> To use this feature, you must be located in the US
How does Google expect to compete with OpenAI globally if they keep limitting the rest of the world?
Or if you are not in the EU, spend more money I guess and become an attractive market.
It's google's choice to forgo privacy and thus a huge market like the EU. Other companies, like OpenAI, seem to manage fine.
Again no one in Europe cares about some Gemini because frankly no one even knows what it is. They had their run with the black founding fathers and most people who tried it then dismissed it forever.
For normal people ChatGPT = AI.
When normies hear Gemini, they cringe and get that icky feeling.
It didn't help that when Gemini came out it was giving you black founding fathers and Asian nazis.
I have no horse in the race either way, but I do find it funny how HN will swoon over a feature from one company and criticize to no end that same feature from another company just because of who made it.
At least Recall is on-device only, both the database and the processing.
With ChatGPT Atlas, you simply uninstall it. done.
It's pretty easy to explain if you assume that HN consists of multiple people with varying opinions.
So the pushback makes perfect sense to me. Also, HN isn't 1 entity, it's many people with many different opinions, you can easily find people who were/are excited about Recall the same way people are excited about Atlas.
People will probably leave it default past the perk period.
That’s the idea. It’s an obvious dark pattern. Just like a free trial which automatically stars billing you at the end of the period.
You miss the most questionable bit which is asking for keychain access. I said no to that one.
I really doubt OpenAI consciously wants my passwords, but I could absolutely see a poorly-coded (or vibe-coded, lol) OpenAI process somehow getting my keychain into their training set anyway, and then somebody being able to ask Chat-GPT 6, "hey, what's Analemma_'s gmail password?" and it happily supplying it. The dismal state of LLM scraper behavior and its support (or lack thereof) of adherence to best practices lends credibility to this.
If you publish something on the web, what are you expecting to happen?
Building a new browser engine is 99% of the work and slapping LLM features on it is the other 1% of it.
Because you work in firmware (so presumably you appreciate measurement, risk, durability) you might be more critical of the “wear sooner than ideal” signals and want a tire with more robustness.
I’m not sure about voice chat, though - it’s equally frustrating for me. Often, it’s excessively verbose, repeating my question with unnecessary commentary that doesn’t contribute to the answer. I haven’t tried the personality tweaks they recently introduced in the settings - I wonder if those also affect voice chat, because that could be a potential solution.
I often get annoyed with ChatGPT yammering on and on, so I repeatedly told it to cut to the chase and speak more succinctly.
Now it just says "I'll get right to the point..." and then still yammers on and on unabated.
Instead, telling them to do the opposite works. "Brevity is appreaciated", or "Preserve Tokens and be concise."
More access for free users might not provide enough attraction.
1. Turn on browser memories Allow ChatGPT to remember useful details as you browse to give smarter responses and proactive suggestions. You're in control - memories stay private.
2. Ask ChatGPT - on any website Open the ChatGPT sidebar on any website to summarize, explain, or handle tasks - right next to what you're browsing.
3. Make your cursor a collaborator ChatGPT can help you draft emails, write reviews, or fill out forms. Highlight text inside a form field or doc and click the ChatGPT logo to get started.
4. Set as default browser BOOST CHATGPT LIMITS Unlock 7 days of extended limits on messaging, file uploads, data analysis, and image generation on ChatGPT Atlas.
5. You're all set — welcome to Atlas! Have fun exploring the web with ChatGPT by your side, all while staying in control of your data and privacy. (This screen also displays shareable PNG badge with days since you registered for ChatGPT and Atlas).
My guess is that many ChatGPT Free users will make it their default browser just because of (4) — to extend their limits. Creative :)