News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by legitster on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @01:10PM (#47155289)
> I am reminded by the perhaps revisionist history but still applicable belief that slavery was really ended by industrialization making abolition economically advantageous and not actually a socially driven movement. (In reality it was certainly a convoluted mixture of the two I'm sure.)

More or less.

Adam Smith famously wrote that slavery was economically detrimental way back in 1776. It still took nearly 100 years to abolish slavery, and even to this day, people still equate slavery with prosperity (as implied by that controversial 1612 Project article, for example).

Another way to think about it, the South did not embrace slavery because it made them richer; the South embraced slavery because they opposed industrialization. Southerners would regularly complain about the hustle and bustle of the North, the size of the cities, and how hard regular (white) people had to work. The "Southern way of life" was a thing - a leisurely, agrarian society based on forced labor and land instead of capital.

In this regard it's a doubly fitting metaphor because much of the opposition to abolishing slavery was cultural and not economic.

[dead]
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by legitster on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @01:40PM (#47155802)
- The difference between Ben Franklin writing about farming in the 1770s and the civil war was that industrialization didn't hit the US until the 1810s/1820s when the first steel mills and steam engines were set up.

- "These people categorically did not want to start a farm; otherwise they would not have been facing famine." The vast majority of immigrants to the US at this time WERE farmers who were not allowed to own land in Europe. The reason they came to the North instead of the South is because they were largely not allowed to settle anywhere East of the Appalachians in the South. The South was staunchly anti-immigrant and barely had any cities at the time.

- At the outbreak of war, the Union army was almost entirely made up of American born volunteers. Later, immigrant brigades were enlisted, but most were highly regarded and commended and still made up less than half of the army.

- Your explanation cutely ignores the fact that Southern troops fired first in the Civil War

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by selimthegrim on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:59PM (#47158571)
- The South was staunchly anti-immigrant and barely had any cities at the time.

New Orleans has entered the chat.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by tclancy on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @01:40PM (#47155803)
I liked it better when you guys called yourselves "Know Nothings". It made it easier to follow what was going on.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by thinkingtoilet on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @01:33PM (#47155674)
What makes you think the newspapers of the day are all telling the truth? Does the media today tell the truth? Did newspapers disclose when the equivalent of a billionaire bought them out and drastically changed the editorial bias?

I'm not saying we shouldn't read historical documents. I'm saying to not apply the same skepticism you would apply to modern media to old media is a mistake.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by snozolli on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @01:45PM (#47155873)
These people categorically did not want to start a farm; otherwise they would not have been facing famine.

Please tell me more on your theories regarding these immigrants.

The only ones I'm aware of were Irish immigrants. Most of them were urban dwellers, not farmers. The Irish who were farmers were generally working on farms owned by the English.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by octernion on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @01:33PM (#47155668)
ah yes the famine was because the people were lazy and did not want to farm. the history understander has logged on for everyone here!
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by hippo22 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @01:39PM (#47155789)
Everything you’ve described sounds economic, not cultural. Being able to lounge around while others toil for your gain is absolutely economic. And the data shows this: if you exclude the enslaved, the south had a higher GDP per capita than the north.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by legitster on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @01:52PM (#47156001)
Maybe - a lot of the material wealth of the South was having a lot of land divided amongst fewer people. Enjoying more leisure has a nasty habit of not making people richer in the end.

Here's specifically what Adam Smith had to say in the Wealth of Nations:

> But if great improvements are seldom to be expected from great proprietors, they are least of all to be expected when they employ slaves for their workmen. The experience of all ages and nations, I believe, demonstrates that the work done by slaves, though it appears to cost only their maintenance, is in the end the dearest of any. A person who can acquire no property, can have no other interest but to eat as much, and to labour as little as possible. Whatever work he does beyond what is sufficient to purchase his own maintenance can be squeezed out of him by violence only, and not by any interest of his own.

Later, to explain this trap of why people insist on owning slaves even if paying workers would be more productive in the long run:

> "The pride of man makes him love to domineer, and nothing mortifies him so much as to be obliged to condescend to persuade his inferiors. Wherever the law allows it, and the nature of the work can afford it, therefore, he will generally prefer the service of slaves to that of freemen."

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by dyauspitr on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:39PM (#47157526)
> Enjoying more leisure has a nasty habit of not making people richer in the end.

Human slavery might be one of the few exceptions to this. People can reproduce and create more people provided they are given the bare necessities of life. As long as you could keep the enslaved under control, you would have new slaves you could constantly sell and they mostly took care of themselves.

Honestly it sounds like a great life for an unambitious, lazy person. Maybe we’ll all be able to experience something similar when humanoid robots are commonplace in the future. Find an isolated piece of land with a few robots. Make them grow food and commercial crops. Raise some animals. Live a life of relative self sufficiency and leisure.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by lazide on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:02PM (#47157812)
The issue (for the masters, and besides any ethical issues) is being a slave master is a very tenuous position, and prone to revolts.

Too capable (but also valuable!) slaves tend to be self sufficient and strong enough to throw you off.

Too weak (and therefore non-valuable!) slaves tend to be easy to control - but are a huge drain on the system, including ‘master’ management, which is often the most constrained resource anyway in any hierarchical system.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by jacquesm on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:42PM (#47159109)
That's the dream. Except in the minds of those who aim to bring it about you are in some unmarked plot.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by dyauspitr on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:44PM (#47159124)
Yeah roving bands of murdering robots would be a problem in that scenario. We should be able to keep/maintain our current security and rule of law though.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by dosinga on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @02:13PM (#47156311)
> if you exclude the enslaved, the south had a higher GDP per capita than the north.

In other words, if you remove the people that earned the least (close to nothing) the overall income per capita goes up? If you exclude the non nobles I am sure the middle ages had a very high GDP too

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @01:49PM (#47155962)
> Being able to lounge around while others toil for your gain is absolutely economic.

And being comfortable doing it via slave labor is cultural.

> if you exclude the enslaved, the south had a higher GDP per capita

If you exclude the murders, Ted Bundy was a really nice guy.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by inglor_cz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:17PM (#47157236)
Prior to the steam engine, what sources of energy you have?

The wind and the water, both rather limited to specific activities (milling, sailing). And the power of human and animal muscle. Where the animals are stronger, but also much dumber, so most of the actual hard work has to be done by human hands.

Basically all the settled civilizations used some sort of non-free or at best semi-free labour. Villeiny, serfdom, prisoners of war, slavery of all sorts, or having low castes do the worst work.

And given that humans are very good at rationalizing away their conditions, the cultures adapted to being comfortable with it, even considering the societal inequality as something ordained by the gods or karma.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:32PM (#47157432)
> Prior to the steam engine, what sources of energy you have?

Oxen? Paid laborers? It's not like the American South was unique in needing farm workers.

> Basically all the settled civilizations used some sort of non-free or at best semi-free labour.

The South was notable in clinging to slavery long after it had been abolished elsewhere.

> And given that humans are very good at rationalizing away their conditions, the cultures adapted to being comfortable with it, even considering the societal inequality as something ordained by the gods or karma.

Good, then we agree; it was at least in part cultural.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by inglor_cz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:41PM (#47157545)
"Oxen? Paid laborers? "

In other words, animal and human muscle, we agree on that.

I didn't claim that all human labour was non-free, far from that. Every classical civilization had paid artisans and employees as well.

But the paid professions tended to be the skilled ones, and the non-free ones tended to be the arduous, backbreaking ones.

"The South was notable in clinging to slavery long after it had been abolished elsewhere."

Elsewhere where? If I look at the timeline of slavery abolition on Wikipedia, it seems that the South was not even the last holdout in the Americas, much less worldwide.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_abolition_of_slave...

They were about as delayed as Russia. (Serfdom in Russia was not quite slavery, but brutal and backward nonetheless.)

And the timeline of slavery abolition seems to dovetail with the expansion of the Industrial Revolution across the globe quite tightly, or not?

"it was at least in part cultural."

Chicken, egg. This is a system stretching over millennia with endless feedback loops. Runaway slaves may become the masters (such as the Aztecs) and vice versa, developing their own justifications why it happened.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:51PM (#47157683)
> In other words, animal and human muscle, we agree on that.

Sure. My objection is to the slavery bit, not the "humans doing work" bit.

> But the paid professions tended to be the skilled ones, and the non-free ones tended to be the arduous, backbreaking ones.

There were plenty of non-slave manual laborers throughout history. Doubly so for chattel slavery of the sort practiced in the South.

> Elsewhere where? If I look at the timeline of slavery abolition on Wikipedia, it seems that the South was not even the last holdout in the Americas, much less worldwide.

What we'd now call the developed world.

That article lists many restrictions and abolitions of the practices hundreds of years prior to the 1860s. The Russians you mention managed it in 1723; Massachusets deems it unconstitional in 1783. By the 1860s still having it as a properous nation was pretty weird.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by inglor_cz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:02PM (#47157811)
"What we'd now call the developed world."

The developed world of now is much more extensive than the developed world of the 1860s, and the South was very backward until the 1950s or so. In the 1850s, it was seriously lagging behind the North in industrial power, which is one of the reasons why they lost the war. This would point to a yet another chicken-and-egg problem. Nonfree labour tends to cement premodern societal and economic structures, which perpetuate existence of non-free labour, unless disrupted from the outside. The Islamic world didn't give up slavery voluntarily either.

I am not sure if we can call the South of the 1860s "developed", even relatively to the rest of the Western civ. By what criteria?

"The Russians you mention managed it in 1723"

Serfdom in Russia was abolished after the Crimean War, and the Tsar used the money gained by the Alaska Purchase to pay off part of the due compensations to the nobles.

Yes, these institutions were not equal. Different cultural and historical development. Still, a Russian serf of the 1850s was a very non-free person, tied to the land and dependent on whims of his lord or lady. Few would care if a drunk noble whipped him to death, even though theoretically he should not be doing that. A rough equivalent in category.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by cyberax on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:29PM (#47158142)
> The Russians you mention managed it in 1723

In 1861.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:30PM (#47158160)
The link lists this in 1723:

> Peter the Great converts all house slaves into house serfs, effectively making slavery illegal in Russia.

1861 ditches serfdom, too.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by cyberax on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:24PM (#47159508)
Yep. The power of rebranding.

Serfs were essentially slaves. They could be traded without any real limits and could be punished at will. The families could be split, and serfs were officially prohibited from making lawsuits against their owners.

And it was one of the reasons for Russia's "misadventures" during the 20-th century. The serfdom abolishment came when other countries were already in the midst of the industrial revolution.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by pksebben on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:25PM (#47159518)
> This is a system stretching over millennia

not quite. 'Slavery' has been around that long. 'Chattel Slavery' started in the 1600s and peaked in the 1800s. So like, half a millenia.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by inglor_cz on Thursday February 26, 2026 @03:24AM (#47163402)
Chattel slavery in the Islamic world definitely predates the 1600s. By a thousand years or so.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by Forgeties79 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @02:03PM (#47156170)
Like trying to assess the economy of the Third Reich while omitting that whole pesky war thing
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by QuercusMax on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @02:57PM (#47156985)
They used slave labor too, don't forget!
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by inglor_cz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:12PM (#47157174)
Slave labor is most efficient when it comes to non-skilled, hard work. Mining, agriculture, sex (where it still survives even in the Western world), where the output is easily checked and counted.

When it comes to anything sophisticated done by qualified people, like "making advanced tools for the Führer", the options for subtle sabotage are there and pissed-off people will use them.

In general, German occupation authorities had better results when they actually paid the workers and gave them vacation vouchers. But of course the racial theories got in the way, as it was unthinkable to treat, say, Jews as normal employees.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by 05 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:32PM (#47157431)
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by inglor_cz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:45PM (#47157601)
Sure you can stuff smart people into penal colonies, but what is their productivity?

I am not aware of anyone like Kapica or Kolmogorov producing their best results in a penal camp.

OTOH we have a notorious railway tunnel in Prague from the 1950s, designed by imprisoned engineers. Guess what, it is half a foot too narrow to put two tracks into. Someone got the last laugh.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by embedding-shape on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:03PM (#47158645)
Does it matter what their productivity is as long as it's above 0 of whatever? Leon Theremin invented the "Buran eavesdropping system" while "working" at the sharashka, used to spy on embassies in Moscow via their windows.

Another fun anecdote related to Theremin:

> Theremin invented another listening device called The Thing, hidden in a replica of the Great Seal of the United States carved in wood. In 1945, Soviet school children presented the concealed bug to the U.S. Ambassador as a "gesture of friendship" to the USSR's World War II ally. It hung in the ambassador’s residential office in Moscow and intercepted confidential conversations there during the first seven years of the Cold War, until it was accidentally discovered in 1952.

Interesting life in general: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leon_Theremin

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by parineum on Thursday February 26, 2026 @12:02AM (#47162082)
> Does it matter what their productivity is as long as it's above 0

Slaves cost money. You have to feed and house them. Plus, they require security to keep them inline.

They have to be more productive per dollar than a free individual.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:34PM (#47157460)
> Slave labor is most efficient when it comes to non-skilled, hard work.

And yet, we invent things like the cotton gin, "enabling much greater productivity than manual cotton separation", patented in 1794.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:38PM (#47158281)
I’m not entirely sure what point you’re trying to make. The invention of the cotton gin increased the use of slaves; it didn’t decrease it.

https://freedomcenter.org/voice/eli-whitney-cotton-gin/

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:47PM (#47158406)
> The invention of the cotton gin increased the use of slaves; it didn’t decrease it.

Because the efficiency increase in that part of the process meant we could grow so much more cotton to be processed. It wasn't very profitable before that, because slave labor wasn't very efficient at the process.

(This led, eventually, to more automation of the planting/harvesting process.)

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by aaronbrethorst on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:09PM (#47158732)
Clearly, you are much more clever than I am because I still have no idea what your thesis is supposed to be.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:19PM (#47158867)
Thesis: Slavery is a morally unacceptable crutch that leads to stagnation over innovation in the long run.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by margalabargala on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @01:53PM (#47156018)
> if you exclude the enslaved, the south had a higher GDP per capita than the north.

That doesn't tell the whole story though. If you own 100 slaves, you need to spend nonzero resources maintaining them, or else they will starve and then you have zero slaves. So the owner has less wealth than the equivalent person in the North that has the same income but zero slaves. You can't directly compare GDP per capita excluding enslaved people.

I do agree with your broader point about usage of labor and how being able to have leisure via slavery is economic.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by jmyeet on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @02:05PM (#47156199)
Except that slaves also make new slaves that can be sold.

I really dislike this idea that slavery was just a cultural aberration and not economic. For one thing, that lightens the moral stain of slavery adjacent activity, most notably colonialism and the exploitation of the colonies. This never went away. Economic colonialism exists to this day. We just call it “outsourcing”, “offshoring” and “subcontracting”.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by daymanstep on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:09PM (#47157893)
Offshoring generally improves the lives of the people who get the offshored jobs. Usually foreign companies pay more and have better working conditions than the local companies.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by jmyeet on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:46PM (#47159144)
Yeah, that's a lie. It's propaganda.

Consider as just one example the lawsuit over child slavery against Nestle, etc [1]. The Supreme Court ultimately ruled that Nestle can't be held responsible for the child slavery even though they have full knowledge of it happening. Go figure. In fact, that's what they pay for.

The whole shipbreaking industry in Bangladesh is incredibly dangerous for those involved and couldn't possibly be done in any developed nation.

[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2021/feb/12/m...

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by cucumber3732842 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:41PM (#47157548)
It's worse than that because it takes something that should beg the question what modern things we peddle today because they make $$ are in fact morally wrong into a trite "hurr durr past people bad we smart now" that nobody learns anything from.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by cobbzilla on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @03:35PM (#47157480)
There is certainly a cultural component. A very good book named Albion’s Seed traces the waves of early American immigration. The North was mostly settled by dissidents pre-ECW. The South was mostly divided up into estates and settled by post-ECW lords that mirrored the social structure and power dynamics they liked.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by watwut on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @02:34PM (#47156633)
> if you exclude the enslaved, the south had a higher GDP per capita

Yeah because your "capita" is severely undercounted.

If I exclude every who dont live in New York, USA has astonishing GDP per capita ... because I am assigning each person production of many. Same thing.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by bluGill on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @02:53PM (#47156916)
If you own a lot of slaves your life is better than the freemen who own less/none, much less slaves. However society overall could be muca better even if for you personally it is worse
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by lovich on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:44PM (#47159123)
> …if you exclude the enslaved…

If you ignore the part that makes you wrong, then you are right.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by helterskelter on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:24PM (#47158090)
The south wasn't really situated for industrialization at the time. They didn't have enough rivers that could turn a water wheel effectively. (That's what I've heard anyway)
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by legitster on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:15PM (#47159426)
It's true the first mills were in the north because they had some good sites, but there are good mill sites throughout the South as well. More tellingly, when the first steam engines in the US were imported from Europe - they could have been just as easily installed in the South.

I think more importantly, steam mills solved for a problem the south did not have. If one was to tell a southerner, I have a technology that will save on labor costs, the southerner's response would have been "what are labor costs?"

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by helterskelter on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:57PM (#47159848)
You still have to wonder why the south never built factories to compete with the north. They exported most of their cotton to the north just to buy it back again the the form of textiles, so slavery working by hand wasn't able to compete with factories on that level.

I'd venture that the north's earlier industrialization built up experience and supporting infrastructure which made it a dubious business prospect for any southerner that might have considered building a factory, along with the fact that making textiles by manpower alone made less money than picking cotton and exporting it.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by mr_toad on Thursday February 26, 2026 @03:48AM (#47163573)
> They exported most of their cotton to the north just to buy it back again the the form of textiles, so slavery working by hand wasn't able to compete with factories on that level.

It seems to fit the pattern of a resource curse.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by pm90 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:02PM (#47158623)
Hmm, this doesn’t seem to be accurate. The missouri/mississipi rivers come to mind, as do many other river systems.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by helterskelter on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:45PM (#47159715)
My impression was that there was a lack of fast moving rivers which were suitable for water wheels. You could make some elevation, or build a larger wheel, but that can become prohibitive for the volume needed for a real factory.

It looks like the south does have some suitable rivers, but you wonder why they exported their crops to the north just to buy them back again in their more processed form...that just doesn't make much sense from an economic standpoint. Clearly slavery wasn't a suitable replacement for the type of production work done in the north. It must have been a mix of social factors, combined with the fact that the north specialized in industry early on and you couldn't compete very well with the lack of expertise and lack of industry which supported the local industry in the south.

Anyway this is all just wild speculation. Take it for what you will.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by roenxi on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:38PM (#47158270)
> Adam Smith famously wrote that slavery was economically detrimental way back in 1776. It still took nearly 100 years to abolish slavery...

Slavery had basically been a thing for all of human history up to that point, and based on my discussions on HN many smart people don't believe a lot of what Adam Smith said. There are still a lot of basic economic ideas that would make people much wealthier that struggle to get out into the wild. With that perspective the near-total abolition of slavery in a century seems pretty quick. And it can't really be a social thing because it is clear from history that societies tolerate slavery if it makes sense.

And we see what happened to the people who tried to maintain slavery over that century - they ended up poor then economically, socially and historically humiliated.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:04PM (#47160431)
> Slavery had basically been a thing for all of human history up to that point

Would note that New World-style chattel slavery doesn't seem to have broadly historically precedented.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by eucyclos on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @10:11PM (#47161336)
True, but if your point is that most slavery regimes throughout history were less awful for the slaves, it's also worth remembering that most accounts of those regimes weren't written by the victors of a war that saw the other sides slavery practices as justification for said war.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by JumpCrisscross on Thursday February 26, 2026 @04:14AM (#47163748)
> if your point is that most slavery regimes throughout history were less awful for the slaves

Not at all. The fact that we have practically zero first-hand accounts from the slaves of antiquity speaks volumes to their treatment. My point is on scale (and with that, the institution's effect on the societies that hosted it).

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by legitster on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:32PM (#47159009)
Slavery was already being abolished in the West when Adam Smith wrote the Wealth of Nations. But what was notable was that Adam Smith was really the first to make a strong case and prediction that it was not just the moral thing to do, but would lead to prosperity.

Adam Smith also differentiated between different levels of slavery - that Roman slavery was different than Serfdom was different from chattel slavery in the US.

It's worth noting that Adam Smith did not think total abolition was possible. One of his concerns about free markets was that people deeply desired control of other people, and slavery would increase as a byproduct of wealth.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by jacquesm on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:37PM (#47159057)
And effectively it did: many people are kept in their place by the combined pressure points of debt and employment to stay (barely) afloat.

This is of course nothing compared to the cruelty of real slavery but the effect is much the same, a lot of people are working their asses of for an upper class that can ruin their lives at the drop of a hat. That there are no whips involved is nice but it also clearly delineated who was the exploiter and who were the exploited. That's a bit harder to see today.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by eucyclos on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @10:05PM (#47161298)
Rental versus outright purchase is a weird transition. I have this idea for a faction in a post apocalyptic setting that started out as a libertarian community that idealized a society with zero slavery but found it constantly hiding in arrangements like the one you describe, so they made it very explicit and transactional instead: every member of the community is a central bank, and the currency takes the form of small clay discs with a number and a thumbprint. Anyone can mint their own money, but anyone can redeem money for hours of slave labor with the issuing party. And of course there are rules limiting what slaves can be compelled to do, like no minting more hours and no demanding a specific slave.

For some reason this concept is very sticky to me. I actually think it could work as a low tech monetary regime in a grid down scenario.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by Retric on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:17PM (#47159441)
Slavery in Europe was replaced with a more efficient system in the Middle Ages.

So calling it a constant throughout history is only true in the way that slavery still exists today, in that you could find it somewhere on the globe.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by mr_toad on Thursday February 26, 2026 @03:41AM (#47163517)
That’s partly true, but it’s also the case that medieval Europe didn’t have any convenient sources of slaves. Conquests had dried up, Europe was effectively surrounded by stronger neighbors, and instead of being able to take their neighbors as slaves many of their neighbors were taking Europeans as slaves.

That didn’t change until the Age of Sail opened up new frontiers and the wheel turned again.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by jacquesm on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:33PM (#47159016)
Ah, the master of bad takes is at it again.

> Slavery had basically been a thing for all of human history up to that point,

Except that of course it wasn't.

> and based on my discussions on HN many smart people don't believe a lot of what Adam Smith said.

And many smart people do.

> There are still a lot of basic economic ideas that would make people much wealthier that struggle to get out into the wild.

Yes, such as the one that wealth is not very good as a context free metric for societal success.

> With that perspective the near-total abolition of slavery in a century seems pretty quick.

You missed that bit about the war. If not for that who knows where we'd be today.

> And we see what happened to the people who tried to maintain slavery over that century - they ended up poor then economically, socially and historically humiliated.

Yes, they relied on the misery of others to drive their former wealth, but they are not the important people in that story. The important people are the ones that were no longer slaves.

And never mind that many of those former slave owners did just fine economically afterwards, after all, they already were fantastically wealthy so they just switched 'business models' and still made money hand over fist.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by pksebben on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:16PM (#47159429)
It really comes down to granularity at the end, and whether you attempt to look as closely as possible or you accept a certain lack of fidelity because it makes the abstraction work for you.

In this case, I frequently hear people talk about how "the greeks and romans had slaves! and they were white! See, it's fine!" but that fails to take into account that there's a gigantic difference between slavery-as-a-legal-status like they had (entered into by contract or as legal punishment, exit conditions, no real social meaning), and chattel slavery based on race (the 'fuck you got mine' of ethos). I think the idea is that if you squint real, real hard; you can make it look like "not being racist" and "human rights" are somehow newfangled, 'woke' ideals, which is the kind of hilariously wrong misunderstanding we once saw embodied by cletus the slackjawed yokel.

I can call my ma from up here. Hey, ma! Get off the dang roof!

Slavery as we talk about it has been around since roughly the 1600s, and even then didn't peak until the 1800s. Everything prior to that was a totally different beast. and a quick sidebar - wth is supposed to be wrong with being alert to your surroundings? Do we really value being asleep that much?

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by FarmerPotato on Thursday February 26, 2026 @02:01AM (#47162815)
I don't see much difference when you consider the condition of farming and mining slaves in Roman society.

Slaves were spoils of war since before the Republic.

Even if a slave had valuable skills, and were treated better, they had no legal recourse against a Roman citizen. Their owner could sell them like chattel, break up families (slave marriage had no legal basis) and kill them outright.

The highly skilled could enter into a kind of indentured servitude. That's a separate category.

You hear romantic stories about household servants gaining high esteem and a few being granted or buying their freedom. These were the exception, against the backdrop of menial labor.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by philipallstar on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:46PM (#47159734)
> You missed that bit about the war. If not for that who knows where we'd be today.

It's not just a war. The British Empire declared for moral reasons slavery illegal, and slavers could be hunted for bounty like pirates. The only place that remained in the Empire with slavery was India, because the British felt that the Indian culture could not be disentangled from slavery.

Because slavery was everywhere.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by joe_mamba on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:05PM (#47159330)
>Except that of course it wasn't.

Except that it definitely was.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by pksebben on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:19PM (#47159461)
no.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by roenxi on Thursday February 26, 2026 @01:41AM (#47162691)
> Ah, the master of bad takes is at it again.

Peace and love to you too, brother.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by MengerSponge on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @04:42PM (#47158339)
Technology developed after Smith's writing changed the calculus. The cotton gin made wide-scale cotton cultivation far more lucrative, and drove American slavery: https://historyincharts.com/the-impact-of-the-cotton-gin-on-...

Without the cotton gin, chattel slavery would have probably ended at least one generation earlier in the US

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by Braxton1980 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:04PM (#47158658)
Mississippi declaration of secession.

"“Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery — the greatest material interest of the world....Its labor supplies the product which constitutes by far the largest and most important portions of commerce of the earth.”

Georgia

"“The prohibition of slavery in the Territories… is destructive of our rights and interests.”

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by legitster on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @05:48PM (#47159162)
The full preamble of the Mississippi declaration is fascinating, and further shuts down doubters that the civil war wasn't about slavery and racism:

> Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery-- the greatest material interest of the world. Its labor supplies the product which constitutes by far the largest and most important portions of commerce of the earth. These products are peculiar to the climate verging on the tropical regions, and by an imperious law of nature, none but the black race can bear exposure to the tropical sun. These products have become necessities of the world, and a blow at slavery is a blow at commerce and civilization. That blow has been long aimed at the institution, and was at the point of reaching its consummation. There was no choice left us but submission to the mandates of abolition, or a dissolution of the Union, whose principles had been subverted to work out our ruin

Also, they clearly make the case that cotton was the most important good in the world, perhaps imploring the intercession of foreign powers.

I think it's worth pointing out though that these people were not being honest with themselves - nothing in their argument about the importance of cotton suggests it couldn't have been done with wage labor. They are dancing around the fact that only a very few benefit from slavery.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by munificent on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:19PM (#47160075)
> It still took nearly 100 years to abolish slavery, and even to this day, people still equate slavery with prosperity (as implied by that controversial 1612 Project article, for example).

The enslaved people sure as fuck aren't prospering in that situation, so the only way one could possibly equate slavery with economic prosperity is by simply not counting them as people at all.

> Another way to think about it, the South did not embrace slavery because it made them richer; the South embraced slavery because they opposed industrialization... and how hard regular (white) people had to work.

One way to think of slavery is that it's a far point on the continuum between equality and inequality. What they really hated was equality because that necessarily involves taking something away from them, the people who have the most.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by xhkkffbf on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:25PM (#47160135)
Capital was actually a big part of it. The plantation owner didn't just need to capitalize the cost of the land, but the labor as well. When someone purchased a slave, they were paying up front for the remaining labor that could come from that body. This was often pretty expensive when the body was young. Before the Civil War, New Orleans was one of the biggest banking centers of the US because of all of the borrowing.

People often make the mistake that the labor was "free". It wasn't to the people who bought slaves. It wasn't even really free to the slave traders because of the cost of transport.

It was a horrible system in many ways, but it was also a outrageously expensive because of all of the banking and loans involved.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by parineum on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @11:55PM (#47162045)
Reading this post made me wonder if there were "temp agency" type businesses for slaves. Having to own the labor would make your it very difficult to expand and contract your workforce.

Morality aside, it really doesn't seem like a great system.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by xhkkffbf on Thursday February 26, 2026 @11:09AM (#47167972)
Yup. This is why it failed.

I think it was fairly common for plantations to loan, rent, or trade slaves just as they treated any other asset.

Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by Breza on Friday March 06, 2026 @12:14PM (#47277934)
This was incredibly common here in Washington DC. Think about construction. Building the Capitol required a ton of temporary labor, for example, so Congress contracted for both free and enslaved labor for its construction.
Re:Following 35% growth, solar has passed hydro on US grid by Breza on Friday March 06, 2026 @12:19PM (#47278007)
I highly recommend the book Accounting For Slavery to anyone even remotely interested in this topic.

You talked about the costs of buying a human being, which is already horrible. But once an enslaved person was owned outright, they were used as collateral in loans to expand operations.