News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lutorm on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:04AM (#13891376)
This is a reminder that the announcement that you should "keep your seat belt fastened at all times when you're in your seat" isn't just something someone made up. It's a small price to pay in case you ever encounter severe turbulence en route, but it might be one of these things that most people don't realize until it happens to them. Hitting your head against the cabin ceiling can seriously put a damper on your trip.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by taejavu on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:13AM (#13891425)
Yeah I'm pretty sure that's the first rule that goes out the window when you're on a private jet.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:45AM (#13891569)
There's a reason that people with money and power don't always experience good outcomes. Sure, you can do what you like on your jet, and therefore expose yourself to risk that most people never experience. Likewise skiing off-piste or a number of other equally silly activities that you can do, but absolutely shouldn't.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by maaaats on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:45AM (#13892056)
Not sure why you are calling off-piste skiing silly, a rich man sport and something one shouldn't do.

It's an incredible feeling, lots of fun, and if you have to walk up the mountain first it's a nice nature experience as well. Yes, it can be dangerous, but it's a risk you can manage yourself. So it doesn't have to be very dangerous if one follows common advice and also don't ski where there is a high risk of avalanches.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:32AM (#13894718)
Yes, it can be dangerous, but it's a risk you can manage yourself.

Probably what Michael Schumacher thought to himself, back when he could still think.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by maaaats on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:05PM (#13895704)
Everything carries a risk, my point was that off-piste skiing doesn't have to be too much more dangerous than more mundane stuff, like driving a car.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by fulafel on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:11AM (#13891654)
Probably they have a different idea about risk management than more risk-averse people. Worrying a lot about very low probability events is not compatible with the risk-taking typically required to make a lot of money. After all millionaires are largely a "survivor club" filtered from high risk appetite workaholics.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by closeparen on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:08AM (#13892137)
>millionaires are largely

Pedantic, but. Families with $1m net worth are largely late-middle-aged (newly retired) salary workers with paid-off mortgages on their median-priced houses in suburban flyover country, plus ~40 years of 401k contributions and capital gains.

They drive Toyotas and fly economy for their 1-2 yearly vacations because that's what left when the 15% 401k contribution, mortgage on 3bd house, children's educations, and groceries are paid for.

Think teachers, bureaucrats, journalists (pre-internet), scientists, engineers, doctors, and lawyers, in roughly ascending order. What you'd call the upper middle class.

There are about 8 million millionaire households in the US as of 2016 [0].

Private jets are more a feature of the Fortune 500 CEO Davos-going class. $1 million in income maybe, very different from $1m net worth. It's not generally useful to conflate these wildly different wealth levels under the same terminology.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millionaire

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by mark-r on Friday March 17, 2017 @08:13AM (#13893350)
You're taking the term "millionaire" too literally. There was a time when a million dollars really was well beyond the reach of a salary worker, but a century of inflation took care of that. The term is still used as a synonym for "really really rich". Last time I heard the true threshold for really rich was about $100 million.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by closeparen on Sunday March 19, 2017 @04:09AM (#13905915)
The internet personal finance community rallies behind The Millionaire Next Door, which talks about the habits of the people I'm describing as if they were the same rich elite that flies on private jets.

As a result, I try to call out abuse of the term millionaire whenever I see it.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by mark-r on Sunday March 19, 2017 @11:26PM (#13911450)
I see your point, but "abuse" is in the eye of the beholder. It might be time to retire the word Millionaire, but unfortunately nothing has arisen to replace it.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:36AM (#13891774)
I don't know about that. I think mostly it has to do with having the power to pick and choose critical service providers, bully them, etc. If Michael Jackson and Steve Jobs had not been as wealthy and powerful as they had been, they would also both probably be alive.

Neither has much to do with being risk-takers, although you might be right that a higher arousal threshold desensitized them to risk. It may also be that people used to winning, on some level, expect to keep winning. Either way, we're not just talking about Fortune 500 C-levels here, plenty of people with loads of money and power did nothing to get it, and have no special qualities associated with that ability to get it.

They still often have bad outcomes.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by komali2 on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:12AM (#13891927)
I feel like Steve Jobs is an odd choice... He turned down treatment I thought?
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by redler on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:26AM (#13891977)
He wasted precious time indulging quackery.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by tluyben2 on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:36AM (#13892244)
Anecdotal but I notice in my circles only less financially well off people endulge in quackery. The latest is that you do not need treatment for anything if you do enough marijuana and reiki (not to mention a lot of poor people burn their last money on reiki training....) especially not doing chemo when they sbould is hard to witness.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by pm on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:35AM (#13892910)
I can't say I know anyone who's indulged reiki, but I've got a lot of flak from my brother telling me that cannabis cures cancer, when I told him that I was doing chemoradiotherapy for my Stage 3 rectal cancer. Today I've finished a cycle of six weeks of treatment, and while I'm extremely tired, the signs are good that it's in remission. If I'm lucky, I'll have a full pathological response, i.e., it's gone.

Despite the number of people who go through cancer, it's rarely brought up in polite conversation. It wasn't until I got it myself that all manner of people came out of the woodwork to talk about how someone they knew had gone through the same thing. Many of them have been using concentrated cannabis oil (which my brother also said I should do). After reading a couple of studies, it does have a positive effect on cancers, but the level depends on the type of cancer. In the case of colorectal cancers, it seems to stop the cancer but not kill it, most likely due to the CB1 receptors in the tumour being hypermethylated (as in, the gene isn't being expressed). The level of evidence isn't that of a systematic review, but it's enough for me to give it a go and certainly enough for further research. Unfortunately, the two sides of the argument seem to think that it either doesn't do anything (there's not enough evidence) or that the medical establishment is just a ruse and that cannabis cures all cancer. I prefer to use my critical thinking skills and get the best of both worlds.

I can understand why people might indulge in quackery - I've got surgeons telling me they need to cut out my rectum and part of my lower intestine, even with a full pathological response. Possible side effects are shitting 3 times a day (not so bad) and erectile dysfunction (worse). This has been the gold standard of care for 15+ years now, and the surgeons don't give a fuck about my quality of life, they just want to cut. There's mounting evidence to show this might be overtreating the problem, and that you can get away with a heavier dose of chemo with the radiotherapy. Frankly, I don't want anyone cutting anything out of me unless it's absolutely necessary, but it's hard finding an advocate who would be willing to tell the surgeons to fuck off.

I'm lucky, in this sense: I understand the research and I have access to upcoming studies (I used to work at an institute that did systematic reviews of evidence). Most people won't have such advantages, so they just sit there and do what the surgeons tell them to do, as if they don't have any options other than no treatment. If that's all the choice I got, I'd be wary of the medical establishment too.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by komali2 on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:03PM (#13896938)
I'm not sure about cannabis curing cancer, but there's ample research to support that it can help tremendously with the side effects of chemo. Basically, it can make life more comfortable while you go through treatment.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by tluyben2 on Sunday March 19, 2017 @09:10AM (#13906839)
I would advocate, for many reasons, taking regular treatment and cannabis at the same time, but refusing regular treatment because cannabis will do it is a bit over the top. I am a cancer survivor so people tend to talk to me about it.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by pm on Saturday March 18, 2017 @12:33AM (#13899909)
Yes, there's plenty of evidence for that, I'm not disputing that fact. However, even the most casual search you can find studies testing the effects of cannabinoids in vitro on different cancer types. As I said, the effects are different for each - they respond to different receptors (CB1 and CB2) and have effects ranging from nothing, to halting growth, to promoting cell death and reducing tumour size. The reasons why such differences exist are yet to be researched as far as I can tell though.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by adventured on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:05AM (#13892125)
Which more likely has absolutely nothing to do with him being rich. His quackery behavior was very high on the scale before he was rich post Apple IPO.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by andruby on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:03AM (#13892116)
But even if he was't rich I'm pretty sure he would have done the same.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by djsumdog on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:07AM (#13894502)
He was a fruitarian, and that much fructose is pretty toxic for your pancreas.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by jabl on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:41AM (#13892710)
> ... Steve Jobs had not been as wealthy and powerful as they had been, they would also both probably be alive.

Steve Jobs got pancreatic cancer, IIRC. Which has a pretty low survival rate, per wikipedia 5% after 5 years from initial diagnosis. So most likely he'd be dead by now no matter what he would have done.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by bipson on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:19AM (#13893087)
Not all pancreatic cancer is alike. IIRC he had a variant that would have had a ~80% chance of a favorable outcome, given he would have chosen the generally advised treatment
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by jabl on Saturday March 18, 2017 @12:51PM (#13902142)
Oh, I didn't know that. Thanks for the correction.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by djsumdog on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:09AM (#13894513)
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by leroy_masochist on Friday March 17, 2017 @08:12AM (#13893347)
Re: skiing off piste being a rich man's sport, are you familiar with the term "ski bum"?
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by bdamm on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:17PM (#13895168)
Many sports have the same "X bum". Even aviation!
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by intoverflow2 on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:13AM (#13892838)
Quad biking around your estate comes to mind.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by danaliv on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:21AM (#13891469)
And it's the number one way you're going to get injured.

Keep your seatbelt buckled, even when the sign is off.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by umanwizard on Friday March 17, 2017 @10:33AM (#13894243)
Flying is already so incredibly torturously uncomfortable for me that the very slight risk of injury or death is worse it for the increased comfort of not having a seatbelt on.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by davrosthedalek on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:55PM (#13896248)
It is worth the risk for the persons next to you or the row over when you get thrown through the plane and hit them in the head?
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by umanwizard on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:50PM (#13898983)
Since I don't get upset when other people do things for their own comfort that make me extremely slightly less safe to a similar extent, the Golden Rule school of ethics suggests: "yes".
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by silverdrake11 on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:31PM (#13895992)
I wonder if your head would actually hit the cabin ceiling though because of the centrifugal force. The plane might have flipped too quickly for that to happen
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by xapata on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:13AM (#13891663)
Private planes also crash far more often than standard airline flights.

Case in point: Chapecoense.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by geezerjay on Friday March 17, 2017 @04:51AM (#13892505)
IIRC, the Chapecoense flight was done by a private charter company which provided services to football teams. That was not a private jet incident at all.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by xapata on Friday March 17, 2017 @09:56AM (#13893985)
charter ~ jet

No?

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by Neliquat on Friday March 17, 2017 @10:18AM (#13894132)
Charter =/= Private

To us it is the same, but to the person with a private jet, there is a substantial difference.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by xapata on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:06PM (#13895059)
Ah, right. Like a weekly maid versus a live-in maid.

Still, as far as I know, the safety of standard commercial airlines is much better than both charters and private planes. Without the regulators to monitor the maintenance and pilots, it turns out people take more risks.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @10:34AM (#13894249)
It's not even a rule on airliners, merely a suggestion. I'm sure silly people on private jets will keep their seat belt off when seated, but plenty of silly people do that on airliners too.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:12AM (#13891660)
Never in my experience.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by wallace_f on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:42AM (#13892932)
Can we talk about this in terms of actual statistics? How dangerous is flying without a seatbelt relative to say, driving without one?
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:37AM (#13893174)
Per the FAA (https://www.faa.gov/passengers/fly_safe/turbulence/):

- Each year, approximately 58 people in the United States are injured by turbulence while not wearing their seat belts.

- From 1980 through 2008, U.S. air carriers had 234 turbulence accidents, resulting in 298 serious injuries and three fatalities.

- Of the 298 serious injuries, 184 involved flight attendants and 114 involved passengers.

- At least two of the three fatalities involved passengers who were not wearing their seat belts while the seat belt sign was illuminated.

- Generally, two-thirds of turbulence-related accidents occur at or above 30,000 feet.

Edit: These stats do not include general aviation (private jets, etc...).

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:41AM (#13893190)
For comparison, about 10,000 unrestrained motorists die in fatal vehicular accidents every year, and millions are injured. https://www.cdc.gov/motorvehiclesafety/seatbelts/facts.html
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by wallace_f on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:59AM (#13893279)
So according to this answer[1], ~1.7MM fly/day.

Making a quick guess that from '80-'08, Americans average 1MM flights/day, then odds of serious injury are ~1 in 95,000.

Odds of death are 1 in 9,333,333.

Assuming the possibility of taking 3 'average' flights/day, then you'd need to board flights non-stop for 8,523 years to die, on average. 88 years to be injured.

[1] - https://www.quora.com/How-many-people-fly-domestically-in-th...

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @09:21AM (#13893691)
Of course, general aviation is much more dangerous. As a general rule, the smaller the plane, the riskier it is, partially due to the corresponding increase in regulatory scrutiny as the size of the aircraft grows. Private pilots need a minimum of ~50 hours for their license. Most newly-hired jet pilots, private and commercial, have at least 1500 hours, and many have more than that.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @10:45AM (#13894308)
Larger airplanes are also much more capable (better instruments, things like anti-icing systems, ability to fly above weather), far better maintained on average, fly into better airports, have better flight planning resources, and more.

Note that when looking at airline safety, you'll get misleading numbers if you go back too far. Safety has improved remarkably in the past couple of decades. In the 80s and 90s, a couple hundred fatalities per year was about typical in the US. In the last decade, the typical number is zero. There hasn't been a fatal crash involving an American airliner for over eight years, and you have to go all the way back to 2001 (November, not September) to find one involving a major American airline. Even if you include foreign airlines operating in the US, that only adds one fatal crash and three deaths to the recent total.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:18AM (#13894581)
The challenge with measuring the safety of general aviation is that it is much more behavior-dependant. All of the US airlines use the same standards for deciding when to fly/ not fly for weather, have similar maintenance programs, training requirements, etc... When it comes to private air travel, it's all up to the pilot and the insurance company.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:56PM (#13896254)
I imagine GA follows something like a Pareto distribution, with 10% of the pilots involved in 90% of the incidents. That 10% would get retrained or weeded out in the airlines, and the rest get much more consistency on all the rest of the stuff you mention.

So yeah, there really isn't any one "the safety of general aviation." It's a huge spectrum.

Another challenge is reporting. The FAA knows exactly how many flights and how many hours the airlines did last year, but GA activity is much harder to gauge. It's hard to figure out what safety looks like when you don't have a good figure for the denominator.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @04:58PM (#13897943)
From my limited experience working with them, the general aviation insurance industry seems ripe for startups. Data science is a huge deal in insurance, but the companies insuring Cessnas and Pipers don't seem to have fully caught on.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by acallahan on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:06AM (#13894486)
Maybe it's safer /not/ to wear a seatbelt.

It was hard to find good stats with quick googling, but this old source[1] suggests that blood clots during flights are the greater risk, killing at least 2,000 people in the UK per year. I suspect that keeping a seatbelt off while cruising lets you shift around more mid flight and would give a small decrease in the frequency of clots.

[1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/1109406.stm

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lutorm on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:31PM (#13895996)
You don't need to wear it tight (like you do with a car seat belt), we're not talking about tens of G accelerations like in a car crash. All you need is for it to prevent you from flying up out of your seat.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lutorm on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:28PM (#13895960)
I'm not saying the risk is particularly large, at least in a large aircraft. However, the inconvenience of buckling your seat belt is practically nil, so the value proposition is pretty clear to me.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by wallace_f on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:49PM (#13898655)
The inconvenience of wearing a harness is subjective. Some people don't like it.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by amelius on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:01AM (#13894437)
> How dangerous is flying without a seatbelt relative to say, driving without one?

I guess it depends on (the size of) your aircraft.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by tinco on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:49AM (#13892955)
i don't think you can even compare those, driving without a seatbelt is a ridiculously unsafe idea.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by sandworm101 on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:04AM (#13891635)
Or, as with cars, just be in the bigger car. Another a380 would probably have shaken off this encounter. Size, and the flex that comes with size, flattens out these things.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by sundvor on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:39AM (#13891539)
True.I would think this would be more of a problem for people from US states where wearing a seatbelt is not mandatory.

In other parts of the world (with more sense) such as Europe, Australia, we're conditioned to always using it due to strict enforcement and as such it's not such a novelty.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by throwanem on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:49AM (#13892958)
The only such US state is New Hampshire. (Because of course it is.)
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by uzoodoo on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:55AM (#13894944)
Live free or DIE!
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:44AM (#13893207)
Speaking as someone who has actually done seatbelt enforcement, (I worked as a cop for a year after college before getting into software development,) catching people who aren't wearing their seatbelts is really, really hard. Each seatbelt ticket written probably takes ~30 minutes of time for the issuing officer.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by burkemw3 on Friday March 17, 2017 @08:26AM (#13893406)
I'm interested in hearing the intracacies!
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @09:15AM (#13893643)
There really aren't any good trick to it-- it's just a matter of finding a good vantage point and watching each driver go by. You're supposed to note the color of the belt (black) and the color of the driver's shirt before pulling the car over. As you'd imagine, fatigue comes quickly-- I never did more than an hour or two at a time. (I still have no idea how the highway patrollmen can it all day, every day without losing their minds.)

NHTSA provides substantial grant funding for traffic-safety enforcement, conditional on the department's enforcement statistics for a particular set of safety-oriented violations, especially seatbelts. The brass encouraged us to take a minimum number of enforcement actions to maximize the chances of having the grant expanded. (It paid a for substantial chunk of our salaries and offered regular 1 1/2 overtime.)

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by mikk14 on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:02PM (#13895027)
Legend says that in the streets of Naples they used to sell white T-shirts with a black band to simulate the seat belt :-)
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by scrumper on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:58PM (#13896893)
Aha that last point might explain the recent plea bargain I had: a ticket for crossing a double yellow line (points, substantial fine) and I was offered a small fine and no points if I took a seatbelt violation. So did everyone else in court. So I guess that helped the PD get some traffic safety funds?
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:29PM (#13897186)
It's possible, but in my experience the stats NHTSA looked at were compiled by the police department, not the court. (They cared about how many tickets we wrote, not how many convictions were obtained.)

A more likely explanation is the severe underfunding and understaffing of prosecutor's offices and state court systems. Most prosecuting attorneys are responsible for carrying hundreds of cases at a time-- they have no choice but to prioritize, aggressively.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by scrumper on Saturday March 18, 2017 @05:55PM (#13903714)
Ok thanks, and interesting. Understood re tickets written.

(I don't think it alters your point at all because you're still talking about constrained resources and a need to prioritize, but in traffic court in my village the PD is the prosecutor; my negotiation was with a police officer and he in turn represented the results of that negotiation to the judge. Same with everyone else's tickets. Only more serious stuff involved the town prosecutor - he was handling code violations, underage drinking, and a DUI.)

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Sunday March 19, 2017 @07:50AM (#13906552)
I'm actually really curious about the officer handling the DUI on his own. Those cases are often simple, but are also often very complex and involve defense counsel and evidentiary disputes. Which state do you live in?
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by scrumper on Friday March 24, 2017 @01:55PM (#13950834)
I live in NY but just to be clear this wasn't a DUI - I don't drink and drive! My ticket was for crossing a double yellow line, the offense in NY is called "Disobeying a Traffic Control Device".

The town prosecutor was handling the only DUI that day. (A town PD officer handled the lesser offenses, including mine.)

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by macintux on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:12PM (#13895121)
I'm surprised. At least here in Indiana, as best as I recall, drivers cannot be pulled over for seatbelt violations, only if some other offense occurs.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:21PM (#13897112)
It varies based on state law. The federal DOT can't pass its own traffic laws or regulations for constitutional reasons, so they incentivise states to implement what they think is a good idea by offering them financial incentives. The best example of this is the 21-year-old drinking age. (They threatened to cut off all highway funding for states that didn't raise it from 18 to 21.)

Pretty much every traffic officer I know could find at least 5 reasons to pull over any car, no matter how scrupulous the driver.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by antisthenes on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:12PM (#13897023)
Computer vision and machine learning to the rescue?
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:44PM (#13897317)
The better way to make people wear their seatbelts would be to standardize a really annoying seatbelt alarm in every car. I have a Subaru Forrester, and if I unbuckle my belt for 10s in my driveway, it goes crazy.

Fun fact: At the police department, we actually had the seatbelt alarms for all of our cruisers disconnected. Being able to get quickly in and out without the seatbelts snagging on our gear was the priority at low speed. Most officers are trained to unbuckle and be ready to exit the vehicle before coming to a full stop (technically illegal.)

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:39PM (#13897270)
The truly cool application of technology to traffic enforcement is the speed camera lottery in Stockholm. I have very mixed feelings on automatic license plate readers: rules for what can and can't be done with the data they produce don't really exist, and that's a real problem.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by gingerbread-man on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:35PM (#13897240)
I think it would be a very hard problem. Take a look at some pictures of cars in traffic-- the seatbelt is extremely hard to see. If it were doable, it would probably take more optics engineers than ML scientists; glare and lack of contrast look like the biggest problems.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:44AM (#13891563)
When I was in single digits, my mother and I were coming home from an international flight and the plane was struck by lightning. We lost a bit of altitude (felt like a TON of altitude subjectively), and yeah... it was a damned good thing we'd all been told to keep those seatbelts on. It was literally the difference between seconds of terror, and someone being seriously injured.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by hueving on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:45AM (#13892054)
What likely happened is that you hit a wind shear at the same time as being struck by lightning. Planes are struck by lightning frequently without passengers even realizing.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by jkchu on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:19PM (#13897093)
I flew into Dallas during a storm once, plane was struck by lightning many, many times. It was pretty spooky, but that was all. The lightning simply passes through the exterior of the plane. However if there is a gap in the exterior, then damage could occur.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-happens-when...

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by ghshephard on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:16AM (#13891947)
Using that philosophy, then anyone riding a bicycle, even if they aren't going at high-speed on road, should wear a helmet "just in case" there is an accident to protect their skull?

There is a balance between annoyance and utility. I personally have no problem wearing a belt for the entire flight, including while sleeping. But I'm not to dismayed by those who leave it off, walk around the cabin, go hang out near the cocktail lounge in business class, etc...

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by webignition on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:01AM (#13892111)
Yes, you should absolutely wear a helmet when riding a bicycle at low speeds.

Your skull is vulnerable to impacts at speeds that are relatively low compared to full-speed cycling.

On a few occasions I've witnessed a cyclist panic and wobble after being passed far too closely by a car traveling far too fast for such a manoeuvre. This has caused such cyclists to wobble, inadvertently clip the curb and mount the pavement, fall off sideways and subsequently strike their head on a nearby wall whilst falling.

The resulting injury can be very harmful.

Another example of slow-speed head injury: off-road biking down a very steep incline with a loose surface. I've seen people fall and tumble at almost stationary speeds.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by ghshephard on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:38AM (#13892695)
To be clear - any cyclist crazy enough to ride a bicycle on the same road as cars definitely needs all the protection they can get, I think that goes without saying. But now you've moved from the "extraordinary low risk of accident" that comes from cycling to the "Probably one of the most dangerous things I can do" risk factor.

And, pretty much 100% of the time I go snowboarding, I wear a helmet.

What I'm trying to surface (apparently poorly) is that life, to some degree, is about managing risks. And we often respond carte blanche scenarios with exactly the same response, regardless of whether it's proportionally required.

Cycling - on road, moving fast, around anything else moving fast, at all treacherous conditions - sure, yes wear a helmet. But, casual cycling on a nice day, protected path - probably not required.

Another area of proportional risk response - portable devices on planes. At one time, end of the world if you had one on during takeout (seriously, other passengers would freak out if they thought yours was on) - and then, all of a sudden - every airport/airline in the United States lets you read your kindle, play games on your phone. People realized their responses were not proportionate to the risk.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by jabl on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:46AM (#13892732)
Huh? Over here at least, people (me included) cycle on the same road as cars all the time. Not freeways, of course, but normal city roads with a speed limit of up to 50 km/h. It's actually illegal to cycle on the sidewalk unless there's an explicit traffic sign allowing bicycles.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by ghshephard on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:21AM (#13892862)
You could not pay me to rid a bicycle on the road here in Singapore. Or in many places in Northern California. I can't tell you about Dubai, because I've never seen a cyclist on the road there. My "Risk Mitigation" strategy in these scenarios is to say, "No, Hell No."

Regarding the law - it's illegal in Redwood City to ride on the sidewalk, but almost 100% of "Utility" cyclists (that is, people taking short trips who aren't decked out in "cyclist" gear) almost always ride on the sidewalk; and the police certainly did not make it a priority to ticket them - and given the density of police cars in Redwood City, any given cyclist traveling a few kilometers was likely to be seen by one, if not more police officers.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by dantillberg on Friday March 17, 2017 @09:30AM (#13893767)
When I lived in Boston, it was certainly legal to ride bicycles in the road (and illegal to ride them on many sidewalks), but cyclists still got hit by cars all the time. Riding with cars (whether in your own "lane" sandwiched between parked cars and moving cars, or in the same lane as the cars that want to bolt ahead at 40 mph whenever they have the chance) is the only legal option to get around by bike, but is absolutely not safe. It's one of the places where I think our legal code is absolutely bats--t crazy.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by umanwizard on Friday March 17, 2017 @10:37AM (#13894266)
Where the fuck are you supposed to ride them, then? Sure I'd love it if cities built separated bike paths everywhere people want to commute, but that's far from reality currently
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:36AM (#13894763)
Boston has bike lanes, so... that would usually work.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by bartvk on Saturday March 18, 2017 @03:55AM (#13900385)
Washington DC as well.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by baq on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:12AM (#13892835)
Netherlands doesn't count, it's a place where cars respect bikes and vice versa. Try riding a bicycle in a country where there's hostility between the two.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by paulmd on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:32PM (#13895325)
> the "extraordinary low risk of accident" that comes from cycling

No, bicycling is fairly high-risk in general, like skiing, or any other sport that involves a human body travelling faster than the average set of legs can walk it around. Even just going around the block a few times there's always the chance of some random events leading to an unfortunate encounter with a tree.

Of course, it's not skydiving either. And life is a series of risks, I'm not saying don't do it.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by tajen on Friday March 17, 2017 @04:43AM (#13892472)
Yours are anecdotal evidence of an extremely low risk. There are some bike accidents, which are already rare; Very few involve the head; and even fewer would be saved by a helmet. Whereas, requiring a helmet is a sufficient disincentive to biking that studies have shown that it increases the number of deaths in countries that made it mandatory, by making people drive instead and later die from cardiac diseases and obesity.

So yes you should wear a helmet while biking, but we should not make it mandatory.

In other counter-intuitive statistics about biking, passing at the red light is good for you.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:40AM (#13894795)
"Thinking is pointless, just like motorcycle helmets!"

"Rafi, how many of your friends have died in motorcycle accidents?"

"Pfft, nine. Buy NONE of them were from head trauma, they all died from massive spinal trauma."

Be honest... are you just playing the reference game, or do I need to be really worried?

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lorenzhs on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:08AM (#13892576)
Please don't turn this into yet another debate on whether making helmet use mandatory is a good idea.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by JoshTriplett on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:46AM (#13892282)
> Using that philosophy, then anyone riding a bicycle, even if they aren't going at high-speed on road, should wear a helmet "just in case" there is an accident to protect their skull?

Having personally done a header over the handlebars onto my helmet, resulting in a dented helmet and an un-dented head: yes, I'd recommend it.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by sulam on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:49AM (#13892067)
Yes, you absolutely should wear a helmet, just in case -- no quotes required. I have been hit by a car on my bike, and trust me, my helmet absolutely saved my life. No high speed required.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by peteretep on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:47AM (#13892283)

    > anyone riding a bicycle, 
    > even if they aren't going at
    > high-speed on road, should 
    > wear a helmet "just in case" 
Is this a trick question? The answer is yes. In many places it's a legal requirement.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by Zombieball on Friday March 17, 2017 @04:07AM (#13892344)
Thank you!

I'm probably heavily influenced by the fact that I live in one of these places (where helmets are a legal requirement).

All I could think while reading this is "yes, you definitely should always wear a helmet!!"

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by throwaway7767 on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:41AM (#13893193)
Out of curiosity, is cycling a common mode of transportation where you are from?

I recall seeing studies showing that helmet-laws generally coincided with low use of bicycles. Places where cycling is extremely common (like Denmark and Holland) never seem to have them, and it's uncommon to see cyclists using them unless they're doing something particularly dangerous (riding in traffic, off-road, etc).

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by uzoodoo on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:06PM (#13895060)
I would guess in places where biking is extremely common (like Denmark and Holland), it's also a lot safer to bike (dedicated bike lanes, etc.)
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by ajdlinux on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:09AM (#13892141)
That happens to be the justification that my country uses to make bicycle helmets mandatory (though there's significant debate about whether it's actually helped reduce injury rates, and it fairly clearly depresses overall rates of cycling versus other modes of transport).

I think the cost of wearing an aircraft seatbelt while you happen to be seated is rather lower than the cost of having to wear a bicycle helmet, though.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by ProblemFactory on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:23AM (#13892871)
There's an argument that mandatory bicycle helmets are worse, not better for the overall health goals: https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2015/aug/12/mandato...

Mandatory helmets protect cyclists from injury - but make cycling less popular. Fewer people cycling means they get less exercise and increase other health risks. On average it's a health benefit to cycle without a helmet, compared to driving - and of course people are still welcome to add helmets if they don't mind them.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by tempestn on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:34AM (#13892680)
What's the cost? Helmets aren't that expensive. Having to carry it around? Could always lock it to the bike. Helmet hair?
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by uzoodoo on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:43PM (#13895447)
Wouldn't work if you're using a bike share.

It's actually the reason why I don't use the bike share program, even though I have a station right next to my apartment building. I could ride it to/from the train station or the grocery store, but I'm paranoid about not wearing a helmet, and hauling the bulky thing around all day is a massive inconvenience.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lmm on Friday March 17, 2017 @09:18AM (#13893671)
Would you be ok with a mandatory helmet law for car drivers and passengers? The risk of a head injury that a helmet would prevent is much higher in a car, and carrying a helmet around in your car is more convenient than on your bike (e.g. it's much less likely to get stolen). Nevertheless, we don't have mandatory helmet laws for people in cars; why is that?
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by umanwizard on Friday March 17, 2017 @10:40AM (#13894283)
> The risk of a head injury that a helmet would prevent is much higher in a car

What is this based on? My own intuition is that the risk is many times higher on a bike.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by monort on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:07AM (#13894498)
There are were 42000 brain injury-related hospitalizations for motor vehicle occupants per year, though this data is from before 2001.

https://stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/13379/cdc_13379_DS1.pdf (Table 10)

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by umanwizard on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:10PM (#13895754)
Sure but you have to normalize it somehow. Americans drive way more than they bike. I imagine if you calculated this per-time or per-distance, driving would still come out much safer for the brain than cycling without a helmet.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lmm on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:39PM (#13896083)
Again just from memory, driving is a lot worse per-time and per-commute, though a small factor better per-distance.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lmm on Friday March 17, 2017 @10:49AM (#13894346)
I don't remember the source, take that as you will. Cars go faster which means a higher risk of collisions (less time to react etc.), and also a higher risk of head injury per collision.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by umanwizard on Friday March 17, 2017 @10:59AM (#13894425)
Maybe I'm just a shitty cyclist but I've wiped out way, way more times on a bike than in a car. You can crash without it being a "collision".
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lmm on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:20PM (#13895204)
Did you hit your head though? Even "low" speed for a car can be 20mph; you can hit a stationary object and be thrown around pretty severely.

That said yeah if you're "wiping out" more than like once every few years you're doing something seriously wrong (or at least taking an unnecessary risk). I've only once had any kind of incident on my cycling commute.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by umanwizard on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:07PM (#13895721)
The hardest I've wiped out on a bike was where a bike trail intersected a road. Everything was super wet and slick from rain. Despite bikes having right of way and my bright bike light being on, a truck with no headlights barreled across it without stopping.

Once I saw it, I had to slam on the brakes so hard my rear brake cable popped out of the handlebar, disabling the rear brake completely and I was putting full pressure on the front brake. I didn't have time to react and avoid going over the handlebars, and I hit my helmet on the pavement. (Thankfully, I did stop in time to avoid the truck hitting me).

Was I doing something seriously wrong? Yes -- I was riding a bike without a properly adjusted rear brake cable. However, this sort of mechanical issue (and any number of others) could happen to any riders who aren't much more hyper-diligent about maintenance than average.

Who knows if we'd even be having this conversation had I not been wearing a helmet that night.

From a public health perspective, evidence suggests making helmets mandatory is counter-productive, and so I don't support those laws. However, I still maintain that anyone who cycles without a helmet is fucking stupid.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lmm on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:21PM (#13895882)
Cycling in the rain is a risk. Cycling in the dark is a risk. Cycling across badly-designed intersections (and if it put you as a cyclist in the kind of danger it wouldn't have put a car in, it's a badly-designed intersection) is a risk. Being on the road without a helmet - indeed doing anything in your life without a helmet - is a risk. In all of these cases one weighs up the risk of doing it against the inconvenience of not doing it.

Maybe we're all "fucking stupid", but by the stats someone cycling without a helmet is less stupid than someone driving, at all. There's this weird, disproportionate cultural obsession with helmets for cyclists and cyclists only.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by throwaway7767 on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:51AM (#13893238)
Locking it to the bike isn't a good solution if you live in a place where it rains or snows a lot. So you end up having to carry it with you on errands. If you bike a lot, those small inconveniences add up.

I can't imagine fashion sense is much of a reason, that seems like a strawman argument commonly conjured up by helmet laws advocates.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by throwanem on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:55AM (#13892984)
People being afraid their bike helmets make them look like goobers, maybe?

Well, they do. Better to be a goober with an unfractured skull, though.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by mnw21cam on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:01AM (#13893014)
I always thought the statistic that mandatory helmets reduced cycling was a bit pathetic myself. It really isn't that hard. Yes, I have come off my bike and hit my head, while wearing a helmet. Unfortunately, I landed on a tooth rather than my helmet, which wasn't a lot of fun.

Regarding helmet hair, I had a colleague who had the most amazing hair spikes (think coffee cup sized), who would very carefully put a cycle helmet on every day before cycling home.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by mikko-apo on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:35AM (#13892238)
Keeping the safety belt on protects other passengers too. A person weighing 80kg has surprisingly high amount of kinetic energy when the plane trashes around.

Kinetic energy is also the reason why the flight attendants try to lock as much as possible of the loose items to the overhead bins or under the chairs.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by mikestew on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:23AM (#13894641)
Using that philosophy, then anyone riding a bicycle, even if they aren't going at high-speed on road, should wear a helmet "just in case" there is an accident to protect their skull?

Speed only makes a difference if your head hits something whilst moving at that speed. Or you can just fall off at a walking pace, and the acceleration between the top of your head to the ground is enough to kill you. Happened to a guy on the local trail a few years ago, as happens elsewhere as well.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by _ph_ on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:11AM (#13892153)
I think the bicycle helmet comparison is valid here - one big point is, that the typical bicycle helmets are not protecting your head well, you would need a motorcycle helmet for good protection.

I don't think one needs to be confined to the seat for the whole flight duration, but when sitting down, there is no good reason not to wear a belt either.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by ptaipale on Friday March 17, 2017 @04:33AM (#13892429)
Bicycle helmets are a compromise of course; a heavier helmet would give better protection but would be very cumbersome. But even light helmets give a lot of protection against very simple, silly accidents, like not noticing a bump on the road, or failing to unclip when slowing down.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by Moru on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:36AM (#13892689)
And there are ofcourse better or worse bicycle helmets around. And the way you wear them is also important. I have helped a large number of kids around my block put them on correctly after seeing them mostly hanging on the back because the parents don't know how to set the length and angle of the strap...
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by sneak on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:16AM (#13892168)
There is a pretty good statistical argument for wearing a helmet anytime one is near roads, sidewalks, moving walkways, bike lanes, or anywhere else objects are moving more than 0.5m/s, whether you are moving or not. You can even die relatively simply from falling from an otherwise motionless standing position and hitting your head on the paved ground. The brain is remarkably fragile.

I kind of want the helmet-in-public fashion trend to kick in.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by jen729w on Friday March 17, 2017 @04:14AM (#13892374)
Here in Australia, where they're mandatory, us 'hipster' types get around this by wearing helmets that look like the sort of 'crash hat' that skateboarders wear: very dome-like, skull-shaped things rather than the traditional swept-back-vents-all-over helmets that your racing cyclist would wear.

Hotter in summer, but they look cooler. ;-)

FWIW, I thought it was weird at first having to wear a helmet. I'm from the UK. Now, though, it just seems bizarre that I wouldn't. It's my skull! My brain is in there. It only takes one idiot, and knocking my head off concrete from 6ft up at even 10km/h sounds like a terrible idea. Anything that cushions the blow, even if that blow is unlikely, now seems like the most obvious idea in the world.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by Moru on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:38AM (#13892699)
But a skateboard helmet doesn't work as well as a bicycle helmet when bicyckling. They are made for different falling types. They are better than nothing but not as good as the better bicycle helmets.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by jen729w on Friday March 17, 2017 @09:32AM (#13893773)
Sorry, thought about it at the time but didn't write it - they are actual bicycle helmets styled like skateboard helmets. They're fully rated for bike riding.

If the cops stop you (which they do, occasionally) and you are actually wearing a skate helmet, not rated for bike riding, that doesn't count as 'wearing a helmet' and you'll be fined.

(I'm sure the idea of being fined for wearing the wrong helmet will horrify some people but remember, that's the law here. The law also says you need a bell on your bike. It's rare, but the bike police do random stops and if you don't have a bell, strictly speaking, you'll be fined. Never happened to me, but it can.)

((Which, by the way - and sorry for the errata with the double-brackets - I actually support. I ride through central Melbourne. Pedestrians are a nightmare. Having a working bell is actually important. They cost $5. The law is a public service which, in this case, works. Get a bell.))

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by ptaipale on Friday March 17, 2017 @04:35AM (#13892434)
Indeed. I feel naked if I start to cycle without a helmet (even though they are not strictly mandatory here, the law says you should wear one but there are no penalties for not wearing it.)
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by wfunction on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:21AM (#13891474)
While I agree with the general sentiment, to be honest there are easier solutions here. They could've just turned on the sign as soon as they saw the A380 so that people could fasten their seatbelts then. And then turned off the sign when the threat was gone. You don't need a cannon to kill a fly.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by ekianjo on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:53AM (#13891587)
> They could've just turned on the sign as soon as they saw the A380 so that people could fasten their seatbelts then

In a car you usually fasten your seatbelt all the time so that you don't have to guess when the risk is going to occur. In a plane there's no reason not to act the same way.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by wfunction on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:01AM (#13891623)
> In a car you usually fasten your seatbelt all the time so that you don't have to guess when the risk is going to occur. In a plane there's no reason not to act the same way.

Sure there is. The chances of dying in a car accident are around 1% whereas the same in an air accident is, like, 100x less likely?

It's like how you wear a helmet when you're in a construction zone but you don't wear a helmet when walking around the city despite the nonzero chance that something might fall on your head. (Or do you?)

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by Moru on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:46AM (#13892729)
We are not only talking about dying in accidents, hitting your head on the ceiling can still hurt a lot. The risk does not only come from meeting planes, it can also be natural turbulence that you get no warning for.

The reasons there are less accidents in the planes is not because they are inherently more safe (ever read up how helicopters work?), it comes from the rigorous rules around everything flying. The rules exists mostly because something happened and the industry set rules to make it not happen again.

You wear helmets on construction sites because the risk of something falling on your head is so much higher when people are working with loose tools in high altitudes, hanging from ropes or whatever. (And the company is responsible for your safety so will protect their asses from getting sued.)

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by sulam on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:51AM (#13892073)
Surely this entire event is notable because no one had any idea that this might happen. Seat belts or not, 3 or more rolls and a written off airplane is an outcome they would have avoided if they'd known it had even a remote chance of happening.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by wfunction on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:58AM (#13892103)
You'd think so, but from now on do you think planes are going to stop flying under each other or try to maneuver out of the way when this happens inadvertently? I really wish they do, but that's not the impression I got from the article. All I saw was "ATC all around the globe have recently been instructed to exercise particular care with A380s crossing above other aircraft. The Aviation Herald had already reported a number of Wake Turbulence Encounters involving A380s before", which is kind of vague and doesn't quite give me the impression they're necessarily (literally) going to go out of their ways for this if it has a chance of happening.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by andruby on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:09AM (#13892143)
Yes. I think that all small aircraft pilots will read/hear about this story. They might even practice the event in simulators.

And all of them will avoid passing under a large aircraft at 180 degrees.

Source: my father is an airline pilot and they always take the time to learn from severe incidents.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by paulajohnson on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:06AM (#13892571)
If you are flying in controlled airspace then you fly where ATC tell you, not where you happen to think would be a good idea. If you want to change course for any reason you ask ATC. The only exception would be to avoid an imminent collision.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by andruby on Friday March 17, 2017 @09:42AM (#13893850)
Good point.

Is there any leeway to adjust your heading slightly and then correct back?

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lutorm on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:36PM (#13896045)
Does not work for Clear Air Turbulence, which can be severe enough to make people fly out of their seats, too. I've been in planes where the CAT was severe enough to have lifted me out of my seat if I hadn't been buckled in, and it happened with no warning.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @12:47AM (#13891574)
In the 1-2 minutes between this thing booming past them, and being sent into a spin... you want them telling people to buckle up? That doesn't seem like the easier solution; it mostly sounds like a way to have people still hurrying in the aisles when it's too late.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by wfunction on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:08AM (#13891648)
Even half a minute minute is a hell of a lot of time and overwhelmingly better than no notice. Currently airplanes sometimes only turn on the sign after the turbulence has already started.

Also, it's not like they never have no idea which airplanes are around them until they visually see the airplane. They could turn on the sign earlier if they know earlier.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:22AM (#13891700)
I mean you say that, but wasn't this an accident predicated on not being aware of the positions of other planes? You're basically saying that we should plan for accidents, because wearing a seatbelt is somehow... what? Cumbersome?

If your neurological integrity isn't worth some hours in a seat, I guess that's your choice to make though.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by wfunction on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:30AM (#13891743)
> I mean you say that, but wasn't this an accident predicated on not being aware of the positions of other planes?

Uh, no? "an Airbus A380-800 was observed by the crew passing 1000 feet above" http://avherald.com/h?article=4a5e80f3

> You're basically saying that we should plan for accidents

Yes, whenever possible. It should make sense, really.

> because

...because it's sometimes possible and predictable, in which case it logically makes sense to plan for it.

> wearing a seatbelt is somehow... what? Cumbersome?

Not because of that. But yes, it is cumbersome. Makes it harder to relax, sleep, get up, etc... is this really that shocking to you?

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:33AM (#13891761)
"According to information The Aviation Herald received on March 4th 2017 the CL-604 passed 1000 feet below an Airbus A380-800 while enroute over the Arabian Sea, when a short time later (1-2 minutes)"

They saw the plane, and 1-2 minutes later... bang. We already went over this.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by wfunction on Friday March 17, 2017 @01:38AM (#13891784)
> They saw the plane, and 1-2 minutes later... bang. We already went over this.

We did, that's why it made zero sense that you said this was predicated on not being aware of the positions of other planes. They were aware of this a full 1-2 minutes earlier at least. They could've turned on the sign. The solution was totally implementable.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:04AM (#13891894)
I think we've reached that point at which I'd be happy to buckle my seatbelt and let you walk around the cabin to your heart's content. I am not your parent.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by ptaipale on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:45AM (#13892937)
When I sit in the same cabin, and I'm buckled up, the previous poster (or his body parts) will be bouncing all over the seats of the same cabin, which is a danger to me. So I still prefer that he also buckles up.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @11:30AM (#13894712)
As do I, but he's a poster on HN and not on a flight with me, and I have considerations for the value of my time and the integrity of my sanity when dealing with people who think that "intentionally obtuse" is a position in argument.
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by Moru on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:02AM (#13892802)
Except if he lands on you, that isn't very funny
Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by lathiat on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:22AM (#13892629)
In my experience (particularly on Emirates) they generally turn the seatbelt sign on before the turbulence because they can generally predict it on radar.

It is a little annoying when you have 20-30 minute seatbelt periods with barely any actual turbulence but there you go.

Re:Enroute Airbus A380 wake flips Challenger business jet up... by M_Grey on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:07PM (#13896382)
This is true for any airline, but there is something (like the story in this case) called "CAT" or Clear Air Turbulence.