Very few people don't take rail for the fun of it.
People take rail to go somewhere, therefore the market is transport.
The options for say Glasgow to London are
Drive Coach (2 operators (national express, megabus) Fly (2 operators I think) Train (2 operators)
That's 7 different options, each has pros and cons
Re:France’s new high-speed trains
by icebraining on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:38AM
(#19270415)
Assuming the railway itself is public and shared, as in this case, how is rail a natural monopoly?
A key reason is that off-peak services are often subsidised by on-peak services, so to economically provide a good all-day service the whole thing needs to be provided by the same operator.
Re:France’s new high-speed trains
by icebraining on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:17AM
(#19270564)
No reason to require a single operator, you just need a shared "pot" to move money around. On-peak trains pay into the pot, off-peak trains get money from it.
This certainly didn't help in the UK. It's been a shameful saga with multiple failures and no clear rationale. The theory was: privatisation -> ??? -> uber efficiency. Ignoring the fact that the economic theory which usually fills in the ??? requires free entry and exit into the market. That doesn't exist in the case of natural monopolies like rail.