News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by WalterBright on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @02:39PM (#41514089)
> Women, who make up 41% of the Tech Guild, earn 12% less on average than men

Such statistics are meaningless without more context. For example, are women over-represented in entry level positions? Do they work the same hours? the same overtime? And so forth.

Articles that present such statistics are pushing propaganda.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by kelseyfrog on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @03:56PM (#41514816)
Your sea-lioning is making HN worse. Can you please refrain from it and follow the guidelines?
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by salmonfamine on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @04:07PM (#41514911)
How is this sea-lioning? The evidence being requested is highly pertinent to the discussion.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by keeganpoppen on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:17PM (#41515789)
did they commit thought crime or something? any even semi-competent statistician would have these questions, and any semi-competent journalist would question numbers being produced by an organization that are being used to promulgate that organization's agenda. and, moreover, we both know that the likelihood that these numbers actually properly control for these things is essentially 0. the sad thing is that if they did actually do the right thing, the numbers would be not as fair, but much more heinous and actionable. as it is there is absolutely no conclusion to draw for anyone involved-- how is the NYT supposed to fix the policy when they cannot even divine whether it's an underpromotion problem vs a recruiting problem vs an outright racism problem? isn't the goal to get them to fix things? the fixes for those three things are DRAMATICALLY different from one another.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Manuel_D on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:23PM (#41515832)
The above commenter is asking for relevant facts. If Job A pays more than Job B and there's a larger proportion of men in Job A then men's average pay will be higher, but both genders are receiving equal pay for equal work.

If anything, your allegations of sealioning are violating HN's guideline "Assume good faith."

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by missedthecue on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:30PM (#41515868)
I've always wondered why companies don't overhire women to save on labor costs.

The only explanations I can rationalize is that management isnt aware of the pay difference, or they are aware but they're more sexist than they are greedy.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by WalterBright on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @07:58PM (#41516359)
> I've always wondered why companies don't overhire women to save on labor costs.

And you should, as any selfish greedy company would do exactly that.

The beauty of the free market is it relies on selfish, greedy behavior to produce prosperity, rather than hopelessly trying to crush such behavior.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Manuel_D on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @06:35PM (#41515897)
Because the reality is that when you adjust for type of job, experience, and hours worked the wage disparity effectively disappears: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2017/08/01/are-wome...
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by aiisjustanif on Monday September 16, 2024 @10:31AM (#41556504)
That is from 2017 and focuses on 3 European countries only.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Manuel_D on Monday September 16, 2024 @01:02PM (#41558110)
From Wikipedia: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_pay_gap#:~:text=In%20....

> In the United States, for example, the non-adjusted average woman's annual salary is 79–83% of the average man's salary, compared to 95–99% for the adjusted average salary

It's the same in essentially every western developed country. Discrimination on the basis of gender is no longer accepted, the disparities that persist are due to different choices.

If women were paid less for the same work companies would benefit from staffing mostly women.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:19PM (#41516738)
Same reason Republicans voted more heavily against Jim Crowe laws/for the civil rights act. Green is the only color that matters.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Der_Einzige on Thursday September 12, 2024 @08:02AM (#41519822)
In that era republicans were the more liberal party and the north voted for them.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by tracker1 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:41AM (#41522140)
I think that today is very interesting in that a lot of the R neocons of yesteryear have shifted to D neolibs today. It's really weird in a lot of ways.

Note: I've been pretty heavily libertarian minded for a long time, so this observation has mostly been an outside perspective even though I'm currently more inclined to move R as a secondary/pragmatic position. There are some aspects of R and D I'm inclined to support.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by gjvnq on Sunday September 15, 2024 @09:47PM (#41551993)
One explanation I've heard is that companies don't extract the same value from women as they do from men because society's sexism causes managers and peers to assign "low value tasks" disproportionately to women even when they have the same job description as their male counterparts.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @09:12PM (#41516704)
It’s not meaningless if you want to see women making at least as much as men regardless of the job and their skills. That’s the obvious implication of such statistics.
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Manuel_D on Wednesday September 11, 2024 @10:30PM (#41517029)
But is that really a valuable goal? The market determines wages, and usually it's willing to favor sacrifices like a 24 hour oncall rotation. Don't those people deserve for the value of those sacrifices to be reflected in compensation?

"Equal pay for equal work" is a much more compelling goal in my view than "equal pay for unequal work".

Not to mention it's incentivize companies to cut the roles with artificially inflated wages. Imagine a government mandated that some component or material cost 15% more than market rate. You'd refactor your design with that new cost in mind, and reduce usage of that component. Similar deal with labor.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by tracker1 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:43AM (#41522164)
I'd counter it's more likely that you'd see even more corruption and revolving doors between civilian and govt roles. It's very easy to spend other people's money (govt spending from taxes).
Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by rexpop on Saturday September 14, 2024 @03:02AM (#41538035)
> is that really a valuable goal?

Congratulations, you've taken a swing at this troll's strawman.

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by Manuel_D on Sunday September 15, 2024 @01:48PM (#41549034)
It's not a straw man. In the UK, the government has stepped in and mandate that two different jobs be paid the same, in the pursuit of pay equity.

Specifically, they forced Next to pay their warehouse workers and retail workers the same. When the retail workers were asked why they wouldn't just take jobs in the warehouse, they responded to the effect of "it's a less pleasant job, you'd have to pay me a lot more money to do it." Yet the UK mandated equal wages on account of the fact that more retail workers were women, and market rate wages created a net pay disparity (though women and men in the same roles were paid the same).

https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2024/09/eq...

Re:New York Times tech workers union votes to authorize a st... by TeaBrain on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:25AM (#41521976)
The intended implication of the presented statistic is obvious, but the actual disparity is impossible to realize without context on the types of positions being included in the statistic.