News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by 1ris on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @08:48PM (#12973499)
This is common practice in germany. The whole payment methode "sofortüberweisung" or "sofort" is based on this. You give your login information and a single use password to sofort, they initiate a wire transfer and instantly guarantee the money will arive. (It will arrive 24h later, as banks are allowed to delay it this long and they use it as additional liquidity) Of course this is a security nightmare and or course the ToS of the Banks prohibit you from sharing your login details. But unfortunately they don't enforce their ToS. Recently the cartel office called for making this part of the Banks ToS void, as they would "hinder the adoption of innovative FinTec".

But it illustrates how deeply flawed the whole banking sector is that people are willing to give up passwords to third parties or paying insane fees to paypal. IMHO we urgently need a law that makes wire transferees instant, or this dangerous and incredible expensive layers grow for the disadvantage of everybody (expect paypal and sofort).

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by Rafert on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:43AM (#12974688)
This is a solved problem in the Netherlands with iDEAL. Go to checkout, select your bank, authenticate at your banks website with your credentials and 2FA (SMS/EMV CAP reader/QR code), confirm transaction details and you'll be redirected back to the web store. The wire transfer is not instant but it is guaranteed so the merchant can start shipping immediately.

See https://www.ideal.nl/demo/en/ for a demo.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by rbag on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:00AM (#12974770)
In France we have 3D Secure, when you make the paiement you are redirected to a page that belongs to the bank, you receive a SMS with a one time code to validate the paiement and are redirected to the merchant with the validation.

Quite efficient, but I think there's fees for the merchant in this case.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by phlo on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:34AM (#12975553)
3D Secure is used to authorize credit card payments, while Sofort and iDEAL send wire transfers. Big difference.

With 3D Secure, you provide the normal card data (i.e. card number, expiration, name, CVV/CVC) to the merchant and are then redirected to an authentication form from your card issuer. There, you'll be asked to either provide a password or, as you described, input a confirmation code from a text.

With Sofort, you're entering your login data to your e-banking account on a login page served by Sofort. They, in turn, use it to log in to your e-banking using a simulated browser and send a wire transfer. You lose control, however, of what else they do: once they are logged in to your e-banking, they can check your previous transactions, send other transfers or they might change your mailing address...

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by dx034 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:33AM (#12976180)
As far as I know, 3D secure also works for debit cards. In many countries debit and credit cards use the same system (Visa/Mastercard). Have seen 3D secured payments several times for my UK debit Mastercard.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by makmanalp on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:37AM (#12974945)
I've seen some horrific UI on some 3D secure implementations. Also, I've seen some websites refresh to a "loading 3D secure ..." page, only to somehow skip it and go further. If the merchant can just skip it and charge your card like a regular credit card, then what's even the point of having it?
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by phlo on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:37AM (#12975569)
As another comment already pointed out, you are probably seeing your card issuer's risk-based 3D Secure system in action. If your system (IP address, location, user-agent) and/or the transaction (merchant, sector, amount) look familiar enough, some issuers let you skip the password/TAN entry. If they are doing it right, that's a good thing.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by captn3m0 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:14AM (#12975446)
The worst I've ever experienced is the RuPay card network's (India) Second Factor. You pick an image out of collection of thirty odd images that you must select again at the time of every transaction. It also forces you to type your PIN via a shuffled numeric clickpad on the browser.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by Elhana on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:43AM (#12975591)
I believe that if buyer supports 3dsecure and merchant skips it, then he'll be the looser in case of a fraud.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by vladvasiliu on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:26AM (#12975179)
The merchant can choose wether and when to use 3dsecure (at least in France). I work for a company that uses Paybox for online payments. We can set an amount above which 3dsecure is used, e.g 20 EUR. I'm guessing the bank has to support 3dsecure, but they can't or at least don't impose it.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by mack73 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:38AM (#12975242)
I work with fraud detection at an online travel agency. If you use 3D Secure and there is a fraud, your insurance will cover the cost of that transaction. As a merchant you may bypass (not use) that security feature at your discression. 3D Secure is a Mastercard feature, no?
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by vladvasiliu on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:50AM (#12975312)
3dsecure works with Visa too. I don't know about AmEx, although I do know that for Point Of Sale payments we have to have a special bank contract (one for Visa / Mastercard and one for AmEx).

I suppose the merchant decides wether to use this or not by trying to find a balance between user experience and fraud risk.

In our case I think the limit is set right above the usual purchase amount (we sell movie tickets). It's low enough that a fraud wouldn't hurt us too badly and there's not much incentive for it either. Also, most of the clients don't have to fiddle with 3dsecure (in my case I would have to cary a fob around, which I never do), so it's a better experience for them.

If someone tries to buy a lot of tickets at once, they are more likely to be doing something fishy so we use 3dsecure.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by Flimm on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:51AM (#12975001)
I'm guessing that the page gets skipped when you're on a familiar IP address with a familiar cookie, or there are other factors where the bank decides more authentication is unnecessary.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by mack73 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:57AM (#12975348)
10 years ago I got a Mastercard that for the first time required me to answer a 3D Secure questing each time I did an online purchase. It's been at least seven years since I had to answer that question though. How 3DS figures my card carries no fraud risk I have no idea. Is my card less likely to get stolen? Perhaps they have geography as a metric?
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by greggman on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:40AM (#12974961)
That would suck if anytime I wanted to deal with things back home while travelling I had to remove my local sim and put back in my home sim just so I could receive SMS messages from my bank.

Do they offer any non SMS options?

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by briandear on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:50AM (#12975313)
In France they do not have a non SMS option. Also if you change your number you have to wait days while your bank mails a new activation code to your postal address. Actually snail mail. (At least with BNP.)

An incredible pain. I hate it. ApplePay for the web is far superior.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by just_had_tea on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:26AM (#12976811)
Data point of one here, but my experience is different. I used Crédit Coopératif, and they issued me with a password generator fob (like a small calculator in which you stick your Visa chip-card) which the 3D Secure page would ask for a response from.

I suspect it depends on your bank. Back when i used Crédit Agricole, i was indeed forced to do SMS auth, which is inferior.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by shripadk on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:50AM (#12974994)
3D Secure (at least in India) offers both SMS OTP and Password validation. So you can use your 3D Secure Password (which is different from bank credentials) or use SMS OTP to confirm the transaction.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by eknkc on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:53AM (#12975324)
Have 3d Secure here in Turkey too. Most merchants provide a checkbox to enable 3D secure, if you do so, they redirect to the bank's page and you need to enter a code.

Most of the time, non 3d secure purchases take a little more time to go through and if the amount is higher than your regular spendings or the charge happened to be in the middle of the night, banks ask for confirmation via SMS anyway. If you go with 3D secure, it just works instantly.

All banks provide virtual credit card numbers with predefined limits too though.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by blowski on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:14AM (#12974828)
Usually there are no fees, and it also protects you from chargebacks. But it's harder to implement, and it does tend to increase abandon rates a bit.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by cm2187 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:22AM (#12974871)
And some implementations rely on 3rd party cookies!
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by atomwaffel on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:09AM (#12975747)
Yes, the same system exists in Germany too (confusingly alongside Sofortüberweisung). It's called Giropay and it works the same in that you sign in on your online banking website and the wire transfer is guaranteed by your bank, not a third party.

It's nice and works well. All would be great if it weren't for the fact that it's only offered by some banks (mainly cooperatives I think) and only accepted by some shops. Why the German banks have tried to sue Sofortüberweisung out of existence instead of implementing their own universal system that undercuts Sofortüberweisung's merchant fees (0.9% + €0.25 per transaction) is beyond me.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by thesimon on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:56AM (#12976017)
> instead of implementing their own universal system that undercuts Sofortüberweisung's merchant fees (0.9% + €0.25 per transaction) is beyond me.

Well, they are trying with wasting 300 millions so far on Paydirekt.

Their rates are still over credit cards though...

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by atomwaffel on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:42AM (#12977301)
Oh right, thanks! It seems they're such a strong competitor that I've never even heard of them. And they still support nowhere near as many banks as Sofortüberweisung, although I appreciate that these things take time (and there are a lot of banks in Germany).
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:40AM (#12974962)
I don't consisted that a solved problem. Austria has the same "solution". Try paying as a foreigner without a local bank account. Also no support for chargebacks.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by MagnumOpus on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:12AM (#12975432)
However the cost is minimal. As a foreigner you can pay with credit cards - the merchant might not support it due to the horrendous cut that Visa/MC/Amex take (several percentage points).
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:58AM (#12977029)
If you charge a card that supports 3DSecure the fees are not even a whole percentage i think.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by lucaspiller on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:59AM (#12975043)
This is how most ecommerce works in Lithuania too. Debit cards (vs credit cards) typically didn't allow online transactions until last year, so most ecommerce companies just do this - there are only 3 or 4 major banks, so for the user it's pretty easy. I assume the fees are lower for the business too.

The only downside is if you don't have a local bank account (i.e. as a foreigner) you can't use it.

2FA is done by a) paper code b) passcode generator fob or c) mobile signature, which uses your SIM which holds an RSA key (it doesn't use SMS):

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_signature

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by webjunkie on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:08AM (#12975739)
This sounds exactly like "Giropay" in Germany, a competitor to Sofort and supported by some banks, but has very low adoption.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by jve on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:06AM (#12975078)
Yeah, also happens in Latvia. Already for many years, many banks here and many online services provide you with this way of payment.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by fungi on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:03AM (#12975058)
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by gosubpl on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:10AM (#12975425)
Solved problem in Poland. Actually I usually laugh when I hear about "FinTech" startups struggling to deliver technology that is history here. mBank has been offering "instant" money transfer for purchases for the last 15 years, now there are more then a couple of vendors aggregating almost every bank that there is on the market. Real time transfers have been available via BlueMedia (private company) for like 7 years and via central banking transfer hub for over a year. You can pay with your mobile via a couple of providers, including said central banking transfer hub (Blik payments). And standard bank transfers (take around 8h to deliver - depending on incoming and outgoing transfer sessions timing - there are 3 sessions a day) are free - so many people are used to pay via standard bank transfer and there are many solutions for merchants that do automated account scraping to match incoming transfers. Poland - the land of FinTech future. Downside - if you are Financial IT provider - you can hardly get anything sold here - everything that comes from outside is history here.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by kybernetyk on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:28AM (#12975851)
Yeah, I was living in Poland for 4 years some time ago. (2008-2012) and I was astounded how modern banking is compared to Germany.

Here wire transfers still take 1 day minimum. (Except your transferring within the same bank). Doesn't matter if you send the payment in the first or last scheduled transaction window. For the receiver it won't show up till the next day.

Our bank cards won't double as credit/debit cards either. We still have to get an extra card if we want to perform VISA payments. And NFC is still not wide spread. (though that might be a good thing)

I also like how integrated Polish banks are with public services. You could issue a tax or social insurance payment directly from online banking. Granted on the backend it's still just a normal wire transfer but that most banks have an easy to use form for that is great.

I still have my mBank account and feature-wise (and UI wise) it's light years ahead of what my local German bank offers.

I guess here in Germany when it comes to banking we're the victims of early innovation and have to cope with entrenched old standards instead of adopting all the nice new tech.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by dx034 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:31AM (#12976171)
Germany has a very bad banking system, mostly due to the high market share of very small banks that don't want to or cannot adapt quickly.

Here in the UK transfers also arrive within seconds 24/7 and debit cards can be used for online payments. No idea why transfers in Germany need 1-3 days (depending when you submit it) in a time when there's no manual work involved.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by jsingleton on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:05AM (#12976339)
As a Brit I was surprised when I received a reply on Twitter to a blog post I wrote [0] that said:

  ...in Germany nearly 80% of transactions are still cash - lots of places that simply don't take cards
Reading this thread that now makes more sense. We have it pretty good in the UK with contactless and chip & PIN (although I hear the Dutch have it better). I always feel the US is so backwards when I visit and they do the stripe & sign thing.

However, I still think there are many reasons cash should always be accepted. I won't repeat them here as they're covered in the post.

[0]: https://unop.uk/do-you-accept-cash/

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by nickez on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:41AM (#12976514)
The standing joke here is that Germany is a "developing" country when it comes to payment. 10 years ago it would even be difficult to pay with an international credit card.. In Sweden bank transfers are immediate if I use "Swish" and I use cash maybe once a month.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by kwhitefoot on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:14AM (#12976730)
Here in Norway I use cash only at a loppemarked (literally flea market but generally in support of a charity, the local brass band, or sports club). Even these now have payment terminals more often than not, just not enough to go around so it is still quicker with cash.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by fennecfoxen on Thursday November 17, 2016 @11:49AM (#12979022)
> I always feel the US is so backwards when I visit and they do the stripe & sign thing.

Nowadays we're switching to chip & sign.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by chuckus on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:42AM (#12976526)
I feel we in New Zealand, despite our small size, we actually have modern POS systems. I have been using contactless Visa regularly for at least 3 years now and have switched to Apple Pay recently. It is so popular here, that relatively small number of vendors who do not have contactless, have stick a physical label on the POS device saying "No Paywave" so when the customer goes to wave, they know do swipe/insert instead.

I've heard that we are a test bed for some technologies, given that the sample size is small relative to the world. An example of this was Pokemon Go, which was AFAIK release first here in NZ (and Australia).

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by Rockslide on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:45AM (#12976546)
Actually it is 1 day maximum, which is the legal requirement for transfers within the EWR. If it takes longer at your bank, go sue them. But I can't share your experience. I've lately transferred money between three different banks, on a Sunday, and it all happened in near-real-time (DKB, comdirect and my local Sparkasse where involved).
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by antihero on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:01AM (#12977039)
I think the comedy value of the shock on people's faces when you pay at a place with contactless (some bigger shops have it) with Apple Pay is brilliant, though.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by mootothemax on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:54AM (#12975653)
Yeah, the tech side is great, it's just a shame that borrowing costs - for anything in złoty, e.g. mortgage - are gigantic, saving interest rates are abysmal, and you really have to watch out for bad actors thanks to the close-to-zero consumer protection rights.

For example, a number of online shops show items as being "in stock" despite having an empty warehouse (or no idea if their supplier has anything in stock). It's possible to transfer large sums, and then have to sit around waiting for a month or two while the shop decides what to do, all with close to zero repercussions for the shop themselves.

If you've paid with a credit card instead of a bank transfer, it's simple enough to kick off a chargeback. (well, not as simple as in other nations, but a short form and a quick chat with a moody call centre rep).

As a recent example, I had a ~5,000zł purchase go wrong (to a well-known Apple authorized store) after the payment was successfully taken, but the store's website had an error and failed to process. Trying to get a response out of the payment processor or the shop was like getting blood out of a stone; the only thing that worked inside of a reasonable timeframe (I gave them a week to even reply to me on phone -or- email) was a chargeback.

While I can live with unfavourable rates, give me the UK's consumer protection laws any day of the week!

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by koliber on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:50AM (#12975987)
It's interesting how different people can interpret the same situation in different ways.

I am wondering why you consider borrowing costs for a mortgage in PLN to be gigantic. I just checked and the total annual rate looks to be around 3.3%. Is that what you consider gigantic?

I've lived in Poland for over five years now. It took me some time to get used to operating procedures here. It is different than in the US, which is what I was used to. There are things that are worse than in the US, and there are things that are better. It is not as horrible as you make it seem.

Like everywhere, you have to know how to maneuver. A person having just arrived in the US may not know what to do when faced with bad service. Things that tend to work there is insisting to talk to a manager, and threatening a chargeback. Both will be difficult if you don't speak English.

In Poland, depending on the situation, threatening to report the company to UOKiK (the consumer rights groups) works really well. This will be difficult if you don't speak Polish.

I've had bad experiences in both countries. These were few and far between, both in the US, and in Poland.

Regarding the bad experience you've had... Could the delay in replying been to language difficulties, or were you communicating with the store in Polish?

P.S. You're right on about many retailers listing stock they don't have. Lot's of just-in-time types of stores. It comes down to finding reputable retailers. Not once though have I had a situation where something was not shipped. I've made hundreds of purchases online.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by mootothemax on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:42AM (#12976528)
>I just checked and the total annual rate looks to be around 3.3%

Lowest I've seen is 3% plus base rate. If you typed "poland mortgage rates" into Google, you might be seeing the same infobox as I am, which references a US-based credit union. Taking Millenium Bank as an example, the calculator on their site offers 3.6% - base not included - for 25 years on a house value of 1,000,000zł with a loan of 700,000zł. That seems gigantic to me, and over 25 years it's just painful.

In a way, this kinda illustrates my frustration with the country; you really need to read the fine-print.

> threatening to report the company to UOKiK

Which I severely resent having to resort to; the companies should want to offer great service, and not have to be beaten into it.

Thankfully, since I've been here, I've seen a great increase in the quality of customer service. The Polish people I've met seem to fall into two groups though: either they'll complain; or they'll put up with absolute nonsense for months on end. It's such a shame.

>Could the delay in replying been to language difficulties, or were you communicating with the store in Polish?

Entirely in Polish.

>It comes down to finding reputable retailers. Not once though have I had a situation where something was not shipped. I've made hundreds of purchases online.

Five years ago, I would've said exactly the same thing as you. Then I bought a house, needed an oven, fridge, washing machine etc. etc. etc. all of which - from many different shops - had issues one way or another. I also had the same experience buying tires online recently, despite having thought I'd learned my lesson.

I love being here, and the country and people are great. On a practical level, though, it's not always as rosy as it's sometimes made out to be.

Edit: while I'm ranting, an anecdote: tried to buy a new nice-ish hoover online a few weeks ago. Looked up prices, and all the major players have it - Saturn etc. - and I see a small shop that's an authorized retailer for the brand and figure "Sure, I'd much rather give my money to you than the massive companies" went ahead, and hey presto, I receive every automated order received/packed/sent email from them, only to have the owner contact me a few days later and admitted he had a problem in his supply chain. Fine, these things happen, he promises delivery a week later, and I go with it. Of course, their website still listed the same damned thing in stock and, of course, there was another delay after that week. Cancelled the order, gave my money to Saturn mutter mutter grump grump and had the hoover the very next day. GRRRRR.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by zo1 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @11:23AM (#12978788)
>"Lowest I've seen is 3% plus base rate. If you typed "poland mortgage rates" into Google, you might be seeing the same infobox as I am, which references a US-based credit union. Taking Millenium Bank as an example, the calculator on their site offers 3.6% - base not included - for 25 years on a house value of 1,000,000zł with a loan of 700,000zł. That seems gigantic to me, and over 25 years it's just painful."

Sitting with a 10.x% mortgage right now in sunny South Africa. It's all about perspective. Then again, we're on-par to paying the thing off within a few years, but plenty of people carry their mortgage around for up to 30 years, or more with re-financing.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by brazzledazzle on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @08:57PM (#12973540)
This is totally and completely insane. If a site gets hacked and your money is stolen there's no way the bank is going to indemnify you when you willingly turned over your credentials to a third party.

Do they have to have all kinds of specialized fraud detection in place to prevent unknown IPs from transferring more than a certain dollar amount? It also just occurred to me that you probably can't have 2-factor enabled on your bank account.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by paulmd on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:00AM (#12974471)
This same procedure is used in the United States with startup darlings like Coinbase. No debit card or one-time-password required, please give your real bank account password.

https://support.coinbase.com/customer/en/portal/articles/194...

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by gertef on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:51PM (#12982501)
It's also used by all the major financial-management apps like Mint.com and Bank of America Portfolio Manager

https://www.mint.com/how-mint-works/security

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ColinDabritz on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:34PM (#12983256)
I had heard good things about mint, and I liked the 'dashboard' screenshots and such. Then I looked at how it worked, particularly "provide your bank credentials" part.

It didn't take long to realize how incredibly dangerous that was, and leave.

Banks should provide API access for services like this because it mitigates significant security issues.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ryan-c on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:48AM (#12974707)
They at least make it optional.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by JustSomeNobody on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:20AM (#12976772)
How does this, in any way, make it better that they do it at all?
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by 1ris on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:26PM (#12973713)
The second factor is the one time password. You get ~200 by snail mail and need one for each transaction. So you only give up control for one transfer. But yes, indeed, this is insane.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by duskwuff on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:47PM (#12974064)
So you need to order new passwords if you're making a lot of online purchases? That seems even more insane, really.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by chrisper on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:10PM (#12974175)
You do not have to use that service and there are also electronic versions of a one-time-password generator.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ctpide on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:06PM (#12974147)
Many banks now actually provide code generators, but yes in the past you would receive new codes every so often.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ThePadawan on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:15AM (#12975782)
Generally, as the bank also tracks the rate at which your passwords get invalidated (by being used), they will automatically send you a new sheet when there are only ~20 remaining on your current sheet.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by rak00n on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:37PM (#12974317)
What if snail mail gets stolen?
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by kybernetyk on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:32AM (#12975872)
In theory nothing bad happens as the person with the snail mail code list still needs your login/password to issue money transfers.

But then again ... you just handed your banking credentials to some shady fintech startup.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by biafra on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:01AM (#12975050)
You need to activate the next block of TANs with one of the previous.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by revelation on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:01PM (#12973563)
There isn't actually anything you can do with the login + password. Sure, you can look at the transactions, so I guess it's a privacy problem.

But any transaction or change usually requires generating a single use pin with your debit card and a small card reader. Some also use your mobile phone.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by bathory on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:32PM (#12973743)
That really depends.

Some banks dont require a code at all for known contacts. Some banks dont require a code at all for small amounts (under 50). Some banks send you a plain SMS with a one-time-password. Some banks send you an SMS with some additional information (receiver, amount) and a one-time-password. Some banks ask for a one-time-password from a dongle. Some banks ask for a one-time-password by entering a challenge code into your dongle and then the dongle generates the new one-time-password. etc.

What I am trying to say is, there is no real standard. The best method I've come across so far is a device in which you insert your debit card, enter your pin, then scan a QR code on the computerscreen and the device will actually show you the receiving IBAN + amount. After pressing OK you get a challenge that you have to enter on the website.

Also in the Netherlands the banks have an API they can use called iDEAL which does the same as "SOFORT" but instead of having "SOFORT" log in to your account, your actual bank immediately transfers the funds and sends an OK to the vendor.

It makes me really angry that bank security isnt standardized and that good systems like iDEAL dont find international adoption. Luxembourg is trying to develope its own version of iDEAL e.g.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by morgante on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:15PM (#12973649)
This is a solved problem. Credit cards work great.

The issue is that lots of merchants (particularly in the EU) simply don't want to deal with the fees associated with credit cards so come of up with lots of creative ways to externalize the cost of fraud to consumers.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by 1ris on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:32PM (#12973746)
No, they don't. They are completely insane aswell. They are like smart cards, but with the secret printed on them, visible for the world. If you want to clone them you don't need a highly advanced lab, you can just remember the number. You also share said "secret" with everybody you do business with.

Of course you constantly get your money stolen. You just don't notice because the loss is distributed evenly. That's why they are so expensive.

I'm suprised people use such a low tech system. I wouldn't even accept such authentication system for my throw-away reddit accounts, let alone for money.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by morgante on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:44PM (#12973800)
Sure, I don't dispute that credit cards are technically very simplistic and basically don't have any security.

The huge benefit of them is that almost all those security risks are externalized. If someone uses my credit card fraudulently, I don't pay any of the costs. Basically every alternative (Verified by Visa, etc.) is about shifting those liabilities back to the consumer.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by closeparen on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:25AM (#12974601)
The costs are distributed evenly, in the form of the markup on all products that covers the interchange fee and losses to charge backs.

You do pay them, but in small undetectable increments all the time instead of random surprise large losses.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by Hyperborian on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:23AM (#12975501)
Which is vastly superior to the alternative, which is taking on the liability myself and facing the possibility of being financially devastated by fraud and/or theft.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by closeparen on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:04PM (#12979193)
The best alternative is a system where the bank still carries the liability but the system is harder to defraud (i.e. because it does push instead of shared secrets authorizing pull).
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by briandear on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:55AM (#12975337)
So kind of like insurance?
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ChemicalWarfare on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:50PM (#12973834)
Technically "verified by visa" shifts the liability from the merchant towards the issuer.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by chrisper on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:13PM (#12974187)
Yes, but if your credit card gets stolen, it is not your money that is getting stolen. Credit card companies are okay with that. If a CC is convenient, a lot of people will use it. These companies don't care if they have to reimburse let's say 10% of all transactions. In this case convenience > security.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by kamjam on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:36AM (#12976190)
In the UK at least, all our payments in store above £20 require a PIN to be used (payments below £20 you can use the fairly recently introduced touch pay which just requires you to touch the card to the payment machine).

If you are purchasing online, all my credit and debit card payments require me to enter 3 random characters from my (previously set up) password.

Not sure what the system is like elsewhere in Europe/worldwide.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by mnw21cam on Thursday November 17, 2016 @09:33AM (#12977721)
> In the UK at least, all our payments in store above £20 require a PIN to be used...

Not true (notwithstanding that it increased to £30). Some people (myself included) have opted for a chip-and-signature card instead of chip-and-pin, because it is harder for the bank to push the cost of fraud onto me that way.

It's been only seven years (I think?) since chip-and-pin was introduced. It's amazing how quickly all the checkout staff have forgotten what to do when their till tells them to check the card signature. Also almost none of them actually have a pen to hand.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by kamjam on Tuesday November 22, 2016 @11:30AM (#13015196)
Did not know the limit had been increased, and agree about checkout staff having no clue when the pin does not work (happens a fair amount with foreign cards).

I've seen a lot of people in the US not sign their card and instead write "ask for ID", which seems like a much smarter move!

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by jamessb on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:45AM (#12976541)
The limit for contactless payments was raised from £20 to £30 last September (and when first introduced the limit was £10) [0]

[0]: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-31164806

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by Amezarak on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:41AM (#12977289)
> If you are purchasing online, all my credit and debit card payments require me to enter 3 random characters from my (previously set up) password.

Doesn't this mean your password is being stored unhashed?

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by Accacin on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:55AM (#12977418)
It's £30 now.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:42AM (#12974969)
They haven't been for a long time in the EU. All recently issued cards use two factor or are at least required to support it.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by art0rz on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:16AM (#12975132)
This works great, but some international merchants (some airlines in my case) don't support it yet. I've gotten my card declined with a relevant error message but no redirect to my bank's 2FA login page.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:58AM (#12977025)
I think it very much depends on your bank how it handles this. I haven't had a card rejected in a very long time.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by Symbiote on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:51AM (#12974999)
The EU has introduced limits for card fees, so there's no reason for merchants not to accept debit cards now.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by codedokode on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:42AM (#12976518)
If they don't want to pay the fees why don't they just develop some open payment protocol any bank and merchant could use? It would also solve the privacy problem with sending customer data to USA (Visa and MasterCard are both american companies).
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by dom0 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:58AM (#12975034)
> This is common practice in germany. The whole payment methode "sofortüberweisung" or "sofort" is based on this.

I've never used that and only one person I know did use it ever. And even that person felt rather uncomfortable about it. So I don't think it's very common.

A year ago or so it was also exposed that sofortüberweisung doesn't only do the transfer, they actually retrieve details of all recent transfers.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by darklajid on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:10AM (#12975091)
Well, given that they have all the login information (bank, user/account number, password/pin) they can basically access everything that is read-only and not TAN protected.

For my bank the transfers of the last month would be accessible right away, for example.

Honestly, I (German as well) didn't believe 1ris right of the bat and went to their website to prove someone wrong on the internet. Oh my was I wrong (apologies, 1ris). Horrible idea.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by vurpo on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:05AM (#12976338)
This is a common method of payment in Finland as well, but, the store always asks you to choose your bank, then redirects you to the online bank where you then authenticate and authorize the transfer on the bank's website. It then redirects you back to the merchant's website.

Basically, banks provide an API (similar to OAuth? I guess) where the merchant only asks the bank for a specific amount of money, and the authentication and authorization of the payment happens only directly between the customer and the bank.

Why would this be so hard to so in other countries?

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ptaipale on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:08AM (#12976698)
And note: the same authorization is mandatory also for credit card payments in Finnish web shops.

I.e. when you're ready with your shopping cart and click "pay", and give your credit card number, then next thing is a redirect to the bank's page (where you really should check the URL and SSL certificate...), you give your OTP for bank login, and this authorizes the credit card payment, you get a redirect back to the seller website and complete the transaction.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by mnw21cam on Thursday November 17, 2016 @09:36AM (#12977747)
> where you really should check the URL and SSL certificate...

Yeah, we are really training people to be vulnerable to phishing scams, aren't we.

The advice I give is that if you didn't type the URL of the bank web site into the address bar yourself, it may not be your actual bank you are talking to.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by djsumdog on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:23PM (#12973691)
I thought in Germany you used one-time disposable TAN numbers for this purpose?

Australia also has direct person-to-person/business money transfers, but without the one-time-use pins. That this company would even ask for a bank login is terrible and unnecessary.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by atomwaffel on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:22AM (#12975824)
> I thought in Germany you used one-time disposable TAN numbers for this purpose?

We do, Sofortüberweisung just acts as a man in the middle and passes through all TAN requests from the banking website to the client. They can't transfer money out of your account without your consent, but they can do just about anything else that doesn't require a TAN.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by dx034 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:37AM (#12976193)
If someone intercepts the traffic (a hack on sofort's server) they could read all transactions and account info without anyone noticing. Guess with that information you could make a lot of money phishing.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ChemicalWarfare on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:02PM (#12973872)
>>we urgently need a law that makes wire transferees instant

Not sure about Germany, in the US this is a "technical" issue with the way consumer banking settlement is implemented. The notification of the intent to move the funds is almost instantaneous, the actual clearing takes days in some cases.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by dx034 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:40AM (#12976207)
In the UK it was solved by making all small transfers instant, while large transfers (direct debits, salaries) are still settled overnight. That way most of the transfers are instant while >90% of the amount transferred is still settled. Avoids issues for the banks' cash management while it's convenient for the user at the same time.

I think the US has the problem that it had to set up that way when clearing was done physically (due to the size of the country) and it's now very costly to change, for very little benefit to the banks.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ascorbic on Thursday November 17, 2016 @09:48AM (#12977841)
Faster Payments aren't just for small transfers. The only limits are by individual banks, and they are normally in the thousands.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by dx034 on Friday November 18, 2016 @05:10AM (#12985659)
While that's true, they're still mostly used for rather small amounts. The payment volume is around 5% of all electronic payments [1].

Not saying that Faster Payments are not a good thing, but they would probably cause problems for banks if most money would be moved by it. It works well because the major source of cash management is done due to card payments, direct debits and Bacs. So the normal cash buffer a bank holds throughout the day is sufficient to do fast transactions.

[1] http://www.paymentsuk.org.uk/sites/default/files/publication...

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by hackinthebochs on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:01PM (#12973564)
What we need is just a secondary password with limited permissions and some fraud guarantees. There's no reason your bank account can't also act as a payments gateway with the right protections.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by wmf on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:32PM (#12973742)
We could call it... a credit card number.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ctpide on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:09PM (#12974163)
Yes, because that never got stolen in the past
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by wmf on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:00AM (#12974464)
Any password that you give out will be stolen; that's why "let's have a special secondary password" doesn't solve much. There are now passwordless ways to authenticate, authorize, prove identity, make payments, etc. so that's what we should be suggesting.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ctpide on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:13AM (#12974541)
Apple Pay is technically trying to solve this problem by providing one-time authentication keys for a specific transaction at time of payment. This sort of key can not be reused in another transaction... What exactly do you mean with other passwordless ways?
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by wmf on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:45AM (#12974692)
Basically OAuth, which allows you to prove to one site (e.g. a merchant) that you have an account at another site (e.g. a bank in this case). http://designingsocialinterfaces.com/patterns/The_Password_A...
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by biafra on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:18AM (#12975139)
To solve the problem with Sofortüberweisung it would be enough if my bank would just provide a digitally signed statement, that I authorized a payment and had enough funds at the time so they would execute it. I could take this statement, show it to the merchant and he could verify it by using a publicly known publlic key of that bank. If nothing better is available it could be the key they us on their website.

I wonder who is interested not to already have this. I can't be the first person with that idea.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by blauditore on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:04AM (#12975395)
From what I understand, this is basically what happens for most online credit card payments. If you enter your credentials, you're redirected to a verification page by the issuer where you have to enter a password or SMS-sent key. On success, this page then passes a signed token (or similar) back to the original online shop as confirmation.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by thirdsun on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:23AM (#12974878)
Is that actually true? I remember I used Sofortüberweisung once when I had to and it didn't feel (for a lack of a better term) as if I was sharing my credentials with Sofort.

It was a long time ago but I had the impression that they used some kind of legitimate connection to your bank (with TAN check and my original banking interface) and were only notified about the success (or failure) of the transaction while never receiving the sensitive credentials themselves.

Of course I may be wrong.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:39AM (#12974956)
Yes, they just scrape your banks online system.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by thesimon on Thursday November 17, 2016 @04:55AM (#12976011)
>as they would "hinder the adoption of innovative FinTec".

Which is not surprising considering the banks have their own similar scheme giropay/paydirekt and not allowing competitors doesn't seem that fair.

> IMHO we urgently need a law that makes wire transferees instant

SEPA Instant Transfers are coming 2018

PSD2 coming 2018 requires bank to provide API access to third parties as well, so this is basically a solved problem.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by codedokode on Thursday November 17, 2016 @06:10AM (#12976372)
What if the login credentials are stolen with a keylogger, will the hackers be able to transfer the money the same way? It looks totally insecure.

And as I understand the customer cannot charge back the payment later.

> IMHO we urgently need a law that makes wire transferees instant,

Why not just use card processing systems like Visa? Are the fees too high or are there privacy concerns with sending personal data to USA?

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by jnsaff2 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @05:18AM (#12976109)
In Estonia it was solved in a somewhat saner way: there is a unified framework with which customers can: - click on a Pay with Internet bank link - it directs you to your chosen bank's internet bank - you log in - the payment is already pre-filled and - once it is done the seller gets a signed confirmation from the bank that the transaction has actually happened.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by 77pt77 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:09AM (#12974806)
Some places solved this by creating one shot virtual VISA cards created at the banks website.

It's a good compromise that works almost everywhere.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by captn3m0 on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:12AM (#12975433)
.nl and .in have similar systems that allow one-time transfers to be made using your online bank account.

In .nl they have iDEAL, as someone already pointed out. In .in, we have to integrate with each bank individually, and there are several aggregators that do this for you, and you don't have to sign an agreement with each bank.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by gosubpl on Thursday November 17, 2016 @03:20AM (#12975482)
Yes, I have noticed. But thanks for the update again :) I think future is here, just it is not evenly distributed. But I really laugh when talking to someone who has just heard of this new exciting London or SV Fintech startup and learns that in some countries this is already forgotten history and we moved forward since :) I think Poland is more striking for them than The Netherlands as people are used to thinking about old Comm block countries as a bit backwards ;)
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ThomPete on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:17AM (#12977144)
Wiretransfer at least internationally can't be instant since there is no such thing as an international wiretransfer. What there is is a bunch of agreement between banks. So at least globally a law wont change anything.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by germanier on Thursday November 17, 2016 @10:24AM (#12978197)
Not only is there such a thing as a common system for international wire transfers in Europe (SEPA Credit Transfer, which is also used for domestic wires as well), instant payments are coming soon™ to that (supposedly end of next year): http://www.europeanpaymentscouncil.eu/index.cfm/sepa-instant...
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ThomPete on Thursday November 17, 2016 @11:02AM (#12978577)
Sure i was talking about globally.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by germanier on Thursday November 17, 2016 @11:21AM (#12978760)
The existence of SEPA shows that it might be viable on a larger scale. While the EU and EEA members already share a common legal framework, the other two SEPA members (San Marino and Monaco) don't (even though they cooperate closely with the EU in certain areas). With enough political will a larger payment area doesn't seem impossible. (But personally I can't imagine this to happen globally.)
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ascorbic on Thursday November 17, 2016 @09:44AM (#12977818)
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by gcb0 on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:26PM (#12974259)
that is actually great!

with one time password it does work.

In the USA, you give them a number (which is written on each check anyway) that allows anyone to empty your account if so they wish, with absolutely no passwords or anything else.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by candiodari on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @08:55PM (#12973533)
From the merchant's perspective this works because bank transfers have to be free for both the source and the destination. So banks have an incentive to sabotage this and they will. By contrast bank fees on credit cards can go close to 6% now. That's why you get cashback offers, points, ... on credit card offers.

I think a lot of people (but not banks) would be very keen on having regulated fees for transfers. Of course, not banks.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by morgante on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:17PM (#12973657)
> By contrast bank fees on credit cards can go close to 6% now.

I'm not sure where you're getting your info, but that's off by a factor of 2.

Credit cards work great for consumers, just not merchants.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by 1ris on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:41PM (#12973786)
Guess who pays for them. It's not the merchants.

But you are right about credit cards, it's not that much.

Right now I'm more or less fored to use paypal. They offer a very similar service. I'm paying a tiny bit less than 10% of my income directly to paypal.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by morgante on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:45PM (#12973809)
Huh? Merchants definitely are the ones who pay card processing fees.

Some small merchants offer cash discounts, but that's comparatively very rare.

Edit: since you mentioned Paypal, I agree that they're horrible to both merchants and consumers. Stay far away if you can. (In fact, I'm curious why you're using Paypal instead of someone friendlier like Stripe.)

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by ctpide on Thursday November 17, 2016 @12:18AM (#12974569)
In my experience merchants in Australia often add the fee directly at checkout. You can't really pass on the costs any more direct than that. They often do provide PayPal for checkout, which is why I expect people use it. Stripe is simply not present, so how could we use it?
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by morgante on Thursday November 17, 2016 @11:58AM (#12979131)
I'm mostly speaking from the US perspective, where credit card surcharges are extremely rare for online transactions (and only slightly less rare for offline ones).

Stripe is meant as a suggestion for merchants, not customers.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by cgriswald on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:56PM (#12973856)
The merchants pass on those costs in the form of higher prices. The better your rewards the more someone else is subsidizing your credit card fees, but you're not breaking even either.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by morgante on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:10PM (#12973911)
Sure, in the same sense that merchants pass on all costs in the form of higher prices.

That being said, if you play it right you can actually make far more in rewards than the merchants paid. There's a whole subculture devoted to it: I routinely earn around 4-5% back, to the point that I prefer to pay my taxes via credit card even with the surcharge.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by callalex on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:35PM (#12974308)
What a perverted system of middlemen who provide no value to the economy.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by morgante on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @11:42PM (#12974351)
Yea! Except for providing seamless global payments, distributed credit provisioning, fraud protection, rewards, travel benefits, purchase insurance, what have credit cards ever done for the economy?!
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by 1ris on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:50PM (#12973838)
I'm very sure it completely tickles down, although I have nothing to back that up.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by dublinben on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:09PM (#12973608)
Credit card transaction fees are regulated at a much lower level in Europe.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by cmdrfred on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @09:18PM (#12973662)
I don't understand why we don't do that here. People like the rewards but that only works because the cost of those rewards is subsided by a price increase for everyone, even the people paying cash.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by biafra on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:12AM (#12975109)
I wonder, why we do not have cash prices and whenever you want to use a credit card you have to pay the fee on top.

I heard this is in the contracts between merchants and credit card companies. Merchants are not allowed to make prices more transparent to consumers or they will lose the ability to accept credit card payments.

Can anybody confirm that?

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by nickles on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:21PM (#12973960)
>> Credit card transaction fees are regulated at a much lower level in Europe.

> I don't understand why we don't do that here.

It really comes down to allowing markets to operate efficiently. Such regulation, in order to be work as intended, creates a price ceiling for the credit card market. This ceiling produces a deadweight loss (in this case, you would likely see it as either a reduction in the aggregate quantity of credit extended to consumers or the perks associated with using the card like fraud protection, ability to file charge backs, and customer support). On the whole (producer surplus + consumer surplus), you will observe such a loss.

Now what makes the government more capable of determining appropriate prices than market participants themselves? Allowing a competitive market to determine prices for credit services will drive the cost of the services to an efficient level. Given that governments are tasked with many pressing issues, it's reasonable to believe that they can only afford to put so many resources into assessing price levels for each regulated good or service. However, each market participant is able to focus solely on determining a price for the product offered. Even if the government can determine the optimal price level for the market, there is necessarily a lag time for the regulation to be passed and implemented, reducing the ability of the market to respond to systemic shocks and changing conditions.

Along different lines, if price regulations on credit card fees are acceptable, should the government install price ceilings on housing (causing reduced incentive to build more) and other markets? Should the price of all meals at restaurants be capped at $10 so more people can dine out? In the latter example it's easier to imagine the ramifications of a price ceiling, but the same market forces are at work.

> People like the rewards but that only works because the cost of those rewards is subsided by a price increase for everyone, even the people paying cash.

That's not true in specific, observable cases, and I suspect it's not true in general either.

To provide concrete examples, many gas stations and vending machines offer discounts for paying with cash instead of card, specifically to avoid the impact of fees on their prices. Additionally, vendors can choose to set minimum thresholds at which they accept credit cards, in order to mitigate the impact on their pricing and profitability.

In general, I assume the rewards are not truly subsidized by merchant fees. From my recollection of previous reading on the subject (I'd appreciate more accurate numbers if someone can provide them), merchants pay 3% to accept the credit card. ~2.5% of the fee is consumed by the cost of fraud. The remainder is split between the payment processor (e.g. Stripe), the issuing bank, and the credit card company. Clearly in a world of 2% rewards cards, a 3% fee does not allow for fraud protection, servicing expenses, and rewards.

My guess is that rewards programs only become feasible when you consider the interest charged on unpaid balances. Somewhere on the order of 50% - 70% of consumers carry debt on their credit cards. At 6% - 30% APR, this expense can reasonably cover the perks conferred by a credit card. If all consumers suddenly stopped carrying debt on credit cards, I suspect rewards programs would disappear rapidly.

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by dublinben on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @10:41PM (#12974035)
To elaborate on this further, a competitive market in payments allows for a great diversity in interchange rates for different payment types.[0] This allows competing payment networks (Visa, Mastercard, AmEx, etc.) to offer the exact most efficient rate for a transaction, based on their actual costs. Under a regulated system, less risky transactions would be subsidizing more risky transactions, because the rates are capped. Our current system allows a major grocery retailer like Costco to have flat rates at $0.30 per transaction.

[0] https://usa.visa.com/dam/VCOM/download/merchants/Visa-USA-In...

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by Sacho on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:35AM (#12975231)
I found your analysis very interesting but I think one thing is missing from it.

Once a product or service becomes ubiquitous, people will sign on partly due to the social pressure of being left out - e.g. I might get a social media account just in case my friends want to chat to me there, or a credit card because it is the primary method for online payment.

Customers like this are not necesaarily as engaged with the product/service as the initial, enthusiastic ones. The difference in engagement creates a pyramid scheme of perverse incentives, where the companies create more and more benefits for their "engaged" customers and offload the costs to everyone else. Companies get really good at evaluating just how mich cost to offload without disturbing the largely unengaged customers.

This leads to the creation of a secondary market, where you compete on extra features for the engaged part of your consumer base. Here on HN, we proudly acknowledge this fact when companies cater to geeks and techies - if i like your product, I will convince my relatives to use it.

This practice ia not neceasarily malicious, but the cost ofnpleasing your engaged consumers muat naturally come from somewhere. When a credit company adds bonuses and incentives, they are not trying to serve the interests of all their consumers.

I don't know if government intervention is appropriate in this case, especially simple and heavy-handed rules like a price ceiling. However, in this case, the incentives of the government are more closely aligned with that of all the consumers, compared to the company.

(I hope this post was coherent, I rarely write on mobile)

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by Symbiote on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:02AM (#12975054)
The EU cap is 0.2% for debit cards, so for transactions under €150, everyone gets that super Costco rate or less. Alternatively, the cap can be set to €0.05.

The card companies still appear to be making good profits.

http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=uriserv%3...

Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by dublinben on Thursday November 17, 2016 @01:57PM (#12980273)
The problem with capping the rate for all transactions is that some riskier transactions simply cost more than this to process. Without being able to charge more for them, processors will likely make the decision to just not handle these. Suddenly, entire industries and classes of customer will be shut out of the network, simply because they can't be charged fairly.
Re:Site requests bank logins for online purchases by kekub on Thursday November 17, 2016 @02:41AM (#12975255)
Let me elaborate on that:

For a German it is common to have a "check account". The underlying system is called "girocard". It contains a module for paying in stores (electronic cash) and another one for withdrawing money from cash dispensers ("Deutsches Geldautomaten-System"). In addition to that most banks offer their customers access to "maestro" (some debit card service from Master Card) and V-Pay (same as maestro but from Visa). Credit cards are only popular among the younger population as they need them to buy things online (iTunes, Google Play, etc...). However the "check accounts" come with a different kind of insurance. You can read quite a lot about that online, my personal experience is the following: If somebody steals (no matter how) 200€ from your credit card the bank will cancel the transaction immediately, if the same happens with your "check account" you need to go to court to get it back.

Having this system you might imagine why our online-banking is overly complex: You have to login with a username and a password[=PIN] (for some banks you have a fixed username, at others you can choose one). Afterwards you are allowed to send someone money. Therefore you require another one-time-password[=TAN]. This TAN can be obtained in multiple ways: 1. Snake Mail (Just a printed TAN list asking you for a random free TAN), 2. Snake Mail (A printed TAN list asking you for a specific TAN at a given index), 3. Snake Mail (A printed TAN list asking you for a specific TAN at a given index and returning a verification code, that is also printed on the list), 4. Mobile TAN (TAN via SMS), 5. Push TAN (TAN via Banking App), 6. Photo TAN / QR TAN (Optical System which works with pub/priv key to verify your transaction), 7. Chip TAN (Special device that uses the chip in your card to verify your transaction).

After you verified your transaction it takes up to three days before the recievers bank notifies the reciever that he got the money. The real joke is, that everything regarding payments can be transmitted in real time. However some banks make use of these days to generate more interest.

End of the story: If you want to pay something online and you want to recieve it quick you need to either use a Credit Card or some proprietary system that your bank might support (see paydirekt, giropay). As both might not be available for some users they either have to wait for 3 days for their money to arrive at the reciever or use a untrustworthy service like sofortüberweisung (which scans all your transactions and predicts your accountability [Disclaimer: If I remember correctly, German Ref. http://www.pcwelt.de/news/Datenschuetzer-alarmiert-Sofortueb...).