Many people didn't understand their move into MP3 players or mobile phones, either.
If you take a step back, Apple is an "affordable luxury" technology products company with a heavy emphasis on design and user experience.
In the luxury and "affordable luxury" tiers, cars are technology products with a heavy emphasis on design and user experience.
Apple knows that smartphones, as we know them today, are likely to be an anachronism by 2030. The market for transportation is large enough to be interesting as a potential source of revenue when the iPhone cash cow falters.
Apple is extremly skilled at collecting a tons of parts suppliers, giving them extreme specifications while simultaneously buying up their entire output, and creating an incredibly polished product.
The final reason apple is wanting to make a car is driving experience is now largely driven by software. The basic suspension geometry has to be decent and the mechanicals can't leave you stranded, but the basic day to day interaction with your car is now all software. Apple is great at software, they are a software company. None of the car manufacturers are great at software. They have all become good enough to get by. Is there anyone out there who thinks Apple won't blow the auto industry away at simple but powerful UI?
Car manufacturing hasn't been this easy to disrupt since the original brands moved out of sheds in the early 20th century. Tesla has joined the game but is struggling with manufacturing scale, something that has always protected the big car makers. Apple is unbelievably good at manufacturing scale, they have endless cash available, and they have a ton of software components to leverage already in use by hundreds of millions of people. Sounds like a winner to me.
If expected ROI is too low they should return the money to investors (share buyback or dividends) and let investors choose a different investment with better prospects by themselves.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_proble...
Grant the MP3 comparison, though - and that's why I'm trying to understand this. They've got smarter people than me pushing for this.
That said, I do agree the idea that they're fundamentally a company good at making high-tech, well manufactured items cheaper and at a larger scale than anyone else can and extrapolating that to luxury cars as a market is a reasonable and possibly sufficient view of this.
I think it’s only natural that those companies want to get in on the autonomous car industry, at least for the software side. I’m thinking that it might be more likely that companies who do hardware have a greater interest in it, but so far, from the 3 companies with a hardware side; Samsung mainly, but also Apple and Microsoft, only Apple seems to be putting research into autonomous cars. (I have too little knowledge about Huawei and other Chinese companies to know if they have the same possible reasons or approach)
Perhaps driving to work is mostly an American thing and Samsung and Microsoft see the world going more towards increasing remote work, increasing mass transportation.
It’ll be interesting to see the development. Maybe I will still be alive in 30 years to look back on this comment and see what happened.
There should be a startup opportunity for a smart scheduler, combined with voice integration. There are three types of things to listen to (corpuses?): music, a book or similar on tape, or podcasts. If I'm listening to a book, I probably want to continue listening. I want voice recognition to switch between them. 'play abbey road" already works in my car, but I can't continue the book i'm listening to. I can't ask for my usual daily podcasts - marketplace morning report for 5 minutes, then NY Times the daily, maybe a nasa podcast or something about politics, then yesterday's marketplace morning.
The challenges are (1) miniaturizing, (2) input devices and (3) social acceptance, but as far as I can see AR as the universal display technology is inevitable. Not sure though on the time frame and whether it will be glasses, lenses or implants.
https://thebulletin.org/sites/default/files/2018%20Doomsday%...
Today, my Apple Watch, iPhone, and iPad provide different "lenses" on my digital self + my digital stuff. If I run an errand without my phone, I can still make phone calls, text my wife, play my music, etc.
Things like CarPlay, Apple TVs, and HomePods are other lenses. CarPlay happens to need an iPhone now, but something wearable will be enough to power CarPlay at some point. Eventually, cars will have enough native computing power and connectivity that they won't require a proxy device to work.
By 2030 I expect AR smart glasses to be fairly common, hopefully with less-conspicuous options for people who don't need vision correction. Maybe they'll be powerful enough on their own, or work more like CarPlay and require a wearable complement. Additionally, voice user interfaces will continue to evolve and work with all of these lenses.
TLDR: Instead of today's "hero device" model, I think we're moving toward an "many devices" model.
The iPod's simple UI, coupled with easy iTunes integration, made it head and shoulders above the rest... though the first few iterations were quite expensive compared to the competition.
No.
So by definition Apple can’t be behind of nothing.
*Tesla "autopilot" which require all time human supervision clearly doesn’t count as of now.
Conversely if any company brag about it’s leading mastery without delivering this should be considered as a PR stunt until proven otherwise.
It always surprises me when Apple is described that way, this is an oxymoron.
It goes to show how great their PR is.
> It always surprises me when Apple is described that way
I realized this was true when I noticed low wage workers (McDonalds/Dunkin Donuts drive thru staff) on their iPhones and with their Apple Watches on their wrists, folks making right around minimum wage. You might not be able to afford a starter home, or a nice vehicle, or your student loans, but by god all of us could afford an iPhone on a 24 month payment plan (~$20-30/month).
Apple's marketing and brand is invaluable.
That's right, they're going to want to watch movies, play games, and fiddle with apps, preferably on a big screen in their car. And guess who needs to be on those big screens in the car to stay relevant? That's right, carOS needs to be on that big screen in the car, or Apple should just cede the market to Google and accept inevitable irrelevance.
This is an extremely strategic play that will develop over the next 10-20 years as more and more transportation is completely automated and large screens become ubiquitous.
I am a programmer and I would never ever get in a self-driving car if I had a choice. I don't trust other programmers, I don't know if a backdoor has been put in by someone, and I don't want to get into a vehicle that can be hacked.
I believe self-driving cars will be a catastrophic failure.
Then how are you commuting currently? Almost every part of the vehicle is electronically controlled nowadays. All the components are connected - one way or another. So, it's easy to traverse around and make your way to CAN. Once, you are there, you can control the car.
https://www.kaspersky.com/blog/blackhat-jeep-cherokee-hack-e...
And it surely can't disable brakes. It can disable ABS or force it to cycle, turn off power assist, and apply electric parking brake, but brake pedal is still connected to the brakes through some old school hydraulics.
The same applies for power assist - it's quite powerful; steering at high speed is possible but quite hard if it simply turns off; however, if it would be actively working against you (and do it suddenly without any warning), it's likely that you wouldn't be able to turn it back until you'd already smashed into the opposite lane.
You ever look at other drivers when you are stuck in traffic? You will see people looking at their phones. You will see people eating. You will see people shaving. You will see people doing their makeup. You will see people reading books. You will see people with dogs on their laps. And that is just the people who might accidentally kill you due to carelessness. Vehicular suicide is more common than most people expect and there is no telling if you might be collateral damage in one of those collisions.
Self driving cars don't have to be perfect to be dramatically safer than human drivers.
This statement is technically correct, but it severely downplays how close to perfect the autonomous cars have to be to be significantly better than human-driven cars.
If you look at European countries, current statistics are around 2 fatalities per billion km. The US is around twice that number. Either way it's actually a quite safe mode of transportation.
In fact, if you compare it to travelling by train, the average over European train travel over the past decade is around 0.2 deaths per billion passenger km. Trains are driven by professionals, still accidents happen.
In other words, the fatality rate for cars per billion passenger-kilometers is in the same order of magnitude as for trains driven by professional drivers. How much do you really expect autonomous cars to be able to improve on that?
Second of all, I agree a 5x improvement would be impressive. But that's the level of a professional driver on a closed, dedicated track. I don't think autonomous vehicles will reach that level anytime soon.
There was a vid on here recently of the Porsche 919 beating the lap record at the Ring, and one of the comments was "I don't have the balls to drive that fast in a video game" such is the skill level of humans at the wheel-a few to be sure, but still and all there it is.
Here's the vid btw. And it is ridiculous...
+1
The causes of most crashes are human fallibilities that AI doesn't suffer from:
An AI isn't tempted to drive drunk. It isn't distracted by incoming text messages. It doesn't get fatigued after driving for hours late at night. It doesn't suffer from road rage, and it isn't tempted to drive aggressively and take risks because it's running late for work. Just by avoiding these issues you've made driving a lot safer!
An AI also has reaction times that no human can match, has no blind spots and can track other vehicles in 360 degrees at once, and "see" through fog and rain using radar to detect obstacles.
Conversely, some of the things that are easy for humans are also the most difficult for AI to grasp: the social cues that we use to resolve pathing conflicts (eye contact, a wave, a blink of the headlights, etc), or our ability to intuitively predict the behaviour of other road users.
So while we may be some way yet from true, socially-accepted Level 5 autonomy, we're not far at all from semi-autonomous, driver-assistance technologies that significantly improve safety.
And incidentally, many of the human problems are being solved without autonomous driving. Modern cars already have systems to detect that you're falling asleep and pull the car gently over. People are working on in-cabin online breathalyzers, which will detect alcohol in the air and make the driver blow into the straw to verify (s)he's not drunk (just a passenger). Better integration of phones with cars (CarPlay, Android Auto) and voice input will make texting-while-driving less convenient than just talking to the car with your eyes on the road.
Don't get me wrong, many of the new driver assistant safety features are great. Stuff like blind zone warning and auto emergency stop for pedestrians is awesome. But I think where we are now (autonomous highway driving in good conditions) will be the approximately the endpoint for autonomous cars in the foreseeable future. I think none of us will live to see L5 cars (without any steering wheel at all) on the road.
The EU typically cites a value of 0.14 for the EU-28. Numbers are (statistically) worse in the least developed EU members, and better in more developed ones. For example in both the UK and Germany it was 0.06 in the last two year periods I looked at.
So how much can we improve? Well apparently a LOT.
And "buff neck", really? What did that have to do with anything I said, except as a way to shut down the conversation?
It's plainly obvious that a braking system controller software is a very different beast from an autonomous car software, and I have no problem understanding why someone would trust th former and not the latter.
Are you sure? That code is closed source, and the peek behind the curtain we saw with Toyota's investigation did not inspire confidence:
http://www.safetyresearch.net/blog/articles/toyota-unintende...
Even then, it takes very little software to do electric power steering, so I'm not sure how you would consider this at all comparable to autonomous driving.
This is a pretty generous assumption you're granting here.
That's another very generous assumption wrapped in a truism.
I'd say it's one of the more difficult problems problems in the industry, given the billions of dollars poured into it.
Do you use electricity...?
Do you use indoor plumbing...?
All of those things are controlled by ... computers!
It's the same reason there's not an Apple Television, there's an AppleTV - the display doesn't matter, the source does.
That said, I can't map this vision of Apple as a company with too much money to spend looking for new markets with the Apple that can't be bothered to update its desktop computers and who bailed on the wireless router market. If there's any company that has the resources and vision to create the components for an actually useful and productive Connected Home, I would have expected it to be Apple. And I would have thought home servers (in the form of a beefier Mac Mini, maybe) and no-nonsense self-meshing wifi routers (the products they already had) would have been the perfect platform to build on. But they really do seem to have hit some sort of practical limit on how many things they can do at once within their current corporate structure.
Companies like Apple & Google are uniquely suited to this problem just by having lots of talented software engineers who know about artificial intelligence. The fact that it has nothing to do with their existing businesses doesn't matter too much; it might end up being a lot bigger than their existing businesses.
Cars are fashion, and convenience. Even if an uber was cheaper I wouldn't wait 5 minutes for one outside a store.
No need to get a license, no need to do car registration, no need to insure your vehicle, no need to pay attention whilst driving, no need to find parking, no need to refuel/charge, no need to have the car maintained, no such thing as owning a car that has broken down, no need to change a busted tyre, and the list goes on.
You might need to wait a minute or two for the cheaper ride to arrive, though. Time will tell whether that's a bias based on our current context or a natural preference.
Besides, with enough volume, an autonomous vehicle might pick you up faster from a store's exit faster than you can walk through a parking lot to your car.
They are limited by roads and physics so they'll never have a wait time competitive with a car in the parking lot - and that is the killer.
I do see the allure on the economic side so I understand why this vision is being sold to VCs. But it's going to be just another feature the dealer tries to upsell you on.
And if not cost what benefit does it have to take a taxi than my own self driving car? I can't leave my things in it. It won't have my radio stations set the way I want. And every trip I'm faced with the guilt of an explicit dollar value for the trip.
Answers: health care and pharma, finance and real estate, energy and petroleum, government and defense, and transportation.
Of these only transportation and perhaps health care make any sense for Apple, given their core competencies.
Apple is a huge consumer of eco-friendly power and builds farms simply for producing the power it needs with no carbon emissions.
It is in the finance space indirectly by running the app stores, and directly with Apple pay. It's in the health industry by pushing people to collect health data on their phones and watches.
Apple is a big player in real estate markets. That's where it puts stores.
I totally agree with you that those are the big sectors Apple can use to move the needle. My only disagreement is that you think only one is tenable. I think all of them but government/defense are realistic. I don't see a future where Tim Cook lets Apple get into world-building.
But other than that, Apple is already there. Transportation is the straggler.
Do you happen to know how Braeburn compares to other big name funds?
So, it’s both less of a stretch then you might think and less of a gamble than most other companies in this space are making.
The invention of electronics combined with electricity meant that we could augment or replace tools that traditionally were mechanical in nature, and thus required some maintenance by the owner. (A good example being the mechanical wrist watch which transitioned from manual winding to battery power; timekeeping transitioning from mechanical to quartz crystals; and the clock face transitioning from moving hands to LCD).
The invention of general-purpose computing meant that we could slowly tack on "smartness" to new and existing tools that had become electronic.
Apple (originally named Apple Computer) rides on this second shift enabled by the invention of the general-purpose computer -- by using technology to allow us to do more with less.
From my observation of Apple, it appears they view the world exclusively through this lens -- where they completely re-imagine our daily tools to make them more useful, more life-enriching, by putting a general-purpose computer at its core.
In other words, Apple's unstated mission is to enrich lives using technologies we interact with on a daily basis by designing tools with a computer at the core rather than as an afterthought like other manufacturers. In addition, they try to differentiate themselves from everyone else by shipping devices that are not only beautiful to behold but also well-thought out in terms of ease of use. Sometimes they succeed wildly like with the iPhone. Sometimes they don't.
It's well known that he loves cars. Perhaps he's bored and has taken on other projects to keep him at Apple (designing the new campus, Apple car).
hah. jokes aside, they develop a lot of low-level electronics and operating systems. and they have an AI with arguably the largest voice training. And they have Maps, with lots of real-world travel data. They know which roads are the best and the worst to use for a route. They know when traffic is congested. they know where you’ll need to be and where you’ll be leaving from. They know when your kids get off from school and how they look like. Speaking of sensors, their devices have the most advanced sensors. There are so many different kinds of sensors crammed into the iPhoneX. The best self-driving car sensors use IR, and apple’s already using IR on face-ID. I don’t see why they wouldn’t they be able to develop reliable sensor technologies for cars, given enough time. They don’t have to be the first movers. They’re probably just starting now and maturing the self driving tech and will be ready to respond to how the market develops.
Apple partnered with AT&T to get the iPhone out. They could partner with an auto manufacturer for a self driving car.
If they want to stay on top, they need to move on. But to what? Self driving cars seem like they stand a very good chance of being the next huge industry.
There are only so many markets big enough for Apple to consider entering. Cars is one of them.
Banking is another. They're allowing people to pay by phone now through credit cards. One day soon it will be an easy transition to just keeping your money in Apple Bank.
If the defining feature of cars is engine or physical design, Apple doesn't have a chance; it isn't like traditional industrial companies don't have smart and talented engineers - the Apple of cars already happened with Toyota and their inspired manufacturing process. Apple does have a chance if software is the hardest part of designing the car of the future. In a world where Apple fields a good all-round car with great software, and the software notably improves the driving experience in a difficult-to-mimic fashion, then maybe Apple can find a margin.
It is an ambitious play. If they can't differentiate themselves with software it isn't going to be a winner for them. But if they can, it would fit very well with the Apple model of entering a market that was understood to be mature and demonstrating massive profits for well-designed software/hardware combinations. Driving cars in 2018 is like 20c/texts when using the phones of 2006 - if that chore went away, we wouldn't miss it.
If you hop in a self-driving car, then hop out at your destination, the only parts you have connection with is the seating and the software.
That's why Amazon Google and Apple did tablets, home automation, ...
I don't think they seriously think it's the next big thing, but they don't have alternatives to invest in that promise growth.
Cars are such a strong status symbol that Apple can’t resist. If these vehicles become the next huge computing platform, they have no choice.
With Apple's cash reserves, they can afford the risk. The chance of shooting the moon is worth it.
Self-driving cars is a huge business. You could disrupt Uber, Taxis, Trucking and Public transportation in most of the developed world by a single solution. That's a trillion dollar business.
Driverless cars are the only possibility I can think of right now.
My speculation: cars, houses (or likely condos with Apple financing), then communities (like Disney/Celebration) and Cities. All designed by Apple, with everybody living the Apple way.
If market analysts were sane, Apple would've hit the 5 trillion mark a while ago.
But it's a stupefying number that isn't worth talking about. Apple is bad at growth. Apple is very good at profit. To them, that's all that matters, and that's not going to change.
I think we'll never see Apple valued at 5T because Apple will increase buyback programs and go totally private within 10 years. Exactly because they don't want to have to deal with people who talk about a 50 trillion valuation like it's a thing that better happen or else.
At Amazon's P/E, Apple would be worth about $8T. But I don't think "sane analysis" and "Amazon P/E" are a good fit.
> Apple is bad at growth. Apple is very good at profit.
I've been wondering about this for a while, so I finally bothered to look up some numbers:
2004-2017, Amazon revenue grew from $6.92B to $177.87B, at 28% per year: https://www.statista.com/statistics/266282/annual-net-revenu...
During that time, Apple revenue grew from $8.2B to $222.23B, at... 29% a year: https://www.statista.com/statistics/265125/total-net-sales-o...
Obviously, these numbers are quite sensitive to starting and ending points, but to me, it looks like Apple has managed to grow at the same overall rate as Amazon, while being massively more profitable.
Apple destroys almost every other company on the planet in profitability. Amazon owns the market share for online sales and makes almost zero profit. Somehow that gets a better P/E for Amazon than it does Apple.
Anyway, short version, I think people use the word growth in very specifically different ways.
A couple years ago amid reports that project Titan was an gigantic, unfocused clusterfuck, there were rumours of a rift between project lead Steve Zadesky and Jony Ivy backed by a bunch of top engineers about whether to build a more conventional vehicle for private ownership or to work towards an autonomous mobility service, and that they were going in two opposing directions at once, before doing a reboot.
A place where Apple is working hard to improve is maps. Instead of thinking of the self driving car project as something to sell, think of it as powering Apple Maps. Although it's probably cheaper to just pay a bunch of people to drive around the country 24/7/365.
When operating a $200 billion/year business and needing to grow, entering a $X billion/year market will barely move your needle if $X is too small.
There are only so many large consumer industries (current or future) that Apple can pick to enter.
This autonomous stuff is stupid. In the mean time people are buying more new ICE vehicles or a poorly made Tesla as a poor substitute for what they really want - a Tesla running iOS with an Apple logo.
Also probably because they know they can't outcompete actual car makers at making cars.
How much thicker do you think the margins would be on a Ford if it carried an Apple logo and access to their walled garden on the software end?
They've made a trillion dollar business out of small, high-margin electronics that consumers replace every couple year. Most of their products serve to enhance this business model or have high complementarity from a technology standpoint. The self-driving car project feels like an incredibly expensive diversion from this core business with limited technological overlap to their existing product lines. I'm trying not to see this as "Post-Jobs Apple finally jumps the shark," but I'm just not getting what the vision here is.
This isn't snark, by the way - I'd really love to hear a good model for what they're doing.