In this case it's a minor thing which probably wouldn't require much maintainance, but you have to draw the line somewhere.
If option for backspace behaviour suddenly starts interfering with some unrelated feature, it means somebody seriously fucked up the architecture of the project. Nothing else. Configuration flags aren't scary, and should not be used as a rationalization for dumbing down software.
In this case, the right thing really is contextual, so a configuration or extant setting / default is worth the cost in complexity.
The quote "Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler" comes to mind here.
From the maintainer's point-of-view, having the option to bind "backspace" to "window.history.back" shouldn't require any more maintenance than having the option to bind "alt-left" to "window.history.back" does.
It is Google's fault that they didn't make Chrome work this way. It also means I can't unbind "ctrl-shift-q" from "quit_immediately_without_asking", because Google refuse to add an option to make it so that I can't accidentally fat-finger a C-w into something that ends my entire session. All keyboard shortcut problems disappear instantly if key bindings are configurable, however, without adding new options for each command.
This is a shortcut button … The maintenance argument is really a straw-man in this case …
> but you have to draw the line somewhere.
And this shows that they chose to place this line at «this product is our product, there is no customization options»
That said, I'm glad they finally did something to fix this bad UX design.
leaving it enabled also allows them to do this, which they have done for the last couple years and clearly their data says that it's not worth supporting, because now they're dropping it.
[1] https://www.thestar.com/news/insight/2016/01/16/when-us-air-...
Any idea what could block it? Never seen this before...
Many CDNs can be configured to block access within a country. For whatever reason, that's what The Star has chosen here.
now if only our cars are as adjustable, given the almost-similar circumstances
I think the second is more of an optimization because when you click on the address bar you're most likely either copying or overwriting the URL. It's much less common to modify it.
If you want a supremely annoying address bar, you should check out Windows File Explorer from Vista/7 onward. Each component of the URI is a drop down menu item and only by clicking on whitespace to the far right can you get to the actual URI.
If you're in folder "C:\foo\bar\baz\boz\" and want to go to "C:\foo\" it's just one mouse click. Or if you want to go to "C:\foo\bor" that's just two mouse clicks. Much faster than clicking "back" or "up" multiple times.
I agree with parent, the adress bar should be the adress bar. Also better for sans-mouse-use. Just F6 and end, ctrl+shift+left arrow until you get to before "bar" and then backspace, enter.
Sure, it's more input but it's still way faster than reaching for your mouse.
No, it's unpredictable amount of clicks, drags and scrolls to unpredictable places, if C:\foo\bor is not immediately visible in the tree view. And worse, if there is "bor" in every one of 100 "foos" you have on C:.
Going from memory since I couldn't reproduce this behavior in 7. Could also be wrong about 10; someone else should try it and confirm.
Yeah, I remember doing it once and thinking it was extremely helpful at the time, but I only remember doing it once so far.
Actually, I’m one of the people who like that so much, I enabled it even in KDE Dolphin.
EDIT: Due to submission restrictions, I can’t answer right now – I’ll have to wait about an hour before I can answer comments, sorry.
To me that address bar abomination is just an obfuscation of otherwise useful information with large clickable regions of functionality I don't want.
My main computer is a Mac and I very much wish its "Finder" had navigation tools as nice as the "breadcrumb bar" you are describing in Windows.
It's not completely the same as on Windows, but:
- Shift-Apple-G lets you enter a directory path to open (including bash-like completion with tab).
- Option-Apple-P shows/hides the "path bar" at the lower edge of a window where the hierarchy of the current folder is displayed (including a spartan context menu).
On Windows I mainly use the explorer address bar to go to those hidden folders like ProgramData.
I think there is also a "show breadcrumbs" option in the preferences for Finder, which may or may not give more of the functionality you want.
Well, the tree view in dolphin is small, and mostly hidden by the bookmark menu.
So I have to resort to using the breadcrumbs as a poor (wo-)mans tree view.
You can also right click the bar to edit or copy the URI...
It's the fact it's inconsistent on my platform (KDE on Debian GNU/Linux) exacerbates the annoyance. I should not have to consider which application I'm in, in order to preempt the way the scrollbar / mouse will work.
With the second - I appreciate that for many people, for much of the time, you're wanting to type something else into the address bar. However, on MS Windows you have to type ctrl-c / ctrl-v to copy / paste. On real operating systems <tm> you just have to select the region -- so having a whole line selected for you when you click near it is unwanted.
But ultimately it's the inconsistency. I need to consider if I'm clicking in the address bar, or another text box, in order to predict what's about to be selected.
And, yes, the Win7 explorer bar has moved me to tears also. I can highly recommend the breadcrumbkiller [1] - even if you don't install it, the rant on that guy's page is well worth reading.
[1] http://twigstechtips.blogspot.com.au/2010/02/win7-remove-win...
On the other hand selecting the text in the URL bar in any other way (with mouse drag, triple click, or keyboard) will update the selection.
(Unless I'm mistaken, the right-click copy uses a different clipboard, so you can't use that.)
I liked it (back when it existed on Mac OS X): By moving the mouse horizontally to the vertical scroll bar I could instantly return to where I started scrolling. Use case: Read something (web page, source code...), scroll around to look for related information, then return back to the exact position I was before.
> Each component of the URI is a drop down menu item and only by clicking on whitespace to the far right can you get to the actual URI.
And you also have the confusing "copy address" / "copy address as text" context menu.
I use drag to scroll assigned to my right mouse button (works great in FF, so so in Chrome):
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/grab-and-drag...
https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/scrollbar-anywhere...
I miss this so much outside my browser...
I think some of those complaints reaching the front page of reddit may have helped spur this into action by the Chrome team.
Backspace to go back, OTOH, I was aware of, but I doubt I ever wanted. Alt-Left is easier to use because it's less modal. Still bothers me in general when devs screw with established defaults.
I do find the spacebar behavior isn't super predictable when I am trying to pause things, such as youtube .
I've never managed to consistently replicate it by having had the player in/out of focus already, not/scrolled, etc. odd.
EDIT: and before anyone points out that if I'm already using extensions I could easily add another, yes and I would if I had to, but it's not ideal, because 1. Extensions crash, fail to load, or aren't allowed by internal browser pages, and 2. You sometimes have to use other peoples' machines and it's annoying when basic functionality is locked away.
I've never actually seen someone complain about it until now.
Frankly, I would be perfectly happy if space to page went away entirely. I exclusively use two finger dragging on laptops and scroll wheels on desktops to browse websites. I never use space to move down a whole page at a time, and that's a jarring action anyway because it inevitably causes me to lose the context of where I was reading in the document in a way that smooth scrolling accomplished through other means does not.
I don't have a scroll wheel or a touch screen.
The gaming instance is a failure of Web controls to adequately adapt to context. I can see how that would be distracting. I am not willing to sacrifice my space-to-scroll capabilities on that account.
As with Fitts' law, the spacebar is a very large target. Easy to hit. Frequent action. Well-placed use.
You do raise one other point: scrolling tends to make re-aquiring reading point difficult. That's a fair gripe and one that annoys me.
I'm particularly sensitive to it in DuckDuckGo, which smooth-scrolls a pre-set amount in the SERP when scrolling (I forget if by up/down, pgup/pgdwn, space, or other). I absolutely cannot figure out where I was and where I want to be, and have reported this multiple times.
For long-form text, I've taken a strong preferene, in portrait display devices (my tablet when reading) to fully paginated text, and a page flip mode. Much as PDF is an abysmal format in many ways, I find the capability to retain a spatial memory of where content is on a book or in a page is useful, and generally prefer this to smooth-scrolling.
Pocket, which offers a page-flip mode, makes it both brittle and of limited utility. Any up-down motion whilst flipping a page "breaks" page-flip mode and returns to scroll.
Page-flip doesn't clearly indicate location within the work as a whole (Pocket also mutes the scrollbar indicator generally).
And lastly, the pages aren't consistently presented -- effectivly Pocket repaginates a document whenever and wherever you enter into Page Flip mode. I'd prefer it had a sense of what the pagination breaks were for a given viewport size and font selection, and stuck to that.
Or I could read a book....
> I don't have a scroll wheel or a touch screen.
I use the middle button + trackpoint for scrolling - works great. That's the default on most Linux distros/desktop environments, might require some configuration on Windows.
Fitts' Law.
I don't find it jarring at all to read that way, because I know where to resume reading after hitting space. There is one exception: a lot of websites with absolutely-positioned headers scroll incorrectly when you hit space, such that the point you would resume reading at ends up behind the header, and you have to scroll up a bit to reveal it.
A few websites with headers get it right, and your resume point is below the header after hitting space. This makes me much less sympathetic to the websites that screw it up.
I do use paginated reading on my Kindle, which always gets it right. It doesn't quite work properly on the web often enough though.
It's a race to the bottom.
Thankfully on OSX/Safari, this legacy behavior/cruft is not present.
Also, Lazarus is an old plugin for Firefox that saves forms between sessions/refreshes. Too bad goog want to capture new users at any expense. If it doesn't work because the latest hotness is js forms that's a problem with webdevs.
I think there's an argument to be made in either direction.
I use Chrome (and other apps like Sublime) on three different platforms and would much prefer to have commonality on the application level. Since it's a big part of my workflow, having it work differently from OS to OS would definitely slow me down.
The problem, I think, comes down to this -- more people use lots of different applications on one platform, than the same application on multiple platforms.
If you're going to use one application only, on multiple platforms, then I could see how a consistency in the way that application behaved would be useful. But I can't see how anyone's workflow wouldn't involve interacting with some number of other applications on each of those platforms.
At that point you could assert all applications on all platforms behave consistently. This is not likely to be a well-received suggestion. Or you could try to make all applications on a particular platform behave consistently. The latter seems to align with people's UI expectations, and, for the most part, is what we have out there now. The pain point is where expected behaviour from one platform bleeds into applications running on different platform where that behaviour might best be described as 'surprising'.
This is one of the annoyances on Windows. On Linux/OSX you can click and drag on the URL to select a portion of the string, but on Windows it auto-highlights the full string completely, forcing one to reclick again (slowly!) to highlight a portion.
Also: right-clicking on a link in Linux/OSX auto-highlights the full link text so you can `Copy` or `Search on Google` the highlighted text. In Windows you must manually highlight the link, then right-click on it.
Small things add up to big annoyances.
Works fine on Windows. Just don't click into the address bar before dragging and everything works as you'd expect. With clicking first you have a selection, though, and dragging that will do drag & drop of text instead.
Wait, they removed that (I didn’t do the update yet, refused to connect to WiFi to avoid it).
I quite literally use that every minute – typing on UK layout German and British, and trained the dictionary to accept any mix of the two languages.
The kind of people who are willing to go to the Advanced Configuration Settings page are also willing to tweak their keyboard mappings to map any modifier key they want to to the "go back in history" accelerator for Chrome.
My defence here is that the test matrix for the way it worked already existed.
And the change would have included some unit tests.
Further, neither the way it worked, or was changed to work, is an especially complex mechanism.
Developer explanations in the bug reports for both were not 'this is going to be hard to maintain', but instead were 'having this configurable will confuse users'.
Edit: they could maintain a flag to change these behaviours though, if they were a concern. You could also build your own copy of the browser, patched as you wish... ;-)
It used to be different, but that behavior unfortunately has made it to default in OS X now. It annoys me to no small extend, since I very frequently want to edit URL's to remove session ID's or reference tokens. Of course, the average user is to daft to double-click...
If you do a search for "JavaScript" and then later perform a search for Java by typing "Java[Enter]", it will do a search for "JavaScript" instead, possibly before you have time to react. To prevent this, you have to stop before pressing [Enter] for each search to make sure it doesn't auto-fill, then press backspace if it did.
This feature cannot be turned off, and the faster you are at typing, the more aggravating it is.
There's been a general trend in computing for a while now to not have any kind of configurability. You can see it in most of the major UIs now. And from what I've read on tech discussion forums, techies themselves absolutely hate configurability: they complain that they don't want to have to slog through a bunch of configuration options for everything, they want things to be set up to their preference out-of-the-box.
- Make changes that annoy some users
- For fear of annoying anyone, keep adding without ever removing, increase the number of settings, in other words bloat. Until a new, "lighter" alternative products comes and everyone moves out from your bloated product
So yes, by removing features that they realized weren't good one, they're keeping the product simple.
If I wanted the entire URL highlighted I could just double click on it like in every single other piece of software.
Worst feature EVER. I can't begin count how many times I've had the following talk with users:
user: My password doesn't work
me: Did you copy it from Outlook?
Problem solved.
It's terrible. Really.
I was going to see if it happened here but I can't highlight any of your comment while typing mine.. I can only highlight inside this text box. Good job I don't want to quote anything.
What Linux users wanted was for it to behave normally - i.e. not auto select, but set primary selection if you selected something in the URL. The auto select was apparently non-negotiable, so we ended up with the current compromise.
It does set the primary selection if you manually select some/all of the URL though.
Isn't Chromium opensource? I'm sure they'll accept your pull request.
Evidently the kinds of people that can't be bothered going into the Advanced Configuration Settings page would be confused by an additional item in the Advanced Configuration Settings page.
I never used the backspace button for back (though it's probably what's mapped to my mouse button #8 - I'll know on the next upgrade), but I did get mightily annoyed by two changes a while back, and am always happy to bring them up whenever there's a story about Chrom* devs doing this kind of thing.
1. snap-to-mouse - while dragging the scrollbar, if you move the mouse further than ~80 pixels away from the scrollbar column, the page jumps back to the original location - apparently MS Windows users love this feature, but chrome/chromium is the only application I've found on GNU/Linux that does this, and
2. clicking inside the URL bar selects the whole contents - apparently MS Windows users are used to this feature, but chrome/chromium is the only application I've found on GNU/Linux that does this.
No idea what the defaults are for OSX, and, really, it doesn't matter - these features should be sensitive to extant defaults on whatever desktop environment the browser finds itself running on.