News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by whizzter on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:12PM (#46074012)
For reference, this city is about as north as Anchorage Alaska and today they got less than 7 hours of sunlight and it'll continue to decrease for the next 3 weeks.

The Nordic countries generally still wants to increase their wind and solar power, but the big issue during winters is when there's cold air high pressure systems we get neither sun nor wind, having an energy storage that can hold up to 5 days worth of energy should help us nudge past them.

Hydro-energy exist (mainly Sweden and Norway, but I think some in Finland as well), but it's fairly built out so stable non-fossil power needs to be nuclear, or wind/sun + storage (that hasn't been good enough so far).

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Reason077 on Thursday November 27, 2025 @07:54PM (#46074570)
> “Hydro-energy exist, but it's fairly built out so stable non-fossil power needs to be nuclear, or wind/sun + storage”

Interconnectors also exist (and more are planned), which means, for example, that Norway can buy wind energy from the UK when it’s cheap and abundant, in preference to using stored energy from their hydro lakes.

That way they effectively get more out of existing hydro lakes, which in Norway is already a very significant storage capacity.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by tordrt on Thursday November 27, 2025 @11:58PM (#46075655)
Theres not going to be built any more interconnectors from Norway anytime soon.

Electricity became a lot more expensive in Norway after building several interconnectors to UK and mainland Europe. Importing high prices from the failed energy politics of UK and Germany which both have among the most expensive electricity in the world.

This has been a huge debate, and the general concensus seems to be that joining ACER and building inrerconnectors to mainland Europe was a big mistake.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by parineum on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:21AM (#46075752)
That seems counterintuitive to me.

Electricity prices don't go up because you have access to expensive power, it goes up because you don't have enough cheap power so you have to buy the expensive power.

It seems like Norway just wouldn't have power if they weren't connected to other sources, not that they'd have more cheap power.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by jltsiren on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:48AM (#46075866)
Electricity prices go up when you have access to customers who are willing to pay more. If grid connections to other regions are limited, people in regions with a lot of cheap generation (such as Norway) pay low prices. But if you add grid connections without increasing generation capacity, prices start equalizing between regions, as every power company tries to sell to the highest bidder.

Norway could power itself fully with domestic hydro. But it chose not to, as the power companies make more money by importing foreign power when it's cheap and exporting hydro when it's not.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by seanmcdirmid on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:12AM (#46075992)
Washington state has the same problem to a lesser degree. California pays more for cheap Washington hydro, which causes the costs to go up for us, although I guess not as drastic as Norway since our electricity is still considered cheap.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by yxhuvud on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:29AM (#46076082)
Norway still have cheap electricity in the grand scheme. It is just more expensive than it used to be.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by DownGoat on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:43AM (#46077429)
> "Norway could power itself fully with domestic hydro." We have events where the we cannot get enough load from domestic production. Typically in winter when water freezes.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by fulafel on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:23AM (#46076054)
> It seems like Norway just wouldn't have power if they weren't connected to other sources, not that they'd have more cheap power.

This is not the case as Norway and neighbouring Sweden have plentiful hydro. It's especially valuable as it can be regulated to complement wind/solar fluctuations, essentially replacing storage.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Hamuko on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:08AM (#46076956)
It’s basic supply and demand. And by linking to other grids, you increase demand since there’s now more customers for your supply. What they have (comparatively) less is supply since the supply in those markets is shite in comparison to what Sweden and Norway have for their local demand.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by sgc on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:39AM (#46075826)
Obviously the presumably large amount of money spent to interconnect could have been spent adding local production and storage. It would be a waste of money if there was a reasonable path to local energy independence that was neglected.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by vidarh on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:05AM (#46077272)
A significant proportion of Norway's domestic energy production is hydro, which comes with it's own "built in" storage up to the capacity of the dams, so Norway already has a very significant storage capacity.

Estimates suggests a storage capacity of 87TWh of storage in hydro reservoirs, compared to production capacity in recent years between 146 and 157 TWh, and a theoretical production capacity of ~309TWh (I don't know the basis for that - I'd imagine peak production at all the plants, but I doubt that could ever happen in reality, so the 146-157TWh based on real production are better...)

Compare that to Norwegian electricity consumption of 124 TWh in 2020.

Of course, since so much of Norways total electricity production is hydro, large storage is necessary, as the hydro supply is highly seasonal, based on e.g. things like the amount of melting snow in the mountains in spring.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by PunchyHamster on Friday November 28, 2025 @08:35AM (#46078489)
but they have enough cheap power

they have too much cheap power, so they decided to sell it. But the fact they have a buyer that buys for more than locals, means they do not longer have to sell to locals at low price.

Tho it being state owned make it weird, you'd think state would keep lower rates for the people

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by skeletal88 on Friday November 28, 2025 @10:44AM (#46079612)
Prices went up in norway because the uk had even higher prices than norway. Having these interconnections is good for producers in norway and consumers in Uk, but very bad for consumers in Norway
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by kragen on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:02AM (#46075929)
Does that mean Norway is making a huge amount of money exporting electricity over those interconnections?
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by yxhuvud on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:27AM (#46076075)
Yes. But that is money the consumers don't see.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by teiferer on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:17AM (#46076315)
About 90% of Norway's 40 GW energy production (mostly hydro) is state owned. By exporting energy and thereby getting other countries to pay, the money literally goes to the norwegian people. Not directly into their bank accounts, but into their govt budgets, which they later pay less in taxes.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by varjag on Friday November 28, 2025 @03:44AM (#46076813)
Norwegian power generation is sized for the domestic market, so tax income from selling excess is marginal at best. The power bills however have indeed crept quite a way up. This was especially noticeable in the first winter of the Russian invasion, when the Nordics had to subsidize the bill that suddenly dropped on short-sighted German energy policy.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by pkfz on Saturday November 29, 2025 @06:15AM (#46086699)
Germany benefits a lot from the open market. If only countries introduced a rule to export only the excess of the energy then Germany would be cooked, because prices would sky rocket for them, not 2x, 3x, but way more. Luckily for them they can make strategical mistakes and go away with it making others to pay for that.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Reason077 on Saturday November 29, 2025 @06:06PM (#46091672)
Of course countries only export "excess energy". No country cuts power to its own citizens and businesses because they'd rather export it.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by teiferer on Sunday November 30, 2025 @02:44AM (#46094678)
"Excess energy" is not a static value. It dynamically depends on price point. Which depends on demand and supply which both depend on price. That dynamic (and circular) interplay is at the core of why economics as a discipline exists in the first place.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bear141 on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:59AM (#46076531)
Do they actually pay less in taxes because of this? I’m not arguing. That is great and I would appreciate if you could provide a source for me to read.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by varjag on Friday November 28, 2025 @03:53AM (#46076867)
We do not but there's a social consensus about the value people get from this taxation level. However the excess power price which is not a domestic supply/demand outcome is a lot harder to sell.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by TeMPOraL on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:59AM (#46076536)
Right, but people tend to be oblivious to anything that's not on their bank accounts.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by stefs on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:16AM (#46077327)
i think that doesn't hold true as much in norway and scandinavia in general.

as varjag said: "there's a social consensus about the value people get from this taxation level"

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Cthulhu_ on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:58AM (#46077516)
Until it's taken away, of course.

Example, the Netherlands had the biggest gas reserve in forever. It's 2/3rds or 3/4ths empty now and extraction has or is stopping due to it causing earthquakes. But the income from exporting the excess gas has been used for socialist policies. Now that that income is gone, and now that expenses for gas have gone way up (also due to reliance on cheap Russian gas), people are feeling it in their bank accounts directly and the socialist policies are being dismantled one by one.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by PunchyHamster on Friday November 28, 2025 @08:33AM (#46078472)
Their tax rate is already pretty high. But yes it effectively sponsors their entire energy infrastructure
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by teiferer on Sunday November 30, 2025 @02:47AM (#46094689)
Only if you compare apples with oranges. Scandinavian taxes are considered high, but they include things like child care, health care, public transportation infrastructure. For people participating in all of those services, the take home pay (as percentage of gross income) ends up not less than in presumably low tax countries.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by eru on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @01:21AM (#46130843)
But incentives to earn more (and thus pay more in taxes!) are still blunted by the high marginal rates.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by theodorton on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:33AM (#46076105)
There are government subsidies for consumers to either have a fixed price or a price cap on electricity in Norway as a political response to the increase. This would be harder to pull off if not most of the profits from export didn’t land in the public sector (either taxes or government owned energy companies).
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by kragen on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:45AM (#46076158)
Norway has experience circumventing the resource curse/Dutch disease with undersea oil. Hopefully they'll manage it this time too.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by KaiserPro on Friday November 28, 2025 @09:44AM (#46079093)
> Importing high prices from the failed energy politics of UK

Remember that its a market, not the consumer price.

The spot price for UK electricity is still quite competitive in the winter, just not reliable.

The other thing to note is that peak in the UK is different to peak further up in longitude, which means that there is benefit to both countries for this.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by eru on Wednesday December 03, 2025 @01:19AM (#46130839)
> Importing high prices from the failed energy politics of UK and Germany which both have among the most expensive electricity in the world.

Look at it the other way: producers of electricity previously could only sell for cheap at home, and now they can export and make more money. That's good!

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by citrin_ru on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:43AM (#46077152)
> Norway can buy wind energy from the UK

Even Southern England cannot get enough wind energy from Scotland to fully utilise wind farms because transmission capacity is insufficient. I would imagine a transmission line to Norway will be even more expensive than to England.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by brohee on Friday November 28, 2025 @06:12AM (#46077592)
Solving the Scotland/England interconnect under-capacity is well underway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_high-voltage_transmiss...
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by ZeroGravitas on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:57AM (#46077237)
But they are building such a link, because it'll make/save more money than it costs.

Imagine how many doom and gloom headlines we'd have avoided if these two massive construction projects could have been sync'd up perfectly or if we had a national press that could do anything other than try to scare people with big numbers.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by arcade79 on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:58AM (#46077240)
The interconnects already exists.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:26PM (#46074093)
Hydro energy generation is fairly built out, but the Nordics have lots of places suitable to build out hydro energy storage. Hydro generation requires a flow to dam, but storage doesn't.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Tuna-Fish on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:44PM (#46074205)
We don't really. Hydro storage requires reservoirs where you can freely adjust the water level. Most of our lakes have shorelines that have been built out, and the property owners get really angry if you suggest frequently adjusting the water level significantly.

The largest planned hydro storage projects are using decommissioned mines, and those are going to run out quickly.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:48PM (#46074236)
You could use the ocean for the bottom level and an artificial reservoir for the top level. You're not going to noticeably affect ocean levels.

Or just use a large lake. You're not going to noticeably affect the water levels of a large lake. You might pump 10 billion litres of water, which is .02% of the volume of Mjøsa.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by vkou on Thursday November 27, 2025 @07:07PM (#46074347)
> You could use the ocean for the bottom level and an artificial reservoir for the top level. You're not going to noticeably affect ocean levels.

Then you have to deal with the problem of sea water corroding everything it touches.

> You might pump 10 billion litres of water, which is .02% of the volume of Mjøsa.

It's not the amount of water that you pump, it's the amount * the elevation delta. Where are you planning on getting the elevation delta from?

Neither of these challenges is technically insurmountable, but this is a field where capex + opex/KWH is everything.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 27, 2025 @07:26PM (#46074443)
> Where are you planning on getting the elevation delta from?

Elevation delta is not hard to find in Norway! A typical pumped storage facility uses 100m of delta; I imagine Norwegian ones would use more.

> but this is a field where capex + opex/KWH is everything.

And pumped storage is significantly cheaper for seasonal storage than any proposed alternatives.

The original post is efficient for heat storage, but converting low grade heat to electricity is not efficient.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by skybrian on Thursday November 27, 2025 @08:38PM (#46074808)
For some applications, you don't actually convert the heat to electricity.

This sounds pretty cheap if it works out:

https://austinvernon.site/blog/standardthermal.html

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by kmacdough on Thursday November 27, 2025 @08:49PM (#46074847)
> A typical pumped storage facility uses 100m of delta

Most projects seek 200-600m. This map doesn't even consider pumped hydro <200m: https://maps.nrel.gov/psh

> And pumped storage is significantly cheaper for seasonal storage than any proposed alternatives.

Based on what? Cost is particularly variable for pumped hydro. It can be one of the cheaper options when stars align. But you need 1) a suitable geography that minimizes the cost of damming or digging a resivoir with sufficient head 2) available for development without too much backlash 3) Near enough grid resources to minimize infrastructure and line losses. I'm surely leaving pieces out.

It can be cheap, but it has far more hoops to jump than alternatives like batteries, hot sand and other "storage-in-a-building" designs which can be built where needed and using fairly standard industrial construction.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by pbmonster on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:45AM (#46077444)
> And pumped storage is significantly cheaper for seasonal storage than any proposed alternatives.

This is incorrect. There is currently not a single pumped hydro station that is suitable for seasonal storage. They're all designed to drain their upper reservoir in 4-16 hours.

It's the only thing that's half economical. Do the math: Even a modest power plant - 1 GW output - that can run for 1000 hours means you need a 1 TWh (even typing it feels ridiculous) storage reservoir. If you only have 100m of head, that's 3 cubic kilometers of water. That would mean building an artificial lake that immediately would be Norway's 6th largest body of fresh water, and draining it completely every winter.

And effectively, you'd have to build it twice - you also need a lower reservoir. Because there's nowhere to get 3 cubic kilometers of fresh water to fill it otherwise, and you really don't want to do pumped hydro with seawater.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bryanlarsen on Friday November 28, 2025 @09:42AM (#46079080)
And yet it's still far cheaper than any other form of seasonal storage.

Seasonal storage is crazy expensive. You need a lot of power, and a lot of energy, but you can only amortize the cost over one or two usages per year.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by vidarh on Friday November 28, 2025 @10:35AM (#46079523)
Norway already have seasonal storage with a storage capacity equivalent to 6-8 months of total electricity use in the form of its existing hydroelectric plants, with no need to pump things back up again.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by pbmonster on Friday November 28, 2025 @06:32PM (#46083782)
> And yet it's still far cheaper than any other form of seasonal storage.

Only for countries with very suitable landscape, and the willingness to use it - damming high altitude valley is extremely unpopular and bad for the environment.

Also, pumped hydro is expensive. Initial capex is higher than today's lithium batteries, if you design comparable systems. The only reason anybody is still building new pumped storage is that you can use it for 100 years (instead of 20 for the batteries, although nobody really knows how much they'll actually degrade).

I think we'll find hundreds of TWh of seasonal storage elsewhere. Thermal storage is extremely attractive if (or once) you have district heating installed. Takes care of a massive junk of domestic heating, and could take over light (food processing, paper,... ) and medium (chemical, ...) industry. Just don't try to turn it back into electricity...

Once steel and concrete get electrified, we might get seasonal hydrogen storage in underground salt caverns. Concrete and steel need absurd amounts of high heat which probably means making lots of hydrogen, putting those in the right locations might make additional hydrogen for fuel cells/gas turbines available, relatively cheaply (still extremely expensive, seasonal storage always is). But who knows...

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by vidarh on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:27AM (#46077364)
The problem is where to store it.

10 billion liters of water is 1,000 m^2 * 10m deep. There is no suitable location for that that is both elevated enough and near enough to Mjøsa to be financially viable.

Norway also existing hydro reservoirs with a capacity equivalent to around 6-8 months electricity supply, so it's not really a major need for Norway, anyway, but this is a fairly general problem: Finding suitable locations that are close enough to a water source, and provides a large enough potential reservoir is hard.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bryanlarsen on Friday November 28, 2025 @09:48AM (#46079123)
> Finding suitable locations ... is hard.

No it's not. Here's almost a million of them: https://re100.eng.anu.edu.au/global/

If big ones are hard, you can make a bunch of smaller ones.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by vidarh on Friday November 28, 2025 @10:33AM (#46079510)
Looking at a few of them, a few obvious problems are apparent.

Firstly, it takes a rather liberal idea of how close the basins need to be to each other to be viable.

Secondly, most of the ones I looked at would require extensive relocation of existing populations and/or large-scale infrastructure changes, such as re-routing important roads.

The first few I looked at also do not have a sufficient water supply nearby - you'd face either covering them or you'd quickly run into problems of evaporation that you have little ability to replenish/replace.

A lot of the ones I quickly looked at would also face "fun" issues such as no nearby infrastructure such as roads to bring in construction materials.

I have no idea how many suitable locations there are on that map, but it seems pretty apparent it is a small fraction of the ones marked before you even consider how many would be politically unviable because of public resistance to the environmental destruction.

To be clear, I'm not at all opposed to investigating pumped storage, but it's also not nearly that simple.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by fifilura on Thursday November 27, 2025 @11:58PM (#46075653)
You could just build a back-channel for the existing hydro-dams? Those reservoirs are only full for a short period and that is when you dont need pump energy.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by 2000UltraDeluxe on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:32AM (#46077101)
But where? In Finland, at least, the land is relatively flat when compared with Norway and Sweden, and with a large rural population there aren't really any good locations.

In my local area, we had major flooding this spring because the hydro plant operators were sleeping on the job (or whatever they did instead of regulating water levels). And that was a simple 2m increase in water levels.

NO/SE have some more geographically suitable locations, but last time I checked, flooding them was considered too environmentally destructive too the local environment.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by vidarh on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:16AM (#46077328)
Yeah, you're right regarding the environmental concerns.

Most of Norway's hydro dams were built a long time ago when there was little focus on the environmental effects.

The last major plant went live in 1993. Most of the focus now is on far smaller schemes, that doesn't really add up to a lot compared to Norway's established generating capacity (which outstrip the total electricity use anyway), but which also meet far less opposition.

Part of the reason for that was growing local opposition to larger plants, and sometimes national opposition, culminating with the Alta controversy[1] in the late 70's that were some of the largest civil protests in Norway since the end of WW2. The protests eventually failed, but it had a lasting effect on Norwegian politics.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alta_controversy

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by fifilura on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:50AM (#46077472)
If you pump the water back into the existing reserviors you will have less flooding?

I suggested a pump-water extension to existing hydro power reservoirs.

Like your EV recharges when you release the pedal.

Right shouldn't talk about EVs with a Finn, that analogy will not fly. Ok, like if you plan carefully where you throw up your koskenkorva you can re-use it.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by 2000UltraDeluxe on Friday November 28, 2025 @07:45AM (#46078164)
The reservoirs in Finland aren't quite at the scale your Explorer Vodka-fuelled Swedish mind believe them to be. Most are small generators hooked up to the local rivers, and are required to prioritize keeping the water from flooding residential areas.

There's a reason we're looking at using old mines for pumped hydro rather than trying to pump water upriver during a spring flood because other power sources have surplus generation.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by magicalhippo on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:42PM (#46074190)
True, but that disrupts ecosystems. Or so the argument against go building storage dams go.

That said, there's been a fair bit of talk here in Norway recently about tax incentives blocking hydro owners from upgrading old generators, improving efficency. Apparently a lot of currently unused power available if they "just" did that.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by tempestn on Thursday November 27, 2025 @08:55PM (#46074870)
I wonder if it's possible to also increase the amount of generation on existing dams? I could imagine there being situations where there's excess peak flow capacity but it isn't utilized because the flow rate would be unsustainable. But if we're looking for storage it could make sense.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by foota on Thursday November 27, 2025 @09:24PM (#46074992)
I think hydro storage is a lot less disruptive because you don't need as much space. Traditional hydro reservoirs have to last all season.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by beambot on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:44PM (#46074206)
Hydro doesn't work so well when things freeze over. Geothermal on the other hand...
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:52PM (#46074254)
It doesn't get cold enough for long enough for lakes to freeze solid.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bawolff on Thursday November 27, 2025 @07:02PM (#46074317)
I imagine the thaw/freeze cycle would be hell on the equipment to run pumped hydro storage.

Are there extant succesful examples of pumped hydro in cold regions?

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by gpm on Thursday November 27, 2025 @07:25PM (#46074438)
> Are there extant succesful examples of pumped hydro in cold regions?

There's some pumped hydro at Niagara falls in Canada, which is far enough North that it should see a bit of a that/freeze cycle but is still a relatively mild climate.

Don't know anything about what issues this does/doesn't present to them, just happen to know it exists.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by numbsafari on Thursday November 27, 2025 @11:46PM (#46075594)
For reference, Niagara Falls is at roughly the same latitude as Barcelona and Milan. Vääksy, Finland, is approximately 1,250 miles (2k km) north of there, slightly north of Anchorage, Alaska.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by gpm on Thursday November 27, 2025 @11:50PM (#46075610)
Latitude is a poor point of comparison here, North America tends to be substantially colder than Europe at the same latitude.

Or concretely Niagara Falls goes from an average low of -6.44 C in February to 21.0 C in July. Barcelona an average low of 4 C in January to 20.2 C in August (according to the internet).

But yes, it's warmer than Finland, just cold enough to see something of a freeze that cycle.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bawolff on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:37PM (#46081424)
A couple days of -6 is probably a lot easier. Its probably still economical enough to heat the equipment on the days below 0. I imagine having a couple months of -20 is a bit different.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bryanlarsen on Thursday November 27, 2025 @07:29PM (#46074450)
A reversable pump-turbine is not significantly different from a standard hydro generation turbine, and there are tons of examples of those operating in cold regions.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by kalleboo on Thursday November 27, 2025 @10:39PM (#46075294)
You have Juktan in northern Sweden which was pumped hydro from 1978-1996, and now they want to re-build it back into pumped hydro again https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juktans_kraftstation
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by 7952 on Friday November 28, 2025 @03:53AM (#46076874)
Surely the turbines could be fed from subsurface water that is not frozen.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by DownGoat on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:49AM (#46077466)
Some of the hydro power is run-of-river hydro power stations, which has lower flow when it is cold.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Tuna-Fish on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:59PM (#46074294)
There's not much geothermal available when you are standing atop the baltic shield.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by baq on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:43AM (#46076153)
Either fusion or drill baby drill is necessary. Watt’s steam engine was absolutely horrible, but it was the worst steam engine ever built. If Finland builds the worst deep geothermal ever that still works, we can hope for better ones.

Yeah I know drilling through ~8-10 kilometers of rock is kinda hard… they know, they tried, maybe it now is a good political climate to try again?

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by distances on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:16AM (#46076314)
> Yeah I know drilling through ~8-10 kilometers of rock is kinda hard… they know, they tried, maybe it now is a good political climate to try again?

The Finnish 7 kilometer geothermal drilling failed commercially, I guess that's what you're referring to. Is there any reason to assume drilling deeper would work?

Ref. https://fi.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otaniemen_syv%C3%A4rei%C3%A4t

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by baq on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:29AM (#46076383)
Yeah, that’s the one. Economics of this are hard - but money is numbers in computers, it’s just a question of how serious the government is with getting it done - physics-wise it gets like 10-15C warmer with every km, which is important for the delta T obviously. I know nothing about drilling the extra couple km, though, only assuming it can be done with enough engineering.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by distances on Friday November 28, 2025 @03:37AM (#46076774)
I understood that temperature wasn't the problem. How it works is that you pump water into one well, and get it out from an adjacent one. The main problem was permeability, they couldn't get the necessary flow rate between the wells.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by baq on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:12AM (#46076990)
Ah good to know, I for some reason thought it wasn't hot enough. Sounds like they need to figure out horizontal drilling 8km deep in volcanic rock.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Tuna-Fish on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:12AM (#46076284)
Or just fission, we know how to do that.

8-10km is not anywhere enough, the Baltic Shield is ~50km thick.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by baq on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:31AM (#46076392)
You don’t need to drill to magma, just deep enough to get to 120-130C rock. (‘Just’)
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by jabl on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:14AM (#46076300)
They tried in southern Finland not long ago. At great expense and spending a lot of time they managed to drill down 6-7 km until they figured out that the porosity of the rock down there was so poor that it was impossible to make the project economical, so it was cancelled. The idea was to pump this heat directly into the district heating grid.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by dofdial on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:17PM (#46074047)
invest in saving/harvesting energy. Better than producing when solar is cheap as hell and you get no-solar-harvesting because of your location
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bjourne on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:40PM (#46074174)
Right, the worst case scenario is cold temperatures, transmission problems (say days after a storm), lull, and nuclear and hydro power malfunction. However, it should be pointed out that winters are usually quite windy and there are only a few days per year you get very cold temperatures coupled with nearly no wind at all.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by alvah on Thursday November 27, 2025 @07:04PM (#46074329)
"there are only a few days per year you get very cold temperatures coupled with nearly no wind at all"

This is a terrible handwave. How many days per year, in the middle of winter, in a cold country, are you OK with having no power?

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by kieranmaine on Thursday November 27, 2025 @07:43PM (#46074523)
The system in the article works alongside gas and wood chips heating, so there are other options in place if the sand battery cannot be "charged".

FTA:

> The project will cut fossil-based emissions in the Vääksy district heating network by around 60% each year, by reducing natural gas use bu 80% and also decreasing wood chip consumption.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Maxion on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:51AM (#46076194)
Not really, we're currently borderline. If OL3 goes down, and it's simultaneously cold over the nordics + northern germany and the baltics, and no wind, our industry will have to shutdown.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by trollbridge on Thursday November 27, 2025 @10:30PM (#46075256)
This would be an argument for widespread backup power, actually. If every residence had enough backup power to get through 24 hours, it would be far easier to deal with these relatively rare doldrums.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by bjourne on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:46AM (#46077177)
Please read the hn guidelines and reconsider your participation.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Kon5ole on Friday November 28, 2025 @06:00AM (#46077527)
Why no power? The forests, hydro dams, heat plants and such that gave power long before wind became a thing are still there.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by einpoklum on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:41PM (#46074181)
I'm not ruling out Nuclear in general, but let's remember that:

* Energy can also be carried northward from other areas in the same country or neighboring countries, where there are more sunlight hours or more wind.

* Geothermal energy sources, e.g. https://www.rehva.eu/rehva-journal/chapter/geothermal-energy...

* Increase in solar panel farm area

* Improvements in panel efficiency (which continue)

* Improvement in energy use efficiency

... in some combination, and with decent storage, might get even the Nordic countries to cover their needs.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Tuna-Fish on Thursday November 27, 2025 @06:55PM (#46074274)
1. The southernmost spot in Finland is too far north, and the scramble that happened in EU at the loss of Russian energy supplies made it crystal clear that we can not trust any other country to help in times of need.

2. We have no geothermal sources sufficient for production of electricity, it can only be used to slightly reduce primary energy use during winter, but it will raise electricity use during winter.

3. Helps not at all, because 0 times however large number you like is still 0.

4. Likewise.

5. Improvements in efficiency do not help you stay alive when it's -30°C.

The option up here really truly is "do we use fossil fuels, or do we use nuclear". Renewables do not help. They are nice to have, and it makes sense to build them because they complement the reduced output of nuclear in summertime, and because the lower cost/kWh can help some industry, but that's all.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by trueismywork on Thursday November 27, 2025 @07:02PM (#46074318)
> The southernmost spot in Finland is too far north, and the scramble that happened in EU at the loss of Russian energy supplies made it crystal clear that we can not trust any other country to help in times of need.

That's the failure of European union

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by buzer on Thursday November 27, 2025 @07:59PM (#46074607)
Note that even Central Europe did have sufficient energy for export it wouldn't really help during crisis. To get the energy to Finland it would need to either go thru the Baltic Sea via undersea cables or via Northern Sweden. We have seen that it's not necessarily good idea to rely on the former during the crisis as those lines can easily be cut, they have been multiple times in just past year or so by certain commercial ships "accidentally" dropping their anchors.

As for latter Sweden, doesn't currently have capacity for it and I don't think they have been very interested in increasing it, currently Finland often benefits from the fact that there isn't enough transport capacity between Southern and Northern Sweden electric grids so Finland gets some cheap electricity from there.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Teever on Thursday November 27, 2025 @09:02PM (#46074905)
I don't think it's necessarily a failure of the EU for member states to prioritize stability and independence of their electrical grid.

Texas having their own grid is not a failure of American federalism.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Tuna-Fish on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:23AM (#46077048)
That's true, but it doesn't matter. It's not something we can change.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by jltsiren on Thursday November 27, 2025 @08:27PM (#46074762)
The difference between baseline and peak electricity consumption in Finland is >2x. That's mostly driven by heating. Because renewables make electricity cheap on the average, utility companies invest in cheap heat storage systems such as sand batteries. They use electricity when it's cheap, store the heat, and distribute it when it's needed.

As for nuclear, the challenge is finding companies that are able and willing to build it. Areva and Rosatom both failed at the "able" part. And a power company (I think it was Fortum) recently stated that they would consider building new nuclear reactors with German electric prices but not with Finnish prices.

There is more to that than a power company asking for subsidies. Finland is a small country. Olkiluoto 3 alone generates >10% of the electricity. Newer reactors would likely be smaller but still ~10% of the total. Finnish power companies are too small to take risks like that on their own. They can't build new reactors at their own risk, in order to sell the power in the market. Before a reactor gets built, the power company needs long-term commitments from industrial users and utility companies to buy power for a guaranteed price. Such commitments would make sense for the buyer with German electricity prices but not with Finnish prices.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by epistasis on Thursday November 27, 2025 @09:03PM (#46074912)
I think this is exactly right, and people are focusing on the wrong risk with nuclear. It's financial risk, not safety risk, that is the biggest burden for more nuclear.

Finland was very very wise and savvy to get a fixed price contract for Olkiluoto 3. The final cost was far far far above its price, and France ended up paying that price. I'm not sure if you'll see a builder go down that route any time soon again.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by intrasight on Thursday November 27, 2025 @09:31PM (#46075025)
> It's financial risk, not safety risk

If that's the case, then why does the indistry demand the repeated renewal of the Price-Anderson Nuclear Industries Indemnity Act?

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by epistasis on Thursday November 27, 2025 @10:02PM (#46075154)
Well that covers the financial risk from the safety risks... but even if it were purely about safety it's an act that's part of making the safety not be an issue. Unless it were not renewed, then it would be a problem agai.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by energy123 on Thursday November 27, 2025 @08:52PM (#46074859)
> 3. Helps not at all, because 0 times however large number you like is still 0.

Show me your Monte Carlo simulation where wind (which is negatively correlated to solar) and 8 hours of battery storage are factored in, along with small amounts of gas peaking plants.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by adrianN on Thursday November 27, 2025 @10:29PM (#46075249)
In case people want to play with a toy model: https://model.energy/
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Maxion on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:48AM (#46076177)
You don't even need to open up R or Pandas to understand that solar is not viable in the winter.

Here's the official meteorology insitutions sunshine data: https://www.ilmatieteenlaitos.fi/1991-2020-auringonpaiste-ja...

Here's some solar production data over the seasons in visual form: https://profilesolar.com/locations/Finland/Helsinki/

What is also important to know is during the winter is that while production on average shows numbers every day, in practice that production comes only during the few actually sunny days in December when the panels aren't covered in snow.

Go even a bit up north from Helsinki and unless you keep your panels clear of snow manually, you'll hardly make anything between Nov and April.

EDIT: Here's a reddit thread where someone shares real production data: https://old.reddit.com/r/Finland/comments/1i6onkk/solar_ener...

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Tuna-Fish on Friday November 28, 2025 @02:17AM (#46076318)
We have the problem of stable high-pressure polar air masses potentially parking over the country. Whenever that happens, we get 2 weeks of dead calm, coinciding with the coldest weather that occurs in the country. At the time of the year when there is no solar.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by energy123 on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:57AM (#46077235)
That's where inter-country interconnects, storage and gas come in, which can only be reasoned about through simulations.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Maakuth on Friday November 28, 2025 @07:02AM (#46077907)
These weather systems are quite big indeed. It's cold and calm in the neighboring Scandinavian countries as well and typically in Central Europe too.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Tuna-Fish on Saturday November 29, 2025 @06:17AM (#46086708)
> That's where inter-country interconnects

Recent experience has shown that we need to have our power generation on our soil. That is not something that can be compromised on.

> storage

Weeks of storage would be hilariously more expensive than just building more nukes.

> gas

Our main source of gas was Russia. Enough said.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by PunchyHamster on Friday November 28, 2025 @08:41AM (#46078537)
Show one where it does work. Even in far souther countries like Poland solar production is 1/4 of what it is in summer. I'd have to fill my entire roof with solar and still would have to get some power from the network to heat my house
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Ekaros on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:38AM (#46076123)
>2. We have no geothermal sources sufficient for production of electricity, it can only be used to slightly reduce primary energy use during winter, but it will raise electricity use during winter.

The project for properly deep geothermal for district heating in Espoo was not resounding success. And that is 6,4km deep hole in southern part of Finland. My understanding is that it somewhat worked. But not as good as expected.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by Kon5ole on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:44AM (#46077437)
>The option up here really truly is "do we use fossil fuels, or do we use nuclear". Renewables do not help.

Hey now - renewables gave us electricity up here long before Einstein started thinking about atoms!

We are very few people here, 250MWh helps a lot, but if we have to chip in to build a nuclear plant we'll be broke before the project planning is done. ;-)

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by fulafel on Thursday November 27, 2025 @11:07PM (#46075421)
> the big issue during winters is when there's cold air high pressure systems we get neither sun nor wind

Wind does better in the winter.

See eg here for Canada monthly stats: https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=251000...

Also, wind does better at night than day, which may be related or not.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by helsinkiandrew on Friday November 28, 2025 @12:52AM (#46075880)
And in Finland: 60% of Finnish wind energy 'collected' in the winter months (Oct-Mar)

https://suomenuusiutuvat.fi/en/wind-power/wind-power-in-cold...

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by lanthade on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:28AM (#46076077)
I think the point is that winter can create periods where there is neither adequate wind or adequate sun. Having strong wind production at some times will only be good if there's a way to store the excess. That's exactly what this project does and I believe that was GPs point.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by fulafel on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:15PM (#46082819)
Generally lulls in wind production are more common in summer. But they do happen in all seasons. And the district heating application of this sand battery is of course more relevant in the winter when there's more demand for district heat.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by baq on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:32AM (#46076101)
> there's cold air high pressure systems we get neither sun nor wind

AKA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunkelflaute

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by teiferer on Friday November 28, 2025 @01:36AM (#46076114)
That hydro is regularly turned off when it gets too cold.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by jve on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:00AM (#46076915)
Really? How do they turn it off? Where can I read about it?

I often pass the hydro bridge, so we have winters and whatnot - I didn't know they turn them off.

I can see hydro pumping power for all year long and being the top source of electricity in Latvia: https://www.ast.lv/en/electricity-market-review?year=2025&mo...

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by ZeroGravitas on Friday November 28, 2025 @04:49AM (#46077194)
But "stable" isn't really want they want or need. They have a) cold, dark winters so they want more energy in the winter not a constant amount year round, b) hydro (89% of electricity in Norway!) that is already used as seasonal storage and can be varied to meet daily variation.

Cheap wind that produces more in winter is the obvious answer and indeed seems to be a focus of their build out.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by flakeoil on Friday November 28, 2025 @05:14AM (#46077307)
> But "stable" isn't really want they want or need.

Yes, that is exactly what they need. They need stable energy over let's say a 1-2 week period. A windy week is often followed by a non-windy week. So if they can store the energy from the windy week and use it in the following week then they can rely on wind power as a stable energy source.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by ViewTrick1002 on Friday November 28, 2025 @07:09AM (#46077945)
> but it's fairly built out so stable non-fossil power needs to be nuclear,

Or just gas turbines running on decarbonized fuels. The backup for the "10 year winter" can be fossil fuels. It is such a minuscule problem that it does not matter in the slightest.

It is essentially the emergency reserve we are talking about, no point wasting tens of billions in subsidies per new built nuclear reactor.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by whizzter on Friday November 28, 2025 @08:20AM (#46078405)
Those "10 year" winters seems to appear every year with producers falling back to burning fossil fuels to keep the grid working.

Now part of that problem is that we more or less constantly export electricity to Germany (but that was because they closed their nuclear plants).

The main problem domestically in Sweden is that 30% of current electricity generation in Sweden is nuclear, but the _newest_ plants are 40 years old, on top of that the electricity generation needs to increase, steel mills de-carbonizing, more electric cars and so on.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by ViewTrick1002 on Friday November 28, 2025 @09:27AM (#46078938)
For a few hours leading to insignificant emissions.

> Now part of that problem is that we more or less constantly export electricity to Germany (but that was because they closed their nuclear plants).

We have previously imported way more. The problem nowadays is that carbon emissions are expensive and even more so when coming from LNG rather than pipeline from Russia.

In other words: our prices were previously more aligned with Germanys because ours were more expensive and Germanys was cheaper.

If you are Swedish, or understand Swedish following from the "we", take a look at this talk starting at 43:40 to understand where the prices are coming from:

https://play.mediaflow.com/ovp/16/88PEO8YFIF

> The main problem domestically in Sweden is that 30% of current electricity generation in Sweden is nuclear, but the _newest_ plants are 40 years old, on top of that the electricity generation needs to increase, steel mills de-carbonizing, more electric cars and so on.

And new built nuclear power won't be online until the 2040s. Are you saying that we should wait until the 2040s to decarbonize those parts of the economy rather than do it ASAP with renewables and storage?

The existing nuclear power fleet has now targetted their maintenance on operation until the 2060s, so it is not like it will disappear overnight.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by mapt on Friday November 28, 2025 @07:29AM (#46078062)
One of the interesting things about hydro is that it's usually constructed to satisfy baseload power. In reality, shifting that over to a peaking plant requires relatively modest changes to system, a small fraction of the cost of an entirely new dam. You don't actually need the "Pumped" part of pumped hydro, you can just throttle normal hydro on and off if you have enough turbines (though for ecological & geomorphological reasons some minor downstream damming also helps). There wasn't any reason to install the extra turbines in the age of fossil fuels. They only take ~30 seconds to spin up, versus days or weeks for thermal plants.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by scotty79 on Friday November 28, 2025 @07:32AM (#46078076)
Imagine if we build hydro to full capacity and monetize the excess with data/compute centers and/or crypto mining. We'd have so much spare capacity for any residential or industrial purposes.
Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by mapt on Friday November 28, 2025 @10:13AM (#46079335)
Datacenters and crypto are evidently a bad source for large-scale load variability because their significant capex demands that they be kept running 24/7.

This is often a problem with variable load schemes that do any useful work, rather than just dumping heat into something. It would be interesting to see a list sorted by just how thick they are with capital considerations. Aluminum smelting, hydrogen electrolysis, lots of other options on that list.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by scotty79 on Saturday November 29, 2025 @11:02AM (#46088533)
> their significant capex demands that they be kept running 24/7.

US companies are sitting on a pile of not yet connected GPUs because they have no place to put them. They would take 10 out of 24h if they could get 10. It's better than zero that they currently have for those GPUs.

Same with crypto. No point of running a rig if it's losing you money becaus electricity is too expensive at this moment. Regardless of capex sometimes it's better not to run it.

Re:250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland by dzhiurgis on Saturday November 29, 2025 @05:29AM (#46086508)
> You don't actually need the "Pumped" part of pumped hydro, you can just throttle normal hydro on and off if you have enough turbines (though for ecological & geomorphological reasons some minor downstream damming also helps).

Yeah that generally can work for a week or so, not for entire season.