News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by jillesvangurp on Thursday February 06, 2025 @12:06PM (#42964315)
A bit of inaccuracy in the article:

> a typical Li-ion battery retains only 80 percent of its charge capacity after 300 to 500 cycles

That's off by 10x at least. Typical LFP batteries that are widely used now have thousands of cycles. Over 5K in some cases. Some of the solid state batteries that are coming to production in the next few years might do better. 300 to 500 is more typical of some older chemistries. Even NMC batteries used in e.g. Teslas have cycle life spans of at least 1500 or so cycles.

And for reference, if you charge and full de-charge your car that would be 1 cycle. A decade is only 3653 or so cycles (there might be 2 or 3 leap years). Most car vehicle owners don't charge nearly as often or so completely. A typical Tesla that is partially charged maybe once a week or so is not going to need a battery replacement until the 2040s or so.

Anyway, the article carefully avoids talking about energy density. Which is of course the key thing here. Together with other things like charging speeds. Operational temperatures, etc. These all matter.

This is a university study, not a plan to get this to production. Promising and interesting but probably well over a decade away from any serious applications. By that time we might have all sorts of other battery tech that is sitting a bit higher on the technological readiness scale on the market.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by johnmaguire on Thursday February 06, 2025 @12:21PM (#42964461)
I find it interesting that my 2021 MBP's "health" was down to about 85% after the first year, but has only decreased to 82% after two additional years. I have 653 cycles now.

Assuming that's accurate, and batteries spend a majority of their usable lifetime around this capacity, perhaps battery estimates should be based off of the 80% capacity mark.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by peer2pay on Thursday February 06, 2025 @12:50PM (#42964721)
80% SoH is the de-facto industry standard for EoL/replacement. Mostly because after that you will eventually get a "knee-point" in your degradation curve at which operation is risky and largely inefficient.

Without knowing specifics, your MBP might have had issues with an individual cell such that initial capacity dropped significantly until the cell was disconnected.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by formerly_proven on Thursday February 06, 2025 @03:20PM (#42966116)
I've seen several laptops start out in the 90-95% SoH range, drop off quickly to the mid-80s and stay there for a very long time. Similarly for iPhone batteries, they go below 90% pretty fast, then each % off takes longer and longer until they actually start dying. Maybe that's due to different baselines though, BMS of laptop batteries normally refer last-full energy to the design energy, which is probably just a fixed value in an EEPROM and might not ever be reached due to a more conservative charge cutoff and tolerances.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by vasco on Thursday February 06, 2025 @04:30PM (#42966686)
Enough cycles and you get a free pillow so the risk comes with rewards sometimes!
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by thefourthchime on Thursday February 06, 2025 @02:32PM (#42965673)
I use https://apphousekitchen.com to only charge to 80%
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by ffsm8 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @02:54PM (#42965880)
Apple added a feature that only charges to 80% if you're only using it while plugged in (and discharges to 80% if not disconnected).

That made me uninstall aldente again.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by johnmaguire on Thursday February 06, 2025 @03:23PM (#42966140)
I struggle a bit with this concept. It feels silly to me to only use 80% of my laptop's battery capacity in order to... avoid my usage bringing my battery's capacity down to 80%.

OK, so it can go below 80%, but if it takes 3-4+ years, I'm not sure I care. (Don't get me wrong - I do of course use the built-in intelligent charging on Apple and Android devices. No reason to charge a battery to 100% when I'm going to plug it in for bedtime in a few hours anyway.)

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by nicoburns on Thursday February 06, 2025 @03:43PM (#42966295)
It might make sense if you occasionally use the full 100%. But for most people I expect it makes more sense to just use 100% of the capacity and then replace the battery if/when it degrades. For some reason, many people seem to have an aversion to replacing the battery in phones. Yes, it's expensive, but those same people will often replace the entire phone which is much more expensive!
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Tagbert on Thursday February 06, 2025 @04:55PM (#42966883)
For most people they are not using 100% of capacity every day. In fact large numbers of laptops are primarily used plugged in and just move from desk to desk. In that scenario charging to 80% has no downside. The upside is that your battery may last longer. If you are keeping your laptop for longer than 2-3 years that might be worthwhile.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by cameldrv on Thursday February 06, 2025 @05:21PM (#42967114)
It's more than just going down to 80%. After a while the battery will essentially fail entirely and not hold a charge, or swell up and push around other components of the computer, and it becomes a fire hazard.

I have an M1 MBP and I use it 95% of the time at my desk. I use Al Dente, and if I'm going to be using it away from my desk or I'm going on a trip, I'll just click the button to fully charge it. Even if I forget, the battery life is good enough that 80% is usually enough.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by tzs on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:14AM (#42972148)
The idea of not charging all the way is to get more total use out of the battery.

These batteries degrade with use. They degrade faster when they have a high charge or a low charge. Suppose each day you used 50% and charged at night. That's a cycle every two days.

If you are doing that by going from 100% to 50% and then charging back to 100% you will get some number of cycles before you need to replace the battery. Let's say it is 1000. You'd need to replace the battery after 2000 days.

If instead you do your 50% per day by going from 80% to 30% and then charging back to 80% you are operating in a charge range that has a lower degradation rate, so now you might get 1500 cycles, or 3000 days.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by johnmaguire on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:00AM (#42974172)
I understand it increases the total lifetime of the battery, and certainly I do know a few people who are still using their iPhone 8, but most people seem to replace devices every 4 years at least. I just don't find the tradeoff worth it, but I understand from some of the sibling comments that this is probably most useful for people who don't typically run on battery power.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by apt-apt-apt-apt on Thursday February 06, 2025 @05:56PM (#42967330)
I was pretty careful with my 4.4yr old Intel MBP, nearly always using Charge Limiter to max at 80% or so.

It's at 500 cycles now, the battery has been declaring it recommends service for a year, and taking it out to cafes limits my work time to maybe 3 hours max (starting at 80%).

There were at least one or two occasions where it 'cooked' itself to death inside my backpack though, when it didn't sleep on lid close as expected.

Not sure how big an impact charge limiting has made (is my battery life better? did I avoid pillowing?). Or the self-cooking. But that has been the life of this computer.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by codemiscreant on Thursday February 06, 2025 @08:06PM (#42968165)
The number is, I believe, simply peak voltage. And personally I find the measure grossly misleading: an iPhone with an 80% battery has an almost useless runtime. It definitely isn’t 80% of the original runtime.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by ruszki on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:48AM (#42970977)
My iPhone could handle about 2 days with heavy usage. It was reduced to a day after 1 year. Now after 2 and half years, the battery dies in about 12 hours with the same usage. The battery health is 83% according to iOS. So it’s definitely not a good indicator for real life usage.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by ksec on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:06AM (#42971344)
600 cycles in 4 years is pretty high IMO. Do you carry it around all the time without it being plugged into socket ?
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by kccqzy on Thursday February 06, 2025 @12:33PM (#42964568)
> Typical LFP batteries that are widely used

It depends on the use case. I believe LCO batteries are still more widely used since they are popular in small electronic devices rather than electric vehicles. These do not achieve the thousands of cycles you mention.

In general I don't like articles that simply talk about specs of Li-ion batteries as a whole without specifying the exact chemistry. Apple has different incentives when they choose a battery as compared to say Ford.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by hnuser123456 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @12:50PM (#42964718)
High discharge rate + high energy/mass density optimized chemistries usually have the worst charge cycle degradation. LFP doesn't have top discharge rate or energy/mass density, it trades some of that off for improved long term stability.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by morserer on Thursday February 06, 2025 @12:51PM (#42964727)
Li-ion != LFP.

LFP is incredible, but LFP batteries are 5x larger than li-ion. The two aren't comparable. You won't find LFP batteries in cars nor smartphones.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Animats on Thursday February 06, 2025 @03:49PM (#42966358)
BYD has raised lithium-iron phosphate Wh per liter up to lithium-ion levels. Wh per kilogram is still maybe half that of lithium-ion.

BYD "Blade battery 1": 168 Wh/kg. 448 Wh/L. Shipping now.

BYD "Blade battery 2": 210 Wh/kg. Announced for 2025. [1]

Tesla current lithium ion battery: 260 Wh/kg. 416 Wh/L[2]

(Tesla also uses lithium iron phosphate, in their lower-end cars.)

Close on size, big difference on weight. Weight differential is narrowing.

At this point, all fixed installations should be lithium iron or better. There's no excuse for big lithium-ion battery fires such as Moss Beach and the Port of Los Angeles any more.

Solid state batteries with better density are coming along, but nobody has those in volume production yet.

(Incidentally, if you ask questions like this to search engines that use an LLM, the results may be bogus, as they tend to pick numbers from the wrong places. Check the references.)

[1] https://electric.guide/renewable-energy-storage/byd-blade-ba...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-ion_battery

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Reason077 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @05:32PM (#42967178)
> "Wh per kilogram is still maybe half that of lithium-ion."

At the pack level, it seems to be a lot less than that. If you compare a Tesla Model Y standard range (with LFP pack) to a Model Y long range (with NMC), you're looking at around 62 kWh vs 80 kWh for the latest versions, putting the difference in energy density at < 30%.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by ksec on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:18AM (#42971397)
On Smartphone, First generation silicon-carbon battery, or lithium-ion battery with a silicon-carbon anode is shipping already at ~23% higher capacity. 2nd Generation is shipping this year at 40% increase over original. And hopefully 50% next year. With expected 100-200% increase by 2035.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Psyonic on Thursday February 06, 2025 @04:04PM (#42966491)
While most cars are not LFP, your claim that you won't find LFP batteries in cars is incorrect:

Rivian switched to LFP: https://insideevs.com/news/720396/2025-rivian-r1s-r1t-lfp-ba...

Some Teslas use LFP: https://www.notateslaapp.com/news/2464/tesla-lfp-batteries-c...

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Reason077 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @04:55PM (#42966884)
Most Chinese-built EVs use LFP. And China is the world's largest EV market, bigger than the rest of the world combined. So presumably, the majority of EVs shipping globally are using LFP batteries today.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by guerby on Thursday February 06, 2025 @05:34PM (#42967198)
And China is using LFP even for electric trucks.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Reason077 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @06:17PM (#42967476)
Absolutely. Likewise most of the battery-electric buses in London (and presumably, other European cities) have always used LFP. Safety is a big consideration there as nobody wants a bus-sized battery fire in the middle of a dense city.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by gertlex on Thursday February 06, 2025 @10:25PM (#42969005)
Had one in our university solar car 15 years ago, too :D
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday February 06, 2025 @02:00PM (#42965379)
Lithium-ion is an umbrella term that properly includes common cell chemistries like lithium iron phosphate (LFP), lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide (NMC) and lithium nickel cobalt aluminium oxide (NCA).

It doesn't make sense to compare LFP vs. lithium-ion, because the first is a sub-type of the second.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Melatonic on Thursday February 06, 2025 @03:55PM (#42966418)
Most commonly when people say lithium ion they really mean lithium polymer (lipo). Usually for the other lithium ion chemistries they will specify like you Jane (LFP etc).

You are technically correct - that's just how I've seen it casually used

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by CyberDildonics on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:22AM (#42974437)
Most commonly when people say lithium ion they really mean lithium polymer (lipo)

I don't think this is true. There are still lots of lithium ion 18650 cells around in battery banks, tool batteries and home devices, you name it.

Also lithium polymer is the same general chemistry (there are lots of variations), the polymer is the separator.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by stevenhuang on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:10AM (#42969655)
Yes you can be a pendant about a topic to a degree that you manage to confuse even yourself, or you can understand the term is also commonly used to refer to the typical metal oxide cathodes we all are familiar with (NMC, LCO, NCA, lipo). From context it's really the obvious interpretation.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by dgacmu on Thursday February 06, 2025 @01:01PM (#42964838)
There are a lot of LFP model 3's on the road, and my understanding is it was only canceled because of manufacturing location effects on tax rebates.

A lot of BYDs cars use LFP. And they sell a -lot- of cars.

The 2024 Mach-E is LFP. The Kia EV5.

And so on. I think you have an outdated model of lfp tradeoffs.

Many of the extended range models still use higher-density chemistries. But LFP is making amazing strides.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by rstuart4133 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @06:39PM (#42967629)
LFP Tesla 3's is what they ship from China. Australia gets Chinese made Model 3's, so they are all LFP. The US doesn't get Chinese made Tesla's, so no LFP for you.

It doesn't seem to effect things much. The cars still have the same range. I guess they must be heavier.

Australian drive their cars around 13,000 km's per year. If the LFP battery got 3,000 cycles that's 90 years. I guess they must hit some other limit long before then.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by joking on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:06AM (#42971078)
Batteries also degrade by time even if you don't charge and discharge them.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by dgacmu on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:12PM (#42975035)
They used to sell LFP base model 3's in the US: https://www.electrive.com/2024/10/04/tesla-withdraws-model-3...

> Tesla is known to frequently change the prices or availability of its models without providing separate information. As the US publication Electrek writes, the Model 3 Standard Range disappeared from the US configurator at the beginning of October. At 39,000 dollars, this variant was the cheapest Tesla in the US. Recently, however, only the Model 3 with the larger Long Range battery has been available there – in the rear-wheel drive version from 42,490 dollars. There is also the Model 3 Long Range with all-wheel drive (47,490 dollars) and the Model 3 Performance (54,990 dollars).

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by elihu on Thursday February 06, 2025 @03:50PM (#42966365)
LFP is a type of lithium ion battery. Modern LFPs perform pretty well, though they're a bit worse than "regular" lithium ion, in part because they run at a lower nominal voltage of 3.2 volts rather than 3.6 volts. They're used in cars all the time, just not usually in the United States.

I've never heard of an LFP smartphone battery, but that doesn't mean it isn't done. I wouldn't be surprised if it was common in China.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by avtolik on Thursday February 06, 2025 @01:29PM (#42965081)
I read last week that about 40% of the electric cars produced now are with LFP batteries.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by hnuser123456 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @12:57PM (#42964802)
It would appear LFPs are making their way into EVs, despite having about half the energy/mass density.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_iron_phosphate_battery

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Reason077 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @04:46PM (#42966817)
LFP has made huge energy density improvements in recent years, so the difference is much less than that today.

If you compare a standard range Tesla Model Y with LFP pack, the newest LFP pack stores around 62 kWh, vs. around 80 kWh for the long range (NMC) variant. And the LR pack actually weighs more than the LFP one, putting the difference in energy density at <30%.

Further more, typically with an NMC pack it's recommended to only charge to 80% for day-to-day use, to reduce long-term degradation. But with an LFP pack you can routinely charge to 100%. So the effective difference in range for day-to-day driving if you follow that recommendation is small.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by CorrectHorseBat on Thursday February 06, 2025 @01:57PM (#42965351)
LFP batteries are Li-ion though
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Reason077 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @04:26PM (#42966655)
> "Li-ion != LFP."

No, LFP is one form of Li-ion battery, along with other chemistries like NMC, NCA, LMO, etc.

> "LFP is incredible, but LFP batteries are 5x larger than li-ion."

Nope. Today it's more like 20-30% less energy density. And the gap has been closing over time.

> "You won't find LFP batteries in cars"

Absolutely false. The vast majority of Chinese-built EVs (brands like BFD, NIO, MG, XPeng, Geely) use LFP in many models. Most Chinese-built Teslas use LFP packs. Tesla's Powerwall 3 home storage batteries use LFP. Western automakers are also increasingly looking to LFP to reduce costs and improve stability and safety.

In fact, I'd say the significant majority of all EVs shipping in the world today contain LFP batteries.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by throw-qqqqq on Thursday February 06, 2025 @05:38PM (#42967216)
> You won’t find LFP batteries in cars

That’s not correct.

The MG4 uses LFP. So does some Model Y and Model 3s from Tesla.

See a long list here: https://evdb.nz/ev-battery

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by gruturo on Thursday February 06, 2025 @06:35PM (#42967592)
> You won't find LFP batteries in cars nor smartphones

Bold statement. Quite incorrect too. My car has one, and I'm pretty sure Tesla sold them to other people too, not just me (M3 RWD 2022)

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Johnny555 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @07:43PM (#42968066)
>You won't find LFP batteries in cars

Cars with LFP batteries: https://evdb.nz/ev-battery

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by CyberDildonics on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:19AM (#42974395)
LFP batteries are 5x larger than li-ion

This is completely wrong. Anyone who has bought a single LFP cell knows they are close but not quite as energy dense for the weight as regular lithium ion batteries. They are very common in all sorts of applications like medical devices and cars at the very least.

You won't find LFP batteries in cars

This is also not true at all. Here is a list of 42 car models with LFP batteries including telsa model 3, model Y and the ford mustang.

https://evdb.nz/ev-battery

Where were you seeing your information?

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by dragontamer on Thursday February 06, 2025 @12:52PM (#42964731)
LFP is 3000 cycles last time I checked.

NCA, a very common LiIon chemistry, is only 500 cycles as the article rightfully claims

The article is anywhere from 'correct' to off by 600% depending on which LiIon chemistry. But that's the nature of such a wide chemistry, there's so many LiIon out there it's hard to generalize.

NCA / NMC is common for phone and even EV applications though. So it's not necessarily wrong and both have similar endurance specs.

> Anyway, the article carefully avoids talking about energy density. Which is of course the key thing here.

No one cares about density in utility scale applications. It can be heavy as all heck but as long as it's cheap it will be an effective solar or wind battery.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by ziga on Thursday February 06, 2025 @03:37PM (#42966247)
You can't really generalize cycles based on chemistry alone. Battery management and usage matters. But two examples with NCA/NMC chemistry:

- The Tesla Powerwall 2 battery warranty[1] is for effectively 3650 cycles (daily cycle for 10 years).

- Many cases of Tesla cars at 200k mileage (~1000 cycles, depends on battery size) with less than 15% capacity loss[2].

And these batteries didn't die after reaching the high number of cycles, they just retained less capacity.

[1] https://energylibrary.tesla.com/docs/Public/EnergyStorage/Po...

[2] https://insideevs.com/news/723734/tesla-model-3y-battery-cap...

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by tjoff on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:59AM (#42973347)
Yes, Your phone or laptop though... that we dont have regulations that at least require manufacturers to give users the option to not charge to 100% is beyond me.

Many billions of batteries and thus billions of devices needlessly scrapped.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by megaman821 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @02:22PM (#42965585)
Also for utility uses, why is 80% the benchmark? It seems likely that batteries will be used down to 60% capacity; so double the number of cycles for a reduced capacity.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by nine_k on Thursday February 06, 2025 @07:36PM (#42968014)
Also, in a utility-scale battery with literally millions of cells there will always be gradual but constant replacement of a small amount of cells, while the remaining cells continue to bear the load. This is something you can't do in a phone, and what may be too costly in a EV.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by bcrl on Thursday February 06, 2025 @09:26PM (#42968609)
It doesn't quite work out for a centralized utility scale battery unless it gets built gradually over the expected lifetime of the component batteries, as most existing infrastructure projects tend to get financed and built all at once, so all the batteries are the same age and are likely to require replacement around the same time. On a small scale that is quite visible with UPS batteries in data centers that all fail at once.

The easiest way to avoid that is to slow things down and build up a decentralized grid scale battery over time through incentives.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by mttch on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:26AM (#42971813)
A few companies are cropping up to do EV battery repairs so it may be affordable to a consumer.

E.g. https://cedarelectric.co.uk/electric-and-hybrid-battery-repa...

My thoughts are that even after 80% usage the battery still has a second life for use in home power storage. Even after that most of the battery parts can be recycled. I think that battery trade-in schemes will start to become affordable once these reuse and recycling routes are scaled up.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Qwertious on Thursday February 06, 2025 @09:49PM (#42968729)
Energy density indirectly matters in utility scale applications, since it implies the cost is more dependent on raw materials and therefore it limits how low the cost of production can get.

In contrast if the raw materials are dirt-cheap per watt-hour (because you don't require as much mass) but the manufacturing process is expensive, then over time the manufacturing process can generally be made cheaper and you can expect the batter to get cheaper quicker.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by LUmBULtERA on Friday February 07, 2025 @07:01AM (#42971646)
FWIW, Apple's current batteries are stated to last 1000 cycles until they reach 80% capacity. [0]

Anecdotally I have 98% capacity at 248 cycles on my 15 pro. I use an 80% charge limit as I don't use that much battery in a day.

[0] https://9to5mac.com/2024/02/20/iphone-15-battery-lifescyle-s...

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by londons_explore on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:41AM (#42973091)
The 80% charge limit will dramatically extend the lifespan.

It turns out the top few percent is what really damages the cells - which means there is always an inherent capacity vs cycle life tradeoff.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by CyberDildonics on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:14AM (#42974327)
3000 for LFP is a common number, but there are some that are now claiming 6000 cycles. Of course like everyone has mentioned, battery management matters and charging temperature, discharge temperature, charge and discharge limits matter.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by hinkley on Thursday February 06, 2025 @12:54PM (#42964764)
The last aluminum battery discussed here only had about 40% of the volumetric density of Lion and did not mention wh/kg, just w/kg. Which sounds a lot like lying with statistics.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by moron4hire on Thursday February 06, 2025 @03:49PM (#42966357)
Oh, but they should be able to get that time down to a few months if they just use an LLM.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by Melatonic on Thursday February 06, 2025 @03:53PM (#42966397)
When people say Li-ion they typically are talking about Lipo batteries (unfortunately). LFP obviously are much better longevity wise.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by jillesvangurp on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:10AM (#42970233)
No they are not, they are talking about batteries that contain a lot of lithium. Aside from battery nerds, the finer points of most chemistries are lost the vast majority of people and I doubt even experts would agree with your very narrow definition.

In any case, my point was that the car industry and the storage industry is dominated by a wide variety of batteries (most of them lithium based of course; some might say lithium ion even) that have way better longevity than the article suggests is the key selling point of this new battery chemistry.

I think it's a bit misleading or sloppy. I'd expect better from IEEE.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by tim333 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:55AM (#42970710)
I've been guilty of thinking of lithium polymer. Most people have no idea of battery chemistry beyond thinking of the thing that comes with their phone.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by ikigai_sign on Thursday February 06, 2025 @08:40PM (#42968341)
I got so burned on QuantumScape stock I haven't been able to think about solid state batteries since then.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by toss1 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @10:19PM (#42968941)
You are not alone, sadly.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by amatecha on Thursday February 06, 2025 @09:07PM (#42968516)
LFP !== Li-ion.

If you "full de-charge" your car battery that battery is toast, so that's not a useful comparison.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by gnabgib on Thursday February 06, 2025 @09:10PM (#42968528)
LFP is certainly a Li-ion battery chemistry (and also a Lithium Iron chemistry).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_iron_phosphate_battery

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by amatecha on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:06AM (#42970218)
Sure, and I'm no expert on the subject, but when someone writes "a typical Li-ion battery" they mean the common rechargeable lithium battery with lithium cobalt oxide, not lithium iron phosphate. LiFePo4 is not a "typical" Li-ion chemistry yet, unfortunately.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by kvakerok on Thursday February 06, 2025 @11:59PM (#42969596)
Came here to ask about energy density, but it seems the article answered it without answering it.
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by lightedman on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:04AM (#42969623)
"300 to 500 is more typical of some older chemistries."

And this is almost purely a function of the very first charge cycle the battery receives. If the initial charge cycle is fairly aggressive, you can actually pull something like 1500 cycles out of those older chemistries, at the cost of actual capacity. We're running tests on this right now in a lab in San Diego. Almost all non-solid-state Li chemistry batteries are similarly affected.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by jve on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:55AM (#42970460)
And there is such thing as DoD (Depth of Discharge) - Doing 4x 25% charges (1 cycle) is much much much better than 1x100% cycle.

You'd lose 27% of capacity vs 8% capacity over a cycle test that lasted 2,5 years. https://youtu.be/i31x5JW361k?si=93KYNqKFVJRgSbKs&t=1216

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by hilbert42 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:03AM (#42970492)
Spectrum: "…its energy density will need to be improved, the researchers say."

"Anyway, the article carefully avoids talking about energy density. Which is of course the key thing here."

I agree. And as you say, there's a bit of inaccuracy in the article. In fact, it's more than just a little—not to mention the omissions.

What's so annoying about this article is that it's from the IEEE's magazine Spectrum where one expects the best—the most authorative, factual and most current—technical information available at publication time but it's often not the case.

Unfortunately, in recent years, the IEEE has been unduely influenced by commercial interests which has affected or slanted the accuracy of its reporting of science and engineering news. As Spectrum is the main face of the organization and its principal news outlet this is where the policy shift has been most obvious.

I could give other instances of bad or overly enthusiastic reporting of new tech where known downsides were either not reported and or downplayed but I'll refrain here as I don't have the issues of Spectrum immediately to hand to give specific references. Suffice to say, I became so disillusioned with stuff I was reading in Spectrum† that I terminated my 20-year-plus IEEE membership some while back.

My main criticism of this story is—as you correctly point out—carefully avoids talking about energy density, which has to be a crucial aspect of any story about new battery tech that's posited as a potential competitor and or replacement for Li-ion. That's damn obvious. If the researchers did not provide numerical comparisons (experimental and or theoretical) of the energy densities between their Al-ion prototypes and Li-ion in their paper/press release then Spectrum's editor should have provided a side/footnote on the matter.

Most of us already know that Li has a larger electrode potential‡ than Al, so Al is already coming from behind Li in this regard, but of course that's far from the end of the story as there are many other factors involved in addition to those benefits as promulgated by the researchers, namely recharge cycles, safety and cost. For example, how does Al stack up against Li as far as electrode surface area (spongy metal surfaces, etc.)? We know from long experience with electrolytic capacitors that Al can be treated to have very large effective surface areas, in fact they can be enormous. If Al has the potential to be much better than Li in this regard then this new tech could certainly be a winner. As this is an obvious factor, Spectrum's editor should have mentioned it amongst others even if not mentioned in the original paper (in fact, Spectrum should have criticized its omission if the case).

In summary, one would hope this research leads to much better and safer batteries but the IEEE—as the premier representative for electrical and electronic engineering/engineers—has done precious little in providing us with information that actually matters.

__

† Whilst I've strong criticisms of the IEEE not all are negative, many of its specialist publications are quite excellent including Proceedings of the IEEE.

‡ From Wiki: Standard electrode potentials:

Li: Li+ + e− ⇌ Li(s) -3.0401V

Al: Al3+ + 3e− ⇌ Al(s) -1.662V

Edit: It was only after I'd written this comment that I was able access the original ACS research paper (initially I'd difficulty downloading it). I've since skimmed it several times and I need to read it thoroughly to get a proper understanding but it's pretty short on the issues I've raised. Thus, my point that Spectrum should have mentioned these shortfalls still stands.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by ErigmolCt on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:24AM (#42970578)
I think by the time it's commercially ready (if ever), the battery landscape could look very different
Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by DoctorOetker on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:38AM (#42971512)
> Anyway, the article carefully avoids talking about energy density. Which is of course the key thing here.

But it's right there in the article:

https://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/acscentsci.4c01615?down...

> The cell with F-SSAF electrolyte and pyrolytic graphite (PG) cathode show reversible capacities of 83, 81, 79, 77, and 75 mA h g−1 at the current densities of 20, 40, 60, 80, and 100 mA g−1 (Figure 2a).

so 83 Ah/kg (at 20 A/kg), and at a cell voltage of ~ 2V thats ~166 Wh/kg.

Re:Aluminum Batteries Outlive Lithium-Ion with a Pinch of Salt by baranul on Saturday February 08, 2025 @07:00AM (#42982361)
Clarity is very much needed. There are so many stories about "battery technology breakthroughs", but then they never come to market or are x number of years away from production. The general public is often way more interested in when they are going to actually sell the new battery technology, and getting their hands on them to put to use.