News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by drooopy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:35AM (#39418534)
Nearly twenty five years ago, the DoJ nearly split Microsoft into two companies due to them abusing their position as an ecosystem gatekeeper. How did we go from that to the point where apple (or google even), acting both as gatekeeper and direct competitor, can dictate how another company can communicate things to its end users/customers?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:40AM (#39418557)
Probably because unlike 25 years ago, US lawmakers and enforcers, realized a large chunk of their economic dominance is dependent on big-tech abusing their market position as gatekeepers, so they intentionally look away when they see how much of their GDP these companies bring in, not to mention aiding the US dragnet mass-surveillance capabilities being the icing on the cake.

What else are they gonna do to earn $? It's not like the world is lining up to buy their ultra reliable and high quality cars and planes.

Sorry for the tongue in cheek.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by latexr on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:05AM (#39418713)
> big-tech abusing their market position as gatekeepers

No no, you see, that is called “innovation”. And whenever the EU does anything to try to curtail those abuses of power, what they are doing is stifling innovation. Because as we all know, the one thing that matters in life is growth growth growth, particularly company growth, and there’s nothing more innovative than coming up with ways to exploit people’s privacy and attention for profit. And if you can get the ones exploited to rally in your favour, you’ve hit the jackpot. All hail corporate America, let’s raise a glass to the obscenely rich getting richer at the expense of everyone else, that is working out great.

https://www.newyorker.com/cartoon/a16995

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:22AM (#39418842)
> the one thing that matters in life is growth growth growth, particularly company growth, and there’s nothing more innovative than coming up with ways to exploit people’s privacy and attention for profit.

But wait, there's more! The only reason growth is pushed for so hard is because most of the investors are retired or retiring soon and don't want to work any more. If the companies stop growing then their stock prices might go down. They gambled hard when they removed pensions from US companies and they can't lose the game before they die!

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lotsofpulp on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:40AM (#39419432)
> They gambled hard when they removed pensions from US companies and they can't lose the game before they die!

Defined benefit pensions and 401k get invested in the same thing.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:21AM (#39419742)
The difference is that if the stock market dips, you still get paid a pension for the set amount of time (paid out of company profits if it has to). With a 401k, you can watch years of your retirement disappear.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lotsofpulp on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:27AM (#39420313)
If the stock market dipped permanently, those pensions would not pay either because they are all invested in the same equities.

Hence why the government repeatedly provides a backstop whenever things start to take a downturn.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:14AM (#39419221)
> most of the investors are retired or retiring soon

Where are you getting this? Baby Boomers are smoothly transitioning their share of stock ownership to younger generations [1].

[1] https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/z1/dataviz/dfa/distr...

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:29AM (#39419355)
I don't know if you are making a joke, because the data says the exact opposite.

When the silent generation had 55% of the "total wealth" (and declining), boomers had 40% of the remainder, but now boomers have 55% (and climbing, instead of declining), and the younger generations only have 26% (combined).

It looks like they are still hoarding (for lack of a better term) wealth than relinquishing it.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:37AM (#39419407)
> When the silent generation had 55% of the "total wealth" (and declining), boomers had 40% of the remainder, but now boomers have 55% (and climbing, instead of declining), and the younger generations only have 26% (combined)

One, stock ownership, not total wealth.

Two, boomer share is declining after peaking around 2020. It’s flat-ish as they begin retiring. Gen X got screwed, but the pick-up among Millenials looks like a return to the norm. (Look at the Boomer/Silent share in the 1990s.)

Three, the generation on the precipice of dying, the Silents, are not the chief stockholders. Boomers still have decades to live. They’re not looking to eke out another year or two of growth at the long-term expense of anything, they need that decades-on value to bank on.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:18AM (#39419718)
Why did GenX get screwed? I though millennials got screwed by the 2009 crash.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by wwtrv on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:57AM (#39420635)
Weren't millennials a bit too young to have significant (or even any) amounts invested in the market back in 2009? And then they got live through one of the biggest stock market booms in history (which unlike dot.com didn't just blow up)?

OTH Gen X got a chance to lose their savings during the latter stages of dot.com and then again in 2009.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @02:58AM (#39438968)
Many millennials graduated from college and couldn't get a job due to the market crash. So, not only did they not have savings, they couldn't save if they wanted to. Then, by the time a good chunk could have savings and start investing, inflation slapped them in the face. Now, grocery shopping for a house full of kids is downright expensive. Not to mention, the amount of monthly bills a household is expected to pay is 4-500% of what their parents had to pay while wages have largely stayed the same, housing costs are through the roof because boomers want to make sure they get their "investments" back, and so on.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by xadhominemx on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:52AM (#39419504)
Is the status quo -- US and to a lesser extent, Chinese technology dominance -- preferable for Europe?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by drooopy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:09AM (#39418744)
All I can think of is where we'd be as a species now, at least technologically, If Microsoft, Apple, IBM or even Commodore and Atari had similar abilities since the 70s to restrict what kind of software developers can make and publish for their platforms...
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by pavlov on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:11AM (#39418761)
There have always been walled garden software platforms. Nintendo is a very successful example from the Commodore/Atari era.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by malermeister on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:44AM (#39419973)
Nintendos are specifically gaming devices, though. Smartphones are general purpose computing platforms.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by paulmd on Sunday February 18, 2024 @06:03PM (#39424428)
This is an artificial marketing distinction that you’ve bought into. And insofar as any particular apps exist or don’t on switch, it’s purely a result of gatekeeper decisions on the part of Nintendo - Nintendo keeps there from being an email client or an office suite and that’s the reason you perceive it as “just a gaming device”. They’ve gatekept successfully.

This is the problem, there really isn’t a coherent threshold between switch and iPhone or a reason console vendors shouldn’t be equally considered general purpose devices other than marketing. You could plug in some usb peripherals and run office suites on a PlayStation just fine.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Jensson on Monday February 19, 2024 @04:15AM (#39427611)
> This is an artificial marketing distinction that you’ve bought into

No, nobody buys a nintendo to do banking on them. I bought a phone since I needed it to do banking. This is a real difference, not just a marketing distinction.

> it’s purely a result of gatekeeper decisions on the part of Nintendo

Yes, and that gatekeeper power ensures Nintendo isn't a general purpose device. If they allowed it to be a general purpose device like Apple did with phones then things would be different.

Controlling such a major share of general purpose devices like Apple does is a serious issue. Controlling a share of gaming computing like Nintendo doesn't matter nearly as much, so therefore lawmakers aren't going after them to the same degree. It doesn't matter if technically they are the same, in practice one doesn't cause issues for society while the other one does.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Aurornis on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:14AM (#39419227)
But the most powerful general purpose computers we have are all wide open for development. A lot of us here write software on our laptops and desktops all day and can download and install whatever we want.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by dylan604 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:01AM (#39419577)
I too think it is funny that there is so much attention paid to a mobile device, but then am forced to remember for so so many of today's youngest "users" that mobile device is their only compute device. While you and I might look at the mobile device as just an additional thing that only gets used when away from keyboards, more and more people don't even have a keyboard to be away from.

I'm also much more sane about how retail works, and realize that MSRP vs retail pricing is how the world works. Expecting to earn full retail pricing while selling your wares through someone else's store is just farcical. Developing a product that can only work on someone else's product and then complains about the rules of that other product's maker puts in place is also just hubris.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by tomas789 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:53AM (#39418631)
Usually, I would not engage with this kind of conspiracy theory like comments but I think that this particular case has some merit.

We are solid in a gray zone where we have to decide where are priorities are. Fair market vs tech dominance in US is a great example. Another one is carbon neutrality vs strong industry in EU. I’m sure there are so many others.

It is just important to keep that in mind when building your business because we can easily slide from one side of this gray zone to the other.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by mjburgess on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:01AM (#39418687)
It's not a conspiracy theory, i'm not quite sure even how that term could possibly apply -- since this describes the ordinary practice of politics.

The modern republican party does not support anti-trust enforcement, or indeed, most executive enforcement of anti-corporate regulations. So when they are in office, there isnt any.

There's been some increasing bipartisan support for anti-tech anti-trust because republicans perceive them to be (largely accurately) biased towards the cultural left.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by roenxi on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:31AM (#39418923)
The Republicans would be exposing the thinking that has resulted in them losing almost every culture war battle in the last ... I don't know how long. The bureaucracies enforcing anti-trust will lean left. Eventually there will be a bias of anti-trust action used to break up any companies that look to be helping Republican candidate elected. It'll be these Donald Trump court cases all over again.

What actually works for the right is free markets. Turns out if they just leave YouTube alone they get Rumble. If they ignore Twitter they get X. If Amazon makes a habit of booting right-wing sites, there will be a right wing version of Amazon. There are more than enough right wing media consumers for a free market to reward right-leaning content. Anti-trust will eventually lead to overregulation and lock in of companies hostile to the right in general and republicans in particular.

There is a much better argument for anti-trust to try and defuse the risk of a vast an hasty flash-mob forming and doing something stupid, but as a political response it just isn't going to be effective.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by tester756 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:48AM (#39419042)
>What actually works for the right is free markets.

Have this "free market" thing ever been tried?

Take a look at e.g semiconductor industry.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Jensson on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:43AM (#39419000)
: The Republicans would be exposing the thinking that has resulted in them losing almost every culture war battle in the last

Conservatives always lose cultural battles in the end, that is why they are called conservatives they are the past the future is always progressive. Conservatives have short term victories but long term the conservatives become todays progressives, it is in the definition of the words.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by roenxi on Sunday February 18, 2024 @04:46PM (#39423737)
In the sense that civilisations eventually fall, yes. But as a practical matter until someone comes up with a better idea we should all be conserving capitalism, free markets, liberty and equality. Because the alternatives are much worse.

Just because progressives want to change things and change is technically inevitable doesn't mean we can't push the bad ideas out beyond the life of anyone breathing right now.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:16AM (#39419245)
> modern republican party does not support anti-trust enforcement, or indeed, most executive enforcement of anti-corporate regulations

The MAGA GOP is unsettled on antitrust. Its defining elements, however, are loyalty and a strong executive, so presumably there would be support for antitrust action against those deemed disloyal.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lapcat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:46AM (#39418589)
That's a nice sounding story, but what actually happened was that George W. Bush was awarded the Presidency after a 5-4 Supreme Court vote stopped the recount in Florida, and the Bush DoJ announced a slap on the wrist for Microsoft just a few days before 9/11, which wiped the story off the map, and everyone forgot.

(I'm not suggesting a 9/11 conspiracy, by the way.)

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:50AM (#39418609)
So Bush is to blame for the war on terror AND for failing to regulate Microsoft? Wow, just when I thought that being a war criminal was enough of a reason to be hated, now comes the cherry on top.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by votepaunchy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:50AM (#39418610)
Note that the Supreme Court ruled 7-2 that the recount was performed illegally. There would have been time for a legal recount had Florida not wasted time on a partisan recount.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lapcat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:20AM (#39418829)
This very misleading. It was an unusual per curiam opinion, not attributed to specific justices. The anonymous author of the opinion, who turned out to be Kennedy, “included Souter, Breyer and Stevens as agreeing that there were equal protection "problems" without consulting them.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bush_v._Gore#Equal_Protection_...
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by bsdpufferfish on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:19AM (#39419277)
I hadn't considered that people might still be complaining about Florida in 2000 in light of 2020.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lapcat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:53AM (#39419513)
I don't know what you're referring to by "in light of 2020", but in any case it wasn't a complaint, merely an observation.

The point was that there wasn't a "change of heart" about the Microsoft monopoly between 1999 and 2001, merely a change of power, and one that didn't necesssarily reflect the will of the people, who indisputably voted more for Gore than Bush, regardless of the Electoral College numbers.

It appears that the original comment by FirmwareBurner that I was replying to was edited substantially afterward to change the meaning, perhaps in reponse to my reply, which unfortunately removed some context that made sense of my reply.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by bryanrasmussen on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:27AM (#39419331)
what happened in 2020?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:51AM (#39419500)
accusations by Trump of getting the election stolen from him.

Personally, I think there were shenanigans going on and we should be investigating them but I also feel like the hanging chads was a far bigger issue than the shenanigans that happened in 2020.

I don't believe the election was stolen but I also don't believe it's everyone's imagination that some shady shit was going on in places. I suspect that kind of crap happens every election.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Timon3 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:41AM (#39419932)
Every election will have some shady stuff going on from all participating parties if it's big enough. But it's important to remember that every election has even more stuff going on that can look shady from the outside, but is absolutely normal on further inspection.

2020 was special because the sitting president (who has accused others of election and voter fraud against him in AFAIR every election he's been part of) has primed his emotionally invested base to expect fraud everywhere. They saw a bunch of things they thought were shady, part of which were caused by unrealistic expectations (e.g. "I can just show up and be Poll Watcher without registering beforehand"). If you are aware of shady going-ons that have not been investigated I'm open to hear them, but all the occurrences I've seen have been investigated and explained - but since many people aren't open to normal explanations, the fraud idea keeps and keeps on festering.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:21PM (#39421531)
this is a contradiction.

If every election has some shady things happen then it's not possible for every bit of shadiness to be explained as anything other than shadiness.

So was there shadiness or wasn't there?

A lot of it can be explained away, which is why I said the hanging chad issue was a bigger problem. but ALL of it? I don't think so, even at the time there were a few things that gave me pause.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Timon3 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:44PM (#39423080)
> this is a contradiction.

> If every election has some shady things happen then it's not possible for every bit of shadiness to be explained as anything other than shadiness.

> So was there shadiness or wasn't there?

I didn't say that there was absolutely no shadiness, but I haven't seen evidence that there was more shadiness than in any other election. The "evidence" brought forth for Trumps position that I've seen hasn't held up to scrutiny.

> A lot of it can be explained away, which is why I said the hanging chad issue was a bigger problem. but ALL of it? I don't think so, even at the time there were a few things that gave me pause.

You're free to share them if you'd like. All I'm saying is that I'm not aware of evidence brought forward that holds up to scrutiny, which leads me to believe that there was no significant deviation from the norm - the simpler explanation is that being primed for months by somebody with a lot of sway, combined with the strong distrust in non-partisan media, has led to these heaps of non-evidence (again, as far as I've seen, I'm happy to be proven wrong).

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by zer00eyz on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:50AM (#39418615)
Signal, Spotify...

Find an average (non tech) IOS user, and try to get them to switch to these apps.

Im guessing that there is a large intersection of "apple users" who also take their cars back to the dealership for oil changes and service. It's not stupidity, it's about creating an air of trust. Apple goes out of its way to keep customers trust (as do car dealers to an extent) because the money is in keeping a customer.

As an aside, the source of this complaint being Spotify is interesting. I would love to know from artist who pays better between the two (because I dont think its spottify)

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ksec on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:05AM (#39418708)
At least before 2023, one could argue Spotify were paying 15% of their revenue to Apple on iOS hence they pay less to artist. Not too sure about 2024
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by JustExAWS on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:29AM (#39420340)
Spotify hasn’t allowed in app purchases of subscriptions in a decade.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by matwood on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:55AM (#39418651)
There have been stories that Apple pays near the top of any streamers. How much of that gets to an artist remains a question.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:45AM (#39419016)
Probably because they don't have to pay themselves a 30% tax.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by matwood on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:00AM (#39419132)
Spotify doesn't allow in-app sign ups, so they don't pay 30% either. Try again.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:03AM (#39419151)
Where does spotify fit in here? If apple had to comply with it's own rules, do you think they would be able to continue to pay out more than the competition?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by drooopy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:28AM (#39418889)
According to reports, Apple pays the most to artists. But Apple also has the luxury of not having to pay a 30% commision fee to another company every time someone buys a subscription or a track via Apple music.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by FireBeyond on Sunday February 18, 2024 @06:39PM (#39424707)
That's not true, at least per stream. TIDAL is actually the most artist friendly, and it's not even close:

> Compared to Spotify, Apple Music pays a higher rate per stream. The exact amount varies from $0.006 to $0.008 per stream.

> Tidal, a high-fidelity music streaming service, pays artists one of the highest rates per stream, ranging from $0.0125 to $0.015 per stream.

Source: https://www.lalal.ai/blog/music-streaming-payouts-2023/

> Tidal also says its HiFi Plus tier pays significantly higher royalties per stream than its rivals, "at least 50% or more vs the regular rate across the four largest streaming services,”

Source: https://www.loudersound.com/features/which-music-streaming-s...

Also: https://producerhive.com/music-marketing-tips/streaming-roya...

> Let’s start with the elephant in the room. On average, Tidal pays $0.01 per stream, which is way above the $0.003/0.005 offered by Spotify.

> Though Tidal’s service being more profitable for artists is worth praising, the remuneration itself is not the biggest issue here, as it’s the way the revenue streams are distributed among artists.

> Spotify pays artists pro-rata, meaning they calculate the total streams within the platform and estimate the proportion each artist should receive.

> This model greatly favors prominent artists, often leaving independent musicians with mere cents even when they have a loyal and active fanbase.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by jwells89 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:16AM (#39420250)
I use Signal with a couple people but it’s not really set up for mass traction so I don’t expect it to become my primary messenger any time soon.

If I were to switch streaming services, Spotify would be dead last on my list, because they’re hypocritical — they pushed out third party devs building alternative players for paying users by deprecating libspotify, refuse to support interop with anything that’s not a Spotify Connect device (HomePod for example supports third party streaming, yet Spotify won’t use the APIs), have treated their users terribly with incessant AB tests and pushing content unrelated to music in their faces, and have spent a ridiculous amount of money trying to lock up and monetize what was previously the most democratic and available medium (podcasts).

At least Apple Music allows third party players and tries to support other ecosystems (Android + Chromecast).

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by troupo on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:37AM (#39420431)
> Find an average (non tech) IOS user, and try to get them to switch to these apps

You do know that Spotify has 600 million users? And that it got those users without practices like pushing its app in phone setup, account setup, settings, home screen, default music app, default music app in carplay etc.?

> As an aside, the source of this complaint being Spotify is interesting. I would love to know from artist who pays better between the two (because I dont think its spottify)

Neither pays artists directly. They pay money to rights holders. Why no one ever questions the rights holders is beyond my comprehension at this point.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by DavidPastrnak on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:58AM (#39420646)
> Why no one ever questions the rights holders is beyond my comprehension at this point.

I imagine most people either don’t care or don’t know this.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by crossroadsguy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:34PM (#39425340)
> Signal, Spotify...

> Find an average (non tech) IOS user, and try to get them to switch to these apps.

Interesting take :)

- the average user doesn’t even use Signal anywhere, let alone an average non-tech iOS user

- As for Spotify, you must mention geography (I guess that’s USA you meant) - because in some geographies Apple Music might not even be the third music app on an iPhone

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by barelysapient on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:07AM (#39418730)
Probably because Microsoft controlled 97% market share, but Apple controls about 20%.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by graemep on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:34AM (#39418943)
Depends how you define the market. The relevant definition here is users of Apple devices.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Aaargh20318 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:45AM (#39419020)
By that logic you can always make up a group in which a company controls 100% of the market.

Walmart should be forced to sell competitors products because they control the whole market for Walmart customers.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:08AM (#39419190)
If your only choice is to shop at Walmart, this sounds like a reasonable definition of a market.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by mrmanner on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:25AM (#39419320)
Moving to an area with more grocery stores is orders of magnitude more demanding than selecting another operating system next time you upgrade your phone or computer, though.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:34AM (#39419382)
> orders of magnitude more demanding than selecting another operating system

Having switched from Apple to Microsoft Phone to Android and back to Apple ... I disagree. In that time, I've moved states and even countries. Moving is far less demanding than switching operating systems. Moving is pretty simple: you pack, move, then unpack; and you even get to keep all your stuff! Switching operating systems requires researching for similar apps, purchasing them again, potentially copying music/photo libraries using sketchy tools, hunting down tutorials for how to do things you don't know how to do, etc.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by mrmanner on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:54AM (#39419524)
I don’t agree: Specifically if you live somewhere with only a single food store, there’s a decent likelihood that you’re either heavily invested in the area (farming, forestry, …) or that you can’t afford to live anywhere else.

More generally, moving means leaving friends, forcing kids to change schools, and if moving far, learning new laws and customs. Not to mention that packing and moving all that stuff takes days and/or costs thousands of moneys. Extracting files from Google Drive and iCloud is a pain, but is it _that_ bad?

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:10AM (#39419657)
> More generally, moving means leaving friends, forcing kids to change schools, and if moving far, learning new laws and customs.

Moving the goalpost are we? Sure, if you keep moving it far enough, long enough, then yeah, you'll find a set of conditions where this is no longer true (such as having a family, friends, changing schools, etc).

> Extracting files from Google Drive and iCloud is a pain, but is it _that_ bad?

I take it you haven't done it. Put your money where your mouth is and just switch. It's that easy, right?

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by bmicraft on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:10AM (#39420199)
If you're moving far enough to have "access to other supermarkets" you by definition don't have access to the same school and friends anymore
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by mrmanner on Monday February 19, 2024 @04:48AM (#39427815)
> It's that easy, right?

I've used... six mobile operating systems in the last ten years. Some learnings:

1. There are cross-platform alternatives for file storage. Consider using them for important things. 2. For work things and organized volunteerism you'll use the tools of the company/organization anyway. 3. Backups help when migrating. You need backups anyway, so make use of them. 4. Only migrate things you actually care about. Screenshots from last year or that draft email to the electrician who installed your fridge? Let them burn

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:02AM (#39419588)
I don't know how anyone can say something like that with a straight face and expect others to take them seriously.

You're even trying to imply that moving to another country is easier than switching from iphone to android (or vice-versa).

For their next trick this poster is going to show us how running for 2 hours straight is easier than running for 10 seconds.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:14AM (#39419691)
Sprinting is def harder than running for 2 hours. I used to run 5-12 miles (8-19 km) in a single session, every week. I still got winded doing sprints.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:19AM (#39419733)
well it's a good thing I didn't say sprinting then isn't it?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by filoleg on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:40PM (#39422350)
Agreed. I did the apple-android-apple switch multiple times. At worst, it took me a day of transferring data and making sure all works the way it is supposed to, and then a week or two getting used to the UIUX (because each switch had multiple years in-between). That's quite nothing.

My move back from west coast to east coast of the US recently was way more demanding and taxing in every single way, even if we exclude monetary factors entirely. Moving countries would've been multiple magnitudes even more complex than that. Did that once almost 15 years ago, so I have a basic idea of how difficult it can get. It wasn't even that difficult at all compared to most cases. Doubly ridiculous to hear people trying to compare moving cities to switching between iOS and Android.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ImPostingOnHN on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:59AM (#39419565)
Asking my grandma to switch operating systems would be like asking her to start using a new language she doesn't understand as her primary.

Meanwhile, she's moved twice in my lifetime. I actually suspect most people move more often than they switch operating systems, and do so more times in their life, too.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Aaargh20318 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:32AM (#39420369)
> Asking my grandma to switch operating systems would be like asking her to start using a new language she doesn't understand as her primary.

I hate this rhetoric that old people are stupid and are intrinsically incapable of understanding modern technology.

Computers and cell phones didn't pop into existence overnight. The first home computers entered the market in the late 70's and became commonplace in the 80's. If your grandma is in her 80's now, she was in her 40's back then.

None of us had to learn these things overnight and tech was much simpler back then. All she had to do was keep up with what was happening in society. If anything, all this is more complicated for kids as they weren't eased into it like us older folks were.

Same goes for cellphones. They got common in the 90's and it took decades for them to get to the point that they are basically supercomputers you can put in your pocket.

This is nothing like asking your grandma to start using a new language she doesn't understand. This is more like your grandma stubbornly refusing to learn the meaning of new words introduced into the English language since the 80s. This is about being wilfully disconnected from society. This is not about an inability to learn but an unwillingness.

This is not an age thing, to get to the point where switching cellphone OSes is an impossible task you had to have checked out decades ago. It has nothing to do with age and everything with apathy and laziness.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:51PM (#39422441)
My kid will simply kill me outright in using a phone as a controller. I never learned those motor skills and my brain probably is incapable of spending the time in learning them. I remember pwning my dad in N64, while I watched him turn in circles.

Further, when you get to your 40s and some "new tech" comes out (like these VR headsets), you have to take a gamble. Is this yet another fad, like the last time ... or is this going to stick around. You have far less time than some teenager to go figure out how things work, on top of that.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Aaargh20318 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:13AM (#39419219)
But it’s not your only choice to shop in the App Store. Having an iPhone does not prevent my from buying an app from the Play Store on my Android phone, from buying a game from PSN on my PS5 or from buying a book from Amazon on my Kindle.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:21AM (#39419286)
Woah, I can install a game from PSN on my iPhone!? I must have missed that feature... /s

We already know the players in the market will conspire to increase prices artificially if given the chance (United States v. Apple Inc., 952 F. Supp. 2d 638 (S.D.N.Y. 2013)). So, no, I don't believe these are actually one market because not even the players think it is one marketplace. They argue this exact illusion to keep anti-trust from applying to them, but behave as if it isn't a single market.

All we need is for lawmakers to change what the definition of a market is, in order to deal with this loophole.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by graemep on Sunday February 18, 2024 @05:11PM (#39423987)
If Walmart owned all the shops in a particular city, then yes, that should happen

In fact regulators do not allow this to happen. For example, I know the UK competition regulators would not allow the same company to buy more than a quarter (IIRC) of the pubs in an area. Source: I heard the CEO of what was the biggest pub company in the UK at the time say it.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by prepend on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:47AM (#39419036)
That’s not how DoJ defines market.

The relevant market isn’t the specific Apple device users, but all users and all their competing devices. This is typically how US antitrust law works as it is based on consumer harm. And that’s broad, not the specific consumers who choose to use a particular tool or be in a particular system.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by nox101 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:51AM (#39420027)
That is how the DoJ defines the market.

https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/253...

> The District Court determined that Microsoft had maintained a monopoly in the market for Intel compatible PC operating systems in violation

Change "Intel compatible" to "A series compatible" and it's Apple. Change it to "ARM compatible" and it's still Apple given they have 60% market share in the USA. Only countries enforce anti-trust, there is no world government to look at market share it the world.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by KerrAvon on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:36AM (#39420413)
Your point is addressed elsewhere in the document; cherry-picking individual sentences from complex legal documents isn’t a great idea.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by nox101 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @04:18PM (#39423470)
feel free to point out that part of the document. AFAICT the entire document is in the context of the first paragraph which sets the scope for everything under it
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by nodamage on Sunday February 18, 2024 @05:06PM (#39423948)
This case does not prove what you think it does because the market for "Intel compatible PC operating systems" does not consist of a single competitor (there are much stricter legal requirements when alleging a single-competitor market).
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by xtracto on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:22PM (#39421546)
Just stop buying apple products... it's like people buying Lego toys and whining because they are expensive and cannot plug with Playmobile toys.

So people are so enamored with apple devices that they cannot stop using them, but don't want to pay the rent the company charges them... just go play somewhere else. Or create your own park. That's what Hawuei did, that's what Android did.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by graemep on Sunday February 18, 2024 @05:07PM (#39423960)
As we are discussing EU law what relevant does US antitrust law have?

Consumer are locked into ecosystems so you cannot just say "they can switch to a competing device". Can they move all apps and content from the old device to the new device at no cost? Do they need significant time to setup.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lttlrck on Sunday February 18, 2024 @06:33PM (#39424656)
It's a thread discussing Microsoft and the DOJ? But you know that.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by graemep on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:35PM (#39425346)
Not the comment I replied to. Check the parent of the comment you replied to.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ben_w on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:33PM (#39421658)
I don't accept the value of that definition, because it would also mean Nintendo isn't allowed to be a monopoly over their own games consoles, with Android being analogous to Xbox.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by barelysapient on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:07PM (#39425872)
By that logic, everything is a monopoly.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by darklion on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:45AM (#39418586)
Should a store be forced to stock a product that has “This product is significantly cheaper if you buy it directly from the manufacturer” printed on the front of the package?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by drooopy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:15AM (#39418794)
Typically you are not forced to sell your product on just one store, with some exceptions, of course. In this case, Spotify can only "sell" their app to Apple customers exclusively via Apple's store and they are forced to pay a fixed 30% to Apple for every transaction done through the spotify app, while using a payment system created and supplied by the store owner. And at the same time apple provides a competing product pre-installed on all their devices. There's a lot more nuance in this case that doesn't fit in with your analogy.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:19AM (#39419270)
> they are forced to pay a fixed 30% to Apple for every transaction done through the spotify app

Spotify has never paid this. You signed up online and then logged into the app.

To the degree Apple has behaved anti-competitively, Apple Music v Spotify is the clearest case. But it’s not because of payment processing, but that Apple can see Spotify’s data and strategy and then use it against them from a superior marketing position.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by darklion on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @10:39AM (#39455110)
If you’re suggesting there’s some sort of data- or usage- mining of Spotify’s app and/or app integrations with the OS going on, you’re going to have to provide much more evidence than just the allegation of “Apple can see Spotify’s data”.

The device might be able to see “Spotify’s data”, but the closest thing Apple-the-company has to “Spotify’s data [on iOS/macOS]” is likely to be device/customer profiles on who downloads the app from the App Store.

And I’m sure the amount of data that Apple has on Spotify and their business and marketing strategies from non-device sources is both vastly superior and vastly more than what they would get from device-based information.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by paulmd on Sunday February 18, 2024 @06:12PM (#39424506)
> Typically you are not forced to sell your product on just one store, with some exceptions, of course.

This is absolutely not true at all, exclusivity agreements are incredibly widespread in supply chains.

https://www.kevingrier.com/uploads/userfiles/files/opinion-p...

> Both retailers and manufacturers assert that over the past decade this practice has increased materially. In some retail outlets or corporations, the activity is now found in virtually every category. Based on reliable industry benchmarks from the late 1990's it is likely that as of 2001, at least half of major Canadian manufacturers are involved in some form of exclusivity arrangement with Canadian distributors.

“With some exceptions” doing some heavy lifting I guess, considering we’re talking about basically whole industries and product sectors.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Jensson on Monday February 19, 2024 @04:22AM (#39427653)
> This is absolutely not true at all, exclusivity agreements are incredibly widespread in supply chains.

I never signed an exclusivity deal to only shop from a single grocery store, I don't think that exists anywhere in the world. But buying an iPhone is effectively an exclusivity deal where you agree to only buy from Apples store. This makes it fundamentally different from other exclusivity deals that are business to business, this is exclusivity on individual customers.

I think the Apple store is the biggest such exclusivity deal on customers in history for a general marketplace. I can't think of anything else, except slavery or where a company owns the whole town and thus all the markets, but a company town is still way smaller scope than the Apple store.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by darklion on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:04AM (#39455501)
> this is exclusivity on individual customers.

Yes, individual customers who choose to buy an iPhone. It’s not like Apple is the only phone manufacturer in the world, and the iPhone is only barely dominant in the United States. There is plenty of competition for the iPhone. If you don’t like the iPhone and its singular App Store, go buy an Android phone.

What you want is an iPhone on your terms. Sorry, that’s not how the market works.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by madsbuch on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:03AM (#39418698)
I better like the marketplace analogy: If I go into a marketplace, I can be told by merchants that we can make cheaper deals outside of the confines of a marketplace.

If you want to stick to the "store" analogy, they Apple also needs to handle support, return cases and a lot more financial risk – A store stocks their own inventories and does not just facilitate transactions between two parties.

The fact is that Apple store is not a store, it is a marketplace. And on a marketplace you can not censor people as easily.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by madsbuch on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:46AM (#39419462)
though it would be lovely to see apple buy 10.000 licenses to sell on their "shop"
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Aloisius on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:36PM (#39422312)
Apple does handle returns and I'm not sure what support the average brick and mortar store offers.

Stores don't necessarily own all their inventories (stock consignment) and some products are extremely low risk (e.g. phone cards, gift cards, digital goods, etc.)

Calling it a marketplace seems odd considering unlike in traditional marketplaces, there are no competing merchants selling the same goods. There are no other merchants at all.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by rendall on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:08AM (#39418735)
The issue as I understand it is that Apple uses its dominance in hardware to direct users to its own music streaming service at the expense of a competing service. Your analogy does not fit.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by EasyMark on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:29PM (#39424990)
They have a pretty competitive pricing range too. The combined TV, music, and a bit of encrypted disk space is fairly priced. I used to pay for Spotify separately, but when they raised prices a couple of times in a row. It made more sense to just get Apple TV and music for a decent price as I already was using the 50 GB iCloud package because google likely data mines Google Docs/drive. So don't assume everyone is just getting it because it's “there”.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by rendall on Monday February 19, 2024 @10:29AM (#39430814)
The issue is Apple's using its dominance in one domain to restrict competitors in another domain, not whether they offer a better deal. In fact, one would expect that they can offer the best deal around.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Nextgrid on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:08AM (#39418738)
If you’re the one of 2 stores in the country, yes.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by realusername on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:46AM (#39419025)
The reality is even worse than this analogy, you only have two stores but customers going to one store cannot even shop in the other one!
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:31AM (#39418917)
It would be like if you went to best buy (or whatever electronics store is in your country) and bought a washing machine. This washing machine (in small print no less) has "in-home purchases" that let you change the modes to include color and whites instead of just a "do it all eco-mode." Best buy takes 30% of all these "in-home" purchases because they sold you the washing machine. They assert that you are their customer and you are not the owner of the washing machine. Oh, and you can't share this "in-home purchase" with anyone else that lives with you. If they want this feature, they have to pay for it separately.

If that makes sense to you ... then I guess there isn't much to discuss here.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by prepend on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:48AM (#39419047)
This happens. Ever try to sell an app on a Samsung tv? Samsung takes their cut of every purchase.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:54AM (#39419090)
I'm relating this to physical/mechanical things to point out how ludicrous the entire model is, but yes, this is the same thing.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:06AM (#39419178)
You do know many products have their Recommended Retail Price printed on the box?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by kelnos on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:14AM (#39420232)
Yes, absolutely. Unless you're going to argue against the concept of transparency, anyway.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by vdaea on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:55AM (#39418648)
Microsoft had an almost complete monopoly of the operating system on personal computers market back then.

Apple doesn't even have 50% share in Europe.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:32AM (#39418927)
As an app developer in the EU, my apps rarely target JUST the EU, but also the US and beyond.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by matwood on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:03AM (#39418702)
Yeah. MS was a completely different situation. They had something like 90%+ OS marketshare and were able to use the threat of cutting off a PC makers access to Windows in order to force them to use IE. Tbh, the case is more relatable to the case Google just lost than to Apple. In that case, Google cut secret deals to exclude phone manufactures from including other stores.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by realusername on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:47AM (#39419037)
Why the market share would matter if there's no competion in the mobile space?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:18AM (#39419268)
> if there's no competion in the mobile space?

How did you come up with this?

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by realusername on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:21AM (#39419287)
What could be signs that Apple and Google are competing with each other on the mobile app space?

The only tariff change ever made was made over a threat of an anti-trust lawsuit and copied straight over completely verbatim to the second company.

And it's not like users of one store can try to shop to the other one anyways. Each user is captive of their respective store.

On the hardware side sure, the competition is fierce and visible, on the software side I don't see anything at all.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by bmitc on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:52AM (#39419072)
Market share does not strictly determine market power.

Further, the commenter was referring to the U.S.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Fischgericht on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:43AM (#39419962)
Right. As long as there are TWO oligarchs left to choose from, it's clearly still a free market. настровье! Nastrovje! :)
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by whynotminot on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:33AM (#39418935)
Didn’t Microsoft win that case?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lapcat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:37AM (#39418961)
No.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by whynotminot on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:44AM (#39419007)
Yes?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lapcat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:51AM (#39419069)
You could read Wikipedia rather than asking on HN: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by whynotminot on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:22AM (#39419294)
lol I did, which is why I replied skeptically because it says Microsoft had most of it overturned on appeal.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lapcat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:49AM (#39419487)
Did you read the part that said, "The case was remanded back to the D.C. District Court for further proceedings on this matter, with Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly presiding." That's not a win. The case was ongoing, and likely would have gone to the Supreme Court eventually, though the court was too cowardly to take the case immediately.

There was a settlement with the DoJ. You don't settle when you win and the other side loses.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:15AM (#39419695)
sure you do, it's a question of the cost.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lapcat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:30AM (#39419823)
The cost of... what?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:30AM (#39420350)
I'm not going to answer that question in any serious way as the answer is extremely obvious.

Instead I'm going to ask you a question.

Do you suspect that lawyers work for free?

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lapcat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:13PM (#39420837)
It seems that you're very confused. The OP claimed, mistakenly, that Microsoft won the case. They did not. When two parties settle a case, there is no winner or loser, and the case isn't decided by a judge or jury.

The DoJ and Microsoft settled the case. There was no winner or loser. If Microsoft had won the case, then the notion of settlement doesn't even make sense. And depending on the law and jurisdiction, legal fees can be awarded to the winner of a case. But with a settlement, one party doesn't usually pay the other party's legal expenses as a stipulation; that would be weird. So I really don't know what in the world you're talking about, and maybe you don't either.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:24PM (#39420947)
not so much confused as I understand English.

Another definition for win is to achieve victory.

The bells got split up, MS settled with the DOJ and got a small slap on the wrist. The other poster considers that a victory (as do most people).

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lapcat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:34PM (#39421069)
The word "win" does have more than one meaning, a collquial one an a legal one. Nonetheless, whynotminot clearly meant it in the legal sense.

drooopy: "Nearly twenty five years ago, the DoJ nearly split Microsoft into two companies"

whynotminot: "Didn’t Microsoft win that case?"

We all know that Microsoft was not split into two companies. That was even stipulated by "nearly" in the initial post. That was obviously a "win" in the colloquial sense, so if that was the intended meaning, then why would whynotminot have even posed a question in the first place? There was no question. Yes, Microsoft "won", colloquially, and just got a slap on the wrist. That was the very background and context of the initial post by drooopy.

So no, you're mistaken about which sense of "win" was under question.

The question would have been phrased differently if it was meant in the colloquial sense, something like, "Didn't Microsoft win in that settlement?" But really, nobody would even phrase that as a tentative question rather than as a statement, because obviously Microsoft came out very well in the settlement, and besides, that was never in dispute with the original post by drooopy, because drooopy was lamenting the fact that monopolists have faced no consequences. Your interpretation of the conversation makes no sense.

Furthermore, whynotminot specifically said, in reference to the Wikipedia article about US v. Microsoft, "which is why I replied skeptically because it says Microsoft had most of it overturned on appeal." This again points to the legal sense of win.

[dead]
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lapcat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:18PM (#39421502)
> odd how you decided not to quote them though

This is a ridiculous, nutty criticism. You're complaining that I left off "lol I did" and instead replaced it with "in reference to the Wikipedia article about US v. Microsoft"? That's exactly what you did by adding "[read the wikipedia article]"! In fact, you left off a part of the sentence too, the "lol" at the start.

> this very clearly is the poster explaining they meant it in the colloquial sense rather than the strict legal sense. If they had meant it in the strict legal sense they would have claimed _all_ of it was overturned on appeal.

No, this doesn't follow at all. It's still the legal sense.

Moreover, that wasn't the end of the case, which was my point in responding to whynotminot. We don't have to guess about what whynotminot meant, because they said exactly what they were referring to: the appeal. They were not referring to the settlement. Nor did they consider that the case was remanded back to district court. So any legal or colloquial "win" was temporary at best.

> bolster your own argument, namely that people who can win don't settle

No, my argment was that people who did win don't settle. As I explained above, the appeal judgment did not actually end the case, which is why the parties ended up settling.

> and now here you are, cherry-picking quotes to try and make an argument. Very alpha of you.

You're a moron. I'm done here.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by thought_alarm on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:41AM (#39418986)
Microsoft gave discounts on Windows licenses to companies that agreed to stop purchasing Netscape client and server software, thereby choking off Netscape revenue streams. It forced Netscape to sell to AOL.

Microsoft controlled 95% of the personal computer market, and they abused that position to put a competitor out of business because that competitor was a threat to their monopoly.

How does that compare to Apple Music?

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by concinds on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:31AM (#39419365)
Apple has non-monopolistic market share, but they bundle the Apple Music app on every iPhone (with nudges to subscribe, like the "For You" and "Browse" tabs), and they give Spotify a bad choice: either adopt IAP (with 30% cut) for subscriptions, or handle all subscriptions through the web, but they can't link to their website from their app. While you can subscribe to Apple Music directly in-app.

The "bundling" issue is about where the similarities to Microsoft begin and end (I can't recall if "bundling" was part of the problem with IE in the US too, or only in Europe, where it was definitely an issue and led to the "browser choice" screen).

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:56AM (#39419537)
I've only ever owned an iphone (of the smartphones) and I've never felt a nudge to subscribe to their music app. the closest I've gotten is the notifications when you're not logged into apple cloud.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ViktorRay on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:07AM (#39419185)
Your interpretation of the Microsoft case is incorrect.

The DOJ wasn’t going to split Microsoft because it was a “gatekeeper.” There is no legal basis in US Law to do that.

It was very close to splitting Microsoft because Microsoft was held to have monopolistic market share and was abusing its monopolistic position in operating systems to illegally and anticompetitively push their web browser. Violation of antitrust law.

Legally in the United States you wouldn’t be able to do this with Apple today when applying that law because Apple does not have monopolistic market share. I don’t know what the iPhone’s market share in America is today but Microsoft had over 95 percent market share back then. Apple isn’t close to that today.

In Europe the laws may be different.

(Also for what it’s worth I’m not making an argument for whether Apple or Google or anybody shouldn’t or should be broken up. I’m just saying your interpretation of the DOJ’s position back then is not correct)

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Salgat on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:31AM (#39419360)
You don't have to have a monopoly to be guilty of anticompetitive behavior, a monopoly simply means it's easier to be anticompetitive. Apple in the US has a roughly 50% market share.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by fnordpiglet on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:27AM (#39419800)
The dissonant threshold is dominance not monopoly. But specifically willfully and intentionally conspiring to use that dominance to manipulate pricing, exclude competition, and otherwise distort cross market structure to their advantage.

The MSFT vs DOJ did in fact use their monopoly power in operating systems to enter a new commercial market, price anticompetitively (price a competitors commercial product at zero), bundle with their new product with monopoly product in a mandatory and exclusionary way, etc. The actions were willful and planned, had no other commercial consideration other than harming competition. Even so the action came many years too late and Microsoft had successfully destroyed Netscape and it took until Chrome before any competition surfaced.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by xethos on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:34AM (#39419855)
You're right, in that Microsoft used their dominance in one market (operating systems) to gain an advantage in another market (web browsers)

Apple or Google would have to be doing something similar, like using their dominance in one market (operating systems) to gain an advantage in a seperate market - for example, music streaming services (Apple Music, Youtube Premium) or web browsers (Chrome, as pushed heavily by the world's most prominent OS, Android)

To be clear: Android is not the entire reason Chrome is ubiquitous. My arugument is that Android is, pretty clearly IMO, a competitive advantage when pushing a web browser.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by leereeves on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:53AM (#39420605)
Apple is not only pushing their web browser, they're mandating it. Safari is the only browser allowed on iOS.

How is that not anticompetitive?

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by xethos on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:39PM (#39421117)
I can see your point, but prefer to stick to rock-solid, unimpeachible arguments (Apple Music for iOS, Google Chrome/Play Store for Android). I shy away from Safari/iOS because Apple is using iOS' dominance (in operating systems) to gain an advantage in web browsers - but that browser is only available for iOS and MacOS. They've steered very clear of using iOS' dominance to push for browser dominance in every other operating system not owned by them.

Going so far as to not even release a client leaves them with a relatively safe defence of only pushing for deep system integration with their own products, as opposed to market dominance in web browsers (as they're likely to be accused of).

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by leereeves on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:43PM (#39421163)
Do you think Microsoft would have been safe if they had never released IE for Macs?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by xethos on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:54PM (#39421890)
I certainly think they would have been safer. Bear in mind though, at the time, Windows had 97% of the desktop market [0]. This wasn't a corporation with ~50% of the market (like Android in the US) trying to muscle in, this was a company with their hooks so deep in personal computers that any product they pushed became a de-facto standard that everyone was expected to at least have access to, if not use.

Hell, the most dominant companies on the planet today, including the literal trillion dollar ones, do not have that kind of market penetration. Google search, the closest I can think of, is still <92% [1]. And it's not that I think holding 92% of a market is good. Nor do I think Apple should get away with only allowing re-skins instead of real browser engines. But percentages are room to quibble, and re-skins can be spun as integration or security.

Whenever Apple's gilded cage comes up, there's backlash, whataboutism, and apologists - so as we start to force interop, openness, and more pro-consumer behavior, I stick to the unimpeachable arguments. Even if it's just till we break the inertia and get the ball rolling. I think you're right, and you make an excellent point. But first I want to convince even the Apple die-hards that this level of control is fucked up, because then we can all agree that something has to change.

[0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2012/12/13/microsof...

[1] https://gs.statcounter.com/search-engine-market-share

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by cnlwsu on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:02PM (#39420697)
I’m viewing this from chrome on iOS. What are you talking about
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by gkbrk on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:05PM (#39420724)
Nope, you're viewing it from a Webkit wrapper made by Google that shares same name.

Chrome is a web browser using the Blink engine, and it doesn't run on iOS devices.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Spivak on Sunday February 18, 2024 @04:52PM (#39423804)
This argument doesn't hold up to any scrutiny if you try to apply it to any other kind of portable software.

Spotify is a music player that uses the Electron framework and it doesn't run on iOS.

Outlook is a email client that uses the WinUI engine and it doesn't run on iOS.

Netflix is an applet that runs on the Microsoft Silverlight engine, and that doesn't run on iOS.

There is something that feels wrong about Apple's restrictions for browsers but different platform necessitating different, often fundamentally different, implementations isn't quite it.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by gkbrk on Monday February 19, 2024 @02:29AM (#39427043)
Spotify's distinguishing feature is not "using Electron". Same for all of the other apps you mentioned.

Chrome's distinguishing feature is "not being Safari or Firefox". It has this distinguishing feature on all other platforms like Linux, Mac, Android and Windows. Only on one platform is this feature missing, and that is why it is emphasized so much.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Spivak on Monday February 19, 2024 @09:12AM (#39429922)
Well even on iOS Chrome is a different app from Safari and Firefox. Mozilla has two different browsers — even on iOS where all browsers are "the same" Mozilla sees enough differences to have two separate ones.

You're just restating the premise. I think Outlook could make a case for just being a wrapper for Apple Mail. Valve could make the case that Steam's distinguishing feature is lacking on iOS. Again, there is some signal here but I've never heard anyone be able to really explain it.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by st3fan on Monday February 19, 2024 @11:52AM (#39431924)
Outlook could make a great case that Apple’s own email client has access to all kinds of great iOS APIs that are only available to Apple and not to third party email clients. Apple mail has deep OS integration that is impossible for third party email clients. Apple Mail can fetch in the background at will while Outlook has to build that on top of mediocre APIs.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by dijit on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:10PM (#39420790)
the engine it’s running is the safari one, chrome on iOS is just an alternative interface with different syncing semantics.

that said, this thread of reasoning has started wrong, there is no market for web browsers on iOS just like there’s no market for phone diallers on your in-car stereo system.. What you get is what you get, and that’s always been the case and Apple products are the only devices that can run Safari…

if you keep thinking of apple devices as computers instead of like consoles or appliances, then you are going to get upset.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by leereeves on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:40PM (#39421134)
> there is no market for web browsers on iOS

I find this difficult to reconcile with the case against Microsoft, which I understood to be about pushing IE on Windows.

Are you saying that the case against Microsoft wasn't based on anticompetitive attempts to dominate the market for web browsers, that the law has changed since then, or that Windows is somehow different from iOS legally?

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by LegitShady on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:16PM (#39421480)
I think the distinction to date is that ios technically may not count as dominant the way windows did.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by hirako2000 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:43PM (#39423067)
Another distinction is that the EU has figured out something in between.

That the US has been waging an economic wars and used unconventional warfare techniques, corporate espionage, corruption, and weaponized the US dollar.

That US businesses have been lobbying and interfering with politics in the EU to provide themselves with competitive edges.

Lobbying is itself illegal in many EU nations hence done undercover, thus is plain bribery and corruption of government officials

EU has started retaliating, that's all. At least in using the justice system the way the US has instrumented its own to serve US businesses, helping them win certain markets, and fine competing foreign to the US businesses, fortunes, and ruining them whenever possible.

Still, not letting side loads, imposing to be an intermediary and payment gateway between all publishers and their audience, taking an outrageous commission rate, plus a fixed developer licensing fee, plus forcing all developers to build the published binaries exclusively on Apple made hardware, plus disallowing third parties to repair, plus circumventing the right to repair bill, altogether is without doubt abusing a position of dominance and deploying anti competition tactics.

Saying these are measures to keep users safe is a fallacy and an insult to educated consumers, all it says really is a reveal of how Apple considers its consumers at large.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by st3fan on Monday February 19, 2024 @11:56AM (#39431967)
There is a market for web browsers as soon as Google is able to ship a “real” Chrome for iOS and half they start breaking things gently on the web for other browsers. Just like they did over the timespan of a decade.

Once Chrome can ship on iOS you will see everyone’s market share crumble and Chrome becoming the only browser.

That is anti competitive and not even addressed in any kind of way by the DMA.

On the contrary, it is the end game for the OWA, which is largely a front for “let’s make sure Chromium will dominate the web so that Google can push project Fugu down everyone’s throats.”

There I said it.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by paulmd on Sunday February 18, 2024 @05:58PM (#39424391)
“my os distro ships with SELinux on by default and I can’t break out of the sandbox!”

ok, so, if you don’t like the sysadmin’s choices then use a different system? Seems like an obviously self-inflicted pain.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by turquoisevar on Sunday February 18, 2024 @06:26PM (#39424615)
I see this point, and others similar to it brought up often, and I think it stems from misunderstanding what antitrust regulation is trying to solve.

By the way, I say this respectfully, not as a dig towards you.

From a US antitrust perspective, almost all commerce has anticompetitive characteristics. Think about it: very few businesses will act in a manner beneficial to their competitors. Most will actively act against the interest of their competitors, but almost all will not go out of their way to facilitate their competitors (passive anticompetitive behavior, if you will).

Straightforward concepts to understand what I’m trying to say here are things such as Pizza Place A not selling stuff made by Pizza Place B. Closer to home, another example would be a device manufacturer, like a smart thermostat, not allowing their competitors to create software and apps that replace their software.

Behavior like this can be found all across commerce, from small businesses and startups to big corporations.

So the legislators (to a lesser degree) and the courts, understanding that laws need to be applied equally regardless of who the parties are, recognized that if they’d purely penalized anticompetitive behavior in a general sense, it would severely impact commerce in general. Even prevent competition to a degree by preventing new market entrants from making their products work exclusively for their own benefit.

Analogous to this is the idea of penalizing all monopolies. The issue with that would be that so-called “organic monopolies,” sometimes also called “innocent monopolies” (i.e., companies that gained a dominant market share by merely being successful), would be punished for their success alone.

Instead of banning all anti-competitive behavior, and analogous to this, banning all monopolies, they came up with the idea that only those that leverage their market dominance to protect or increase their market dominance should be penalized.

There are a bunch of nuances to be had, but in a nutshell, this means that imposing something onerous is okay while you don’t have dominant market power, but doing it while you have dominance would be a no-go.

Subsequently, this also means retroactively penalizing particular behavior initiated before gaining market dominance is generally not done because it indirectly punishes success.

Circling back to the example of Safari (or WebKit, to be exact), when Apple imposed this rule, it had an insignificant market share and little leverage. Because they maintained this rule from the beginning, this would not be deemed an antitrust issue.

Had Apple not imposed this from the start, but instead, had they started imposing this after they gained market dominance, then it could be an antitrust issue because now you’re leveraging your market dominance against parties who may not be able to withstand this pressure due to a variety of reasons such as being dependent on the ecosystem.

Apple is very conscious of this, which is why it generally starts with a very restrictive set of conditions, and sometimes, along the way, it loosens the reigns because doing the opposite way is not an option for them from an antitrust perspective.

Two clear examples of this come to mind.

First is the App Store, and it's often derided commission. Apple started with a simple 30% commission fee.

Later, they provided a 15 percent point discount on recurring subscriptions after the first year, followed by the same discount for streaming services in the Apple Video Partner Program, followed later by the same discount for developers in the Small Business Program.

Had they done this the other way around, say they started with 15%, learned after gaining market dominance that the 15% wasn’t sustainable, and then tried to increase it to 30%, they would be opening themselves up to antitrust penalties.

Related to this are their guidelines that prescribe what kind of apps are needed to implement IAPs. It started with all apps that provide products and services that weren’t consumed outside the app (i.e., physical). Then they added the so-called “Reader exception,” later, they exempted free apps that are a companion to specific online tools such as email and cloud storage.

Now that they allow game streaming services, they need to offer IAPs for services sold outside the app, at least for now, because they can always loosen the requirements but never tighten them.

The other example is their relationship with carriers. When Apple launched the first iPhone, and they were insignificant on the mobile phone market, they were only willing to partner with carriers that accepted their prohibition of installing bloatware on the iPhone.

A couple of years later, when they had gained a significant market share, Apple decided to implement Hotspot functionality, FaceTime, and FaceTime audio.

It stands to reason that Apple wanted all carriers to support this functionality on their terms (i.e., without impediments for users), but taking the same stand on this as they took on bloatware, something that would’ve been way easier now that iPhones were a hot commodity, could be seen as levering their market position.

The result is that carriers could do as they wanted with these functions by carrier profiles. In the beginning, a lot of carriers would turn off the hotspot functionality on some plans and would disable FaceTime use on the cellular network; later on, the carriers relaxed with FaceTime usage on their network, but many now put a data cap of sorts on hotspot usage.

Clearly, Apple felt it might lead to antitrust issues if they told carriers to fully support these functions or not expect to be supplied any iPhones for them to sell.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ViktorRay on Monday February 19, 2024 @02:47AM (#39427124)
This is really good analysis. I didn’t think about this this way before. Everything you wrote makes sense. Thanks for writing all this.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by st3fan on Monday February 19, 2024 @11:27AM (#39431595)
It is also difficult to prove because a web browser, yes even Safari, is an open platform by design and it can can run 99% of the web successfully just like other browser. Yes that is true even for Safari. People like to call Safari the “new IE” but in reality today’s web works equally well in all major browsers including Safari.

(Wait for someone to comment that that feature XYZ does not work on Safari and therefor it sucks - yes but that is the nature of the web and browsers. Every Single Browser out there has something missing or added. That has not prevented anyone from building great websites that work in all of them. )

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by seanmcdirmid on Monday February 19, 2024 @12:58PM (#39432692)
I run chrome on iOS. Yes, it’s using the safari renderer, it at least I have access to my google password stash.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by fnordpiglet on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:22PM (#39421537)
I think a key consideration is they created the entire platform inclusive of the market structure day zero. The law doesn’t protect against market dominance in one or more markets and they’re not leveraging one market against another - they created the markets and distribution channels.

It’s like claiming Amazon Kindle not hosting Nook bookstores is anticompetitive or Krogers not letting Whole Foods sell in their store or Peleton for not opening their bike to other fitness products. They built the platform and the distribution channels, are they obligated to host everything in any channel?

While side loading is a feature of general purpose operating systems not all operating systems offer it, and it’s only really coming to be an issue here because of the ubiquity of their product. But the lack of side loading isn’t new, and has never been offered. To that extent it’s more along the lines of market dominance alone, not using dominance to distort adjacent markets or willful anticompetitive behavior.

I suspect Apple and Google will not be forced to open their products in the US as it’s not clear their strategy runs afoul traditional interpretations of law.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by xethos on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @12:21PM (#39443982)
> they’re not leveraging one market against another

I'm sorry, is your point that "Music streaming service" is not a market? Apple allows signups via every way one could access the application - mobile, web, and desktop. Tidal then has a choice: they can have the same advantage as Apple (a smooth flow with signup prompts available everywhere), or they can have the same pricing model as Apple (by not paying the 30% App Store cut). Tidal cannot have both.

How is this not Apple using their market dominance in app distribution (either due to OS dominance or Apple's exclusive app distribution channel, take your pick) to gain an advantage in the Music Streaming marketplace?

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by scarface_74 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:20AM (#39420275)
This is also not true. Netscape destroyed Netscape. For anyone around at the time, they know that Netscape was a heaping pile of shit on every single platform it ran on.

In comp.sys.*.advocacy groups back in the day, it was a point of nerd pride how well your platform could handle a Netscape crash.

Microsoft got into trouble because they forced OEMs to pay for Windows licenses for all of their computers sold whether or not they had Windows installed and they didn’t allow OEMs to install Netscape.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with entering new markets using the resources you have from your existing markets. Should Netflix never have entered the streaming business?

And it wasn’t Chrome, Firefox started chipping away at IEs dominance before Chrome.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by mdale on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:50AM (#39420573)
Hmm ... and Internet Explorer was a high water mark of software excellence ?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by scarface_74 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:50PM (#39421843)
Yes - IE was much less crash prone and the Mac version used a different engine and was much more standards compliant at the time than Netscape
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by fnordpiglet on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:14PM (#39424910)
At the time IE was horrific and basically didn’t exist. Microsoft reallocated the entire focus of the company R&D towards development of the next version of IE - a colossal investment of resources that outstripped all of Netscape’s revenues for all of its history just on developing a free browser to put it out of business. So, yes, sure. It was incredibly better. But it was anticompetitive to develop it in that way. With the same resources, could Netscape have done it? Would Microsoft have done it if there was any commercial considerations?

Netscape made a product that ran on over 20 operating systems and promised a future where the operating system was a detail for how to launch a web browser. Microsoft saw this as an existential threat and crushed Netscape under a mount of money that was spent to ensure the only meaningful browser was a feature of their operating system.

After their Pyrrhic victory, IE decayed with very little investment. As you would expect in something that was developed only to destroy.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by scarface_74 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:28PM (#39425984)
So it’s “anticompetitive” to use your resources to make a better product to compete in a new market? Was it anticompetitive for Google to give Android away to crush all of the competitors beside Apple? Was it anticompetitive for Netflix to use its profits from its dvd by mail business to create a streaming service? Apple to create iPods and then iPhones? Amazon to start AWS?

Netscape did run on a lot of platforms - and it sucked on all of them.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by fnordpiglet on Monday February 19, 2024 @03:33PM (#39434476)
No, and there were thousands upon thousands of pages filed on both sides arguing both sides with hundreds of pages of written opinions explaining why this behavior is different than normal competition. A lot of it was Microsoft leaderships very specific motive, which was not about creating more competition but in specifically eliminating all competition. It’s not illegal to compete in a market or create new markets. It’s illegal to use market dominance in one market to destroy all competition in another.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by scarface_74 on Monday February 19, 2024 @05:17PM (#39435502)
How exactly do you think companies that survive and don’t suffer from the “innovative dilemma” manage to survive if they don’t use their dominance in one market to get into other markets?

What Microsoft did was much more nuanced than spend money to get into other markets - it involve pressuring OEMs not to work with competitors among other things. BTW, this is the same thing that Google has been fined for repeatedly.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by floydnoel on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:41AM (#39419434)
Being anticompetitive isn't illegal, basically it is encouraged/incentivized for companies.

The snag is for companies with monopoly power- they are prohibited from abusing their monopoly via anticompetitive behavior.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by madeofpalk on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:21AM (#39419755)
What’s an example of something that’s anti-competitive but legal?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by mardef on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:52AM (#39420035)
Everything about iOS

Apple has excluded all other browsers on iOS, requires you to buy more apple hardware to produce software for iOS, and has all of their rules around IAP and not allowing you to even link to an alternate store in many cases.

If iOS had a 90% market share in the US, I bet they'd have a lot more legal troubles

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ukuina on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:27AM (#39419793)
Loss leaders.

See "Loss leading as an exploitative practice": http://idei.fr/sites/default/files/medias/doc/wp/2012/lossle...

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by bhpm on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:04PM (#39420713)
Zero rating, like when wireless carriers don’t charge for certain bandwidth but do for others.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ViktorRay on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:28PM (#39420994)
This actually is illegal in many countries as it is a violation of net neutrality.

I don’t remember what the current net neutrality status is in the United States but if the FCC is currently requiring net neutrality then things like zero rating would be illegal.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by sudofox on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:29AM (#39419807)
Intentionally pushing competition out of the market. If you don't have monopolistic power, totally legal.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by thfuran on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:05AM (#39420156)
Exclusivity deals are commonplace.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ToucanLoucan on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:35AM (#39419396)
I mean, every business is anti-competitive. The only time the authorities step in is when they dominate markets to a degree where competition no longer functions. iOS market share is strongest in the states I believe at 57%, which is certainly high but not even remotely approaching a monopoly.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:07AM (#39419636)
>iOS market share is strongest in the states I believe at 57%, which is certainly high but not even remotely approaching a monopoly.

Ackchyually you don't need to be a monopoly to warp the whole market in your favor.

Windows was a monopoly back in the day with ~95% market share, but users could easily install any other apps and any other browser besides IE. The issue was many users stuck with IE because it was the default, but Microsoft wasn't blocking them from installing other browsers than IE or other apps not sold through their channels.

Meanwhile, Apple might have only 57%-60% market share instead of ~95%, but unlike Microsoft, it's actively blocking users form installing any other browser that's not Safari based and any app that's not on the AppStore, therefore doing even more damage than Microsoft was doing back in the days.

And speaking of iPhone market share, despite being it 57%-60% of the US right now, it's also the most wealthy and influential of the market, and looking at the demographics, it's at 87% amongst US teens, so it's safe to assume those teens will stick to iPhone when they grow up due to inertia and network effects, and then iOS market share will be close to 90%, therefore a guaranteed monopoly.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by TimPC on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:39AM (#39420440)
The fact that the most popular option in a demographic where someone else pays for the phone is the most expensive option says almost nothing about what those users will do when they have to spend their own money on an option. I highly doubt 87% of the population will be buying a luxury brand with their own money. Convincing mommy and daddy it’s socially isolating to be on Android sure. But their own money in their 20s I doubt it.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:56AM (#39420629)
> I highly doubt 87% of the population will be buying a luxury brand with their own money.

You're making it sound like they're Lamborghinis or Patek watches. Maybe in developing countries iPhone is a luxury brand, but in no way is it in any western developed countries, especially the US, the wealthiest of them all.

Yes they're expensive as in they don't do anything essential for the average user (text, browse the web, take photos) radically better than what a ~300 Euro Samsung A54 can do, but they're not unaffordably expensive.

>But their own money in their 20s I doubt it.

Credit, installments and carrier plans, make it that anyone can afford an iPhone. I live in a central EU country where average income is less than the US, and even the pizza delivery courier here can get an iPhone.

Let's do some napkin math: The iPhone 15 Pro is ~1200 Euros with tax here. A full time supermarket "wagie" with no education takes home nearly 1800 Euros per month after taxes. Subtract 600 Euros rent, 400 for eating, 200 for utilities and bills, and you're left with about 600 a month to spend as you please.

So you can buy the latest iPhone after saving for 2 months, or instantly by walking in to any carrier shop and signing a 3 year contract for a plan which you need anyway.

How is that "luxury"? Yes I know, this lifestyle is probably luxury compared to how average people live in some nations from Africa, Asia, LATAM and Middle East, but definitely not in the developed west. Otherwise Apple wouldn't be selling them by the boatlaod.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ToucanLoucan on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:07PM (#39420767)
> Meanwhile, Apple might have only 57%-60% market share instead of ~95%, but unlike Microsoft, it's actively blocking users form installing any other browser that's not Safari based and any app that's not on the AppStore, therefore doing even more damage than Microsoft was doing back in the days.

Okay so like: humor me. What is the damage incurred by the user's inability to install, for example, a true Firefox on iOS that uses their Quantum engine? I'll fully cosign that iOS' Safari has quirks that make it kind of annoying, very occasionally, like once every few months I'll find something that it does in a bizarre way that others don't. But I swear every time the topic of iOS' dominance comes up, there is a detachment of users out there who are simply furious that they can't install a web browser that doesn't use Apple's WebKit on an iOS device and I just... I do not get it. At the absolute worst I have never given even 10% of the shit required to where I would upend all my stored passwords and whatnot for the ability to even use a different WebKit based browser.

Now, granted, if this was the situation on the Mac, oh hell yes, I would absolutely be right there with everyone else and grabbing my own pitchfork. But on my phone? On my tablet? I dunno, am I weird for just not really caring?

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:24PM (#39420951)
It's not directly affecting you the user, it's affecting the market of app and web developer which have no choice but to dance to Apple's tune as they control a large chuck of a very lucrative market.

Why should you, the user, care? For the same reason users care when Micros ft was a monopoly on desktop.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ToucanLoucan on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:30PM (#39421024)
How is that different than web developers being required to dance to the tune of basically every major browser? They all have little oddities that have to be taken into account, speaking as someone who has done quite a bit of web development, every major browser has it's deviations from the standard, intentional and often otherwise, that require little tweaks to one's code.

And to be totally honest with you, a lot of Safari iOS's quirks are unambiguously good, pro-privacy practices that frustrate the shit out of surveillance marketing firms and I quite hope Apple keeps it up.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by dickersnoodle on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:57PM (#39421934)
> ..to be totally honest with you, a lot of Safari iOS's quirks are unambiguously good, pro-privacy practices that frustrate the shit out of surveillance marketing firms and I quite hope Apple keeps it up.

So do I.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday February 18, 2024 @01:05PM (#39421372)
Weird that you don't see a problem with monopolies and why they're bad.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ToucanLoucan on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:10PM (#39422059)
Weird that you've sidestepped my points entirely to do vague whataboutism.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:29PM (#39422242)
I don't want to repeat all the arguments already said by others in this thread so all I had to add is that any monopoly can and does eventually end up abusing it's power for profit. Now it's towards developers and competitors, tomorrow it could be towards users aka you.

The fact that you don't see a problem with that is the issue because you seem to assume that Apple is and will always be on your side and looking after your best interest.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ameister14 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:12PM (#39420822)
>every business is anti-competitive

That's not actually true. Every business is competitive, but not every business engages in anti-competitive behavior.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by jwells89 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:03AM (#39420130)
Surprisingly, iOS is a bit more popular in Japan than it is in the US, where it has ~68% marketshare. That market usually favors local manufacturers (Sony among other local companies still make Android phones), but that for some reason doesn’t apply in this case.

Still not a monopoly though.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by DiabloD3 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:36AM (#39420417)
That isn't true though.

In the US, Apple is a minority player. I have no clue why Wall Street values them as a $1T company, when all they do anymore is make a bunch of phones that are under-competitive and over-expensive.

The only time in the past few years that iPhones out sold Android phones in the US (the only market which Apple is a major player in; any of the global markets, they're virtually a nobody) was a glitch in 2021, most likely due to being pandemic-inspired. Never before nor since have they broken the 50% barrier.

Although I 100% agree with what the EU is doing to Apple (and I hope they keep going), I don't understand why they're bothering with such a relative small fry, when Google doing the exact same thing on the Google Play Store is right there, and Google has far more capability of paying fines than Apple does.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by jakub_g on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:58AM (#39420651)
Apple has 61% mobile market share in US, and in 2023 it shipped worldwide more phones than Samsung. Having a hefty margin on each device, avg price being way bigger than average Android; on top of that, their % share of total revenue coming from services (app store, subscriptions etc) compared to hardware shipments keeps growing every year.

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2024/01/apple-hits-all-time-...

https://gs.statcounter.com/vendor-market-share/mobile/united...

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by capybara_2020 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:02PM (#39420692)
It looks like the iPhone has always had more than 50% market share and right now it is at 61%

https://gs.statcounter.com/vendor-market-share/mobile/united...

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by matthewmacleod on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:53AM (#39420593)
Apple is a $1T company—actually, $2.8T—because it brings in over $100bn a year in operating income, and was literally the world's single biggest seller of smartphones globally in 2023.

The overall Google ecosystem is obviously more popular worldwide – but the idea that Apple only "makes a bunch of under-competitive phones", are "virtually a nobody" in the global market, or are a "small fry" is low-effort trolling.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by fauigerzigerk on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:39AM (#39419912)
>The DOJ wasn’t going to split Microsoft because it was a “gatekeeper.” There is no legal basis in US Law to do that.

Being a gatekeeper is not illegal in the EU either and it's not what the parent comment claimed. Abusing a gatekeeper position for anticompetitive purposes is illegal, which is similar to the U.S situation even if the vocabulary is slightly different.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by sjtgraham on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:25PM (#39422197)
> Legally in the United States you wouldn’t be able to do this with Apple today when applying that law because Apple does not have monopolistic market share

That depends on how you define a market. Apple has a monopoly on app distribution to iOS devices. The argument for defining it like is is persuasive because in the Microsoft case you could at least install an OS from another vendor. You can't do that with an iPhone. Your only relief is to buy a new phone from a different manufacturer.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by nodamage on Sunday February 18, 2024 @05:00PM (#39423896)
Market analysis under US antitrust law doesn't work that way. You don't just get to choose an arbitrarily narrow market such that a single competitor by definition owns 100% of it, otherwise plaintiffs would basically never lose in court. Market analysis is done by examining actual consumer behaviors, and in general, markets comprised of a single competitor are not permitted by the courts in antitrust cases (unless specific exceptions are met).
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Zuiii on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:15PM (#39425573)
Sounds to me like US antitrust laws are currently deficient and need to be updated.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by simfree on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:22PM (#39425618)
Apple owns 70% of the mobile device market in the US, and is the exclusive app distribution channel on the that platform.

Web Apps do not work right (especially when compared to the other major mobile platform) and Apple is making little effort to improve the viability of this potential channel, instead choosing to delete web push tokens every week or so amongst other sabotage of web applications, while these same web applications work just fine on the other platforms that support web apps.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by seanmcdirmid on Monday February 19, 2024 @01:02PM (#39432733)
58% as of December 2023. See https://explodingtopics.com/blog/iphone-android-users

Not sure where you are getting 70% from, that seems way too high. They do, however, make around 80-90% if the profits in the market.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by nodamage on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:51PM (#39423174)
> It was very close to splitting Microsoft because Microsoft was held to have monopolistic market share and was abusing its monopolistic position in operating systems to illegally and anticompetitively push their web browser. Violation of antitrust law.

This was overturned on appeal and subsequently settled out of court so it was never actually determined whether bundling IE with Windows would have been illegal under US antitrust law.

Other aspects of the case were upheld on appeal (mostly related to shady dealings with OEMs) but appeals panel concluded that the district judge incorrectly analyzed the browser issue. They also overturned the original court ordered split for the same reason.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by lenkite on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @07:12AM (#39440322)
Apple already has >60% market share in the U.S. If that doesn't qualify for a monopoly, then I don't know what magic number will. And Apple has a strangulating choke-hold on their platform compared to Microsoft.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Am4TIfIsER0ppos on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:07AM (#39419187)
Microsoft was beaten with a legal stick because they didn't bribe lawmakers, i.e. running a business without lobbying. Tech companies don't make the same mistake these days.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by fennecfoxy on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @12:17PM (#39443910)
He he, it'll be tough for that to happen to Apple, as Apple has become a protected class in their customers' minds, imo.