News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ChatGPT Atlas by thewebguyd on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @09:04PM (#45663800)
Isn’t this what Recall in Windows 11 is trying to solve, and everyone got super up in arms over it?

I have no horse in the race either way, but I do find it funny how HN will swoon over a feature from one company and criticize to no end that same feature from another company just because of who made it.

At least Recall is on-device only, both the database and the processing.

Re:ChatGPT Atlas by mlrtime on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @10:41PM (#45664351)
I think it makes sense, many don't have a choice to run Windows (Linux/Mac won't work for them for whatever reason). If MS turned on Recall without a disable (and its not hard to believe they wouldn't, onedrive), people would be upset.

With ChatGPT Atlas, you simply uninstall it. done.

Re:ChatGPT Atlas by Vinnl on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @06:22AM (#45667037)
> I do find it funny how HN will swoon over a feature from one company and criticize to no end that same feature from another company

It's pretty easy to explain if you assume that HN consists of multiple people with varying opinions.

Re:ChatGPT Atlas by sensanaty on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @09:41AM (#45669017)
I'm the last person to defend OpenAI on literally anything and personally I hope they crash and burn in a spectacular fashion and take the whole market down with them, but you at least have a choice in using Atlas as it's simply a program that you install on your computer of your own volition. With Recall, there's no choice, M$ will just shove it down your throat whether you want it or not, and most likely (knowing their history it's pretty much a guarantee) you'll be stuck with the privacy nightmare that is Recall with nothing you can do about it.

So the pushback makes perfect sense to me. Also, HN isn't 1 entity, it's many people with many different opinions, you can easily find people who were/are excited about Recall the same way people are excited about Atlas.