News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by peatmoss on Monday March 16, 2015 @01:31PM (#9212884)
When you total up the amount of land that we dedicate to cars, it's absolutely staggering. I read a stat a while back (can't find it right now), that something like 33% of the land area of Seattle is paved vehicle surface. I'm sure Seattle isn't more paved-over than most other cities. Then, when you realize how this staggering amount of land is used to separate living, working, and other activity space, you begin to feel that we're living in little islands surrounded by fast-moving rivers of lethal steel--lethal steel that results in toxic gas and water runoff that sickens the remaining population that isn't directly killed at a rate of tens-of-thousands per year.

Gosh I hope we can figure this out in my lifetime.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by eqdw on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:35PM (#9213346)
Food for thought:

A ~450 sqft studio apartment in SF costs about $2k/mo in rent.

a ~150 sqft monthly parking spot (as per http://sanfrancisco.bestparking.com/), costs about $400

Three parking spots takes up the same square footage as a studio apartment. It costs a little over half of that.

Then consider how much parking in SF is free parking. Just straight up free. Parking lots for stores. Street parking on most residential streets. Driveways and garages.

It's fucking insane how much space is wasted on car storage. It's even more fucking insane that so much of this storage is de-facto free (which is implicitly a subsidy from the person providing the space to car owners; in a sense it's a subsidy from renters, since any parking space could be a sorely needed living space instead)

I can't wait, I just can't wait until Uber-like on-demand ride tech + self driving cars means we can massively reduce our vehicle stock. Think of all the things that could be more awesome

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by BrainInAJar on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:39PM (#9213367)
> I can't wait, I just can't wait until Uber-like on-demand ride tech + self driving cars means we can massively reduce our vehicle stock. Think of all the things that could be more awesome

First, get rid of the zoning laws that require those spots, then they'll disappear. You can cram (depending on building height restrictions) dozens of apartments in to the same 2 dimensional plane as those 3 parking spots.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Crito on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:31PM (#9213751)
Perhaps all hard limits on building height could be removed, but with the addition of a new rule that requires every new residential building to have 1 level of parking garage for every 3 stories it has (or some other similar ratio). Then, if you wanted to build a 15 story apartment building you would be allowed to, but you'd have to provide enough parking garage to satisfy all of those people.

The problem then is parking in commercial districts. Street parking is good for businesses on that street, but a better solution could be more city-run parking garages in good locations, and city streets in commercial areas that are optimized for pedestrians.

The best example of this I have ever seen is down-town Silver Spring in Maryland. That was several years ago, I hear they tore a bunch of it up, but it at least used to be great.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by lmm on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:57PM (#9213949)
If you build more parking space then you bring new more cars onto the street.

Here in London new residential buildings are built with zero parking spaces (just a small a shared drop-off/deliveries area). There are already too many cars in the city, and public transport is good enough for most people (of course there are people who for good reasons need cars, but they're the exception rather than the rule).

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by MBlume on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:58PM (#9214720)
Why have a requirement? If the people want garages, let them demand garages, let the market price garages so that they're an efficient use of space and construction resources on the margin.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by BrainInAJar on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:26PM (#9214145)
That kind of defeats the purpose of removing the parking requirements. If you require every 3 units to have one parking spot, you raise the price of each unit by 30%. Additionally since tenants are paying for the spot anyway, it incentivizes them to buy a car that they might otherwise do without. If there turns out to be a market need for parking spots, I'm sure someone will step in and build a long term parking garage in the neighbourhood, but you aren't mandating every tenant regardless of car ownership desire subsidize the others.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by TheCoelacanth on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:57PM (#9214337)
Minimum parking requirements subsidize car users at the expense on non-car users.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by kalleboo on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:46AM (#9216330)
Minimum parking requirements already exist in many (most?) cases. In fact they may be the problem, not the solution.

Read: The High Cost of Free Parking http://www.uctc.net/papers/351.pdf

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:27AM (#9216418)
A lot of the cost comes from dedicating acreage to parking.

If there were more parking garages, there would be less asphalt sprawl.

Mandatory parking garages inside apartments is a bad method, but the goal is admirable. No surface parking, no matter how many cars.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by PinguTS on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @04:24AM (#9216811)
Actually, that is law in Germany. For every amount of building space (residential, business, ...) you are required to provide a number of parking space (depending on the type of building). If you can not provide the required amount of parking space, then you have to pay a fee to the city. All the numbers like required parking space and amount for the fee is decided by the city. So in high density cities the fee is more expansive than in the country side.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by math0ne on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:10AM (#9216237)
I believe the city of austin has similar limits on new building downtown, parking must be integrated vertically.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Tiktaalik on Monday March 16, 2015 @06:36PM (#9214942)
I believe SF is ahead of many cities in not requiring their developers to build excessive parking. Cutting parking requirements in buildings is one of the easiest things a city can do to make building construction cheaper and lower housing costs.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by b_rad on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:18AM (#9216395)
SF is ahead of many cities, but apparently still has "minimum parking requirements" for certain new developments. Good news though, that may be about to change:

http://sf.streetsblog.org/2015/03/02/supervisor-breed-calls-...

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by dredmorbius on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @09:28PM (#9222987)
On demand / driverless vehicles don't necessarily reduce vehicle stock. If the use is for standard travel patterns, they barely reduce it at all. That's where land use, encouraging bikes, and transit fill in -- walking, bikes, busses, trolleys, and subways all have vastly greater capacity per unit street area than single-passenger vehicles do. How they deal with complex routes can vary considerably though.

What such systems do allow is for vehicle storage to be separated from high-density land-use. A self-driving vehicle can be told to go park itself elsewhere, a dispatched vehicle doesn't need to park while the passenger is otherwise occupied.

But both still occupy street space, and require storage space somewhere.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by chrismealy on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:24PM (#9214492)
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by DenisM on Monday March 16, 2015 @09:10PM (#9215670)
Perhaps we should embrace this view, and extend it just a tiny bit further:

Since the tunnels for cars are already dug up, all we need to do is cover them with concrete slabs, cover the slabs over with asphalt for bikes/pedestrians and vegetation for sitting around, and declare the entire city pedestrian only. The cars can continue to hurry back and forth underground.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Apofis on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:13AM (#9216248)
There's some really nice futurist art from the 1930's depicting NYC in 2000. All cars are underground in tunnels under the streets, just like subways are. It's beautiful and the city would be amazing if this happened at some point, which honestly with overpopulation just might in the next 100 years or so.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by cpeterso on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:42AM (#9216323)
After the Great Seattle Fire in the late 19th century, Seattle had the opposite problem of the one illustrated there: the city rebuilt the streets higher than before to avoid flooding problems, but merchants didn't want raise their buildings. So the city streets were 12–30 feet higher than the sidewalks!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seattle_Underground

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by ars on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:33PM (#9213333)
Travel is the driver of all human progress and development.

What, you think the amount of roads we have now is a lot? We've always had roads, they were for carts, or horses, or anything else. There is nothing special about cars here.

> Gosh I hope we can figure this out in my lifetime.

We did. We made travel cheap and easy and it has benefited us massively.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by wutbrodo on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:38PM (#9214225)
This is a hell of a strawman. The proposition isn't to remove the ability to travel, which (as you said) is effectively the removal of geographic barriers to interaction. It's to replace car travel with something that has lower costs in terms of efficiency, health, economics, city planning, fatalities, the environment, etc etc etc etc.

> What, you think the amount of roads we have now is a lot? We've always had roads, they were for carts, or horses, or anything else. There is nothing special about cars here.

Not all roads are made equal. There's a huge difference between "space reserved for a mode of travel" and the public spaces that roads[1] (in cities) were before cars became ubiquitous.[2] A good analogue is imagining a path in a park: it's generally used for transit (people walking and occasionally biking), but it's also fully open as a public space for the citizenry to use as they please.

[1] This whole conversation is about roads in cities, so that's what I'm referring to: roads across sparsely populated countryside don't have nearly as high a cost, nor do they have as many viable alternatives.

[2] http://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by ars on Monday March 16, 2015 @06:09PM (#9214777)
You have a VERY rosy eyed view of what cities were like before the car.

What they were actually like is rivers of mud mixed with horse manure. There were just as many roads before as now, except they were very dirty.

> and the public spaces that roads (in cities) were before cars became ubiquitous

Absolute nonsense. Go read some history, or even fictionalized accounts. Roads were never public spaces like you imagine. They were roads, and carts and horses routinely road right over people who didn't get out of the way.

They were crowded and dirty, and those open spaces you imagine did not exist inside cities. (There plenty of open spaces outside cities, of course.)

Your dream world existed to some degree inside farm villages, but never in cities.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by classicsnoot on Monday March 16, 2015 @06:28PM (#9214894)
>fictionalized accounts

The amount of plays, novels, stories, poems, and songs that take place in and on and nearby, as well as revolving around and referencing to, ares of transit is pretty large. When looked at in the context of human existence on the planet, roads are the pathways human cells use to move and multiply and spread and settle. So much culture and development occurs on the paths of humanity. This is not limited to any single road concept; bridges, train tracks, shipping lanes, and airports all spawn society blocks around them.

The Pathways have always been public spaces. Are you opposed to those public spaces being safer and more productive? If so, would you say it is because vehicles [methods of human conveyance] have a priority over people [humans living] in the Public Square?

The point of travel is the people that can do it, not the profits to be gained or the methods to be employed IMO.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by jackmaney on Monday March 16, 2015 @11:22PM (#9216098)
> vehicles [methods of human conveyance] have a priority over people [humans living] in the Public Square

On roads, vehicles absolutely have a priority over people. This is so obvious, I'm honestly not sure why I had to state the previous sentence.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by ars on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:42AM (#9216322)
You do know there are people in those vehicles right? The way you write that, you make it sound like the vehicles are just driving around on their own.

The vehicles have no priority at all, the people in them do.

Does that bother you that someone wrapped in a vehicle has priority over someone not wrapped?

It's like that always - small boats have to give way to large ones for example.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by O____________O on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:27AM (#9216572)
It's like that always - small boats have to give way to large ones for example.

Boats traveling through fluid, controlled by a relatively tiny prop, are in no way comparable to road-going vehicles that enjoy the static friction of rubber on asphalt.

Additionally, all vehicles on the road are held to (virtually) the same legal standards, regardless of size. If anything, laws are more restrictive the larger the vehicle.

Also, this is false:

The vehicles have no priority at all, the people in them do.

There are many parts of the country where it would be illegal to cross a road on foot (jaywalking), but entirely legal to do so within a vehicle.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by classicsnoot on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @10:08AM (#9217979)
I get the feeling that you have little to no experience on the water outside of Jaws and pontoon party boats. Size only matters in context with the area one operates in. Malaca Straits? Bet your ass the big boys have priority... but that is because of traffic and pirates. Coastal Downeast Maine? If you have the elephantiasis feel free to cut off the lobstermen in their tiny boats; i will watch you get keel hauled from a safe distance.

It is always context as well as proportion. Neither air nor water work as reference points for driving, as the scale in both those worlds is analogous to the variance in insect size [ant to dragonfly] or water creature [diatom to jelly fish] while the road is much more like the difference in dog breeds. On top of that, the land is our natural habitat, as opposed to the hydro- or atmosphere, and the use of that space must take into account that society is based on people and not profits or production. Yes, like mobility, the are absolutely important, but only in how they advance culture and society. A heart is a meat pump if there is no brain to feed oxygen.

There are more people without vehicle access than with. De-personalizing vehicles would be a good thing.

And just because i'm on a rant: how many people die from terrorist attacks per annum v. car accidents? If the government[s] actually cared about people, vehicular death would be confronted with the same rigor and rhetoric that extremist islam is. Kind of sad that rich south africans and faceless cororations are the only ones who seem to be doing anything about it.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:08AM (#9216377)
Because it's not obvious. Do you dispute the article about jaywalking?
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by wutbrodo on Monday March 16, 2015 @08:53PM (#9215605)
> You have a VERY rosy eyed view of what cities were like before the car. What they were actually like is rivers of mud mixed with horse manure. There were just as many roads before as now, except they were very dirty.

I was actually worried my point may come across like this and considered clarifying, but I figured it would be obvious with even a moment's thought that I'm not suggesting literally reverting to exactly how roads were before cars. The only point I was making with respect to the way roads were used was that they were closer to public spaces than the situation we have now. Roads today are reserved pretty much exclusively for vehicles: just try dawdling or having a conversation on a major street in any city to see what I mean. If you RTFA, Hamburg is planning to replace the massive amount of space wasted by roads with green spaces. Relying on things like underground subways or elevated monorails or (much much much smaller than roads) bike paths means we can have the best of both worlds: undo the disastrous damage that cars did to city planning and public spaces without giving up the incredible benefits of streamlined transportation that cars enabled.

> Absolute nonsense. Go read some history, or even fictionalized accounts. Roads were never public spaces like you imagine. They were roads, and carts and horses routinely road right over people who didn't get out of the way.

Absolute nonsense. Go read some history, or even fictionalized accounts. Roads were public spaces almost exactly as I described them, since what I said was that vehicle traffic existed alongside people strolling and standing and doing whatever the hell else. As I mentioned above, we'll even be getting rid of the vehicle-induced downsides of these previous spaces (the mess and the danger), since vehicle traffic will be completely excluded from the road-replacements being described in the article.

We're lucky enough to have video from the early 1900s[1], which shows exactly what I mean about roads essentially being extensions of the way sidewalks are today (+ vehicle traffic), as opposed to the "all vehicles except for crosswalks" style we have today.

By the way, I notice that the only thing you addressed in your entire response was nitpicking (an inaccurate interpretation of) my unimportant supporting comment about how roads previously were. As I said before, the only thing I was alluding to was the fact that they were space that you could actually use, spend time on, play on, etc, as opposed to the reserved-for-cars and much-more-dangerous-for-pedestrians streets we have in the modern era. I can only assume you fully agree with the _actual_ point of my comment, which is that talking about giving up the advantages that efficient transit has bought is either disingenuous or idiotic, since that's not what's being discussed.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IJfTa5SjDCY

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by ars on Monday March 16, 2015 @10:45PM (#9215976)
> I was actually worried my point may come across like this and considered clarifying,

No, I understood, I was trying to tell you that roads are, and were, for travel and that's it. This public space you love never occurred on roads. People have ZERO interest in doing anything on a road except getting to their destination. We have lost nothing whatsoever.

> vehicle traffic existed alongside people strolling and standing and doing whatever the hell else

You can not bring back the halcyon days when people strolled slowly and were not in a rush. Those days are gone and are not coming back. People want to get where they are going without any time waste.

You propose replacing roads with underground subway or monorail, which are entirely unsuitable for 90% of cities. Plus they don't solve the last mile problem, I've actually never heard of any solution for it except self driving cars that don't exist, or expensive taxis. And even then you still need your hated roads!

> As I said before, the only thing I was alluding to was the fact that they were space that you could actually use, spend time on, play on, etc,

No ever actually did that. Your dream world simply never existed.

Go watch that video you posted and tell me how many people you see talking to other people. I spotted exactly ZERO. People were shopping, or going places, sometimes together. But none were using this "public space" you imagine for anything except travel.

Perhaps you are thinking of central markets like a souq? But that's only a tiny portion of the road network.

> which shows exactly what I mean about roads essentially being extensions of the way sidewalks are today (+ vehicle traffic), as opposed to the "all vehicles except for crosswalks" style we have today.

And you'll still have your hated roads even in your scenario! Only instead of carts you'll have slow autos? So in essence you want to drop the speed limit? And that's about it? So why all the text about how much space roads are taking?

Or do you want to get rid of roads to bring back an ideal that never existed and that no one even wants (periodic mini-parks would provide all the advantages and none of the drawbacks), and have no suggestions for what to replace it with?

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:06AM (#9216374)
> You can not bring back the halcyon days when people strolled slowly and were not in a rush. Those days are gone and are not coming back. People want to get where they are going without any time waste.

If you're in a rush then taking cars through a city is a terrible method to get somewhere fast. The root problem is not that people have gotten more efficient.

>the last mile problem

You could have public transport. It wouldn't have to be exotic. It would need one lane and wouldn't fill it.

> And you'll still have your hated roads even in your scenario! Only instead of carts you'll have slow autos? So in essence you want to drop the speed limit? And that's about it? So why all the text about how much space roads are taking?

A few slow cars would not take up nearly as much space, and they would not interfere with people walking.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by classicsnoot on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @10:17AM (#9218044)
>This public space you love never occurred on roads.

You are flat out wrong. Markets, bazaars, strip malls, housing; these are all based on road placement. What happens when a city has a huge celebration? Why, they shut down the roads so people can move freely in safety and merriment. What happens when the government pushes its citizenry too far? Why, take to the streets and make yourself heard!

TBH, i cannot think of a thing/facet of infrastructure that is more representative of public space and socializing than a road. True, steel death machines flying about at 70kph+ is not conducive to healthy neighborhoods. really, the personal car is a huge fracking waste of time, material, and currency.

I think you may, as my father does, believe that the car is some magical device that creates freedom and profits out of thin air. Just look at the commercials; each year we are expected to believe that the NEW one is SO MUCH FUCKING BETTER than last years model WHICH IS SHIT COMPARED TO THE NEW AVENTURAMO by NISSOTA NOW FOR JUST 200%+ THE AMOUNT IT COSTS TO MAKE!!! Truly, car culture is what props up the fallacious American Exceptionalism that capitalists purport.

How sad is it that the most patriotic thing i can do, more than military service or medical aid or child rearing, is to own 1+ cars and make all of the requisite repairs and pay for all of the titling, permits, and insurance?

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by bluthru on Wednesday March 18, 2015 @09:46PM (#9229784)
>No ever actually did that. Your dream world simply never existed.

You are completely wrong:

http://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by jdietrich on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:57PM (#9214340)
With the automobile came the invention of 'jaywalking', and the idea that the street belongs primarily to cars rather than people. The nature of public space changed fundamentally.

Many European cities are heavily pedestrianised, with large areas of the centre accessible only for deliveries. There are big public health impacts - walking and cycling becomes more popular, children have safe spaces to play, accident rates fall and the air quality is drastically improved.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by wlesieutre on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:03PM (#9214375)
And not just an invention after the fact! "Jaywalking" was a word made up by the auto companies to sway public opinion in their direction (and paint pedestrians who use the street as stupid).

99% Invisible did a nice episode on it a while back: http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/episode-76-the-modern-...

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by samatman on Monday March 16, 2015 @08:33PM (#9215548)
There weren't many powerful automobile companies in 1891.

https://books.google.com/books?id=Noo4AQAAMAAJ&q=%22jaywalki...

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by saurik on Monday March 16, 2015 @09:07PM (#9215653)
Obviously the indexed text of this book is not actually from 1891, given that the very next sentence talks about 1926 in the past tense.

> Results 1-1 of 1 > Page 49 > Within ninety days after the signing of those pledges, the records of the Bureau of Public Safety showed a decrease of almost 50 per cent in accidents resulting from jaywalking. In 1926 all honorary and special commissionerships in the police ...

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by samatman on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @11:20AM (#9218482)
Hah! That'll teach me to cut and paste fresh data....
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by wutbrodo on Monday March 16, 2015 @08:59PM (#9215626)
Hm,that's interesting. I wonder why the OED doesn't mention this source in its earliest usage:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaywalking#Origin_of_the_term

EDIT: In case that sounded sarcastic or like I didn't believe you, I'm actually curious about how they're so far off in their "first usage".

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by cowsandmilk on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @08:44AM (#9217501)
Because this is Volume 39, which was actually published in 1954, not 1891.[1]

Search the book for 1954, or any year before then, you will get results. Search for 1955 and you get nothing.

[1] http://onlinebooks.library.upenn.edu/webbin/serial?id=ncycus...

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by 6t6t6 on Monday March 16, 2015 @09:39PM (#9215773)
Many European cities have 30km/h zones where the term jaywalking makes no sense because people has always priority over cars.

I really thing life is better in cities where people has priority over cars. But it is also true that the lower population density in a city, the higher dependency on cars it has.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by justincormack on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @04:54AM (#9216866)
I am currently in Kyoto where cars go pretty slowly and give way to bikes and pedestrians. Rather then honking a horn. Its rather nice.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by makeitsuckless on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:17PM (#9214077)
We didn't have roads 4 lanes wide (which is a huge amount of additional land lost), and we didn't have the insane amount of parking space.

Even a not particularly car friendly city like Amsterdam would look dramatically different if you removed the parking space, because it would free up such an insane amount of space.

Cars have multiplied the amount of space dedicated to transport, without actually adding much to human progress and development, what with most of it being used to carry individuals short distances from A to B and back again.

I don't see the massive benefit here. It's a pointless habit we shaped a life/work culture around with a mostly negative impact on the quality of life.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by classicsnoot on Monday March 16, 2015 @06:36PM (#9214941)
>without adding much to human progress and development

I am opposed to vehicles being the priority, but their prevalence is directly related to their usefulness within the economic regions they occur in. If you ever go to the developing world, you will see vehicles used to grow and maintain society. It is easy to forget, living in the suburbs as i do, that most of the world does not joy ride over-produced SUVs.

The ability to move freely is a magical thing. Living in a place with bad roads is a reality to itself that i think every westerner should experience. The problem is what we use to take advantage of the roads.

Roads are society's rivers.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:23AM (#9216406)
Roads are great. The argument is against personal cars. You can have most of those gains with a vastly smaller number of automobiles, and remove many of the negatives like parking lots.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by classicsnoot on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @09:58AM (#9217909)
I completely agree. I was only responding to the assertion that roads and vehicles are fairly useless.

I hope i live to see the day when city centers are car free, and all cars on the road are automated and distributed. Imagine leaving your domicile, hitting a widget on your device, and in a short time a vehicle approaches near silently, its bay door opening. you step in and you are off to work at a consistent 60kph. Each day, you see the same people on their commutes, so you naturally strike up conversations and friendships. With the steering column as well as ~90% of other standard car interaction gack gone, the interior is free to be redesigned to suit whatever purpose one may have. Vehicles could link up, breakfast could be enjoyed over whatever amount of data you choose to view on your way, and there would be no traffic that the passenger is accountable for. And in the afternoon you do it all again, only now beverage quads flit back and forth between mothership and car swarm, possibly making the commute the high point of the day.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by flomo on Monday March 16, 2015 @07:39PM (#9215270)
> We didn't have roads 4 lanes wide

Actually that would have been pretty typical for a 19th century American city, e.g. in San Francisco most of the older streets have always been that wide.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by limeyx on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:22PM (#9214116)
Exactly. The Romans just parked their horses in a nearby field and got them fed at the same time! Renewable fuel and the perfect "green space" parking lot / local park
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by ars on Monday March 16, 2015 @06:11PM (#9214805)
No, they did not. Those nearby fields only existed in transit (between cities). By cities those areas were simply seas of mud that people avoided.

Cities did not value green spaces at all.

I understand the desire for the "good old days", but those days never actually existed.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by walshemj on Monday March 16, 2015 @07:28PM (#9215219)
Mud and horse poop - before the car London as the biggest city had serious problems just getting rid of all the waste from the horses used on its streets.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by r00fus on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:16PM (#9214071)
> We did. We made travel cheap and easy and it has benefited us massively.

If you're referring to ICE and automobiles, that "cheap" cost is bought by uncountable externalities that aren't on the balance sheet: many lives and wars to secure this cheap fuel, not to mention climate change.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by yellowapple on Monday March 16, 2015 @09:09PM (#9215667)
That's being fixed already with new propulsion methods - namely, electric power, which could potentially be provided via cleaner energy sources (wind, solar, fission, geothermal, fusion (someday), etc.). This will soon make automobiles even cheaper on all fronts - even those that - as you say - "aren't on the balance sheet".

Arguments to ban cars outright because of climate change and oil might've been relevant in the 20th century, but now they're pretty much moot, so long as electric vehicles continue to grow in popularity.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by CalRobert on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @08:04AM (#9217359)
Electric vehicles can still kill your family, friends, and self.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by yellowapple on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @03:38PM (#9220712)
No disagreement there. I was merely pointing out that objecting to cars because of their pollution is silly when more and more of us are driving around in electric vehicles.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by guelo on Monday March 16, 2015 @09:49PM (#9215805)
Most electricity is generated from coal and other fossil fuels.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by yellowapple on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @03:38PM (#9220721)
For now. That, too, will eventually no longer be an issue.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by breischl on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:22PM (#9214112)
Yes, but carts and horses don't habitually move at 25 MPH or more. It was possible to get run over and killed by a cart, but walking into a busy city street full of cars (without following the signals) is almost certain to get you killed. That's a pretty big difference in how the space can actually be used.

The first section of this article is interesting in this context: http://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by mc32 on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:46PM (#9214274)
To be fair, millions of horses in the streets would cause a lot of pollution in the form of horse dung. Streets would be mired in horse crap... And what would you do with it, if you removed it? Some could be used as fertilizer, but not all. Woe are us after the rains...
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by walshemj on Monday March 16, 2015 @07:30PM (#9215226)
Actually horse transport did kill a substantial number of people you might not know that today horse riding is a dangerous sport.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by thaumasiotes on Monday March 16, 2015 @07:19PM (#9215176)
> walking into a busy city street full of cars (without following the signals) is almost certain to get you killed

This is total nonsense, easily falsified by just looking at daily urban life in the modern world. The behavior you describe is completely routine in Shanghai; deaths are rare.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by nl on Monday March 16, 2015 @10:43PM (#9215971)
This is total nonsense, easily falsified by just looking at daily urban life in the modern world. The behavior you describe is completely routine in Shanghai; deaths are rare.

The Chinese appear to disagree:

Shanghai traffic police have punished 350,000 cases of pedestrian jaywalking this year.... There have been more than 200 crashes involving pedestrians that have killed 56 people as a result of ignoring traffic signals in Shanghai this year, traffic police said. (2012)[1]

and

According to Shanghai traffic police, 48 people have been killed and 206 injured in more than 200 accidents in the first 5 months of 2013, involving either jaywalking or scooters and mopeds running red lights[2]

[1] http://en.people.cn/90882/8059898.html

[2] http://www.healthandsafetyinshanghai.com/shanghai-traffic.ht...

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by thaumasiotes on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @08:50AM (#9217524)
48 deaths in 5 months is a rare malfunction for something that happens millions of times a day. And those aren't even all pedestrian deaths.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by swayvil on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:48PM (#9213883)
> Travel is the driver of all human progress and development.

Actually, people with lots of free time and access to drugs is the driver of all human progress and development.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by s73v3r on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:22PM (#9214482)
Really? What drugs did Sir Tim Berners-Lee do when he created the World Wide Web?
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by lifeisstillgood on Monday March 16, 2015 @07:10PM (#9215132)
Sir Tim, as a UK citizen in the late 20thC would have used many drugs in his lifetime, paracetamol, aspirin, penicillin, vaccines... I think you may have leapt to a conclusion about the drugs the parent post meant. Are you thinking about those recreational drugs a bit too much ... :-)
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:32AM (#9216436)
Please do not insult the reader. Honestly, your comment offends me. I know you're making a joke but it's so condescending I can't stand it.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by lifeisstillgood on Wednesday March 18, 2015 @03:27AM (#9224066)
Yes the last sentence was meant as a joke and is admittedly rather condescending. However the first half of my comment is I think valid - access to medicinal as opposed to recreational drugs is part of the virtuous circle that has driven human development - better agriculture, better sanitation and better medication have all had outsize impacts.

To deliberately - or perhaps honestly - miss that point and suggest access to recreational drugs (the only kind we use the term "doing drugs") is necessary to point out.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Dylan16807 on Wednesday March 18, 2015 @03:31AM (#9224078)
"free time and access to drugs" is clearly talking about drugs that alter mental state. s73v3r was not the one missing the point.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by lifeisstillgood on Wednesday March 18, 2015 @08:04AM (#9224843)
I disagree, in the context of the post (human society and development over thousands of years), then I read that as "free time - better agriculture" and "access to drugs - medication to improve quality of life"

I can see it as being taken either way though

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Dylan16807 on Wednesday March 18, 2015 @06:49PM (#9229171)
Increased productivity over time hasn't correlated very well with the amount of free time people have, and there's always been room for tinkering. There were especially large amounts of free time pre-agriculture.

And I wouldn't put advances in medical drugs particularly high on the list of advances either. It's not even the top of the list of medical advances. Though I don't classify vaccines as drugs.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by swayvil on Wednesday March 18, 2015 @05:20PM (#9228776)
I meant psychoactive drugs.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by breischl on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:56PM (#9214703)
I think it was that radioactive spider venom stuff. I hear Peter Parker was on it, too.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by megablast on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:30AM (#9216292)
> There is nothing special about cars here.

Cars kill 1.2 million people a year. I think that is special, and not something that happened before.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by BrainInAJar on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:37PM (#9213355)
> Gosh I hope we can figure this out in my lifetime.

We can figure it out with pure market forces; currently building codes across the continent require businesses to have a certain amount of off-street parking. That also has the effect of killing small local businesses. Own a restaurant? Doing well? Want to expand? Your 6 table restaurant requires no off street parking, but an 8 table restaurant requires (for example) 6 spaces, meaning you can't just add another couple tables, you need to buy / lease the entire building next to yours, demolish it, and use it for parking.

Get rid of these anti-business pro-car zoning laws, and the problem takes care of itself.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by yellowapple on Monday March 16, 2015 @09:16PM (#9215697)
Which continent? At least here in the States (near Lake Tahoe specifically), there are plenty of 8+ table restaurants that don't have their own off-street parking. This has been the case in pretty much every American downtown I've visited; most drivers rely on either roadside parking spaces (usually metered) or dedicated parking garages/lots instead.

The main exception I've noticed is Reno (along with the Nevada side of Tahoe), given that the bigger casinos - even in "downtown" areas - will typically provide parking garages for their guests.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by WildUtah on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @07:03AM (#9217196)
Some pre-code buildings are grandfathered. Minimum parking was mostly phased in between the 1930s and 1960s. You can't build a new restaurant without parking except in a very, very small fraction of American urban areas.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by yellowapple on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @07:54PM (#9222514)
I'd imagine that restaurants in urban centers are rarely "built" nowadays; in downtowns, you're probably leasing (or maybe buying) an existing building.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by e40 on Monday March 16, 2015 @07:43PM (#9215299)
The flip side is, ignore the problem, remove the building codes, and what will happen? I can tell you: gridlock. Over the last 15 years I've been visiting a suburb of Charlotte, NC. Every year I'm amazed how many forested have been bulldozed and shiny new subdivisions standing in their places. The result is a trip that used to take 10 minutes can take 40, or more. My father, who lives there and has been watching the local politics surrounding this, says everyone is just burying their heads in the sand. More building permits are issued and the problem gets worse and worse. The problem is, there is a lot more building planned, but still no solution to the transportation problems.

When it comes to infrastructure, market forces don't really work.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by kansface on Monday March 16, 2015 @09:34PM (#9215756)
Suburbs exist only because of government subsidies - they wouldn't be built in a free market because they are just too damn expensive. They require massive public funding for infrastructure - roads, water, sewage, side walks, etc, over the course of decades. At the same time, that infrastructure is only used by the residents of the suburb by design. They don't permit through traffic nor do they allow for mixed use. The problem isn't growth in a free market. The problem is just the opposite in fact.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by BrainInAJar on Monday March 16, 2015 @08:57PM (#9215616)
All those highways were put in with taxpayer money. And the parking at the other end is the fault of building codes. If developers had to pay for all the highway to their new subdivisions, the market would look very, very different.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by balabaster on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:39PM (#9214241)
I'm unfamiliar with this - does it pertain to physical tables or number of seats? If for instance you take an approach such as Bennihana where you have large tables and just add people to the table until it's full, is that counted differently than 8 tables for 4? If two parties of 4 show up, they're both seated at the same table... if the table is for 10, then when another couple show up, they're added to the same table. Does this count as 1 table or 3?
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by WildUtah on Monday March 16, 2015 @06:41PM (#9214970)
http://shoup.bol.ucla.edu/

Minimum parking laws are the most important of many command-and-control policies and mandates that created the car-oriented American city. More than minimum setbacks, minimum lot sizes, FAR limits, single use zoning, ploughing heavily subsidized freeways through cities, and the rest, parking policy is why American cities have decayed.

Returning to free markets would let American cities be great again.

As for restaurant parking minima, they're usually based on inside area and sometimes on seating. There are minima for offices, factories, schools, homes, ana every land use in most cities.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by BrainInAJar on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:47PM (#9214275)
Depends entirely on the city's zoning law. Max occupancy or floor space ratio are fairly common
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by godzilla82 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @03:36AM (#9216696)
I feel you should visit any developing country to get a feel of why zoning / building / parking laws are required.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by baddox on Monday March 16, 2015 @01:43PM (#9212972)
I'm confident that some reduction of paved surface can be achieved in most or all cities, but I think your tone is making the situation seem a bit more ridiculous than it actually is. I would expect a significant portion of any densely populated city to be paved, for the simple reason that people need to be able to get to essentially every part of a city. Short of more fanciful solutions like fully elevated or underground passageways, you're going to need roughly the same grid of roads even if you eliminate cars. Granted, you could theoretically get significant constant factor reduction in the width of roads if you can remove lanes (through banning cars, encouraging carpooling/public transit, or increasing bicyclists and pedestrians).
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by rayiner on Monday March 16, 2015 @01:52PM (#9213035)
Of course, wide streets predate cars. Both Chicago's and NYC's street grids, with their wide avenues, predate the era in which everyone had a personal automobile. But take a look at older cities with narrower streets. You can get around Center City Philly, but the streets are so narrow in parts you barely notice crossing them.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by eqdw on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:43PM (#9213388)
> Short of more fanciful solutions like fully elevated or underground passageways, you're going to need roughly the same grid of roads even if you eliminate cars.

Not actually true. Grids come in many different shapes and sizes. As one easy example: the block size. As a city planner, you can choose any block size you like, and this will adjust the ratio of real estate to transportation infrastructure accordingly.

Additionally, and this is fanciful futurism more than anything else: in a city that functions without ubiquitous private vehicle traffic, you can make the roads narrower, which also increases the real estate. To take an example from where I live:

http://sfdpw.org/modules/showdocument.aspx?documentid=3690

Potrero Avenue in SF is 100 feet wide. A hundred feet. If you naievely parceled this land out by drawing a line across the road every 5 feet, the each demarcated space would be worth $2k/mo rent. In a hypothetical future city without cars, you wouldn't need a road to be a hundred feet wide.

More reading re: grid plans

http://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2014/10/14/places-and-non... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_plan (specifically this image http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Block_Sizes_and_Street_Len...)

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by avn2109 on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:01PM (#9213520)
Agreed, the trick is to ban parking and narrow the roadways a lot. A few months ago this [0] was on HN and I was very convinced by its arguments pertaining to automobiles and urbanization.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8090190

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by tigrella on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:09PM (#9214025)
Like Venice, Hamburg could use its vast system of waterways for transportation. If it's going to happen in any European city, I think Hamburg is one of the most logical options. It is after all, often referred to as the Venice of the North.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by antr on Monday March 16, 2015 @01:47PM (#9212995)
You should take a look at the Madrid Rio project by Dutch studio West8, it's very similar to the mentioned idea in the BBC article: http://www.west8.nl/projects/madrid_rio/

In Summary:

- The city of Madrid buried a 6km section of their ring road

- In this buried section, a total of 46km of roads/tunnels have been constructed

- The above area is now a reclaimed riverbank and a huge park

- IMO, a superb public realm initiative, although I'm guessing not cheap

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Squallco on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @09:38AM (#9217772)
Thank you for this link. This is really impressive.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by timjahn on Monday March 16, 2015 @01:37PM (#9212914)
Seriously! It's crazy.

We live in such an auto centric society. I often think, why do we have the parking lot in shopping centers go all the way up to the front door (so you have to cross in the path of cars to enter the building)?

Why don't the aisles go directly up to a big sidewalk/walking area in front of the building and that's it? You could have turnarounds every few for picking people up and something dedicated for emergency vehicles, but it's crazy that you have to cross in front of cars to enter the building, when there's 0 reason for those cars to drive right in front of the building!

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by criley2 on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:21PM (#9213235)
Regardless of design you must let emergency services access the building simply.

No lane in front means Fire Trucks cannot stop in front of the massive building.

I'd bet that front lanes are a building code / safety requirement.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by timjahn on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:00PM (#9213514)
I'm confident you could alter the current design to allow for extremely easy emergency service access to whatever part of the building needed, without having a giant ass road right in front of the building's front door.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by toomuchtodo on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:05PM (#9213541)
Correct. You can indeed have an aisle that supports emergency and delivery vehicles without allowing daily vehicle traffic to the front of the building.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by jseliger on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:47PM (#9213417)
Gosh I hope we can figure this out in my lifetime.

Me too. BTW, The High Cost of Free Parking by Shoup is amazing on this issue (http://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Free-Parking-Updated/dp/1932...). Totally changed my perspective when I read it.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by egypturnash on Monday March 16, 2015 @01:55PM (#9213058)
I've lived in multiple cities over the years. Currently it's Seattle. If anything, I'd say Seattle is one of the less paved-over places I've been.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by arcadius on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:03PM (#9213124)
All the bodies of water certainly help.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by egypturnash on Thursday March 19, 2015 @02:03PM (#9233575)
There's also just a lot of green space here. The city's got parks all over, in a bunch of different sizes. If you're downtown you have to trek a bit to get to a nice quiet park, but it's generally pretty easy to find somewhere you can just sit in a patch of dandelions and contemplate the ineffable.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by bduerst on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:12PM (#9213189)
I seem to remember someone saying that just over half of Los Angeles' land is paved for roads and parking lots. It's pretty ridiculous.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Crito on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:24PM (#9213699)
Even if we banned cars from Seattle, I would hope that we wouldn't tear up those roads and put buildings on them. Turning them into elongated parks for pedestrians would be a better option.

Of the arguments against cars in cities, I think that "streets waste space" is the weakest. I rarely drive, but I wouldn't want to be in a city without some sort of streets, that would just be claustrophobic.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by lmm on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:36PM (#9214217)
Have you been to a European city, somewhere built before cars? Open space is good but you don't need the width of American streets, and it's important to get the pedestrian density up high enough that people feel like there's something going on.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Crito on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:56PM (#9214705)
Yes, and I find it claustrophobic.

Pedestrian density should be targeted using a "pedestrians per block" metric, not a "pedestrians per square meter" metric. 100 people on a wide pedestrian path is preferable to 100 people on a narrow pedestrian path of the same length. I don't think that constantly getting in the way of other people, getting stuck behind other people, and constantly bumping into other people helps anyone.

Then again, I also avoid concerts because crowd density, so maybe I'm just the odd one out here.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by anigbrowl on Monday March 16, 2015 @07:15PM (#9215159)
Well, it depends where you go. Amsterdam is certainly dense and claustrophobic, so are a lot of smaller towns built around markets. Then you have cities like Edinburgh or Paris that are built around the notion of wide boulevards. Most likely you'd find some fractal pattern in the distribution of wide vs narrow streets in most older cities.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by rodgerd on Monday March 16, 2015 @08:47PM (#9215584)
> Have you been to a European city, somewhere built before cars?

Ahh, Paris. Well-known for its cramped boulevards.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by dagw on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @05:10AM (#9216908)
Central Paris is kind of a special case since the original center was all but demolished and rebuilt in a sweeping top down reform to get rid of all the cramped streets. And solving traffic congestion was one of the reasons for putting in those wide boulevards. The 'original' Paris, before Hausmann rebuilt it from the ground up, was full of narrow streets.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by dragonwriter on Monday March 16, 2015 @09:17PM (#9215702)
Well, it was known for its cramped streets until, to p make it easier to respond effectively with massed fire to the kind of anti-government action seen in the revolution, they were widened.

That change does predate cars by a little bit, though.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by BrainInAJar on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:30PM (#9214181)
visit old Europe. The tiny little avenues between buildings are quite cozy and beautiful
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by forrestthewoods on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:58PM (#9213497)
No way in hell is Seattle 33% paved vehicle surface. Not even remotely possible. City blocks account for more than 66% of surface area in the city core. And there aren't sprawling parking lots everywhere.

You're gonna have to provide a citation for this one.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by brenschluss on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:48PM (#9213888)
"About 27 percent of all land in Seattle is public right-of-way. SDOT manages the land through a permitting process, said Jennifer Wieland, an SDOT program manager." [1](http://realchangenews.org/2013/05/01/parking-spaces-could-be...)
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by peatmoss on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:03PM (#9214374)
Thank you! Not the stat I remember, but sounds like it is in line. As others have pointed out, the ROW includes sidewalks, and the planting strip used to protect sidewalks from vehicles. If I add to this all the off-street parking, then 33% sounds pretty darned plausible / in-line with this stat. Aside, Jennifer Wieland is one of the most awesome public servants I've ever met.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by mason240 on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:42PM (#9214253)
ROWs usually extend far beyond the edge of the road.

You'd be surprised how far into your yard the ROW for your street extends.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by gills on Monday March 16, 2015 @08:34PM (#9215551)
My neighborhood has possibly one of the more generous plantable right-of-ways in the city; the sum of plantable ROW is wider than the paved surface. But most places it seems to be 4-6 feet plantable, and denser areas completely paved.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by refurb on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:00PM (#9213965)
I would assume that includes sidewalks?
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by drcoopster on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:27PM (#9214151)
Yes. Paved doesn't necessarily mean that it's vehicle-accessible.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by forrestthewoods on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:46PM (#9214631)
Does 'public right-of-way' include green parks? Spaces such as sculpture park, volunteer park, botanical garden, discovery park, and many more?
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by peatmoss on Monday March 16, 2015 @08:17PM (#9215480)
No, those aren't considered part of the ROW by any accounting I'm familiar with.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by peatmoss on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:13PM (#9214424)
27% ROW, minus the parts for pedestrians and the parts designed to protect pedestrians from cars, plus all the off-street parking (including driveways)? 33% sounds pretty darned plausible to me.

But you're right, this is one of those academic stats I should be able to cite properly. Since I can't find it (I swear it was on Seattle Public Utilities website once upon a time), perhaps this will be an afternoon task to validate. Should be doable by carving up the city into grid cells of some appropriate unit and then using orthophotos to aid blocking out car-accessible hardscape in a random sampling of grid cells.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by forrestthewoods on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:59PM (#9220386)
Contact me if you do! Check my profile. Would love to see the result.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by easytiger on Wednesday March 18, 2015 @04:35AM (#9224245)
> When you total up the amount of land that we dedicate to cars, it's absolutely staggering.

What a narrow minded blinkered and oblique view of reality. Without the invention of the internal combustion engine and our ability to efficiently do as we please whenever we please we wouldn't have almost any of the economic freedom we enjoy today. If you wish to be a luddite and which a rural localised way of life on everyone that's another matter