News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by darklion on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:45AM (#39418586)
Should a store be forced to stock a product that has “This product is significantly cheaper if you buy it directly from the manufacturer” printed on the front of the package?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by drooopy on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:15AM (#39418794)
Typically you are not forced to sell your product on just one store, with some exceptions, of course. In this case, Spotify can only "sell" their app to Apple customers exclusively via Apple's store and they are forced to pay a fixed 30% to Apple for every transaction done through the spotify app, while using a payment system created and supplied by the store owner. And at the same time apple provides a competing product pre-installed on all their devices. There's a lot more nuance in this case that doesn't fit in with your analogy.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:19AM (#39419270)
> they are forced to pay a fixed 30% to Apple for every transaction done through the spotify app

Spotify has never paid this. You signed up online and then logged into the app.

To the degree Apple has behaved anti-competitively, Apple Music v Spotify is the clearest case. But it’s not because of payment processing, but that Apple can see Spotify’s data and strategy and then use it against them from a superior marketing position.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by darklion on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @10:39AM (#39455110)
If you’re suggesting there’s some sort of data- or usage- mining of Spotify’s app and/or app integrations with the OS going on, you’re going to have to provide much more evidence than just the allegation of “Apple can see Spotify’s data”.

The device might be able to see “Spotify’s data”, but the closest thing Apple-the-company has to “Spotify’s data [on iOS/macOS]” is likely to be device/customer profiles on who downloads the app from the App Store.

And I’m sure the amount of data that Apple has on Spotify and their business and marketing strategies from non-device sources is both vastly superior and vastly more than what they would get from device-based information.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by paulmd on Sunday February 18, 2024 @06:12PM (#39424506)
> Typically you are not forced to sell your product on just one store, with some exceptions, of course.

This is absolutely not true at all, exclusivity agreements are incredibly widespread in supply chains.

https://www.kevingrier.com/uploads/userfiles/files/opinion-p...

> Both retailers and manufacturers assert that over the past decade this practice has increased materially. In some retail outlets or corporations, the activity is now found in virtually every category. Based on reliable industry benchmarks from the late 1990's it is likely that as of 2001, at least half of major Canadian manufacturers are involved in some form of exclusivity arrangement with Canadian distributors.

“With some exceptions” doing some heavy lifting I guess, considering we’re talking about basically whole industries and product sectors.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Jensson on Monday February 19, 2024 @04:22AM (#39427653)
> This is absolutely not true at all, exclusivity agreements are incredibly widespread in supply chains.

I never signed an exclusivity deal to only shop from a single grocery store, I don't think that exists anywhere in the world. But buying an iPhone is effectively an exclusivity deal where you agree to only buy from Apples store. This makes it fundamentally different from other exclusivity deals that are business to business, this is exclusivity on individual customers.

I think the Apple store is the biggest such exclusivity deal on customers in history for a general marketplace. I can't think of anything else, except slavery or where a company owns the whole town and thus all the markets, but a company town is still way smaller scope than the Apple store.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by darklion on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:04AM (#39455501)
> this is exclusivity on individual customers.

Yes, individual customers who choose to buy an iPhone. It’s not like Apple is the only phone manufacturer in the world, and the iPhone is only barely dominant in the United States. There is plenty of competition for the iPhone. If you don’t like the iPhone and its singular App Store, go buy an Android phone.

What you want is an iPhone on your terms. Sorry, that’s not how the market works.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by madsbuch on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:03AM (#39418698)
I better like the marketplace analogy: If I go into a marketplace, I can be told by merchants that we can make cheaper deals outside of the confines of a marketplace.

If you want to stick to the "store" analogy, they Apple also needs to handle support, return cases and a lot more financial risk – A store stocks their own inventories and does not just facilitate transactions between two parties.

The fact is that Apple store is not a store, it is a marketplace. And on a marketplace you can not censor people as easily.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by madsbuch on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:46AM (#39419462)
though it would be lovely to see apple buy 10.000 licenses to sell on their "shop"
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Aloisius on Sunday February 18, 2024 @02:36PM (#39422312)
Apple does handle returns and I'm not sure what support the average brick and mortar store offers.

Stores don't necessarily own all their inventories (stock consignment) and some products are extremely low risk (e.g. phone cards, gift cards, digital goods, etc.)

Calling it a marketplace seems odd considering unlike in traditional marketplaces, there are no competing merchants selling the same goods. There are no other merchants at all.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by rendall on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:08AM (#39418735)
The issue as I understand it is that Apple uses its dominance in hardware to direct users to its own music streaming service at the expense of a competing service. Your analogy does not fit.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by EasyMark on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:29PM (#39424990)
They have a pretty competitive pricing range too. The combined TV, music, and a bit of encrypted disk space is fairly priced. I used to pay for Spotify separately, but when they raised prices a couple of times in a row. It made more sense to just get Apple TV and music for a decent price as I already was using the 50 GB iCloud package because google likely data mines Google Docs/drive. So don't assume everyone is just getting it because it's “there”.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by rendall on Monday February 19, 2024 @10:29AM (#39430814)
The issue is Apple's using its dominance in one domain to restrict competitors in another domain, not whether they offer a better deal. In fact, one would expect that they can offer the best deal around.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by Nextgrid on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:08AM (#39418738)
If you’re the one of 2 stores in the country, yes.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by realusername on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:46AM (#39419025)
The reality is even worse than this analogy, you only have two stores but customers going to one store cannot even shop in the other one!
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:31AM (#39418917)
It would be like if you went to best buy (or whatever electronics store is in your country) and bought a washing machine. This washing machine (in small print no less) has "in-home purchases" that let you change the modes to include color and whites instead of just a "do it all eco-mode." Best buy takes 30% of all these "in-home" purchases because they sold you the washing machine. They assert that you are their customer and you are not the owner of the washing machine. Oh, and you can't share this "in-home purchase" with anyone else that lives with you. If they want this feature, they have to pay for it separately.

If that makes sense to you ... then I guess there isn't much to discuss here.

Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by prepend on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:48AM (#39419047)
This happens. Ever try to sell an app on a Samsung tv? Samsung takes their cut of every purchase.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by withinboredom on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:54AM (#39419090)
I'm relating this to physical/mechanical things to point out how ludicrous the entire model is, but yes, this is the same thing.
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:06AM (#39419178)
You do know many products have their Recommended Retail Price printed on the box?
Re:EU to hit Apple with first ever fine in €500M penalty ove... by kelnos on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:14AM (#39420232)
Yes, absolutely. Unless you're going to argue against the concept of transparency, anyway.