News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Your car is selling your data by tomrod on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:33AM (#49684449)
How can this be stopped, from a technical perspective? Can I wrap the comms in a Faraday cage?

Obviously it would be better to have this action be illegal. But with legal privacy protections eroding in the US and other countries, it seems prudent to have a better understanding of the systems involved in the immoral surveillance.

Re:Your car is selling your data by schmeichel on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:36AM (#49684474)
It is possible to remove the hardware itself that is responsible for this, but depending on the car it can very involved: https://arkadiyt.com/2026/05/13/removing-the-modem-and-gps-f...
Re:Your car is selling your data by willis936 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:43AM (#49684542)
I've had good luck with pulling service manuals, finding the telematics antenna connectors, and unplugging them. It's popular to pull the telematics module fuse, but that typically disables internal microphones and GPS that are used by android auto and carplay. This severely degrades features spouses expect to just work. The antenna pulling is a much lighter touch.
Re:Your car is selling your data by greenavocado on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:50AM (#49685334)
You should be using a 50 ohm 1 watt dummy load / termination. It's better at attenuating the signal than leaving the antenna unplugged.
Re:Your car is selling your data by willis936 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:07PM (#49686128)
You're implying the stub of an exposed coax inside a faraday cage is capable of establishing a link with cell towers. This doesn't really pass fermi tests and I've never observed it myself, just read the paranoid concerns of people online.

Regardless, taping some foil around the connectors with the foil making okay contact with the metal chassis is more than enough attenuation at sub GHz microwave to remove this concern without having to source specialty terminations and crimpers (or worse, non-reversible damage to the OEM cable assemblies by repurposing their terminations). I've done the foil+tape on some of my vehicles, but it hasn't made a difference in binary "does it connect or not?" testing.

Re:Your car is selling your data by femto on Sunday September 13, 2026 @07:42PM (#49689952)
Best to use a termination, to avoid the power that would have gone into the antenna from reflecting back into the transmitter output and damaging the output driver transistors. Damage is no bad thing if you do want to permanently disable the transmitter, but not so good if you want it to be reversible. Chances of damage due to reflections is probably low given the relatively low power being transmitted, but best not to take the risk if it can easily be avoided with a termination.
Re:Your car is selling your data by willis936 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @09:52PM (#49690895)
I agree it's a good practice. However in this case I consider the possibility of frying the amplifier a knock-on benefit. The fucking thing should have never been made.

If a hypothetical future owner feels strongly about it then replacing a telematics module in the dash is much easier than replacing harness runs. I somehow doubt I would sell one of my vehicles to someone who would do that though.

Re:Your car is selling your data by dylan604 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:20AM (#49684994)
I wonder if this increases or reduces the value of the car???
Re:Your car is selling your data by tomrod on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:45AM (#49685268)
If your buyer is an institution like Carmax or similar, lower.

If your buyer is the end owner, probably increase a little bit unless they are surveillancemaxxing.

Re:Your car is selling your data by willis936 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:10PM (#49686149)
A good question. I'm not really concerned with the answer since I don't plan on selling my cars. I'm sure a good population would pay to not have their car spy on them and I can think of very few that would pay to have it turned on.

Easily reversible mods only affect price for suckers anyway.

Re:Your car is selling your data by 4chandaily on Sunday September 13, 2026 @07:24PM (#49689824)
To whom? The owner of the car, or the manufacturer and "their partners"?
Re:Your car is selling your data by classified on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:02AM (#49684772)
> features spouses expect to just work

Never underestimate the risks of spousal dissatisfaction.

Re:Your car is selling your data by chneu on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:25PM (#49686317)
The amount of times I see "I'd like to do the right thing but my spouse isn't on board" is mind boggling.

It's wild how convenience trumps everything and then we look back to say, "we should have done better."

Re:Your car is selling your data by willis936 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @03:25PM (#49687707)
Okay it's a red herring here. I also like to use carplay and the phone's GPS is truly awful to use. I also like to dictate texts and take calls in my car. These are things that don't need to be sacrificed if a scalpel is used in place of a butcher's knife.

Sometimes it helps to have someone with their priorities in order keeping a reality check on people who don't always stay grounded.

Re:Your car is selling your data by mannanj on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:54PM (#49688576)
The convenience here for you is CarPlay though. You could instead use a different more accurate gps device you plugin that doesnt have the data leak issues concerned in articles like this one. Then if you really needed you could pull out a sort of external monitor stick it over the other display when carplaying and when needing car-vital features you need the car display for, pull over and temporarily do that thing then pull your extra monitor out again and keep going.

I think maybe being grounded has changed - I would be comfortable doing what I described but I imagine your comfort with your preexisting solution means your ground has shifted and a reality check means you woudl rather give away your data than take the higher friction option?

Re:Your car is selling your data by ranger_danger on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:25AM (#49691980)
I think most people would not be on board with your solution, but in general to your point I would say everyone draws the line somewhere different.

Yes there are many (maybe most) who will not give up their comforts or risk modifying their vehicle in order to make it more private... but trying to play the judge in a made-up internet game of altruism olympics is not going to convert many people either.

Re:Your car is selling your data by mannanj on Monday September 14, 2026 @08:43PM (#49706253)
If I came off judgy or higher than thou, I apologize, it wasn't my attempt.

I meant to gracefully share what I did, and hope to have no offended anyone.

Re:Your car is selling your data by WarmWash on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:45AM (#49684574)
What sucks is that at least with my car, if you pull their access, you also lose all your remote access as well, and the ability to receive updates.
Re:Your car is selling your data by ryandrake on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:53AM (#49684663)
Why does a car need "remote access" and to "receive updates?" I'd consider this a bonus side effect.
Re:Your car is selling your data by ellisv on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:58AM (#49684718)
People who live in cold or hot places like to prestart the climate control in their car.
Re:Your car is selling your data by MarkusQ on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:14PM (#49688216)
When I was a lad we walked out to the car and did that with the key. In the snow. It wasn't that bad and, despite what you may have heard, was not in fact uphill both ways.
Re:Your car is selling your data by tredre3 on Monday September 14, 2026 @01:05PM (#49700306)
I'm sure you take advantage of a lot of modern conveniences that you didn't have as a lad, and you would prefer to not give those up.
Re:Your car is selling your data by MarkusQ on Monday September 14, 2026 @08:17PM (#49706049)
Yeah, but I still have a soft spot for the old classics like privacy, autonomy and dignity.

I don't want to give up my modern conveniences, but I have and will if forced to choose.

Re:Your car is selling your data by derwiki on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:54AM (#49684674)
Why do you need remote access to your car? What updates does your car need?
Re:Your car is selling your data by slau on Sunday September 13, 2026 @12:07PM (#49685541)
It’s practical to see battery level so I can optimise the electricity price at which I charge it.

Although it wasn’t worth the cost of the 3 year subscription so I now just estimate the charge status based on the charge’s power consumption.

If the car is at 10% battery, it may be worth charging at .15 or .3€/kWh. If it’s at 70% charge, I’ll wait until the price drops to .005€/kWh. The whole thing is automated in HA.

Re:Your car is selling your data by WarmWash on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:04AM (#49684800)
You can do stuff like like turn it on to heat or cool the cabin, live track it's location, lock/unlock doors, open/close trunk, and updates are mostly for the infotainment systemn and driving assists.

Their is a cell modem in the car, so all these features are available anywhere the car has cell service.

Re:Your car is selling your data by drnick1 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:49PM (#49687333)
> You can do stuff like like turn it on to heat or cool the cabin, live track it's location, lock/unlock doors, open/close trunk, and updates are mostly for the infotainment systemn and driving assists.

Are any of those things more important than your security (e.g., against hackers) and privacy?

Re:Your car is selling your data by fhdkweig on Sunday September 13, 2026 @03:19PM (#49687632)
> What updates does you car need?

These cars are more software than hardware now. And like everything else in the software industry, every product gets released incomplete and patched later.

Although the correct solution would be a USB port somewhere to insert a patch file rather that over-the-air updates that might happen while driving.

Re:Your car is selling your data by natch on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:56AM (#49684697)
Vote with your dollars. I know one brand that has the most leading edge tech and does not sell my data so I bought from them. However they do use my anonymized data to train models for a future FSD capability but only because I opted in to that.
Re:Your car is selling your data by bix6 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:22AM (#49685010)
Which brand? And what's to stop them from changing your opt in toggle on after an update as we've seen countless companies do time and time again?
Re:Your car is selling your data by natch on Monday September 14, 2026 @09:32PM (#49706625)
Since 2008 they have not changed the policy. But sure, the policy could be changed if they changed management. Tesla, to answer your question.
Re:Your car is selling your data by skrause on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:20AM (#49685001)
I want a car that doesn't collect the data, not one that gives a pinky promise not to sell still collected data.
Re:Your car is selling your data by pnw on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:41PM (#49687247)
When given the choice between privacy and convenience, the great majority of consumers choose convenience over and over again.

I'm not sure what the solution is, but it's not going to be market based if you look at any recent trends. Interest in privacy is unfortunately a niche concern outside of places like HN.

Anyone who has tried to market a privacy oriented product knows what I am talking about.

Re:Your car is selling your data by mannanj on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:55PM (#49688586)
Is it that the friction to use privacy is too high and not that interest in privacy is actually a niche concern?

I imagine its friction and not indicative of interest itself.

Re:Your car is selling your data by mnmalst on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:23AM (#49685023)
Which brand is that if you don't mind me asking?
Re:Your car is selling your data by natch on Monday September 14, 2026 @09:33PM (#49706630)
Tesla
Re:Your car is selling your data by SirHackalot on Thursday September 17, 2026 @01:41PM (#49744067)
Thanks for the laugh. Tesla recorded people having sex in their garage.
Re:Your car is selling your data by natch on Saturday September 19, 2026 @07:41PM (#49771073)
Sentry mode. A feature that is turned off by default. Then if you turn it on, You still have to opt in to Sentry at home above and beyond that. Then… have sex in your garage, sure, you can do that.

Then, beyond that, it was rogue employees who were looking at that, and they were caught. I don’t know if they were fired, maybe you do.

Re:Your car is selling your data by SirHackalot on Sunday September 20, 2026 @03:13PM (#49778985)
Rogue employees? There is a rogue CEO who data mined the entire U.S. population with his IT devshop called DOGE and you’re still talking about Tesla and data privacy? If this wasn’t HN I would use an expletive at this point. You can use your imagination, as I’m sure you know what you are. Get lost.
Re:Your car is selling your data by SirHackalot on Thursday September 17, 2026 @01:42PM (#49744082)
Re:Your car is selling your data by SirHackalot on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:33AM (#49685146)
“FSD?” You aren’t talking about Tesla, are you? “Vote with your dollars?” So you voted for regulatory capture, election interference, erosion of free speech (due to concentration of media power), and you’re financially supporting an openly racist, openly fascist oligarch who’s let the mask completely slip? I can’t even mention the gesture he did on the inauguration stage, because the mods tend to delete any mention of that. Galaxy brain moment. /s

The fact that you even said that with a straight face. If you buy a Tesla in >2025 you’re morally bankrupt. Yeah… I’d rather my data get sold than support any Musk-led company.

Re:Your car is selling your data by 93po on Sunday September 13, 2026 @12:16PM (#49685634)
don't forget that elon is personally responsible for the deaths of 14 million people, now ranked #4 just below hitler and above stalin
Re:Your car is selling your data by SirHackalot on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:40PM (#49686488)
He has caused a non-zero number of deaths from entirely preventable diseases, I would rather not mention any numbers (nor do I claim real knowledge of them) before there is public accountability. Mentioning numbers tends to put the Elon Stans into a willfully ignorant state. It’s natural for them, as they have to pretend the Emperor’s garments are astonishing 24/7.
Re:Your car is selling your data by 93po on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:13AM (#49691898)
but you agree he's personally responsible for at least like a million though right?
Re:Your car is selling your data by SirHackalot on Monday September 14, 2026 @02:36PM (#49701750)
Are you being sarcastic? Hard to tell online. I don’t know the exact numbers, like I said. I know it’s non-zero because of simple logic. That’s all I need to know to form an opinion on the guy.
Re:Your car is selling your data by qwerpy on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:32PM (#49688374)
That’s a lot of words coming from a very angry place. Frankly I’m surprised and disappointed that this hasn’t been flagged yet.
Re:Your car is selling your data by SirHackalot on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:25PM (#49688874)
Congrats you free speech absolutist! You got my comment flagged, but the good thing is everybody with above room temperature IQ can infer what a [flagged] comment probably said based on context :)
Re:Your car is selling your data by retardlocator on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:17PM (#49688798)
“Someone disagrees with what I’ve been told to believe, I want them censored!!!1!”

Just like musk, props on the consistency

Re:Your car is selling your data by SirHackalot on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:15PM (#49688788)
Found the Musk Stan. It’s perfectly fine to be angry with a political trillionaire who did all of the aforementioned things. Keep being disappointed, that’s going to be your natural state when this dust settles.
Re:Your car is selling your data by m4ck_ on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:05PM (#49686109)
Haven't they been caught snooping on customers before with their in car surveillance?
Re:Your car is selling your data by visiondude on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:58PM (#49689129)
lol sure - provide their terms and maybe we can believe this trust me bro attitude
Re:Your car is selling your data by forgetfreeman on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:36AM (#49684478)
Simple: don't own a vehicle with this capability.
Re:Your car is selling your data by tomrod on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:37AM (#49684482)
Much like owning a home without an HOA attached, it is becoming harder and harder to meet this requirement.

It also seems to conflict with `right-to-repair` laws if the capability is legally required.

Re:Your car is selling your data by calvinmorrison on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:57AM (#49684712)
How do you think right-to-repair intersects with cars?

An obvious thing may be to say the software must be published or the spec released, but we've had computers in cars since the 80s. It seems like a tall task but people can and do reverse engineer entire ECU systems (See Trionic Tuning)

Another seemingly very obvious one - requiring manufacturers to publish specifications regarding ALL OBD interface options. Of course this immediately runs into trouble. Saab for example gated features of the security system to prevent key reprogramming, swapping of certain components without a dial out to the internet using specific saab software that runs on a laptop and interfaces.

Re:Your car is selling your data by tomrod on Sunday September 13, 2026 @12:56PM (#49686026)
> How do you think right-to-repair intersects with cars?

Strongly. You don't own the thing you purchased if you can't legally repair it or legally obtain the knowledge to repair it. At beat you're paying an overpriced lease and granting a liability waiver.

Re:Your car is selling your data by calvinmorrison on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:15PM (#49688787)
I tend to agree. In my mind, it would be pretty cost efficient to put a builtin- system diagnostic utility in all new vehicles that provide at least moderately good tooling for the ODB. T
Re:Your car is selling your data by bookofjoe on Monday September 14, 2026 @06:38PM (#49705195)
You own something if you can sell it.
Re:Your car is selling your data by cucumber3732842 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:56AM (#49684704)
>Much like owning a home without an HOA attached, it is becoming harder and harder to meet this requirement.

The near universal proliferation of owner's associations and management groups and whatnot for developments larger than ~1ac (the EPA threshold, some states/towns have lower) is something you can lay at the feet of the Clean Water Act and it's implementation and precedents over the following decades.

The exact area of the buildings, the driveways, the community park and gazebo, etc, etc, are necessary features of the site plan that makes the math that is required to meet stormwater/environmental requirements. And and some legal entity has to be responsible for that in perpetuity. Enter the HOA. This is also why HOAs often won't allow you to expand your driveway or add a non-permeable patio, it could (prob not, but still) ruin the environmental calculations they're responsible for enforcing as a condition.

I'm not nearly as familiar with car regulatory stuff but I would bet a lot of money that they're using OTA telematics to check some sort of compliance box...

Re:Your car is selling your data by tomrod on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:47AM (#49685289)
I believe it was Strongtowns reporting a few months back that HOAs are generally being driven by developers, the only folks with (a) land to build in bulk; (b) capital, relationships, and experience to get fully through permitting in bulk; (c) building a substantial fraction of SFH.
Re:Your car is selling your data by cucumber3732842 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @12:51PM (#49685983)
Strongtowns is happy to follow the money and incentives on all sorts of other issues. Why do they just throw up their hands and say "it's the developers" on this issue?

Developers don't do anything that costs money, like set up an HOA, without a reason. The developers create the HOA because you need your >1ac residential development to pass stormwater permitting. While you theoretically could make each individual .25ac parcel you're putting a house on compliant it's infinitely cheaper to just ignore all that, grade everything toward the road, dig a ditch, send the contents of the ditch through your stormwater treatment features, build in a little margin to those items, show the permitting authority the numbers that prove it passes with flying colors and when some jerk says "but what if X Y Z changes" you point to the excess you built in and tell them to GFY.

Now, where it really gets evil is when you start really pinching pennies or where the rules change over the course of the process making your numbers not work. Say you've got a lot of grade, a lot of rainfall, a lot of stormwater you gotta "treat". Well, you start adding rules to the HOA. Require certain parts of the lots remains grass or planter or whatever. Disallow patios, but do allow wood decks because the municipality considers those pervious, etc, etc. Or maybe the results you've got are marginal but you throw the bureaucrats a bone by saying you'll disallow car-ports and sheds in the HOA rules to prevent people from adding impervious surface. Or maybe you're uphill of some wetlands but not close enough to be regulated by default you promise to disallow working on cars and require people pick up their pet waste and not use lawn fertilizer or some other laundry list of certain things in order to make the local town's wetlands people comfortable not raising objection and claiming jurisdiction.

And of course, however these rules and plans shake out, the HOA is responsible for implementation in perpetuity.

Re:Your car is selling your data by briHass on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:59PM (#49691392)
Not just storm water, but also things like maintenance of 'common areas', roads, and snow removal. Many small municipalities are budget strapped and don't want to be responsible for plowing/surfacing the new little 1/8 of a mile culdesac the developer created to build their 'neighborhood'.

In carving up the 5 acres the developer purchased, the 30 houses they squeezed in left some remainder that wasn't buildable or odd shaped, so this now becomes a lame 'park' or some other space that requires maintenance.

I read all my local municipal meeting minutes, and at least around here, permitting and ordinances control all the environmental/nuisance stuff, so I can't really explain why HOAs go beyond the collective expenses into the draconian rules.

Re:Your car is selling your data by cucumber3732842 on Monday September 14, 2026 @06:06AM (#49694428)
>so I can't really explain why HOAs go beyond the collective expenses into the draconian rules.

Grass is really good at filtering/absorbing/treating stormwater so you might have to force everyone to keep their lawns lawn because the way you've got the lots graded you need that little bit of extra because it lets you make your "shit parcel" where the basin will go a little smaller and squeeze one extra house into the development.

Beyond that I think what a lot of it comes down to is that local governments are invariably run by a lot of the same kinds of busybodies that HOAs attract and the way rules are written these days the "normal permitting process" exists only to let the useful idiots think that just about everything isn't discretionary. There's always some gotcha or twistable phrase so everything goes through a special permit or variance of some sort. That opens up all sorts of off the record dealing wherein the developer agrees to throw everything and the kitchen sink into the initial HOA rules and the Karens in government make sure those things are in there before deciding how to exercise their discretionary approval.

Re:Your car is selling your data by thfuran on Sunday September 13, 2026 @11:10AM (#49684862)
There’s no reason that sort of compliance needs an HOA. Most places already have building codes enforced by mandatory government inspections for major renovations.
Re:Your car is selling your data by forgetfreeman on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:18PM (#49691080)
It really isn't. FB Marketplace is literally awash in perfectly serviceable vehicles that don't and can't phone home. For the budget conscious among us it's also significantly cheaper to buy a "clapped out" used older car and refresh the drive train than buying new or late model.
Re:Your car is selling your data by ranger_danger on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:28AM (#49692000)
Besides the irony of a privacy-conscious user using facebook to buy a car... those "perfectly-serviceable vehicles" are 1. no longer manufactured, and 2. will not last forever.

Unless a new age of unconnected cars becomes a reality in the near future, I don't see this being a long-term solution.

Re:Your car is selling your data by forgetfreeman on Monday September 14, 2026 @01:00AM (#49692182)
"will not last forever" doesn't comport with observed reality to date. There are literally model A's still on the road. Barring true oddities there doesn't appear to be a model of production vehicle that has gone extinct at any point in automotive history. Anyway, three of my cars are older than I am, and I am not a young man. Buying into their shit is optional.
Re:Your car is selling your data by dragon-hn on Monday September 14, 2026 @06:49AM (#49694785)
Finding parts for older cars is a very real concern, aside from a handful of cars that are very popular with enthusiasts.
Re:Your car is selling your data by forgetfreeman on Monday September 14, 2026 @12:34PM (#49699704)
So pick a vehicle you can get parts for if you're worried, you've literally highlighted the solution to the problem you're claiming exists.
Re:Your car is selling your data by ranger_danger on Monday September 14, 2026 @09:17PM (#49706525)
I meant to say their availability will not last forever.
Re:Your car is selling your data by Tepix on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:18PM (#49686960)
Remember that story a week ago „everything I own, owned“? That’s one way.
Re:Your car is selling your data by base698 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @03:45PM (#49687913)
You learn animal husbandry and join the Amish.
Re:Your car is selling your data by pvaldes on Monday September 14, 2026 @04:56PM (#49703887)
You drive an used car from 2016, that is much easier.
Re:Your car is selling your data by codedokode on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:27PM (#49688896)
It definitely can be stopped. For example, China sells cars internally at cheaper prices, but they are locked to prevent using them outside the country. However, there are people who can hack and unlock them allowing operating in any country. But maybe it would be illegal in the West, I don't know. Removing the modem is an easier task.
Re:Your car is selling your data by hosteur on Monday September 14, 2026 @01:44AM (#49692461)
> How can this be stopped, from a technical perspective?

It can't. Not realistically.

It can be stopped by legislation. But that would require politicians who have our interests as a priority rather than the various industries. So not going to happen anytime soon.

Re:Your car is selling your data by KurSix on Monday September 14, 2026 @01:59AM (#49692551)
You probably can't make this reliable across every modern car without breaking something, but that's different from technically impossible
Re:Your car is selling your data by KurSix on Monday September 14, 2026 @01:57AM (#49692536)
It should be as mundane as pulling the SIM card from a phone (or must be)