
> If so, it would mean the EU & UK approach of separating the track and train companies is very foolish.

Yet it works fine for air travel, where the airports, air traffic services and airlines are all separate and charges are transparent.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by notahacker on Thursday February 28, 2019 @08:18AM (#19271107)
The dynamics of air transport are very different though. Air transport involves hubs with carriers from all over the world flying into them. Rail lines typically involves one or two companies having access to a given piece of rail infrastructure (generally with natural or state-guaranteed monopolies on particular routes) so vertical integration makes a lot more sense, especially compared with a model where operating companies don't have the flexibility to push forward upgrade timetables they think are commercially necessary, but do get to capture profit windfalls from public investment.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by Vinnl on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:07AM (#19270055)
> Just curious, what are they doing in the Netherlands?

The Netherlands has a tracks company (ProRail) and several railroad companies, by far the largest one being National Rail (NS).

That said, that's one of the most criticised points of the Dutch construction, and whenever something's wrong, there's a lot of finger pointing going around (although that seems to have lessened a bit recently). NS and ProRail would like to merge though.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by NeedMoreTea on Thursday February 28, 2019 @03:09AM (#19269820)
Whether by accident, or design, The Netherlands seem much more able to have transport options that join up. Buses that terminate at the train station, tram routes that serve both, park and ride that serves all. With compatible timetables and ticketing. After reading the piece about Delft cycle routes yesterday, I suspect a reasonable part was by design. I'm sure someone native can point out some major holes, but still from my UK perspective it seems to work very well. :)

UK still happily has bus, train and tram routes that only sort-of join up, sometimes, often by accident. The bus might arrive at the station 5 minutes after the express leaves, etc.

> tracks + trains as a business is very different from roads + vehicles

I'm no rail expert either, but I'll waffle on a bit. :)

It's much closer to air than road - you can't just throw more trains out there, they need slots, separation and compatible timetabling with the others. On a road you can just put out another bus and see which survives, they can even have the same timetable if you like.

The problem I see with UK privatisation is the competition is a myth, but it's been made bloody complicated for the sake of it - for example "what is the "optimal" penalty that the train operator...". A single train operator gets a single regional franchise, yet at least three companies are involved in every route (track, train, buildings). The old train builders, station hotels, and catering had already been sold off.

The old big 4 (GWR, LNER, LMS, SR) owned track, station and train, a train builder, the station hotel and caterer too - if they want to add a new route it wasn't a nightmare of inter-company contracts, or trying to persuade another company to keep the building staffed another hour, or to put new sign on a station wall. No penalties or silliness, just service embarrassment, maybe a government requirement or two. Only when you got to an interchange station did it become multi-company. Course that meant there wasn't much competition - well no kidding. Before the big 4 there was more competition, often from duplicate lines. Also more than one company running trains on lines, though one rail company always owned the infrastructure and rented a slot. So more coexistence than competition.

We missed an opportunity several times to get the main lines electrified - West coast main line was asking for electrification for about 40 years before it got it. Same for expanding to 4 lines so slow and fast can run together more easily, and freight can expand. Beeching destroyed a lot of the joined up nature of our rail, and much of the branch network. We bought in too heavily to the car as the only answer. Thanks to the curse of being early, we may never get double decker trains - that would need countless bridges and tunnels being modified or rebuilt.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by tremon on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:32AM (#19270389)
Whether by accident, or design, The Netherlands seem much more able to have transport options that join up. Buses that terminate at the train station, tram routes that serve both, park and ride that serves all. With compatible timetables and ticketing.

The timetabling is partly by accident, I suspect -- or rather, it's a consequence of having high-frequency routes. Most inner-city buses and trams have a ride every ten minutes or less, so there's always an option that joins up. The NS (railway) does invest a lot of effort in matching their arrivals and departures with the most-used transfers, and I suspect regional bus services do the same. But I'm not aware of any timetable coordination between different operators.

On the other hand, it's very rare for train stations not to be serviced by at least one other type of public transport, and that's definitely by design. Even inter-city bus routes have their termini at train stations rather than the city centers of the cities they connect.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by kmlx on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:19AM (#19270574)
> The Netherlands seem much more able to have transport options that join up.

The Netherlands is a very small country, almost half the size of Panama, with a mostly dead flat geography. It is also one of the most densely populated countries in the world.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by NeedMoreTea on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:19PM (#19272983)
UK is pretty densely populated as countries go. If you consider just England, actually slightly higher density than The Netherlands, though obviously not quite as flat.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by kmlx on Friday March 01, 2019 @09:39AM (#19280983)
i'm getting 395 pop. density for UK, and 488 for the netherlands. nl is also the most densely populated country in the EU. on a world scale, netherlands is 31 out of 254 territories (incl. countries). i'd also add the WW2 devastation that allowed some of the European countries to overhaul huge parts of their infrastructure.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by eloisant on Thursday February 28, 2019 @03:49AM (#19269988)
Netherland is a small country, they don't need bullet trains.

The distance from Paris to Marseille is close to 800km, you'd better have a bullet train if you don't want the trip to take a full day.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by mcv on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:44AM (#19270178)
Netherland is small, but it's not an island. We have high-speed trains to France and Germany, and soon England. The Dutch part of the trip is generally the slowest part, though.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by pbhjpbhj on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:35AM (#19270630)
>well if you're being deprived of funds better to keep the train running than the sandwiches fresh //

I'm not sure about this: the sandwiches are an easy daily income; you've got a captive audience, why not make them awesome? In this situation you still have to pay the person making them and selling them, why not make them good?

Can you imagine "I take the train, it has the best sandwiches!". Why can't that be a thing?

>The meals in dining cars managed to stay pretty damn good. //

Presumably because the "fat cats" ate in the dining cars.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by jdietrich on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:26AM (#19269130)
Rail subsidies are highly regressive. The rail network primarily connects cities to cities via relatively affluent suburbs. If you live on a council estate and work in a factory, it's highly unlikely that you have the option of commuting by rail. Very few workers with below-average incomes have the need to travel from Manchester to London for a meeting. Rail travel is inherently more expensive than other modes and always will be, due to the massive infrastructure cost. It's not even lower-carbon than bus travel in the vast majority of cases.

Why should taxpayers subsidise a mode of travel that is inherently used primarily by the wealthy?

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by ip26 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:41AM (#19269202)
Rail might not be the mode of choice for day laborers. But on a trip around Europe, via probably twenty different trains, I didn't see a single monacle, glass of fine alcohol, or even a suit. Trains were full of very ordinary people, including children and students... The clientele felt very similar to cattle-class air travel.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by GordonS on Sunday March 03, 2019 @09:22AM (#19294538)
> I didn't see a single monacle

Thanks, I just spat coffee up a wall!

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by pas on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:08AM (#19269306)
> Why should taxpayers subsidise a mode of travel that is inherently used primarily by the wealthy?

Well, the same goes for roads. Some people don't even have a car, and wealthy people move around a lot more in cars.

But it turns out wealthy people do a lot more of a lot of things, especially move around, because they have money to do so.

And were travel cheaper probably more people would do so.

So, taxpayers basically pay for the ability to have a network that allows them to travel a bit.

In some countries low income folks get cheaper tickets. Also high income folk pay a lot more taxes.

All in all, it'd be great to merge the high speed rail and ordinary road bus networks, and just maintain and subsidize that one, and have more socially fair pricing.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by vixen99 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @03:44AM (#19269968)
The same doesn't go for roads. I might not have a car but my life would be severely impacted if local providers of goods and services including public ones, can't use roads.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by mcv on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:49AM (#19270197)
Roads that would be clogged with more passenger traffic if there was no mass transit available. Better train infrastructure isn't just good for people who take the train, it's also good for road traffic.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by atoav on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:17AM (#19270091)
In Austria many people commute to Vienna via train, which as a nice side effect reduces the number of cars in the city.

As an Austrian in Germany who used trains regularily to go back and forth I can assure you that it is not rare to see workers in full clothes with toolboxes and stuff in trains. Most regular people look like office workers, families and you will always spot a few upper class managment people.

The mixture depends entirely on your timing. If you use the train only during the holidays or weekends, you might get a very distorted image of who uses these trains on a day to day basis.

But trains as a mode of transportation for the wealthy? Might be that way in the UK (I wasn’there a lot), but certainly not in the other parts of Europe.

In Germany and Austria you will see a mix of people that sort of represents the society as a whole (in terms of wealth.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by NeedMoreTea on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:56AM (#19269761)
Many of those affluent suburbs became wealthy because of the station and rail link to London. The less-affluent suburbs are often those Mr Beeching ripped connection from, by removing most of the branch line network.

In the rest of the country, I've never felt surrounded by wealth on trains. Mostly it just seemed like the same mix of regular people you'd see anywhere.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:49AM (#19270691)
> Very few workers with below-average incomes have the need to travel from Manchester to London for a meeting

Manchester to London doesn't receive subsidies, it makes a lot of money which is plumbed back into (for example) the south wales valleys lines

South West Rail for all those affulent bankers going into London also makes a profit that's reinvested in say services in Cornwall

> Rail travel is inherently more expensive than other modes and always will be, due to the massive infrastructure cost.

That's not nescersarilly true, I suspect you aren't accounting for externalities like polution, the military cost of oil, etc.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by pjc50 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:14AM (#19270544)
Rail is high-volume, far more so than achievable by bus, and the modal users are the middle class and commuters. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...

Really this is a "yes and" situation. We should also have decent low-cost buses, which in the UK are only available in London, Edinburgh and a few other places.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by adrianN on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:10AM (#19270528)
Because the alternative to rail is cars. Cars don't scale to the level needed in cities. They also pollute a lot and kill a lot of people in accidents. Everybody benefits from fewer cars on the road.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by pbhjpbhj on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:42AM (#19270665)
>Because the alternative to rail is cars. //

Going by air is an alternative to rail for some journeys [eg within UK] too. Edinburgh-London for example.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @09:03AM (#19271342)
There are about 2600 seats on 29 planes from Edinburgh to London's 3 airports on Monday -- average of say 100 seats a plane.

There's about 12,600 train seats

How do you propose to fit in another 145 flights a day between the two cities?

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by adrianN on Thursday February 28, 2019 @08:14AM (#19271085)
Airports in city centers are pretty problematic and I don't think that they can handle the number of commuters that a railway can.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by pbhjpbhj on Thursday February 28, 2019 @11:48AM (#19272695)
I wasn't contemplating it as an en masse replacement: from a traveller's perspective I consider flying for journeys where rail is an option (because cars are cheaper usually for short-medium, and walking/buses for short journeys).

You're right re city centers, perhaps I gave a bad example - in UK for longer journeys I like the train but flying is superior (for my use-case) usually - cheaper, faster.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by 7952 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:07AM (#19269301)
At least in London rail let's people avoid higher house prices by having a longer commute. But that expands the commuter belt, and raises prices for everyone else. It would be better if people could live closer to work.

I think they should use subsidy to make shorter local journeys free or very cheap. Include bus travel also. Ramp up the prices on longer journeys. They could also help out regional airlines to take strain of the rail network.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:49AM (#19270694)
Generally we all agree that flying when you could use the train is a very bad thing.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by 7952 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:44AM (#19270941)
A new generation of electric planes could change that. And a lot of the cross country fleet is diesel anyway and produces CO2 and other emissions.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @08:40AM (#19271227)
Sure, let me know how that works out.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @08:51AM (#19271277)
> While walk-on fares have increased above the rate of inflation

Barry Doe covered this in a recent Rail issue.

Inflation in this context is RPI, because that's what rail salaries are based on. Walk on fares are regulated and thus kept relatively cheap (Vrigin off peak returns are 6% higher than they were in 1995, after RPI for example. Service is now nearly twice the speed and twice the frequency). RDG want to get rid of this protection though.

But you're right that advance fares are both cheaper and easier to get.

The biggest winners are season ticket holders - many have risen by less than inflation (Chiltern, c2c, EMT, Great Northern, Sourther, Thameslink, South Western and Virgin)

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by titanix2 on Wednesday February 27, 2019 @09:30PM (#19268575)
> It doesn't need to open up the network to competition.

I think this is mandated by the EU. And it could be a good thing. I'm personally fed up to be treated like a thief when I forgot composting my ticket (which happen because there is not gate to access the rails) or when I could not buy it in the first place (some station doesn't have have vending machines).

Also the price lottery for TGV tickets is infuriating (price goes from 14€ to 140€ for the ride I take the most) and the commercial strategy of the SNCF is to offer cheap TGV which lacks any confort to kind of punish you not buying the more expensive option.

But actually I would even be happier if we import all the working staff from Japan and make them the whole thing working smoothly under a join JR-France company.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by ambicapter on Wednesday February 27, 2019 @09:44PM (#19268628)
For english speakers, "composting" here means punching a ticket. I never understood where the word came from, and I'm a native French speaker.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by niea_11 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:43AM (#19269208)
Apparently the meaning doesn't come from the verb but from the italian word : "compositore" (according to wikitionary [1] and the larousse dictionary [2])

(again in [1]) "compositore" from italian is equivalent to "compositeur" in french which can mean "a person that writes music" but can also mean "a typographer or compositor".

[1] : https://fr.wiktionary.org/wiki/composteur

[2] : https://www.larousse.fr/dictionnaires/francais/composteur/17...

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by carlob on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:02AM (#19270039)
Funnily enough the word we use for stamping tickets in Italian is vidimare which comes from vidimus (seen) in Latin, so it's actually closer to visa in etymology.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by magduf on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:13PM (#19272924)
For ESL speakers, "composting" to us means "put in a bin with a bunch of dead vegetation and let it rot". It can also refer to throwing something away in a bin that is destined for a compost pile (for instance, food scraps).

I was wondering why the OP would be treated like a thief for not throwing his ticket away to be composted.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by bane on Wednesday February 27, 2019 @11:24PM (#19268936)
Wow, thanks for that. I can't find a definition in an English dictionary that was able to make sense of that. It appears to have etymology in Old French composte which comes from Latin "composita" or "compositum" which means something like "something put together".

Even crazier I can't figure out how we arrive at the modern meaning of decaying vegetables to make soil...but I can arrive at how we got to "composite" which seems to have different but similar roots.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by jcranmer on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:10AM (#19269073)
> Even crazier I can't figure out how we arrive at the modern meaning of decaying vegetables to make soil...

The etymology I see all mentions "composte" as "mixture of leaves, manure, etc., for fertilizing land", which suggests that it started as people using a *composita of manure and plant detritus together to ferment for fertilizer and the word sense shifted from referring to the specific mixture to the general composting process.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by bane on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:33AM (#19269157)
Ahh, that makes sense.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by titanix2 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:24AM (#19270117)
Thanks for having filled the "exercice left to the reader" as I didn't know the correct word!
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:43AM (#19270674)
> I think this is mandated by the EU.

Not really, the EU is democratic, and generally there's skeptisism in the EU about a liberal rail market.

The Fourth Railway Package explicity allows tracks and trains to be owned by a single holding company. The main point of the package was things like harmonising safety standards across europe (so if you wanted to run a train from london to warsaw you wouldn't need to get safety certification from UK, France, Belgium, Netherlands, Germany and Poland).

It will mean that a given EU government can't use the rail industry as a way of hiding state aid to people/industries. If SNCF are good, that's fine, they continue. If DB come along and say they can run France's network for half the cost, then DB get the job.

> I'm personally fed up to be treated like a thief when I forgot composting my ticket

That's because you're not traveling with a valid ticket. Try driving off from the petrol station without paying, or boarding a plane without showing a boarding pass.

> Also the price lottery for TGV tickets is infuriating

It's demand led, like planes.

> the commercial strategy of the SNCF is to offer cheap TGV which lacks any confort to kind of punish you not buying the more expensive option.

So buy the more expensive one if you value the comfort.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by cowl on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:14AM (#19270809)
>That's because you're not travelling with a valid ticket. Try driving off from the petrol station without paying, or boarding a plane without showing a boarding pass.

that's not even remotely close. I don't know exactly how it is in France but in Italy (and I suspect it's similar) I may have a monthly ticket clearly stating the validity FROM-TO, having my name on it and yet still if i don't time stamp it at the start of month i'm treated like a thief because bureaucracy says ALL tickets must be timestamped. WHY? how could i cheat with a named monthly subscription ticked? Ticket controllers not having to fear for their job don't even try to think and treat passengers with respect.

Now that we have a private Operator the situation is a little bit better but still until we have laws that dictate nobody must do any effort to maintain the job it's not gonna be pretty.

Now You may ask Why I don't simply time stamp it at the start of the month. Maybe i'm late and I miss my train But most of the time and in many stations the stamping machines do not work. courtesy of the same guaranteed monopoly Company.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by ssmiler on Thursday February 28, 2019 @10:16AM (#19271853)
I suppose that government subventions are split as a function of the number of passengers...
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:22AM (#19270838)
Does that monthly ticket has a start date printed on it before you compost it?
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by cowl on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:47AM (#19270957)
Of course it does. it's a monthly ticket valid from first of the month until end of the month. And even for the tickets without a date Why should the passenger be penalised when there are no working stamping machines in the train station? how is that the passenger problem?
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @10:55AM (#19272209)
> Of course it does

Dunno about France (OP gave no indication he was talking about a period ticket), but in the UK monthly tickets last a month from the time they begin (which is printed on the ticket at time of purchase). Most train tickets I've bought on the continent are undated - if you don't composte them then you could use them time and time again, which would be theft of service.

In the UK we have carnets which must be dated (albeit with a pen rather than a machine) before boarding the train. They give very little discount and users are often accused of fraud.

> Why should the passenger be penalised when there are no working stamping machines in the train station? how is that the passenger problem?

It's the passengers problem as they presumably can't board the train without a valid ticket. I'm not sure how competition or changing ownership would help, what you need are strong laws making the train company liable if it's not there.

Again in the UK we have "penalty fares", which are on the spot "fines" for "honest mistakes". Sadly the same doesn't apply to train companies, when they deny boarding despite a valid ticket, or you get threatened with legal action despite a valid ticket, you have to fight it, but they don't get fined.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by cowl on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:31PM (#19276469)
> I'm not sure how competition or changing ownership would help

Competition always helps. It would be as simple as putting a stamping machine inside the train like they do on the buses. I mean it doesn't cost anything and the only reason it is not being done is the same reason machines in stations do not work. The train company has a monopoly and they don't care to try offering a decent service.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by glandium on Thursday February 28, 2019 @03:00AM (#19269785)
The JR service comes at a cost. Shinkansen tickets are vastly more expensive than TGV.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by titanix2 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:22AM (#19270110)
Yes it's a bit more expensive but the trains themselves are way more confortable, most of the time on schedule and drive at full operational speed all the time because they rails are made for it. With TGV on the other hand you have a few sections which are standard rails and thus you the train drive at a normal (low) speed...
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by mcv on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:35AM (#19270155)
More comfortable than the TGV? The train I'm most familiar with is the Thalys, the high-speed train from Amsterdam to Paris, and I'm not sure if it's more comfortable than other TGVs, but it's always a joy to travel in.

I recently went to London in the Eurostar, and they'd managed to make the train experience feel like a plane. Very disappointing.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by kmlx on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:07AM (#19270521)
Having recently used both the TGV and the Tokaido Shinkansen, I'd say the Hikari line is much more comfortable than any of the TGV trains.

Regarding the Eurostar, it works like that because the UK is not in Schengen. As such, border control needs to happen. Not to mention the potential issues with terrorism. And the Eurostar is net inferior to any of the Shinkansen trains.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by GordonS on Sunday March 03, 2019 @09:27AM (#19294557)
Can confirm, I've been on the TGV and also a few bullet trains in Japan - the bullet trains were practically luxurious in terms of comfort and space, and the service was fantastic.

I also found the bullet trains to be great value, especially when compared to the expensive, uncomfortable, over-crowded, slow, dirty, late trains here in the UK.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by mcv on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:36AM (#19270900)
The border checks absolutely added to the plane feeling of the experience, but Eurostar seats are also significantly more cramped than those of the Thalys.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by ownagefool on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:56AM (#19270223)
Err UK rail was famously terrible before "privatisation".

Not that privatisation is the answer, nor that being public was at fault, but I'm not sure rewriting history is helpful.

Looking at UK water companies being privatised so their owners can stuff them full of debt to get around the profit caps is probably a better case study.

Profit percentage caps are silly because the obvious way to make more money is to make the entire service more expensive by wasting money, this increasing turnover, thus increasing the size of that 4%.

Monopolies being privatised doesn't seem super helpful either, but hey, that's the UK for you.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by elcomet on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:10AM (#19270291)
I read in a lot of articles that it is actually more terrible for a lot of tracks after privatisation in the UK.

What happens is that companies focus on the most profitable tracks, so the other ones are not well maintained.

An example: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/dec/05/the-gu...

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by ownagefool on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:35AM (#19270406)
I'm not sure that article say's it's worse than pre-privatisation, just that it's not great now and they're right, I pay over £400 a month to sit on the floor for a train that turns up when it wants to. It's not exactly amazing.

But, as a counter: https://www.ft.com/content/d192b1b4-458b-11e5-af2f-4d6e0e5ed...

Now indeed, the terrible service in the past was most likely due to underfunding, but recent history suggests we'll consistently vote in a Government that starves national infrastructure then sell it off to it's mates, so it's hard to see public ownership lasting and resulting in success.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by nickik on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:04PM (#19272854)
Its always easy to pick you some things that are worse. But the UK train system was terrible and getting more terrible constantly year after year with total stagnation of new lines and other advancements.

You can just as easily point to a number of other metrics that 'private' or whatever you want to call it British system has actually improved.

The people dislike of anything to do with privatization ends up people and journalist just looking for the problems. But the problems they find are not actually that much worse then the problems they had before.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by C1sc0cat on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:14AM (#19270308)
And when franchises change the outgoing franchisee just milks it for the last two years or so - which lead to the complete fracking disaster of the thames link.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by james1071 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:52AM (#19270980)
What you said about the water companies is not correct. They are regulated on the basis of price - the regulator sets a pricing formula for the industry RPI + X (i.e. X is the annual price increase above inflation).

There are no caps on profit.

The reason why companies carry large amounts of debt is that debt finance is much cheaper than equity. Given that a utility has stable cashflows, it makes sense for it to use a high proportion of debt finance.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by ownagefool on Thursday February 28, 2019 @11:07AM (#19272324)
Fair enough, I defer to somebody who obviously knows more. I admit I likely conflated several industries anyway ( I believe rail is on a 4% cap). However, there still seems to be questions around the debt, divididends, and asking Government for investment.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-41152516

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/aug/03/water-...

https://www.ft.com/content/5878de66-9c7d-11e7-8cd4-932067fbf...

Now obviously we live in a country of outrage, and fairly poor reporting, but the reporting does make it seem like we regularly get privatised profits and socialised losses.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by acchow on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:29AM (#19269405)
Hong Kong's is profitable mostly because it is run as a real estate company. They acquire land before adding a metro station and then lease/sell the valuable land after adding the station.

Why don't other cities do this?

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by distances on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:15AM (#19269599)
I think all land within city limits should be publicly acquired with eminent domain before zoning and building of utilities. No reason to let the land value increase fall to private landowners when it's all due to build-up of public services. Better use the profits for maintaining the services.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by mcv on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:39AM (#19270166)
That's roughly the case in Amsterdam. All land is technically owned by the city, and homeowners lease it for 50 years. When the lease will run out is always a detail to pay attention to when buying a home.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by distances on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:41PM (#19274376)
That's actually a great way to address this somewhat fairly. I just hope this would be more widespread. Here the city owns large parts and rents the land out with up to 100 year contracts, but lots of the land is also just privately owned.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by C1sc0cat on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:16AM (#19270322)
Leases that short must make getting a mortgage hard.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by mcv on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:21AM (#19270348)
When the lease is about to run out, it means you need to reserve money for that, meaning the price of the house will be lower. I think you can still use the mortgage to pay for that lease. So overall it doesn't make much difference, it's just an extra thing to pay attention to, or you'll end up with unexpected costs.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by icebraining on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:10AM (#19270532)
If the lease is set to expire in twenty years, can you know in advance how much it will cost to renew, so that you can include it in the mortgage?

If so, then it doesn't really seem to help the city to capture the gains that may have accrued over those years. If not, what happens if the lease now costs much more and you can't afford it? Do you get kicked out of the house?

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by mcv on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:34AM (#19270891)
I think the cost of the lease depends on an estimated value of the house. So if the lease expires soon, you can fairly accurately estimate what it's going to cost. If it expires in 20 years, it depends on what your house is going to be worth in 20 years.

There are also arrangements where you pay this lease every month or every year, rather than paying it off for 50 years at once. If you can't afford to pay the whole thing at once, you can probably take a mortgage to pay for it, but you may also be able to switch to a monthly or yearly payment system.

This estimated value of the house (the WOZ value) is also used for property taxes and you can appeal the estimate if you think it's wrong.

In any case, it ensures that the city benefits to some degree from the rising value of the land.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by falsedan on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:19AM (#19270827)
In the UK, usually you negotiate for the occupier to refresh the lease before concluding the sale. After 50 years, you'll probably be dead so you don't have to worry about lease renewal (in the UK the standard leasehold is 99 years, so you'll definitely be dead by then).

If you were due for a renewal, and you didn't have the funds to pay the fee, you'd remortgage. If you were very wise, you'd take out an insurance policy when you moved in to pay for it.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by GordonS on Sunday March 03, 2019 @09:29AM (#19294572)
Aren't leaseholds pretty rare in the UK? I'm in Scotland, but I don't think I've ever come across a leasehold property here.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by C1sc0cat on Thursday February 28, 2019 @08:19AM (#19271114)
It effects the value of your estate and you wont get a mortgage on a short lease very easily.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by falsedan on Friday March 01, 2019 @05:40AM (#19279379)
In the UK, this part:

> In the UK, usually you negotiate for the occupier to refresh the lease before concluding the sale

is a requirement your mortgage lender will impose. Yes, it puts a burden of a few hundred pounds of solicitor's fees + lease renewal to get the leasehold reset when your executors/inheritors dispose of the property.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by mcv on Thursday February 28, 2019 @10:05AM (#19271764)
It's also not necessary for a short lease. If you're going to pay every month or every year, a mortgage is pointless. If you want to pay it off for 50 years, that's when you're probably going to need a mortgage.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by C1sc0cat on Thursday February 28, 2019 @08:18AM (#19271111)
In the Uk you wont get a mortgage on a short lease
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @09:06AM (#19271369)
A land value tax would sort this out. Build a new train station (crossrail was a massive subsidy to land owners[0]), land price increases, more is raised in tax, which pays for the infrastructure.

On the other hand, build a new bypass, land prices drop, and nearby land owners get compensation for their inconvenience.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/mar/18/house-prices...

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by titanix2 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:33AM (#19270148)
Because it's not East-Asia. It works in HK, Japan, Taiwan or others countries because a train station increase value of the surroundings but in France a train station is a place you want to avoid, especially at night. In any city of a respectable size this is where you have you have a lot of beggars, thieves etc. trying to extorts you cigarettes and money. It is even worse for women that get everything of that plus sexual harassement (and it's not from native French).
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by ReptileMan on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:10AM (#19270531)
I don't know. Securing a city is not that hard. East Asia is not some crime free utopia. So it boils down to lack of political will.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @09:12AM (#19271395)
I was shocked by how bad the metro stations were in Paris at night, I changed somewhere in the central zone and it was a right dive. I've never seen a London tube station, or Manchester metrolink, anywhere near as bad as Paris metro ones.

No harassment, just homeless people pissing on the platforms etc.

Paris is a dive though, give me Berlin, Munich, Rome, Prague, etc any day.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by adrianN on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:14AM (#19270546)
That seems to be a problem that can be fixed with some security guards.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by icebraining on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:08AM (#19270772)
Not really. This kind of low-key theft and coercion are hard to catch in the act. You can criminalize loitering and begging itself, but that's problematic, plus rife for discriminatory abuse. Finally, even if you do catch them, the low amounts in question usually mean they'll spend a few hours at a police station, and then they'll go back.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by agumonkey on Wednesday February 27, 2019 @11:25PM (#19268939)
The sad part seems to be that:

- track maintenance is lacking (at least by journalism investigation reports)

- regional lines have shrunk, causing systemic back pressure on cars (partly fueling the yellow vest protests)

I love the new TGV (regen braking) but it seems that holistically it's not a sure bet for the whole nation:

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by benj111 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @03:03AM (#19269798)
"SNCF is fiddling with the wrong things. It doesn't need to separate train operations from rail track network maintenance. It doesn't need to open up the network to competition"

I'm guessing this is being imposed on SNCF by national and European government.

In their defence they seem to be doing the right things. They're preparing for competition by lowering their costs etc.

The proposed system of giving each region the power to grant a monopoly seems a bit ill considered though.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by pathseeker on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:04AM (#19269290)
>That's what "public" means.

No, that's not what that means. "public" is just the only place a money-losing venture can continue in perpetuity.

It's very easy for governments to have self-sustaining programs. They are still "public" but they bring in enough money to pay for themselves.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by atoav on Thursday February 28, 2019 @03:37AM (#19269935)
Public means it is a service all citizen (aka the public) should benifit from. That doesn’t mean it is free of some sort of fee (see public libraries), but it also means it must be available to everyone (see public school).

A good public train network returns a lot of money indirectly, because it keeps all sorts of people mobile and therefore makes it easier for them to fill free positions. And in some areas (e.g. in the Alps) a good rail service is a huge multiplicator for tourism which means a whole industry profits from a cheap and well working train network.

The most important aspect of a public transport system is that it works well, is affordable and without disruptive changes can be so in 20 years time. The goal should be to reach these targets with efficiency.

I am not convinced that privatized railways offer any benefit for the public — they tend to grab all sorts of public money while closing lines that leave part of the public isolated, because there is not much profit to be made. In practise this can be observed in multiple nations. And public train networks have competition: busses.

In nations where people don’t rely as much on public transport (e.g. the US) it is only natural to come the conclusion that railways should be lead like private companies. People have cars anyways, gas is cheap, there is no real public transport network you need to compete with.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by otabdeveloper1 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:07AM (#19269565)
> Public rail is a money-losing venture, in every country (except Hong Kong).

Not in Russia. They had a $2 billion profit in 2017. It's also the third-largest rail company in the world, so yes, it can be done.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by speedplane on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:11AM (#19269580)
Not in Amtrak's Northeast corridor either. If Amtrak was run like a business, it could shut down a number of lines and become a cash-cow. But it decisively not run like a business.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by cosmolev on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:29AM (#19269649)
All this profit comes from freight operations. Passenger services are loss making.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by otabdeveloper1 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:49AM (#19270194)
No. Their passenger services had around $100 million in profits, according to their 2017 report.

Much lower margins, of course, but still profitable.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by tasubotadas on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:18AM (#19269608)
How much of that is profit from industrial logistics (read moving oil), and which part of that are revenues from passengers?
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by conjectures on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:35AM (#19270402)
"It doesn't need to separate train operations from rail track network maintenance. It doesn't need to open up the network to competition."

This certainly didn't help in the UK. It's been a shameful saga with multiple failures and no clear rationale. The theory was: privatisation -> ??? -> uber efficiency. Ignoring the fact that the economic theory which usually fills in the ??? requires free entry and exit into the market. That doesn't exist in the case of natural monopolies like rail.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:52AM (#19270698)
Very few people don't take rail for the fun of it.

People take rail to go somewhere, therefore the market is transport.

The options for say Glasgow to London are

Drive Coach (2 operators (national express, megabus) Fly (2 operators I think) Train (2 operators)

That's 7 different options, each has pros and cons

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by icebraining on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:38AM (#19270415)
Assuming the railway itself is public and shared, as in this case, how is rail a natural monopoly?
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by jnty on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:00AM (#19270488)
A key reason is that off-peak services are often subsidised by on-peak services, so to economically provide a good all-day service the whole thing needs to be provided by the same operator.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by icebraining on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:17AM (#19270564)
No reason to require a single operator, you just need a shared "pot" to move money around. On-peak trains pay into the pot, off-peak trains get money from it.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by makomk on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:55AM (#19270469)
I don't think SNCF have any choice about separating train operations from rail track network maintenance and opening the network up to competition. It's an EU requirement, part of the fourth railway package. That's part of the reason there was talk of the UK not being able to renationalise their railways if we didn't leave the EU - it's increasingly requiring all states to structure their railways more like the UK system (because that worked so great for us!)
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by pbhjpbhj on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:21AM (#19270582)
>That's part of the reason there was talk of the UK not being able to renationalise their railways //

I thought we did effectively renationalise a portion of the network on the East Coast, and it was better [for users] and profitable in some sense [for the exchequer]?

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/oct/26/east-coast-m...

We have a lose-lose system in the UK AFAICT, we have a private system, and we subsidise it from taxation. So private companies get paid dividends, that they didn't earn, from tax money and we still get a fragmented and under-invested system.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @09:13AM (#19271403)
> profitable in some sense

East coast made £100m a year for the exchequer Stagecoach promised £400m for the exchequer

Clearly the latter is better for the exchequer, it means more subsidy can be spent on other areas of the network.

The problem is that Grayling let stagecoach off their promises, undermining the whole point of privatization.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by m0zg on Friday March 01, 2019 @05:39AM (#19279371)
I wanted to travel by rail from Zurich to Paris earlier this year, and as it happens, ended up in Zurich when SNCF was on strike. So I wasn't sure if I'd be able to get back in time and had to cancel the trip. From what I hear this happens relatively frequently there. A train which you're not sure if it runs our not on any given day has somewhat limited utility IMO.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by kmlx on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:02AM (#19270501)
> It doesn't need to open up the network to competition.

What about Japan? Aren't they running the best rail network in the world with 0 subsidies?

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by mcny on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:01AM (#19270724)
I think New York needs to:

1. Cut costs. Lay off workers where possible. Cut wages and salaries across the board.

2. Increase taxes. There just isn't enough money. I've seen a lot of people jump the turnstile.

I think we can't emulate Japan's model in the US. Japan is very homogeneous from what I can tell. We are decidedly not. Any attempt to strict enforcement will lead to hiring people who are attracted to such jobs and think it is their duty to rid society of "scum".

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by peterbraden on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:00AM (#19270723)
SBB in Switzerland is also profitable
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by hestefisk on Thursday February 28, 2019 @07:23AM (#19270841)
And they have nice high speed trains too. And reasonable prices for residents. It runs like a (Swiss) clockwork.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by iagooar on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:45AM (#19270181)
> cut the number of excessive public sector workers

I remind you, that we're talking about France here, where firing people is very, very hard. And we're talking public sector here, which would be a huge offense there. Protests would be massive.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by iagooar on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:55AM (#19270470)
Why is this getting down voted? Did I say something wrong? Not saying I don't agree with what the author suggested.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by simula67 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:47AM (#19269219)
> Public rail is a money-losing venture, in every country (except Hong Kong). That's what "public" means. But it's important to have

Why ? I wish connectivity to airports here in India would improve and railways would just die

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by pas on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:57AM (#19269262)
Why important? Because public rail makes it possible to connect city centers. Airports are biiiiiiig, noisy, airplanes pollute a lot, and take off and landing is slow. Sure, planes are faster than trains, but they are a lot less efficient.

Yes, it's hard to manage, yes it needs "roads" (tracks), whereas planes have the air, but planes are very much a luxury.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by adrianN on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:25AM (#19269382)
For many connections that are less than 500km or so apart, a train is faster than a plane. A good rail network also connects smaller towns that don't have an airport. It can also be used to transport goods. All these uses would have to be replaced by cars and trucks if you'd only focus on planes, that's not very good for the environment.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by lultimouomo on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:39AM (#19269454)
Also, a 4 hour travel door-to-door on a plane means:

* Half an hour to go to the airport

* Half an hour passing security and waiting for boarding

* 20 minutes between boarding and stable flight when you can start working on your laptop

* One hour and 40 minutes when you can work cramped in a noisy environment with terrible air quality

* 15 minutes descent and landing

* 15 minutes deboarding and getting out of the airport

* Half an hour to get where you need to be

Same trip by train:

* Half an hour till you are on the train

* 3 hours working comfortably in a usually bigger space with ground level air pressure and very little noise

* Half an hour to get where you need to be.

Travel in reasonably modern trains is by far the best kind of business travel you can have today, IMO.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by pmontra on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:04AM (#19269556)
> Half an hour passing security and waiting for boarding

Only 30 minutes sounds optimistic. You also didn't count the time to recover luggage. I've seen people bringing huge suitcases on high speed trains. They couldn't take them in cabin on a flight. Planes are good past the 2 hours flight time IMHO, or across countries where there are no interconnected high speed networks (I'm writing this with Europe in mind.)

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by divbyzer0 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:25AM (#19270118)
My experience with heavy luggage on the French TVG was positive and so efficient Il Duce would be jealous.

My ticket told me where to stand on the platform. When the train pulled to a precise location, I did not have to move any distance. One door for boarding, one for deboarding, passengers did not bump or block each other. Luggage storage located immediately inside train, pass a sliding door to my assigned seat.

The train seemed to stop for less than a minute, we were moving before I took my seat.

No security in boarding station (Morliax), a little over 3 hrs to Paris, 450km as the crow flies.

Perhaps our French colleagues could chime in and let us know if this is a typical experience.

Baggage security in France and other EU countries is quite efficient, not everyone carries bags.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by isostatic on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:55AM (#19270710)
I used to live a 7 minute taxi from Manchester airport. I would usually aim to arrive 30 minutes before wheelsup. It it took longer than 5 minutes from taxi to boarding it was unusual.

In the rare occasions I checked luggage I'd arrive about t-45 and have a beer in the lounge.

Never missed a flight. To get to west london it was far faster than the train and tube, although most of the time I was changing at Heathrow onto a longer distance flight.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by Symbiote on Thursday February 28, 2019 @11:36AM (#19272589)
And your children will hate you for it.

(i.e. the climate.)

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by riffraff on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:01AM (#19269544)
With fast trains, even >500km is better than airplanes, since you go from city center to city center and don't have to be at the airport in advance.

In Italy, the Milan-Rome (570km, 2.5/3 hours) fast trains have been making a killing for years.

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by jaclaz on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:16PM (#19272948)
Sure, but the situation - bar a few "main" cities is far from being "good".

The maps on the ESPON project are interesting in this regard:

http://mapfinder.espon.eu/?page_id=31&category-name=115&proj...

Though I seem not being able to find a more recent version of this "classic" anamorphic (deformed) map (I find these the easier way to visualize the abnormalities in connections):

https://calomelano.it/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/05_populati...

Re:France’s new high-speed trains by ehmorris on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:52AM (#19269247)
I believe the Hong Kong metro owns and leases the land on top of its stations.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains by pas on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:58AM (#19269267)
Also, density. Amtrak [and other big country networks] also has money making routes, but that money is nothing when it comes the losses that need to be offset on the other routes.