News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by threeseed on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @02:56PM (#41862525)
There are no big pushes into nuclear power. These are all tiny deployments that may never even happen.

And those dumb turbines and solar panels produce power at a fraction of the cost of nuclear. And every year they get cheaper and more efficient. Which is why the market has continually decided over and over again to go in this direction.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by nine_k on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:29PM (#41862882)
> produce power at a fraction of the cost

Sadly, also for a fraction of the time.

Until storage is solved in a satisfactory way, solar and wind will remain auxiliary. And the capacity should be in gigawatt-days.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by threeseed on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:26PM (#41863490)
Well that fraction coincides with when demand is the highest.

And storage is being solved as we have more batteries being deployed and grid supply capable EVs becoming more popular.

The market is deciding where money should be allocated and it's simply not going towards nuclear.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by abfan1127 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:40PM (#41863629)
why would you want to share your EV battery capacity with the grid? I don't understand this. Range is entirely dictated by your EV capacity and you're going to "rent" back the capacity (and battery cycles) for night time hours? I don't understand how this would work at scale.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by crazygringo on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:13PM (#41863903)
> why would you want to share your EV battery capacity with the grid?

Because you'd get paid for it, and you like free money.

And it should be pretty trivial to set an option to ensure you always have the necessary range for your daily commute by a little bit before you leave your home.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by abfan1127 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:57AM (#41870267)
if services like Uber have shown anything, its that you can sell your vehicle's intrinsic value, depreciating it's value in the process. But will you be net positive after depreciated value?
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by crazygringo on Thursday October 17, 2024 @11:56AM (#41870849)
Obviously almost nobody would do it if it weren't net positive.

And why wouldn't it be? The whole point here is for power companies to avoid buying as many batteries themselves, and their own batteries depreciate too.

This isn't hard -- the power company adjusts the price it pays minute per minute, and you set the threshold at which it is profitable for you, taking battery cycles into account. And it becomes a classic supply and demand curve -- it's Econ 101.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by abfan1127 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @01:54PM (#41871930)
Uber drivers earn roughly $0.70/mile[1]. Gas at $3/gal and MPGs at 25mpg mean it costs $0.12/mi in fuel. a $30k vehicle driven to 150k miles costs roughly $0.20/mi in depreciation. Without additional maintenance costs, its roughly $0.32/mi to drive a car. Approximating tires, oil changes, brakes, and other maintenance of roughly $0.15/mi, you're looking at total cost to drive at $0.45-0.50/mi.

Do you think most Uber drivers drive for the $0.7-$0.12 = $0.58/mile or the actual cost of $0.70-$0.50=$0.20/mile? Sustainable Supply/Demand doesn't work until all costs are measured.

A Rivian battery is roughly $17k. Estimating 1500 charge cycles [2], that's roughly $11/charge. If you "give back" half a cycle, there's only $1.50 worth of electricity sold back, but its $5.50 worth of battery. Are you expecting to get paid $1.50+profit or $7+profit?

[1] https://www.stilt.com/careers/how-much-does-uber-pay/ [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/Rivian/comments/10onhud/ev_battery_...

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by 7952 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @05:37PM (#41864091)
The most important metrics are cost and speed of co2 reduction. An 80% renewable grid may achieve that more effectively than nuclear. It may be optimal to burn gas for a couple of weeks per year. Or to build massive pumped storage and nuclear stations.

But trying to hit some purity target of 100% is irrelevant. There are lower hanging fruit for decarbonisation than the last few percent of power generation.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by whatever1 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @03:25AM (#41867243)
Not really we just need cables across different time zones
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ksec on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:18AM (#41869919)
>Until storage is solved in a satisfactory way

We need a battery that is safe and mandate every home to have one. Or provide incentive for it to be installed. We shouldn't wait for super battery to be install in a central place, instead every home could afford one an provide high quality electrical power.

Surely instead of a giant Water boiler in a lot of homes we could have a giant battery instead.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by kulahan on Thursday October 17, 2024 @01:51PM (#41871903)
We probably cannot shop our way out of climate change. The intense climate damage you'd do installing hundreds of millions of batteries (of any kind) would likely offset dozens of years of use.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday October 17, 2024 @10:43AM (#41870138)
Nuclear power needs an 85% cost reduction to be competitive with renewables when modeling system costs.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030626192...

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by m101 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:26PM (#41862855)
Solar and wind emit a lot of CO2 upfront relative to the energy they produce down the line.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:56PM (#41863168)
"A lot" is really subjective, so I'll link this chart instead:

https://assets.solar.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Carbon-f...

I'd say 1-5% of coal is pretty good.

Also as we make the power grid cleaner and switch to electric vehicles, the CO2 used in manufacturing goes down.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by m101 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @05:58PM (#41898826)
It's not about comparing to coal but rather about comparing to other good alternatives, with that being nuclear.

Energy return in investment is <10x for solar, but more like 100x for nuclear. We have an energy budget to solver climate change. This is nothing to do with how much things cost.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Dylan16807 on Monday October 21, 2024 @05:29AM (#41902239)
You said solar and wind emit a lot, but according to the chart wind and nuclear are tied.

Rooftop solar is worse, but 4x worse than wind/nuclear is still quite good (and non-rooftop solar is almost certainly better than that). Solar's energy return on investment is higher than 10x by my searching, and we should be mass producing all three technologies at this point.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by nine_k on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @03:39PM (#41862998)
So does nuclear, and in much larger absolute extent: production of steel and concrete, used copiously in NPP construction, inevitably releases a lot of CO2. Melting silicon or smelting aluminum, not nearly as much. (IDK about epoxy resin production.)

I suppose that instead of eliminating the processes that produce large amounts of CO2, we should embrace them, learn to capture the CO2 where it's produced in high concentrations (like steel plants or cement furnaces), and either bind the carbon in non-volatile ways, like in plastics, or produce fuel from it again and close the loop.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by m101 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @05:58PM (#41898824)
It's not about absolute but about relative to the amount of energy produced.

Energy return in investment is <10x for solar, but more like 100x for nuclear. We have an energy budget to solver climate change. This is nothing to do with how much things cost.

Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Angostura on Wednesday October 16, 2024 @04:00PM (#41863200)
Now run that in comparison to building and decommissioning a nuclear power station
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by m101 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @05:59PM (#41898832)
It works out even with that. It's actually better than that - many nuclear plants work well past their initial design lifetimes.
[dead]
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by m101 on Sunday October 20, 2024 @05:57PM (#41898820)
Energy return in investment is <10x for solar, but more like 100x for nuclear. We have an energy budget to solver climate change. This is nothing to do with how much things cost.
Re:Amazon buys stake in nuclear energy developer in push to ... by Ghaenergyyy on Monday October 21, 2024 @06:32AM (#41902640)
That was not my point. A solar panel is co2 neutral after 3 years and wind in a year.

And if we could build nuclear properly in a reasonable fast way around the globe, i would be for investing it heavily anyway i'm just not controling it in anyway and the only thing actually working is solar, wind and battery.

Low risk, broad spectrum investment (private, small companies, big, basically everyone can)