News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by the_clarence on Saturday November 17, 2018 @03:05AM (#18474548)
The new generations in Europe bother less and less to get a driver’s license. Most of my friends don’t have one. Public transport is that good.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by dorfsmay on Saturday November 17, 2018 @09:05AM (#18475565)
Where do you live? My experience is that the better transport a city has, the more expensive living in that city is, and middle class people are pushed to the suburbs where transportation take a long time to take you to work and you need a car to go shopping and activities.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by candiodari on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @11:45AM (#18503943)
Plus it is common knowledge that this graph seems to match almost perfectly with the massive prolonged economic crisis in Italy.

Somehow that seems to totally escape everyone here.

It is also common wisdom that gasoline demand growth (and more generally energy growth) is the most direct and reliable indicator of economic trouble, more so than any other (mostly because governments "change" (a cynic would say falsify) essentially all other indicators).

And lo an behold ! This matches the data in other sources:

https://www.google.com.au/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f...

https://www.google.com.au/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f...

(note that the last graph is without taking inflation into account, so the real "zero" level is somewhere between 1.5 and 2.5% at the moment and therfore hasn't seen a single year of real economic growth since 2000 or so, and has had a few years of double digit "real" declines)

So I think we can safely conclude that the real issue is that Italy has seen a very long an disastrous economic recession, and that they are in fact not buying a lot of electrical cars.

This is also very much not a positive evolution. This is going to have cost a LOT of Italians a LOT of quality of life.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by charlesdm on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:22AM (#18475021)
This depends on the country you're in. If you're living in a large city such as London, Berlin or Paris -- sure.

But try living in Belgium, a bit more rural Germany or the Netherlands (perhaps with the exception of Amsterdam) and things are definitely less accessible if you want to get out of the city for a bit.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by phicoh on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:24AM (#18475265)
It's a different pattern of living. If you mostly use a car then you know about highways, traffic jams, parking, etc.

If you mainly use public transports, then you know what places are easily reached that way, when the last train, bus, etc. goes in the evening.

There is stuff that is hard to do with public transport (be in the middle of nowhere early in the morning) and there is stuff that is hard to do with a car (go out drinking in a city center).

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by CM30 on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:16PM (#18478329)
Even in London this is very area specific. Sure, virtually no one will recommend driving in central London, so if you're visiting the city/square mile, you're probably going to take public transport (due to traffic jams, the congestion charge, maze like street layouts, difficulty parking, etc).

But outside of it, many parts of London will have people drive all over the place. If you're in Havering or Barking and Dagenham or other areas on the perimeter of London, a car is basically seen as mandatory for anyone over 16 or so.

I suspect it's partly cultural too; a lot of the Hacker News/Reddit user/cosmopolitian 'liberal' mindset becomes a lot less common outside of tech hubs and densely populated urban areas.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by Balero on Sunday November 18, 2018 @04:54AM (#18479602)
The driving age for cars is 17 in the UK.

I also disagree that anywhere in London requires a car. And doubly that anyone from the perimeter requires a car early on. I know many people who lived in these areas and did not learn to drive.

Smaller towns and rural areas in the UK do require having a car to live effectively in.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by Jaruzel on Sunday November 18, 2018 @08:36AM (#18480302)
Pull up a map of Greater London, and look at Biggin Hill (very south part of the map). There's no train or tube out here, and the bus routes basically run North and South requiring at least a change to get anywhere useful. We are INSIDE London, and part of a London Borough, having a car here is almostly mandatory if you actually want to get anywhere in a timely manner, or if you work in central London. It 's ridiculous as we're only 20ish miles from Westminster as the crow flies.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by Balero on Sunday November 18, 2018 @03:16PM (#18482298)
What are you talking about! You just walk to the airport and fly straight to London city!

But in all seriousness, that does look pretty poorly connected, but it also looks like the only place. Some people I know from Slough, Kew, and Watford all don't know how to drive, and none seems to have suffered from it.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by Jaruzel on Monday November 19, 2018 @10:28AM (#18487050)
> You just walk to the airport and fly straight to London city!

It's about £650 for a one-way helicopter trip from the airport to a City based helipad. I do it every day... XD

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by maxerickson on Saturday November 17, 2018 @10:40AM (#18475911)
My experience in the Netherlands was that the railways connected all the major cities and stopped at lots of towns and villages between them.

And then there are segregated bike routes all over the place, in addition to lots of on road accommodations.

Do you just not think anywhere there is "out of the city"?

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by ollysb on Saturday November 17, 2018 @09:27AM (#18475634)
> things are definitely less accessible if you want to get out of the city for a bit.

You can always rent a car when you want one. Just checked some prices and in the off season here in Barcelona you can pick up a car for $1/day...

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by IkmoIkmo on Tuesday November 20, 2018 @07:36AM (#18493364)
That's just nonsense, you can't.

Feel free to add a source that is transparent about all non-fuel costs.

There's tons of false advertising, e.g. rent a car for 1 euro a day (service charge), but also pay a maintenance charge, an insurance charge, a monthly membership fee etc etc.

For example I have a 3 euro a day rental, but I also pay monthly.

Typically cars will cost about 30-35 euros or so per day, for the cheapest ones, with possibilities here and there to do 15-20 in certain seasons under limited conditions.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by olalonde on Saturday November 17, 2018 @12:22PM (#18476389)
I have a time believing that figure... Where did you get it from?
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by maccard on Saturday November 17, 2018 @03:06PM (#18477105)
I can't confirm OPs number but I have in the past hired a car for less than 6 euro a day in Ireland.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by omnimus on Sunday November 18, 2018 @04:35AM (#18479554)
The problem is these prices are trap. I think its a big risk since the car is not covered - if anything happens to it (somebody crashes into you or even malfunction) then you pay for it.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by eMSF on Saturday November 17, 2018 @01:10PM (#18476604)
Not without a license.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by thepangolino on Saturday November 17, 2018 @03:45AM (#18474646)
Not necessarily. Some cities still have fairly bad public transport. Using the car just happens to be worse.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by jsemrau on Saturday November 17, 2018 @04:47AM (#18474809)
Anecdotal evidence, I just came back from Munich and compared to Singapore vehicular traffic is much worse.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by jmiserez on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:25AM (#18475028)
While Singapore public transport is good and taxis are reliable, they also make it very expensive for people to own a car, and the total number is restricted.

See here for numbers: https://dollarsandsense.sg/complete-guide-buying-car-singapo...

Their example car worth 50'000S$ (~36'000 USD) will end up costing 160'000S$ (116'000 USD) total.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by charlesdm on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:35AM (#18475066)
Still cheaper than most Scandinavian countries!
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by htgb on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:44AM (#18475109)
What on earth do you mean with that? Seems to be around 40k USD in Sweden, and I've never before heard of any rumor that cars would be an unaffordable luxury in Scandinavia.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by analyzethis on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:42AM (#18475479)
Hint: Scandinavia is not a country. Cars are cheap in Sweden compared with Denmark, for instance.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by charlesdm on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:05AM (#18475186)
How much would, say a new Audi A4, cost you in Sweden?

Singapore is expensive because of the additional taxes that get added on to the base price. From what people (on HN in fact) have told me most Scandinavian countries levy significant extra taxes on car purchases.

So the $40k car might actually only be $15 to 20k in other countries such as Germany and Belgium?

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by pathseeker on Saturday November 17, 2018 @09:32AM (#18475648)
But neither of those ranges are near the $160k in Singapore.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by jeroen on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:18PM (#18477921)
Starting prices for a Volvo V60, in euros:

The Netherlands: 36,500 Belgium: 35,000 Germany: 37,500 Sweden: 31,000

These may not be exactly comparable feature-wise, but those extra taxes don't seem to have a big impact.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by EastLondonCoder on Saturday November 17, 2018 @10:18AM (#18475835)
As other people are mentioning it depends what country in Scandinavia. Sweden is not super expensive. Norway is very expensive but on the other hand they have excellent subsidies for electric cars: https://www.theguardian.com/money/2018/jul/02/norway-electri...
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by skrause on Saturday November 17, 2018 @05:19AM (#18474864)
But still the total number of cars e.g. in Germany has been rising in the last few years: http://www.geodaten.guetersloh.de/umweltdaten/umweltd/daten/...

The only decline in car ownership was in 2008, and that was because of the financial crisis, not because of great public transport (which has actually been getting worse in my city in the last few years). The story that people are giving up cars in masses is mostly a myth, even though it might look like that if you live in certain bubbles in the largest cities.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by wongarsu on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:10AM (#18474988)
If a middle income family gets a second and sometimes even third car that doesn't necessarily translate into a proportional increase in kilometres driven.

If enough families get additional cars that could also easily offset whatever young people are doing. It's more complex than "there are more cars, thus people giving up cars is not a trend"

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by ineedasername on Saturday November 17, 2018 @10:17AM (#18475824)
But are middle class families getting second and third cars at higher rates? It's a plausible explantion if true, but I haven't seen any evidence of it.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by rsync on Saturday November 17, 2018 @11:03AM (#18476011)
"If a middle income family gets a second and sometimes even third car that doesn't necessarily translate into a proportional increase in kilometres driven."

True, but the embedded carbon cost of each additional vehicle is roughly equal to 10-12 years of driving that vehicle.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by D_Alex on Sunday November 18, 2018 @10:42AM (#18480836)
> the embedded carbon cost of each additional vehicle is roughly equal to 10-12 years of driving that vehicle

This is not really true, though you can adopt certain extreme assumptions that would support such a claim.

Using statistically average assumptions (12 tonnes of embedded carbon/"average" car, 180 g CO2/km, 14,000 km/year) results in DIRECT CO2 emissions from burning the fuel alone to be roughly equal to 5 years of use.

But to get a like for like comparison, you should add the embedded emissions in producing the fuel, car service and maintenance, accidents, infrastructure costs etc... under such considerations the embedded carbon cost of the vehicle will roughly equal to 2-3 years of use.

FWIW.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by your-nanny on Saturday November 17, 2018 @01:18PM (#18476640)
new vehicle. but used? lots of second cars are beaters. does demand in the used market induce manufacture of more cars? hard to see how.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by petre on Saturday November 17, 2018 @12:16PM (#18476367)
Don't worry. It eventually gets sold to less fortunate people second hand.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by sisidjdif on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:36AM (#18475310)
While I agree that it’s mostly a myth I’d like to add to wongaru; we’re a one car family (my wife works at home). I flirt with the idea of being a two car family but we’d barely use the extra car.

On the other hand, if there was a way for me to get to work with public means, I’d do it (28 miles/day commute) I’d still keep my car and still flirt with the idea of having an extra beater (I.e an extra car for the wife) lying around for weekends [1]

I wor the day that I loose my ICE car though. The ICE car, if terrible, is one of the most important tools for the maintenance d liberty (with no AI, of course). As an example, the pentagon papers would not have been published (and therefore hasten the end of the Vietnam war) if not for the mighty station wagon.

[1] when you have kids having either parent able to take the kid out to an event and maintain the other’s ability to go to stores quickly is a massive increase in flexibility.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by ced on Saturday November 17, 2018 @11:30AM (#18476126)
Eh, that is certainly true in the suburbs, but we live in the city with a child and no car. We can buy 99% of what we want within walking distance. Bigger items we would have delivered. If I had a driving license (which I would if it wasn't such a costly hassle in my province), I would rent a car occasionally. Metro + bus + walk + bike in the summer is completely fine otherwise.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by pjc50 on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:22AM (#18475419)
I suspect that's an inequality thing - more people with second or third cars, not a growth in the number of households with a car.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by gambiting on Saturday November 17, 2018 @02:12PM (#18476886)
I absolutely disagree with the conclusion. I live in the UK and my friends who don't own a car mostly don't have one because it's so stupidly expensive to own one. None of them say they prefer to sit on the bus for an hour instead of a 30 minute drive, no matter how nice the bus is.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by longerthoughts on Saturday November 17, 2018 @02:27PM (#18476937)
>None of them say they prefer to sit on the bus for an hour instead of a 30 minute drive

Nobody suggested this. The point is that when public transit is effective, it becomes more attractive because of the cost savings relative to owning a car. In the absence of effective public transit, commuters will still tend to buy cars regardless of the expense because they don’t have a good alternative.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by stiGGG on Sunday November 18, 2018 @03:38AM (#18479410)
From my experience in Berlin it’s more like sitting 20 minutes in the underground, instead of 30 minutes sitting in the car if you include finding a parking lot.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by em-bee on Sunday November 18, 2018 @07:31AM (#18480047)
i do. on the bus i can read, reply to messages or even sleep. if i had a car, i'd have to pay attention to traffic.

it's half an hour wasted vs an hour doing something productive.

greetings, eMBee.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by gambiting on Sunday November 18, 2018 @10:09AM (#18480659)
If driving means being home with your kids 30 minutes earlier, then being productive on the bus means absolutely nothing in comparison. Besides, I like to listen to podcasts/audio books while driving, so it's not completely wasted time.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by miluge on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:09AM (#18474985)
I lost mine in France when I was 21 ( got it at 18yo ), I'm 27 now and just starting again you can travel Europe quite easily the big problem where I live now is I need it more and more due to work.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by chrisseaton on Saturday November 17, 2018 @03:44AM (#18474643)
Do most of your friends live in cities?

How do your french friends in the rural countryside manage without cars?

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by BorisEm on Saturday November 17, 2018 @04:38AM (#18474781)
Young people living in the country side of France all get their driver’s license as soon as possible.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by usrusr on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:21AM (#18475018)
They move to the city. I wonder how much of that gasoline use reduction is simply a consequence of ever higher urbanisation.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by CydeWeys on Saturday November 17, 2018 @10:37AM (#18475900)
Not many people live in the rural countryside, and those that do likely still need cars.

And yeah, it's very common for someone who lives in the city themselves to have all of their friends also live in the city. Not many young adults out in the boonies, plus how would you ever meet and become friends with them in the first place if you couldn't get there?

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by the_clarence on Sunday November 18, 2018 @09:55AM (#18480619)
Some of them got their driver license early, some of them had their parents do most of their driving until they moved to the city.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by jordanbeiber on Saturday November 17, 2018 @03:52AM (#18474665)
Isn’t urbanization a thing?
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by iwiririwo on Saturday November 17, 2018 @04:37AM (#18474777)
As in "people moving to the city", it is. But in my area, the city density never reaches a level where anything except the car is really convenient. Sure you can take the bus. If you're back home at 11, willing make a 15 minute ride an hour's, and pay the same as for a cheap car.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by freeflight on Saturday November 17, 2018 @05:38PM (#18477730)
This is really an issue of the quality of public transport and general infrastructure. Southern Germany, Bavaria, has a very good railway system.

Even the regional railway lines often get you faster where you need to go than a car would, especially during rush hours.

There's also the rarely mentioned factor of parking space becoming increasingly harder to find and more expensive in city centers. In my region, this is being solved by building affordable, or even free, parking decks near subway stations on the fringes of the city.

But even with that the parking situation still remains tense.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by jordanbeiber on Saturday November 17, 2018 @04:53AM (#18474821)
Fair enough. But as a whole the people of the world move together in ever exanding lumps.

One (there are many pros and cons) slightly positive side effect is that efficency have to increase. It’s unavoidable as humans in general seems to have a will to survive.

What seems to slow it down is mainly an unbridled capitalism, which is why for example China in a weird and somewhat unexpected fashion leads the way.

EV’s are not only more energy efficient, they also have a positive impact when it comes to proximity pollution.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by chrisseaton on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:09AM (#18474986)
I don't understand what you mean by saying that.

Do you think nobody lives in the countryside any more? Do you think the next generation will permanently live in cities? Who do you think will grow your food and look after your open spaces?

My point was the author of my parent comment probably has a very skewed view of the need for cars, if all their friends are young metropolitan professionals.

They have a blind spot to the needs of a lot of other people.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by LaGrange on Saturday November 17, 2018 @11:43AM (#18476194)
> Do you think nobody lives in the countryside any more?

Less and less people. Pretty much all of my extended family moved out two decades ago, for example, and several no longer live in the countryside because their region is no longer countryside.

And AFAIR France at least a few years ago had a problem with farmer solitude stemming from this, and ultimately from farm automation.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by jordanbeiber on Saturday November 17, 2018 @10:43AM (#18475926)
My point was that on the whole this is what has been going on. Round the world.

In the context of the thread and with my own situation in mind I’m not surprised that the demand for oil to support public transport is decreasing.

I’m with you that the car is going nowhere!

I think we just missunderstood each other a little bit.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by dorgo on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:27AM (#18475047)
>Who do you think will grow your food and look after your open spaces?

Robots, i hope.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by pathseeker on Saturday November 17, 2018 @09:38AM (#18475670)
>Robots, i hope.

Funny, I have the opposite dream for technology where it alleviates the need to pack in as tightly as possible into cities for no particular purpose other than a job. While some people do truly love the city for the density and variety of amenities (I did when I was young), many people are forced to go there because that's where the good jobs are. This is made obvious by the number of people willing to commute an hour in from suburbs.

Ideally the only people living in high density are people who want that, which could easily be enabled by technology (remote working).

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by chrisseaton on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:38AM (#18475081)
That's not remotely realistic any time soon.

We can't all move into the cities and leave the countryside as a wasteland. Many people want to live there, and we need people to live there to keep the spaces living and working.

I worry that many people in tech have never spent any time outdoors and have no appreciation of nature at all.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by Brakenshire on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:59AM (#18475535)
It is already true that robots grow our food, the labour productivity for food production is orders of magnitude higher than 100-200 years ago, huge tracts of land that previously required hundreds or even thousands of workers are now managed by a handful of people and their machines. That process in a way has already happened. And it is already the case that most career opportunities (and a high percentage of young people) are in the cities.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by petre on Saturday November 17, 2018 @12:35PM (#18476452)
Not a wasteland, just sparsely populated like Isaac Asimov's Solaria. Don't worry, the countryside will be just fine without people. Just read The World Without Us.

I guess I'll become an agricultural robot repairman like the guy in Interstellar when I grow older.

Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by RivieraKid on Saturday November 17, 2018 @09:56AM (#18475753)
Public transport.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by dominotw on Saturday November 17, 2018 @10:15AM (#18475817)
Even after they hit 35? Easy to not have a dl when you are young and no kids.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by mschuetz on Saturday November 17, 2018 @04:10PM (#18477423)
Starting with elementary school, they can just take the public transport on their own. Used to do this as a kid in Vienna. For younger kids, cars are defenitely an advantage but I'm seeing more and more parents with their kids on a bike. Either on a childrens backseat, in the front part of a carrier bycicle, or by accompanying them on their own bike.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by dominotw on Monday November 19, 2018 @12:53PM (#18488214)
Thats nice. Americans cities are too cold and not bike friendly for that, unfortunately. Bike friendliness might change( or not) in future tho.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by freeflight on Saturday November 17, 2018 @05:29PM (#18477696)
It's still easy after 35 because nobody is forcing you to have kids.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by dominotw on Monday November 19, 2018 @12:54PM (#18488222)
huh? How is that relevant to the question I asked. Don't have kids because u don't want to get a DL ?
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by blattimwind on Saturday November 17, 2018 @05:49AM (#18474935)
Coincidentally, many of the folks not bothering with a driver's license don't know even the most basic traffic rules, yet move in traffic with their bikes... to their own (and others) detriment.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by usrusr on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:17AM (#18475002)
And yet many of them know more about the rules applying to cycling than most drivers. A cyclist rolling through a red light is fully aware of its meaning, licence or not. Many drivers who cut off a cyclist while turning however seem to have a deeply rooted misbelief that somehow a turning car would have precedence over a cyclist going straight. The licensing requirement is surprisingly ineffective.
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by xiphias2 on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:03AM (#18475366)
Are you talking about a car that is taking over a bicycle before turning, or a bicycle taking over a car from the right in the same lane (which is not allowed)?
Re:Oil Demand for Cars Is Already Falling by usrusr on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:41AM (#18475475)
I'm talking about different lanes