Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by hacknat on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:43PM
(#11357954)
To all the people dissing this plan from afar you have no idea how bad Seattle has gotten in the last three years. Over 100k people have moved into the metro area every year for three years.
My commute times changed noticeably over the course of one year. It went from consistently 30 minutes over the 90 bridge to consistently an hour (we're talking 18 miles, door to door).
This thing should have been built in the 70s.
My wife and I actually moved back to the Midwest 2 months ago after living in Seattle for 8 years, despite my comfortable Senior Engineer salary, because all of our closest friends moved away in the span of a year, because they could no longer afford to live in the city (none of them worked in tech).
I wish Seattle good things from afar, and it will always hold a special place in my heart, but I'm glad I'm not living through these infrastructure growing pains that should have been addressed years ago.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by erikw on Thursday March 24, 2016 @11:13PM
(#11358282)
I think that economics will sort out the cost-of-living issues. Seattle doesn't seem to have the NIMBYism of the Bay Area, and Washington State actually requires that communities plan for growth under the state Growth Management Act. I'm not sure how this compares to California (witness the unencumbered sprawl of LA, or the inability to build anything in the Bay Area), but from what I've seen, local Washington governments are not pretending that population growth is a fantasy. Seattle's growth plan specifically mentions "directing growth to existing urban centers and villages", so I can see how the proposed Sound Transit line extensions would help facilitate urbanization.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by specialist on Friday March 25, 2016 @12:23PM
(#11360932)
I hope so.
Seattle, Vancouver, SF, etc need to upzone, to permit more development, so that supply can meet demand. As I understand it, that upzoning is not happening nearly fast enough.
Public transit initiatives trigger (begats?) upzoning. This is an end run around the regressive restrictions on property taxes and entrenched NIMBYism.
I fully support it. Whatever works. I wish my peeps working on affordability, homelessness, economic justice would put less emphasis on set asides, protecting older listings, etc, and place more emphasis on increasing inventory.
One potential monkeywrench of increasing supply is absentee landlords. I just read something like 1/3rd of Vancouver properties are owned by Chinese investors. Which I'm totally cool with so long as the units are mostly occupied.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by NotSammyHagar on Sunday March 27, 2016 @03:21PM
(#11371118)
Seattle does have plenty of stupid people like every other place. People that vote against all road building because they only want bike lanes or transit. People that vote against transit because they don't want poor people coming where they are (really this happens, search for Kemper Freeman initiatives to keep the poor people out of bellevue).
We have to do increase all modes of transportation. The problem with this proposal is that it will take 25+ years. We need a 10 year version of this plan. Charge us rich programmers more, we can afford it.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by erikw on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:25PM
(#11357900)
Trains are very cool, and the idea of shared public transportation is probably noble, but there is an intractable economic problem. If my wife and I both take the train, it costs twice as much to us. If we drive somewhere, it costs half as much.
Additional issues that need to be solved to make pubtrans competitive with car ownership are scheduling, the ability to bring cargo, and negative class connotation. And this completely discounts the probable arrival of ubiquitous autonomous electric vehicles before Sound Transit even gets to finish this project. As much as I enjoy the romantic nature of trains, I think the Puget Sound is gearing up for a folly of a white elephant.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by greggman on Thursday March 24, 2016 @10:14PM
(#11358071)
Have you calculated how much you're actually spending per day?
I roughly calculated my expenses once.
$32k car $8k tax/license + loan interest up to point I paid it off = $50k
$200 gas a month for 6 years = $14400
$4k renew service plan
$1200 a year car ins $7200
2 sets of tires at $1k each = $2k
100k miles on it at 6 years
So $50k+14.4k+4k+7.2k+2k = $77.6k / 100k miles = 0.77 cents per mile.
My commute was 40miles each way or $61 PER DAY!!! That's a TON more than public transportation. That price will slowly go down the longer I keep the car but still, $61 per day is a lot of money. At 20days month that's $1220 a month. That's far more than 2 people's monthly transportation passes.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by erikw on Thursday March 24, 2016 @10:46PM
(#11358207)
Living in Seattle or the Bay Area, most people "have to" have a car, so I see it as a sunk cost, rather than amortized. I'm impressed with the political will that it must have taken to plan a line from Everett to Tacoma. With that kind of community planning, the Puget Sound may be more like NYC than the Bay Area in 25 years. The duplicitous rail options interoperating within the Bay Area fiefdoms- Muni, VTA, Caltrain, BART... are ridiculous. Seattle can't do anything to improve their weather, but for those who don't mind being damp, I think it's an easy choice over the Bay Area, and they are proving that they can think long term.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by jschwartzi on Friday March 25, 2016 @11:08AM
(#11360444)
What about the inevitable repairs on a used car? I find that I spend another 1000/yr on things that break in my car because it is off-warranty. Also, gas prices are more like 2.80 to 3.50 here in Seattle, historically.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by marssaxman on Friday March 25, 2016 @12:05PM
(#11360830)
I spend at least $2000/year on things that break in my car (and I've never owned a car new enough to know what is or isn't covered by a warranty), because it's a Range Rover and replacement parts cost more than you think they should. That's still far less than I'd be spending on monthly payments if I had a newer car, and insurance is cheap since I don't have a loan company requiring me to sign up for the expensive comp/collision package, so I feel like I'm coming out way ahead.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by marssaxman on Friday March 25, 2016 @12:14PM
(#11360880)
The total cost of ownership only matters if you are deciding whether to own a car at all, and that is really less a question of cost than your willingness to change your lifestyle around a commitment to non-car-ownership and stop doing the things which are only feasible when you have a car.
For decisions about any individual trip, gas price really is most of the issue, because you're already committed to paying for the option of driving whether or not you choose to exercise it in any particular instance.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by MikeHolman on Thursday March 24, 2016 @10:04PM
(#11358036)
I live in Seattle, and what you're saying doesn't really ring true to me. First, many employers pay for a card that you can use for public transit. So it will be free for a large percentage of people during the all important rush hours. Second, driving is expensive in Seattle. The 520 bridge costs money, parking costs money, the carpool lane costs money.
If you opt for the free I90 bridge or don't use carpool lane, you are going to be sitting in traffic, basically no matter the time of day. And if you are driving within the city limits, you have to deal with parking. There is Uber, and for going around within the city, this is viable. But if you are going longer distances it becomes cost-prohibitive for many people.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by Grishnakh on Friday March 25, 2016 @12:23PM
(#11360931)
SkyTran solves all the problems that come with trains and light rail, which are 19th-century technology. Too bad everyone is happy to spend hundreds of billions of dollars on a crappy public transit system that is so slow and inconvenient that no one wants to use it, when it's entirely possible to build a system which is cheaper and much faster and more convenient, but everyone thinks it's sci-fi (but somehow, automated cars aren't).
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by specialist on Friday March 25, 2016 @12:26PM
(#11360943)
I'd still like to understand how the Seattle Monorail failed, got spiked. I'd been thinking it was for want of a champion. But now I wonder if the missing ingredient was triggering upzoning.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by melling on Thursday March 24, 2016 @11:06PM
(#11358262)
Well, you can always use unromantic buses. At some point automobiles and population growth cause too much traffic and people waste their lives in traffic.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by greggman on Thursday March 24, 2016 @10:19PM
(#11358090)
It's a fair comparison and one I make often. Example: My friends and I could take public transport 10 miles. It might cost $5 per person. For four people that's $20. $20 might pay for a cab for all four of us.
Same with planes. I could fly or drive from LA to Vegas. Flying is $240 per person friday to sunday. 4 people = $960. 1 car carrying 4 people will be a lot less even if I rent it.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by jacalata on Friday March 25, 2016 @03:21AM
(#11358863)
Your comparison is valid for the scenario 'whats the difference in price for x people to make this trip by car or plane'. His comparison was 'how does the cost of the trip change if I go from one to two people for either method of travel'. Assuming he and his wife operate as a single financial unit, then the cost of the trip by car does not change when they both travel somewhere instead of one person travelling, and you have to make that assumption or his mention of 2 train tickets being more expensive makes no sense.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by WalterBright on Thursday March 24, 2016 @10:26PM
(#11358131)
Ironically, the existing tracks from Renton to Bothell could have been used for half of a light rail system for a song. But the government has desperately pretended those tracks don't exist, and has gone to considerable lengths to destroy them.
A few years earlier, they destroyed the tracks from Renton to Black Diamond so thoroughly the right-of-way can never be used for rail again.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by OrwellianChild on Friday March 25, 2016 @03:48AM
(#11358927)
This interests me... Do you have any articles I can read about this?
I was always under the impression that the Sounder (our commuter heavy rail line) used tracks shared with commercial traffic (BNSF, etc.) and thus couldn't be fully developed into a city-wide system...
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by WalterBright on Friday March 25, 2016 @06:11AM
(#11359287)
Nothing has run on the tracks for 20 years. Some of it has been pulled up, but the right-of-way remains.
Seattle Transit just announced a $50 billion plan to blast new right-of-way, never mind the trackage could be doubled by re-using that right-of-way for a few million.
although it has been renamed "Cross Kirkland Corridor" in their attempt to hide what it is. Sound Transit prefers a plan that costs one thousand times as much, still won't serve the eastside, and will not be in service until half the existing taxpayers are long dead.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by Twirrim on Friday March 25, 2016 @10:03AM
(#11360107)
It's not Sound Transit's fault. The cities won't let them. Kirkland wants them to build out Buses and threatens to veto any light rail project. Residents by the CKC want to "save the trail" (aka we're selfish jerks that bought a property by a railway line, but don't want noise of trains)
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by NotSammyHagar on Sunday March 27, 2016 @03:26PM
(#11371133)
There are reasons why they can't be used. The city of kirkland has lots of residents against it. But more importantly, the tracks don't really go to the city centers that we need. I think we are so desperate we should try using them, as it would cost much less.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by specialist on Friday March 25, 2016 @12:33PM
(#11360999)
Yes, that lost opportunity saddens me.
The Eastside (the Kemper Freeman Jr cohort) has traditionally spiked anything resembling public transit, public good, regional bon ami. Apart from their public statements about "those people", I assume their primary bare knuckled motivation is that anything that hurts Seattle helps Bellevue (landlords). Which I'm totally fine with, love and war and all that. I just hate the hypocrisy.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by stevewilhelm on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:50PM
(#11357982)
Building transit infrastructure is expensive and time consuming in metropolitan areas.
Case in point: a five mile extension on an existing Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) line and one new station cost $890 million and took seven years to build. [1]
The resulting extension is expected to increase in ridership by 5000 to 7000 daily trips in the next decade. [2]
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by greggman on Thursday March 24, 2016 @10:21PM
(#11358098)
I have a strong feeling much of that is corruption and/or over charging. I have no proof but AFAICT Singapore and Tokyo have no trouble building new lines quickly and for far less money and I suspect they both do a better job.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by JDDunn9 on Friday March 25, 2016 @04:03AM
(#11358954)
I wish someone would give PRT a chance. Something like skyTran could be built for 1/5th the cost and would be significantly faster for commuters (since most time is spent at stops before yours).
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by Grishnakh on Friday March 25, 2016 @12:32PM
(#11360985)
Yep, I say this all the time, and people think it's an even crazier idea than bigfoot and alien sightings.
Somehow, it's realistic to think about us all having self-driving cars dealing with the chaos of city traffic and pedestrians, and it's realistic to propose spending billions and billions of dollars on slow light-rail systems which require years of construction where the roads are all torn up, but it's completely bonkers to think about building a system with elevated rails hanging on utility poles and small, autonomous cars riding on these rails for only $1 million per mile.
I can't wait until Israel has their SkyTran system working so all these idiots in America won't be able to say how "impossible" it is.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by zifnab06 on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:57PM
(#11358006)
Just to point this out: sound transit's last project, which expanded the existing westlake->seatac airport light rail from Westlake to capital hill and finally to UW, finished under budget and ahead of time.
It was originally scheduled to open September 2016, and the first trains carried passengers last weekend.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by djcapelis on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:06PM
(#11357829)
Line S1 will be much slower than most traditional trains, the energy usage of maglev isn't that much less than traditional rail (so they don't tend to run faster, the metal rails aren't a large limiting factor for speed) and the vertical alignment restrictions on maglev technology means it's not necessarily gonna be technology you can easily put everywhere.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by melling on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:45PM
(#11357961)
Can you be more specific? How fast are traditional trains? These are intercity trains we are discussing, right? The S1 is being used where you would have a subway or light rail.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by djcapelis on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @06:08PM
(#11393416)
The point I'm trying to make here is the speeds on Line S1 are similar to commuter trains in a similar class of operation. Maglev doesn't really provide a speed advantage on that line over traditional rail.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by djcapelis on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @06:05PM
(#11393398)
That is definitely not an actual commercial operating speed, IIRC. Trains can go really fast in test and demos, operating speeds right now rarely break 300 km/hr on most systems. Many systems are headed to 320-360 though. The Shanghai maglev is the only commercial line that regularly does over that in commercial service, at 430 km/hr, but that's only for a few runs a day, most of the day it goes 300 km/hr.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by djcapelis on Wednesday March 30, 2016 @06:12PM
(#11393437)
> Japan"s intracity maglev is going to go almost 600kph.
No it's not. 603 is the fastest they've ever gotten the train to go on a test track, which doesn't make that the speed they'd actually run for commercial service. Their current plan is 500 with a top speed of 505. Which is really good, but also a decent ways off and involves some serious earthworks to make the track flat enough.
For comparison, the speed record for wheel on steel rail trains is currently 574 km/hr.
The rail really isn't a huge impact on the speed yet. At those speeds it really start being more about aerodynamics of the vehicles and the cost per kWh. Maybe maglev technology will change that at some point, but right now we haven't really seen results that would lead us to assume that big of an advantage comes from getting rid of the rail. Arguably the biggest advantage is going to come when someone figures out how to put the trains in a tube where the aerodynamic situation changes completely. That's why the hyperloop proposal wasn't just "use a maglev".
Maglev trains are cool as shit though, you're literally floating through the air, it's awesome. I highly recommend riding the one in Shanghai. Make sure you hit a 430 km/hr run and not the slower 300 km/hr ones, the experience is very different. It's fun as hell.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by rtpg on Thursday March 24, 2016 @08:50PM
(#11357760)
Let's say that 500,000 cars (100k/car, pricing in the cost for storage and maintnance). The most Expensive subway line in the world cost 15 billion and serves something like 800k people. So you could also use that money to build two subway lines and save for maintenance. You could probably build 4 light rail lines (since you're not digging tunnels but instead buying up land).
Plus rail incentivises denser living, meaning that the more rail lines you build, the shorter you need to make them. Self driving cars let you share the cars so kind of solves the parking problem (but keeping track of people doing nasty stuff), but is really just a bunch of micro-buses.
If you can get the political will for rail, it's a pretty effective way of moving people around.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by barney54 on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:03PM
(#11357818)
Rail isn't very efficient in the United States--except for maybe Manhattan (even then MTA loses money).
Seattle should look at what's happening in other cities. For example, according to the LA Times, "The Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority, the region's largest carrier, lost more than 10% of its boardings from 2006 to 2015, a decline that appears to be accelerating. Despite a $9-billion investment in new light rail and subway lines, Metro now has fewer boardings than it did three decades ago, when buses were the county's only transit option." http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ridership-slum...
The point is that rail is not on-demand. It is not flexible. It is not serve people individually. Rail does a wonderful job of taking larges numbers of people from dense living areas to dense working areas.
The future is not light rail. The future is much closer to the individualized, on-demand, flexible nature of Uber rather than the rigid, expensive, inflexible nature of rail.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by csydas on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:23PM
(#11357894)
This is debatable - Light Rail isn't always the answer, that is absolutely true, but in many places, it can alleviate traffic congestion, and in conjunction with other ride share services, can help immensely in all forms of traffic.
Seattle has a major congestion issue and I5 is a mess all through Seattle, and you can feel the impact even in Tacoma during heavy traffic.
A well placed light-rail can be extremely effective, for example the Hiawatha line in Minneapolis. It's not a panacea for infrastructure issues (I5 really is just trashed in most places around Seattle) but again, in conjunction with ride shares, it likely will serve a good number of riders.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by koenigdavidmj on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:22PM
(#11357885)
We just added two stops to our light rail line. It still doesn't sync up with nearby buses, and school is on break (one of the stops is for the university). Instantly, the line became overcrowded and we'll be lengthening trains next week.
In Seattle people ride trains if they're there. This is an observable fact.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by username223 on Thursday March 24, 2016 @10:25PM
(#11358120)
LA holds no lessons, since it has some of the most dysfunctional public transit of any major city. Want to go from Venice to West LA? The blue buses run fairly frequently, although you'll never be able to predict their schedule, since they have to fight LA traffic. Want to go from Venice to downtown, Hollywood, or the SFV? Sorry, no single bus line serves all those areas, so you need to ride one line as far as you can, then walk a bit to pick up another.
Sadly, I agree that the future does look like sitting still in a sea of on-demand four-wheeled robots on the 405.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by rtpg on Thursday March 24, 2016 @11:34PM
(#11358357)
Losing money is fine (you don't make money off of your car right?). The important thing (at least on the economics) is looking at whether it costs more for everyone to own a car, or for everyone to pay for trains, or the right mix (with other transit options).
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by rayiner on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:26PM
(#11357901)
Cities like NYC and Boston are still enjoying the fruits of investment in rail that they made 100+ years ago. Those self driving cars wouldn't last 10.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by specialist on Friday March 25, 2016 @12:40PM
(#11361047)
Upvoted you.
As a huge supporter of mass transit and the public good, methinks the era of centralized big bang projects are coming to an end.
In the '80s, one of my buddy's sci-fi stories (a detective novel, mystery) featured on demand personalized transportation. I've been wanting that forever. With the cost of collaboration and coordination falling thru the floor, its inevitable. Stuff like Uber, Pronto, Car2Go, ZipCar are exciting precursors.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by jkchu on Friday March 25, 2016 @02:59PM
(#11361957)
Services like Car2Go are great when you are staying within the city. The main traffic issue in Seattle is traveling to/from/through downtown Seattle. Adding a train that travels between Bellevue and Seattle would solve a ton of problems with the traffic on our two bridges, 520 and I-90. Currently we only have buses as our only mass transit option. I have found riding the bus to take significantly longer that simply driving (they get stuck in all the same traffic).
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by natrius on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:13PM
(#11357847)
All you have to do to eliminate congestion is to raise the price of congestion until it goes away. Don't want to pay the full price? Share a ride with other people.
This is only unpopular because so many people would rather have free, congested roads and expensive, slow transit than just paying for the roads. This will clearly change before most of Seattle's new plans are completed: self-driving cars will clog up our roads waiting for riders unless we charge them to be on the roads.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by st3v3r on Friday March 25, 2016 @02:29PM
(#11361791)
The problem with that solution is that it puts most of the burden on those least able to shoulder it. Most of us here probably have flexible hours, so moving our commute by even an hour isn't that big of a deal. Someone working a lower end job has set hours, so they cannot move their commute. Meaning they have to drive when congestion happens, meaning they get hit with the price.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by natrius on Saturday March 26, 2016 @12:33AM
(#11364440)
Very true. We can subsidize those trips if we want to, but I don't think that will be necessary. Employers in high congestion areas will have to pay more to compete with other employers. It'll probably work itself out, but if it doesn't, we should fix it directly instead of forcing everyone to endure traffic.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by barney54 on Thursday March 24, 2016 @08:54PM
(#11357783)
And neither does light rail. light rail is a bad investment. It is expensive and low capacity. It is 19th century technology.
Building bus rapid transit makes much more sense because it is felixible and less expensive. But politicians don't like photo ops with buses nearly as much as with trains.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by dpark on Thursday March 24, 2016 @10:38PM
(#11358173)
Politicians like trains because their constituents like trains. Buses are stuck in traffic. Light rail runs on dedicated lines. Light rail is attractive because it is more predictable. The buses in Seattle are less attractive because they suffer the same congestion and unpredictability as driving.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by superuser2 on Friday March 25, 2016 @01:48AM
(#11358663)
Bus rapid transit specifically refers to bus lines on dedicated right-of-way.
However, once you are going to the trouble of building dedicated right-of-way, the incremental cost of making it rail isn't too bad compared to the enormous efficiency/scalability of rail over buses.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by praxulus on Thursday March 24, 2016 @08:55PM
(#11357788)
Not exactly nothing (people won't need to drive around looking for parking, in theory self-driving cars could pack in more closely to reduce road congestion), but probably not enough to make it worth it.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by wildmusings on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:41PM
(#11357947)
Traffic exists because human drivers form a compression wave. The car in front of you accelerates, then you accelerate, then the person behind you, etc. Every time someone taps the brakes, they create traffic behind them. Self-driving cars would presumably synchronize, allowing all of the cars to start moving at almost the same time and move in unison at high speeds.
Also, people don't feel safe driving at 60mph in a densely packed road, so they don't. This should be no problem for a computer, so you could have a densely packed highway but traffic still moving at very high speeds. Basically, flow velocity could remain constant as the highway becomes more congested.
On city streets, your car would route around traffic light timing, in coordination with other vehicles, to distribute traffic and prevent unnecessary stopping.
Edit: One caveat worth mentioning is that these optimizations would be most effective if a road is 100% automated cars, though maybe dedicated lanes are a good transition mechanism. Once the safety benefits are clear, I think adoption will be very fast. The societal cost of car accidents is absolutely massive.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by paulddraper on Thursday March 24, 2016 @09:54PM
(#11358001)
"people don't feel safe driving at 60mph in a densely packed road, so they don't"
Not only do they not feel safe, they aren't safe driving bumper-to-bumper.
Computers will have better reaction times, so much of that goes away. But it's still dangerous. If two cars ahead of me slows, and the car ahead doesn't slow and collides, it will decelerate very quickly, perhaps too quickly for my brakes at 60mph.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by wildmusings on Thursday March 24, 2016 @10:08PM
(#11358049)
You're right, the failure mode for self-driving cars at high speeds is catastrophic, but that's no different from many safe technologies. And the bar here is pretty low. You'd have to really screw up when designing the system for it to be even remotely as dangerous as human drivers. If everyone switched to self-driving cars, serious car accidents would probably become something you hear about in the news, not something that's happened to many of your friends.
Re:$50B transit proposal would boost light rail throughout S...
by st3v3r on Friday March 25, 2016 @02:31PM
(#11361806)
That kind of technology won't be commonplace, available, or in a position to do anything about the problem for a long, long time. Meanwhile, the traffic problem exists today.
I'm all for self driving cars, but I'd like to see solutions for the problem today, not just letting things get worse until something magically makes it better.
My commute times changed noticeably over the course of one year. It went from consistently 30 minutes over the 90 bridge to consistently an hour (we're talking 18 miles, door to door).
This thing should have been built in the 70s.
My wife and I actually moved back to the Midwest 2 months ago after living in Seattle for 8 years, despite my comfortable Senior Engineer salary, because all of our closest friends moved away in the span of a year, because they could no longer afford to live in the city (none of them worked in tech).
I wish Seattle good things from afar, and it will always hold a special place in my heart, but I'm glad I'm not living through these infrastructure growing pains that should have been addressed years ago.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_State_Growth_Manage...
http://www.seattle.gov/dpd/cityplanning/completeprojectslist...
Seattle, Vancouver, SF, etc need to upzone, to permit more development, so that supply can meet demand. As I understand it, that upzoning is not happening nearly fast enough.
Public transit initiatives trigger (begats?) upzoning. This is an end run around the regressive restrictions on property taxes and entrenched NIMBYism.
I fully support it. Whatever works. I wish my peeps working on affordability, homelessness, economic justice would put less emphasis on set asides, protecting older listings, etc, and place more emphasis on increasing inventory.
One potential monkeywrench of increasing supply is absentee landlords. I just read something like 1/3rd of Vancouver properties are owned by Chinese investors. Which I'm totally cool with so long as the units are mostly occupied.
We have to do increase all modes of transportation. The problem with this proposal is that it will take 25+ years. We need a 10 year version of this plan. Charge us rich programmers more, we can afford it.
Additional issues that need to be solved to make pubtrans competitive with car ownership are scheduling, the ability to bring cargo, and negative class connotation. And this completely discounts the probable arrival of ubiquitous autonomous electric vehicles before Sound Transit even gets to finish this project. As much as I enjoy the romantic nature of trains, I think the Puget Sound is gearing up for a folly of a white elephant.
I roughly calculated my expenses once.
$32k car $8k tax/license + loan interest up to point I paid it off = $50k $200 gas a month for 6 years = $14400 $4k renew service plan $1200 a year car ins $7200 2 sets of tires at $1k each = $2k
100k miles on it at 6 years
So $50k+14.4k+4k+7.2k+2k = $77.6k / 100k miles = 0.77 cents per mile.
My commute was 40miles each way or $61 PER DAY!!! That's a TON more than public transportation. That price will slowly go down the longer I keep the car but still, $61 per day is a lot of money. At 20days month that's $1220 a month. That's far more than 2 people's monthly transportation passes.
Car: $11,600
http://bellingham.craigslist.org/cto/5494584275.html
Taxes/tags: $1,500
Gas: $150/mo (100,000 miles @ 25mi/gal @ $2.50 gal over 6 years) = $10,000
Maintenance: $250/year * 6 years = $1,500
Insurance: $600/year * 6 years = $3,600
2 sets of 65k mile tires: 2*600 = $1,200
sell the car @140k miles: -$2,000
http://seattle.craigslist.org/see/cto/5488481558.html
Total: $27,400 or $0.274/mi
You certainly can find a car for that or much less, but not a 2012 Camry.
For decisions about any individual trip, gas price really is most of the issue, because you're already committed to paying for the option of driving whether or not you choose to exercise it in any particular instance.
If you opt for the free I90 bridge or don't use carpool lane, you are going to be sitting in traffic, basically no matter the time of day. And if you are driving within the city limits, you have to deal with parking. There is Uber, and for going around within the city, this is viable. But if you are going longer distances it becomes cost-prohibitive for many people.
Here's a classic to drive the point home:
http://www.bikehub.co.uk/news/sustainability/iconic-waste-of...
The train is only ~$3 to go all the way to the airport.
So I'll keep driving.
Per person, a train costs the same regardless of the number of people.
Same with planes. I could fly or drive from LA to Vegas. Flying is $240 per person friday to sunday. 4 people = $960. 1 car carrying 4 people will be a lot less even if I rent it.
A few years earlier, they destroyed the tracks from Renton to Black Diamond so thoroughly the right-of-way can never be used for rail again.
It boggles the mind.
I was always under the impression that the Sounder (our commuter heavy rail line) used tracks shared with commercial traffic (BNSF, etc.) and thus couldn't be fully developed into a city-wide system...
Seattle Transit just announced a $50 billion plan to blast new right-of-way, never mind the trackage could be doubled by re-using that right-of-way for a few million.
You can still see the tracks on Google Maps:
https://www.google.com/maps/@47.6753261,-122.1882192,16z
although it has been renamed "Cross Kirkland Corridor" in their attempt to hide what it is. Sound Transit prefers a plan that costs one thousand times as much, still won't serve the eastside, and will not be in service until half the existing taxpayers are long dead.
http://seattletransitblog.com/2016/03/12/kirkland-st-struggl...
I'd build the system to the border of Kirkland, and wait for the Kirkland residents to get fed up with rotting on 405.
The Eastside (the Kemper Freeman Jr cohort) has traditionally spiked anything resembling public transit, public good, regional bon ami. Apart from their public statements about "those people", I assume their primary bare knuckled motivation is that anything that hurts Seattle helps Bellevue (landlords). Which I'm totally fine with, love and war and all that. I just hate the hypocrisy.
Case in point: a five mile extension on an existing Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) line and one new station cost $890 million and took seven years to build. [1]
The resulting extension is expected to increase in ridership by 5000 to 7000 daily trips in the next decade. [2]
[1] http://www.bart.gov/about/projects/wsx [2] http://www.bart.gov/about/projects/wsx/chronology
It cost 250 billion yen, or just over 2 billion US dollars. [1]
[1] http://www.treehugger.com/cars/trainspotting-new-subway-line...
Somehow, it's realistic to think about us all having self-driving cars dealing with the chaos of city traffic and pedestrians, and it's realistic to propose spending billions and billions of dollars on slow light-rail systems which require years of construction where the roads are all torn up, but it's completely bonkers to think about building a system with elevated rails hanging on utility poles and small, autonomous cars riding on these rails for only $1 million per mile.
I can't wait until Israel has their SkyTran system working so all these idiots in America won't be able to say how "impossible" it is.
It was originally scheduled to open September 2016, and the first trains carried passengers last weekend.
Seriously, 25 years out. That just seems ridiculous to me.
http://youtu.be/c8SqDVUdMtY
http://gbtimes.com/china/beijing-launch-first-maglev-line-20...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_S1,_BCR
http://youtu.be/VuSrLvCVoVk
Of course, you don't build that to go 10 city blocks.
No it's not. 603 is the fastest they've ever gotten the train to go on a test track, which doesn't make that the speed they'd actually run for commercial service. Their current plan is 500 with a top speed of 505. Which is really good, but also a decent ways off and involves some serious earthworks to make the track flat enough.
For comparison, the speed record for wheel on steel rail trains is currently 574 km/hr.
The rail really isn't a huge impact on the speed yet. At those speeds it really start being more about aerodynamics of the vehicles and the cost per kWh. Maybe maglev technology will change that at some point, but right now we haven't really seen results that would lead us to assume that big of an advantage comes from getting rid of the rail. Arguably the biggest advantage is going to come when someone figures out how to put the trains in a tube where the aerodynamic situation changes completely. That's why the hyperloop proposal wasn't just "use a maglev".
Maglev trains are cool as shit though, you're literally floating through the air, it's awesome. I highly recommend riding the one in Shanghai. Make sure you hit a 430 km/hr run and not the slower 300 km/hr ones, the experience is very different. It's fun as hell.
1989 - route plan
2000 - voter approved tax increase
2005 - construction started
2008 - operations started
Plus rail incentivises denser living, meaning that the more rail lines you build, the shorter you need to make them. Self driving cars let you share the cars so kind of solves the parking problem (but keeping track of people doing nasty stuff), but is really just a bunch of micro-buses.
If you can get the political will for rail, it's a pretty effective way of moving people around.
Seattle should look at what's happening in other cities. For example, according to the LA Times, "The Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority, the region's largest carrier, lost more than 10% of its boardings from 2006 to 2015, a decline that appears to be accelerating. Despite a $9-billion investment in new light rail and subway lines, Metro now has fewer boardings than it did three decades ago, when buses were the county's only transit option." http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ridership-slum...
Phoenix spent $1.4 billion on light rail and transit growth slowed (even though population growth did not). http://www.coyoteblog.com/coyote_blog/2016/01/phoenix-light-...
The point is that rail is not on-demand. It is not flexible. It is not serve people individually. Rail does a wonderful job of taking larges numbers of people from dense living areas to dense working areas.
The future is not light rail. The future is much closer to the individualized, on-demand, flexible nature of Uber rather than the rigid, expensive, inflexible nature of rail.
Seattle has a major congestion issue and I5 is a mess all through Seattle, and you can feel the impact even in Tacoma during heavy traffic.
A well placed light-rail can be extremely effective, for example the Hiawatha line in Minneapolis. It's not a panacea for infrastructure issues (I5 really is just trashed in most places around Seattle) but again, in conjunction with ride shares, it likely will serve a good number of riders.
In Seattle people ride trains if they're there. This is an observable fact.
Sadly, I agree that the future does look like sitting still in a sea of on-demand four-wheeled robots on the 405.
As a huge supporter of mass transit and the public good, methinks the era of centralized big bang projects are coming to an end.
In the '80s, one of my buddy's sci-fi stories (a detective novel, mystery) featured on demand personalized transportation. I've been wanting that forever. With the cost of collaboration and coordination falling thru the floor, its inevitable. Stuff like Uber, Pronto, Car2Go, ZipCar are exciting precursors.
This is only unpopular because so many people would rather have free, congested roads and expensive, slow transit than just paying for the roads. This will clearly change before most of Seattle's new plans are completed: self-driving cars will clog up our roads waiting for riders unless we charge them to be on the roads.
Building bus rapid transit makes much more sense because it is felixible and less expensive. But politicians don't like photo ops with buses nearly as much as with trains.
However, once you are going to the trouble of building dedicated right-of-way, the incremental cost of making it rail isn't too bad compared to the enormous efficiency/scalability of rail over buses.
Also, people don't feel safe driving at 60mph in a densely packed road, so they don't. This should be no problem for a computer, so you could have a densely packed highway but traffic still moving at very high speeds. Basically, flow velocity could remain constant as the highway becomes more congested.
On city streets, your car would route around traffic light timing, in coordination with other vehicles, to distribute traffic and prevent unnecessary stopping.
Edit: One caveat worth mentioning is that these optimizations would be most effective if a road is 100% automated cars, though maybe dedicated lanes are a good transition mechanism. Once the safety benefits are clear, I think adoption will be very fast. The societal cost of car accidents is absolutely massive.
Not only do they not feel safe, they aren't safe driving bumper-to-bumper.
Computers will have better reaction times, so much of that goes away. But it's still dangerous. If two cars ahead of me slows, and the car ahead doesn't slow and collides, it will decelerate very quickly, perhaps too quickly for my brakes at 60mph.
I'm all for self driving cars, but I'd like to see solutions for the problem today, not just letting things get worse until something magically makes it better.