In an established firm, existing product lines pay the bills. No company is an island onto itself. Companies have partners, large clients, relationships, etc.
Bottom line? To keep existing product lines healthy, you must pay respect to your loyalties. You start seeing the behavior of purposefully undermining the new product to keep the old alive and kicking. You start using sub-standard parts, just to keep purchasing from the same suppliers. You keep on old hands that actively despise the new way of doing things. And that's just the tip of the iceberg.
Frequently, starting with a clean slate is a huge competitive advantage. No baggage.
http://www.claytonchristensen.com/books/the-innovators-dilem...
I don't think the innovator's dilemma applies here. I think the OP glosses over a lot of very complicated engineering and the fact the founder also happened to found a God damned space company.
He took long-established product. And sold a _less_ capable, _more_ expensive version (the Roadster). And used that to sell a _slightly_ more expensive, but _more_ capable product (Model S). Aiming eventually for a comparably priced product with far better capabilities, but at mass-market marque.
That's actually somewhat like the Apple model, so it's not completely novel. But we're not used to thinking of cars as high-tech products (or at least haven't been for a century or so).
http://insideevs.com/hearing-on-tesla-selling-cars-in-north-...
https://openwatch.net/i/40/why-did-the-virginia-dmv-deny-tes...
For the record, not all of North Carolina is so backwards.
FYI this is a good podcast explaining how we got to this point:
http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/12/171814201/episode-...
Here's a little known but closely related fact about Congress: its membership has long contained a disproportionate number of car dealers, which leads to "wins" for America like this: "Last summer...Congress approved a financial reform bill that specifically exempted auto dealers’ financing from regulation."
http://www.publicintegrity.org/2011/04/11/3948/6-car-dealers...
This raises the larger point about car finance in general, which has become the heart and soul of the business. Essentially, the major car companies have become banks with manufacturing wings attached. The interests, skills, and motivations of their senior ranks tend to reflect this non-automotive set of priorities, so it's no wonder that Musk was able to poach serious talent. People who have obsessed about cars their entire lives finally found an employer who wouldn't leave them to die on the vine.
Which brings us back to point #1 about business in general: it's not about what's on the table. It's what's in the chairs.
I'd never heard that before, but somehow, that Congress is full of used car salesmen is the least surprising fact I've learned in a long time.
I personally would rather have a Congressman who had some familiarity with business rather than being gentry for life in Congress.
Here are the actual facts:
A) US Population per the 2010 Census (i.e. the survey that determines levels of representation) ~ 308,400,000. B) 1.4% of this population = 4,317,600 (i.e. the number of car dealers that would need to exist for their current level of representation to be proportionate). C) Actual number of car dealers in America < 20,000.
In other words, their level of representation is not only disproportionate, but wildly so. Like, by a factor of 215.
In other words, the firm already is sitting on top of a machine that prints money. Of course the first instinct shouts, "Don't rock the boat!"
I don't understand: what hasn't Apple done that isn't "half as cool"?
Clearly, the iPad alone is a significant product that has literally changed the computing industry.
Jesus, even the word "app" is new.
http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=app
Using language as proxy, this looks like the point when the smartphones began turning into the most personal of personal computers in a really big way.
"Let's make a bigger one" was a really great idea, but it's not really in the same league.
With the Model S you still have roads, parking, large upfront costs, a driver, and traffic. The only difference is fuel. Minor.
(I'm all for the Model S, but I think you're putting much too high a standard on "innovative".)
That's pretty disruptive if you're a music retailer.
There is a world out there which is willing to go to great lengths in order to maintain an oil supply, and a main use of oil is for transportation.
So how's life at RIM these days? You guys hiring?
Think about what happens if the car really catches on in China (somewhere that has a ton of vehicles and needs a more environmentally friendly solution).
I think you are significantly underestimating the removal of gasoline from the car equation.
Why on earth would you say that?
(Also everything the parent of that comment said. Plenty of places are horrible to use without a car even where the distances involved are easily walkable or cycleable. We increasingly tend to plan for cars first, people second which I personally would consider a dead end and rather short-sighted.)
Energy efficiency issues aside, cars provide something even more valuable: isolation and privacy from the disgusting and invasive sensory overload that is public transport.
I would say the iPhone changed the industry. The iPad also changed the industry. A toddler might not be able to use and iPhone but they sure can use an iPad. That is a game changer not just a bigger iPhone.
If I described Tesla the way you described and iPad, I would say "another electric car with better styling".
Tell that to all of the small businesses that have replaced their cash registers with iPads equipped with Square Register.
I know of plenty of companies that have bought one just to easily demo stuff or to be able to do stuff in the field that they wouldn't have done earlier.
The iPad came out to wide acclaim because they got it right and showed it was possible. So many nay sayers saying even 6 months after release that it wouldn't be popular, it was a tiny market. It's very easy to reinvent history but I remember the crunchpad/joojoo coming out before the iPad, and it got panned everywhere even though many of us wanted a big screen iPhone.
Let's make an electric car is on the same level of innovation as lets make a bigger iPhone. Both had already been thought of a decade before, both had already been tried before, both had already had failed entrants that made no money and it turns out they were actually both pretty large technical challenges to do it well enough that the consumers would actually buy the product.
I would say they were in exactly the same league.
And lets not forget that Apple had already single handedly created the portable computing market in the first place with the iPhone.
And that's exactly the point I'm trying to make, perhaps badly! Before the iPhone or the iPad people knew there was a market there. But they claimed it was tiny and not worth entering or putting serious R&D into. So you ended up with hobbyist/yuppie toys.
Say tomorrow someone unveils a 3D printer that does some essential household task and every house has one in 5 years time because you'd be crazy to not have an Initech Megamaker 3000! Were Initech the the first into the market? No! But they were the ones that turned it from a hobbyist thing into a real powerhouse multi-billion $$$ market. They single handedly grew the market by orders of magnitude, they saw the actual potential market.
Whatever comparatively miniscule market there was before the iPhone is a reminder of how easy it is to think too small. Just look at the Android preview before the iPhone came out! It was utterly rubbish. Google were thinking small.
(And many would argue the world is a better place for people not being dependent on existing large companies to have an impact).
The way you keep people like Musk in companies performing is giving them a large portion of ownership of their particular endeavor, so they benefit based on how successful they are - however then they're really just becoming investors.
Which vary greatly, I might add. The Corvette and Camaro are very nice cars. The HHR was a nice looking, if somewhat derivative car, and the SSR was pretty unique and a pretty cool ride in it's own right.
OTOH, you have the modern Malibu, which is an insult to the Malibu legacy, and all the other crappy/generic low-end stuff they are pushing out.
GM has really suffered from "brand confusion" the past few years. And even killing off a few brands (Oldsmobile, Saturn, Pontiac) didn't really help, because there's still little clear connection between any of the remaining brands and any specific positioning. Well, OK, I guess Cadillac is still the "luxury" brand. What what does Chevy represent? Performance cars (Corvette, Camaro), electric cars (Volt), entry level cars for first-time buyers (??? I don't even know what their model for that is these days), or something else?
This is probably going a bit off-topic, but when GM did the big brand re-org, I think they screwed the pooch. If they were going to kill what was supposed to be their "performance" brand (Pontiac), they should have repositioned Chevy into that role, and focused on the Corvette, Camaro and similar models. Saturn could have picked up all of the low-end, entry level stuff, and Buick would have made a fine home for generic mid-level sedans and family cars. Where electric cars fit into this is subject to debate, I suppose. I would think you could position one as either "luxury" and put in under the Cadillac brand, or "performance" and put it under the Chevy brand (in my re-imagined GM).
Anyway... sorry for rambling. I grew up a fan of GM products, Chevy in particular, and still own a 1968 Camaro, so I have some sentimental attachment to them. But GM management never seen to quit finding new and innovative ways to disappoint their loyal fans.
It's pretty classic "innovator's dilemma" material but a more interesting comparison here is Fisker (probably going out of business) vs Tesla (currently making a small bit of money).
Fisker did exactly what you suggest, they took a bunch of 'off the shelf' components and bolted them together into a nicely shaped car body. They 'designed' an electric car where "car" was the most significant bit and "electric" was the least significant bit. Since existing off the shelf electric gear couldn't get the range they wanted they added a gas powered generator.
Tesla (and I put all of this on Elon) appear to have ripped up history and started from how do we build something you can drive around based on electricity. They seem to have started with what properties do the batteries have to have, what capacity, what weight does that impose etc. They took that very expensive engineering and thinking about power trains and then slapped a Lotus brand body on it to appeal to the elite geek crowd. And they instrumented the hell out of it.
Then they took all of that knowledge and said, ok, given what we know about how this stuff worked, what did and didn't work? Now lets incorporate that into what comes next.
I found that engineering focused direction very appealing, work from zero, develop an expertise, test that understanding, iterate and improve. Now at rev 2.0 they have a much better product than rev 1.0. Their X series should be really something to behold.
Elon also bet big on being able to create an electric drive train with range. Had he started a couple of years earlier he might have missed out by building with Nickel based batteries rather than Lithium based ones. So there is a timing component as well. The larger companies have all put their toes into the water (the EV-1 for example) but hadn't yet committed to jumping. They don't have to commit since they have a working business, building the equivalent to the Roadster or the Model S would have been merely incremental to their business rather than whether they lived or died. So I expect they were waiting for a bit more clarity on this stuff. They always have the option of buying Tesla later and they take no risk in the meantime. Clearly that was on Toyota's mind when they invested.
You can see the same forces at work in SpaceX so it suggests to me it's a management style that Elon expresses.
But really, what's amazing to me is that rev 2.0 is better than most cars on the road today which are at rev double digits, having developed in one of the more competitive markets in the world.
Basically, rev 2.0 desperately needs to be this good, otherwise no one would pay attention.
Our world view is a little skewed because of our ability to launch software products over a weekend or release a new build every afternoon.
They're also luxury (the base Model S is twice an Audi S4) and on limited runs (the yearly production of Tesla is the same as AMG. Not Mercedes, the subsidiary which takes standard Mercedes cars and refits them with custom hand-built engines)
I mean I could make the same complaint wondering why the rest of the industry can't be Ferrari (7000 cars/year[0]) or Bugatti, but basic thinking will help me note that the market for that kind of money is sort-of exclusive.
[0] note: Tesla has ~250 more employees than Ferrari, expects to produce ~3 times as many cars in 2013 and has roughly 20% the revenue. The comparison turns out to makes way more sense than between Tesla and Audi or BMW, let alone Tesla and Ford or VW group.
They're not hand-building the cars, so I wouldn't compare them to the small run hand-build manufacturers. They're building the company for scale. Hand-building is much easier to ramp up and change, but then you get no economies of scale.
http://money.cnn.com/2013/03/27/autos/mercedes-tesla-b-class...
Mercedes-Benz has unveiled a new electric car developed in partnership with California-based Tesla Motors (TSLA). The car is a version of Mercedes' B-class hatchback which has not, until now, been available in the United States.
This car, the 2014 Mercedes B-class Electric Drive, will be available first in the states before reaching other markets, according to Mercedes-Benz. It will go on sale early next year, first in just a few states, but will become more widely available later on.
Another aspect of the Model S worth mentioning is that EVs are heavily subsidized with a $7.5K federal tax credit a huge pile of cash from California--so Tesla has extra money to apply to the fit and finish of the car vis a vis non-electric luxury cars. In fact, as of last quarter all of Tesla's profits came from selling ZEV credits to other auto manufacturers, not from the actual car itself. Take out the $70M from selling ZEV credits and Tesla's gross margin is only 6%--much less than other luxury manufacturers. In fact they'd be running at a $50M quarterly loss without them. So it's easier to make a great car if you don't have to make as much money at it. If Tesla manages to get their gross margin to 25% without these incentives, however, it will be a different story, and a remarkable feat.
To date Tesla has lost more than billion dollars which has not been recouped; that's roughly -$50K per car sold in 2013 ($1B / 20K). In contrast, BMW only makes a profit of +$5K on each of their 1.5M cars sold yearly.
The real nutcutting time will come when an established brand decides to build a high-end electric (the BMW i8, for instance), where they get to combine their much more significant economies of scale with the advantages of an electric drivetrain.
EDIT: The i8 is a plug-in hybrid, actually, so it's really a worst of both worlds sort of deal. The point still stands as made, however.
> To date Tesla has lost more than billion dollars
Are you including liquid assets, like the California plant, as losses? (not accusing you, I haven't looked at their numbers)I think that in order to resell ZEV credits more than 13% of a manufacturer's cars must be electric, which is not true of any other luxury manufacturer.
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=tsla+earnings
But, that may not be GAAP. Where did you find that total?
And then select 'Annual', 'Balance Sheet', and then look at the line item for "Retained Earnings (Accumulated Deficit)"
Or alternatively, from TSLA's 2012 10-K:
"We incurred a net loss of $396.2 million for the year ended December 31, 2012. In addition, we have accumulated net losses of $1,065.6 million from our inception through December 31, 2012. We have had net losses in each quarter since our inception."
Source: Page 31 Here: http://ir.teslamotors.com/secfiling.cfm?filingID=1193125-13-...
Since when is a plant a liquid asset?
This cannot be overstated.
I don't like a lot of the Tesla S design - both interior and exterior. Further, my use case(s) don't necessarily lend themselves perfectly to an electric car.
But the Tesla has a third row with five-point child harness seats built fucking in[1]. This feature alone changes my life. The existing auto industry answer to carseats and children in general ranges from "makes me want to kill myself to insert/remove carseat" to "merely makes me want to kill others".
How much of the rest of a Model S is like this ? Apparently the shocks/suspension are[2].
[1] Optional. [2] http://www.edmunds.com/car-reviews/track-tests/2012-tesla-mo...
1) [X] no radiator
2) [X] grill-less front end (see also (1))
3) [X] smooth underbody
4) [X] "frunk" (front trunk)
5) [X] storage in rear, in addition to frunk.
I guess the point is, in some ways, we've been "living in the future" for a long time; it's just that we haven't been marketed-to enough to realize it. Tesla is interesting to me, and I'm not trying to diminish what they've accomplished, but at least some of the little things that "fell out" of the design that people seem to impressed by are 50 years old.It's just interesting, that's all.
======
Interesting fact: 1968 VW Type 3 is the first volume produced auto to ship electronic fuel injection. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_air-cooled_engine#Ty...)
This is a bit like PayPal versus other payment vendors (what an appropriate example!) -- it's easy for other payment vendors to talk big when they're at a small scale or dealing only in a niche, but once they're generalists those ideals tend to fall apart.
Rear-facing seats are illegal in many areas, for one, leading to export issues. The second is that anything dealing with children is a legal nightmare in general, and faces by far the most regulatory scrutiny: Having four young children, I've gone through probably half-a-dozen child-seat recall issues for various relatively minor things. Integrate that in the vehicle and you suddenly have a major corporate liability.
Tesla is an amazing company, but as they grow they will get the layers of protection that every other company eventually gains (e.g. "the most we'll do are some frame-anchored LATCH anchors that we are forced to install by the government...").
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/motoring/car-manufacturers/bmw/10...
Meh. If they avoid the volatility of other luxury manufacturers that's an accomplishment in and of itself and something that makes them an interesting investment, even if their margins aren't phenomenal.
Who owns Jaguar or Lotus right now? Or Aston Martin, or whoever? These aren't stable companies we're talking about.
2. Stupidity
3. Money
4. Because the US is too fiercely independent and hardheaded to adopt the principles of this guy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._Edwards_Deming
Overall, I think Musk is just a really fucking smart guy. He happened to get a lot of money, and that doesn't usually happen to the smart people; it usually happens to the people who know how to grab at money, which as it turns out is not a remarkable skill and doesn't correlate too highly with future success. Whether you like the guy or not, Elon Musk is a dreamer, and has big ideas, and the capital to realize them. That's a damn rare thing, and we're lucky for it.
If you're one of those people, for pete's sake go do something big. Everyone else is pretty stupid, and nearly everything can be done better.
Because they have hundreds of billions already invested in factories. That's why.
You want to drive an electric car? Great, this means that the kilometer assembly line making gears, piston and other stuff is now completely useless. The investment goes down the drain.
In R&D department you have 50 something years old specialized in fluids, internal combustion engines and moving parts wear.
How they are going to feel when you remove ALL the internal fluids but refrigeration, remove the combustion engine and minimize moving parts and wear?.
Now you need experts on electric motors, and power electronics. What are you going to do with the old staff?
That is the reason.
Read the book, I highly recommend it if you're interested by these kinds of questions!
The Model S is by all accounts an excellent car, and I want one, but I am bearish on Tesla the company.
The definition of a disruptive technology is one that starts off objectively inferior but which, on projected technology trends, will meet the market need at some future date. The existing market can recognize these facts well in advance, but when the time comes to switch technologies finds upstart incumbents using the new technology with a cost structure the established companies cannot match.
Electric cars qualify because they do not at the same price have the same range, acceleration, or refuel time as gasoline cars. But all three aspects are improving exponentially over time. On current trends, electric cars will be comparable to or better than gasoline cars on all three metrics within 20 years.
What Elon has done is realized that the cost difference between building a top end car and a bottom end car is not that great, and at the price of a top end car he can deliver equivalent to better acceleration and range, with recharge time that is acceptable to many. This is very unusual - normally the upstarts in a disruptive market start at the bottom of the market and move up. (Indeed that was the pattern that Christensen predicted for electric cars.) But the mechanics work the same way. By the time Tesla can deliver a mass market car at a mass market price, the incumbents won't have the technology or business structure to deliver a competitive car at a competitive price.
For all of the reasons why existing companies will not be able to modify their technology and business structure to what is needed to compete with Tesla, I highly recommend Clayton's followup book, The Innovator's Solution.
Of course they are. They work completely differently from ICE cars and even hybrids to solve the same problem (transportation). That's the definition of a disruptive technology.
A disruptive electric car would be if a golf cart maker made a $7500 car with a top speed of 60mph and a range of 50 miles. No current car customer would want that, but people that couldn't afford a new reliable car, or teenagers whose parents only sort-of trusted them, etc would love to buy it.
That's one of the central points in the aforementioned book Innovator's Dilemma. Disruptive technologies often start out as expensive products that only attract a small segment of early adopters. This leads established players to ignore them. But new technology often holds greater potential for improvement (easy gains in existing technology have already been tapped). With time, cost is reduced while performance is increased, and it wins over the market.
Tesla may or may not end up being disruptive. But price certainly doesn't rule it out.
You don't skate toward the puck, you skate where the puck is going. This kind of thinking is why, for example, Toyota was able to build the Prius and GM wasn't.
Japanese manufacturers started earlier, building up the necessary experience, technology, and culture at a time when nobody could sell hybrids without heavy subsidies. They took losses for years, learned the hard lessons early, and kept the disasters small. Then, when the market was finally ready, they were, too.
That's what Tesla is doing... but despite countless historical examples of market disruption, the incumbents will react with great surprise when they get their asses kicked. Today the car costs $100K. Tomorrow they will know how to build one that costs $10K.
If you consider the change in routine fueling habits, too, that's pretty amazing. Plugging in at night vs weekly trips to a gas station is a big deal.
Yeah, except unlike an M5, it is a high-tech and environmentally friendly vehicle.
Contrast that to the Tesla, which has been engineered from the ground up to use batteries to power it. The car is a technological marvel, even compared to cars like the M5. And this translates to a driving experience that is different enough from ICE cars* that it makes it a disruptive tech.
*instant acceleration, no engine noise, real-time graphical feedback about the car's systems, etc.
ICE automakers can't retool their supply chains overnight (or even over several years) to make an equivelent product.
How are they disruptive? They achieve identical (performance wise, superior) capability with reduced maintenance and reduced fuel cost due to electricity being cheaper than gasoline.
In the short term, the increased cost makes them disruptive only in the high-end sedan market. As the production scales up, this will move into the lower-tier markets. I think you are intelligent enough to get this.
I believe they are/will soon be selling in the UK.
My other mistake was in saying "electric car" and not "Tesla's electric cars". Thanks to all for the interesting discussion.
PS: I still want one.
PPS: I'm still pretty sure that trying to get to scale without a dealer network is what's going to break Tesla's back. Never underestimate the power of the local car dealer.
Those things alone have a hell of a broad impact on American life.
For example, I know that with Ford Motor Company, as an example, the Ford family has a heavy hand in the top-level management (i.e. previous CEOs have been kicked out 'unofficially' because they didn't follow what the Ford family wanted or didn't live up to their expectations). That kind of stuff puts a drag on innovation.
It's interesting that you bring up Ford. Of the big American auto companies, the only ones who have been putting out product I'm not just remotely interested in, but actually interested in, is Ford.
IMHO, decent looking product, good value, mileage ratings look good, interior design is decent, etc.
Part of it is being a well-known billionaire and engineer who partners with the right people to get the job done.
Part of it was determination and long-nights in the office.
Part of it was being able to avoid the red-tape (and stakeholder interests) that the market leaders have in their companies.
Tesla, SpaceX and SolarCity would make good case studies about how to take a finite (but large) amount of capital and develop it into companies that can change the world.
They are, but at a snail's pace. The Mercedes SLS Electric Drive came out a few months ago, I believe, and it's a work of engineering and art.
But Ford isn't Mercedes, and they can't afford to switch up their assembly processes because then it would drive up the prices of the cars they sell, which defeats the point of Ford -- affordable, reliable transportation. Remove the affordable, because the cost of manufacture goes up immensely, and the reliability goes down. Electric automobiles are still experimental technology, albeit very mature experimental technology. Imagine them as Debian testing installs that are very stable, but still aren't as stable as Debian stable installs (the gasoline-powered vehicles).
It will take time, but it will also take game-changers like Tesla for electric cars to go mainstream.
> Imagine them as Debian testing installs that are very stable
Second of all, there's a reason that Tesla started with a high-end sports car and that's because bringing a sports car to market is easier than bringing an economy or mid-priced sedan. Most mass-market cars have small (or even negative) profit margins. In order to make financial sense, the development costs need to be spread over a large production run, preferably world-wide. The size of the big auto companies is so that they can take advantage of economies of scale to make a cost-competitive car. Building decent cars at a competitive price is a different market than the one Tesla is engaged in.
Innovator's dilemma: at which point it's OK for a new product to cannibalize market of your established products? Think iPhone vs. iPod.
In a large enterprise, it also is matter of inter-departamental power struggles.
Every car company has been chasing Lexus the past 10 years in this price range and they could have done something similar.
Second, Tesla suffered quarterly losses for their first 10 years of its existence. It wasn't "that easy". It was a long struggle.
Two bicycle mechanics in a small town game us the airplane, but there were a lot of smart people that tried to do just that before them and failed.
It's easy because we only talk about the ones that had everything go right for them.
I would also suggest that, like the Wright brothers, Tesla had no choice but to make a number of long term focused decisions because doing anything else would obviously fail.
However, I don't think you can overlook the damage the bailouts did. The Chrystler bailout in 1980 and the more recent GM bailout preserved the existing Detroit power structure. All of that talented labor pool and capital that would have been set free via liquidation instead was allowed to stay together. These companies didn't innovate because they didn't have to.
The engineers would have been let go into a horrifically bad labor market where demand for mechanical engineers is zero due to expensive and unavailable credit.
It's like any other business that's been extremely successful for so long. It's very difficult to change course unless you are built that way.
We may be talking about electric cars but one of the best things that Tesla has done compared to everyone else is making the interior joyful.
I don't think we've even seen everything of what Tesla can do yet. If they are really interested in giving away refueling for free then that can that speed up the transition away from oil.
Because big incumbents have little interest in changing anything. They're happy selling the same thing, slightly improved year after year, decade after decade, and only myopically competing against their "direct competitors" (i.e. all the other companies cloning each other's products).
You need new thinking, new ways of doing things and new business models to change the game and the market - something the incumbents have very little interest in pursuing.
Also, who said it was easy? You should watch some Elon Musk documentaries, to see how many times he was close to bankruptcy, not just of the business, but personal, too - all while running a rocket company, too. He might make it look easy, but it certainly wasn't, and I'm sure most still believe he'll never beat established car companies like GM and Ford (I'm quite certain he will, and make Tesla the "Apple" of the car industry).
You see the same thing in airlines. You'd think there'd be little harder than starting an airline and yet southwest, JetBlue and virgin come in and have great success.
Southwest was incredibly successful and disruptive to the airline industry (to the point where today's legacy carriers look much more like Southwest than like the flagship carriers of the 70s and 80s). Virgin America has yet to do anything that significant, and there's a good chance it never will.
Most of the big companies you see out there car makers or otherwise are only at their best good maintaining status quo and doing the incremental revenue push. Reasons, everyone knows already: Layers and Layers of hopelessly useless middle management, Politics, Bureaucracy- Your usual large company BS.
There is total lack of urgency, there is no sense of higher purpose. No clear vision, goal or even a path many big companies want to take. Its all about fixing the most immediate short term things which prevent them dieing, and maintain the stock prices to a acceptable value. The management at all levels is simply designing most ingenious ways to take back big checks while sleeping on their jobs. And then blame the actual workers for all their company problems.
No wonder small unknown start ups with a few folks severely underfunded and under clocked for resources screw these companies left, right and center. And not just that, also in ways these large companies can't even defend themselves.
A more modern example of failure: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aptera_Motors
But examples like Tesla and Microsoft and Google and Facebook and so on are all testaments to the power of startups. It's quite possible to disrupt large businesses (and become one) with a small foundation, I just wouldn't call it easy. I think Musk himself has said on occasion that Tesla has been very close to failure at least a few times.
Is it that easy to start a space company?
Because they can make massive profits with the way things are now. The existing industry is the last place you should be looking for change. Their job is to get a position and embed themselves in that position, not innovate.
Other car companies design most cars by committee and focus group.
Step 2: Take fortune, hire people to build your vision
Step 3: Possibly profit.
The car being reviewed is $90,000. Are competitively priced vehicles really "mediocre"?
The Tesla was not built independently. Most of its components come from the auto industry. Most of its innovations are auto-industry innovations. When you make a $90K car, you have the capacity of really optimizing the entirety of it.
"This car performs better than anything we've ever tested before. Let me repeat that: not just the best electric car, but the best car. It does just about everything really really well."
This is also just one review. It's not like this is suddenly the world's universal judgment of the Model S.
They're great at objectively layout basic facts. Poor at subjective measures.
Worse, over the past few years they've become rather attention crazed, so it's an endless sea of "iPhone not recommended"-type attention eliciting narratives.
In general, I got the feeling that "mediocre" was referring to all the shitty interfaces on cars, and general lack of polish that Tesla seems to be doing correctly. This is something that car companies could / should be doing for minimal effort since they employ so many and spend so much money, but they're not.
Why can't the existing industry do this? Why all the mediocre product that's the tail end of pumping billions of dollars into R&D staffed by largely the same folks Tesla has been hiring?
edit to be clear I'm not just talking about electric cars, but cars in general. There's a few Model S's in my area, and they're beautiful.