By analogy, it is absolutely true that a person has a right to self-defense. People in common dialogue should insist on this being actually true. Does that mean your lawyer should go into a courtroom with the strategy of simply insisting that's the case? No, obviously.
The invocation of Dobbs is clearly referencing a political strategy and not a trial strategy.
I am responding (quite clearly) to the proposed political strategy, while you are reading it as a trial strategy.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49294009
> they are not wrong [per my interpretation]
> you are therefore a dick
I think between 1 lawyer and 2 laypeople talking about law, it's quite likely the lawyer has the idiosyncratic interpretation. I did not fail to ask a question nor did I insult anyone. You did both.
> Referencing the desires of a wannabe dictator is not dickish in the context of a conversation about state surveillance powers.
I disagree. Again, it matters less what you think and more what impression you leave, especially in the greater context of everything else you’ve said in this discussion.