News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by janalsncm on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @03:18AM (#41508862)
It should tell you something that 95% of the union voted to strike. I found more information from them here:

https://www.nyguild.org/post/new-york-times-tech-guild-votes...

I wonder how other news outlets will cover this, if at all. They’re probably afraid others will get the same idea.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by aurareturn on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @04:18AM (#41509247)
Isn’t it a little ironic that NY Times, and most east coast media, is very anti big tech and pro union while their own employees are protesting because of low wages?

Who are they to judge how big tech treats their employees when they pay their own so poorly?

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Retric on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:29AM (#41509967)
> Who are they to judge how big tech treats their employees when they pay their own so poorly?

Being anti tech has nothing to do with salary, it’s centered on what big tech is doing.

The people actually writing articles tend to be in Unions which may help explain their pro Union stances. Both from below and management being concerned with union relations.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by ljlolel on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @04:32AM (#41509329)
They’re also incredibly non-diverse and complain about big tech being non-diverse.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by donohoe on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:47AM (#41510084)
“Incredibly non-diverse”? No. They are in a better position than most

https://www.nytco.com/2023-new-york-times-diversity-and-incl...

The my don’t complain about tech being non-diverse, they report that it is non-diverse - which is true.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by klooney on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:02AM (#41510163)
60% white is much whiter than a tech company
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Rinzler89 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:18AM (#41510247)
Why is the color important here?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by mensetmanusman on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:52AM (#41510436)
Because dei and the nyt focus on that being important.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Rinzler89 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @08:08AM (#41510554)
Feels like this deviation is always used as a distraction to divide and conquer the workers and voters on race and skin color and have them fight against each other to prevent them collectively allying against those from the top actually oppressing them.

Q: "Hey, 1% and big corporations, why are you screwing over all workers and consumers regardless of their skin color with your bad practices?"

A: "Hey don't look over there, let's focus and argue on present day diversity and social matters. Are you saying that's not important? Are you a right wing supremacist racist/nazi?"

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by giantg2 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:12AM (#41511033)
"Feels like this deviation is always used as a distraction to divide and conquer the workers and voters on race and skin color and have them fight against each other to prevent them collectively allying against those from the top actually oppressing them and eroding their rights and wages."

It does seem that way, slightly. There seem to be some natural causes for misalignment that I would think are more influential. One main issue is that different people and groups of people have different experiences. If you've never been screwed over, you might not see the problems in the current system. If you have been screwed over and seen other screwed over, you might just think that's the way it goes.

What are the alternatives proposed to the unfair impacts? I want to see the objective rating criteria that can reduce or prevent people from getting screwed over. I do think tech unions can help with this a little, but I haven't seen any successful approaches to things like ratings. Even the places that set standards seem to have subjective criteria, or you work is subjectively applied.

I've been screwed over and passed over multiple times. I also have a disability, no less it's one that causes inconsistencies with policies and treatment to jump out to me. I still haven't seen any solutions that will work until the members agree on what are the problems and how do we fix them. Many of my coworkers think my company is great, but those also tend to be the people that consistently get high ratings and promotions. Meanwhile, I struggle to point out all the contributions I made, align them to the standard, and otherwise do my manager's job of rating me for them only to get an average rating. It also doesn't help that I have to tell them what the corporate policies say when they try to misuse them against me (holding time off against me, holding prior period performance against me for this period, not providing accommodations that were promised, etc). Nobody else seems to have this hard of a time so why would they risk anything to speak up for people like me? I've learned to live with the disappointment by giving up any dreams of advancement and just trying to keep the job I have while fending off as much BS as I can... and perhaps complaining about it on HN.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by WarOnPrivacy on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:49AM (#41511375)
> Feels like [feelings about dei]

It's an issue of competence.

Having cleared the lowest bar, society is demonstrably less racist than a century ago. The next bar is much more difficult; we may be less equipped than we were for the last one.

We can measure some more nuanced outcomes of racism. Past that we are struggling to even qualify successes and failures. Instances & causes remain tied to systems & psychology that seem too complex for current skill sets to parse well. As a result, poor performance and less-poor performance are happening all at once.

At this level of the challenge, failure is one of the best learning tools at our disposal. Bad actors are quick to see that and are doing what they have always done - exploiting our poor valuation of failures to derail progress.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Rinzler89 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:57AM (#41511458)
Understandable that people would feel that way but the reality is much simpler than you're making it be. The present day issues aren't caused by skin color or race, it's just haves vs have nots, elite vs plebs.

Core issue is not social, it's economical masquerading as social to divide and conquer people to keep the plebs occupied bickering against each other based on race and skin color while the ruling elite light up Cuban cigars with $100 bills taken from the pockets of both of them through the housing and economic policies they created.

Keep people divided so they can't turn against you has been a successful MO since the Roman empire. But average people are too stupid to understand such grand economic issues, liek why you can't afford a house anymore, but race, gender and skin color is much more approachable by the unwashed masses and more easily gather political support in campaigns.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by WarOnPrivacy on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:52PM (#41513154)
> the reality is much simpler than you're making it be. The present day issues aren't caused by skin color or race

This strongly implies that racism is no longer a meaningfully impactful problem. That would not be true.

> Core issue is not social, it's economical masquerading as social...

If this were meaningfully true, police & justice stats for poor white populations would be indistinguishable from poor black and brown populations - across the country.

> ...to divide and conquer people

Planned and coordinated division is most visibly on display when a marginalized group is suddenly, widely demonized. False rhetoric and tightly crafted language indicate that fascism is a factor.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Rinzler89 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:06PM (#41513302)
>This strongly implies that racism is no longer a meaningfully impactful problem. That would not be true.

That was the point I weas trying to prove from the start. The moment you point the fingers at the causes of our massive problem (ruling elite, economy policies, etc) and away from racism, people will immediately accuse you of discrediting racism as a problem. I never said racism it's not a problem, I said as a society we have much bigger problems that impacts everyone, not just this or that group.

Like I said above, the elite take 9 out of the 10 piece of the wealth pie, give half a piece to one class, half of piece to the other, and say "hey look, the other guy's class is why you only have half a piece, go fight him over it to claim back what's yours", and you keep focusing on that other half piece instead of the other 9 pieces.

If you can't afford a house anymore, and inflation ate away your savings, and your wage has stagnated, it's not because one skin color made a targeted attack on precisely other skin color. Like I said, it's haves vs have nots now, not one race vs another.

>Planned and coordinated division is most visibly on display when a marginalized group is suddenly, widely demonized.

Who is currently being demonized, where are they being demonized, and who is the one demonizing them?

>False rhetoric and tightly crafted language indicate that fascism is a factor.

Can you point that out where you see it? And please let it not be Twitter or other social media garbage.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by IncreasePosts on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:21PM (#41513428)
> The present day issues aren't caused by skin color or race, it's just haves vs have nots, elite vs plebs

Can you possibly think of a reason why black people might be highly over-represented in the "have nots" group in America?

Go out on a limb, what could it possibly be.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Rinzler89 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:31PM (#41513511)
What about the other color of skins who are also part of the "have nots"? Are they not also affected? Why must the focus always be on the skin color instead of on the "not have" part? What's with this racism shit?

You're only proving my point that I made above, that people care more about punching up against a skin color they consider have an unfair advantage due to past history, but which won't improve their situation anyway, instead of focusing on the economic and political issues made by the ruling elite of today that impact those of all skin colors who are on the wrong side of the financial fence.

Our modern economic system is based on "time in the market beats timing the market", that's all. So of course those who come from a well off background of several generations will be even more well off today, while those who come from an impoverished background will have a hard time building any wealth and most likely stay impoverished, but that's nothing to do with skin color since money doesn't get transferred genetically though osmosis where one skin color somehow is born with more money in their account and the other not otherwise there would be no broke white people. If your parents were broke AF, most likely you'll also be broke AF no matter your skin color, unless you bust your ass in school to escape poverty.

But if you have an alternative answer please go ahead.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by IncreasePosts on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:05PM (#41513793)
Of course people with other skin color are also affected by poverty, or whatever it means to be a have-not, why wouldn't they be?

I didn't say the focus must be on skin color. I'm saying to disregard why certain groups are represented in the haves/have-nots, you must ignore history.

I don't believe you're arguing in good faith if you think point out that racism exists/existed, and you call that "racism shit"

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Rinzler89 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:32PM (#41514030)
I called your argument "this racism shit" since you're trying to argue how some people today are poor because of events from 150 years ago and not do to their own actions or inactions. That would be like me blaming my lack of financial success in life on the Ottoman empire's occupation of my country.

How about personal responsibility? How can you blame people you've never met and who are long dead for why you're poor today.

Why is it that Iranians, Indians, Taiwanese, Chinese, and other Asians who emigrate to the US with little to no money can become very successful within 1-2 generations despite being poor foreign immigrants while a certain minority of the US citizens who enjoy rights and benefits immigrants do not seem to be stuck in poverty/crime and keep blaming history for it? Is it because some cultures value education highly while a US minority does not?

It's not your fault you are born into poverty but it's your responsibility to do your best to get out of it. Who is stopping that minority group from going to school/college or trades to escape poverty?

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by IncreasePosts on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @04:04PM (#41514895)
Interesting. I wonder what could be the cause that a certain minority culture doesn't value education highly?

Go out on a limb, what could it possibly be.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Rinzler89 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @02:14AM (#41518063)
I dunno, you tell us why, since so far you haven't made any arguments, but kept baiting and beating it around the bush with loaded questions. Just say what you want to say.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by kmeisthax on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:14PM (#41513886)
And, funnily enough, this kind of divide-and-conquer exploitation also happens to create incredibly homogenous workplaces. The reason why these horrible workplaces have fewer black people or women is because the business practices - i.e. lots of crunch time, toxic workplace environment, shitty mismanagement, etc - filter out people who don't have the tolerance for that shit. It just so happens that young white men happen to be the least sensitive to bad business practices (because of all that stuff the woke left packaged into the word "privilege") so they're the last one standing.

Most corporate DEI is less "what can we do to retain power minority employees" and more "how can we turn minorities into more effective worker drones that we can then abuse". This is less because they actually want diversity and more because they want to be able to put the word "diversity" in a mission statement. It's left-wing[0] language being coopted to serve the purposes of cutthroat capitalism. "Diversity" happens to be a popular term with the people who are currently their most abusable worker drones. So they apply it liberally to make them think they're winning when they're losing.

This works the other way too - effective labor organization and opposition to corporate power needs (actual) DEI just as (again, actual) DEI needs organized labor. Collective solidarity cannot function if you leave out certain groups of people, otherwise you're not doing a revolution, you're doing a changing of the guard.

[0] Libertarian left specifically. Yes, there is an "anti-woke left", it's called the Chinese Communist Party.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by giantg2 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @08:56AM (#41510894)
If you read some of the linked articles off of the one posted a few comments back, then you will see that the recent cuts have disproportionately affected minorities, minorities are making less, and that minorities are receiving lower evaluation scores. So it seems they do have a diversity problem.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by daseiner1 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:44AM (#41511313)
perhaps diversity has a performance problem.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by giantg2 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:47AM (#41511344)
I want to see the actual studies that the guild has used to generate the numbers for their claims so I can see what possible mechanisms might be at play and what sort of level setting they've done for the data. Unfortunately, I didn't see any of the studies released.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by SpicyLemonZest on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @08:58AM (#41510907)
It’s “true” only according to a custom definition of diversity common in newsrooms and universities - but not, apparently, the Times’s own diversity report - where some groups which become too included no longer count as diverse. I think this standard, whereby I’ve had a non-white yet non-diverse manager for 95% of my career, deserves an extraordinary amount of scrutiny.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by kettlepot1337 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:29AM (#41511726)
>> “Incredibly non-diverse”? No. They are in a better position than most

Absolutely not. This is typical trickery of stats. They have diversity at lower levels. But unlike SV almost no diversity at senior ranks. I think its past time that we consider janitorial and admin jobs as a win. If we have legions of educated minorities, why aren't they making it into executive roles at the NY Times?

Here is the exec staff: https://www.nytco.com/company/people/ "Filter by executive"

There are >64 million Hispanics living in the United States, yet not a single one on the NYT exec team.

They have 1 token asian,

1 token black person.

That is not "Better position than most." That seems like 3x worse than your average tech firm.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by dario_od on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:47AM (#41512478)
I opened the link and filtered by executive. Thirteen people there: - 5 white men - 4 white women - 1 black man - 2 black women - 1 asian woman

Pretending that a sample size of 12 should exactly reflect the diversity of the whole population of the country is just weird to me.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by gosub100 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:32AM (#41512349)
A citizen journalist I follow on YouTube pointed out that for having 5900 employees, they have fewer than 10 who are veterans. It explains why they get so much wrong when reporting on the military.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by sickofparadox on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:48AM (#41512490)
I'm sure that both of those people would feel very vindicated in their career knowing that the person advocating for further affirmative action calls them "tokens".
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by gwervc on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @05:21AM (#41509617)
Always the same story... A few years ago a big left French newspaper (Libération) always pushing for "diversity" published a photo of their staff, which was like 98- 100% white.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by throwawaylolx on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @05:29AM (#41509665)
It's not always the same story at all. Many times those organizations do discriminate against white candidates.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Larrikin on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:44AM (#41510405)
Which ones?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by ekianjo on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @08:23AM (#41510672)
every employer that has quotas for non-white employees? that necessarily follows.

not that its not limited to race. if an org wants more women they will actively select candidates based on gender first.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Zigurd on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:19AM (#41511631)
Comparing a specific employer against "every employer that has quotas" is not a useful comparison.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by parineum on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:54AM (#41512558)
Discrimination is a necessary means to achieve quoatas, no matter what the quota is.

Introducing discrimination is often the explicitly stated purpose of quotas

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Zigurd on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @03:43PM (#41514696)
The reason it's not a useful comparison is that unnamed, nonspecific "employer who has quotas" is assuming that many employers have quotas. Who? How much? And did they eat my cat?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by jimbokun on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:29AM (#41511728)
Which employers are those?

In the US, they would be blatantly violating the law and targets for lawsuits.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by umanwizard on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:48PM (#41514178)
> every employer that has quotas for non-white employees?

Does any employer in the US have this? I'm almost certain it'd be illegal.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by VancouverMan on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:29PM (#41512904)
Just over a decade ago, there was a job ad for a host role with the state-funded Canadian Broadcasting Corporation that explicitly required applicants to be "Any race except Caucasian".

https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/cbc-no-caucasian

While it was portrayed as a "mistake" during the subsequent backtracking, that incident certainly planted a seed of doubt in my mind.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by ekianjo on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @08:22AM (#41510664)
thats called projection
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by whimsicalism on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:28AM (#41512298)
in terms of binary black-white thinking, NYT is definitely more diverse than tech
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by grumple on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:09PM (#41512721)
Is big tech non-diverse? It seems to have a higher non-white population than the US itself according the numbers I've been able to find. If we count contractors and off-shore, it will become even less white. I'd bet tech has a higher proportion of LGBT+ people as well (without looking at numbers, admittedly, but I'd be surprised if I was wrong). Gender diversity is an issue; but not for lack of trying. Cis women are probably 5% of the resumes I see.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by BurningFrog on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:48PM (#41513106)
In my SV teams over the years, I'd say that the straight white male US born people were ~20% of the engineers.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by HPsquared on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @05:11AM (#41509555)
Projection is a thing (assuming the opinions they print are their own)
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by gsky on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:56AM (#41510128)
Easier said than done, right. Who would dare to criticize them afterall
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by ParetoOptimal on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:51AM (#41510434)
Yeah, therefore big tech should get to treat their workers however.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by ETH_start on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @05:48AM (#41509754)
The NY Times is pro-union and anti-big-tech in large part because its journalists are unionized and tech platforms disintermediate unions. The workers that produce articles and create the newsroom culture have a conflict of interest that affects its editorial slant. There is also the factor that tech threatens the ad revenue of traditional news media.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by donohoe on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:49AM (#41510094)
I worked at NYT for seven years and I can say from direct personal experience that your many points are not true.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by reissbaker on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:21AM (#41511660)
Kelsey Piper, a journalist at Vox, leaked two years ago that the NYT has had a years-long top-down directive to only write negative stories about tech [1]. Plenty of journalists have confirmed this since. Since you worked at the NYT for seven years, want to explain that particular policy in light of your rebuttal that the NYT had no conflict of interest and wasn't trying to smear tech companies?

1: https://x.com/KelseyTuoc/status/1588231892792328192

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by donohoe on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:16AM (#41512166)
You are making a very different claim here. The parent comment says:

>> The NY Times is pro-union and anti-big-tech [...]

That is the claim. These are the reasons it sues, and my notes on each:

* journalists are unionized and tech platforms disintermediate unions

Thats a broad generalization based on the authors opinion and not necessarily true. The attitude was not reflective of my interactions with journalists either. I would dispute this from personal experience. We can agree/disagree forever, I'm just giving my IRL experience.

* workers that produce articles and create the newsroom culture have a conflict of interest

It could be said that any journalist who covers any subject has a conflict of interest by covering that subject. Thats a bit weak.

* tech threatens the ad revenue of traditional news media.

Yeah. Rising costs of paper also threaten traditional news media. The NYT is profitable and not reliant on ad revenue streams for survival. They have a health revenue stream in number of other areas. In addition, for better or for worse, most journalists don't actually know/care that much about ad revenue given the tradition divides between business and editorial sides (I see that at many media orgs I have worked for - its not just the NYT)

So.. that was what I was talking about ("workers", not a "top-down directive").

In regards to your point: Thats a new and different claim so hard for me to speak to that.

I would note that the claim came from Matthew Yglesias. He since deleted the tweet. I would note that he never worked at the NYT as far as I can tell.

I don't know much of Kelsey Piper, but she "heard it from NYT reporters at the time" so not quite first-hand account either. Her tweet is not a "leak" (thats very different) and I see nothing to prove or substantiate it - just she "heard" it.

I'll keep an open mind but I'm skeptical.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by reissbaker on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:07AM (#41518940)
It could be said that that any journalist who covers any subject has a conflict of interest

I think that's a really weak claim. Journalism has had significantly reduced revenues in the late 2000s through today due to the rise of tech platforms that let people learn about what's happening in the world for free online. Both print and online newspaper combined revenue has been wiped back to the 1950s [1], for example. Journalists covering, say, election politics have no more conflict of interest than any other American. But they definitely have more of a conflict of interest covering tech than other Americans! For most Americans, tech has largely contributed to economic improvements: you can buy more advanced products for less inflation-adjusted money, pretty much every year. You have a supercomputer in your pocket and you can talk to your lights and tell them to turn off while you're lying in bed. For journalists, though, tech has been devastating.

You might try to claim that because journalists don't set their own salaries, somehow this removes the conflict of interest. But that implies journalists are incredibly stupid. You can't work in a vastly diminishing field and not realize that it's going to depress your salary and job opportunities over time, regardless of whether you set the salary or not: there's just vastly less money to go around. And that's what tech has done to traditional journalism.

And the NYT is not immune. While it's doing better than its peers (many of whom have gone out of business), it's not doing well: it's experienced approximately zero market growth since its peak in 2002 over twenty years ago, when shares traded for about $48. Today, they trade for $52. And working at the only institution in your field that hasn't experienced total collapse, but has achieved no growth in 20+ years, is obviously going to color your views on the sector that did that to your field.

1: https://www.statista.com/chart/612/newspaper-advertising-rev...

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by ETH_start on Friday September 13, 2024 @03:33AM (#41528880)
Thanks for sharing your real life experience.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by cantSpellSober on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @08:54AM (#41510879)
> Who are they to judge how big tech treats their employees when they pay their own so poorly?

The journalists (and tech workers) don't decide their own salary.

You conflated "they" as both management and the people being managed, to make it "ironic."

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by lupusreal on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:20PM (#41512825)
I wonder if the NYTimes journalists will sympathy strike. (They won't.)
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by matrix87 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:52PM (#41513148)
Are you saying that management doesn't have input on editorial direction? sounds pretty hard to believe
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by ramon156 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:22PM (#41516180)
Uh hello, journalists also don't choose the theme they write in. That's also management
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by cantSpellSober on Friday September 13, 2024 @08:24AM (#41530536)
You're thinking of editors, and journalists do choose what they cover to an extent. Management ostensibly sees that everything goes according to plan/schedule. Fair point though–if mgmt is pushing some initiative, that pressure is felt in a newsroom.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by nemo44x on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:47AM (#41511342)
A lot of the East Coast media, like the Times, has a lot of downwardly mobile people in them from wealthy or upper middle class families. And they aren't any longer in many cases and they are full of resent and bitterness that their turn has been looked over. That they aren't getting what "they deserve" as they did "everything right" like join a bunch of clubs in high school or w/e and go to college and get a degree that shows the world they are the continuation of their family legacy. But it's not there any longer and there's jealousy of of the new middle class that tech has built.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:54AM (#41511429)
When the bloody hell has the New York Times been pro-union?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by kettlepot1337 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:12AM (#41511577)
>> Isn’t it a little ironic that NY Times, and most east coast media, is very anti big tech and pro union while their own employees are protesting because of low wages?

It is more than a little ironic that the NY Times complains about a "lack of diversity" in silicon valley, when practically the entire NY Times senior staff are generationally rich white people who live in Manhattan and Brooklyn.

Here is the exec staff: https://www.nytco.com/company/people/ "Filter by executive"

There are >64 million Hispanics living in the United States, yet not a single one on the NYT exec team. They have 1 token asian, 1 token black person. Half the staff is Jewish. Yet they are complaining about diversity in Silicon valley.

As a person of asian origin, there is probably no way I can get a non-crappy role at the NY Times, yet silicon valley offers enough of a meritocracy that I can get a job there without having a rich uncle.

Remember, when the establishment complains about diversity, they are actually complaining about themselves losing control to the general population. That is why colored people in executive roles in SV is so scary to newspapers.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by tiznow on Friday September 13, 2024 @04:59AM (#41529376)
It's funny, my experience with NYT and tech has been the opposite as a minority -- probably a lot easier to get in than many would think, but talent is not the fulcrum.

"Half the staff is Jewish" made me laugh though, perhaps closer to true than false. It's funny how people call The New Yorker the pinnacle of privilege as a writer-type, and their staff writer team is more diverse than just about any other East Coast bigwig outlet.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by vrosas on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:21AM (#41511664)
Their current CEO, Meredith Kopit Levien, is about as let-them-eat-cake as they come. She was doing a town hall years back when they were forcing everyone to “hotel” desks so they could lease out more floors of their HQ in Times Square, when she mentioned she’s giving up one of her two offices in the building but it’s ok because one was “mostly for shoes, anyway”.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by salawat on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:08AM (#41512081)
...Just because you're being payed absurdly doesn't legitimize your work any either. There's a lot of work that's aimed at getting done where the big fat paycheck is considered "STFU and do what you're told. with what we're paying you, we own you."

Just because you're potentially paid 500k to essentially implement the basis of metadata leakage and privacy compromise on scales that previous century actual dictators couldn't even reasonably dream of does not make the work of implementing it more "legitimate". It just makes it easier to attract people who value naterial comforts right now over safety from systemic abuse later. It's all tradeoffs.

Someone'll pay you well to do ultimately horrible things, and make it sound like you're doing everyone a favor.

Juniors, take note. You set the bar on the hell you'll be trapped in down the road. Always, always, be suspect.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by whimsicalism on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:27AM (#41512279)
it’s not ironic at all, usually ostensibly left organizations are most vulnerable to union pressure because of their customer base.

almost all modern places that unionize have a liberal/left-leaning customer base the company is afraid of losing

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by tiznow on Friday September 13, 2024 @04:52AM (#41529332)
This is a journalism industry problem, not a journalism content problem. Journalists trying to get paid more doesn't exclude Big Tech from criticism it deserves
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by andsoitis on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @08:24AM (#41510683)
> I wonder how other news outlets will cover this, if at all.

You are reading this on another news outlet!

Last year, NYT tech workers also had a strike over return -to-office, as covered by Reuters: https://www.reuters.com/world/us/new-york-times-tech-workers...

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by busterarm on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:07PM (#41513815)
Tbf, I wouldn't want to go back to that office. That area of NY is always swarmed with NYPDESU and is kind of a shithole.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by washadjeffmad on Thursday September 12, 2024 @07:22AM (#41519568)
I'd cry irony, but I couldn't imagine the modern NYT writing about the help.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by giantg2 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @08:53AM (#41510874)
I wanted to look at the pay study, but all it did was link me to another page with the same pay blurbs, but no actual study.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by dialup_sounds on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:51AM (#41511400)
The source says that 89% of members voted and it passed by 95%, which is about 85% of the union, not 95% of the union.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by julesqs on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:17AM (#41511619)
the editorial bias from management of NYT has always been skeptical of Google and Facebook and perhaps all of big tech because big tech was a threat to their business. Most newspapers in the US have been hollowed out because of social media and the tech industry, NYT ironically has not because they hired a real in house tech team that has kept their paper relevant.

But that doesn't mean they like paying their tech workers any more than any other management. It's just about money. Big tech is a threat to management's profits, just like workers demanding better salaries is a threat to management's profits.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by lupusreal on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:18PM (#41512809)
> Most newspapers in the US have been hollowed out because of social media and the tech industry,

They've been declining ever since radio and TV started doing news broadcasts, early to mid 20th century. Internet tech has played a role too, but the whole newspaper industry should have seen the writing on the wall several generations ago.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by julesqs on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:46PM (#41513626)
sure. Not making excuses for any business decisions by newspaper management, just pointing out that that their criticism of the tech industry isn't out of character with a company that also is hostile their own workers' union.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by jimbokun on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:22AM (#41511675)
> * Women, who make up 41% of the Tech Guild, earn 12% less on average than men

> * Black women and Hispanic or Latina women, who make up just over 6 percent of the Tech Guild, make 33% less than white men in the unit

> * Black workers, who make up 7 percent of the union, earn 26% less than white workers

Do they work equivalent jobs with equivalent experience?

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Workaccount2 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:59AM (#41512015)
If we look at past times these things are brought up; almost certainly not. Often things like part-time vs. full time aren't considered or amount of overtime hours worked (for hourly jobs).
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by andai on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:02PM (#41512640)
The reasoning I heard is that it's explained by differences in personality across the two populations. One group is, on average, more assertive, and as a result more likely to negotiate higher salary.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by bbatha on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:35PM (#41512959)
Which is reasoning that's difficult to prove. To the contrary women and underprivileged minorities also feel like they can't be assertive without being labeled as shrill.

The wage gap, at firms without a history of discrimination, is almost entirely determined by women having their first child and the support structures around it (subsidized childcare, paternity leave, flexible hours).[1][2] This suggests the assertiveness is probably not the issue.

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/lisaconn/2023/11/08/nobel-winne... [2] https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/regional-economist/j...

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by darby_nine on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:37PM (#41512988)
This explanation hold less and less water as corporations switch more firmly to tiered compensation tied directly to title.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by jimbokun on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:32PM (#41513513)
New employees vs more experienced employees, and different job descriptions are even more likely to explain the differences.

I don't know if that's the case here. But it would be good to investigate all the possible factors before coming to any conclusions.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:24PM (#41516763)
The reality is likely much more nuanced. But Id expect what fields they choose to go into is the bigger factor.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by darby_nine on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:36PM (#41512970)
This kind of thing is impossible to control for, though. How can you tell whether someone's success or lackthereof (including via degree of responsibility) comes from earnest evaluation of merit or social bias? I have a difficulty imagining trusting any kind of confident assessment of the bias at hand.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by IshKebab on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:54PM (#41514236)
Yeah it's really difficult, but that doesn't mean you should just give up and take the average.

There was a case recently in the UK where Next (high street clothing chain) were paying their warehouse staff more than their shop staff for (apparently) similar work. The shop workers had a higher proportion of female workers than the warehouse workers (something like 70% vs 50%).

Next claimed this was because the market rate was higher for warehouse workers. They got sued by the female shop workers for discrimination.

They lost and have to pay back pay. Now... you might think 70% vs 50% is barely a difference - did the Next bosses really discriminate? Surely not. Well, that's what the court thought too. Apparently even though they accepted that there was no conscious or unconscious discrimination, the effect of the pay difference was in itself discriminatory.

I dunno how that makes any sense. The shop workers should have sued the IT department and then they'd be in for a serious pay day!

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by superb_dev on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @03:11PM (#41514419)
The IT department isn't doing comparable work, so of course that wouldn't work.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by IshKebab on Thursday September 12, 2024 @02:04AM (#41518003)
Clearly warehouse workers don't do the exact same work either though. Otherwise it would be the same job and the market rate would be the same.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by superb_dev on Friday September 20, 2024 @07:08PM (#41606250)
You said "exact same work", I said "comparable work"
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by darby_nine on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @03:46PM (#41514721)
> Yeah it's really difficult, but that doesn't mean you should just give up and take the average.

Presumably the rational approach would be mild skepticism about confidence, not specifically accepting or rejecting any claim. Which leaves this well within the grounds of "plausible".

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by tracker1 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:48AM (#41522207)
I think the problem is that often the solutions are worse than the problem... price controls, wage ceilings, protectionism, etc. As opposed to offering negotiation training to women to push for the highest wages you can achieve.

I've worked pretty hard to teach my daughter than it doesn't hurt to ask for more than offered, or even to price yourself out of a job if there are multiple opportunities on the table. Women tend to naturally optimize for stability over maximum income and other factors and to accept a given deal vs negotiate. Much like men are far more likely to move to another location for career advancement and higher pay. There are natural tendencies that training can overcome which is likely better than trying to price control.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:21PM (#41516747)
> This kind of thing is impossible to control for

Then it’s impossible to determine if its sexism

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by darby_nine on Thursday September 12, 2024 @12:10AM (#41517517)
Sure, but people are always going to make their own judgements, so why bother complaining about it? It comes off like you're trying to defend the industry as being equitable when it clearly caters to people with certain skills.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by jimbokun on Thursday September 12, 2024 @09:04AM (#41520445)
But that is equitable, no?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by deepsun on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:06PM (#41512690)
It's averages. It could take as little as one ultra-high-paying worker (like CEO) to skew the statistics of averages.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by devnullbrain on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:06PM (#41513799)
There's not enough information to derive this. Mean is a subset of things we call average, not a synonym of it.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by ryandrake on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:53AM (#41511946)
If not, then that's also an equity problem. If the "dog jobs" are mostly offered to women and minorities, that should also be called out as a problem for employers to solve.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by pc86 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:07AM (#41512076)
This presupposes a lot of pretty nasty things. It reads like you apply to the NYT and then you get offered a job based on your gender or race which is obviously not the case. That lack of equity (which is equality of outcome, not opportunity) is itself a problem and not simply a byproduct of different people being different. That when your entire sample size is 622, you can make broad generalizations based on the pay of ~37 of them. Even if you can, it also assumes that your salary in your job is based on objective set criteria and not a) whether you negotiate, b) how hard you negotiate, c) whether you have a BATNA that makes you need the job less, d) whether you had breakfast that morning or were more tired than normal or were coming down with a cold or any number of a myriad of other things that could affect a high-stakes negotiation.

The pay gap as a systemic issue (for equal work for equal hours with equal qualifications) has been debunked a thousand times over. But while it's certainly possible (likely?) that some individual companies have a racially or gender-driven pay gap, it's a far stretch to assume that the NYT is one of them.

Equality of opportunity is good, giving people a leg up early in their lives when they've been disadvantaged, regardless of their race or gender, is good. "Equity" for the sake of it is racist.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by darby_nine on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:38PM (#41513003)
> It reads like you apply to the NYT and then you get offered a job based on your gender or race which is obviously not the case.

Obviously? A newspaper is exactly the kind of business to hire based on your personal narrative (including 100% of protected class intersections). That's the entire point of the opinion column. Granted, I don't think that the folks being discussed here are publishing any personal opinions, and I doubt the times is doing anything legally actionable or we would have heard about it, but the idea that they don't consider these factors just because it's illegal is laughable.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by pc86 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:19PM (#41513407)
Yeah I didn't phrase it very well, what I meant was that you're not applying for any old job on the tech team. You apply for a specific job, presumably one you're qualified for that would be a step up in your career.

If you look at a very small sample of people and one racial minority or gender has all the "lower" jobs, that doesn't tell you what jobs they were "offered" it just tells you what jobs they applied for.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by darby_nine on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:52PM (#41516901)
I'm pretty conflicted answering this. On one hand reporting is miserable; on the other hand it's virtually impossible to exclude bias in hiring, especially if the hiring requires skills that people pay to learn.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by keeganpoppen on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:21PM (#41515819)
man the downvotes on this thread are all over the place-- people need to take a long, hard look in the mirror about what discourse they actually tolerate, vs what they tell themselves... it's absurd. at best this comment is mildly combative, but it doesn't seem like OP took it personally, as they shouldn't have, but yet... downvote city. it's especially bizarre because i couldn't even tell you what ideological trigger shibboleth is being triggered here, even...
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by pc86 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @08:52AM (#41520305)
I try not to talk about voting on here per the guidelines, but it is pretty interesting to me the cross-section of completely legitimate, valid viewpoints that will get obliterated if they're mentioned on the wrong thread. Like everyone else I'm predisposed to think my particular ideology is slightly more persecuted than the other one but it doesn't even seem to be liberal v. conservative, authoritarian v. libertarian, or Democrat vs. Republican. I'm sure the initial thread topic has something to do with it and I do recall dang saying they keep an eye a little more closely on threads that are particularly political.

I'd be curious to see an analysis of downvoted comments in political threads and what their general ideological bent was.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by matrix87 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:48PM (#41513103)
how do you know the problem originates with the employer and isn't supply side?

if above demographics aren't getting CS majors (or whatever other educational equivalent), there isn't much prospective employers can do about it

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by umvi on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:03PM (#41513270)
I think it's more like:

- african americans are statistically more likely to originate from lower on socio economic ladder than, say, asian americans

Thus when you get a bunch of job applicants, you might get an asian american with a Yale degree (James) and an african american with a community college degree (John). Affirmative action or other DEI pressures might force you to hire both James and John, but James will probably be able to outperform John due to higher initial degree of education. Furthermore, James may have had parents who networked and ensured he got good internships and experience growing up while John didn't have that opportunity.

So it's not that the company is offering John a "dog job", it's just, James's capacity to perform in current role and take on new responsibilities is at a higher initial state than John's, so it's not unthinkable he would climb corporate ladder faster than John given those initial advantages. Pay gap is a natural consequence that follows.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by TheMagicHorsey on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:37PM (#41513555)
I don't really think a Yale degree makes you better than someone with a community college degree. There's no magic at Yale. The education you get everywhere is pretty good now because of all the resources universally available to all students.

But Yale basically applies a filter function and attracts the top 0.01% of high school graduates every year (plus some less elite legacy students and DEI admits). When you hire a Yale graduate, that's what you are paying for. Not the Yale education. If you could find a similar filter function some other way, you'd hire that 0.01% of high school graduates via that filter function.

And in fact companies are always trying to get ahead of their competitors and find other, less well-known, filter functions to get high performers who others don't know about. In the 1980s and 1990s Microsoft was among the first to discover that Indian IIT graduates were products of an extreme filter function applied to Indian high school students (IIT grads are like top 0.0001% of Indian high school grads). For a long time Microsoft hired those engineers for cents on the dollar. By the 2000s though, the word was out ... hiring IIT grads is as difficult as getting any other high performing grads.

There was also a brief period of time when Google had an edge in recruiting by identifying high school kids who were good at programming competitions online and via contributors to projects in Google's open source projects. But now, that signal is well-known too.

So John's community college degree doesn't matter if John is an elite performer.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by drivebyhooting on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:51PM (#41513672)
As someone who has studied at both kinds of schools I can tell you there is a WORLD of difference. In a middling school the professor was constantly providing remedial education to the students and had to cut down the curriculum breadth and depth.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by TheMagicHorsey on Thursday September 12, 2024 @08:59PM (#41527180)
When we are talking about the elite 0.01% of students the professor is irrelevant for regular coursework. They are almost uniformly autodidacts. A mentor is of course useful at the very boundaries of knowledge that textbooks and papers don't cover. But by the time you are in that range of work, you will be recognized through your performance, and you can find mentors by reaching out to them with links to your work.

Generally, people are completely unaware of what top 0.01% of performance looks like because we are so rarely around these people unless we are in some very elite institution or working on some project which attracts such people.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by smabie on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:21PM (#41513942)
Your entire comment basically talks about how a Yale degree means you probably better tho?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by codr7 on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @03:00PM (#41514285)
Better at playing the Yale game, which is obviously useful in this society but says little else about the person.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by smabie on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:45PM (#41515931)
Useful in society says a lot?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by IncreasePosts on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:07PM (#41513318)
Not really. Imagine if it takes 20 years to acquire some senior status, and the world was 100% sexist/racist/whatever 20 years ago(so only white men were allowed) but 0% now, you would have a bunch of white men as senior rank even though the world isn't sexist/racist/whatever any more.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by yodsanklai on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:11PM (#41513348)
I don't know if employers can solve the issue of not finding qualified candidates coming from minorities if there are very few such candidates.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by jimbokun on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:48PM (#41513642)
Employers are not responsible for forcing people to do the work required to be qualified for a position the employers are trying to fill.

Among the people who are qualified for the position, they are prohibited by law from considering race or gender or other protected characteristics when making a hiring decision.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by dwallin on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:14AM (#41512141)
It's notable that you completely skipped over the following point:

> Two-thirds of the members fired by New York Times management since the Times Tech Guild formed have been from underrepresented groups.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by loeg on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:05PM (#41512677)
The statistic, just like the other ones, doesn't tell you whether these firings were reasonable or not.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by darby_nine on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:42PM (#41513043)
Our labor laws are so weak in this country this is nearly impossible to determine unless someone fucked up.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by whimsicalism on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:26AM (#41512273)
this seems like it could easily be a symptom of aff action policies. Making it so firings have to be perfectly representative will discourage companies like these from taking a chance on an underrepresented candidate who might have a slightly weaker resumé if they are stuck with the decision
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by bushbaba on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:41AM (#41512429)
Affirmative action at the companies I’ve worked at was hard to hire less qualified individuals into roles. Those folks were often under performing but marked as “meets” at request of hr. Now with economy and other factors, they are being performance managed out given a worse output/impact than peers at same level.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by BurningFrog on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:43PM (#41513050)
Note that a majority of the employees can easily be from underrepresented groups.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by jimbokun on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:52PM (#41513680)
That's worthy of further investigation to understand if there's bias in these decisions or some other explanatory factor.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by not_wyoming on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @12:37PM (#41512990)
This line of questioning is often brought up in response to pay gap conversations. Universal trends do not explain individual data points, but in general, studies do seem to indicate that pay gaps are real.

https://www.epi.org/publication/what-is-the-gender-pay-gap-a...

https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2016/07/01/racial-ge...

https://www.americanprogress.org/article/women-of-color-and-...

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by jimbokun on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:41PM (#41513588)
I scanned the first article.

It's difficult to parse, because it says that experience and occupational choice does pay a significant role in the gap. But then editorializes and claims that less experience and occupational choice are due to discriminatory issues in the broader culture.

Culture war issues like this are unfalsifiable in either direction and largely reflect the political persuasion of the person making the argument than anything quantifiable.

Here's another example from the American Progress article:

> Women of color disproportionately work in jobs within the service, care, and domestic work sectors—jobs with historically low pay.

This is an empirically verifiable claim.

> This is due to occupational segregation, which is the funneling of women and men into different jobs based on gender and racial norms and expectations

This is an unfalsifiable political claim. Some unknown force, by some unknown mechanism, forces people to make certain choices.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by busterarm on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @01:59PM (#41513744)
It's funny, every hedge fund and tech startup I've ever worked at since roughly 2001 very proudly boasts about how they pay women more than the men.

But as my career goes on into the years I find that I'm working with less women and less minorities and not more. Despite the best of efforts...

If I were to look for evidence though, I would point things squarely at the interview process... In the past if you could operate a computer you were hired and assumed you would figure it out. Nowadays it's much more about fitting a certain narrative that's largely down to socioeconomic factors... I don't think I've ever worked with someone in tech who went to an HBCU, but lots of people who were token at NYU, Yale, etc...

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by echelon on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @03:19PM (#41514493)
It isn't the interviewing.

I conducted around 500 interviews at my last company at all stages: initial screen, technical, architectural, etc. There were simply far more white men applying. (And this is in Atlanta where we have a highly bimodal racial distribution.)

It wasn't like we weren't bending over backwards to attract diverse candidates. I personally went to HBCUs on outreach programs, and there were dozens of annual Girls / Women Who Code programs and partnerships that other folks on my team participated in.

I was once even told I couldn't recommend someone for a role because they weren't diverse.

Look to undergraduate enrollment.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by busterarm on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @08:28PM (#41516518)
You're looking at it too narrowly. In fairness, I should have said "it's the recruiting process".

It's not the "interviewing" itself but it's the recruiting stage. If you're looking at fresh graduates you're already significantly skewing things. It's hard to blame companies for this, but a few of the bootcamps are cranking out nontraditional candidates and many companies still overlook them in hiring.

Remember that story from the other day about founding Valve and Gabe recruiting game modders to his team? Two of them were pizza delivery guys and thought they were being called on a prank.

To be honest though, I think we're all lying to ourselves. The job isn't about ability to code. We're not looking for people with those skills. Most companies hiring are looking for stable clock-punchers who will do things that make their manager look good.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by jimbokun on Thursday September 12, 2024 @09:07AM (#41520482)
So stability and ability to complete assigned tasks are not relevant characteristics for an employee?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by TeaBrain on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:30AM (#41522036)
In today's market, most companies will automatically filter out bootcamper applications regardless of candidate background. It shouldn't be considered unusual that a subset of those are not being hired.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by tracker1 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:54AM (#41522266)
About 3/4 of the bootcamp learners I've interviewed only did the minimum to get through the course(s). I've found the biggest differentiator for bootcamp learners are those who did more than they were assigned and those who only did what they were assigned. There seems to be a very significant basic knowledge and skill gap between those two groups. It's even more significant in my experience than those with a more traditional education or self-taught.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by WalterBright on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:39PM (#41514089)
> Women, who make up 41% of the Tech Guild, earn 12% less on average than men

Such statistics are meaningless without more context. For example, are women over-represented in entry level positions? Do they work the same hours? the same overtime? And so forth.

Articles that present such statistics are pushing propaganda.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by kelseyfrog on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @03:56PM (#41514816)
Your sea-lioning is making HN worse. Can you please refrain from it and follow the guidelines?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by salmonfamine on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @04:07PM (#41514911)
How is this sea-lioning? The evidence being requested is highly pertinent to the discussion.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by keeganpoppen on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:17PM (#41515789)
did they commit thought crime or something? any even semi-competent statistician would have these questions, and any semi-competent journalist would question numbers being produced by an organization that are being used to promulgate that organization's agenda. and, moreover, we both know that the likelihood that these numbers actually properly control for these things is essentially 0. the sad thing is that if they did actually do the right thing, the numbers would be not as fair, but much more heinous and actionable. as it is there is absolutely no conclusion to draw for anyone involved-- how is the NYT supposed to fix the policy when they cannot even divine whether it's an underpromotion problem vs a recruiting problem vs an outright racism problem? isn't the goal to get them to fix things? the fixes for those three things are DRAMATICALLY different from one another.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Manuel_D on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:23PM (#41515832)
The above commenter is asking for relevant facts. If Job A pays more than Job B and there's a larger proportion of men in Job A then men's average pay will be higher, but both genders are receiving equal pay for equal work.

If anything, your allegations of sealioning are violating HN's guideline "Assume good faith."

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by missedthecue on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:30PM (#41515868)
I've always wondered why companies don't overhire women to save on labor costs.

The only explanations I can rationalize is that management isnt aware of the pay difference, or they are aware but they're more sexist than they are greedy.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by WalterBright on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:58PM (#41516359)
> I've always wondered why companies don't overhire women to save on labor costs.

And you should, as any selfish greedy company would do exactly that.

The beauty of the free market is it relies on selfish, greedy behavior to produce prosperity, rather than hopelessly trying to crush such behavior.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Manuel_D on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:35PM (#41515897)
Because the reality is that when you adjust for type of job, experience, and hours worked the wage disparity effectively disappears: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2017/08/01/are-wome...
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by aiisjustanif on Monday September 16, 2024 @10:31AM (#41556504)
That is from 2017 and focuses on 3 European countries only.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Manuel_D on Monday September 16, 2024 @01:02PM (#41558110)
From Wikipedia: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_pay_gap#:~:text=In%20....

> In the United States, for example, the non-adjusted average woman's annual salary is 79–83% of the average man's salary, compared to 95–99% for the adjusted average salary

It's the same in essentially every western developed country. Discrimination on the basis of gender is no longer accepted, the disparities that persist are due to different choices.

If women were paid less for the same work companies would benefit from staffing mostly women.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:19PM (#41516738)
Same reason Republicans voted more heavily against Jim Crowe laws/for the civil rights act. Green is the only color that matters.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Der_Einzige on Thursday September 12, 2024 @08:02AM (#41519822)
In that era republicans were the more liberal party and the north voted for them.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by tracker1 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:41AM (#41522140)
I think that today is very interesting in that a lot of the R neocons of yesteryear have shifted to D neolibs today. It's really weird in a lot of ways.

Note: I've been pretty heavily libertarian minded for a long time, so this observation has mostly been an outside perspective even though I'm currently more inclined to move R as a secondary/pragmatic position. There are some aspects of R and D I'm inclined to support.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by gjvnq on Sunday September 15, 2024 @09:47PM (#41551993)
One explanation I've heard is that companies don't extract the same value from women as they do from men because society's sexism causes managers and peers to assign "low value tasks" disproportionately to women even when they have the same job description as their male counterparts.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:12PM (#41516704)
It’s not meaningless if you want to see women making at least as much as men regardless of the job and their skills. That’s the obvious implication of such statistics.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Manuel_D on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:30PM (#41517029)
But is that really a valuable goal? The market determines wages, and usually it's willing to favor sacrifices like a 24 hour oncall rotation. Don't those people deserve for the value of those sacrifices to be reflected in compensation?

"Equal pay for equal work" is a much more compelling goal in my view than "equal pay for unequal work".

Not to mention it's incentivize companies to cut the roles with artificially inflated wages. Imagine a government mandated that some component or material cost 15% more than market rate. You'd refactor your design with that new cost in mind, and reduce usage of that component. Similar deal with labor.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by tracker1 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:43AM (#41522164)
I'd counter it's more likely that you'd see even more corruption and revolving doors between civilian and govt roles. It's very easy to spend other people's money (govt spending from taxes).
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by rexpop on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:02AM (#41538035)
> is that really a valuable goal?

Congratulations, you've taken a swing at this troll's strawman.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Manuel_D on Sunday September 15, 2024 @01:48PM (#41549034)
It's not a straw man. In the UK, the government has stepped in and mandate that two different jobs be paid the same, in the pursuit of pay equity.

Specifically, they forced Next to pay their warehouse workers and retail workers the same. When the retail workers were asked why they wouldn't just take jobs in the warehouse, they responded to the effect of "it's a less pleasant job, you'd have to pay me a lot more money to do it." Yet the UK mandated equal wages on account of the fact that more retail workers were women, and market rate wages created a net pay disparity (though women and men in the same roles were paid the same).

https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2024/09/eq...

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by TeaBrain on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:25AM (#41521976)
The intended implication of the presented statistic is obvious, but the actual disparity is impossible to realize without context on the types of positions being included in the statistic.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:10PM (#41516698)
No that’s for all members of the tech guild which includes designers, engineers, etc of varying skill levels.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by neilyio on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:57AM (#41522306)
A lot of comments on this thread seem to feel like the “why” of this matter is settled with an answer of “The men have more experience and are working higher-level jobs. Therefore, they receive higher pay.”

This is not the equilibrium we are aiming for as a society, and the matter is not settled here.

The point of these measurements is not to demand that women are paid more for less work. The point is for us to keep asking “why”, and not just stop after the first one.

“Why are women earning less at the New York Times?”. Maybe the company is just top-heavy with men in leadership roles. This has been floated in this thread as a common cause.

“Why are there more men in leadership roles?”. A few commenters have shared anecdotes of having far more men in their recruiting process. More men applying would help explain more experienced men higher up in the company.

“Why are there more men than women applying?”. We’re getting closer to root causes now. In software engineering, for example, there are just more men in the workforce.

“Why are there more men in the workforce?”. It gets more difficult, but also more important, to investigate the answer at these lower levels. Girls Who Code and similar initiatives are tackling this behemoth cultural problem. It will take years to see the effect of their work, but their success breeds hope that someday, the gap in this New York Times statistic will close a little.

At any of these levels, a company can step in and try and correct the natural bias in their hiring or development pipeline. That is, of course, the most sensitive topic for a lot of us here. Such initiatives should have buy-in from the workforce, and there’s an implication here that the (unionized) workers of NYT do support some kind of intervention.

Their choice, and above all the very measurement of a wage gap, doesn’t need to be threatening to anybody here. It will forever be important to track this number even if we “feel” like the explanations are simple. It doesn’t represent some kind of action the company should be forced to take. It measures where we are on every level of asking “why?”.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by janalsncm on Thursday September 12, 2024 @06:20PM (#41526259)
The issue is that we can’t make reliable judgements about the hiring or promotion process based on the outputs without more information about the inputs. But I agree, the answer is more information, not less.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by jimbokun on Friday September 13, 2024 @03:27PM (#41534323)
"We" don't have to do any of those things.

There is no need for a society that forces, top down, every possible occupation to be perfectly split 50/50 by sex. Just let individuals make their own decisions.

In this case, why do we "need" more women coding? Maybe they are doing other work that is just as important and fulfilling and useful to society?

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by janalsncm on Thursday September 12, 2024 @06:07PM (#41526130)
The bit you’re quoting is one of the complaints people have raised. It is not the only complaint, and given the near unanimous support for the strike it is not even likely the biggest complaint. They also mention the company handing out PIPs like candy and fears from automation, problems I think many people on this site can sympathize with.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by darthrupert on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @11:58AM (#41512597)
What percentage of workers are in the union?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by VirusNewbie on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @08:26PM (#41516502)
It tells me most of the talent left.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by aiisjustanif on Monday September 16, 2024 @10:37AM (#41556563)
I think it is absurd that people imply that highly skilled individuals do not unionize or should never.