Thanks, I just spat coffee up a wall!
Well, the same goes for roads. Some people don't even have a car, and wealthy people move around a lot more in cars.
But it turns out wealthy people do a lot more of a lot of things, especially move around, because they have money to do so.
And were travel cheaper probably more people would do so.
So, taxpayers basically pay for the ability to have a network that allows them to travel a bit.
In some countries low income folks get cheaper tickets. Also high income folk pay a lot more taxes.
All in all, it'd be great to merge the high speed rail and ordinary road bus networks, and just maintain and subsidize that one, and have more socially fair pricing.
As an Austrian in Germany who used trains regularily to go back and forth I can assure you that it is not rare to see workers in full clothes with toolboxes and stuff in trains. Most regular people look like office workers, families and you will always spot a few upper class managment people.
The mixture depends entirely on your timing. If you use the train only during the holidays or weekends, you might get a very distorted image of who uses these trains on a day to day basis.
But trains as a mode of transportation for the wealthy? Might be that way in the UK (I wasn’there a lot), but certainly not in the other parts of Europe.
In Germany and Austria you will see a mix of people that sort of represents the society as a whole (in terms of wealth.
In the rest of the country, I've never felt surrounded by wealth on trains. Mostly it just seemed like the same mix of regular people you'd see anywhere.
Manchester to London doesn't receive subsidies, it makes a lot of money which is plumbed back into (for example) the south wales valleys lines
South West Rail for all those affulent bankers going into London also makes a profit that's reinvested in say services in Cornwall
> Rail travel is inherently more expensive than other modes and always will be, due to the massive infrastructure cost.
That's not nescersarilly true, I suspect you aren't accounting for externalities like polution, the military cost of oil, etc.
Really this is a "yes and" situation. We should also have decent low-cost buses, which in the UK are only available in London, Edinburgh and a few other places.
Going by air is an alternative to rail for some journeys [eg within UK] too. Edinburgh-London for example.
There's about 12,600 train seats
How do you propose to fit in another 145 flights a day between the two cities?
You're right re city centers, perhaps I gave a bad example - in UK for longer journeys I like the train but flying is superior (for my use-case) usually - cheaper, faster.
I think they should use subsidy to make shorter local journeys free or very cheap. Include bus travel also. Ramp up the prices on longer journeys. They could also help out regional airlines to take strain of the rail network.
Why should taxpayers subsidise a mode of travel that is inherently used primarily by the wealthy?