News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by pferde on Friday December 29, 2023 @06:51AM (#38804011)
From the article:

"Later on, Scheller and Freund realised that Pliny didn’t say what Facciolati-Forcellini claimed he did, but they liked the idea so they instead supported it"

I wonder, how many historical so-called facts are similarly based on a whim of some historiographer or other? We should take everything with a grain of salary... I mean, salt. :)

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cies on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:14AM (#38804514)
And this is quite an irrelevant fact. How many people know/remember that the US faked an attack on it's fleet on August 4 to join the Vietnam war?
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hef19898 on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:21AM (#38804576)
The Tonkin Incident. Well, Wikipedia has a decent enough write up of the whole Vietnam War, including the French one, including Tonkin.

The problem is less that those crucial facts are not know, but rather that they get ignored in public discourse.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cies on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:17AM (#38806566)
Exactly! Same for the --benign-- roman wages in salt story. It will get ignored.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hef19898 on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:24AM (#38806678)
And than all kinds of people will use that bit for all kinds of weird theories.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cies on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:40PM (#38809286)
That do not harm a million Iraqi or Viet civs.

Plenty of groups believe/ promote all kinds of "weird theories". As long as they are harmless I dont care. The moment it involves cutting baby penisses or promoting hate I'm voicing myself out against.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hef19898 on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:54PM (#38809460)
The cutting baby penisis remark was totally uncalled for, and can be seen offensive.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by lifeisstillgood on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:27AM (#38804630)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulf_of_Tonkin_incident

One real attack August 2, one confused incident where actually no attack happened.

It's kind of true but really it's hardly a false flag operation

(paraphrasing and being kind to US administration - US Navy breached territorial waters, exchanged fire on Aug 2, then on Aug 4 they fired upon radar returns and possible signals traffic. The second time there was no actual North Vietnamese and the Navy expressed doubts but US administration wanted to escalate and both incidents became conflated. It's not the same as for example pre-planned false flag operations. Is there a fine line? Yes. exactly where that is is hard to say.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cies on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:16AM (#38806551)
I'd say knowingly trying to claim an attack that did not happen is --not a false flag-- but certainly a govt conspiring to deceive "the people".

Not sure what's worse.

And see the result: how many dead Viets? I recently heard a US TV anchor say "all civilian deaths since WW2" (they meant to say "US civ deaths").

The Iraqi WMDs were a similar hoax to get "involved". I never trust a word 3 letter agencies again: professional lairs with zero accountability.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by jvanderbot on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:59AM (#38807205)
I didn't read the above to mean "Knowingly trying to claim at attack that did not happen". I read it as "We aren't sure there's someone there, but please just shoot anyway we need to be aggressive", and political officials portrayed that as "Attack" without proof.

These are congruent accounts with different interpretations, and I tend to believe public speakers are opportunistic spin doctors, not world-shaping conspirators.

As for "never trust a 3 letter agency", that's quite an extreme viewpoint. CDC? EPA? FBI? CIA? NSA? All of them do good, even if their findings can be spun ( or are even directed to be spun ).

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cies on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:37PM (#38809256)
> CDC? EPA? FBI? CIA? NSA? All of them do good

What do you think is the good? Maybe the FBI to some extend (my point was quite a hyperbole I know). But under the line they mostly do bad imho. And they spin their own "findings", that's how we got into this conversation.

I the plan was to invade Vietnam/Iraq, and the attack are propped up to "allow" then to invade. If you think they govt was deceived by it's own speakers, that to my is quite a stretch... The plan was to invade, and the story was made to match. That is a conspiracy in and of itself.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by jvanderbot on Saturday December 30, 2023 @12:23AM (#38812999)
If you're writing off CDC and EPA entirely then I think there's no common ground here.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by genman on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:43PM (#38808628)
And when Communists took power in Vietnam then exactly what was expected to happen happened - a large scale human tragedy with mass killings and torture and mass exodus.

Saddam Hussein was a mass murderer who had murdered around 400 000 people - half of them after US refused to take him down after the Gulf War. Any excuse to get him removed was a good one.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hef19898 on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:07PM (#38809582)
The right time to take down Saddam was after the secind gulf war, the first one with US participation. In the first gulf war between Iraq and Iran, Iraq was an US ally.

And no, removing Saddam with good reason was a really bad idea...

To cut it short, in the frame on the war on terror 4.5 million people died, almost a million directly related to the war and 38 million people displaced. If you think all that was a just price to pay to get Saddam and Bin-Laden, because the Taliban pretty much won, you should re-adjust your moral compass.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by genman on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:46PM (#38810607)
Why should I readjust my moral compass? Because people could not forget their feuds and started to kill? The system held together by terror was pushed out of equilibrium. They had a change to find a better one but they chose not to. If anything then US has done not enough by letting sociopaths in Syria and Iran still run the show - a huge part of the deaths (I'm not going to dispute your claimed numbers) could have been averted and not only in Middle East.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cf1241290841 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @04:19AM (#38813877)
Interesting

>could have

Do you have a rule of thumb how many deaths you are willing to accept and risk on what probabilities for which futures? Also, you used the term sociopaths, do you consider yourself a psychopath?

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by genman on Saturday December 30, 2023 @07:27AM (#38814775)
It is clear now that Syrian leader was willing to murder hundreds of thousands of people, so were Iranian leaders. Moving against them early "could have" avoided large part of the Middle East casualties.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cf1241290841 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @09:49AM (#38815651)
What perspective other then ideology has this not apply to your own position? You seemed pretty comfortable in your position despite the number of people killed and outcome counter to your declared intention.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by genman on Saturday December 30, 2023 @10:19AM (#38815869)
Your personal attacks are lame.

I based my argument based on reduction of human suffering.

Now please, buzz off.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cf1241290841 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @11:00AM (#38816213)
I am sorry that you took it that way, it wasnt intended as such. I responded out of curiosity.

edit: Thank you for your response none the less.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by acqq on Friday December 29, 2023 @07:39PM (#38811843)
You probably don't want to know:

https://pulitzercenter.org/stories/how-us-secret-war-laos-st...

"From 1964 to 1973, the United States bombed Laos more heavily than any country on earth. The reason most Americans do not know this is because it was a secret war orchestrated by the CIA; it stands as the largest covert CIA operation to date."

"One team can find anywhere from three to 16 bombs in a day. The UXO Lao’s 2015 annual report states that since 1996, 1.4 million UXO have been cleared in Laos by a combined effort of UXO Lao and other UXO-clearing organizations, like MAG International. At this rate, it will take thousands of years before Laos is free of UXO."

"Forty percent of UXO victims are children who pick up the bombs, usually thinking they are toys."

The US cluster bombs. Now also in Ukraine:

https://edition.cnn.com/2023/07/20/politics/ukraine-cluster-...

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by genman on Saturday December 30, 2023 @06:52AM (#38814536)
Is this some "Kissinger bad" propaganda take?

US didn't bomb Laos, it bombed Vietnamese Communists covertly operating in and from Laos against Republic of Vietnam and US. The reason that it was a covert war was geopolitical - every actor there operated covertly.

In my country we still find ordnance from WW2 or even WW1. I even had some close encounters.

It looks like some early training of children can save lives. What I can read from https://laos.worlded.org/projects/uxo-education-and-awarenes... is that the education is mainly addressed toward primary school children meaning that the children below the age of 6 will not receive any education (from the program, perhaps there are other programs). What is completely lacking is education of parents.

Now what about cluster bombs in Ukraine?

These have been proven to be highly effective against Russian attacks.

If we talk about future safety concerns then Russian forces have laid mines over vast areas. The density can be as much as 5 mines per square meter and I doubt that they will share the mining maps when this eventually ends (if they even have systematic maps). Already the area affected by the destruction of the Kakhovka Dam by Russians has mines randomly scattered all over the area because of massive flooding.

Ukraine is keeping track of its cluster munition usage and the low percentage of unexploded munitions is a mere drop against the mayhem Russia has created.

Keep in mind that Russia has very clearly declared its genocidal goals.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by Hikikomori on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:32PM (#38818812)
Is this some "US good, Russia bad" propaganda take?
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by genman on Sunday December 31, 2023 @09:40AM (#38824347)
Are you going to argue that a demographic country like Ukraine doesn't have right to protect itself against genocidal aggressor?
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by ilovecurl on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:08AM (#38806425)
If you are ever in the Seattle area, you can tour one of the destroyers that was involved in that incident, the USS Turner Joy, which is docked right next to the ferry terminal in Bremerton.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by narag on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:14PM (#38807467)
How many people know/remember that the US faked an attack on it's fleet on August 4 to join the Vietnam war?

BTW, have you heard of the Maine?

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by newsclues on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:06AM (#38804436)
Not just history, but any field of study.

Trusting experts is a problem, because experts are human.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by toolz on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:17AM (#38804547)
I believe life is most pleasant when you choose to err on the side of trusting experts, but there is something quite amusing (to me) that programmers have "cargo culting" and if you write code and deeply invest in any community you'll meet experts all the time that do things just because others do them, but then you'll meet someone in another highly trained field and just trust what they say is all evidence based.

It's rather curious how many high skill professions seem to default to trusting others based on their credentials.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by paleotrope on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:52AM (#38804851)
“Briefly stated, the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect is as follows. You open the newspaper to an article on some subject you know well. In Murray's case, physics. In mine, show business. You read the article and see the journalist has absolutely no understanding of either the facts or the issues. Often, the article is so wrong it actually presents the story backward—reversing cause and effect. I call these the "wet streets cause rain" stories. Paper's full of them. In any case, you read with exasperation or amusement the multiple errors in a story, and then turn the page to national or international affairs, and read as if the rest of the newspaper was somehow more accurate about Palestine than the baloney you just read. You turn the page, and forget what you know.” ― Michael Crichton
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by yonaguska on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:31AM (#38805278)
Usually, the cost of doing something the wrong way as a programmer is minimal compared to say- a doctor or a rocket scientist. There's not really a governing body on how to do things, as in actual engineering- and most of the work we do is under the constraint of time. saving time means deferring decisions to others. I personally find that there's a lot of value in sifting through and examining the myriad of opinions on a given subject, and coming to your own conclusion, but in the professional world, this a luxury for but a few.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by toyg on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:35AM (#38804702)
The problem is that, as soon as you hit moderate complexity, validating claims becomes difficult, time-consuming, and full of traps. Are you going to microscopically analyse every sausage you eat? If not, how do you trust that it's safe? Experts.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by toolz on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:42AM (#38804761)
I get what you're saying, but I also understand that poses it's own problems. Just because trusting the experts is the best we can do, does not mean that it doesn't sometimes come with significant consequences. History is littered with people abusing their expert status to maliciously achieve some goal.

The first example that comes to my mind is the Tuskegee experiment, where the US public health service and CDC allowed 100 of the 400 men in their study to die, refusing to provide them with treatment for syphilis and preventing them from getting treatment by other means, so they could study the men. They also never revealed to those men that they had syphilis.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by blowski on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:02AM (#38804945)
It’s why pluralism is so important, where experts hold each other to account. It’s worrying when not believing some dogma causes you personal problems.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hef19898 on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:00PM (#38809506)
That behaviour is morally beyond bankrupt and racist. Doesn't mean the people involved were or were not experts in their fields so.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cf1241290841 on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:45AM (#38806128)
You cant actually trust that its safe to eat, you just like the idea and act accordingly. And deal with the consequences of the uncaught error cases. Tainted food still occurs.

At best you can be confident / trust that a product is created in a given process which manages certain risks through certain means.

Also, finding faults in said process is a lot easier then coming up with it or executing it. Be it making a sausage that is unlikely to make you sick or coming to an expert judgement with sufficient confidence to act on.

It doesnt require the ability to validate a process to find it faulty, you just have to detect an error case occurring that isnt dealt with.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by tim333 on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:38AM (#38805391)
I'm happy eating sausages in the UK but less so in say Nepal. No experts involved, just a look at the shops.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hef19898 on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:48AM (#38805504)
All things considered, Nepalese meat is propably saver than industrial one. After all, the remains seen on the sreetside are from the same day, meaning whatever meat you buy was still alive in the morning.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by tim333 on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:30AM (#38805963)
Having eaten in both places and gotten ill in Nepal I'm skeptical. He's a pic of a typical meat shop there. https://c8.alamy.com/zooms/6/445bf76d991f4c27a9b88318955c2e3...

and uk https://www.ballardsbutchers.co.uk/sites/default/files/style...

note differences in cleanliness, refrigeration and so on.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hef19898 on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:33AM (#38806005)
The issue is not the meat, it's the dust. Properly washing it before cooking takes care of that. Vegetables are no different in that regard.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by toyg on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:55PM (#38809461)
Without stringent laws, drafted with experts, your "rule of looks" wouldn't be worth the bits it's written on.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cf1241290841 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:34AM (#38813698)
That sounds like a belief. Laws are obviously incomplete, circumvented and broken all the time. There is no substitute for common sense when it comes to not getting food poisoning. Some data:

There is the show "Bizarre Foods with Andrew Zimmern" in which he ate weird stuff around the globe. He mentioned across several interviews that he never got sick on one of his trips by mostly just staying away from stuff like known bad tap water.

At the same time he had gotten food poisoning 4 times in the last decade in the US. Including

>Worst case was in Portland, Maine eating mussels at a crappy restaurant that I shouldn't have been eating in in the first place. On the road, in the third and fourth world I have not gotten sick.

https://web.archive.org/web/20230607121840/https://starcasm....

If i recall his rule of thumb is that if the local grandmas eat there and they dont use stuff you have to be exposed to for a while to tolerate it (rotten food / tap water in India) you are good to go.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by toyg on Saturday December 30, 2023 @04:43AM (#38813954)
> Laws are obviously incomplete, circumvented and broken all the time.

If they were, we'd have rates of food poisoning close to Nepal's. But we don't. Obviously laws have to be enforced, with checks and all, but they largely work.

Same for tap water: when it's handled following expert-based rules, you don't need to stay away from it. Sure, some can build resistance by repeated exposure, but not everyone; and anyway we don't need to, if we employ the scientific knowledge we built over centuries. It's like saying that births will happen even without expert assistance: sure, but chances that stuff will go horribly wrong are dramatically higher.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cf1241290841 on Saturday December 30, 2023 @05:23AM (#38814122)
"They largely work" doesnt run counter to my argument. I am saying there is no way around common sense to prevent food poisoning in an individual. Being able to lower the overall risk doesnt change that.

You can get food poisoning in the first world by over relying on regulation when you should have known better and you can avoid getting food poisoning in the third world by applying common sense. As long as you can afford to which most people there cant. If tainted water is all you got, you will get sick.

We are making different types of arguments, being able to lower the overall risk doesnt mean common sense / "rule of look" is worthless. Nor does it become worthless in an unregulated environment.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by newsclues on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:47PM (#38807884)
Trust but verify.

Asking experts to provide rationale for their decisions should be welcomed by experts.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hef19898 on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:58PM (#38808021)
All the people I consider experts I ever encountered, where more than happy to explain their rationals. I learned a shit ton of things listening to them.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by tim333 on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:36AM (#38805351)
Experts plus common sense and direct evidence I think works. Experts sometimes come out with complete nonsense, especially if there's politics involved.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by cf1241290841 on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:16AM (#38805817)
I would argue its over relying on complexity management solutions, so less a problem of experts but the inability or unwillingness to live with degrees of uncertainty and manage your confidence/trust accordingly.

The whole expert thing becomes really problematic once people start making circular arguments to justify their existence and then promptly overrely. So the perceived necessity or benefit of having an expert means there has to be somebody you can trust. Which you then promptly overdo without functioning checks and balances.

Expertise cant stem from demonstrated conviction and cant require trust, thats is describing religion and Ponzi schemes. You arent doing experts any favor by treating them as such, at best they still all have incomplete expertise and cant shoulder your reckless levels of trust.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by marcosdumay on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:24AM (#38805191)
One of my favorite ones is that the entire idea that any ancient population ever believed that the Earth is flat seems to come from a semi-fictional biography of Columbus from the 18th century.

Somehow people just read an interesting book and decided that their great-grandparents all believed on that stupid thing.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by bombcar on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:34AM (#38805315)
The sad thing is it obscures the real issue people were bringing up with Columbus - they said the world was much larger than he thought so he would starve and die before getting to the indies.

They were right, too, as the size of the planet was pretty accurately known. He just lucked out that someone had left a continent for him to run into.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by PurpleRamen on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:49AM (#38805516)
Didn't he also never reached the continent, just some islands, which then were used as a starting point for more expeditions?
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hn_throwaway_99 on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:01AM (#38805653)
No, he definitely reached Central and South America. But even until his death he had insisted he had reached the East Indies.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by PurpleRamen on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:11AM (#38805753)
Ah, according to Wikipedia, he only reached the continent on his third and fourth voyage. On his first two expeditions, he was only cruising around the Bahamas, Cuba, etc.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by runeofdoom on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:01PM (#38808883)
I think I recall that his grants from the Spanish crown (and part of his fame) were tied to him having made it to the East Indies. So there would have been motivation for him to stick with his stories.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by PurpleRamen on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:46AM (#38805489)
Define ancient. We do know that cultures from 2000+ years ago believed in a flat earth. There is enough proof for this, and Ancient Greece and Romans discovered this to be wrong. But independent of this, there is also the claim that people in medieval Europe believed in a flat earth, again, and this was brought up as a reason why Columbus expedition would fail when he searched for supporters and ships.

And in fact, such stories are not that uncommon at the 18. Century. Thinkers and scientists were fighting against the church, and they made up many fake stories to show how stupid and dangerous the church is. And AFAIK the church believing in a flat earth was one of them.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by marcosdumay on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:19AM (#38806584)
> We do know that cultures from 2000+ years ago believed in a flat earth.

There are plenty of cultures from 2000+ years ago that never bothered thinking about the shape of Earth. I don't know of any that did bother and decided it was flat (and would really like a pointer), even though I do know of some ambiguous texts that people keep interpreting as that, but are much better explained as they not caring about the shape.

It's quite hard to do astronomy on a larger area than a single city and not discover the planet isn't flat. And it looks like people have been exchanging astronomic findings over some longish distances for longer than they have been writing texts that we can read today.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by Zancarius on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:53AM (#38807103)
> I don't know of any that did bother and decided it was flat (and would really like a pointer)

Semitic cultures very much believed the Earth was more or less a disc-like shape that consisted of the known world (mostly in their sphere of influence, if you pardon the expression). But they also had some other ideas, like that of chaotic universal waters above and below the Earth, separated by the firmament, and supported by pillars (though you can see this idea changing somewhat by the time the book of Job was written). This is a theme that is repeated in Genesis, Isaiah, Job, and one or more of the Psalms.

Not coincidentally, it's fairly well established in the scholarly literature that this was the view of ancient Near Eastern writers, and it wasn't until Young Earth Creationists decided to apply a degree of scientific concordism to the text where we get a more distorted view of Hebrew words like hûg inferring something other than a disc or circular inscription. It's true that they probably didn't care so much about the shape (unlike us), but their cosmology is definitely inferred rather strongly in the biblical texts (and in some cases from their neighbors). John Walton's "Lost World" series on Genesis are a good pointer in this direction, but I'd also suggest the IVP Bible Background Commentary (Walton is a contributor) which certainly touches on this motif and draws upon other creation accounts such as those in the Ugaritic tablets, Baal Cycle, etc. The late Dr. Michael Heiser has a great lecture series you can find on YT talking about biblical cosmology that might help if you're into that format.

The link with Columbus was indeed perpetrating a myth. You get this as recently as Ray Comfort's "Evidence Bible" which is filled with complete buffoonery in that it attempts to explain Columbus' motives based on his mention of Isaiah; YECs like Comfort link this to Isaiah 40:22 (again, with an incorrect reading of hûg). Columbus was motivated by his eschatology and the only reason he ever cited Isaiah was because of its dual function as prophetic-apocalyptic literature.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by marcosdumay on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:28PM (#38810399)
Thanks. Those people seem really interesting.

They were right on the way when the idea of popular astronomy (instead of only god-appointed people doing it) reached Europe, and yet they seem oblivious from it.

It's a really good reminder that even on the era of large empires, culture was still very fractally distributed.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by Zancarius on Saturday December 30, 2023 @11:58AM (#38816687)
> It's a really good reminder that even on the era of large empires, culture was still very fractally distributed.

This is a really good point. The ANE had its own idea of cosmology, Europe its, Asia its, etc. Even then, much of the biblical text contains polemics against Babylonian ideas (recall that cosmology, deity, and "function" are all tied together in their worldview).

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by alex_young on Friday December 29, 2023 @07:02PM (#38811651)
I wonder how this squares with the Babylonian concept of a round earth. It seems odd that so much was uh, “inspired” by their texts but the shape of the earth was exempted.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylonian_astronomy#:~:text....

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by Zancarius on Saturday December 30, 2023 @11:53AM (#38816652)
We have some idea of the evolution of the Babylonian view of the Earth and its approximate dimensions/shape:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylonian_Map_of_the_World

This idea probably wasn't unique to the Babylonians, but this approximation of a disc-shaped Earth was fairly commonplace up to and including the Exhilic Period (biblical texts likely being influenced, at least in part, by the Babylonian views though much of the text is certainly constructed of polemic narratives).

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by D-Coder on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:09PM (#38812297)
If one is being literal:

> Isaiah 11:12: He will raise a signal for the nations and will assemble the banished of Israel, and gather the dispersed of Judah from the four corners of the earth.

Which clearly indicates some kind of quadrilateral, or perhaps a tetrahedron.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by Zancarius on Saturday December 30, 2023 @12:39PM (#38816965)
LOL! You know, I think I'm going to use this the next time someone disputes biblical cosmology.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by PurpleRamen on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:33AM (#38806817)
> There are plenty of cultures from 2000+ years ago that never bothered thinking about the shape of Earth.

For those, we don't have any kind of indicator what they believed about earths shape, so why do they matter?

The way you phrased your comment indicated that you kinda believe that now one at any point in early history really believed in a flat earth, and it's all just a story made up later.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by robertlagrant on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:36PM (#38811049)
Half this comment section is saying that.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by lehi on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:34PM (#38807709)
Chinese astronomical records were extensive, accurate, and continual for more than 3000 years. They believed the Earth was flat and square until the 17th century.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by genman on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:15PM (#38808248)
If you read a story about the edge of the world then you have an example of an "flat earth" believer.

Regardless of shape, I think the most fundamental shift occurred with the idea that the Earth is not a center of the universe.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hef19898 on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:57PM (#38809483)
Earth at the center of the universe was one, the sun turning around earth another. The latter so was known to be most likely true for a long time by everyone who worked on astronomy.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by WalterBright on Friday December 29, 2023 @06:25PM (#38811431)
When I was little, I just assumed that the sun revolved around the Earth. I recall not believing it when I was told the converse.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by genman on Saturday December 30, 2023 @06:53AM (#38814546)
How were you eventually convinced that it is not true?
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by WalterBright on Saturday December 30, 2023 @01:02PM (#38817171)
Adults explaining it to me.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by poizan42 on Friday December 29, 2023 @07:19PM (#38811748)
In Old Norse mythology, the Midgard Serpent (Jörmungandr) encircles the earth, so it would seem they believed the earth to be a disc.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by hnfong on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:55PM (#38812704)
> I don't know of any that did bother and decided it was flat (and would really like a pointer)

天圓地方 (literally: sky round, land square) was a serious core idea in ancient Chinese cosmology that was most popular 2000 years ago around the Han Dynasty period.

As for some serious pointers as you requested, here: https://ctext.org/lunheng/shuo-ri/zh

There's a couple paragraphs arguing that the sky isn't round (dome-like) but "flat" and parallel to the land because people have travelled and have never seen the sky merge with the land. (see the paras starting "實者、天不在地中,日亦不隨天隱,天平正,與地無異。")

You might say the ancient Chinese didn't care enough so they ended up with wrong conclusions (or parroted whatever was told to them by even more ancient sources that just made up its cosmology), but at any rate the Chinese definitely did believe in flat earth 2000 years ago, and we have very reliable records for that one.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by whiddershins on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:58AM (#38805621)
For example, many people today believe that we only use 10% of our brain.

But it wouldn’t be fair to say that’s what our “culture” believes to be true.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by jncfhnb on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:24PM (#38807586)
It is true in the sense that we only use about 10%, at any given time, for some definitions of percent. People just fail to understand that the other 90% is just not useful, rather than unused potential.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by spigottoday on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:49PM (#38808711)
That is news to me and interesting. Do you have a citation or link to share?
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by srinivgp on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:49PM (#38810635)
"people only use about 2% of the volume of their house at any given time"
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by GuB-42 on Friday December 29, 2023 @07:57PM (#38811931)
I thought bullshit too. After all, why would chemical reactions in the brain stop? But after a bit of thinking and Googling, I stumbled upon this

https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2020/aug/energy-demands-limit-our...

Not saying that only X% of our brain is being used, but what it essentially says is that our brain is power-limited, and therefore, it has to be selective in which parts to "turn on". It makes a lot of sense, there are few things in life more important than energy and power management, and human brains already need lots of both.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by duskwuff on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:37PM (#38812413)
We have a word for what happens when people "use 100% of their brain".

We call that an epileptic seizure. :)

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by melagonster on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:38PM (#38812418)
scientists distinguished function of different regions in our brain, so human doesn't need to use all region is a more obvious idea now.

I can't recommend literature, a probably source is in medical textbook.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by Ekaros on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:57PM (#38810719)
Is it even usable at same time? There is some level of plasticity, but in general certain parts activate for certain tasks and you can't really make it use more parts at one time.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by aeonik on Saturday December 30, 2023 @08:58AM (#38815314)
Your brain can definitely get bursts of more activity, it's not desirable though. They are called seizures.

https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/seizure/sympt...

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by russdill on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:54PM (#38810688)
People thought Columbus's voyage would fail precisely because they believed the Earth to be a sphere and thus the distance from Europe to India was too far to traverse. Columbus tried to convince everyone it would succeed by claiming the Earth was instead pear shaped.

https://sacred-texts.com/earth/boe/boe26.htm

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by SilasX on Friday December 29, 2023 @06:13PM (#38811350)
Also, when someone says, "they knew the earth was round in the Middle Ages", they mean "educated people knew". Guess what fraction were educated? Not many. So ... averaged over the population, it's not entirely correct.

It would be like saying, "It's a myth that in the 21st century, they were bunch of rubes who were unaware that every single object is exerting a gravitational force on them." Well, um, it's a myth that physics-educated people were unaware of this, sure. But most people have no reason to learn about this or be aware of it; it's not relevant to everyday life.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by throw0101b on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:16PM (#38808268)
> One of my favorite ones is that the entire idea that any ancient population ever believed that the Earth is flat seems to come from a semi-fictional biography of Columbus from the 18th century.

See also the religion-science conflict thesis, which was popularized by Draper and White:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conflict_thesis

> My guests today are David Hutchings and James C. Ungureanu, co-authors of Of Popes and Unicorns: Science, Christianity and How the Conflict Thesis Fooled the World. David is a physicist, science teacher and writer and James is a historian of science and religion. In this interview we discuss their book and the origin and impact of the Conflict Thesis - the pervasive but erroneous idea that religion and science have always been in conflict down the ages.

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PkfA4v8cwYM

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by acqq on Friday December 29, 2023 @07:31PM (#38811811)
Oh, there's now a bunch of accounts claiming that Galileo was "just" mean to pope and therefore "guilty", but this is an actual pro-religion propaganda. The real sentence is preserved up to this day and is completely clear:

https://hti.osu.edu/sites/default/files/documents_in_the_cas...

"heresy" ... "that the earth does move, and is not the center of the world" ... "contrary to Holy Scripture"

More detailed:

"We pronounce, judge, and declare, that you, the said Galileo . . . have rendered yourself vehemently suspected by this Holy Office of heresy, that is, of having believed and held the doctrine (which is false and contrary to the Holy and Divine Scriptures) that the sun is the center of the world, and that it does not move from east to west, and that the earth does move, and is not the center of the world; also, that an opinion can be held and supported as probable, after it has been declared and finally decreed contrary to the Holy Scripture".

Additionally, Galileo's and Copernicus' books were finally removed from the index of the banned books only in 1835, they were on the banned list for more than 200 years, since the 1616 Inquisition's judgment.

Context: Galileo was the first person to see with his own eyes with his first of the kind self-made telescope the moons that are today known as Galilean moons and recognized them as the satellites of Jupiter in March 1610. Which convinced him that the understanding of the church was wrong. The church sentenced him in 1633 to house arrest where he remained until his death in 1642.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galilean_moons

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by throw0101b on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:29PM (#38812092)
> Context: Galileo was the first person to see with his own eyes with his first of the kind self-made telescope the moons that are today known as Galilean moons and recognized them as the satellites of Jupiter in March 1610.

Which was not evidence for heliocentrism.

In the early 1600s there were seven models floating around: Heraclidean (geo-heliocentric), Ptolemaic, Copernican (heliocentric, pure circles with lots of epicycles), Gilbertian, Tychonic, Ursine, Keplerian.

Newton, in his Principia (1687), did not use calculus to present his Universal Graviation: rather it was carefully structured in Aristotelian form, with axioms and deductive logic. Kepler's laws can be deduced from principles. Still no coriollis or parallax.

The first inkling of the Earth's motion comes in 1728 when James Bradley detects stellar aberration in γ-Draconis. In 1791 Giovanni Guglielmini finds a 4 mm Coriolis deflection over a 29 m drop, thus providing empirical evidence of rotation. In 1806 Giuseppi Calandrelli publishes "Ozzervatione e riflessione sulla paralasse annua dall’alfa della Lira," reporting parallax in α-Lyrae. So parallax, the chief evidence for the Earth's motion came 250+ years after Galileo.

Stellar parallax was considered since at least Aristotle, as he mentions in his On the Heavens (II.14), and since it is not observed then it is reasonable to conclude that there is no motion (it took several thousand years to develop instruments to actually measure it).

Galileo's chief problems were (a) he was an egotistical jackass, and (b) he had no evidence for what he was claiming to be true. He was allowed to put forward the Copernican model "suppositionally", i.e., as an hypothesis, and "not absolutely". The latter of which, (b), Galileo admitted in his first deposition (12 April 1633): it was concluded that his book put forward the idea 'absolutely', which is where his conviction comes from.

By the late 1600s most folks had switched over to the Keplerian model: not necessarily because they thought it was what was actually happening in reality, but probably because it made the math easier.

For a good timeline of events, see (recently late) Michael F. Flynn's "The Great Ptolemaic Smackdown":

* https://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/10/the-great-ptolemaic-sma...

Daniel Whitten's "Matters of Faith and Morals Ex Suppositione" is also an interesting read.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by acqq on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:40PM (#38812427)
So yes, that's exactly an example of the "guilty Galileo and the good church" false narrative.

Many useless claims which don't disprove that his sentence was literally because of:

"heresy" ... "that the earth does move, and is not the center of the world" ... "contrary to Holy Scripture"

And the church forbade his book as "heresy" for 200 years.

He was right. The church was wrong, directly referring to the effing "Holy Scripture" to support its claim and played fighting "heresy", keeping being wrong for 200 years afterwards. It's so clear.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by throw0101b on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:11PM (#38812769)
> He was right.

Monkeys throwing darts can also (just happen to) be "right" when picking stocks that do well in the market. Galileo had as much evidence in believing Copernicus was right as the monkeys.

If he had simply stuck to simply arguing both sides of an hypothesis in his Dialogue, which he was asked to do by the pope in the first place, it would have saved everyone a lot of trouble. Heck, Kepler's stuff was already around for decades, and Galileo completely ignored it (along with Tycho):

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dialogue_Concerning_the_Two_Ch...

If you want to argue 'for science' then Galileo is not a good example: the only thing he just happen to be right about was that the sun was the centre of things, whereas everything else in the Copernican system (including epicycles) was just as messy as in Ptolemy. There was no practical reason to switch systems, and no evidence to think it was correct.

At the end of the day the person who actually got things right was Kepler, and he kept plugging away at the problem because of this belief that the physical world reflected the spiritual realm (KGW XIII, letter 23, 35; 1595)

> In this way, then, the Sun, itself at rest in the middle and yet the fount of motion, carries the image of God the Father and creator. For what creation is to God, motion is to the Sun. Moreover, it moves [the planets] in a fixed place, as the Father creates in the Son. Unless the fixed stars offered a place, thanks to their motionlessness, no movement could exist. I defended this axiom while still in Tübingen. The Sun distributes motive virtue through the medium space, in which the planets are found: just as the Father creates by spirit or by the virtue of His spirit. And from the necessity of these presuppositions, it follows that motion is in proportion with distance.

See Kozhamthadam's "The Religious Foundations of Kepler's Science" and "Theological Foundations of Kepler's Astronomy" by Barker and Goldstein.

Going further, one needs to believe in certain metaphysical assumptions before you can even start doing what we know call science:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalism_(philosophy)#Provid...

There were plenty ideas floating around at the time, but ideas are cheap. Galileo certainly made important improvements to telescope technology, but his efforts in moving forward new models (specifically Copernican) were a dead end, and he made no practical difference to things: Kepler was already defending Copernicus in his Mysterium Cosmographicum (1e 1596), and put forward his laws in Astronomia nova (1609), a copy of which he sent to Galileo, which Galileo promptly ignored even two decades later when he published his Dialogue (1632).

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by acqq on Saturday December 30, 2023 @12:01AM (#38812925)
You still can't deny: the church was wrong, directly referring to the effing "Holy Scripture" to support its claim.

The Earth was never the center around which the Sun rotated. Not in 1AD, not in 1600AD, not now.

If the church claimed that the "Holy Scripture" says that the Earth is in the center, the church was still wrong, and moreover, the "Holy Scripture" was wrong.

The church can't be right to claim "heresy" to somebody who was right then and is still right now.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by defrost on Saturday December 30, 2023 @12:15AM (#38812966)
It was never a grand Science Vs Church issue, not at the time at least, that came perhaps later with legend.

It wan't even the case that the Pope (in person) was mad with Galileo for being used as a Simplicio caricature and figure of fun in his work.

All the data used came from church funded observatories and church backed astronomers, all the main ideas from both sides of the debate came from church funded theorists.

The crux of the dispute and the trial was pretty much that Galileo was a dedicated edgelord who had decades of pissing people off and making enemies on his ledger.

Think less about religion Vs science and more about maverick asshole vs. faction within giant bureaucracy.

Once Galileo had "insulted the Pope" the knives came out and his enemies struck, it was a pure show trial fueled by personal vindictiveness that came from being the target of savage biting insults.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by acqq on Saturday December 30, 2023 @12:18AM (#38812975)
Still:

- the church officially wrote that the Earth is the center

- that the Holy Scripture says so and

- whoever says differently is heretic

and the Earth was never the center.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by defrost on Saturday December 30, 2023 @12:25AM (#38813003)
None of which had much to do with the persecution of Galileo.

The Catholic Church has changed its stance on many things through time, see [history].

In this instance the Church itself had officially requested a presentation be made to demonstrate various arguments for and against different viewpoints .. one of which was that the heavens didn't rotate about the earth.

It wasn't a surprise that such a well known hypothetical should appear in a book commissioned to outline such hypotheticals.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by throw0101b on Saturday December 30, 2023 @08:40AM (#38815183)
> You still can't deny: the church was wrong, directly referring to the effing "Holy Scripture" to support its claim.

It was the pope that asked Galileo to write a book in the first place. The Church was so against the idea that… its leader asked a prominent natural philosopher to write about. The book had two imprimatur approvals.

> The Earth was never the center around which the Sun rotated. Not in 1AD, not in 1600AD, not now.

And there was no evidence to support this assertion until 1728 and Bradley with γ-Draconis, and with the first parallax report in 1806 and Calandrelli (a priest) with α-Lyrae/Vega (the actual value he calculated was wrong). It was not a new idea when Copernicus published his book in 1543, nor when Kepler defended it in 1596, nor when Galileo published his Dialgoue in 1623: Aristotle most famously considered it in ~300 BC and rejected it for lack of evidence. Anaxagoras (400s BC) and Aristarchus of Samos put forward heliocentrism.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by marcosdumay on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:53PM (#38812698)
Oh, the Galileo thing.

Politics is a complex thing where people don't mean what they say, and their meaning change depending on who are listening, how, why and when.

Heliocentrism was discovered by a joint-enterprise of two enemy churches, and only became heresy post-facto when some very good evidence arrived. But by then it seemed to really become heresy, and was punished by itself. Almost certainly the Galileo's posture was important for that, but the society's context was way more important.

Anyway, you won't get any good conclusion if you insist on analyzing the politicians arguments on logic or expect coherence.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by emmelaich on Saturday December 30, 2023 @02:07AM (#38813349)
And yet ... Pope Urban VIII was a patron of Galileo and encouraged him to write his treatise.

Those who judged Galileo were part of the Roman Inquisition.

Pope Urban's hands were tied when Galileo was seen to mock the pope and church through the figure and dialogue of Simplicio.

This is of course does not make the adjudication OK but you're going too far in the opposite direction.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by renewiltord on Saturday December 30, 2023 @06:16AM (#38814353)
Haha yeah, the whole "Galileo was mean" is just insight porn nonsense. Evidence-free claim.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by defrost on Saturday December 30, 2023 @06:27AM (#38814408)
There's the evidence of the character Simplicio, who employed stock arguments in support of geocentricity, and was depicted in the book as being an intellectually inept fool.

The arguments made "by an idiot" were clear swipes at both Lodovico delle Colombe and Cesare Cremonini.

And other passages in other works of Galileo, but that alone is sufficiento sink "Evidence-free claim".

This has been batted back and forth since (at least) The Sleepwalkers (1959) by Arthur Koestler so you can argue against the assertaion but it's foolish to pretend there isn't reams of references on this going back decades.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by renewiltord on Saturday December 30, 2023 @06:53AM (#38814551)
That's not evidence. That's the claim. If you claim that he was put to death for making fun of someone, you can't prove that by claiming that he made fun of someone. It's total conspiracy theory stuff.

All those references are in the class of this salt stuff in the OP. They're whole fiction.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by throw0101b on Saturday December 30, 2023 @09:25AM (#38815487)
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by refurb on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:40PM (#38812639)
> Somehow people just read an interesting book and decided that their great-grandparents all believed on that stupid thing.

Just go on social media today to see the same thing in action.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by gretch on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:27PM (#38812084)
I personally am very skeptical of the other salt theory - salting the earth as a means of disrupting enemy soil.

I started to think about it in depth when thinking about weed control in my own backyard - should I salt my own soil?

The I realized how quickly it would wash away in the next rain. And for ancient times, the sheer volume of salt one would need in order to disrupt a significant amount of land.

I dunno maybe it happened, but it seems like a very very dumb way to go about it. Then again, humans repeatedly prove the magnitude of our stupidity.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by edaemon on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:23PM (#38812351)
This same site has an article on that very myth: http://kiwihellenist.blogspot.com/2016/12/salting-earth.html...

To summarize, salting an area was a real thing, but the evidence suggests that it was done to make the land more fertile and not less. The idea was to replace your enemy's city with weeds and greenery, as if it had never existed.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by dexwiz on Friday December 29, 2023 @08:47PM (#38812189)
Yeah it would take a ludicrous amount to kill a field. Might as well put down gold foil weed barrier.
Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by giraffe_lady on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:44PM (#38812443)
Interestingly, accidentally making the soil too salty to support agriculture is one of the consequences of improperly managed irrigation over longish time scales, like decades to centuries. It's well understood now but I don't believe that it was to ancient peoples.

I don't know how this could be weaponized or if anyone ever made a serious attempt at it. But it's experienced as massive regional catastrophe when it does, and the cause is clear even if not understood. There are places in arizona and california where salt crystals visibly form on the surface of what used to be farmland: it's plausible this would have been seen in the irrigation agriculture societies of mesopotamia and the ancient eastern mediterranean. Certainly easy to make the jump to fantasizing/praying about it happening to your enemies, once you've seen or heard of it.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by buzzin__ on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:24PM (#38812359)
Pliny the Elder and his son Pliny the Younger are also involved in debunking another historical fakery. This one is about Jesus actually existing and not being made up 100 years later and 1000 kms away, in a different country and in a different language.

As much as you can prove a negative, this guys do it by never mentioning him, despite being at the right place and time, and writing about other religions and prophets.

Even the wikipedia entry on this subject starts with a huge logical phalacy.

Re:Salt and salary: were Roman soldiers paid in salt? (2017) by gamblor956 on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:05PM (#38812529)
The Elder Pliny would have been a small child when Jesus died. Not many 10 year olds in the historical record discussing religion.