News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by kulahan on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:47PM (#41862388)
I've been saying for years that we'll know the world is serious about energy when we see big pushes into nuclear power. We're here now. This is the point at which all the dumb "but what about a gorillion turbines and solar panels" start to die off (except for where they're legitimately a great solution) and talk about the only viable power source moving forward will start to grow. This is super exciting to me.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by DCH3416 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:21PM (#41862804)
> "but what about a gorillion turbines and solar panels"

It's a good thing to have a diverse portfolio of energy solutions to help avoid single points of failure in the network. Especially as something like solar continues to become more and more efficient.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by fraboniface on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:35PM (#41863573)
I don't really understand this argument. How are dozens of nuclear power plants a single point of failure? Because of the uranium mining and processing? Then we can invest in fast reactors, which consume 100x less and require less R&D than renewables have benefited from in the last decades. Or seawater uranium, another 100x in reserves, distributed all around the world.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:03PM (#41863845)
> How are dozens of nuclear power plants a single point of failure?

https://www.wired.com/story/nuclear-power-plants-struggling-...

"Amidst a slow-burning heat wave that has killed hundreds and sparked intense wildfires across Western Europe, and combined with already low water levels due to drought, the Rhône’s water has gotten too hot for the job. It’s no longer possible to cool reactors without expelling water downstream that’s so hot as to extinguish aquatic life. So a few weeks ago, Électricité de France (EDF) began powering down some reactors along the Rhône and a second major river in the south, the Garonne. That’s by now a familiar story: Similar shutdowns due to drought and heat occurred in 2018 and 2019. This summer’s cuts, combined with malfunctions and maintenance on other reactors, have helped reduce France’s nuclear power output by nearly 50 percent."

France is about the best existing case for nuclear, incidentally.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Manuel_D on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:57PM (#41864250)
The issue outlined above is a problem for all thermal plants. Coal and gas plants would suffer from the same issue.

Furthermore, nuclear plants don't need to be cooled with potable water. They can be cooled with ocean water, or with waste water. In fact, seawater cooling is the most popular form of cooling. Only 15% of nuclear plants are cooled with river water.

https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-and-fu....

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by numpad0 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:04PM (#41864783)
Off topic question. Can a large nuclear reactor be completely air-cooled? I think a full-scale reactor cluster expelling hot jet upwards and providing air conditioning in form of negative static pressure to its surrounding megalopolis would be very cyberpunk.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Manuel_D on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:11PM (#41864843)
Air doesn't have much thermal mass, so you'd have to move a lot of air through the heat exchangers to make it work. It's probably possible, but there's much more viable alternatives. In particular, you can use wastewater to cool plants where water is scarce: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palo_Verde_Nuclear_Generating_...
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:20PM (#41864891)
https://www.npr.org/2018/07/27/632988813/hot-weather-spells-...

> Nuclear power plants in Europe have been forced to cut back electricity production because of warmer-than-usual seawater.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Manuel_D on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:39PM (#41864994)
This can be addressed by expanding heat exchangers. Unlike the river water cooling which is constrained by how much the plants are allowed to heat the river.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by numpad0 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:34PM (#41865285)
Primary coolant loop runs at arbitrary temperature, there's never going to be a point that a nuke can't be cooled. It's only matter of designed capacity.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by cryptonector on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:30PM (#41864503)
To be fair, and as a non-fan of wind (kills birds, annoys animals and humans) and solar (lowers the albedo of the planet, denies sunlight to parts of the local ecosystem), wind and solar do not have this cooling requirement. So that's nice. But anyways, you can always use sea water if you have access to the sea, or rely on a geographically-very-large grid for the diversity of sources that GP says we need.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Manuel_D on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:35PM (#41864539)
A geographically large grid will require extensive transmission network upgrades. That has to be factored into the cost competitiveness of these sources.

Renewable generation itself is cheap. But what's expensive (or straight up unfeasible) is everything required to mitigate the intermittent production. Storage at the scale of tens of terawatt hours can't even be feasibly built with current technologies. Moving electricity over thousands of miles, across mountain ranges, would require HVDC lines to be constructed in very rugged terrain.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by cryptonector on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:36PM (#41864553)
Europe's and the U.S.'s grids are geographically large.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Manuel_D on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:39PM (#41864582)
Correct, but most generation is still produced close to demand. If you look at a map of where power plants are located (https://synapse.maps.arcgis.com/apps/dashboards/201fc98c0d74...) you'll see they're concentrated near cities. The grid spans a large area, but most energy is transmitted over a short distance.

Renewables, due to their low energy density and specific weather requirements, need to be built in remote areas. This has led to situations where the grid cannot accommodate transmitting the amount of energy that proposed renewable plants will produce: https://www.vox.com/videos/22685707/climate-change-clean-ene...

People often cite the decentralized nature of renewables as an advantage. It's not. It's a significant disadvantage as it has a much bigger burden on the transmission infrastructure.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Log_out_ on Thursday October 17, 2024 @01:48AM (#41866769)
Could part of that waste heat be transfered underground so that a city could use it as a differential source for heatpumps?
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by oakwhiz on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:39PM (#41864109)
It's possible to use "dry cooling" for a nuclear reactor. [1][2] The thermodynamic efficiency would be much lower, but it is possible to use alternative thermodynamic cycles/methods, for example reactors sent into space have used radiative cooling since there is no realistic way to use fluids to finally reject the heat.

1. http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2018/ph241/duboc2/

2. https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/current-and-fu...

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by cryptonector on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:33PM (#41864527)
So basically radiators. They would have to be huge, and they would have to move huge amounts of air through them. As a backup that might work, probably using a hybrid where a water body is used for cooling and air is the fallback.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by kjkjadksj on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:19PM (#41863947)
Thats one of the shortcomings of using a river with variable flow over an ocean or large lake
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Loughla on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:25PM (#41863994)
Ocean yes, but then that opens you up to hurricanes and/or tsunamis.

Lakes can dry up. So that's no better than a river I would think.

Either way, there are no fully safe and permanent sources of cooling water, is what I'm taking away from this.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by kjkjadksj on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:18PM (#41864408)
Certain lakes aren’t going to dry up within human timescales. And disaster risk is present in a lot of places. Just something you take into account when you build it.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by addaon on Thursday October 17, 2024 @12:47AM (#41866488)
> Certain lakes aren’t going to dry up within human timescales.

Which ones? The North American Great Lakes, maybe? Anything else?

The Aral Sea was the third largest lake in the world. Within the human time scale of the last six decades, it's lost 90% of its area.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by kjkjadksj on Thursday October 17, 2024 @01:28PM (#41871682)
Aral sea was milked for agriculture. Not all lakes are like that.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by panick21_ on Thursday October 17, 2024 @05:22AM (#41867817)
Air-cooling is possible. This only effect certain type of reactor. As soon as you go to higher temp reactor air-cooling is very efficient.

And even in France this was only a problem because of their terrible delayed maintenance.

> France is about the best existing case for nuclear, incidentally.

No it isn't. France has done essentially nothing for 30+ years. Has done little maintained, their reactors aren't up to date.

The generation after the generation that built the reactor has always resented the system and wanted to rip it out. They literally decided to retire it by 2035 despite having no plan to replace it.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ceejayoz on Thursday October 17, 2024 @06:14AM (#41868116)
> No it isn't. France has done essentially nothing for 30+ years. Has done little maintained, their reactors aren't up to date.

I mean, we aren’t disagreeing.

They’re the best case, and that’s not great. It a bit like true communism - real success is just over that next hill.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by robryan on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:40PM (#41863631)
The problem is more our lack of ability to build them quickly and in a cost effective way. An investment in solar will much more reliably and quickly turn into a certain amount of power generation.

Hopefully this changes once every nuclear project isn't some complex bespoke thing that is likely to be late and over budget.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by panick21_ on Thursday October 17, 2024 @05:24AM (#41867835)
And yet UAE a country without any technical knowlage built them in a cost effective way and quickly.

In fact, any country that has built them in mass figured out how to do it cost effective and quickly.

The reality is, its only not cost effective and quick when a country only builds a single reactor as a vanity project to keep the industry alive.

No country that seriously tried to quickly increase production with nuclear has failed.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ceejayoz on Thursday October 17, 2024 @07:37AM (#41868642)
The UAE spent $30B and a decade building one nuclear plant. The technical knowledge (and the design, and the construction) came from South Korea.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:41AM (#41870129)
The true costs are unknown. All we have is the announced figure and then two parties with an interest in showing low costs despite a 4 year delay saying

"Yes sir, all went according to plan!!"

Even though it obviously did not all go according to plan.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by threeseed on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:21PM (#41863963)
And who is going to pay for all of this R&D and investment.

The market doesn't want it, banks don't want to finance it, researchers aren't interested and startups can't afford to.

You can't fight against market dynamics when you're talking about capital expenditure this high.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by fraboniface on Thursday October 17, 2024 @02:54AM (#41867078)
This has indeed been a big blocker, but the article is proof that the market now wants it. And there are plenty of new nuclear startups, as well as interested researchers. What was lacking so far was a real need energy-wise (in the absence of a high carbon tax) and regulatory stability/transparency.

Edit: also, sodium fast reactors have existed for 20 years. The R&D has mostly already been done for that tech. But the lack of projects make it stuck to TRL 8.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by datadeft on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:20PM (#41863954)
Isn’t solar energy a SPOF? It goes to zero MW roughly every 12 hours at any given location on Earth where most people live due to the availability of the Sun’s light.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by hoherd on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:23PM (#41863982)
Maybe, but at what cost? There is no such thing as "solar fallout". Doesn't the SPOF come with the trade-off of incredibly low risk of causing long term high-mortality rates of all life in the surrounding area?
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by numpad0 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:57PM (#41864726)
Solars go first in any disasters and there's cleanup cost of destroyed panels, so there is such thing as solar fallout. They also don't decay unlike radioactive fallout.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by dalyons on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:35PM (#41864968)
that... is not even close to comparable. A hurricane smashes a bunch of your local panels, you go and pick them up, and if they're too damaged throw them in landfill. Fukushima is going to cost between $470 billion and $660 billion to clean up. A solar "cleanup" would not even be a 10000th of that cost. Why even mention this?
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by numpad0 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:54PM (#41865089)
It is. They just don't take a lot of weather, so they're not more than disposable subsidy capture device if you live in places that storms and flying debris are normal. Solar panels are glasses painted with heavy metal stained glasses, so you can't leave the panels around, they have to be recovered.

All moot points if they last indefinitely where you are, serious points if they don't.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by nine_k on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:20PM (#41862797)
Wind and especially solar are also serious. But their applications are different; they can offset the load when the sun shines, or the wind blows, but can't provide a stable source.

If you need baseload, and need it carbon-free, your only option currently is nuclear. It's terribly encumbered, but apparently it's still less of an impasse that large-scale electricity storage currently is.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by _aavaa_ on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:09PM (#41863311)
> they can offset the load when the sun shines, or the wind blows, but can't provide a stable source.

That they don't work when the sun doesn't shine or the wind doesn't blow is such a tired and trite remake.

Yes, they don't provide consistent output on their own, but storage exists. If you need electricity store it in batteries or pumped hydro. If you need it for heating store it in thermal batteries.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by tonyedgecombe on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:19PM (#41863416)
Grid connected batteries are only viable for a short duration, they aren’t going to help when you don’t have any wind for two weeks.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:06PM (#41863865)
When's the last time the North Sea had no wind for two weeks?
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by nazgul17 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:39PM (#41864100)
Not everyone can use energy from the North Sea.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:04PM (#41864785)
Thankfully, it’s not the only reliably windy spot on the planet.

Especially on continent-sized electrical grid scales. We put the farms in windy spots, and we pick a variety of spots.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ImJamal on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:17PM (#41864393)
Can the North Sea wind provide enough for 100 million people?
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:09PM (#41864813)
Almost certainly yes. The Dogger Bank farm alone powers six million, and we’ve hardly filled the entire sea with turbines.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by tonyedgecombe on Thursday October 17, 2024 @09:32AM (#41869518)
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ceejayoz on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:31AM (#41870037)
If you dig a little deeper than an industry front quoting the WSJ, "stop" there means "10-20% less than usual" https://climate.copernicus.eu/esotc/2021/low-winds
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by tonyedgecombe on Saturday October 19, 2024 @05:40AM (#41886763)
You still need to cover that 10-20% less.

Try doing the figures, we can't scale batteries to cover these drops.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Teever on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:37PM (#41863598)
Is that a thing where they build wind farms? Like are there any wind farms where it is likely to occur with any regularity?

In my region wind generation dipped down to only 1pc of capacity for a day or two last winter which seems to be the floor as far as I can tell.

That tells me that we only need to increase capacity by 100x to get the coverage we want, and as a bonus we get all that surplus capacity most of the time to use on non-essential industry.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Rebelgecko on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:50PM (#41863738)
>Yes, they don't provide consistent output on their own, but storage exists

I think this varies depending on where you live. In California, Cal-iso has a really cool dashboard that seems to show that they have enough battery storage to hold about 90 minutes of daytime solar generation.

Definitely not something that can handle a fully cloudy day yet (presumably it's cheaper to keep some natty gas plants ready to spin up or import than to store more excess solar?)

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by _aavaa_ on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:26PM (#41864469)
They do. The good news is that the limit factor on that growth appears to be getting through the grid interconnect queue rather than a lack of people willing to pay to build them: https://emp.lbl.gov/news/grid-connection-backlog-grows-30-20...
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by nine_k on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:53PM (#41864217)
Storage exists, but it's insufficient and expensive.

We need 30x, or maybe 100x more storage. After that, we could live on renewables only, and keep gas-fired plants only as a disaster-recovery tool, like diesels in datacenters.

Until then, we need stable generation which does not spew CO2, which is, well, nuclear. It's hard to tell if ubiquitous cheap utility-scale batteries emerge in 5 years or 50 years.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:10PM (#41864338)
> Storage exists, but it's insufficient and expensive

It’s just insufficient. Solar + storage is cost competitive with nuclear. The problem is we have a bajillion needs for batteries, a Balkanised global market and wholly insufficient production forecasts over the next decade without gas or nuclear support. Voters seem to like gas. Private participants are choosing nuclear where they can.

Good to be a gas exporter for the next half century or so.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by nine_k on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:58PM (#41864730)
It is expensive, almost $100 per kWh stored, plus construction costs that involve fireproofing and spacing things because lithium batteries are flammable. And a lithium battery loses capacity with every recharge, so it needs replacement every few years.

We need batteries that cost, say, $10 / kWh, are not (as) flammable, not toxic (not Pb, not NiCd), and don't degrade too fast.

With that, they can be large, heavy, have low specific charge, require high or low temperatures (within reason), etc. For a large utility-grade installation all these qualities are not hugely important. There is plenty of space under solar panels and around wind turbines anyway.

Before that, selling methane remains a very good business indeed.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by caseyy on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:46PM (#41864635)
There are pumped storage hydro-electric plants with abundant and cheap capacities. They also work and are in use, mostly in China and Japan.

China is building a lot more, too. It will probably have 80% of the world’s energy storage capacity in a decade.

We just don’t talk about them in the West for some reason. I guess battery tech is more appealing somehow but it’s not cheaper nor more environmentally friendly, all in all.

I hope that now once there are some serious users of power, they might build some of these plants, and then governments in the West will wake up to how good the plants are.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by nine_k on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:03PM (#41864775)
It might be easy to build pumped storage in Boulder City, NV, situated among mountains near the Hoover dam. It would be much harder to build something similar near Houston, TX, where the land is flat as a table.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by caseyy on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:13PM (#41865196)
They are grid-wide plants, which don’t need to be near large population centres. Sierra Madres/Rockies offer great elevation gradients in West TX, if one would want to keep it in the state.

This is a consideration but I don’t think it’s the real reason we don’t consider these plants.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:32PM (#41865279)
> are pumped storage hydro-electric plants with abundant and cheap capacities

You’re flooding gorgeous landscape near high property values.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by caseyy on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:39PM (#41865930)
I think this is more likely it. NIMBY is a plausible explanation for both the delays in building these plants and NPPs. Not to mention the guaranteed opposition to whoever suggests them as a politician.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @08:32PM (#41865275)
> are pumped storage hydro-electric plants with abundant and cheap capacities

Cool. Yes. Now scale that by two orders of magnitude.

Here’s the kicker: getting approval to put an SMR in Wyoming is easier than flooding another valley or buying massive contiguous plots. Nuclear, if these guys can execute, which is a big if, promises to be as agile as gas generators. Our current default when we have energy shortfalls.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by caseyy on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:46PM (#41865963)
Well, I cannot currently foresee a situation where we’d need to apply this technology to store several orders of magnitude more energy. Even storing 50% more energy this way in the West would have significant self-reinforcing positive effects on the renewable energy industry.

You might be thinking in an all-or-nothing way. Some solutions don’t need to scale well on cubic scales, etc. Moreover, there is hardly a reason pumped storage power plants can’t be done along side nuclear investment. There isn’t a dichotomy of choice, expanding use of both — or either — would benefit us all.

In fact, there are synergies between pumped storage and nuclear power — pumped storage allows nuclear to more closely meet the peaks and valleys of electricity demand throughout the day.

I think the biggest problem is that the energy sector isn’t making big plant investments due to capitalistic incentives. Why invest into plants if less supply of electricity means a higher unit price, and any state investment into private power companies can go straight into retained earnings/dividend? It would be improving things for technological advancement sake, against investor interests. Things work differently when the power companies are state-owned, of course. But that doesn’t completely flip the script either — technological advancement for advancement sake is still not often pursued. And it’s often even seen as wasteful by the electorate.

If we wanted technological advancement, we have several clear ways to achieve it, even without scaling the current technology exponentially. The problem is that we didn’t want it enough. But now some companies do.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by JumpCrisscross on Friday October 18, 2024 @10:49AM (#41879951)
> I cannot currently foresee a situation where we’d need to apply this technology to store several orders of magnitude more energy

The current baseline power demand forecasts from the DoE and IEA.

> Even storing 50% more energy this way

Is in the broad scheme meaningless. It would still require massively increasing our investment in gas generators.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by caseyy on Saturday October 19, 2024 @11:46AM (#41888466)
I don't think we can scale either fossil fuel energy or renewable energy to several orders of magnitude (10^(2+)x). Do we even have means to extract 100x fossil fuels in the time we currently extract 1x on this planet, and does the planet have enough to sustain that pace for a meaningful time? Do we have the means to manufacture 1,000x solar panels and where do we put them, and how much climate change would that cause alone? Same for other renewables.

I think it's good to think about investing into energy at these scales, it would open a lot of exciting doors for humanity, as Kardashev described. But we are at the very start of this investment and I think we need vastly different novel technologies to think about 100x, 1,000x, 10,000x, etc.

We will probably have to do with what we've got for now.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday October 19, 2024 @06:27PM (#41891267)
> don't think we can scale either fossil fuel energy or renewable energy to several orders of magnitude

To replace fossil fuels we need to scale renewables by an order of magnitude. To do that without nuclear we need to scale storage by orders of magnitude.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by AStonesThrow on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @09:17PM (#41865518)
Hydroelectric dams have a storied history of pissing people off, through death and displacement, at the very least.

My ancestors (along with natives) were run off from their valley home in PA when a dam was built. Out here in the Sonoran Desert, we've got a lake where the river should be, and the indigeneous (among others) are still pissed about the dam that was pretty much politically forced on all of us.

Conversely, there are groups who absolutely rejoice when a dam is decommissioned and demolished. It's party time when that land is reclaimed, and the water flows again naturally.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by caseyy on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @10:02PM (#41865750)
Well, this is about pumped storage hydroelectric plants, which are not dams. These plants aren’t generally built on rivers because they require much larger water reservoirs.

As with any land development, they require land, of course. But all power grid elements do.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 17, 2024 @12:12AM (#41866353)
> this is about pumped storage hydroelectric plants, which are not dams

Damn or not, pumped hydro requires flooding and then unflooding, turning the Alpinesque ecologies into tidal pools. That's disruptive.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by caseyy on Thursday October 17, 2024 @01:00PM (#41871433)
They don't turn Alpinesque ecologies into tidal pools if you don't build them in Alpinesque ecologies.

The truth is that we are developing a lot of land every year for different purposes, from industrial to residential. The question is whether we will develop it for everyone's benefit, or for some yet another tax exempt monopoly's warehouse.

We could even build these plants in place of abandoned industrially exploited land, such as quarries, which conveniently already form quite large water reservoirs. We could reclaim a completely dead parcel of land and once we stop using the reservoir, it could blossom into a set of new natural ecologies.

Don't take the worst case scenario and present it as the only one when there is a world of possibilities.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by JumpCrisscross on Friday October 18, 2024 @10:50AM (#41879961)
> don't turn Alpinesque ecologies into tidal pools

Where do you think large, regular flows of water in natural valleys that can be economically dammed with large gravitational potential energy sit?

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by _aavaa_ on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:11PM (#41864350)
> Until then, we need stable generation which does not spew CO2, which is, well, nuclear.

A nuclear plant in the USA takes oh about 18 years to build. That's 18 years of solar, wind, and storage growth and cheapening.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by barbazoo on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:48PM (#41863097)
> If you need baseload, and need it carbon-free, your only option currently is nuclear

What about geothermal, tidal, hydro, etc?

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by nine_k on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:26PM (#41863495)
Good, given the right geography.

- Hydrothermal: great if you're in Iceland, or near Yellowstone, or other such place blessed by heated rock being close to the surface. Not as great if you need to drill 7 km to reach it.

- Hydro: great if you have a lot of mountains and rivers, like Switzerland or Norway. Harder if you don't, like in much of Texas, to say nothing of Florida.

- Tidal: great if you have a sea shore, preferably with narrow bays / fjords. But if you're in a place like Turkmenistan (one of the two doubly-landlocked countries), you resort to drilling for and burning methane %)

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by bobthepanda on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:41PM (#41863643)
Hydro has a bunch of problems.

* most of the "good sites" have already been taken

* hydro will regularly silt up, requiring constant dredging

* hydro does not work as well or at all in drought conditions, which are increasingly common

* hydro dams require reservoirs, which in addition to the obvious disruption of the displacement of thousands or even a million plus people in the case of Three Gorges, can end up emitting large amounts of carbon as flooded vegetation decomposes.

* hydro is extremely disruptive to migratory fish. the success rate of interventions like fish ladders is in the low single digit percents. so you can get a bunch of carbon free power but also destroy an ecosystem in the process, not to mention any downstream fishing. and you see similar effects with other things that downstream users might want from the river like fresh silt.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by njtransit on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:55PM (#41865102)
Pumped storage hydro solves many of these issues.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by bobthepanda on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @07:58PM (#41865122)
It’s not really baseload without something else, though. And pumped hydro capacity is generally meant for hours or days.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by kulahan on Thursday October 17, 2024 @01:54PM (#41871933)
I agree with all of this. I get annoyed with the conversations surrounding wind and solar, but I don't dislike the techs themselves. They have a place and are great, and solar is mind-bogglingly affordable right now. I've seen utility companies offering them """for free""" (you lease, your electricity covers the cost of lease, no money for extra generated) because it's so cheap now.

But we need, as you said, a baseload. Nobody is really discussing how to create this, they're just saying we should magically invent an incredibly dense battery (more energy-dense than hydrocarbons, ideally, or let's say within 50% as useful) using technologies nobody can even fathom. Meanwhile, we're seeing breakthroughs in fusion tech, miles ahead of the usefulness of fission, which is miles ahead of anything else we have right now.

I just don't understand the aversion to a clean, renewable power source.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by psunavy03 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:20PM (#41862794)
If you're not serious about nuclear, you're not serious about climate change.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by barbazoo on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:49PM (#41863102)
Source?
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by atomic128 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:05PM (#41863258)
Germany is a tragic real-world example.

Take a look at what Germany did to itself. Compare France.

The anti-nuclear wind/solar proponents are dangerously wrong.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by _aavaa_ on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:07PM (#41863282)
That Germany's early retirement of its fleet was a bad idea does not mean that building more is a good idea.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by barbazoo on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:59PM (#41863804)
Germany has been reducing its carbon emissions by increasing the ratio of renewable energy, year after year despite the exit from nuclear power.

https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-energy-c...

Isn't that the goal? If they can do that without nuclear power - great.

Despite France's >50% nuclear power they have a much higher ratio of "dirty" power compared to Germany.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_France

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Manuel_D on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:04PM (#41864308)
Germany's energy industry emits 6 times as much greenhouse gases per MWh of electricity generated than France: https://www.lemonde.fr/en/economy/article/2024/09/08/france-....

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Germany#/media/File:...

Germany's energy is 80% fossil fuels. France's is 50%. I'm not sure how you reached the conclusion that Germany's energy mix is less "dirty" than Frances.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by barbazoo on Thursday October 17, 2024 @11:35AM (#41870635)
> Germany's energy is 80% fossil fuels.

Where did you get that number from?

https://www.iea.org/countries/germany

> Renewables 39.4% share of power generation, 2022

vs. France's 26.1%.

Edit: I guess you might be talking about consumption whereas I'm talking about production.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Manuel_D on Thursday October 17, 2024 @11:43AM (#41870725)
Nuclear power is less "dirty" than most forms of renewables: https://world-nuclear.org/images/articles/0a2091ce-35b3-4ada...

Again, Germany emits 6 times as much C02 for every MWh of electricity generated as France.

It's not an issue of production vs. consumption. You're counting nuclear power, which is heavily utilized by France, as a "dirty" energy source despite the fact that it's cleaner than most renewables.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by scotty79 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @07:54AM (#41868775)
I read that it turned from being large exporter of energy to be large importer.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by lancesells on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:15PM (#41864379)
If you're not serious about energy consumption, you're also not serious about climate change. Unfortunately consumer and business technology wants to go the other way.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by epistasis on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:40PM (#41864584)
Climate change fact #1: CO2 (and to some extent other GHG) is the cause of climate change.

Climate change fact #2: energy consumption is not a cause of climate change, except for when it causes CO2 emission.

Climate change fact #3: reduced CO2 emission will not stop climate change.

Reducing energy usage is a losing climate strategy in three ways 1) it doesn't solve the problem, cutting emissions 50% does jack shit, we need to get to 0% emissions and then negative emissions. 2) It's politically ineffective because only some people and countries will actually reduce emissions. 3) It's political suicide because it validates false anti-climate change propaganda. 4) It's highly socially regressive because these dictates demand that the burden be placed mostly on developing countries.

Reason #1 is enough to disqualify the "reduce energy usage" as a climate strategy, but really there's zero way to look at it and think that there's any validity. Please find better sources and stop spreading this counterproductive idea.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by scotty79 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @07:55AM (#41868781)
Getting rid of CO2 from the atmosphere will take a lot of power. Energy conservation is not the way to go.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by epistasis on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:34PM (#41864536)
More logically, if you're serious about climate change you're not serious about nuclear.

This Amazon investment aims to only have 5GW of nuclear on the grid 15 years from now. That's not a solution to climate change, it's not even a rounding error. It rises to a rounding error on the suddenly discovered need for new energy for AI, but it's a decade late for that. In 15 years, the grid will be completely decarbonized by solar and batteries and wind, existing nuclear/hydro, and probably some new tech like enhanced geothermal. This is 2039 energy environment that nuclear will enter into, and it will have to compete with 15 more years of prices falling on batteries and renewables. SMRs can't compete on price with today's price for new large nuclear, todays new large nuclear can't compete on price with today's solar/wind/batteries, and today's solar/wind/batteries sure as hell won't compete with 15 years of prices falling. SMRs like this have no hope to be a competitive product.

Nuclear has overpromised and underdelivered for 60 years. We should have kept existing plants running. If our anscestors had lit money on fire to produce a bunch of reactors 40 years ago, we'd be in a much better position.

But we'd also be in a much better position had they not pooh-poohed solar and made bigger investments sooner, driving forward solar revolution by 15-30 years from where it is now.

We'd have been in a much better position if there had been a massive investment in battery technology 15-30 years earlier, making EVs feasible sooner, and revolutionizing the grid with storage sooner.

Solar and batteries will be the foundation of the future, because they are technology that gets cheaper the more we invest in them. Nuclear might be around in 50 years, maybe not, but it won't be any cheaper or more affordable. It's a technology that barely moves the more we spend on it, and can sometimes be economically efficient in the best of cases. But the average case for building nuclear is big price overruns, and it's not uncommon for utilities to be brought to the point of bankruptcy.

We have better technology available, today, to be deployed. Let's do it. Nuclear is a pipe dream from people that haven't run the numbers, or have run the numbers they have gotten them drastically wrong. The entire history of nuclear energy in this country is of people not running the numbers or running the numbers and getting them drastically wrong.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by threeseed on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:56PM (#41862525)
There are no big pushes into nuclear power. These are all tiny deployments that may never even happen.

And those dumb turbines and solar panels produce power at a fraction of the cost of nuclear. And every year they get cheaper and more efficient. Which is why the market has continually decided over and over again to go in this direction.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by nine_k on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:29PM (#41862882)
> produce power at a fraction of the cost

Sadly, also for a fraction of the time.

Until storage is solved in a satisfactory way, solar and wind will remain auxiliary. And the capacity should be in gigawatt-days.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by threeseed on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:26PM (#41863490)
Well that fraction coincides with when demand is the highest.

And storage is being solved as we have more batteries being deployed and grid supply capable EVs becoming more popular.

The market is deciding where money should be allocated and it's simply not going towards nuclear.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by abfan1127 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:40PM (#41863629)
why would you want to share your EV battery capacity with the grid? I don't understand this. Range is entirely dictated by your EV capacity and you're going to "rent" back the capacity (and battery cycles) for night time hours? I don't understand how this would work at scale.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by crazygringo on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:13PM (#41863903)
> why would you want to share your EV battery capacity with the grid?

Because you'd get paid for it, and you like free money.

And it should be pretty trivial to set an option to ensure you always have the necessary range for your daily commute by a little bit before you leave your home.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by abfan1127 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:57AM (#41870267)
if services like Uber have shown anything, its that you can sell your vehicle's intrinsic value, depreciating it's value in the process. But will you be net positive after depreciated value?
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by crazygringo on Thursday October 17, 2024 @11:56AM (#41870849)
Obviously almost nobody would do it if it weren't net positive.

And why wouldn't it be? The whole point here is for power companies to avoid buying as many batteries themselves, and their own batteries depreciate too.

This isn't hard -- the power company adjusts the price it pays minute per minute, and you set the threshold at which it is profitable for you, taking battery cycles into account. And it becomes a classic supply and demand curve -- it's Econ 101.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by abfan1127 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @01:54PM (#41871930)
Uber drivers earn roughly $0.70/mile[1]. Gas at $3/gal and MPGs at 25mpg mean it costs $0.12/mi in fuel. a $30k vehicle driven to 150k miles costs roughly $0.20/mi in depreciation. Without additional maintenance costs, its roughly $0.32/mi to drive a car. Approximating tires, oil changes, brakes, and other maintenance of roughly $0.15/mi, you're looking at total cost to drive at $0.45-0.50/mi.

Do you think most Uber drivers drive for the $0.7-$0.12 = $0.58/mile or the actual cost of $0.70-$0.50=$0.20/mile? Sustainable Supply/Demand doesn't work until all costs are measured.

A Rivian battery is roughly $17k. Estimating 1500 charge cycles [2], that's roughly $11/charge. If you "give back" half a cycle, there's only $1.50 worth of electricity sold back, but its $5.50 worth of battery. Are you expecting to get paid $1.50+profit or $7+profit?

[1] https://www.stilt.com/careers/how-much-does-uber-pay/ [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/Rivian/comments/10onhud/ev_battery_...

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by 7952 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:37PM (#41864091)
The most important metrics are cost and speed of co2 reduction. An 80% renewable grid may achieve that more effectively than nuclear. It may be optimal to burn gas for a couple of weeks per year. Or to build massive pumped storage and nuclear stations.

But trying to hit some purity target of 100% is irrelevant. There are lower hanging fruit for decarbonisation than the last few percent of power generation.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by whatever1 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @03:25AM (#41867243)
Not really we just need cables across different time zones
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ksec on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:18AM (#41869919)
>Until storage is solved in a satisfactory way

We need a battery that is safe and mandate every home to have one. Or provide incentive for it to be installed. We shouldn't wait for super battery to be install in a central place, instead every home could afford one an provide high quality electrical power.

Surely instead of a giant Water boiler in a lot of homes we could have a giant battery instead.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by kulahan on Thursday October 17, 2024 @01:51PM (#41871903)
We probably cannot shop our way out of climate change. The intense climate damage you'd do installing hundreds of millions of batteries (of any kind) would likely offset dozens of years of use.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:43AM (#41870138)
Nuclear power needs an 85% cost reduction to be competitive with renewables when modeling system costs.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030626192...

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by m101 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:26PM (#41862855)
Solar and wind emit a lot of CO2 upfront relative to the energy they produce down the line.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:56PM (#41863168)
"A lot" is really subjective, so I'll link this chart instead:

https://assets.solar.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Carbon-f...

I'd say 1-5% of coal is pretty good.

Also as we make the power grid cleaner and switch to electric vehicles, the CO2 used in manufacturing goes down.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by m101 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @05:58PM (#41898826)
It's not about comparing to coal but rather about comparing to other good alternatives, with that being nuclear.

Energy return in investment is <10x for solar, but more like 100x for nuclear. We have an energy budget to solver climate change. This is nothing to do with how much things cost.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Dylan16807 on Monday October 21, 2024 @05:29AM (#41902239)
You said solar and wind emit a lot, but according to the chart wind and nuclear are tied.

Rooftop solar is worse, but 4x worse than wind/nuclear is still quite good (and non-rooftop solar is almost certainly better than that). Solar's energy return on investment is higher than 10x by my searching, and we should be mass producing all three technologies at this point.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by nine_k on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:39PM (#41862998)
So does nuclear, and in much larger absolute extent: production of steel and concrete, used copiously in NPP construction, inevitably releases a lot of CO2. Melting silicon or smelting aluminum, not nearly as much. (IDK about epoxy resin production.)

I suppose that instead of eliminating the processes that produce large amounts of CO2, we should embrace them, learn to capture the CO2 where it's produced in high concentrations (like steel plants or cement furnaces), and either bind the carbon in non-volatile ways, like in plastics, or produce fuel from it again and close the loop.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by m101 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @05:58PM (#41898824)
It's not about absolute but about relative to the amount of energy produced.

Energy return in investment is <10x for solar, but more like 100x for nuclear. We have an energy budget to solver climate change. This is nothing to do with how much things cost.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Angostura on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:00PM (#41863200)
Now run that in comparison to building and decommissioning a nuclear power station
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by m101 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @05:59PM (#41898832)
It works out even with that. It's actually better than that - many nuclear plants work well past their initial design lifetimes.
[dead]
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by m101 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @05:57PM (#41898820)
Energy return in investment is <10x for solar, but more like 100x for nuclear. We have an energy budget to solver climate change. This is nothing to do with how much things cost.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Ghaenergyyy on Monday October 21, 2024 @06:32AM (#41902640)
That was not my point. A solar panel is co2 neutral after 3 years and wind in a year.

And if we could build nuclear properly in a reasonable fast way around the globe, i would be for investing it heavily anyway i'm just not controling it in anyway and the only thing actually working is solar, wind and battery.

Low risk, broad spectrum investment (private, small companies, big, basically everyone can)

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by hindsightbias on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:08PM (#41863302)
I’ve been saying for years that new nuclear plant development will be evidence of an AGI fufilling its physiological hierarchy of needs. I see Starship as another requirement.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by epistasis on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:40PM (#41864590)
How are any of these things connected?
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by AtlasBarfed on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:41PM (#41864119)
The basic economics of power generation do not agree with your contention.

The reality is that this is all nuclear can rest its hopes on. Industry specific applications, because for general electricity generation it is hopelessly non-competitive.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by cyanydeez on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @06:49PM (#41864666)
Unfortunately, this isnt to sustain exiwting enetgy, its to add powER TO AI GIGO.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by xinayder on Thursday October 17, 2024 @03:55AM (#41867373)
I just wish this brings more research into Thorium based reactors, as they seem to be the future of sustainable nuclear power. Maybe a SMR powered by Thorium in the future? Who knows.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by tim333 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @08:01AM (#41868818)
Thorium based seems to be a conventional nuclear reactor with added complications. Getting conventional made is hard enough.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by preisschild on Thursday October 17, 2024 @08:50AM (#41869191)
Doesn't even neccessarily need to be Thorium-232, we also have a lot uf Uranium-238 that isn't really used efficiently.

Thermal/Fast Breeders are needed to use those fuel sources. Only Russia commercialiced them, because western nations stopped funding r&d (EBR2 in the US and Superphênix in France)

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by tim333 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @09:50AM (#41869659)
Some stats. Solar install 2024 593GW, nuclear install per year about 8GW.

Solar growing about 30% a year, nukes about 0%.

Storage is coming along too.

(some source stuff https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41601621)