News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by insane_dreamer on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @09:18PM (#42395491)
What surprises me is that while WhatsApp has become an "everything" app in many parts of the world, much like WeChat in China, it has not done so in the US. In fact, I don't know anyone in the US who uses WhatsApp "internally" (the only times I use it is to communicate with people outside the US).

The description of WhatsApp here is exactly what Elon wanted X to become (which clearly didn't and almost certainly now won't happen). But I'm curious as to why such as "super-app" hasn't taken root in the US like it has elsewhere.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by itikasp on Thursday December 12, 2024 @01:25AM (#42396738)
Hi, I am one of the editors of this story, and we have also thought about this. In my opinion, one of the reasons why WhatsApp hasn't become the "everything app" in the US is because Apple/iOS devices are very popular in the country, where as in much of the world, Android is popular thanks to the availability of cheaper devices. Apple offers a suit of apps and features, including Facetime, that's not available for Android users, which adds to the popularity of WhatsApp.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by brudgers on Friday December 13, 2024 @03:35PM (#42412121)
Facetime was announced as an intended open standard. Shortly, Apple realized their advantage of keeping it closed.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Uehreka on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:44PM (#42419316)
Idk how much of an advantage this has turned out to be. Like GP said, FaceTime is not as popular outside of the US because it isn’t on Android. Even its US popularity is limited by the fact that it doesn’t work with Android/PC users, mandating that you have another app (which likely works as well as FaceTime) on hand for those situations. I think this is more of an example of them shooting themselves in the foot for no advantage, but not caring because they have like 300 feet.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Jtsummers on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:06PM (#42419439)
A patent lawsuit kept them from opening it up at the time. I think it's only recently been resolved.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by viraptor on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:06PM (#42420141)
This is such a weird claim getting repeated. If they were infringing, opening the protocol wouldn't change that fact. They didn't even have to provide the client for other platforms, so their unit count wouldn't be increased for damages.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by toast0 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:18PM (#42420205)
As a matter of policy, I avoid looking into details of patents, but from the title, I thought the patent was about something the server does, routing or something? In which case, infringement or licensing would scale with the number of users, not the number of shipped clients.

This was around the same time that Apple was charging for OS upgrades, at least on Mac, and I think they wouldn't have wanted to pay for something they were providing for free.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by viraptor on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:51PM (#42420351)
Making the protocol a standard doesn't mean they have to accept every client. They already restrict that.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by toast0 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:56PM (#42420379)
Making it an open standard and then not accepting any clients but their own is an option I didn't even consider.

Not sure it would help them build their network, but I guess it's an option.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Jtsummers on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:13PM (#42420177)
Jobs' statement at the time was the intent to make it a published standard. If that standard was patent encumbered (or could be claimed to be, as the suit did) then it would be pretty hard to convince other people to implement that standard, and difficult to get a standards body to actually publish it. Why would Google, MS, or anyone else implement something if it'd get them bogged down in the same lawsuits Apple was already dealing with?
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by viraptor on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:50PM (#42420344)
There's lots of standards covered by patents. Gif included https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GIF
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Jtsummers on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:54PM (#42420373)
Yes, which is a great example of a patent encumbered standard creating problems for people implementing the standard.

Considering FaceTime postdates the GIF experience, I'm sure plenty of corporate lawyers understood the problem much better.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by loloquwowndueo on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:41PM (#42419298)
An interesting tidbit is that WhatsApp actually predates FaceTime and iMessage, and thus it was one of the earliest iPhone apps that allowed sending text messages over data as opposed to SMS. Interoperability with Android was a plus.

I was tremendously pissed off when I moved from a BlackBerry (with blackberry messenger and “free over data” messaging) to an iPhone in 2008 and had to go back to paying per sms sent. The moment WhatsApp became available I got it (and paid for it!) and have been using it ever since.

I wonder what other iPhone users did for data messaging before iMessage became available.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by epx on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:56PM (#42419382)
At least here in Brazil, WhatsApp consolidated its position by working well in feature phones that ran J2ME and dominated the low-end market before Android. It took testing and adaptation to each and every available phone (as far as I can remember, J2ME was kind of a loose standard so developing a J2ME on one device did not guarantee it ran well, or at all, in any other). This, coupled with the possibility of eliding the outrageous SMS rates and the availability of EDGE data plans.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by toast0 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:11PM (#42420166)
WhatsApp ran on Nokia S40, which is J2ME, but it did not run on other J2ME phones (unless there was some way to put the s40 app bundle on them? I never heard about that).

There was a period of time where someone was selling low end phones with an unauthorized and incomplete client built in... In addition to not supporting group messages, it apparently had a backdoor to remote send spam.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:03PM (#42419420)
I found it surprising at the time that instant messaging apps that originated on PCs (ICQ, AIM, Skype, etc...) did not get widely adopted for this role despite most of the well-known ones releasing iOS and Android versions at the time.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by hocuspocus on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:18PM (#42419860)
ICQ and AIM were pretty much dead already.

Microsoft really missed an opportunity, I remember using a third party app for Messenger and the mobile experience wasn't great. Skype was too focused on voice and video calls, not seen as an instant messaging app, even though it could very well have been.

The biggest fumble really comes from Google though. I was using Google Talk as my main messaging app on PC, and Android had pretty much everything ready before iOS, including video chat over 3G.

However Google went through a pointless revamp with Hangouts and never managed a convincing SMS integration.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by jamesrr39 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:35PM (#42420282)
The amount of perfectly functional messaging apps Google has gone through is crazy[1]. Each Google messaging app (GTalk, Hangouts, Meet, etc) is perfectly functional, but with an endless series of migrations, why would you stay around and every several months/year explain to the non-technical family members how the new version of Google's messaging product works?

Enter Whatsapp, which has been pretty consistent through the years, and of course guess which one people use.

[1]: Of course, it's crazy from a product management perspective - but from a "launch a new product to get the next promotion" perspective...

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:39PM (#42419976)
Hangouts was the default SMS client in Android for a while, and it worked well enough as an SMS client that I never heard anybody complain about it. Much like iMessage, it could upgrade to internet-based messaging if both people in a conversation used it.

Where Google went wrong was bowing to pressure from carriers to stop doing that. Carriers had been much more powerful in the past, and I think Google failed to recognize just how fast their influence was waning.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by hocuspocus on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:58PM (#42420095)
I don't buy it. Google just followed iMessage, only two years later, I don't see why carriers would suddenly have an issue with that. Plus Hangouts has never been a mainstream mobile messaging app, and I was a big user at the time. I worked at Samsung then and I'd bet most Android users never launched Hangouts nor even noticed it was preinstalled.

Google killed the integration in 2017 when they started betting on RCS and Google Messages more seriously.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by ethbr1 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @07:35PM (#42420538)
At the time, Google was in a much weaker position to push against carrier demands, because it didn't have as firm control over Android OEMs.

So it was trying to juggle carrier + OEMs + Android and keep everyone happy.

Anything that upset one party wasn't going to happen. Only in more recent, Samsung/Pixel-centric times has Google had iPhone-like negotiating weight (and will).

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by hocuspocus on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:12PM (#42420722)
But realistically I don't know why any carrier would give a damn about this. In 2013, SMS was already irrelevant in most of the world. And in the US pretty much everyone had had unlimited texting for a while. Encouraging people towards OTT messaging was beneficial to carriers that were now ubiquitously making money on data packages, not texts/calls.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:29PM (#42421034)
End users are not the only customers for SMS. A large number of automated notifications, confirmations, and 2FA codes are sent that way, and carriers get paid for it.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by jorvi on Saturday December 14, 2024 @11:01PM (#42421368)
> End users are not the only customers for SMS. A large number of automated notifications, confirmations, and 2FA codes are sent that way, and carriers get paid for it.

Not just paid, they gouge their enterprise customers for it. Signal did a cost breakdown[0] and of their $13.7 million infra costs, a whopping $6 million is "registration fees".

[0]https://signal.org/blog/signal-is-expensive/

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by hocuspocus on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:44PM (#42421105)
And how is this relevant to Hangouts acting as the default SMS client for a minority of subscribers?
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Saturday December 14, 2024 @10:10PM (#42421199)
If it was nearly every Android device, it wouldn't have been a minority in the mid 2010s.

I don't have an authoritative citation, but complaints from carriers is often reported as the reason Google backed away from the default SMS client decision. Here's one example, but I've seen it from other publications: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/11/rip-google-hangouts-...

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by hocuspocus on Saturday December 14, 2024 @11:37PM (#42421484)
It really was a tiny minority, almost nobody bought Google phones at the time. The vast majority of Android users never even knew of the Hangouts SMS integration.

I had a Nexus 4 and then 5 in 2013 and even though I was a big Hangouts user, I quickly disabled the SMS integration as it served no purpose in my case.

It would be extremely weird for carriers to pressure Google on such a niche feature among Android users when Apple actually pulled it off successfully for the other half of their subscribers.

> Google caved and introduced the standalone Google Messages in the next Android release.

This was more likely motivated by Jibe's acquisition and Google pushing a big revamp of RCS (Universal Profile) at the GSMA.

Ars also forgets to mention Allo. Google's strategy was a complete mess on its own, no need to blame carriers.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Sunday December 15, 2024 @10:11AM (#42423816)
Here's a related story from the period about why Microsoft didn't try something similar with Skype: https://www.pcworld.com/article/447285/why-skype-still-cant-...

I can't help but think carriers were the reason Samsung didn't make Hangouts the default SMS client, which contributed to Hangouts not gaining momentum fast enough, which led to Google acquiring Jibe and launching other chat products.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by hocuspocus on Sunday December 15, 2024 @05:32PM (#42426446)
In retrospect this seems like a silly concern given the Windows Phone market share and how obvious the solution was:

> and once shared-data plans reach critical mass, Verizon and other companies will have an active incentive to encourage the use of messaging services like Skype. More Web-sent data requires a beefier data allotment, after all.

Wasn't that already the case?! I didn't really follow plans available in the US around 2012-2013, but in East Asia and Europe, making subscribers pay more for bigger and faster data packages on LTE is exactly what every carrier was doing.

Regarding Samsung phones, of course Samsung had a good relationship with carriers and would typically be more willing to bend to their will, for instance by delaying and doing staged rollouts of firmware upgrades. However this isn't the main reason here. Samsung was absolutely dominating the Android market, being pretty much the only player making comfortable profit margins on the hardware. On the other hand, Samsung's leadership understood that there was nothing easier than moving from an Android phone to another, and that eventually a big part of the cake would be eaten by Chinese OEMs. Samsung worked hard on building its own brand of phones with One UI and its predecessors. The leadership absolutely hated the fact Google forced so many apps being preinstalled on certified Android phones. Hence people complaining about the number of duplicate apps seen as bloatware, sometimes rightfully so.

I don't think Samsung was afraid carriers would take offense at something as ubiquitous as OTT messaging. Case in point, I had coworkers working on ChatON, our own version of iMessage/FaceTime. This was a flop obviously, which is a bit sad since I believe Samsung had a real chance to acquire KakaoTalk around that time.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Monday December 16, 2024 @12:50PM (#42433374)
The impression I have from period reporting is that American carriers still saw voice and SMS as core businesses and viewed anything that directly tried to transition users away from that as a threat. Including a messaging app on a phone wasn't dangerous if both parties had to have it, but a seamless upgrade from SMS as the default would lead to nobody using SMS.

iMessage was exactly that sort of threat, and articles from the time mention carriers disliking it. Not selling iPhones would have hurt a carrier more than it would have hurt Apple, so their negotiating position was weak.

Google didn't have as tight control over Android as it does now, so carriers could pressure OEMs to not include Hangouts, or at least not make it the default SMS client.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Saturday December 14, 2024 @10:02PM (#42421167)
Did Samsung use a different SMS client by default? I had Nexus and Xperia devices at the time, and they defaulted to Hangouts. If Samsung didn't use it, that approach might not have had much chance of reaching critical mass.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by hocuspocus on Saturday December 14, 2024 @11:46PM (#42421523)
Right, Samsung had its own SMS client.

But even on (near) stock Android, you could easily install the AOSP client, or some third party (Textra was popular somehow).

I'm surprised Sony wouldn't bundle a proper SMS client by default. I thought only Nexus phones and Motorolas would default to Hangouts for a relatively short period, until Google started pushing Messages instead.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by lxgr on Sunday December 15, 2024 @09:34AM (#42423597)
Do you have any details on that being due to carrier pressure?

I remember using Hangouts (and Google Talk before it) with almost everybody in my social circle. It had XMPP interoperability for a while (which let me use it at a computer, even with my phone battery dead, at a time when WhatsApp was available on the phone only) and it otherwise just worked.

I never understood why Google went out of their way as much as they did to kill a perfectly fine product in favor of various alternatives that just looked like yet another WhatsApp clone, including all the deficiencies of that (i.e. being single-device only, not using the existing Google account social network etc.)

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by lotsofpulp on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:30PM (#42419938)
Because WhatsApp was the first with password less-login using SMS login.

It was dead simple to use. You had a phone, installed Whatsapp, it sent you a verification text that it automatically read and verified to ensure you owned that phone number, and that was your “account”.

No user names to remember, no passwords, a completely computer illiterate person could use it, especially if their first device ever was a smartphone.

And it worked amazingly well. And there was no spam. I specifically remember sharing contacts being a pain in the ass until WhatsApp came along.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:47PM (#42420022)
I suppose none of the others, which could have leveraged their existing userbase chose to follow suit because the companies that owned them did not have a way to make money from them. WhatsApp didn't either, but startups weren't expected to.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by ncruces on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:14PM (#42420183)
The initial WhatsApp plan was to charge between $1 and 2€, initially a one time fee paid after a few weeks, then a yearly subscription after one free year.

I kinda wish that had paned out.

It'd still be hundreds of millions of dollars in yearly revenue. Plus businesses.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by hocuspocus on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:19PM (#42420740)
The funny thing is that on Android, I never had to pay the fee as the free trial kept getting extended. Only my friends with iPhones paid for WhatsApp, IIRC on iOS it was upfront too!
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by jorvi on Saturday December 14, 2024 @07:55PM (#42420645)
> An interesting tidbit is that WhatsApp actually predates FaceTime and iMessage, and thus it was one of the earliest iPhone apps that allowed sending text messages over data as opposed to SMS. Interoperability with Android was a plus.

I still remember the "Ping!" app (not Blackberry Ping). Because early iOS was very lackluster with no notification support, every message was a pop-up. And "Ping!" itself had no message history. WhatsApp followed pretty closely after.

Even earlier, people used MSN via eBuddy. Not everyone had a smartphone yet, but at least the whole world was on MSN, so as long as the person without a smartphone was at a PC, you could converse. Someone had to text you "hey, get on eBuddy/MSN" though. Apps could either be foregrounded or dead in the background. There was no background processing aside from privileged apps like Mail or Music. And there was no notification service that could act like an IRC bouncer and wake up your backgrounded application. Medieval times.

Also, back then almost no one was using data, texting / calling was still the major cash cow of providers, so you often got unlimited data for very cheap.

Funnily enough that "unlimited data for cheap" later led to a pretty big scuffle between providers and clever people who rolled over their contract indefinitely. Legally providers had to keep providing them with unlimited internet. The trick they did to push customers to renew their subscription was only providing them with 2G or 3G data (depending on their contract) and also limiting their speeds to the lowest tier. One provider even went as far as squeezing them on band access.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by orf on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:52PM (#42419357)
It’s pretty simple: SMS functionality sucked and was super expensive.

Before WhatsApp there was blackberry messenger (BBM). When I was growing up kids were running around with blackberry phones, marketed at businessmen, purely for BBM. WhatsApp was just this, except on a platform that didn’t suck.

WhatsApp also predates iMessage and FaceTime.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by lostlogin on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:11PM (#42419479)
> WhatsApp also predates iMessage and FaceTime.

I was surprised to find this accurate. Though the lineage for a Mac user would likely include Messages and iChat, which go back further.

iChat: 2002 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IChat Messages: 2007 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messages_(Apple) iMessage: 2011 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IMessage WhatsApp: 2009 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/WhatsApp

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by emchammer on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:33PM (#42420275)
Tidbit: The original iChat had an IPv6 link-local messaging function which worked entirely without Internet access or servers.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by steve1977 on Sunday December 15, 2024 @12:53AM (#42421778)
There also was an iChat server for Mac OS X Server IIRC.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by steve1977 on Sunday December 15, 2024 @12:55AM (#42421781)
But those were not mobile services, more like Apple's implementation of ICQ or MSN Messenger.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by akira2501 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:59PM (#42419395)
Do you think it could be that general purpose computers tend to exist as household items here moreso than in other parts of the world? I see my phone as a small extension of a much larger and more capable computing base. Is that view even possible in other parts of the world?
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by mixmastamyk on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:28PM (#42420252)
Most folks no longer need a general purpose computer, like they once did to participate.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by okanat on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:05PM (#42419433)
WhatsApp was there before Apple. There was even Symbian versions of it.

The reason it got so popular in other counties is the extortionate pricing of SMSes. WhatsApp used (and still uses) very little data and with the lowest level data tariff you would still get more messaging quota. Moreover it costed nothing when WiFi on phones became a thing. Then sending pictures for free became a thing too.

They were also a smaller company and it didn't bother people to pay a small amount for all of the benefits they got.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by josu on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:07PM (#42419445)
The US was one of the few countries in the world where there were unlimited SMS plans. So by the time Whatsapp came around instant free messaging was already ubiquitous. This wasn't the case for most other regions, where Whatsapp actually brought free unlimited mobile messaging.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by comprev on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:26PM (#42419913)
WhatsApp was a paid product to start with.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by notahacker on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:48PM (#42420035)
It cost ~$1 (initially a one time fee, later joiners paid annually). Depending on your SMS plan, that might be paid for with the first 10 messages you sent. There was zero additional cost to use to send a lot of messages, including pictures and group messages. This was quite different to most mobile contracts at the time
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by viraptor on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:57PM (#42420089)
It wasn't even enforced though. Charged only after a year, but you could reinstall and get another year free.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by lxgr on Sunday December 15, 2024 @09:25AM (#42423551)
I've used it at that time, and somehow they never managed to actually charge me (and I didn't go out of my way to avoid paying).
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by carlosroman101 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @07:51PM (#42420624)
Not sure how true this is as I had unlimited SMS in the UK in 2000. I struggled to keep that plan as the original provider got bought by O2. Luckily when it happened lots of providers provided enough SMS that was basically "unlimited". The problem for me was the cost of accessing no wap web pages.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by lxgr on Sunday December 15, 2024 @09:25AM (#42423548)
Importantly these also usually included unlimited media messages (MMS) early on.

Flat rate plans in Europe started appearing a bit later and usually never included MMS, so it was calls and texts only, but no photos. WhatsApp changed that.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by theshackleford on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:30PM (#42420264)
Even in my country where iOS reigns supreme, there is very minimal usage of regular SMS/iOS messages functionality. Almost everyone uses some kind of 3rd party app.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by throw310822 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:38PM (#42420299)
> because Apple/iOS devices are very popular in the country

Apple is popular also in Europe, and Android has a 43% market share in the US. But in Europe nobody would use a messaging system that is broken for 40% of their contacts. So either in the US there is no intersection between the social circles of people that use Android vs Apple (highly improbable) or something in the US culture makes people willing to cripple their own experience in order to impose a tax on those in the outgroup.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by immibis on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:29PM (#42421035)
I read a comment recently on Hacker News that a pesticide or herbicide popular in the US and banned in the EU also happened to be an endocrine disruptor in humans, for a hormone responsible for empathy (oxytocin). Don't know if it's true.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by ikr678 on Sunday December 15, 2024 @04:18AM (#42422473)
The 'something in US culture' is conspicuous consumption and a perception that apple are superior and you shouldnt have to go out of your way to interact with poor android users.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by throw310822 on Sunday December 15, 2024 @04:35AM (#42422529)
I wonder if this is somehow related with the healthcare policies: a country where everyone is willing to pay extortionate prices for medical care, sometimes to the point of financial ruin, so that those who are "undeserving" don't get it for free.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by lxgr on Sunday December 15, 2024 @09:27AM (#42423561)
SMS/MMS is free in almost all phone plans in the US, and I have absolutely no trouble believing that people would subject themselves to a very bad messaging experience if that's the default that comes with their phone, as long as it's free.

If I were to come up with a social/economic theory to further back that, my guess would probably be that phone users in the US have a "full service mentality" much more than in the rest of the world:

Buying a phone on a (very expensive) monthly plan that subsidizes the device is much more common than elsewhere, and historically, SIM cards weren't even a thing, so devices were tied to a given network and (to some extent) even a subscriber much more than in the rest of the world.

That would logically extend to people not expecting to have to install a third-party app for what they consider to be "basic phone functionality".

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by jorvi on Saturday December 14, 2024 @07:33PM (#42420529)
WhatsApp has not become the "everything app" in the EU either?

People use it for chatting with people, groups of people, or businesses. Virtually no one uses the Status or Communities feature.

I have 289 people in my phone book right now, 1 of them occasionally posts on Status when on vacation. Of 25 people I quickly checked with, not one of them uses Communities.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by immibis on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:30PM (#42421038)
This. It's just a replacement SMS and phone app. It's not an everything app.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by lxgr on Sunday December 15, 2024 @09:37AM (#42423609)
I vaguely remember hearing that status updates are much more popular in other markets.

I could imagine the same for channels, as WhatsApp is zero-rated on many data plans in the developing world (as well as for in-flight Wi-Fi plans in more and more airlines!), which would make that an economical way of staying up to date on news.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Yeul on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:36PM (#42420816)
Apple could release a fully functional iMessage for Android if they wanted to- hell the EU council would send them a cake if they did that.

One can speculate why they don't.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by hocuspocus on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:40PM (#42420829)
The EU doesn't care. The DMA doesn't apply to iMessage, its market share is too small.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by deergomoo on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:34PM (#42419256)
It seems to be quite variable over the world. WhatsApp is massive here in the UK but pretty much only as a chat app.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Veserv on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:43PM (#42419310)
Payments. The sticky part of "everything" app is the payments platform. With a payments platform you have a internal "funded" ecosystem. Anybody who can not take payments from the "everything" app has a incentive to get inside so they can get paid. In many countries, the "everything" app contains, what in the US would be called, a bank.

This is basically illegal in the USA. US Banks are extremely stringently regulated to the point where many international banks do not even want to take US customers because that would subject them to US laws about banks. That is how insanely challenging it is for literal banks with decades of past and current experience to manage the regulations. "Move fast and break things" would get "Go directly to jail, do not pass go". Even money transmitter licenses like Paypal and Venmo are extremely challenging. And even those companies try really hard to make sure they do not get classified as a bank.

Trying to graft on a social platform onto a bank or a money transmitter would make the entire social platform subject to bank/money transmitter business restrictions which is almost certainly doomed legally. It is not like these companies do not know to add payments, it is just so insanely hard that even the 900 pound gorillas do not want to mess with Godzilla.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by orf on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:46PM (#42419326)
Nope - nobody in Europe uses WhatsApp as a payments platform. Does it even have one?

It succeeded because it was around at the time where SMS messages where expensive, but smart phones where exploding in popularity.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Veserv on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:55PM (#42419376)
WhatsApp is not a "everything" platform in most of Europe. Do you open WhatsApp to play music, games, order takeout, order online, pay for rent? It is just a very popular chat application in most of Europe in contrast to a "everything" app like WeChat where you do all of those things.

[1] https://www.whatsapp.com/payments/in

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by orf on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:04PM (#42419429)
Nope, but by that definition almost no countries have an “everything app”. There’s like, one example in a very unique market?

It’s the “everything app” for messaging, friends and groups.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by dheera on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:16PM (#42419511)
In China, WeChat supports messaging, payments, as well as:

- Booking trains on the national railway

- Booking flights

- Booking hotels

- Paying all your bills

- Buying stuff

- Ordering food

- Renting a bike

- Getting a rideshare

- Seeing a doctor

- Donating to charities

- Investing

- Reading e-books

- Pretty much everything else

A lot of it is done through their HTML5 "mini-app" ecosystem but it's all under one everything app.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by orf on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:17PM (#42419519)
Yes, but the question was “does this exist anywhere other than in China?”

China is a pretty specific and unique market. Perhaps the existence of such an “everything app” is related to that, explaining why it doesn’t exist elsewhere?

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by wenc on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:01PM (#42419771)
Yes, they exist elsewhere. Check out Grab (southeast Asia), Line (Japan, Taiwan), Kakao (Korea), Gojek (Indonesia), PayTm (India) or any number of everything-apps.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by rrr_oh_man on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:22PM (#42419892)
Kaspi in Kazakhstan
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by out_of_protocol on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:59PM (#42419755)
Telegram moving in this direction very fast. At this moment, telegram is used as news, blogs, file transfer app, chat etc. Recently added miniapps with real payments integration, "stars" as internal currency
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by emptysongglass on Sunday December 15, 2024 @10:40AM (#42423984)
You're getting downvoted mysteriously, as this is indeed true. All of Telegram's recent updates have been toward this purpose.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Veserv on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:40PM (#42419642)
Yes, very few countries have a app where you can do "everything" in it. "This clear definition is really hard to achieve, therefore it must mean something different" is not a counter-argument.

I observe that these applications which are everything apps almost always have integrated payments platforms. This is not always the case, but seems to be the stickiest part of the offering. My thesis is that a competitive application with a integrated payments platform will eventually outcompete the ones without. Payments are possible in China with WeChat which is dominant. Payments are possible in India and Brazil with WhatsApp which are their dominant markets.

Counter-examples would take the form of markets/countries where there are multiple-domain applications with payments platforms that rapidly lose or lost marketshare to multiple-domain applications without payments. Markets where no popular application has payments provide no information as to the relative value of a integrated payments platform.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by orf on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:24PM (#42419904)
> I observe that these applications which are everything apps almost always have integrated payments platforms

But this is essentially a sample size of 1?

There’s definitely an advantage to having integrated payments if you want to do “everything” (most of which requires or is related to payment of some kind).

But IMO you’re missing the forest for the trees: adding a payment button to an app is essentially integrated from the PoV of the user - you can do it with Apple Pay or google wallet seamlessly. So why isn’t this good enough?

That lacks payments between friends, so that’s the most important factor? But then in most first-world countries you’re now competing against banks (old and new), who solve this really well, and a myriad of country-specific shit. That’s why they don’t exist.

So really, it’s not just “payments” - it’s becoming the common digital medium of exchange, and that can only happen now for very large, single currency markets that are starting to transition from an unbanked cash based society to a banked one.

You can’t just shove payments onto WhatsApp and expect people to use it to pay their utility bills in a market that has established and seamless ways to do this already. Why would companies make changes to support this?

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Veserv on Saturday December 14, 2024 @07:22PM (#42420486)
Because if you integrate with Apple Pay or Google Wallet then iOS or Android become the platform that delivers tailored applications, not your "everything app". Almost like that is exactly how it currently works in much of the world.

You are arguing in the wrong direction. You think I am arguing that supporting payments is a compelling feature for get customers. So, logically, you just need to add the ability to do payments in some way. My argument is actually that a robust payments platform is the moat needed to prevent your "everything" app from fragmenting by preventing your users from going around or under you. A lower level platform that provides a low friction means of payments for delivered services undercuts the coherency of the higher level platform since applications can be delivered around you.

So your examples actually support my argument. Payment platforms like Apple Pay and Google Wallet attached to their service delivery platforms, the app stores + OS, make it hard to lock people into "everything" apps because the OS is the "everything" app. Efficient inter-account transfers prevent "everything" apps from locking users into their payment ecosystem. If you do not have the payment moat, you are left with actually competing on features and delivery of services which is really hard to do across "everything", so you are better off focusing instead of trying to make a "everything" app.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by lxgr on Sunday December 15, 2024 @09:39AM (#42423619)
Yes, and that's exactly why it's factually incorrect to paint WhatsApp as the "everything app" for either a specific market or even "the world excluding the US".

> It’s the “everything app” for messaging, friends and groups.

I'd call that a "some things app" :)

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by insane_dreamer on Sunday December 15, 2024 @02:43PM (#42425470)
WeChat is most definitely an "everything" app in the sense of this discussion: messaging, shopping, money transfers, bill payments, cab hailing, transportation (planes, trains, etc.), utilities, hospital appointments, customer service, news, etc. etc.

Source: I used it for years in China at the time it evolved into the "everything" app

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Swizec on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:56PM (#42419381)
> It succeeded because it was around at the time where SMS messages where expensive, but smart phones where exploding in popularity.

Not sure that’s true everywhere. In Slovenia we had unlimited texting way before we had smartphones.

By around 2005 all carriers offered a “teenager” plan with unlimited texting and near zero phone minutes. Data was not yet a selling point.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by conradfr on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:55PM (#42419730)
SMS is one part of the story, group messaging is the other one.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Yeul on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:00PM (#42420919)
WhatsApp let you send pictures. They came up with MMS but by then everyone was already on WhatsApp.

Now that I think about it WhatsApp really took the country by storm- the only thing that I can compare it with was Napster and Kazaa. And just like those it was all done by word of mouth! No commercials or ads. It was all organic.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:09PM (#42419466)
WhatsApp appears to support payments in India, and nowhere else.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Veserv on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:23PM (#42419553)
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by meiraleal on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:00PM (#42419764)
The usage of the payment feature in Brazil is very, very low. I never heard about anyone using it. The Central Bank launched a national payment system (Pix) at the same time whatsapp wanted to launch their solution so they made Meta wait a few more months to get authorization. Now everybody uses Pix.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by immibis on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:31PM (#42421048)
Meanwhile no-KYC cryptocurrency exchange sites are mostly hosted by or proxied through Cloudflare, a US company.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Barrin92 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:58PM (#42419392)
>But I'm curious as to why such as "super-app" hasn't taken root in the US like it has elsewhere.

because there's a lot more traditional banking and business infrastructure in the US or Europe than there is in China or India, so the latter just leapfrogged over it and the experience of using Alipay or running your business of Whatsapp is just much better than any legacy institution in those countries. People in countries with more established ways of doing things are both too used to and don't have that much of an incentive to switch because most stuff works sort of okay.

Same reason why WhatsApp adoption itself is lower in the US and sms based messaging held out so long. The US had cheap sms plans earlier so people were less eager to switch while everyone else just jumped to internet based messaging.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:00PM (#42419402)
I'm reasonably confident WhatsApp never caught on in the USA because most American phone plans had unlimited SMS in the early 2010s when WhatsApp's popularity was growing elsewhere. International messaging was probably also a big driver in Europe, but less relevant in other markets.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by hocuspocus on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:05PM (#42419434)
International messaging is still relevant in many parts of the world that don't necessarily need to message neighboring countries, but have a big diaspora.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Zak on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:14PM (#42419500)
Sure. Americans with close or many international contacts almost certainly use an internet-based chat/voice app with those contacts. That's not a large enough percentage than any one messaging app is a viable option for a group chat involving a dozen randomly-selected Americans. Almost every time, one or two of them will steadfastly refuse to install any app and insist on using MMS.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by toast0 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:26PM (#42420243)
Yeah, but the US is pretty insular. Times are different now, but my grandparents who immigrated basically didn't communicate with the old country in my lifetime.

If roughly 15% of the US population is immigrants [1], and not all of them communicate across borders, and very few non-immigtants communicate cross borders there's not a whole lot of demand for a product that reduces costs of cross border messaging in the US.

As an early employee if anyone knew about WhatsApp, they almost certainly were a younger immigrant. Everyone else was like 'why would I use that?, I have unlimited texts' or they were using BBM.

[1] https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2024/09/27/u-s-immig...

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by kazen44 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:47PM (#42420025)
yes, roaming coasts where still a thing inside the EU, so messaging relatives or friends while on holiday sucked because of the enormous pricing for roaming. (even while using SMS!. I remember paying rougly 30 euros to send a couple of hundred text messages and have a couple of minutes ( like half an hour or something) while on holiday in france.

thankfully, roaming got abolished in the first half of the 2010's thank to an EU directive, but at that time whatsapp was already very large across the EU.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by vladvasiliu on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:30PM (#42421039)
Roaming is abolished but not international fees.

This means we now have this funny situation where if you’re abroad, sending international texts or calls is included in your plan. But if you’re in your own country, calling or texting someone in a different country is not.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by crazygringo on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:19PM (#42420216)
You are correct, this is exactly the reason.

Other countries charged per SMS so everyone had good reason to use an app instead.

The US didn't charge, so why would anyone download an app?

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by oefrha on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:05PM (#42420695)
> The US didn't charge

More like charged so exorbitantly up front so there’s no reason to additionally charge per use. My AT&T phone bill in the early 2010s was ~$80 as a single line or ~$50 per line as part of a family, which was several times over what I paid elsewhere with per-minute/text pricing. I later switched to a cheap MVNO (PureTalk) which did charge per text.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by ethbr1 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @07:23PM (#42420488)
The US did have SMS caps/charges, but pre-2008-iPhone+AppStore. (from memory)

Consequently, I don't remember much of a timespan when US customers had both (a) SMS caps/charges and (b) smartphones with open-enough app stores to distribute something like WhatsApp.

For much of the rest of the world, including international communication, that was a more extended period.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by ianburrell on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:33PM (#42420274)
Another reason is that the Nokia Symbian and Series 40 phones weren't popular in the US.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by lxgr on Sunday December 15, 2024 @09:13AM (#42423471)
It’s that, and the fact that MMS is still not free on most plans (if it even is still available; I know operators that just don’t support it, because nobody uses it).
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Mond_ on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:01PM (#42419404)
This isn't really what an "everything app" is. WhatsApp is a chat app (+ some barebones community stuff, which Telegram and Discord also have).

To be an everything app, it needs to have, at the very least, a built-in payment system, fully featured social media content (ie. proper feeds and comments, at least on the level of Twitter), and non-trivial integration with other apps, businesses, and/or government entities. (This isn't even getting into eg. paying rent, ordering takeout, playing games, etc.)

Calling WhatsApp is just kind of missing the point of the definition.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by spookie on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:30PM (#42419940)
Yeah I fear this is the case really. At most, WhatsApp is a way to communicate with businesses while keeping a separation of concerns for those running them.

It is simply better than SMS and is dead simple. You can have a business app that makes this be a separate thing from your personal life while using the same phone.

I have seen it used as a way to contact restaurants or local stores, order stuff, but that was the extent of it. Just communication, nothing else.

For me, at least, it has only been the messaging app I'm willing to use to be in touch with non-techie friends.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by dheera on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:05PM (#42419435)
For one, in other countries, people are perfectly okay with doing real business over a messaging app. I saw a doctor in Indonesia once and everything from appointment scheduling to follow up with the doctor was done on WhatsApp. They were okay sending medical tests, records, and bills on WhatsApp as well.

In China, same thing, on WeChat.

In the US, they want you to register some stupid MyHealth thing, sign some paper documents, and mail follow up shit to your residential address. They won't give you medical records on anything other than a fucking CD-ROM, even in 2024. Somehow in the US, a messaging app isn't "official" enough, and there's going to be the one first amendment brat* that doesn't want to install WhatsApp for privacy reasons.

* I say this jokingly, and do think we need to be harsher on corporations. However, my point is that in collectivist countries like Indonesia/China, if you don't install WhatsApp/WeChat or whatever is the chosen national app, you'll be the outcast and nobody will help you. The collectivist societies tend to embrace these apps for their convenience, rather than question their terms and conditions.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by tuna74 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:21PM (#42419878)
"In the US, they want you to register some stupid MyHealth thing, sign some paper documents, and mail follow up shit to your residential address. They won't give you medical records on anything other than a fucking CD-ROM, even in 2024. Somehow in the US, a messaging app isn't "official" enough, and there's going to be the one first amendment brat* that doesn't want to install WhatsApp for privacy reasons."

That is because you don't have any good online ID authenticator. Something like BankId in Sweden is so incredibly practical in a lot of ways.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by dheera on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:29PM (#42419927)
bankid.com: "To get a BankID, you must have a Swedish personal identity number"

What do non-citizens use in Sweden to get around?

The "everything apps" of places that have them aren't usually restricted to only citizens (though some admittedly have shitty UIs for non-citizens)

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by wasmitnetzen on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:42PM (#42420000)
Everyone who's a permanent resident in Sweden gets a personal identity number, it's not tied to your citizenship. That would be illegal anyway, at least for citizens of other EU countries.

There's a lower-level, different number, which is less powerful, but easier to get.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by messe on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:50PM (#42420046)
> Everyone who's a permanent resident in Sweden gets a personal identity number, it's not tied to your citizenship

Same in Denmark too. You get a "CPR" number, and can login to most government services (as well as some commercial ones) with "MitID" (my ID). It's quite convenient. I can even use my MitID to buy alcohol without having to interact with another human being in Rema 1000 using their self-checkout app.

Ireland—where I moved from—has a similar "PPS" number that all residents can get, although the online aspect is not nearly as well integrated as it is here in Denmark; it's slowly improving.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by immibis on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:35PM (#42421066)
What is a collectivist country?
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by NoLinkToMe on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:07PM (#42419450)
It’s the first time I hear that Whatsapp is already an everything app. Ive used Whatsapp for about 14 years or so on a daily basis as my main app. But it’s just chat for me, and about 30% of my non-professional calls. And I use the share location feature a lot when meeting friends. But that’s about it.

But banking, social media, ID/login, maps, albums, browsing etc I all do outside of whatsapp.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by viraptor on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:12PM (#42420168)
Yup, that claim went a bit far. I mean, the company account API exists and you can do buttons and automation and lots of companies do support this way. (All my contact with Dell support was over WhatsApp) So the tech is there, but the actual deployment of it isn't that big.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by inemesitaffia on Sunday December 15, 2024 @04:45AM (#42422569)
Depends on your country.

A particular banking service option I use is only available on WhatsApp

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by insane_dreamer on Sunday December 15, 2024 @02:40PM (#42425458)
Here's where the comparison with WeChat maybe breaks down.

I lived in China for years, right during the time that WeChat (WeiXin) came out and evolved to become the "everything" app (vanquishing Weibo and others).

But I've only used WhatsApp for text messages and didn't even know that it had all these other features until I read this article.

So maybe it isn't really comparable to WeChat in that sense -- or maybe it is, I don't really know actually.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by richardw on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:08PM (#42419462)
[delayed]
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by wenc on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:10PM (#42419819)
This is why travel is so important -- it gets us out of our bubbles.

Once I was brainstorming with a German colleague about a new business chat feature, and he said we should target WhatsApp as a channel. My American colleagues were like, "No one uses that these days."

But Americans have little idea how popular WhatsApp really is in Europe, and Brazil (where it's colloquially called Zappy Zappy), and vast swaths of the world. The American experience isn't as normative as we assume. I only know this because I'm part of a diaspora network and I have contacts from all over the world -- FB Messenger and iMessage are not as popular as we think outside of certain high GDP countries.

Conversely, some suggested targeting iOS in Germany, but my German colleague immediately said that iOS marketshare in Germany is actually fairly low. That surprised me but he was right.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/461900/android-vs-ios-ma...

Even France, with its reputation for liking premium products, does not have a high iOS market share.

Japan does have a very high iOS market share however because they appreciate craftsmanship, and due to Softbank's efforts in the country.

I remember the early days of WhatsApp -- it was the non-SMS messaging platform of choice in an era when phone plans changed for texting.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by spookie on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:44PM (#42420011)
Apple devices cost more in Europe, a jump high enough that you might as well consider the competition. I'm taking VAT into account.

That and, well... Google has been more supportive of EU countries than Apple. Apple maps was useless in the EU for a long time. Plus horrendous support across the EU. If you are in a big city, yeah you will find an Apple Store, otherwise tough luck.

It has nothing to do with craftmanship.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by vladvasiliu on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:25PM (#42421023)
I think the only point that stands is the price. Apple products are indeed more expensive in France than in the US.

However, Google Maps runs fine on iOS and you can purchase Apple products from other retailers and they will also handle warranty claims. None of my Apple products were bought from an Apple Store.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by spookie on Sunday December 15, 2024 @10:18AM (#42423853)
In my country I would only find such retailers in one of the big 3 cities.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by shafyy on Saturday December 14, 2024 @07:34PM (#42420535)
> Japan does have a very high iOS market share however because they appreciate craftsmanship

Citation needed

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by happymellon on Sunday December 15, 2024 @04:12AM (#42422456)
Which part of that claim; that Japanese appreciate craftsmanship, or that iOS is crafted?
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by bloody-crow on Sunday December 15, 2024 @05:17AM (#42422655)
I suspect they're asking for a citation establishing a correlation between high iOS market share and craftsmanship appreciation.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by shafyy on Sunday December 15, 2024 @07:47AM (#42423154)
Yes, that's what I meant.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by Scoundreller on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:45PM (#42420327)
> FB Messenger and iMessage are not as popular as we think outside of certain high GDP countries.

Always funny when someone puts an AirTag in their luggage and wonders why they get few updates in a developing country.

Uhhhh, yeah, their average baggage handler and airport employee doesn’t have an iPhone, that’s why.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by throwaway2037 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:53PM (#42420884)
How close does an AirTag need to be to an iPhone to get an update?
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by steve1977 on Sunday December 15, 2024 @12:50AM (#42421762)
> Japan does have a very high iOS market share however because they appreciate craftsmanship

Yeah that's probably not the case.

Sent from my Sony Xperia 1 VI

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by wenc on Sunday December 15, 2024 @02:21AM (#42422071)
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by narrator on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:56PM (#42420078)
Being the rare American Android person, I use it, Signal and Telegram to communicate with Iphone people since IMessage SMS integration is badly crippled.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by madeofpalk on Saturday December 14, 2024 @06:43PM (#42420321)
> The description of WhatsApp here is exactly what Elon wanted X to become

I don't know what an "everything app" is, but that's not my experience with WhatsApp in Europe. It's just how you text or call everyone or businesses, but there's no payments or anything else going on beyond perhaps the occasional business chatbot. But even then, most 'businesses' I interact with over WhatsApp is just some person with a phone.

Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by insane_dreamer on Sunday December 15, 2024 @02:46PM (#42425491)
I think Elon's target was WeChat, and the article implied that WhatsApp had essentially the same functionality as WeChat, but that may not actually be the case, or maybe only in some countries like Brazil.
Re:WhatsApp became an unstoppable cultural force by 1123581321 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:41PM (#42420831)
When Facebook bought WhatsApp, either Facebook or WhatsApp was the top social network in just about every country. It was a critical purchase for Facebook that locked out competitors globally for years. I can’t find the map now; if anyone knows what I’m talking about I hope they can share it.

Free or cheap texting hamstrung WhatsApp’s growth in some countries like the US. It was better in countries where cell plans were expensive because data didn’t meter per communication like SMS and WhatsApp was efficient.

WhatsApp isn’t an everything app like WeChat.