News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Someone1234 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:03PM (#47340603)
"AI-edited comments" is a very interesting one. Where is the line between a spelling/grammar/tone checker like Grammarly, that at minimum use N-Grams behind the scenes, and something that is "AI" edited? What I am asking is, is "AI" in this context fully featured LLMs, or anything that improves communication via an automated system. I think many people have used these "advanced" spellcheckers for years before Chatgpt et al came on the scenes.

I think "generated comments" is a pretty hard line in the sand, but "AI-edited" is anything but clear cut.

PS - I think the idea behind these policies is positive and needed. I'm simply clarifying where it begins and ends.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by jaysonelliot on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:06PM (#47340656)
You should use your own words. It might seem that a tool like Grammarly is just an advanced spellcheck, but what it's really doing is replacing your personal style of writing with its own.

It's better to communicate as an individual, warts and all, than to replace your expression with a sanitized one just because it seems "better." Language is an incredibly nuanced thing, it's best for people's own thoughts to come through exactly as they have written them.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by nkzd on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:08PM (#47340706)
What if English is my second language? Undoubtedly being well spoken is associated with higher class. Your arguments will come of as stronger to the reader.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by jamesmiller5 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:14PM (#47340810)
What you really have to ask is will this community be less inclusive because English isn't your first language, I'd say "no" and I hope most would agree.

> Your arguments will come of as stronger to the reader.

That is persuasian, not authenticity, to the OP's point.

Typed without a spellchecker :).

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by officeplant on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:14PM (#47340821)
Honestly I saw a similar answer on a post talking about AI Translation in github comments.

Post the translation as best you can manage, and below it put the same comment in your original language. If someone has qualms with your comment having broken english/mistranslations they are welcome to run bits of original language themselves.

We're all here to talk about tech, and we aren't all perfect little english robots.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by d4mi3n on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:11PM (#47340752)
Humans have a tendency to ascribe intelligence to how well spoken a person or thing is—hence all the personification of LLMs.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by egeozcan on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:25PM (#47341027)
> Humans have a tendency to ascribe intelligence to how well spoken a person or thing is

That’s true. I’m fluent in German, but there’s still a difference between me and a native speaker. I’ve often seen my ideas dismissed, only for the exact same point to be praised later when a native speaker expresses it more clearly.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by polotics on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:00PM (#47341732)
I don't think that what you're experiencing is grammar related, I'd bet xenophobia.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @10:01PM (#47345377)
Or just management...
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by rrr_oh_man on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:39PM (#47341295)
Logos, Pathos, Ethos
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by polotics on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:58PM (#47341691)
I am sorry but this very broad statement is dated, pre 2023 I think.

I now expect malapropism, hacker curtness, and implicits: TAIDR is the new TLDR.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by tylerritchie on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:14PM (#47340819)
That'd be a "style-over-substance" fallacious argument. Or one could be hoping for a halo-effect to cloud the reader's opinion of their comment because some piece of software made it read like Enron-marketing-hogwash-speak.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dbacar on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:26PM (#47341060)
Sometimes the style is the substance. There is a reason people study rhetoric.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by tadfisher on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:59PM (#47342700)
And that should be anathema to discussions rooted in reason.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:54PM (#47341594)
That's not substance. That's style being all there is, trying desperately to cover up the lack of substance. Rhetoric works best when it gives wings to strong ideas, not when it tries to fly by itself.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by cityofdelusion on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:13PM (#47340792)
This effect is very rapidly vanishing. Well written English is starting to be seen as snobbish and AI-slop especially with younger generations growing up with AI.

The human touch of someone’s real voice myself, rather than a false veneer will carry more weight very soon.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by shadowgovt on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:16PM (#47340852)
[delayed]
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by phs318u on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:35PM (#47341212)
> written English is starting to be seen as snobbish and AI-slop especially with younger generations growing up with AI

This is tragic. I write English well and will employ grammar and word choice effectively to make an argument or get a point across. English was my best subject at school 45 years ago despite a career in tech. In fact, I’d suggest that my career as an architect and the need to convey concepts and argue trade-offs with stakeholders of varying backgrounds has honed that skill. Should I now dumb down my language or deliberately introduce errors in order to satisfy the barely literate or avoid being “detected” as an AI? (as if the latter were possible. It’s an arms race).

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:47PM (#47341452)
> Should I now dumb down my language or deliberately introduce errors

Language is a tool. If it wins the argument, yes. I’ve absolutely gone back through drafts to tighten up language and reduce word complexity. And if I’m typing with someone who frequently typos, I’ll sometimes reverse the autocorrect. Mostly as a joke to myself. But I imagine it helps me come across as less stuck up. (Truth: I’m a bit stuck up about language :P.)

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by phs318u on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:02PM (#47341779)
> Language is a tool

While this is true, it is not just a tool. Or, I should say it’s a tool with far greater utility than just winning an argument or making a localised point. Language is how we think, and the ability to reason well is absolutely dependent on our skill with language.

Language is the mark of humanity in the sense that how else can I convey to you a fragment of my inner state? My emotions, my feelings, my desires. The language of poetry and literature. That which sparks an emotional response in another.

Dumbing down language is dumbing down period.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:15PM (#47342008)
> Dumbing down language is dumbing down period

I agree. But I don’t always see it as dumbing down. James Joyce’s Portrait starts out with a lot of nonsense, that doesn’t mean it’s dumb or dumbed down. It’s just communicating something that is best described that way. Even to an erudite audience.

I have expertise in some topics. I don’t think of communicating that in lay terms to be dumbing down. The opposite, almost: finding good analogies and expressing them clearly is a lot of fun, even if what comes out the other end isn’t particularly sophisticated.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by phs318u on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:37PM (#47343281)
Totally agree. But I’m seeing (or more sensitive to) increasing cohorts that can’t string two words together to express a single thought coherently. There’s a difference between adapting language and use of linguistic tools (such as metaphors) versus semi-coherent blathering.

EDIT: spread > express Which may be a segue to a point regarding using corrective tools as a form of preemptive editing?

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by eszed on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:35PM (#47341220)
I think you're right, and I don't know what to think about it. I enjoy writing, aim to write clearly - a skill or discipline that took a lot of time to learn, and ongoing effort to maintain.

I've never sent or posted anything AI-written, beyond a pro-forma job description - because I don't know the domain-specific conventions, and HR returned my draft to me with the instruction to use ChatGPT, which I think amusing, but whatever: the output satisfied them, and I was able to get on with my day.

I occasionally experiment with putting something I've written through an LLM, and it's inevitably a blandifying of my original, which doesn't really say what I intended. But maybe that's good? My wife thinks I'm sometimes too blunt, and colleagues don't always appreciate being told technical details.

I also appreciate individuated writing - including the posts by people on this board are not native speakers. Grammatical mistakes seldom inhibit understanding when the writing has been done with care.

I'm rambling at this point, but it's because I'm truly uncertain how these cultural changes will turn out, and (an old man's complaint, since time immemorial!) pretty sure I'll end up one of the last of the dinosaurs, clinging to my manually written "voice" long after everyone else in the world has come to see my preferences quaint.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by antonvs on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:38PM (#47341274)
If knowing how to speak and write my native language well makes me a “snob”, so be it. But I don’t think I’m the problem in that case.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by ThrowawayR2 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:02PM (#47341771)
The "L" in LLM stands for "language". If they are unable to express themselves in English (or whatever their native language is) fluently, they won't be able to prompt LLMs fluently and will be, in the debased patois of modern youth, "cooked". It's a self-correcting problem.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by darkwater on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:22PM (#47340965)
You make errors and weird constructiona like we all non-native do and maybe eventually learn a bit more of English in the process. Or not. English dominance as the world's... lingua franca (ahem) deserves to have it bastardized ;)
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by skywhopper on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:22PM (#47340974)
Then it’s even more likely the LLM will change your words to something you don’t intend. And you will never get better at writing English if you turn it over to an LLM.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:25PM (#47341028)
That's fine. Your arguments will not come of stronger to the reader, they are strong or they are not and we're all clever enough to read through the occasional grammar error.

And that's where I think the guidelines could be expanded a bit more to restore the balance. Something along the line of 'HN is visited by people from all over the world and from many different cultural and linguistical backgrounds. Please respect that and realize that native English and Western background should not be automatically assumed. It is the message that counts, not the form in which it was presented.'.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by altairprime on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:29PM (#47341110)
Do the best that you can unassisted. There is a chasm of difference between someone coming into English from another language, and someone using Google Translate to submit a post originating another language. French aphorisms are a stellar example of this: I’d rather read “A bird in the bush may not fly into oven” and have to parse out the meaning, than have some AI translate it as “Don’t count your chickens before they hatch”; sure, there’s an iffy [the] grammatical moment at ‘fly into oven’, but it’s such a distinct phrase and carries a lot more room for contextual nuance than having an AI substitute in an American aphorism with machine translation allows for.

(For example: If I’m trying to express a point about how we shouldn’t assume that dinner isn’t “her duty” but is instead “our duty”, a French-like aphorism expressed in English literally as “the chicken won’t fly into the oven unprompted” could plausibly be AI-translated instead as “don’t count your chickens before they hatch”, doing catastrophic damage to the point. To a machine translator those two aphorisms are not distinctive; but they are, even if it’s a weird expression in common U.S. English.)

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:36PM (#47341225)
> What if English is my second language?

Write it broken.

Broken and true is more authentic than polished and approximately so. When I see an AI-generated comment or email, I catch myself implicitly assuming it is—best case—bullshit. That isn’t the case if the grammar is off. (If anything, it can be charming.)

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by vharuck on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:50PM (#47341518)
Personally, I enjoy reading through comments that are obviously from non-native English writers. They often include idioms or sentence constructions from their native language, which is fun to see.

Besides, this isn't an English poetry forum. Language here is like gift wrapping for an idea: pleasant if pretty, but not the most important thing.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:52PM (#47341553)
Well... for myself personally, that works, but only up to a certain level of broken. Past that I quit reading.

That may be a defect in me. Maybe I should make a stronger effort on such comments. But I suspect I'm not the only one who does that, and at that point it becomes an issue that affects the community as a whole.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:12PM (#47341967)
> for myself personally, that works, but only up to a certain level of broken. Past that I quit reading

At which point you’d be fully justified in using an AI to decode their text. I still think that’s a better world than pre-filtering.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by yellowapple on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @10:08PM (#47345436)
> Broken and true is more authentic than polished and approximately so.

From the perspective of someone reading the comment, I'll take “inauthentic” but actually comprehensible over “authentic” but incomprehensible any day.

Also, using bad grammar as a heuristic for humanity will just end with LLMs being prompted to deliberately mess up their grammar, and now we're back to square one, with the state of the written word even worse off than it was before.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Willish42 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:48PM (#47341484)
This is an angle for people who default to AI-edited written speech that I've tried to be more empathetic to. I think it depends on your audience, but in professional writing that isn't published publicly (i.e. communication with your colleagues, design docs, etc.), or even the "rough draft" form of something that will be published, I think starting with your own words comes across as way more authentic.

I've seen enough GPT-generated slop that I find its style of writing very off-putting, and find it hurts the perceived competence or effort of the author when applied in the wrong context. I'm not sure if direct translation tools serve a better purpose here, but along with the other commenters, I personally find imperfect speech that was actually written "by hand" by the author easier and more straightforward to communicate with despite the imperfections. Also, non-ESL speakers make plenty of mistakes with grammar, spelling, etc. that humans are used to associating with "style" as authentic speech.

It can also become a crutch for language learners of any age / regardless of their primary language, that inhibits learning or finding one's own "style" of speech

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by wasmitnetzen on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:20PM (#47343000)
Luckly, something with the English language makes it that especially native speakers quite often have atrocious grammar: They're - their - there mistakes, who/m, the list goes on.

Funnily enough, I've noticed myself getting worse with they're/their the more is use English (which is my third language).

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by ludicrousdispla on Thursday March 12, 2026 @03:55AM (#47347741)
Most native English speakers consider 'speaking plainly' to be a better indicator of knowledge and expertise than the alternative.

I can understand the sentiment though, as I am learning a second language and in many of our writing assignments we are expected to use (from my perspective) overly formal and complex grammatic structures when writing simple letters. I have come to accept, or at least hope, that this is simply an exercise to ensure that students have fluency with the grammar.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by drusepth on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:13PM (#47340782)
I'm not sure I agree with this. I don't really want to see someone else's stylistic "warts".

I just want clean, easy-to-read content and I don't care about the person who wrote it. A tool like Grammarly is the difference between readable and unreadable (or understandable and understandable) for many people.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by timeinput on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:20PM (#47340931)
You could run the comments everyone else posts through an AI tool and ask it to rephrase it so that it is clean, and easy-to-read.

You could even write a plugin for your favorite web browser to do that to every site you visit.

It seems hard to achieve the inverse that is (would you rather I use i.e.?) rewrite this paragraph as the original author did before they had an AI re--write it to make it clean, (--do you like oxford commas, and em/en dashes! Just prompt your AI) and easier to read

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by phs318u on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:39PM (#47341298)
> You could run the comments everyone else posts through an AI tool and ask it to rephrase it so that it is clean, and easy-to-read.

For those coming from a language other than English, you are more likely to lose information by using a tool to “reconstruct” meaning from poorly phrased English as an input, as opposed to the poster using a tool to generate meaningful English from their (presumably) well-written native language.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by kazinator on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:32PM (#47341146)
> You could run the comments everyone else posts through an AI tool and ask it to rephrase it so that it is clean, and easy-to-read.

But that creates a private version of the text which the original poster didn't sign off on. You could have fixed something contrary to their intent.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by tempestn on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:29PM (#47341100)
There's a big difference between me running a filter on other people's words, and those people themselves choosing to run one and then approving the results.

I personally don't see a problem with someone using a grammar checker as long as they aren't just blindly accepting its suggestions. That said, if someone actually is using it in that way, it shouldn't be detectable anyway, so it probably doesn't matter all that much whether or not it's included in the letter of the rule.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Aldipower on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:11PM (#47340748)
That's true, but on the flip side I regularly get downvoted because my English is not the best, so say it mildly. So, now I need to be really careful, to a) write in a good English or b) not to be recognised as an LLM corrected version of my English. Where is the line? I shouldn't be downvoted for my English I think, but that is the reality.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by ssl-3 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:22PM (#47340971)
It goes both ways.

The quality of my writing varies (based on my mood as much as anything else, I suppose), but when it is particularly good and error-free then I often get accused of being a bot.

Which is absurd, since I don't use the bot for writing at all.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by colpabar on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:33PM (#47341178)
> I shouldn't be downvoted for my English I think, but that is the reality.

How do you know? Is it possible the downvoters just didn't like what you said?

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by phs318u on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:43PM (#47341364)
It’s possible of course but reading all the comments from various non-native English speakers here it seems like a common story. It may indicate a subliminal bias in readers (most of whom are presumably American).
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by yorwba on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:05PM (#47341835)
Note that those comments are written in perfectly understandable English. Further note how often you come across comments written in perfectly understandable English, but they're downvoted anyway.

It suggests a bias in writers to assume that people would agree with them if only they could express their thoughts accurately.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by lamontcg on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:19PM (#47340924)
Books and newspapers have had editors for centuries. It is just code review for the written word.

[It looks like MS Word 97 had the ability to detect passive voice as well, so we're talking 30 year old technology there that predates LLMs -- how far down the Butlerian Jihad are we going with this?]

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by MeetingsBrowser on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:24PM (#47341004)
Editors are mostly tasked with maintaining a consistent style and standard.

There is no need for that here beyond maybe spellcheck. Use your own thoughts, voice, and words.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by lamontcg on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:35PM (#47341218)
I don't personally use AI/LLMs for any informal writing here or on reddit, etc. But I think it is pretty weird to be overly concerned around people, particularly ESL, who use tools to clean up their writing. The only thing I really care about is when someone posts LLM regurgitated information on topics they personally don't know anything about. If the information is coming from the human but the style and tone is being tweaked by a machine to make it more acceptable/receptive and fix the bugs in it, then I don't understand why you're telling me I need to care and gatekeeping it. It also is unlikely to be very detectable, and this thread seems to only serve a performative use for people to get offended about it.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by pseudalopex on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:56PM (#47341629)
Other tools to clean up writing are allowed. They did not tell you you must care. You told them they must not. The submisson's use was to tell you and others LLM generated tone was not more acceptable.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by lamontcg on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:26PM (#47342186)
Well good luck detecting it.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by davorak on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @07:46PM (#47344184)
If it never gets in the way of the humans communicate it probably won't be an issue. That is the reading I have of the rule and Dang's comments

> HN is for conversation between humans.

If it is enhancing that instead of detracting and wasting peoples time it does not seem to be against the spirt of the rules.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by yellowapple on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @08:52PM (#47344812)
Except the letter of the rule makes it verboten even “if it never gets in the way of the humans communicate”.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by davorak on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @10:13PM (#47345493)
> HN has always been a spirit-of-the-law place, and—contrary to the "technically correct is the best correct" mentality that many of us share—we consciously resist the temptation to make them too precise.

That is from dang's post in: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47342616

That whole post is clarifying for the intent of the new rule(s).

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by yellowapple on Thursday March 12, 2026 @12:35AM (#47346489)
The problem with “spirit-of-the-law” is that having rules be subject to discretion is a pretty clear avenue for discrimination and abuse. Not as big of a deal for an Internet forum as it would be for, say, a country's legal code and the enforcement thereof, but the lack of a clear standard for a rule makes that rule hard to follow and harder to enforce impartially.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by davorak on Thursday March 12, 2026 @02:50AM (#47347326)
The typical problem with trying to create clear standards with no spirit of the law is that it never matches the intentions with the 1st, 2nd, etc iterations of developing the clear standards. At least when trying to deal with something nuanced. It can get to the point that it takes more time and effort to follow the clear standards than to think through it fresh each time. The rules can also eat up time and effort to maintain and distract from the original purpose.

"Don't post generated comments or AI-edited comments."

What about non-native speakers? Can they not use translation software like google translate any more?

"Don't post generated comments or AI-edited comments, except for translating to english"

What about cases of disabilities?

"Don't post generated comments or AI-edited comments, except for translating to english and when used as assistive technologies."

Some translation tools and assistive technologies are still going to case the same issues that we have right now so maybe limit the technologies used

"Don't post generated comments or AI-edited comments, except for translating to english and when used as assistive technologies. Technologies x, y, z are not allowed a and b and similar can be used for translation c and d as assistive technologies"

But we do not want to spend time/effort on filtering technologies and/or people into the above categories.

In the long run we likely will come up with technologies that most everyone is satisfied with using in different use cases, spelling grammar, assistive, maybe even tone, and others.

In the mean time we can not let the perfect be the enemy of the good. If there are clear standards that achieve the goals, great, if not we have to do something until everything shakes out.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by lamontcg on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:48PM (#47354624)
This thread is literally doing nothing.

Nobody is going to stop using grammarly extensions to post to HN, nobody is going to be able to detect its usage.

This thread just lets a certain kind of people put on their best condescending hall-monitor voice and lecture other people about how they should behave.

And the rule is arguably less useful than speed limits and will be broken about as often (at least speed limits have a very real link to physical safety via kinetic energy).

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by davorak on Friday March 13, 2026 @03:58PM (#47369046)
> Nobody is going to stop using grammarly extensions to post to HN, nobody is going to be able to detect its usage.

I do not think the new rules or for this use case or at least not target at them.

None of the examples I looked at from Dang's post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47342616 look like gramarly edits that are hard to notice.

> This thread just lets a certain kind of people put on their best condescending hall-monitor voice and lecture other people about how they should behave.

I think it is, at least mostly, about the blatant cases that are often already down voted and flag and make it official.

> And the rule is arguably less useful than speed limits and will be broken about as often (at least speed limits have a very real link to physical safety via kinetic energy).

I often see the rules in: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html broken, mostly small ways, I still think we are better off with them or something similar rather than having nothing.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by yellowapple on Monday March 16, 2026 @05:29PM (#47405170)
> I think it is, at least mostly, about the blatant cases that are often already down voted and flag and make it official.

Which raises the question of why an official guideline is necessary in the first place. Obvious LLM slop being downvoted into oblivion is itself a good enough measure, without needing to create extra rules by which to hang the innocent.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by mjg2 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:22PM (#47340978)
I was just re-reading the passage from Plato's "The Phaedrus" on writing & the "art" of the letter for an essay I'm working on, and your remark is salient for this discussion on LLM-style AI and social media at large.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dbacar on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:28PM (#47341081)
RIP Robert M.Pirsig.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by llbbdd on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:42PM (#47342416)
Oof, I haven't finished Zen yet. I didn't know he was gone. RIP
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by NewsaHackO on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:32PM (#47341147)
>It's better to communicate as an individual, warts and all, than to replace your expression with a sanitized one just because it seems "better."

It is definitely not true that it is better for a poster to communicate like an individual when it comes to spelling and grammar. People ignore posts that have poor grammar or spelling mistakes, and communications that have poor grammar are seen as unprofessional. Even I do it at a semi-subconscious level. The more difficult or the more amount of attention someone has to pay to understand your post, the less people will be willing to put in that effort to do so.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by RevEng on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @11:19PM (#47346023)
Exactly. Tell that to whoever is grading your next paper, or reviewing your resume, or watching your presentation. People are judged by their linguistic ability even in cases where it shouldn't matter. It's a well known heuristic bias. It's no surprise that many of the people here denying it are themselves quite literate.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by bruckie on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:35PM (#47341211)
My elementary school kid came home yesterday and showed me a piece of writing that he was really proud of. It seemed more sophisticated than his typical writing (like, for example, it used the word "sophisticated"). He can be precocious and reads a ton, though, so it was still plausible that he wrote it. I asked him some questions about the writing process to try to tease out what happened, and he said (seemingly credibly) that he hadn't copied it from anywhere or referenced anything. He also said he didn't use any AI tools. After further discussion, I found out that Google Docs Smart Compose (suggested-next-few-words feature) is enabled by default on his school-issued Chromebook, and he had been using it. The structure of the writing was all his, but he said he sometimes used the Smart Compose suggestions (and sometimes didn't). He liked a lot of the suggestions and pressed tab to accept them, which probably bumped up the word choice by several grade levels in some places.

So yeah, it can change the character of your writing, even if it's just relatively subtle nudges here or there.

edit: we suggested that he disable that feature to help him learn to write independently, and he happily agreed.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Terr_ on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:49PM (#47341494)
To rationalize my gut-feelings on this, I think it comes down to the spectrum between:

1. A system that suggests words, the child learns the word, determines whether it matches their intent, and proceeds if they like the result.

2. A system that suggests words, and the child almost-blindly accepts them to get the task over with ASAP.

The end-results may look the same for any single short document, but in the long run... Well, I fear #2 is going to be way more common.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by zahlman on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:25PM (#47342176)
The analogy with tab-completion of code seems apt. At first you blindly accept something because it has at least as good a chance of working as what you would have typed. Then you start to pay attention, and critically evaluate suggestions. Then you quickly if not blindly accept most suggestions, because they're clearly what you would have written anyway (or close enough to not care).

The phenomenon was observed in religious philosophy over a millennium ago (https://terebess.hu/zen/qingyuan.html).

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by abustamam on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:35PM (#47342321)
Tab completion was so novel back when full e2e AI tooling was not really effective.

Now that it is, I just turn tab completion off totally when I write code by hand. It's almost never right.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by skydhash on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:54PM (#47343505)
Emacs has completion (but you can bind it to tab). The nice thing is that you can change the algorithm to select what options come up. I’ve not set it to auto, but by the time I press the shortcut, it’s either only one option or a small sets.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by bruckie on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:26PM (#47342187)
From his description, it sounded like this was more of #1. He cared a lot about the topic he was writing about, and has high standards for himself, so it's very likely that he would have considered and rejected poor suggestions.

I have mixed feeling about it. On the one hand, you're right: carefully considering suggestions can be a learning opportunity. On the other hand, approval is easier than generation, and I suspect that without flexing the "come up with it from scratch" muscle frequently, that his mind won't develop as much.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by yellowapple on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @08:48PM (#47344774)
#1 would be a net improvement over the status quo IMO. Seems like a great way for people to expand their vocabularies organically.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by lossyalgo on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @09:04PM (#47344925)
That reminds me of one of the biggest IMO missing feature of Wordle: They never give a definition of the word after the game is finished! I usually do end up googling words I don't know (which is quite often) but I'm guessing I'm one of the few who goes to the trouble. I've even written to The New York Times a couple times to suggest adding a short definition at the end as I honestly feel like a ton of people could totally up their vocabulary game and it surely could be added with minimum effort (considering they even added a Discord multiplayer mode).
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by yellowapple on Thursday March 12, 2026 @12:32AM (#47346473)
That's a brilliant idea and now that you've mentioned it it seems like a rather glaring omission.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by lossyalgo on Thursday March 12, 2026 @05:56AM (#47348505)
Please write to the NY Times and suggest it! I still play and it still irks me when I have to go google a word.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Terr_ on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:36AM (#47346900)
Is Wordle really the best vehicle for that, though? I mean, it tends towards a subset of 5-letters words the audience is more likely to know in advance, excluding a lot of the more-surprising words.

A "click to see more about why this answer fits" crossword, on the other hand...

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by lossyalgo on Thursday March 12, 2026 @05:55AM (#47348498)
How often have you played Wordle? I've played well over 1000 games, and at lesat 1/5th of those were words I had to look up. They seem to enjoy picking obscure words in order to make the game more challenging.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Terr_ on Thursday March 12, 2026 @12:59PM (#47353855)
Perhaps the unusual outcomes are just more memorable, and so seem more frequent? Here's a representative sample of 30 that were used very recently.

    Shoal, Hasty, Lobby, Vogue, Gunky, 
    Sheep, Theft, Linen, Slime, Fluke, 
    Hydra, Dizzy, Lance, Shred, Buyer, 
    Attic, Guava, Awake, Stank, Hoist,
    Mogul, Squad, Roost, Skull, Bloom,
    Mooch, Surge, Vegan, Scene, Cello,
None of those stand out as "WTF does that even mean", but maybe I'm the weird one if we adjust for age-demographics or book-reading.

If I had to guess at a riskier 20%... Guava, a fruit some people may not have had; Gunky because it's slang; Mogul, Vogue, and Mooch were borrowed from other languages; Cello is something people may have heard more than read; Hoist.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by lossyalgo on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:17PM (#47354154)
> Perhaps the unusual outcomes are just more memorable, and so seem more frequent?

That's a good point and could very well be true. I just know I've played plenty of games where I was mad that they didn't show the meaning. So let's say its 5% for native speakers, and up to 20% for non-native speakers - that's still a golden opportunity to expand vocabularies. And honestly it can't be a lot of work to add a couple lines of static text. At worst it would be ignored, and at most, help people learn more interesting words.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by yellowapple on Monday March 16, 2026 @05:32PM (#47405213)
Even as someone who already knows the definitions of 100% of those words, it'd still be neat to see those definitions, and maybe even some etymologies or other interesting trivia. “Cello” would be a great opportunity for a factoid about the oldest known cello, “guava” would be a great opportunity for a quick recipe using guavas, etc.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by comboy on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:42PM (#47341356)
Oh how I despise these suggestions. You sometimes look for a way to express something and you are on the verge of giving the world something truly original, but as soon as your brain sees the suggestion it goes "oh yeah that fits"
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Terr_ on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:53PM (#47341578)
True! There's an important cybernetic aspect to all this, where an automatic suggestion can be an interruption, sometimes worse if the suggestion is decent.

A certain amount of friction is necessary, at least if the goal is to help the person learn or make something original.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by SchemaLoad on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:12PM (#47342872)
I disabled them immediately, it feels like the tech version of the ADHD person who keeps interrupting you with what they think you are trying to say. Even if the suggestion is correct, it saves you at most 2 seconds at the cost of interrupting you constantly.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by TimTheTinker on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:46PM (#47341428)
GK Chesterton would have something brilliant to say about the inauthenticity of it all or something.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by jrockway on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:46PM (#47341429)
I see the suggestions and then choose something different anyway. I don't want to use one of the top 3 most popular responses to an email from a friend. Even if it's something transactional.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:44PM (#47341400)
> I despise these suggestions

As an adult, I do too. As a middle schooler, we absolutely used word processors’ thesaurus features to add big words to our essays because the teachers liked them.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Gibbon1 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:02PM (#47341775)
Friend of mine was a English teacher. She quit because she's not going to waste her time 'grading' 30 essays written by AI.

Anyway before that she HATED the thesaurus. And she could tell when students were using it to make their writing more fancy pants.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by zahlman on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:30PM (#47342244)
One problem I see is that LLMs have a more nuanced... well, model of how words and their meanings relate to each other than a dead-tree thesaurus could ever present, what with its simplified "synonym" and "antonym" categories. Online versions try to give some similarity metrics, but don't get into the nuance. (It's not as if someone who takes either approach would want to spend the time reading and understanding that, anyway.)
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:10PM (#47341919)
> she could tell when students were using it to make their writing more fancy pants

I had two teachers who called us out on this, and actually coached us on our writing, and I remember them fondly. (They were also fans of in-class essaying.)

The others wanted to count big words.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by tigen on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @11:15PM (#47345974)
In-class essays impossible? Pencil to paper?
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by lossyalgo on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @09:09PM (#47344964)
I look forward to reading studies in 10 years how we all became stupider thanks to this "feature". One step closer to the movie Idiocracy.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by comboy on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:40PM (#47341317)
My broken english now officially bumps my comments up instead of down. Sweet.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by zahlman on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:32PM (#47342274)
For what it's worth, I had a quick look through your comment history and your English seems just fine to me as a native speaker (at least for informal communication).
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by ziml77 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:46PM (#47343404)
People who don't have English as their first language often seem to underestimate how good their English actually is. I wonder if it's because their reference point is formal English rather than the much more forgiving English we use in casual day-to-day conversation.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Teever on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:45PM (#47341405)
But the problem is that people with poor written language / english skills are 'competing' with people who have superb skills in this domain.

There are people here who sit at a desk all day banging out multipage emails for work who decide to write posts of a similar linguistic calibre for funsies.

Meanwhile you have someone in a developing country who just got off a brutal twelve hour shift doing manual labour in the sun who wants to participate in the conversation with an insightful message that they bang-out on a shitty little cellphone onscreen keyboard while riding on bumpy public transit.

You could have a great idea and express it poorly and be penalized for doing so here while someone could have a blah idea expressed excellently and it's showered in replies despite being in some metrics (the ones I think are most important) worse than the other post.

What's the solution for that?

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by magicalist on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:08PM (#47341891)
> What's the solution for that?

Remember that you're on a message board and you're not actually 'competing' for anything?

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Teever on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:13PM (#47341985)
This is a perfect example of what I'm talking about.

I knew someone was going to comment on my use of the word there despite me putting it in quotes which was intended to let the reader know that I meant that word as an approximation of what I was meaning.

When I say competing I mean competing in the space of ideas here. There is a ranking system here that raises or lowers the visibility and prominance of your comments and it's based on upvotes by other uses. For better or worse people penalize comments with grammatical errors over ones that don't and that affects how much exposure other users have to the ideas that people write and how much interaction they get from them.

If that's the case why would somebody who has good ideas but poor expressive capability bother posting here if their comments are just going to get ignored over relatively vapid comments that are grammatically correct?

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by davorak on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @07:52PM (#47344255)
> If that's the case why would somebody who has good ideas but poor expressive capability bother posting here if their comments are just going to get ignored over relatively vapid comments that are grammatically correct?

The main problem is that ai consistently is seeing making things worse. Take a look at the examples in Dang's link in their comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47342616

In the ones I read the AI editing is either hurting or needs to be much, much better to help.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by NewsaHackO on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:39PM (#47342384)
No, I get your point. Unfortunately, alot of people here try to act high and mighty like they are posting here for some altruistic reason. The reason why I, you, and everyone else posts here is the human reason that we want others to engage with our posts. In order to do that, you have to put your best foot forward, which includes making sure the spelling and grammar of your posts is correct. While I do not use an LLM for this, I think that it is vaild to use these tools to make sure nothing gets in the way of whatever point you are trying to make.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Teever on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:59PM (#47342694)
> In order to do that, you have to put your best foot forward

In English. You have to put your best foot forward in English. And in your environment with the resources you have at your disposal.

For example, I'm currently engaging with you between steps in a chemistry process that's happening under the fumehood next to me while wearing a respirator, a muggy plastic chemical resistant gown and disposable gloves nitrile globes.

I am absolutely certain that these conditions are different than the ones I would need to 'put my best food forward' in this discussion. I'm also certain that quite certain that you and I would both absolutely stumble if we were obligated to particpate in this forum in a language that we're not proficient in as many users often attempt to do and are unfairly penalized for by other members of the community.

I'm with you on the LLM usage for grammatical issues for non-native speakers. I bet more in this community would feel the same way if Dang whimsically mandated that people had to use a language other than English on certain days of the week.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by fragmede on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @07:24PM (#47343906)
Oh shit that would be fun. Tuesday, we're going to do it in Mongolian, see how that goes.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by 12_throw_away on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:33PM (#47342294)
> You could have a great idea and express it poorly and be penalized for doing so here while someone could have a blah idea expressed excellently and it's showered in replies despite being in some metrics (the ones I think are most important) worse than the other post.

I absolutely do not understand this comment. Are you saying that posting is competitive and that comments have "metrics"?

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by fragmede on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @07:33PM (#47344018)
Yes! If my comment is above yours in a thread, it means I got more upvotes than you did, which means I get special bonuses and more to eat and you go hungry in Internet land. Also it means I'm better than you (obviously) and I get to go to this secret club with all the pretty people and you're not invited. Isn't that how this all works?
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by fragmede on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:50PM (#47341512)
I disagree. HN is going to bury my raw unedited tirade of a comment about those fucking morons that couldn't code their way out of a paper bag. If I send a comment to ChatGPT and open up the prompt with "this poster is a fucking dumbass, how do I tell them this" and use that to get to a well reasoned response because that's the tool we have available today, we're all better off.

The guidelines state:

> Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse > Edit out swipes. > Don't be curmudgeonly.

On the best of days I manage to follow the rules, but I'm only human. If I run my comment through ChatGPT to try and help me edit out swipes on the bad days, that's not ok?

I'm not using ChatGPT to generate comments, but I've got the -4 comments to show that my "thoughts exactly as they have written them" isn't a winning move.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by zahlman on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:34PM (#47342318)
If you see an incompetent coder and wish to communicate that the person responsible is a "fucking moron/dumbass", the tone with which you do so is not the problem. Tell us what is wrong with the code, as objectively as possible. That's what the guidelines are trying to convey.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by yorwba on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:07PM (#47341869)
The guidelines don't say anything about not posting something because an LLM told you that you shouldn't...
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by ma2kx on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:48PM (#47342530)
As a non native English speaker my own words wouldnt be in English. If I express myself in English I soon struggle for the right words. On the other hand I think when I read some English text I'm quite capable of sensing the nuances. So it feels when I auto translate my text to English an than read against it again and make some corrections, I can express my thoughts much better.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by jjk166 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:20PM (#47343007)
> It's better to communicate as an individual, warts and all, than to replace your expression with a sanitized one just because it seems "better." Language is an incredibly nuanced thing, it's best for people's own thoughts to come through exactly as they have written them.

This is the opposite of how language works. You want people to understand the idea you're trying to communicate, not fixate on the semantics of how you communicated. Language is like fashion - you only want to break the rules deliberately. If AI or an editor or whatever changes your writing to be more clear and correct, and you don't look at it and say "no, I chose that phrasing for a reason" then the editor's version is much more likely to be understood correctly by the recipient.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by davebranton on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:29PM (#47343159)
Precisely. As I wrote in my assessment of AI for my workplace;

"Your unique human voice is more valuable than a thousand prompt-driven LLM doggerels."

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by happytoexplain on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:05PM (#47340628)
I think there's a pretty clear gap between editing for grammar/spelling and editing for tone.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by RevEng on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @11:22PM (#47346045)
How so and why? I know plenty of people whose writing naturally carries a tone that they don't intend. I often help them to change their wording to be less confrontational or seemingly sarcastic when it isn't meant to be. Would you say it is wrong for them to get assistance to get the tone they intend rather than the one they would tend to write?
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by happytoexplain on Thursday March 12, 2026 @08:51AM (#47349873)
It's the difference between correctness and tone/character/semantics (tone and character do affect semantics). We need to do things we don't quite mean in subjective spaces, to learn. Developing yourself is wonderful, but presenting a writing style that does not yet represent your learned tone feels disingenuous to the reader and harms the tone of the whole conversation. Using LLMs to iterate might help you learn, but use that tool privately, or with friends/family/mentors. With others, simply make your mistakes.

To be clear, I also think you shouldn't rely on auto-correction or LLMs for correctness (they are great for identifying your mistakes, but I think you should then fix the mistakes yourself, to develop your brain). It's just that "assisted" correctness isn't misleading/harmful in the way that "assisted" tone/character/semantics are.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by glitch13 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:11PM (#47340753)
I saw a similar conversation somewhere about some project saying they don't allow AI generated code.

It was asked that if "AI Generated Code" is just code suggested to you by a computer program, where does using the code that your IDE suggests in a dropdown? That's been around for decades. Is it LLM or "Gen AI" specific? If so, what specific aspect of that makes one use case good and one use case bad and what exactly separates them?

It's one of those situations where it seems easy to point at examples and say "this one's good and this one's bad", but when you need to write policy you start drowning in minutia.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by kazinator on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:37PM (#47341258)
Projects cannot allow AI generated code if they require everything to have a clear author, with a copyright notice and license.

IDE code suggestions come from the database of information built about your code base, like what classes have what methods. Each such suggestion is a derived work of the thing being worked on.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by RevEng on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @11:26PM (#47346070)
That is not correct because it hasn't been tested in court. In past decisions about who owns the output generated by a computer program the owner has been the operator of the program. You own your Word documents and Photoshopped images. There is good reason to believe that LLM output where you provided the prompt would also fit under that umbrella. We are still waiting for that to be tested in court.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by kazinator on Thursday March 12, 2026 @05:18PM (#47357260)
OK, make that: many projects whose stewards understand copyright issues cannot accept code contributions whose copyright and licensing theory has not been tested in court.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by sumeno on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:36PM (#47343258)
Nobody is actually confused about what AI generated code means in those cases, they're just trying to be argumentative because they don't like the rules
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Mordisquitos on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:12PM (#47340772)
I think that the line between A"I" editing to fix grammar or to translate from a different native language and A"I" editing by using an LLM is one of those things that's very hard to unambiguously encode in written guidelines, but easy to intuitively understand using common sense, in the vein of I know it when I see it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_know_it_when_I_see_it

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by tsukikage on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:13PM (#47340783)
> Where is the line between a spelling/grammar/tone checker like Grammarly

For me, the line is precisely at the point where a human has something they want to say. IMO - use the tools you need to say the thing you want to say; it's fine. The thing I, and many others here, object to is being asked to read reams of text that no-one could be bothered to write.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by thousand_nights on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:13PM (#47340795)
i don't care if someone has bad grammar, i want to hear their thoughts as they came up with them, we're all intelligent beings and can parse the meaning behind what you write.

i type my comments without capitalization like i'm typing into some terminal because i'm lazy and people might hate it but i'm sure they prefer this to if i asked an LLM to rewrite what i type

your writing style is your personality, don't let a robot take it away from you

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by tempestn on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:33PM (#47341185)
I, on the other hand, find incorrect grammar mildly annoying, especially when it's due to laziness. It distracts from the thoughts being conveyed. I appreciate when people take the time to format comments as correctly as they're able.

In fact, I'd argue that lazy commenting is the real problem, which has now been supercharged by LLMs.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by SecretDreams on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:08PM (#47340696)
Your comment is one of semantics. Worth discussing if we're talking a truly hard line rule rather than the spirit of the rule.

I benefit from my phone flagging spelling errors/typos for me. Maybe it uses AI or maybe it uses a simple dictionary for me. Maybe it might even catch a string of words when the conjunction isn't correct. That's all fair game, IMO. But it shouldn't be rewriting the sentence for me. And it shouldn't be automatically cleaning up my typos for me after I've hit "reply". That's on me.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by skywhopper on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:21PM (#47340960)
I don’t think it’s really necessary to play Captain Nitpick over spell-check or whatever. You know what is meant.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by jacquesm on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:23PM (#47340984)
Trying to lawyer this is the wrong approach. When in doubt: don't.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by Someone1234 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:11PM (#47341936)
That feels very uncharitable.

When a policy is introduced to seemingly guard against new problems, but happens to be inadvertently targeting preexisting and common technology, I don't feel like it is "lawyering" it to want clarity on that line.

For example, it could be argued this forbids all spellcheckers. I don't think that is the implied intent, but the spectrum is huge in the spellchecker space. From simple substitutions + rule-based grammar engines through to n-grams, edit-distance algorithms, statistical machine translation, and transformer-based NLP models.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by altairprime on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:24PM (#47341022)
Grammarly use is outright prohibited by this; AI-edited writing is no longer writing that you hold personal and exclusive responsibility for having written. Consider Stephen Hawking’s voice box generator. While the sounds produced were machine-assisted, the writing was his alone. If you find yourself unable to participate in this web forum without paying a proofreader (in time, money, or cycles) to copy-edit your writing, then you’re not welcome on HN as a participant.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by phs318u on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:45PM (#47341407)
> If you find yourself unable to participate in this web forum without paying a proofreader (in time, money, or cycles) to copy-edit your writing, then you’re not welcome on HN as a participant.

You forgot the /s ?

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by altairprime on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:47PM (#47341460)
It’s not sarcasm. If you feel if I have misunderstood the intent of the guideline we’re discussing — “Don’t post generated/AI-edited comments”, as the title currently reads, then I’m happy to discuss further. (I often make logical negation errors that I miss in proofing, so it’s possible I slipped up, too!)
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by phs318u on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:05PM (#47341837)
I thought it was sarcasm given you are asking people to “pay a proofreader”. This sounds ludicrous. Could you clarify wha you meant by that line if it’s not sarcasm? Because I’m having a hard time thinking that it’s meant to be taken at face value.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by altairprime on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @05:23PM (#47342145)
No worries. The post I replied to was asking if use of ‘grammar improvement services’ (my paraphrase) qualified as AI-assisted writing at HN. All such services cost something; Grammarly makes a lot of money charging businesses, AI consumes watts of power that someone pays for, and even Microsoft Word’s grammar checker spins up the CPU fans on an old Intel laptop with a long enough document. I took from that the generic point that one “pays” for machine-assisted proofreading by one means or another, whether it’s trading personal data for services (Google) or watts of power for services (MSWord et al.) or donating writing samples to a for-profit training corpus (Grammarly free tier) or paying for evaluations where your data is not retained for training (Grammarly paid enterprise tier with a carefully-redlined service contract) and generalized to “pay for machine proofreading”.

Then, I considered whether HN would appreciate posts/comments by a human where they’d had a PR team or a hired editor come in and review/modify/distort their original words in order to make them more whatever. I think that this probably is most likely to have occurred on the HN jobs posts, and I’ve pointed out especially egregious instances to the mods over the years — but in general, the people who post on HN tend to do so from their own voice’s viewpoint, as reaffirmed by the no-AI-writing guideline above. So I decided instead to say “pay a proofreader” because, bluntly, if the community found out that someone was paying a wage to a worker to proofread their HN comments, the response would plausibly be the same mob of laughing mockery, disgusted outrage, and blatant dismissal that we see today towards AI writing here. “You hired someone to tone-edit your HN comments?!” is no different than “You used Grammarly to tone-edit your HN comments?!” to me, and so it passed the veracity test and I posted it.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by unsignedint on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:37PM (#47341264)
I think the only practical litmus test here is whether you can stand by the text as your own words. It’s not like we have someone looking over commenters’ shoulders as they type.

Ultimately, this comes down to people making a good-faith judgment about how much AI was involved, whether it was just minor grammatical fixes or something more substantial. The reality is that there isn’t really a shared consensus on exactly where that line should be drawn.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by raw_anon_1111 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:43PM (#47341363)
There is no need to use any of it. Just use your own words.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by czhu12 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:45PM (#47341417)
Finding it more refreshing these days when reading text with broken grammar, incorrect use of pronouns, etc. especially for HN, the human connection is more palpable. It’s rarely so bad that it’s not understandable
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by observationist on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @04:46PM (#47341431)
On a technical level, you can really only guard against changing your semantics and voice - if you're letting software alter the meaning, or meanings, you intend, and use words you don't normally use, it's probably too far.

This is probably ok:

>> On a technical level, you can really only guard against software that changes your semantics or voice. If you're letting it alter the meaning (or meanings) you intend, or if it starts using words you would never normally use, then it's gone too far.

This is probably too far:

>>> On a technical level, it's important to recogn1ize that the only robust guardrail we can realistically implement is one that prevents modifications to core semantics or authorial voice. If you're comfortable allowing the system to refine or rephrase the precise meanings you originally intended — or if it begins incorporating vocabulary that doesn't align with your typical linguistic patterns — then you've likely crossed a meaningful threshold where the output no longer fully represents your authentic intent.

Something to consider is that you can analyze your own stylometric patterns over a large collection of your writing, and distill that into a system of rules and patterns to follow which AI can readily handle. It is technically possible, albeit tedious, to clone your style such that it's indistinguishable from your actual human writing, and can even icnlude spelling mistakes you've made before at a rate matching your actual writing.

AI editing is weird, though. Not seeing a need, unless English isn't your native language.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dang on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:03PM (#47342761)
You're touching on an important point. More here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47342616.

All this stuff is in flux. I thought a lot about whether to add the "edited" bit - but it may change. What I deliberately left out was anything about the articles and projects that get submitted here. There's a lot of turbulence in that area too, but we don't yet have clarity, or even an inkling, of how to settle that one.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dataflow on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @08:04PM (#47344367)
Do the guidelines also disallow comments along the lines of "according to <AI>, <blah>"? (I ask this given that "according to a Google search, <blah>" is allowed, AFAIK.)
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by BeetleB on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @08:42PM (#47344725)
I would lean towards disallowing those. With "According to a Google search ...", someone can ask for specific links (and indeed, people often say to link to those sources to begin with instead of invoking Google). With "According to AI ... " - why would most readers care what the AI thinks? It's not a reliable source! You might as well say "According to a stranger I just met and don't know ..."

If you're going to say that the AI said X, Y, Z, provide a rationale on why it is relevant. If you merely found X, Y and Z compelling, feel free to talk about it without mentioning AI.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dataflow on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @10:55PM (#47345819)
For reference, the point here isn't to say "what AI thinks", but what you found with the help of AI. The majority of the cases where I would say "according to AI, <blah>" are where <blah> actually does cite sources that I feel appear plausible. Sometimes they're links, sometimes they would be other publications not necessarily a click away. Sometimes I could independently verify them by spending half an hour researching (which is), sometimes I can't. Sometimes I could spend half an hour verifying them independently, sometimes I can't do that but they still seem worthwhile.

> If you merely found X, Y and Z compelling, feel free to talk about it without mentioning AI.

I think you're seeing this as too black-and-white, and missing the heart of the issue.

The purpose of mentioning AI is to convey the level of (un)certainty as accurately as possible. The most accurate way to do that would often be to mention any use of AI, rather than hiding it.

If AI tells me that it believes X is true because of links A and B that it cites, and I find those links compelling, then I absolutely want to mention that AI gave me those links because I have no clue whether the model had any reason to bias itself toward those sources, or whether alternate links may have existed that stated otherwise.

Whereas if a normal web search just gives links that mention terms from my query, then I get a chance to see the other links too, and I end up being the one who actually compare the contents of the different pages and figure out which one is most convincing.

Depending on various factors, such as the nature of the question and the level of background knowledge I have on the topic myself, one of these can provide a more useful response than the other -- but only if I convey the uncertainty around it accurately.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by BeetleB on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @11:09PM (#47345929)
> The majority of the cases where I would say "according to AI, <blah>" are where <blah> actually does cite sources that I feel appear plausible. Sometimes they're links, sometimes they would be other publications not necessarily a click away. Sometimes I could independently verify them by spending half an hour researching (which is), sometimes I can't.

In my experience, LLMs hallucinate citations like crazy. Over 50% of the times I've checked, the citation either didn't exist, or it did but didn't support the LLM's assertions.

This is true not just from the chat, but for Google AI summaries.

When the references are more often wrong than not, you can understand why many will simply downvote you for bringing LLM citations into the conversation. Why quote a habitual liar?

(If you look at my other comments, I'm actually in favor of using LLMs in some capacity for HN comments. Just not in this case.)

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dataflow on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @11:19PM (#47346024)
>> actually does cite sources that I feel appear plausible.

> In my experience, LLMs hallucinate citations like crazy. Over 50% of the times I've checked, the citation either didn't exist, or it did but didn't support the LLM's assertions.

Note that those are specifically not the cases where the AI is citing "sources that I feel appear plausible."

(I also don't find over 50% hallucination to be accurate for Google AI summaries in my experience, but that depends on your queries, and in any case, I digress...)

> When the references are more often wrong than not, you can understand why many will simply downvote you for bringing LLM citations into the conversation. Why quote a habitual liar?

To be clear, I do understand both sides of the argument, and I don't think either side is unreasonable. I've also had the experience of being on both sides of this myself, and I don't think there's a clear-cut answer. I'm just hoping to get clarity on what the new policy is as far as this goes. I'm sure it'll be reevaluated either way as time goes on.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by BeetleB on Thursday March 12, 2026 @10:56AM (#47351525)
> (I also don't find over 50% hallucination to be accurate for Google AI summaries in my experience, but that depends on your queries, and in any case, I digress...)

I should point out that I'm not saying 50% of the AI summaries have an error. Merely that the references it provides me don't state what the summary is claiming. The summary may still be accurate, while the references incorrect.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by yellowapple on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @08:46PM (#47344765)
I think those should be allowed iff the nature of being AI-generated is relevant to the topic of discussion — e.g. if we're talking about whether some model or other can accurately respond to some prompt and people feel inclined to try it themselves.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by lossyalgo on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @08:59PM (#47344864)
I constantly read those comments and I personally have conflicting opinion with them. On one hand, it's interesting to compare what is coming out of models, but on the other hand, LLMs are all non-deterministic, so results will be fairly random. On top of that, everybody has a different "skill" level when prompting. In addition, models are constantly changing, therefore "I asked chatGPT and it said..." means nothing when there is a new version every few months, not to mention you can often pick one of 10+ flavors from every provider, and even those are not guaranteed to not be changed under the hood to some degree over time.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by snowwrestler on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @09:05PM (#47344928)
Citations can be helpful. But AI summaries and Google searches are poor citations because they are not primary sources.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by crossroadsguy on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @09:41PM (#47345196)
I'd rather ask AI to provide a source and then cite the source. But if the source itself is AI backed, then it's a bit different :)
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dataflow on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @11:07PM (#47345911)
I explained this in a bit more depth in an adjacent reply (feel free to take a look) but obtaining the source from AI doesn't achieve the same thing. For example, there might be other links that contradict that source, which the AI wouldn't cite. Knowing that AI picked the "best" one vs. a human is incredibly relevant when assigning and weighing credibility.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by MetaWhirledPeas on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @09:55PM (#47345327)
I don't have a problem with that. First off it's not very common. Second off it can add to a conversation, just as it can with in-person discussions. If you feel like it doesn't, don't upvote and don't reply. There's no value in pretending we're Woodward and Bernstein every time we leave a comment.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dfxm12 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @09:57PM (#47345346)
AI is not a source. A Google search result page is not a source. Hopefully, these things help you find a source. If you're posting something you feel the need to source, post the source along with your comment! For example, don't say "according to a Google search, x"... say something like "according to Microsoft's documentation, x" and provide a link to Microsoft Learn page...
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dang on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:14AM (#47346767)
We don't want people copy-pasting in comments generally. Summary comments, onlyquote comments (i.e. consisting of a quote and nothing else), duplicate comments are other examples of this. It's not specific to LLMs.

However, that's probably not critical enough to formally add to the explicit guidelines, so it's probably fine to leave it in the "case law" realm—especially because downvoters tend to go after such comments.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dataflow on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:45AM (#47346958)
Great, thanks for clarifying.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by schappim on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:36PM (#47343264)
Please rethink the “edited” bit on accessibility grounds.

I have a kid with severe written language issues, and the utilisation of speech to text with a LLM-powered edit has unlocked a whole world that was previously inaccessible.

I would hate to see a culture that discourages AI assistance.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by davorak on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @07:41PM (#47344125)
Are you up for sharing details?

> I would hate to see a culture that discourages AI assistance.

Mostly I think the push back is about ai assistance in its current form. It can get in the way of communicating rather than assisting. The cost though is mostly borne by the readers and those not using the AI for assistance. I have seen this happen when the ai adds info and thoughts that were tangental to the original author and I think, but I can not verify times where an author seems to try to dig down on the details but seemingly can not.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by happytoexplain on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @08:01PM (#47344343)
Since it's mostly a good-faith rule to begin with, it seems easy to add something like, "unless you are using it as an assistive technology for accessibility reasons".
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dang on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:20AM (#47346809)
Yes, and that's the case with all the rules. I don't want to say "you should break them when it makes sense" because if I do, someone will post "Tell HN: dang says break the rules". But the rules are there to serve the intended spirit of the site—not the other way around. If you're posting in that spirit, I would hope we would recognize and and welcome that, not tut-tut it with rules.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by BeetleB on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:43PM (#47343360)
Oh wow. I did not anticipate that, which is embarrassing given that I wrote this just recently:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47326351

Yes, please at least have a carveout for accessibility. I definitely have dictated HN comments in the past, and my flow uses LLMs to clean it up. It works, and is awesome when you're in pain.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by pesfandiar on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @06:51PM (#47343464)
Hear hear. And like many other aspects of accessibility, it will help a huge number of people who may not have any severe issues. e.g. non-native English speakers using LLM-powered edits.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dang on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:18AM (#47346798)
That's totally legit and your kid, should they ever take an interest in Hacker News, is welcome here.

These rules are always fuzzy and there's always a long tail of exceptions. All the more so under turbulent conditions like right now. I wrote more about this elsewhere in the thread, in case it's useful: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47342616.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by crossroadsguy on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @09:40PM (#47345180)
I wasn't sure whether it was an omission or an unintended gap, as the guideline specifically points to "comments". So it seems AI generated/edited posts are fine. Strange, because both can be flagged/downvoted if it was to be left with that.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by dang on Thursday March 12, 2026 @01:11AM (#47346750)
I'm not saying they're all fine, I'm saying we don't yet have any idea of where to make a cut.

The comments thing is a lot more intimate in the sense that anyone posting comments is inside the house.

Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by asadotzler on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @10:01PM (#47345380)
ML based word or phrase editing is hardly a problem any more than pre-AI spellcheckers were. AI sentence and paragraph manufacturing is a problem and everyone knows the difference between that slop and a spellchecker. No one cares if your editor does inline spellchecking or even word autocomplete. What they care about is slop and word at a time spelling or phrase grammar checking are harmless.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by ern on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @10:09PM (#47345450)
I caught myself structuring a comment like an LLM on another site. It's expected that people who chat heavily to LLMs will start to mirror their styles.
Re:Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conver... by RevEng on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @11:15PM (#47345978)
I agree on the editing. We use these things all the time - chances are many of you are using it right now as you type on your phone and it checks your spelling for you.

By the same token, what if I have a human editor help me out? What if we go back and forth on how to write something, including spelling, grammar, tone, etc. For example, my wife occasionally asks me to review her messages before sending them because she thinks I speak well and wants to be understood correctly.

The problem is that we are punishing the technology, not the result. Whether it's a human or an LLM that acts as your editor should be irrelevant; what matters is that you are posting your own work and not someone else's. My wife having me write all of her messages for her would be just as dishonest as her having an LLM write all of her messages for her if she always presented them as her own writing. But if she writes the copy and I provide suggests for changes, what's the harm in that? And why should it matter if it's a human or an LLM that provides that assistance?