News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by ergonaught on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @11:19AM (#42712854)
US citizens do not want this.

Every news article descending into tangents on any other point than that is part of why we can't have nice things.

The whole country has turned into some sort of lower primate improv troupe where whatever stupid thing comes up gets a "Yes and let's" diversion instead of an adult in the room standing up and cutting the crap.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by doctorpangloss on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @11:29AM (#42713054)
> US citizens do not want this

Ha ha, I guess you are discovering, many many people do want this.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by tills13 on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @11:53AM (#42713475)
No one who actually uses it or understands it wants this. This is like vegans banning steak.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by loeg on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:05PM (#42713678)
It's like the non-addicts banning heroin. You don't have to be a Tik Tok user to understand that it's bad for it to be PRC-controlled!
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by dvngnt_ on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:09PM (#42713737)
yeah because they wont censor gaza information
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by kjkjadksj on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:00PM (#42714567)
That is a fine take, but the assumption that all other forms of media masses of people are exposed to aren’t also propaganda is a foolish one to make. We have an entire advertising industry in this country. Something like $300 billion in ad spend a year in the US. Ad spend is literally propaganda lest we forget.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:21PM (#42714880)
> aren’t also propaganda

It's not that other propaganda doesn't exist, it's that a likely intended effect of Chinese propaganda is destabilization and/or delegitimization of hostile governments. Ad spend is more about destabilizing consumers' savings.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by rsanek on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:59PM (#42715415)
I don't think that people are arguing that. What kind of propaganda one is exposed to matters.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by amrocha on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:15PM (#42714799)
Why is it bad when China (supposedly) creates propaganda on tiktok but it’s good when the US creates propaganda on facebook?

You’re not a government, you’re a person. Either way you’re being manipulated, and the US government definitely doesn’t have your best interests in mind.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by corimaith on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:46PM (#42715215)
Because we live in a world of Sovereign States, where the point of discrimination very much is between Citizen and Non-Citizen? You free to renounce your citizenship and live without the Protections of the Government, there are many who would be quite happy with that to take your wealth freely then :)

The only people thinking in such a arrogantly privileged manner ironically are Westerners, try saying this crap in China or India and people will laugh at you all day. Or I doubt this poster has the best interests of Americans in mind either.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by amrocha on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @08:14PM (#42719736)
Do I have to adopt the government line of the country I was born in if I want to maintain citizenship? Am I not allowed to think for myself?

How exactly is that different from a dictatorship?

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by qvrjuec on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:56PM (#42715358)
Is this a serious question? China has its best interests in mind, the US government has its best interests in mind. Which one of those two adversaries are more likely to align with your interests?
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by dns_snek on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @04:12PM (#42717070)
Why do we have to choose one? I'm not going to trust US-owned media on the topic of Israel and Palestine, I'm not going to trust Russian media on Ukraine, or Chinese media on Taiwan.

By stifling freedom of expression under the guise of "national security" you're creating blind spots that allow atrocities to go unchallenged. I thought we learned from history but maybe I was wrong.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by panic on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:38PM (#42715893)
I honestly believe the answer is China—by living in the US, its interests and my own are more likely to come into conflict, whereas China’s interests are more likely irrelevant to me.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by qvrjuec on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:55PM (#42716080)
Huh. What are your interests? I'm curious why you think they would come in conflict with those of the US.

I'm confused why you think China's interests are irrelevant to you, unless you truly believe geopolitics is a zero-sum game. We compete in markets, militarily in the indo-pacific, and technologically in ways that are not mutually beneficial.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by panic on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @05:48PM (#42718261)
The US government generally works to maintain harmful institutions like health insurance, gun manufacturing, prisons and policing, etc., and will oppose me through violence if I work to weaken these. They can restrict my access to things online and control what online services I can run via laws like SESTA/FOSTA and this TikTok ban. China can't do any of that to me. I'm less concerned about geopolitics given our massive military and the position of the dollar, not to mention our cultural influence via the Internet (which bans like this directly weaken).
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by amrocha on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @08:11PM (#42719700)
Considering that my country has a history of CIA sponsored coups and election meddling by the US, China definitely has been better to me
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by 0x5f3759df-i on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @05:11PM (#42717861)
> Why is it bad when China (supposedly) creates propaganda on tiktok but it’s good when the US creates propaganda on facebook?

Because this imaginary world where the US somehow equally controls Facebook on the level that China directly influences TikTok isn’t one that exists?

This low resolution view of the world is grating. “Facebook is a US based social media company so it’s exactly the same as China and TikTok” is completely devoid of the context of reality.

Not only does Facebook actually have 1st amendment speech rights with a judicial system empowered to enforce them. But even the slightest appearance that the US government was attempting to influence speech on Facebook would be a career ending scandal.

Compared to TikTok where the CCP literally has a seat on ByteDance’s board by law and has for its entire existence had its algorithm nuke political topics that China does not want discussed.

It’s not the same thing.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by amrocha on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @08:06PM (#42719660)
Honestly, I don’t believe China has as much control over TikTok as you claim, and I believe the US government has much higher control over FB than you.

So from where I’m standing it’s the same thing.

And to give you some perspective, there’s plenty of content critical of China on TikTok even though that stuff gets banned on DouYin.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by mileycyrusXOXO on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @11:32PM (#42721249)
I'd rather be able to choose to consume propaganda than for than the government to be able to decide what I should and should not consume.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by loeg on Thursday January 16, 2025 @12:46AM (#42721754)
Yeah, the heroin addicts say the same thing about heroin though.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by herbst on Thursday January 16, 2025 @04:46AM (#42723344)
And yet the systems where addicts get actual heroin instead of even worse alternatives usually work better. See Switzerland
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by doctorpangloss on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @11:57AM (#42713526)
You're getting it. It is like vegans banning steak!

> "lower primate improv troupe"

> "No one who actually uses it or understands it wants this."

"Everyone's generalizations are stupid, except mine."

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by randomcatuser on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:23PM (#42714901)
The users for sure don't want this. Among non-users, I'd say there's a sizable difference (let's say 50/50)...

Many things aren't that democratic when you look at it like that!

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by theultdev on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:21PM (#42715688)
US citizens elected representatives to make laws for them. Even more so, this is a bipartisan law.

Tiktok US users of voting age are already accounted for in that process, they don't get extra sway just because they use the app.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by mandmandam on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @04:27PM (#42717290)
> US citizens elected representatives to make laws for them. Even more so, this is a bipartisan law.

A majority of American citizens want affordable healthcare, housing, and education, net neutrality, an arms embargo vs Israel, an end to illegal forever wars, stronger environmental protections, cleaner water, less fossil fuel use and an end to fracking, etc - and there's still bipartisan resistance in our politics and media against all of those.

Congress doesn't actually represent us, it represents capital. Been like that for a long time. https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by theultdev on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @04:30PM (#42717319)
Nevertheless, the voters made their choice and actively voted for these representatives.

If everyone is so outraged and there's so many TikTok users, they can rally and vote out the people who voted for this.

I for one support this ban fwiw. You'll find out a lot of people do too. So in this instance and quite a few others, my representative has voted in my favor.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by 3vidence on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @07:41PM (#42719425)
Voting between 1 of 2 respectives every few years to represent all issues doesnt seem to represent how citizens feel about individual issues.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by theultdev on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @10:39PM (#42720847)
What would your system be?
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by herbst on Thursday January 16, 2025 @04:51AM (#42723370)
Democratic
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by theultdev on Thursday January 16, 2025 @11:09AM (#42727183)
So mob rule? Doesn't work.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by LeafItAlone on Thursday January 16, 2025 @02:54AM (#42722569)
That’s not how voting works in practice. The people I vote for do not match my views on every single topic. Just enough (weighted) that they are the better choice.

It is possible that every single candidate on the ballot is in agreement on a topic that every single non-candidate voter has the opposite view on. That doesn’t mean nobody gets elected.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by herbst on Thursday January 16, 2025 @04:50AM (#42723366)
I don't understand this. In my view most people don't want this otherwise they would have implemented a government where the majority is heard, but they didn't. And don't even seem to try.

Either it's a dictatorship or it's listening to the majority. There is nothing democratic about acting against the majority. Never was

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by mandmandam on Friday January 17, 2025 @09:21AM (#42737761)
> In my view most people don't want this

The polls on all the above are pretty clear. There's no need to rely on your own viewpoint.

> otherwise they would have implemented a government where the majority is heard, but they didn't.

May I suggest reading some Chomsky, or at least watching Manufacturing Consent.

> Either it's a dictatorship or it's listening to the majority.

It's a plutocracy, and this has never been more obvious.

> There is nothing democratic about acting against the majority.

Well, there you go. Do check out those polls.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by mint2 on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @07:07PM (#42719120)
Of course the users don’t want it. Asking a fanbase if the thing they are a fan of should be banned and ignoring all other groups doesn’t make much sense. Nothing would be banned.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by tdb7893 on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @11:35AM (#42713165)
I think part of the problem is everyone thinks they are the "adult in the room" and everyone else is the "primates". I agree policy discussions are a bit of a farce though (in a sorta funny twist places like TikTok are responsible for that since the engagement metrics have a tendency to promote nonsense and lies)
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by Etheryte on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @11:58AM (#42713549)
We all live in a bubble that consists of the people and things we interact with. People in your bubble not wanting this doesn't mean other people outside of your bubble don't.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by dyauspitr on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:34PM (#42714146)
US citizens most definitely want this.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by Miner49er on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:46PM (#42714343)
Some, sure, highly unlikely a majority does if you look at how many Americans use TikTok
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by thinkingtoilet on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:00PM (#42714569)
How many of those people voted? The young people who don't vote don't want this and the old people who do vote do want this. The outcome is predictable.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by tartoran on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @03:10PM (#42716240)
I don't think it matters who voted for what and who got elected, TikTok's ban would probably still occur.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by t-writescode on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:12PM (#42715588)
About 1/3 of Americans use TikTok.

When it comes to *restricting* rights (not growing them), it's very concerning that such a large percentage of people can _not_ want something and still have it forced upon them.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by I_AM_A_SMURF on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:38PM (#42714213)
We certainly _do_ want this. I think the fact that we let a foreign company own a social media platform in the first place is preposterous. As others have said, we would never let the CCP own a TV broadcast, why should we let china own a major social media platform? That's just absurd.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by iforgot22 on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:46PM (#42714352)
There are foreign-controlled TV networks in the US. Not over-the-air, but that's probably due to them being niche more than anything.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by dml2135 on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:13PM (#42714782)
Part of it is almost certainly due to the FCC controlling licenses for what is broadcast over the air.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by perlgeek on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:49PM (#42715260)
You do realize that in vast majority of all countries, all major social media platforms are owned by foreign companies?

There seems to be a real risk of propaganda on Tiktok, but foreign ownership alone isn't a sound reason for a ban.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by rsanek on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:58PM (#42715383)
> foreign ownership alone isn't a sound reason for a ban

You're right -- but foreign ownership by a repressive regime with undemocratic ideals certainly is. For example, I don't think anyone would be too concerned if a European country was the one that founded & owned TikTok.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by herbst on Thursday January 16, 2025 @04:44AM (#42723339)
But if it would be a US company people in Europe would have the same kind of distrust like they have right now with china.

The US is even working on their great Firewall. It's red apples Vs blue apples at this point.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by herbst on Thursday January 16, 2025 @04:43AM (#42723334)
Or should it be reason enough. The EU should ban Meta as well, no question. This foreign propaganda, risking mental health in teenagers and all that stuff is US propaganda shoved down our eyes.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by gabruoy on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @05:00PM (#42717729)
“We” do not want surveillance propaganda targeted towards children. The US government does not want Chinese surveillance propaganda targeted toward children. They’re perfectly happy when it’s done on US soil under US jurisdiction.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by paulcole on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @06:35PM (#42718798)
I watch like 25 hours of TikTok a week. I absolutely love it.

I certainly _do_not_ want this.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by culi on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @07:11PM (#42719144)
If we don't want this then we simply won't make an account on those platforms...

YOU want this ban and you don't like that OTHER PEOPLE like TikTok. Clearly you don't have a TikTok account and that's not enough. You want to make sure no one else is allowed to have a TikTok account either

Instead of spreading the message about possible harms you'd rather ban other people's abilities

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by bobmcnamara on Thursday January 16, 2025 @08:10AM (#42724641)
There's a Kremlin radio station in Missouri.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by dpig_ on Thursday January 16, 2025 @04:43PM (#42731294)
For most of the world, your platforms are already foreign-owned.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by iforgot22 on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:48PM (#42714377)
Hey, the ADL president is a US citizen, and he said "we really have a TikTok problem."
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by logicchains on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:59PM (#42714562)
America has an Israel problem.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by drawkward on Thursday January 16, 2025 @07:42AM (#42724448)
America has an Israel problem.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by jhp123 on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:01PM (#42714582)
Pew has it at 32–28 in support of the ban[0]. I think that's pretty low for a bipartisan effort where the opposition hasn't really had a chance to air it's case.

[0] https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2024/09/05/support-f...

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by dlivingston on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:21PM (#42714881)
My opinion on this has not changed since Trump tried to ban TikTok in his first term [0]: if the USA wants to ban TikTok for XYZ reason, they need to pass a general purpose law in Congress that applies equally to all foreign-owned companies.

Singling out TikTok without a universal principle or law leaves a nasty taste in my mouth, and the US gov. will just be playing whack-a-mole with whatever the TikTok successor is.

[0]: https://www.npr.org/2020/12/07/944039053/u-s-judge-halts-tru...

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by happyopossum on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:54PM (#42715323)
Shockingly, given how often congress shirks its duty these days, they did write such a law:

https://www.congress.gov/118/bills/hr7520/BILLS-118hr7520eh....

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by nashashmi on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:30PM (#42715001)
The ones that use the app don't want this. The ones that don't use it ... don't care.

Naturally either you don't want it. or you don't care.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by corimaith on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:39PM (#42715130)
The Senator you voted for this probably voted for this so yes, America does want this.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by t-writescode on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:10PM (#42715569)
Those in leadership being against a meaningful percentage (about 30%) of those under their care is common.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by corimaith on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:23PM (#42715717)
Well let's not talk in abstract phrases, who did YOU vote for, and did you not find it probable that they would support such actions?
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by t-writescode on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:49PM (#42716013)
I voted for a Democrat; and I also was a loud fighter against previous attempts at a TikTok ban. That

  * my representatives didn't vote in line with my requests *and*
  * that they tend to vote in line with me for other issues *and*
  * that there are no other viable options either due to no competition or worse competition
Does not negate that my "representative" is not representing me.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by kansface on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:24PM (#42715726)
I'm for the ban chiefly on the grounds of economic fairness in access to markets. China doesn't allow access to any US social media products. We should only open our doors to Chinese companies conditioned on reciprocation.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by valleyjo on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @03:03PM (#42716168)
I’m a us citizen and I do want this. Speak for yourself. China bans us social media. Us should ban Chinese social media.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by herbst on Thursday January 16, 2025 @04:53AM (#42723375)
Where is that whataboutism coming from. What has the one to do with the other? Do you want a great Firewall for America? Is that what this is about?
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by drawkward on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @03:48PM (#42716725)
I am a US Citizen and I 100% want this. I think this is far too small a step; I think all social media should be banned.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by dns_snek on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @03:57PM (#42716854)
But this isn't about banning social media, it's about banning dissent.

Would you feel the same way if the US government banned all mainstream media organizations except the ones you ideologically oppose?

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by drawkward on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @04:09PM (#42717032)
> it's about banning dissent

On the contrary, I think it is about banning a propaganda and social engineering vector that is under the thumb of an adversarial foreign government. That, for me, is enough of a reason to ban it and justify it under our constitution.

The fact that I am in favor of banning all social media should tell you that it is not ideological, but rather that I think social media is extremely addictive, and has huge negative externalities.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by dns_snek on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @04:47PM (#42717578)
> The fact that I am in favor of banning all social media should tell you that it is not ideological,

I'm not accusing you of being ideologically motivated, I just think that your (otherwise understandable) support for banning social media is inadvertently helping a bad actor in stifling freedom of speech.

Could China be using TikTok to spread propaganda in the US? Sure, but I haven't seen any evidence supporting this and if there was concrete proof I'd support the ban. Meanwhile the US government is labeling truthful discussions about Israel's genocide "antisemitic propaganda" and using them as motivation for the TikTok ban.

On one side we have vague communist boogeymen, on the other there's expressed desire to take control of unpleasant narratives. That tells me that they're really just trying to take away people's ability to discuss their dissenting ideas.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by Cookingboy on Thursday January 16, 2025 @12:35AM (#42721691)
> I think it is about banning a propaganda

The problem of allowing government banning propaganda is it allows government to ban anything they label as propaganda. There is no law defining what's propaganda, so you just end up with the government being able to ban any information they don't like.

Imagine the government drums up for another illegal war like Iraq using fake evidence, and we ban all counter evidence as "foreign propaganda". Do you not see how dangerous that gets?

>That, for me, is enough of a reason to ban it and justify it under our constitution

The Supreme Court has explicitly ruled in the past foreign propaganda is protected speech under First Amendment.

You cannot strip American citizens' rights to receive foreign propaganda if they choose to do so.

Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by drawkward on Thursday January 16, 2025 @07:34AM (#42724388)
You left a few words off in my first quote. I did not say anything about banning propaganda! I am talking about the system of dissemination, not its content.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by Zak on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @11:40PM (#42721305)
What criteria define social media that's ban-worthy for you? Does it require the combination of user-generated content and a personalized algorithmic feed which characterizes modern corporate social media, or do you extend it to a broader range of ways people can interact over the internet?
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by drawkward on Thursday January 16, 2025 @07:36AM (#42724398)
I'm not a lawyer, and therefore I am not qualified to make that kind of definition.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by Zak on Thursday January 16, 2025 @10:05AM (#42726229)
I'm not asking for a legal definition. This is Hacker News; in looking for a definition that would enable hackers to correctly classify things most of the time.
Re:TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday by drawkward on Thursday January 16, 2025 @11:52AM (#42727724)
I think there is probably some combination of the following aspects:

-Content is user-generated -Content is curated by the company (i.e., users don't have the ability to fully turn off what is shown to them) -Content is not universal (i.e., users don't see the same thing)