By the way, for content creation, the only platfrom that really favors new creators is TikTok. Whether it leads to higher content quality is left for one's judgement.
I hope that's not the definition people are using when discussing adoption of "new tech".
When it comes to the topic of AI and "new tech adoption", I think about something like the Rust programming language.
I apologize if it chafes the people reading this comment that I'm something of a Rust evangelist and I'm working from a point of view that Rust's very existence is a (large) net-positive when it comes to programming and how we think about programming language design.
My fear with AI tools in their current state is that it will slow down innovation in programming languages. Rust gained popularity because it brought things to the table that made writing safe, performant, and correct (thinking about the strong, expressive, static type checking) software much easier than it had been with the old incumbents (in certain domains).
But, if Rust were released today or in the near future, would it take off? If we could, hypothetically, get to a point where an AI tool could spit out C or C++ code and push it through some memory sanitzers, Valgrind, etc and just iterate with itself until it was very likely to be free of memory safety bugs, why would we need a new language to fix those things? I guess we wouldn't. And it wouldn't really matter if the code that gets generated is totally inscrutable. But, it saddens me to think that we might be nearing the end of human-readable programming language research and design.
An interesting example is perl which is essentially static at this point (perl 6 was renamed and never got traction).
I know from experience running pipelines that those old perl scripts almost always work, where if I come across an old python script (2x) I will have to go in and make some adjustments. Maybe a library has changed too…
People like new shinny things though. Maybe the new languages will try to train the ai and release there own models, but that’s a huge lift.
People used to be worried that AI performance was going to degenerate if models are trained on AI slop, but it's been found that synthetic data is the bee's knees for coding, reasoning and such, so it may well be that a new language comes with a large amount of synthetic examples which will not just be good for AI training but also for documentation, testing and all that.
I'm highly bearish on the concept of anything like that ever being possible (and near perfectly reliable) with llms, but if it were then it'd make sense as just another processing phase in compilation.
GC languages have many benefits that come from 'you don't have to think about memory allocation'. For instance you can just smack an arbitrary library into a Java program with maven and not think at all about whether the library or the application is responsible for freeing an object. The global problem of memory allocation is handled by a globally scoped garbage collector.
LLMs are great at superficial/local translation processes (e.g. medium-quality translation of 中文 to English doesn't require constraint solving any more than remembering which of the many indexing schemes is the right one for 'how do I look up this row/column/whatever in pandas') But fighting with the borrow checker (getting global invariants right) is entirely outside the realm of LLM competence.
That being said, I think that people underestimate how fast LLM technology can evolve. At the moment, lots of training data is needed for LLMs to learn something. This may not always be the case. In 2 to 5 years, it may be possible to train an LLM to be helpful with a new programming language with much less data than is needed today. No reason to assume that the current situation is what things will be like forever. It's not like this technology isn't evolving incredibly fast.
If the hype was real none of these AI initiatives would be struggling to make money, but they are.
I don't really see it different than the artificial web3 hype, the only difference being that LLMs are use for extreme happy path scenarios.
I would say LLMs are very useful for specific scenarios. They're also getting better. Just takes time to iron out the kinks.
It's also little different than the .com bubble...
I think this teaches us that a thing can be hyped into the stratosphere, suck very much, crash and burn, and then go on to eat the world...
It's kind of sad to think that there may never be new technologies like Rust that break out and gain a critical traction. I'm hoping I'm wrong.
On a related note, are there any techniques for facilitating tech adoption and bringing all users up to speed?
Jokes aside, I find it curious what does and doesn't gain traction in tech. The slowness of the IPv6 was already an embarrassment when I learned about it in university… 21 years ago, and therefore before the people currently learning about it in university had been conceived.
What actually took hold? A growing pantheon of software architecture styles and patterns, and enough layers of abstraction to make jokes about Java class names from 2011 (and earlier) seem tame in comparison: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3215736
The way all of us seem to approach code, the certainty of what the best way to write it looks like, the degree to which a lone developer can still build fantastic products and keep up with an entire team… we're less like engineers, more like poets arguing over a preferred form and structure of the words, of which metaphors and simile work best — and all the while, the audience is asking us to rhyme "orange" or "purple"
Going from 32-bits to 128-bits is complete overengineering. We will never need 128-bits of network address space as long as we are confined to this solar system, and the resulting addresses are extremely cumbersome to use. (Can you tell someone your IPv6 address over the phone? Can you see it on one monitor and type it into a different computer? Can you remember it for the 10 seconds it takes to walk over to the other terminal?)
48-bit addresses would have been sufficient, and at worst they could have gone with 64-bit addresses. This is already too cumbersome (9-12 base36 digits), but maybe with area-code like segmentation it could be rotated into manageable. 128-bits is just not workable.
That's your idea of "extremely cumbersome"?
128 bit is exactly as hard as four groups of 32 bit.
Now you are bullshitting
They don’t push the classics like music platforms do, and I don’t think it’s just streamers’ tastes.
Compared to what though? Compared to Limeware/Kaazaa back in the day, or compared to buying records in a store?
Personally, I find it easier than ever to find brand new music, mostly because Spotify still surfaces new things with ease for me (and always have been, since I started using it in 2008), and platforms like Bandcamp makes it trivial to find new artists that basically started uploading music yesterday.
Compared to curation by other humans. Be it music labels, magazines, radio DJs, or a person sharing their playlist or giving you a mixtape.
In this model, tastes never overlap perfectly, so you're exposed to unfamiliar music fairly regularly, often in some emotional context that makes you more likely to accept something new.
Algorithms don't really do that. They could, but no one is designing them that way. If I listen predominantly to female vocalists on Spotify for a week, I'm only getting female vocalists from now on.
You also assume that all the models in use will in fact be retrained.
Generally, this position flies in the face of lived experience. AI is in fact stifling adoption of new things across many industries.
I suffer from a chronic illness. I saw 5 different specialists over the past 2 years, and each one gave me different treatment. A couple even relied on information from the 70s and 80s. One even put me in the ER because he changed my treatment after I explicitly told him not to.
Another example: Back in my 20s, I injured my back. I took my MRI results to six different doctors - and I'm serious here, every one gave me a different diagnosis. In the end, I fixed it myself by doing my own research and treatment (2 years of physical therapy). One doctor said I had pain because spine fragments were lodged in my spinal cord (not true). Two of the doctors were even pushing me into invasive surgeries, and I'm so glad I told them no.
I don't understand the praise for doctors. If I had to generalize, I'd guess the majority give up learning after achieving wealth and status. seems like an art and not a science. I will emphatically welcome AI treatment.
My dad, who worked in construction, got disabling back pain just in time for the Volcker-Freedman recession [1] His doc wanted to give him surgery which had the risk of being even more disabling, he said he'd go to a chiropractor, his doc said "if you don't do that then don't see me". I remember him taking me along for his chiropractor visits and getting a waterbed (bad idea.) He was on workman's comp at the time but got better around the time the economy got better and work was available again. Not to say he was consciously malingering, but work-associated pain has a lot to do with how you feel about your work.
There are definitely many physicians who do take in the latest developments judiciously. But I find the long tail of default resistance to be very, very long.
I’m sure the same thing applies worldwide.
And that deploying the retrained models won’t require a costly and time consuming recertification process. This is medicine after all.
Many articles and conferences are in english, often dont get translated (well), and one friend who is urology surgeon specifically mentioned this as an issue in his (former) department in Switzerland's biggest hospital (HUG in Geneva). They simply lag behind bleeding edge a bit.
Can't comment on other languages/cultures, but french speaking folks and english often dont pair well together.
Aside from time constraints and perhaps no incentive to stay up to date, we do have to remember that some of these new discoveries always take time to find their way into becoming SOTA treatments everywhere, due to costs, regulations needing updates, special training or equipment being required, as well as sometimes only being marginally better than existing treatment options.
In addition, as the article describes, the LLM services have biases built in to them even among existing technologies. It amplifies existing preferences, leading to less diversity and competition between technologies. Tech leads will have to weigh between the qualities of a technology on its own merits against how well it is supported by an LLM.
I keep thinking I'm going crazy until Rick Beato explains that yes, I am just an RNN Meat Popsicle and the world is interpolated:
I can understand other issues, but this has nothing to do with that. Models don't have to be re-trained to recommend new music. That's not how recommendation systems work.
This sounds like Moral Coating for what is otherwise protection of the Status Quo.
High paid doctors do not want to be replaced by AI. They will use every excuse to keep their high paying job.
https://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2024/12/03/ai-diagno...
Edit: yeah, people don't like this.
A new platform poses new analytic problems. A new edition of the WHO's classification of skin tumors (1), for example, presents new analytic problems.
Of course, that's not what's going to happen. :/
That's not how that would work in the real world. In a lot of places a doctor has to put their signature or stamp on a medical document, making them liable for what is on that paper. Just because the AI can do it, that doesn't mean the doctor won't have to double check it, which negates the time saved.
I would wager AI-assisted would be more helpful to reduce things doctors might miss instead of partially or completely replacing them.
I don't have a crystal ball, so this is a made-up scenario.
Sure, LLMs might not do this anytime soon, but once models understand enough biology, they're going to identify patterns we don't and propose new diagnoses. There's no reason why they wouldn't.
>Empathy (lol... from doctors?)
>New undetectable cases (lol... AI doesnt have to wait 1 year for an optional continuing education class. I had doctors a few years ago recommending a dangerous expensive surgery over a safer cheaper laser procedure)
>corruptible (lmaooo)
We humans are empathetic to the thought our 'friendly' doctor might be unemployed. However, we shouldn't let that cause negative health outcomes because we were being 'nice'.
If it ever turns on us, begins to malfunction in unforeseen ways, or goes away completely—then what?
Shortsighted, all of it.
Why does music continually entrench the older stuff (will we ever stop playing classic rock bands) whereas video streaming platforms like Netflix and YouTube try to hide/get rid of the old stuff?
AI doesn't work for the user. It couldn't care less if the user is happy or not. AI is designed first and foremost to make more money for the company. Its metrics are increased engagement and time on site, more sales, sales with better margins. Consequently, the user often has no choice or control over what the AI recommends for them. The AI is recommending what makes more sense for the company, so the user input is unnecessary.
Think of AI not as your assistant, but as a salesman.
One interesting consequence of this situation I found was that Youtube published a video "explaining" to creators why their videos don't have reach in the algorithm, where they essentially said a bunch of nothing. They throw some data at the AI, and the AI figures it out. Most importantly, they disclosed that one of the key metrics driving their algorithm is "happiness" or "satisfaction" partially gathered through surveys, which (although they didn't explicitly say this) isn't a metric that they provide creators with, thus it's possible for Youtube to optimize for this metric, but not for creators to optimize for it. That's because the AI works for Youtube. It doesn't work for creators, just as it doesn't work for users.
People are complex creatures, so any attempt at guessing what someone wants at a specific time without any input from them seems just flawed at a conceptual level. If Youtube wanted to help users, they would just fix their search, or incorporate AI in the search box. That's a place where LLMs could work, I think.
When you look at things this way, the reason why Netflix/Youtube get rid of old stuff has nothing to do with users, but with some business strategy that they have that differs from the music industry.
The entire music community has been complaining about how old music gets more recommendations on streaming platforms, necessarily making it harder for new music to break out.
It's absolutely fascinating watching software developers come to grips with what they have wrought.