News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by eqdw on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:35PM (#9213346)
Food for thought:

A ~450 sqft studio apartment in SF costs about $2k/mo in rent.

a ~150 sqft monthly parking spot (as per http://sanfrancisco.bestparking.com/), costs about $400

Three parking spots takes up the same square footage as a studio apartment. It costs a little over half of that.

Then consider how much parking in SF is free parking. Just straight up free. Parking lots for stores. Street parking on most residential streets. Driveways and garages.

It's fucking insane how much space is wasted on car storage. It's even more fucking insane that so much of this storage is de-facto free (which is implicitly a subsidy from the person providing the space to car owners; in a sense it's a subsidy from renters, since any parking space could be a sorely needed living space instead)

I can't wait, I just can't wait until Uber-like on-demand ride tech + self driving cars means we can massively reduce our vehicle stock. Think of all the things that could be more awesome

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by BrainInAJar on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:39PM (#9213367)
> I can't wait, I just can't wait until Uber-like on-demand ride tech + self driving cars means we can massively reduce our vehicle stock. Think of all the things that could be more awesome

First, get rid of the zoning laws that require those spots, then they'll disappear. You can cram (depending on building height restrictions) dozens of apartments in to the same 2 dimensional plane as those 3 parking spots.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Crito on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:31PM (#9213751)
Perhaps all hard limits on building height could be removed, but with the addition of a new rule that requires every new residential building to have 1 level of parking garage for every 3 stories it has (or some other similar ratio). Then, if you wanted to build a 15 story apartment building you would be allowed to, but you'd have to provide enough parking garage to satisfy all of those people.

The problem then is parking in commercial districts. Street parking is good for businesses on that street, but a better solution could be more city-run parking garages in good locations, and city streets in commercial areas that are optimized for pedestrians.

The best example of this I have ever seen is down-town Silver Spring in Maryland. That was several years ago, I hear they tore a bunch of it up, but it at least used to be great.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by lmm on Monday March 16, 2015 @03:57PM (#9213949)
If you build more parking space then you bring new more cars onto the street.

Here in London new residential buildings are built with zero parking spaces (just a small a shared drop-off/deliveries area). There are already too many cars in the city, and public transport is good enough for most people (of course there are people who for good reasons need cars, but they're the exception rather than the rule).

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by MBlume on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:58PM (#9214720)
Why have a requirement? If the people want garages, let them demand garages, let the market price garages so that they're an efficient use of space and construction resources on the margin.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by BrainInAJar on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:26PM (#9214145)
That kind of defeats the purpose of removing the parking requirements. If you require every 3 units to have one parking spot, you raise the price of each unit by 30%. Additionally since tenants are paying for the spot anyway, it incentivizes them to buy a car that they might otherwise do without. If there turns out to be a market need for parking spots, I'm sure someone will step in and build a long term parking garage in the neighbourhood, but you aren't mandating every tenant regardless of car ownership desire subsidize the others.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by TheCoelacanth on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:57PM (#9214337)
Minimum parking requirements subsidize car users at the expense on non-car users.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by kalleboo on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:46AM (#9216330)
Minimum parking requirements already exist in many (most?) cases. In fact they may be the problem, not the solution.

Read: The High Cost of Free Parking http://www.uctc.net/papers/351.pdf

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:27AM (#9216418)
A lot of the cost comes from dedicating acreage to parking.

If there were more parking garages, there would be less asphalt sprawl.

Mandatory parking garages inside apartments is a bad method, but the goal is admirable. No surface parking, no matter how many cars.

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by PinguTS on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @04:24AM (#9216811)
Actually, that is law in Germany. For every amount of building space (residential, business, ...) you are required to provide a number of parking space (depending on the type of building). If you can not provide the required amount of parking space, then you have to pay a fee to the city. All the numbers like required parking space and amount for the fee is decided by the city. So in high density cities the fee is more expansive than in the country side.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by math0ne on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:10AM (#9216237)
I believe the city of austin has similar limits on new building downtown, parking must be integrated vertically.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by Tiktaalik on Monday March 16, 2015 @06:36PM (#9214942)
I believe SF is ahead of many cities in not requiring their developers to build excessive parking. Cutting parking requirements in buildings is one of the easiest things a city can do to make building construction cheaper and lower housing costs.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by b_rad on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:18AM (#9216395)
SF is ahead of many cities, but apparently still has "minimum parking requirements" for certain new developments. Good news though, that may be about to change:

http://sf.streetsblog.org/2015/03/02/supervisor-breed-calls-...

Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014) by dredmorbius on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @09:28PM (#9222987)
On demand / driverless vehicles don't necessarily reduce vehicle stock. If the use is for standard travel patterns, they barely reduce it at all. That's where land use, encouraging bikes, and transit fill in -- walking, bikes, busses, trolleys, and subways all have vastly greater capacity per unit street area than single-passenger vehicles do. How they deal with complex routes can vary considerably though.

What such systems do allow is for vehicle storage to be separated from high-density land-use. A self-driving vehicle can be told to go park itself elsewhere, a dispatched vehicle doesn't need to park while the passenger is otherwise occupied.

But both still occupy street space, and require storage space somewhere.