(Also, if a lot of people did choose the 'everyone all the time' setting, that would arguably be a poor outcome, because it's unlikely that this is really what people want.)
The adtech will absolutely freak out and destroy any attempt to make such setting as soon as there's a risk of it working.
The only alternative to that binary logic is cookie banners. So to be clear, you are advocating for cookie banners.
The reality is that the overwhelming majority of people do legitimately want option 1, which makes cookie banners redundant. The only reason that cookie banners exist is as a high pressure sales tactic to sell users into option 3.
So yeah, you can never compel a site designer to stop doing a thing without compelling them to stop do that thing. The only middle ground is a middle ground.