News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by kentm on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:20AM (#49273820)
> I don't understand why a police cruiser can sit in a public space (or even a private one) and write down licence plates and descriptions of passers-by with pen and paper, or record everything around them with dashcams and bodycams for later use, but when it comes to cameras on a pole this would require a warrant.

Scale actually matters. Things that are generally OK at a small scale become problematic at larger scales. A single police cruiser writing down license plates isn't able to track you in the same way a huge surveillance network is, and the opportunities for abuse are much lower.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:02PM (#49274557)
Scale is more about efficiency and cost, though. Plenty of people want more policemen patrolling the streets.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by abirch on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:11PM (#49274701)
If we simply mandated that everyone install an app on their phone so that the government can track them scales very well. The people without the app would probably be criminals,
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:35PM (#49275082)
I don't follow that... posting a police officer in everyone's house is pretty much a Third and Fourth Amendment violation and not primarily constrained by finances.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by ffsm8 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:00PM (#49275466)
Youre the one that made the intellectually dishonest argument that scale is about cost and efficiency while the discussion was about scale of the surveillance.

from your point, nothing is cheaper and more efficient then mandating an app on all phones through which the governments can track everyone, and consequently whoever doesnt have it would be a criminal. it completely tracks from your argument. You may need to make the app stop tracking while theyre in the home, but thats a technicality. voila. no longer an issue according to your point

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by encoderer on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:21PM (#49275788)
No it doesn’t track. In his example, observing license plates is perfectly legal without a warrant. Looking in your phone is not. These are not at all alike.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by hnav on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:35PM (#49276003)
Then it should be legal for citizens to deploy their own network that allows anybody to track any license plate?
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by derektank on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:50PM (#49276178)
Of course? We already have private entities doing this today. Private toll road operators such as United Bridge Partners already administers camera systems that collect license plates for toll payments. I would assume parking lot operators also do this, and private citizens could create a nonprofit network too if they wanted.

Are you suggesting that people couldn’t do that for some reason?

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by coredog64 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @02:14PM (#49276490)
The challenge here is to ensure that any controls that apply to law enforcement operating their own hardware for this purpose would also apply to them obtaining this information from a third party. We don't need the mayor setting up "Totally Not The Cops, LLC" that collects this data and "sells" it to his police department to bypass warrant requirements.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by skinfaxi on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @02:01PM (#49276339)
Is there a law against that?
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by unethical_ban on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:41PM (#49276069)
Here's my rebuttal: I don't want police sitting down and writing every license plate down 24/7 on every street corner tracking my every movement. That's bad. And they don't do that now, so saying "it happens today" is false.

It isn't possible for them to do that without sensors and AI everywhere. That's why using this technology is a red line.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by kbrannigan on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:52PM (#49276203)
Define criminal ? In the USA Under laws like the Fugitive Slave Act of 1793 and 1850, an enslaved human who escaped was considered a criminal.

Sheltering humans running away from slavery was also a crime .

It was illegal for black Americans to learn to read and write. Seeking education made them a criminal.

Buying or selling a beer made you a criminal during prohibition.

Do you see how easy it is to make someone a criminal?

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by TitaRusell on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:12PM (#49277951)
That's why you need to go out and vote against the Christian conservatives. Lest you wake up one day in Gilead.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by autoexec on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:31PM (#49275014)
Spying on the American public shouldn't be cheap or efficient. We shouldn't abandon our freedom to make the fearful feel better.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:38PM (#49275137)
People either have privacy in public or they do not, but I don't know anyone who seriously claims that there's an expectation of privacy on public roads. What freedom are you talking about?
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by throwway120385 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:15PM (#49277967)
Great! Can you send me the link to your personal bodycam so I can watch you at all times while you're out of the house?
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by autoexec on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:42PM (#49275193)
> People either have privacy in public or they do not

Thankfully, the law isn't as overly simplistic and black and white as that. It'd be very stupid if it were. We have the ability maintain a general principal like "there's no expectation to privacy in public" and still prohibit certain things that are deemed harmful, like taking upskirt photos of people while they are in public spaces.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:45PM (#49275235)
> nuance for me but not for thee

If you're going to argue platitudes from altitude, you don't get to retreat to the comfort of circumscribed exceptions.

Nobody is talking about cops or flock cameras taking upskirt photos.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by autoexec on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:25PM (#49275850)
> Nobody is talking about cops or flock cameras taking upskirt photos.

Just as we have the ability to pass laws prohibiting that specific harmful use of cameras while in public spaces, we have the ability to do something about the harmful uses of police and flock cameras while in public. The conversation is about the harms of mass surveillance and the exceptions necessary to protect the American public.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:07PM (#49277162)
This is actually not how the law works. Nice try though!
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:12PM (#49277946)
Convincing argument vs plain view doctrine.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:22PM (#49278063)
Maybe spend some more time digging into the case law amigo
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by unethical_ban on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:25PM (#49278091)
If you like omnipresent surveillance, just say it.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:52PM (#49278391)
I don't have to like it to know it's perfectly legal.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:58PM (#49278465)
You should go read the United States v Jones concurrence and try to figure out why five Justices disagree with you. Have some curiosity about the world!

You can also read Carpenter v United States for some background thoughts on why it's not as simple as Justice Fluidcruft condescendingly imagines it to be.

In fact if you're really curious, you could even look at the state cases that are bubbling their way up like Commonwealth v McCarthy.

If only everyone were as confident and simplistic as you, we could avoid all these darn cases :(

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @05:51PM (#49279082)
idk how installing a GPS tracker is even remotely comparable to taking photographs of publicly visible license plates in plain view in public but please do go on refusing to engage facts.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by unethical_ban on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @07:01PM (#49279754)
Both allow cops to track people as they travel without a warrant.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @07:38PM (#49280006)
People don't have any expectation that the license plate on their car cannot be seen by law enforcement.

People do not expect their phones to be feeding their locations to cops and they do not expect things hidden on them unknowingly to exist. But it really stretches believability that people have no idea that cops check license plate. Or that cops communicate with each other about license plates to coordinate searches or that cops have databases of license plates. Heck there's a whole trope in media that you need to swap license plates to hide from cops.

Next you're going to be telling us we need a warrant for an Amber alert.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @07:45PM (#49280060)
You should read SCOTUS opinions instead of forming beliefs based on media tropes, duh.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @10:10PM (#49281061)
> you should go away until you agree with me so that I don't have to engage in discussion

I didn't ask you to reply to any of my comments.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Thursday August 13, 2026 @02:53AM (#49282541)
I’d like it if you provided relevant quotes from these opinions that support your assertions. It’s not very persuasive otherwise. These cases are highly nuanced.

Also, you’re being kind of a dick. Knock it off.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Thursday August 13, 2026 @07:55AM (#49284638)
> I’d like it if you provided relevant quotes from these opinions that support your assertions... These cases are highly nuanced.

That nuance is why it's worth reading the entire opinion.

Anyway here you go:

> GPS monitoring generates a precise, comprehensive record of a person’s public movements that reflects a wealth of detail about her familial, political, professional, religious, and sexual associations. See, e.g., People v. Weaver, 12 N.Y.3d 433, 441–442, 909 N.E.2d 1195, 1199 (2009) (“Disclosed in [GPS] data . . . will be trips the indisputably private nature of which takes little imagination to conjure: trips to the psychiatrist, the plastic surgeon, the abortion clinic, the AIDS treatment center, the strip club, the criminal defense attorney, the by-the-hour motel, the union meeting, the mosque, synagogue or church, the gay bar and on and on”). The Government can store such records and efficiently mine them for information years into the future. Pineda-Moreno, 617 F. 3d, at 1124 (opinion of Kozinski, C. J.). And because GPS monitoring is cheap in comparison to conventional surveillance techniques and, by design, proceeds surreptitiously, it evades the ordinary checks that constrain abusive law enforcement practices: “limited police resources and community hostility.” Illinois v. Lidster, 540 U.S. 419, 426 (2004).

> Awareness that the Government may be watching chills associational and expressive freedoms. And the Government’s unrestrained power to assemble data that reveal private aspects of identity is susceptible to abuse. The net result is that GPS monitoring—by making available at a relatively low cost such a substantial quantum of intimate information about any person whom the Government, in its unfettered discretion, chooses to track—may “alter the relationship between citizen and government in a way that is inimical to democratic society.” United States v. Cuevas-Perez, 640 F.3d 272, 285 (CA7 2011) (Flaum, J., concurring).

> I would take these attributes of GPS monitoring into account when considering the existence of a reasonable societal expectation of privacy in the sum of one’s public movements. I would ask whether people reasonably expect that their movements will be recorded and aggregated in a manner that enables the Government to ascertain, more or less at will, their political and religious beliefs, sexual habits, and so on. I do not regard as dispositive the fact that the Government might obtain the fruits of GPS monitoring through lawful conventional surveillance techniques. See Kyllo, 533 U. S., at 35, n. 2; ante, at 11 (leaving open the possibility that duplicating traditional surveillance “through electronic means, without an accompanying trespass, is an unconstitutional invasion of privacy”). I would also consider the appropriateness of entrusting to the Executive, in the absence of any oversight from a coordinate branch, a tool so amenable to misuse, especially in light of the Fourth Amendment’s goal to curb arbitrary exercises of police power to and prevent “a too permeating police surveillance,” United States v. Di Re, 332 U.S. 581, 595 (1948).[1]*

=======

Now the question is: is this characterization true only of GPS monitoring? Or is it also true of a sufficiently broad network for ALPRs? The answer of course is the latter.

Here, Sotomayor + 4 other Justices are saying it's actually not as simple as Fluidcruft's "you're in public so plain view doctrine answers it"

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Thursday August 13, 2026 @10:04AM (#49286168)
Remember, though, that a concurrence is not controlling precedent.

The actual opinion in U.S. v. Jones hinges on the fact that "The Government physically occupied private property for the purpose of obtaining information," and also stated "[t]his Court has to date not deviated from the understanding that mere visual observation does not constitute a search."

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Thursday August 13, 2026 @12:15PM (#49288183)
Correct, and the controlling opinion remained ambivalent as to the question that fluidstack (or whatever) believes is so concretely obvious.

So the controlling opinion said: "we won't answer this question." The concurring opinion (signed by 5) said "fluidstack is wrong."

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Thursday August 13, 2026 @01:28PM (#49289197)
There were two concurring opinions in that case: One was signed by Justices Alito, Ginsburg, Breyer, and Kagan. The other--the one whose quotes you cite--was Justice Sotomayor's alone.

There can't be a "concurring opinion" signed by five Justices. An opinion signed by five Justices is a majority, and would constitute the Opinion of the Court.

I think that the most we can say right now is that although the "plain view" doctrine has been weakened somewhat over the last couple decades, it's not completely dead yet.

The fact is that there hasn't been a case on point to answer the questions as to whether 1/ALPRs constitute a "search" under the Fourth Amendment (a threshold question that must be answered "yes" to proceed further), 2/whether use of the technology can be "reasonable" under any circumstances, and 3/whether there are any exceptions to the warrant requirement. We have a long way to go before we know what the law is on this technology. Remember, too, that the Fourth Amendment has only a "reasonableness" and a warrant requirement. It does not ban technologies for surveillance outright. (See, e.g., Kyllo v. U.S., where the use of thermal surveillance technology wasn't the issue in and of itself, but rather constituted a search necessitating a warrant.)

So how about you tone down the attitude a bit? You're arguing from shaky ground, and there are more constructive ways to contribute to this debate.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Thursday August 13, 2026 @03:01PM (#49290483)
Yes you're right. The "signed by five" was a misphrasing on my part.

What I meant is that both the concurring opinions (signed by 5 collectively) agreed on this same point:

> society’s expectation has been that law enforcement agents and others would not—and indeed, in the main, simply could not—secretly monitor and catalogue every single movement of an individual’s car for a very long period. In this case, for four weeks, law enforcement agents tracked every movement that respondent made in the vehicle he was driving. We need not identify with precision the point at which the tracking of this vehicle became a search, for the line was surely crossed before the 4-week mark.

So no, I'm not arguing from shaky ground. And no, ample attitude is warranted against people not just advocating for unbounded state surveillance, but insisting that it is already a foregone conclusion.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Thursday August 13, 2026 @03:22PM (#49290718)
> What I meant is that both the concurring opinions (signed by 5 collectively) agreed on this same point: [...]

I agree with you that the two concurrences are aligned about this. Interestingly, it did not make it into the majority opinion, even though there was a majority on this point. It probably wasn't included because it wasn't needed in order to reverse the lower court's decision; the physical violation was enough to merit a unanimous decision.

> ample attitude is warranted against people not just advocating for unbounded state surveillance, but insisting that it is already a foregone conclusion.

No, it isn't. It is possible, and better, to disagree with someone while remaining courteous--even on subjects you have strong feelings about.

From our Guidelines:

> Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Thursday August 13, 2026 @08:55PM (#49293572)
It's actually far more dangerous to presume we are already protected (your position) particularly based on reading tea leaves in flimsy ancillary opinions when the Court has shown itself fully happy to blow precedent out of the water, particularly with regards to privacy rights which are grounded in interpretation of the Constitution and not actual text (see Dobbs).
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Thursday August 13, 2026 @09:13PM (#49293688)
Obviously not true given that a wannabe dictator would literally say what you are saying ("it's just plain view doctrine! Always been this way! 4th Amendment doesn't prevent me from flying a drone over you to and from your home every day!")

A wannabe dictator, inversely, would not say nor be happy with what I am saying: You have a right to exist as a private individual, even if going out in public would leak vast amounts of information to a drone hovering overhead.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Thursday August 13, 2026 @09:47PM (#49293896)
Obviously sending a drone over private property is not the same as willingly and knowingly displaying a license plate in public for all to see.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Thursday August 13, 2026 @10:05PM (#49294000)
The Supreme Court has already held in three cases that air surveillance, even from an altitude as low as 400 feet, does not constitute a search: California v. Ciraolo (1986), Dow Chemical Co. v. United States (1986), and Florida v. Riley (1989).
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by fluidcruft on Thursday August 13, 2026 @10:33PM (#49294175)
How does that help your argument?
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Thursday August 13, 2026 @10:45PM (#49294238)
You may be confusing me with estearum. I'm just adding data to the discussion.

I did say earlier, though:

> although the "plain view" doctrine has been weakened somewhat over the last couple decades, it's not completely dead yet.

The aerial surveillance cases are applicable examples of that point.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Friday August 14, 2026 @08:18AM (#49297754)
None of these is relevant to the analysis here:

> society’s expectation has been that law enforcement agents and others would not—and indeed, in the main, simply could not—secretly monitor and catalogue every single movement of an individual’s car for a very long period. In this case, for four weeks, law enforcement agents tracked every movement that respondent made in the vehicle he was driving. We need not identify with precision the point at which the tracking of this vehicle became a search, for the line was surely crossed before the 4-week mark.

Altitude has nothing to do with it. Completeness and cost of picture does.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Friday August 14, 2026 @09:18AM (#49298300)
You’re citing that concurrence again. While that concurrence supports your argument, it’s not binding legal precedent. Perhaps someday it will be, but not today.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Friday August 14, 2026 @09:29AM (#49298428)
No, that concurrence is referencing Katz's reasonable expectation of privacy standard, which is binding legal precedent.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Friday August 14, 2026 @09:39AM (#49298543)
That “reasonable expectation of privacy” standard is just the first step of the analysis and goes into the threshold question of “is this a search?” Because if the answer is “no,” then there’s nothing more to be done, not a search, no warrant needed. But if the answer is “yes,” that’s not an automatic win, it doesn’t mean a warrant is needed yet, because there are further analytical steps down the chain.

Also, the court has still not subjected the specific question against the Katz test. If they did, they’d might agree that a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy in their public travels. On the other hand, they might not.

I think you should consult a local attorney, because you’re not really understanding what the legal impact of these cases is, and I think a deep discussion with an subject matter expert in person would improve your understanding a lot.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Friday August 14, 2026 @10:20AM (#49299078)
So in other words, it's not as simple as "plain view doctrine, QED?" or "you're either in public or you're not?"

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49275137

Who knew?

Ah, yes, I did.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Friday August 14, 2026 @11:46AM (#49300361)
> Who knew?

> Ah, yes, I did.

Still a dick.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Friday August 14, 2026 @12:15PM (#49300802)
It's fine to realize that you stepped into this conversation wanting to say "this isn't settled law" but somehow positioned yourself as defending the person insisting "this is settled law."

Perhaps your aversion to perceived dickishness made you misread the situation.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Friday August 14, 2026 @08:14AM (#49297721)
Who said anything about private property? I'm talking about following someone on public streets.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Thursday August 13, 2026 @10:06PM (#49294009)
fluidcruft is not wrong about this particular point. And even if they were, while you may disagree passionately with the state of the law today, that doesn't give you the right to be a dick to them about their analysis. Knock it off.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Friday August 14, 2026 @08:16AM (#49297734)
1. Yes they are

2. There's nothing dickish in my prior comment whatsoever

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Friday August 14, 2026 @09:23AM (#49298359)
> It's actually far more dangerous to presume we are already protected (your position) particularly based on reading tea leaves in flimsy ancillary opinions when the Court has shown itself fully happy to blow precedent out of the water, particularly with regards to privacy rights which are grounded in interpretation of the Constitution and not actual text

What’s wrong with this? It’s correct that there’s been no case yet on the legality of warrantless end-to-end surveillance technology, and he’s right that the Constitution has no explicit privacy right. Certainly no lawyer I know would advise their client otherwise, and as an attorney myself, I wouldn’t do it, either.

> There's nothing dickish in my prior comment

When someone tells you you’re being dickish, pay attention and take it seriously. They are giving you valuable feedback about how you are coming across. Even if you don’t intend to be that way, and don’t think you are, others can still see it. You need to take that into consideration.

In this case, saying that a wannabe dictator would use the same argument was pretty dickish, particularly in the context of everything you’ve already said to them. It’s well past the time to lower the temperature of this discussion. Don’t keep it on simmer.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Friday August 14, 2026 @09:33AM (#49298459)
The central claim of the quoted text, and the claim that I'm obviously responding to, is "It's actually far more dangerous to..."

If it were more dangerous to insist that these privacy rights already exist (which they do, at least since Katz), then a wannabe dictator would obviously just insist that these privacy rights exist. But... they obviously wouldn't do that. They'd in fact insist that these rights don't exist, they never have, and they're not in the text of the Constitution.

Referencing the desires of a wannabe dictator is not dickish in the context of a conversation about state surveillance powers. Perhaps you're getting too heated and reading tone into other people's words at this point?

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Friday August 14, 2026 @09:47AM (#49298630)
My interpretation of what they said is that it’s dangerous to make the assumption that the 4th Amendment will cause the exclusion of evidence yielded by ALPRs if the question is adjudicated today, based on current law. I agree with this, and as an attorney myself, I would not make this assumption.

> Referencing the desires of a wannabe dictator is not dickish in the context of a conversation about state surveillance powers.

I disagree. Again, it matters less what you think and more what impression you leave, especially in the greater context of everything else you’ve said in this discussion.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Friday August 14, 2026 @10:26AM (#49299159)
I am extremely doubtful the intention of that comment was, "if I were adjudicating a case, my strategy would be X." Obviously your legal strategy wouldn't rest on this assumption. But we're not talking about legal strategies to bring to the courtroom.

By analogy, it is absolutely true that a person has a right to self-defense. People in common dialogue should insist on this being actually true. Does that mean your lawyer should go into a courtroom with the strategy of simply insisting that's the case? No, obviously.

The invocation of Dobbs is clearly referencing a political strategy and not a trial strategy.

I am responding (quite clearly) to the proposed political strategy, while you are reading it as a trial strategy.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by otterley on Friday August 14, 2026 @11:48AM (#49300403)
The fact that we are reading this differently is an existence proof that there are multiple ways to interpret the conversation and the points being made within. We should be mindful of that and respond accordingly, perhaps asking more questions instead of being combative.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Friday August 14, 2026 @12:10PM (#49300726)
You are the only person who made an assumption (a probably-incorrect one) and then was combative about it. People on general message boards talking about state surveillance powers are not generally crafting trial strategies.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49294009

> they are not wrong [per my interpretation]

> you are therefore a dick

I think between 1 lawyer and 2 laypeople talking about law, it's quite likely the lawyer has the idiosyncratic interpretation. I did not fail to ask a question nor did I insult anyone. You did both.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by unethical_ban on Thursday August 13, 2026 @02:19AM (#49282339)
Do you really believe the level of effort for human LEO to track license plates is the same as a bunch of AI enabled cameras?

Do you think the level of effort to correlate that data between people is the same with a bunch of people with excel as it is with an AI agent?

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @06:59PM (#49279734)
Ah, someone didn't read the opinions. Shame.

Confidence and ignorance live another day!

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by DANmode on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:08PM (#49277165)
I know whole States of them.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by unethical_ban on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:43PM (#49276099)
>I don't know anyone who seriously claims that there's an expectation of privacy on public roads

Hello, I'm here.

Practically, we do have privacy in public pre-AI. We weren't entitled to complete anonymity, but the ability to track every single person at all times was impossible.

Now that AI and sensors are making it possible, people are saying "No, I don't want that to be the norm".

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by pc86 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:11PM (#49275620)
But nobody wants their minds connected and all of them to immediately be able to see, comprehend, and act on anything any of them sees. This is what a surveillance dragnet backed by AI is.

The only people who want that are the ones that want to subjugate large portions of the population, or those that want those large portions subjugated even if they don't get to do it.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by ambicapter on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:18PM (#49275738)
Yeah, bad things are easier to do when you can accomplish them more "efficiently". Thus, the moral hazard.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by AngryData on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:49PM (#49276156)
I don't, 95% of what US cops do is harrass and extort people despite most of these people causing nobody else any concern or even a second glance or thought.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by deaton on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @02:06PM (#49276410)
Sure, I'd love to have more policemen around, but I don't want large automated blanket surveillance network tracking the positions of everyone everywhere. There is a huge difference.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by vonneumannstan on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:44AM (#49274245)
>Scale actually matters

Is this actually born out in Court Cases? Warrantless Surveillance by NSA seems to be blanket legal for example.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by chaps on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:58AM (#49274483)
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by sweetjuly on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:52PM (#49276195)
Yes, this is why a warrant is required to access carrier location data for a phone but one is not required to have a police officer physically following you around town despite the outcome (the police get a trace of your location) being the same. Cell phone location data is too easy and cheap for the government to scale and so courts have found that it demands tighter protection.

See: https://www.oyez.org/cases/2017/16-402

It comes up fairly often here since the HN audience tends to be mostly programmers/computer people, but it's really important to remember that the law is not a series of rules a computer can directly evaluate to determine whether something is or is not legal; judges frequently use their judgement to balance the assumed intent of laws and the competing interests of various parties. I don't say this to you specifically but really just the HN audience as a whole :)

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by pandaman on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:56PM (#49278433)
"Yes, this is why" is in reference to scale here? I don't see how it's "why". Cell phone tracking follows you where a police officer physically cannot follow you (on private property, for example). This is why, not because of scale.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by WarmWash on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:22AM (#49273851)
Great, now rigidly define scale...
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by saveferris on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:34AM (#49274059)
SCOTUS has (sort of) done this in the recent Chatrie case. https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/25-112_0am4.pdf

It's obviously different in that Chatrie was about google location data, and there actually was a warrant. SCOTUS ruled that warrant was too broad since it captured everyone in that location, not a specific person(s).

Constitutional scholars have pointed out the ALPR are next in line to face challenges based on the same principles as Chatrie - LEO can get a warrant for a specific person(s) to search but cannot search the entire universe.

That would not prevent ALPRs from existing, but it would require a warrant to search them. Which seems reasonable and completely in line with the 4th amendment.

Edit: words/spelling

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by WarmWash on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:01PM (#49274539)
OK sure, but do they now also need a warrant to look at their own footage from their body cam, or their dashcam? What about the camera on the side of the municipal building?

Compelling parties to give up data is different than looking at your own data. And it is firmly established that recording and reviewing footage in public space is totally fine.

So we are back to square one...How do we define scale such that a police camera on a police car is OK, but a police camera on every corner is not. Or that individuals can record in public but police cannot.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by connicpu on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:09PM (#49274662)
Sometimes the law is vibes, SCOTUS will probably create a set of tests where lower courts will have to look at how many points it hits and decide whether it's over the line on a case by case basis.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by amanaplanacanal on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:12PM (#49274709)
I don't know what the philosophical answer is, but the real answer is that we don't, the supreme Court does.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by saveferris on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:55PM (#49275403)
SCOTUS gets into it in their opinions on Chartrie, you should check it out.

They wrestle with the balance there of 4th amendment protections and mass surveillance. It's evolving and generally courts are moving to not allowing mass surveillance -or less so than they have allowed in. Courts have been split on it, and someone already pointed it out that SCOTUS will eventually come up with tests for it.

There were some really interesting parts of those Chatrie opinions that really will test the idea that someone in public gives up their right to any privacy - the fundamental underpinning of why governments can currently point cameras at public places and dont need a warrant to search that video.

Chatrie protected the aggregated viewpoint versus any single public moment - And SCOTUS said the aggregated viewpoint (mass search of location data with no specific person(s)) is not allowed under the 4th amendment. A very interesting precedent.

Gorsuch had an interesting take in that he argued that in Chatrie the location data was Chatrie's personal property and therefore protected from illegal searches from government.

There are a lot of similarities to how ALPRs work, and key differences. Mostly Chatrie deals with a private firms data collection of locations - google vs ALPRs are generally on publicly owned property and recoding things in public.

Still, many justices opened the door to the idea that the government can't mass surveil citizens. We'll have to wait and see how it all plays out.

I am very much of the opinion the government should need a warrant to search through ALPR data (and video for that matter). So, I am hopeful that the tenets of Chatrie extend to ALPRs, video, etc.

Edit: Gorsuch argues that the data is personal and not the government's data - this is what prevents the government from searching for it without a warrant. He did not get into why a body cam or something like that is different.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by chaps on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:57PM (#49277745)
Do yourself a favor and submit a FOIA request for some body camera of something you're trying to understand. If the footage is too long, they'll deny your request for being unduly burdensome because of the need to review/redact those records, even in public.

It took 8mo for Chicago Police to review and redact bodycamera footage from a protest in Chicago. It was 95% blurred. Almost hilariously, one of the only parts that wasn't blurred was a moment where one cop commented on another cop's mustache.

So from the FOIA perspective, the public isn't able to get gobs and gobs of footage just because it's public.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by LPisGood on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:37AM (#49274130)
You don’t need to do that, actually. The legal system in the United States is highly capable of sussing out descriptions like “undue or unreasonable”.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:10PM (#49277195)
Watch out, you're gonna break these programmers' brains.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by dghlsakjg on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @05:41PM (#49278958)
Coders and technical people often don't realize that the legal system is frequently fuzzy by design, and that is a feature and not a bug.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by devin on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:33AM (#49274049)
You don’t need to rigidly define scale to demonstrate at a common sense level that there is a major difference between a couple cops writing down your license plate and a nationwide network of them entering your plate into a searchable ledger.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by WarmWash on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:02PM (#49274560)
...so we only have 5 cameras, one at each entrance to our town.

Five cameras is less than what the number of police on duty are using.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by pixl97 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:29PM (#49274995)
Given that in the majority of places police are typically busy doing things like writing speeding tickets and going on calls that leaves a lot less time for them to sit still for an 8 hour shift and record every single plate they can see 24/7/365. Those 5 cameras would represent 15 to 20 officers which is a huge taskforce no matter how large the department.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by autoexec on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:36PM (#49275097)
The number of cameras matters much less than what those cameras are being used for. If police body cam footage was being indiscriminately scanned for any and all license plate data and all of that data was being fed into a national database which was being routinely accessed and abused that would also be problem. As far as I know, that isn't the case.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by RHSeeger on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:31AM (#49273995)
The point at which we decide it's dangerous to the safety, freedom, and happiness of citizens. Every law we have is a balance between "provides good" and "imposes bad" - and we have to adjust where that balance lies on an ongoing basis as things (technology) change.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by incorporeal on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:49AM (#49274311)
It’s impossible to “rigidly” define words like “chair” when faced with someone who’s committed to demonstrating ways you’ve failed to do it.

Luckily we never need to do that with words for them to be useful, even in legal contexts.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by chucksta on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:30AM (#49273984)
How many man hours could the department in question realistically dedicate to the investigation without the technology
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by morkalork on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:50AM (#49274338)
Scale does matter. Take bacterial infections for example, there's a tipping of scale on the way to full blown sepsis
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by eatsyourtacos on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:26AM (#49273914)
But then scale doesn't actually matter. If you have a problem with something that "everyone does" then you should have a problem with something only a few people do.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by falsemyrmidon on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:42AM (#49274210)
There hasn't been an explicit ruling from the supreme Court that applies here, but there are indications that they would have ruled that the fourth amendment applied. They've explicitly avoided closing the door on that possibility.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v.Jones(2012)

> Also left unanswered was the broader question surrounding the privacy implications of a warrantless use of GPS data without a physical intrusion – as might occur, for example, with the electronic collection of GPS data from wireless service providers or factory-installed vehicle tracking and navigation services.[27] The Court left these matters to be decided in some future case, saying, "It may be that achieving the same result through electronic means, without an accompanying trespass, is an unconstitutional invasion of privacy, but the present case does not require us to answer that question."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carpenter_v._United_States

> Ultimately, in Carpenter the court determined that the third-party doctrine could not be extended to historical cell site location information (CSLI). Instead, the Court compared "detailed, encyclopedic, and effortlessly compiled" CSLI records to the GPS information at issue in United States v. Jones, recognizing that both forms of data accord the government the ability to track individuals' past movements.[24] Furthermore, the Court noted that CSLI could pose even greater privacy risks than GPS data, as the prevalence of cellphones could accord the government "near perfect surveillance" of an individual's movements. Accordingly, the Court ruled that, under the Fourth Amendment, the government must obtain a search warrant in order to access historical CSLI records.[1]

Of course there are no guarantees on how they'd rule today, but in the past they've ruled that scale and ease of access and compilation are significant enough to mean that fourth amendment protections should apply.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by Xirdus on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:37AM (#49274139)
It's not about many people vs. few people. It's about a single person doing little with a lot of effort vs. a single person doing an enormous amount with minimal effort.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by eatsyourtacos on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:15PM (#49274767)
Why didn't you have a problem with a single person doing little with a lot of effort?

All I'm saying is it should have been a problem at that point.. not just because it's easy now to do it at a high scale.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by nkrisc on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:31PM (#49275030)
Because the outcome is meaningfully different when every citizen can be passively tracked at all times versus a few cops sitting around writing down license plates.

The former is massively damaging to our rights, the latter is almost useless and thus barely a problem worth talking about.

The difference in scale matters.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by Xirdus on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:36PM (#49275099)
I didn't have a problem because the damage that can be caused by doing a little is very limited, and if someone puts too much effort it becomes very visible and they're put under extra scrutiny, preventing them from doing more harm. Also because outlawing standing on a street and taking notes is a very slippery slope.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by dnautics on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:58PM (#49276288)
that is not the case. It is not about effort: The court has ruled that single point of time monitoring is fine, but continuous monitoring (a covertly placed gps tracker, e.g.) is a violation of privacy.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by estearum on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:09PM (#49277184)
Neither of you are correct.

It's about how costly (in time, energy, money) is it to build how complete of a picture based on what level of prior suspicion?

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by Xirdus on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @06:19PM (#49279364)
Needing more people directly translates to needing more energy and money and to having less complete picture. So reducing it to the simple "how much a single person can do" is very useful I'd say.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by JK-Swizzle on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @12:37PM (#49275119)
By my understanding, this would be similar to the situation with marketing calls. In the US is it legal for a human to call anyone and market to them. But due to issues from scale, it is illegal for either a program to make the call, or a prerecorded message to be played.

To me, that is precedent in US law that computerized methods of executing human tasks do not fall under the same rules.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by t-3 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:40AM (#49274175)
It's not about scale, it's about oversight. A warrant puts a lock on the data until the request is approved. Leaving it wide open is the reason we have constant news stories about police being arrested for stalking people. Nobody wants to limit the police's ability to investigate crimes, but we do want them to use their power to investigate crimes, not to stalk their baby mama, crush, rival, etc. I fully understand and accept your point that there is no real difference between a cop watching and the cop setting (or hiring) a camera to watch, and I even believe that the more data available the more humanity benefits, and that a total absence of privacy as we know it is inevitable, I think we are not there yet culturally, so strictly requiring warrants for police to access these systems is desirable.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by rileymat2 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @11:45AM (#49274255)
> Nobody wants to limit the police's ability to investigate crimes.

This is not true of privacy advocates, they do want to limit the ability to fish for circumstantial evidence that targets innocent people and causes suspicion.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by zahlman on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @02:56PM (#49276995)
This is non-sequitur. "Investigating crimes" entails knowledge that a crime has actually occurred, and deliberately seeking information specifically related to that crime; "fishing for circumstantial evidence" does not.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by rileymat2 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:01PM (#49277823)
Being located in an area of a crime is circumstantial evidence. Any info on what drivers license plates drove by a camera is absolutely circumstantial evidence to a crime in the area that is known to have occurred, almost definitionally.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by rileymat2 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:03PM (#49277849)
Step one get a list of people in the area.

Step two look at drivers license photos for the person that most closely matches the description.

Step three take the person that most looked like the described person and ask a witness with a poor memory if that was the person.

Step four convict.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by DANmode on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:07PM (#49277161)
You would hope.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by zahlman on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:28PM (#49277416)
There's no "hope" involved here. I'm talking about what the words actually mean.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by DANmode on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @05:02PM (#49278511)
Why not consider how they’re actually used in practice by law enforcement?

Pretty big part of the conversation.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by zahlman on Thursday August 13, 2026 @12:20PM (#49288263)
Because the entire point of my comment was to point out a logical fallacy, not to argue the matter at hand.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by tshaddox on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:24PM (#49277367)
I mean it's just not true at all. We don't want police to torture people for information. We don't want police to detain people for questioning, even briefly, without reasonable suspicion. We don't want police to search people or their property without a warrant. And so on.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by dnautics on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @01:56PM (#49276273)
> Scale actually matters. Things that are generally OK at a small scale become problematic at larger scales. A single police cruiser writing down license plates isn't able to track you in the same way a huge surveillance network is, and the opportunities for abuse are much lower.

Not only this, this a precedented court opinion.

[dead]
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by zahlman on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @02:57PM (#49277010)
The large majority of police killings are definitionally not "murder", and have clear moral justification on broadly-accepted grounds.
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by snsr on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @04:03PM (#49277846)
If you can get the boot out of your mouth care to back that up with some evidence?

The increasingly frequent murders performed by police in this country are absolutely unjustifiable on any moral grounds that I'm familiar with.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by zahlman on Thursday August 13, 2026 @12:18PM (#49288235)
Interesting response. Do your claims ever require evidence, or only those of people who disagree with you?
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by semiquaver on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @03:58PM (#49277772)
Scale does not matter. Here’s a quote from Chatrie:

  > Still more fundamentally, we have never understood Fourth Amendment protections as kicking in only once an intrusion “goes too far.” Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Mahon, 260 U. S. 393, 415 (1922) (adopting that approach for regulatory takings). Where the Fourth Amendment applies, it applies—regardless of “the quality or quantity of information” the government obtains. Kyllo, 533 U. S., at 37.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/25-112_0am4.pdf
Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by dredmorbius on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @06:38PM (#49279540)
Scale doesn't matter in a clear 4A violation.

Scale does matter in what characterises a clear 4A violation.

Nationwide pervasive cross-referenced AI-augmented ALPR is a 4A violation on account of that scale.

(I'd argue that that relevant scale threshold is far lower, but probably above the single-officer-in-a-single-cruiser manually taking notes level.)

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by judge2020 on Wednesday August 12, 2026 @08:30PM (#49280383)
Note that they already don't write down license plates. They use LPRs attached to their cars, and tend to be automatically running every plate immediately through the database, which tends to catch people without insurance or expired registration.

Is the line automation? Or 24/7 operation? (genuinely)

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by breakpointalpha on Thursday August 13, 2026 @11:14AM (#49287281)
Personally the line for me is a human police officer with reasonable judgement and accountability.

If an officer was standing next to every Flock camera in America, the public would be hyper aware of the situation we are now in.

Mass, warrantless, and perpetual surveillance is incompatible with liberty and unacceptable to the vast majority of Americans.

It has to be stopped, or we are doomed.

Re:License plate reader searches should require a warrant by judge2020 on Thursday August 13, 2026 @10:43PM (#49294228)
Been thinking about this today and I agree. If the actionability is reliant on a human in the loop making a decision to create some incident (e.g. traffic stop) then there is a limit to the surveillance while still scaling the law to apply to our growing population.

In that vein, I wouldn't be 100% against Flock cameras if their purpose was limited.

The problem in the concept is that they store all license plate hits for later retrieval regardless of if anything is actively tying that license plate to some form of illegal activity. Even with a short retention window, this is mass surveillance because it allows later viewing of hits based on any kind of search given. And you can never limit that search query in a 100% effective manner, but you could very well tell police departments "tough luck, we only have hits if the plate was involved in something at the time of scan".