I roughly calculated my expenses once.
$32k car $8k tax/license + loan interest up to point I paid it off = $50k $200 gas a month for 6 years = $14400 $4k renew service plan $1200 a year car ins $7200 2 sets of tires at $1k each = $2k
100k miles on it at 6 years
So $50k+14.4k+4k+7.2k+2k = $77.6k / 100k miles = 0.77 cents per mile.
My commute was 40miles each way or $61 PER DAY!!! That's a TON more than public transportation. That price will slowly go down the longer I keep the car but still, $61 per day is a lot of money. At 20days month that's $1220 a month. That's far more than 2 people's monthly transportation passes.
Car: $11,600
http://bellingham.craigslist.org/cto/5494584275.html
Taxes/tags: $1,500
Gas: $150/mo (100,000 miles @ 25mi/gal @ $2.50 gal over 6 years) = $10,000
Maintenance: $250/year * 6 years = $1,500
Insurance: $600/year * 6 years = $3,600
2 sets of 65k mile tires: 2*600 = $1,200
sell the car @140k miles: -$2,000
http://seattle.craigslist.org/see/cto/5488481558.html
Total: $27,400 or $0.274/mi
You certainly can find a car for that or much less, but not a 2012 Camry.
For decisions about any individual trip, gas price really is most of the issue, because you're already committed to paying for the option of driving whether or not you choose to exercise it in any particular instance.
If you opt for the free I90 bridge or don't use carpool lane, you are going to be sitting in traffic, basically no matter the time of day. And if you are driving within the city limits, you have to deal with parking. There is Uber, and for going around within the city, this is viable. But if you are going longer distances it becomes cost-prohibitive for many people.
Here's a classic to drive the point home:
http://www.bikehub.co.uk/news/sustainability/iconic-waste-of...
The train is only ~$3 to go all the way to the airport.
So I'll keep driving.
Per person, a train costs the same regardless of the number of people.
Same with planes. I could fly or drive from LA to Vegas. Flying is $240 per person friday to sunday. 4 people = $960. 1 car carrying 4 people will be a lot less even if I rent it.
Additional issues that need to be solved to make pubtrans competitive with car ownership are scheduling, the ability to bring cargo, and negative class connotation. And this completely discounts the probable arrival of ubiquitous autonomous electric vehicles before Sound Transit even gets to finish this project. As much as I enjoy the romantic nature of trains, I think the Puget Sound is gearing up for a folly of a white elephant.