* There was an option of making this non-intrusive, by requiring it to be a browser setting, they chose not to
* The law went into effect ~6 years ago
* Companies still break the law by employing dark patterns
My take is that it makes both the law, and the courts bad.Clearly, national prosecution authorities can't be arsed and we don't have enough citizen-activists filing strong lawsuits.
In an ideal case, if it was just a law, a simpler wording could be "you are allowed to collect anonymized data, but not monetize/share it without permission from users. We may ask you to furnish proof that you havent been doing that at times, failing which you would face massive fines (as %age of revenue whatever)."
Problem is collecting basic anonymized usage data[1] is needed by companies to improve the product, provide a better experience, detect misuse. They bundled those use cases with everything else meaning the law was too broad and we got cookie banners given every site needs basic analytics. On flipside, worst is that most websites use Google Analytics, so they might have had to display the banners anyway.
[1] Moreover, it's vaguely worded so we companies do not know if they have committed a GDPR offence. By general understanding IP addresses are under GDPR. You can get that via request headers. So, to be on the safe side, even anonymized analytics tracking is considered under GDPR
> Moreover, it's vaguely worded so we companies do not know if they have committed a GDPR offence.
Only if they are trying to skirt the law.
notice the part about how purposes cannot be bundled together. EU's own website does that till date.
> NOT needed to improve your website
When I say usage data, aggregated data about how many people bounced off my page, or how long it took for my webpage to load under different internet connections is absolutely needed for me to make sure every user that comes on the page is having a good enough experience. I may not save any info, but those numbers are definitely used in aggregate. if the bounce rate is too high, content is not useful for people i am reaching. If i cant know that, how does the webpage gets better. That is usage data. I do not care about who the person is, but I would want to know whether it was one person doing one action 100 times or 100 different people doing the same action. Makes a massive difference.
I've clicked 3 cookie banners today alone and its not even 2pm yet.
How many cookie banners have I clicked in my life so far? How many cookie banners can I expect to click over the remaining 40-50 years of my life?
The law is objectively bad.
No, the websites you visit are probably bad.
Which cookies did you have to accept/reject? What do they do? Why do the websites believe they must ask you to accept them?
Also, the law allow browsers to automatically accept/reject the cookies on your behalf (actually, the law does not care about which specific technology the websites use to collect and process personal data). You, as a user, can choose a browser/extension that rejects these cookies by default, except the necessary ones. I use https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/istilldontcar... and I haven't see a single cookie banner for years on desktop and mobile. I don't like cookies and I like the law.
(Also, if a lot of people did choose the 'everyone all the time' setting, that would arguably be a poor outcome, because it's unlikely that this is really what people want.)
The adtech will absolutely freak out and destroy any attempt to make such setting as soon as there's a risk of it working.
The only alternative to that binary logic is cookie banners. So to be clear, you are advocating for cookie banners.
The reality is that the overwhelming majority of people do legitimately want option 1, which makes cookie banners redundant. The only reason that cookie banners exist is as a high pressure sales tactic to sell users into option 3.
So yeah, you can never compel a site designer to stop doing a thing without compelling them to stop do that thing. The only middle ground is a middle ground.
>The point is that you'd still get cookie banners even with option 1
Instead law is written in a technology neutral way. It is so neutral that it isn't even called "cookie law". It is called ePrivacy directive. It has only 5 times the mention of "cookie" as an example.
Reference: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=celex%3A...
The law does not mandate websites to display a cookie banner. There are already "Do not track" settings in browsers. A website could choose to honor that setting and don't track you without ever showing you a cookie banner. But most don't.
They didn't do this before the regulation. It doesn't much matter whether a website could do better, they simply aren't going to do better unless forced to.
> A website could choose to honor that setting and don't track you without ever showing you a cookie banner. But most don't.
Exactly! Either fix the regulation to say they can't make UX worse or throw it away.
Yes, because they just tracked you and you didn't have a choice and didn't even know that they were tracking you probably.
You don't seem to understand what GDPR does. Very simply, it says: "Hey, if you run a website and want to store cookies in your visitors browsers that helps you track them, you need to ask them first if that's ok".
There are multiple paths websites could take:
1) Don't set tracking cookies -> No need to ask the visitor for consent
2) Honor "do not track" headers sent by browsers -> Only need to ask visitor for consent if the browser didn't set "do not track" header
3) Ask the visitors, but do it in a nice way that doesn't disrupt the whole browsing experience -> some examples are given in the blog post
There are a lot of browser extension that hide or click reject cookies for you, so you don't need to see 99% of all cookie banners. Have you tried using some of them?
>Instead through incompetent government employees
Or greedy companies, one of the two...
There's no loophole. There's just limited enforcement. Most of the banners you see every day do not match the requirements at all.
Even worse, this thread is full of armchair lawyers that will confidently tell you there's no need for cookie banners in particular cases. Nevermind that there's hardly any case law about this and each country seems to interpret it differently. Any actual lawyer would tell you to slap it on there to stay protected.
I bet the number of cases of illegal implementations due to insufficient consent are vastly smaller than the blatantly illegal consent implementations(i.e. those that make it harder to reject consent than accept it). Companies clearly don't care about following the law anyway.
Presumably, lawyers err on the side of caution? That doesn't mean they're right.
I'm not talking just de-emphasising the reject option here, but cases where there is no reject option or it's buried beneath 2-3 more clicks.
...
Any actual lawyer would tell you
Assuming you're not yourself a lawyer, doesn't speculating about what an actual lawyer would say or do make you an armchair lawyer?
Sometimes life really is is fact a zero sum game and you need to punish the offenders in order to protect the victims.
In my opinion the EU's big failure with GDPR has been slow and ineffective enforcement against blatantly illegal implementations.
GDPR's Article 7 [0] is very clear:
> 3. The data subject shall have the right to withdraw his or her consent at any time. The withdrawal of consent shall not affect the lawfulness of processing based on consent before its withdrawal. Prior to giving consent, the data subject shall be informed thereof. It shall be as easy to withdraw as to give consent. [emphasis mine]
[0] https://gdpr.eu/article-7-how-to-get-consent-to-collect-pers...
Regarding the link you posted, they have a banner at the bottom saying:
> We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. [Ok] [No] [Privacy Policy]
My understanding was that such an implicit consent ("we will assume that you are happy with it") is not legal so I find it a bit surprising to see it used on a website dedicated to the GDPR.
The enforcement/implementation of a law is so deeply entwined with the text that it's deceptive to separate them.
If a law is written in a way so as to make enforcement hard, or if the government doesn't have the resources to quickly and consistently apply it, then it's a bad law because it enables weaponized targeted enforcement of a new law that wasn't present before.
> a lack of resourcing to quickly enforce laws makes those laws bad
Is true, and you haven't refuted it, only used the emotionally manipulative phrase "bad faith argument".
You literally say it's "deceptive to separate them". The whole POINT of modern governance is to separate them.
Saying legislature is writing "bad laws" because the judiciary may or may not have the resources to enforce is to necessarily subjugate the legislature to the judiciary which violates the principles of separation in the first place.
There are countless examples of legislation that does not get litigated due to political or other pressures on the judiciary. Your argument would require that the legislature lie down in those cases. Perhaps that is your preferred order of the world.
But in a modern, principled government, the entire principle is their separation and independence. Suggesting otherwise is to lean into autocracy, whatever your motives.
This is wildly incorrect. The point is not separation - that is obviously stupid and pointless. The point is maintaining checks and balances on the power of the government, and one of the (many) mechanisms is through separation.
> Saying legislature is writing "bad laws" because the judiciary may or may not have the resources to enforce is to necessarily subjugate the legislature to the judiciary which violates the principles of separation in the first place.
Again, incorrect, because the principle is limiting power, not separation of powers test for its own sake. Not passing laws that can't be correctly enforced is not a violation of that goal or the strategy of separation of powers.
> There are countless examples of legislation that does not get litigated due to political or other pressures on the judiciary. Your argument would require that the legislature lie down in those cases.
Nowhere did I say that or does my argument imply or necessitate that. Being unable to enforce a law due to lack of resources is categorically different than political pressure. You're intentionally misinterpreting my words
> But in a modern, principled government, the entire principle is their separation and independence.
This is your own projection of what a "modern", "principled" government should look like - which, as stated before, is obviously stupid and pointless. Separation is not a virtue - it's a means to an end. You may want to consider reading the US Constitution to see this in action.
"Prior to giving consent, the data subject shall be informed thereof."
Means there must be some sort of a cookie notification (which could of course take a small space of the screen, but still).
The existence of this notification makes it easier to initially give consent. If withdrawing later is to be as easy, the notification must never disappear.
The law could have been written in such a way that we could use a browser setting and avoid incessent popups which irritate users and desensitise them to genuinely useful warnings.
Whatever the good intentions of EU lawmakers, they seem inept at technical legislation because they ALLOW companies to continue doing shady things, and rather than tackle it, the legislators create a law that merely annoys users.
No they don't. But enforcement requires complaints, actions, and budgets. Remember that the EU has no police, it's down to national governments to enforce regulations.
Also, take fraud. There are plenty of laws against fraud in any country - and still it happens every day in one way or another. That's not because all fraud laws are bad, but because enforcement is complex and costly.
as written elsewhere (since you obviously didn't read anything) your proposed solution would be just fine. But people opted out of impmenting it that way since it would yield less profit.
Also, if you feel certain, and a ready to defend in court, that practices you have on your website does not constitute tracking. Then you don't have to show the banner either.
Personally, I am much more pragmatic about these regulations - with good reason. I still have to hear about some small innocent company hit with a massive fine. Empirically speaking, it is mostly huge multinational companies with plenty of resources to manage these things down into details who have gotten fines after repeat offences.
All in all. If you assume malicious regulators, then it is going to be stressful to work in a market. From US influence, I also do understand the sentiment, though it is rarely mirrored with EU citizens who generally don't assume hostile regulation.
I don't think that's a specialization of EU lawmakers, particularly. A far as I can recall, laemakers started thinking about internet regulation around the turn of the millenium, and I didn't welcome the prospect; I assumed that regulation would favour state intelligence and police agencies, and would be drafted by adtech lobbyists. Why? Because I didn't think the civil servants who are supposed to draft these laws had the requisite competence.
This kind of behavior reminds me of the book: "Language vs. Reality: Why Language Is Good for Lawyers and Bad for Scientists" - Nick Enfield, Linguistic Anthropologist [1]
[1] https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262548465/language-vs-reality/
We deal with similar issues developing and releasing software. Instead of not ever releasing software, or only writing perfect software that never has issues, we have a couple of options.
1) In critical life or death situations, spend a ton of time modeling all states of the system and program in a way that very strictly controls for these states, with a lot of testing. See NASA/JPL coding standards for critical systems.
2) For less critical situations, or those were modeling all states of the system are impractical, we release, observe, and iterate. Yes there will be edge cases, bugs, and loopholes. But we can observe them, iterate, and release updates.
I think case 1) is impractical for changes to large legal and economic frameworks in the real world given how many variables are at play. If we could model the entire economy and see how it would react to a given change, the world would be a very different place in lots of ways already.
A lot of politics seems to work against 2) and that hurts our ability to improve things. "I will pass a law that does X" and "I will repeal the law Y that is not working, see look at these loopholes!" are good political campaign statements.
"I will gather and analyze data on the operation of the current system and support an iterative change that intends to improve things, implement that change, and then observe the results to determine if future changes are needed" is hard to rally around either in campaigning or when actually doing the work of getting political support to pass law.
I think decent example of this in government, although far from perfect, is the feedback loop of the NTSB and FAA. The NTSB's job is to observe and report on failures of air safety, and the FAA's job is to apply those lessons to future air regulation. Of course there are many examples of this not working perfectly, but it's a more concrete feedback loop than most governmental action has.
More observation of the analysis of the impact of laws after they are passed, and follow-up iterations where we compare the expected and actual results and make updates, would probably result in a lot less gnashing of teeth over "bad government regulation" but I'm not sure how we get there politically.
It has even been implemented in Internet Explorer when it had 90%+ market share.
And then Google intentionally sent malformed P3P header to bypass user preferences in IE.
When Safari added a heuristic rejecting Google's 3rd party cookies, Google has found a technical workaround to bypass it (and has been fined for doing this).
When IE and P3P were totally dead, browsers have tried to give adtech the simplest to implement bare minimum setting - the DNT header. The adtech has completely ignored it.
There are trillion-dollar businesses relying on tracking, and they will do whatever they can to undermine any technology and lobby against any law that would harm their business.
If the cookie law was written properly then it would have just been a browser setting that had to be respected and this whole thing would have been completely transparent to the end user and they would have benefitted by default.
Instead through incompetent government employees we now have cookie banners for the rest of eternity on almost every site and they're not even standardized so worst sites like where journalists publish can have more and more obtuse ones.