I think realistically, someone has the well meant opinion that these conferences should only be held in places where everyone can feel completely safe, and then just completely ignores reality. The unfortunate result is an effectual ban on any meetings in places like Africa or the Middle East, which is equally unreasonable and excluding.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_by_country_or_terr...
The rolling blackouts would also probably be pretty annoying though.
1. Python evangelism is about the tech and is not an endorsement of whoever organize conferences, even if is in nazi Germany.
2. Giving money to a conference IS an endorsement of whoever organize it, so it must comply with the morals of the PSF board and biggest backers.
In hindsight, (1) seems more fair, but because the PSF is about politics and not tech, is not surprising they will always choose (2).
Curiously, it's limited to non-white/non-Western countries. No one is sanctioning Israel for ethnic cleansing, textbook settler colonialism and apartheid going on since 1948.
Companies like Microsoft are proudly sponsoring it.
The entirety of the US would get a lifetime ban if we did that.
Have you not heard what it's like for an Arab or Muslim going through Israeli airports? Sure, they'll be detained and deported at most, but that's enough to exclude the idea of visiting to give a conference talk.
You manage to get past, let's say, Saudi customs as a trans person, get ready for jail time for the crime of existing. Not comparable.
There are legitimate criticisms we can levy against Israel without fabricating a nonexistent reality.
Arab Israeli citizens have the same fundamental legal rights as Jewish Israelis, but they tend to live in poorer cities, have less formal education, and face other challenges that some experts attribute to structural discrimination. In this way you can consider a similarity between the racial tensions in the US.
20% of Israel's population is Arab and the majority among that are Sunni Muslim. However they are afforded the same means of professional development and the same opportunities to speak publicly.
Also I think it's pathetic to discuss religion as if it's something as inalienable or difficult to hide as skin colour, biological sex or ethnicity. Religion is emphatically a choice and not identifying yourself as religious is an option that most people have while travelling.
Religious persecution is wrong but it's a different "level" of wrong even if we conveniently ignore the fact that the same rights exist for all citizens.
tl;dr: You're wrong about what you believe about the state of israel in this case and likening religious intolerance to imprisonment for race, gender, sexuality etc; is also wrong.
Israeli airport security is racist and that's a fact. Being able to hide your religion is not always possible. PSF put religion, sexual orientation, national origin, and ethnicity on an equal footing in their consideration of diversity. https://www.python.org/community/diversity/
Yes, both Zanzibar and Israel are doing bad things and certain groups are affected. But these arguments only seem to come out when "people like us" are affected (LGBT, not Muslims) and when "people unlike us" are affecting (Africans, not Israelis. Not Floridians. Not...).
> as inalienable or difficult to hide as [...] biological sex
in case you extrapolated from my comment: i'm me, but other people are other people, and "the cis" can, in fact, not always tell. not even usually.
Iranian, North Korean and Cuban speakers, for example, would not be able to travel to America (or any US-allied country) as there are very explicit sanctions placed on those countries.
Unless you're claiming Palestine is part of Israel and thus Palestinian citizens are Israeli ones, which would be a very controversial statement indeed.
Weird example since Jews are generally the ones who were getting cleansed. They were evicted by extreme Christians, then murdered by Nazi Germans (remember when US and Canada did not accept a shipful of Jews fleeing gas chambers so they had to go back and die?) and 1948 is when Arab League attacked the new country the next day after it was created. Meanwhile Muslim people in Israel lead far better lives than in many surrounding countries with access to good healthcare, education etc.
And you know what? Africans had nothing to do with it
This is more of a special privilege granted to Israel specifically.
If you policies put people at risk, limit to participation is a natural consequence. There is no conspiracy here.
>I am an African. And I live in a country where such laws targeting LGBTQ has been enacted. FYI, Most people here have no idea what LGBTQ means and those who do don't give a damn. Those leading the making of laws and noise making are just populists after their bread. [These are facts, hoping they still matter]
>If you feel so strong about attending the conference, no one is going to ask your sexual orientation at the airport. Tourists are coming in everyday. Qatar has just hosted the world cup, how many LGBTQ people were jailed? If you don't feel safe, just skip the conference or attend online.
Bullshit.
You are asking people to be invisible, when that's not practical or possible a lot of the time. You are just saying people wouldn't be offended if they don't have the information to be offended. That is not remotely the same as safety.
Case in point: I'm visibly trans, I don't have a toggle for my appearance. I'd be turned around the border in most golf states.
But that should not be a reason to not fund conferences in those countries, conferences which are a way to learn, to discover new things.
What do you think about conferences organizers, of every country, having to put on their website a little explanation of the laws of their country.
Each explanation would be something:
"In our country, the law forbid XXX. We are very sorry for the people concerned by this law and we are sad about those laws. We would ensure that the conference space is a safe space but they should be aware of those rules still apply in the whole country.
In every case, always choose safety. We are missing you, we hope to have the chance to meet you in another time.".
I feel like installing a tradition of such a disclaimer for every tech conference in the world would:
1. Force people to acknowledge issues in their own country (instead of minimizing them). And I guess every country has its own problem.
2. Show support for the victims of those laws and, indirectly, showing supports for the victims in their own country
3. Advance the cause, change mentality. It forces locals and politicians to be confronted with the fact that international visitors (which every country is trying to attract) may disagree to the point of not coming to the conference.
4. It would be nearly risk-free for conference organizer as it could also be defended as a polite way to ask attendees to respect the law.
How would you feel about the PSF (or any other society you sponsor) helping conferences in places you'd not be able to attend because you simply would not be safe there? I understand there are good reasons for funding conferences in countries that would be hostile to many PSF members, because not all people who'd attend to such conferences agree with the intolerance (by law or by custom).
> "In our country, the law forbid XXX"
I would not wish the PSF to be seen as supportive of such behavior.
I would feel very good, because those places are often ignored from such events. A conference in a place is done first for the locals. Saying to all of africa "sorry you can't have a conference this year because the westerners that have 10 a year would not be able to come" is what would make me feel bad. Add on top of that coming to western conferences from africa is usually way too expensive for the median income there. Oh and travel issue for passports when getting into the US or Europe.
I've been reading this whole thread as "westerners being entitled to go to an african conference, run by and for people in africa"
However the reality is, it is staffed by westerners and funded by western companies. So it's a de-facto western foundation.
> In theory the PSF should be worldwide with people from everywhere.
Why?
As for why, well, precisely to avoid the bias at hand here. The tech, despite originating from the west, is what it is: a tech. Especially something as ubiquitous as Python, which is far from being scoped to the west.
We go to great lengths for equity in such boards, promoting openness and such: more women, more LGBT+, people of color, ... But even black people that are included are most often than not are afro-americans living in the west, and not africans living in africa. We always forget about foreign users that are also a minority, except a remote one we can shrug off, unless they are vocal enough.
That said, I acknowledge it may not be possible, the foundation likely being an US nonprofit, so integrating foreigners in the board may be extremely difficult.
As far as I know, it's not a problem. At first glance, PSF board and officers bios appear fairly international currently.
A foreign controlled, foreign benefitting organization that sends nearly all contributions to foreign organizations might not be tax exempt in the US, but that doesn't sound like the PSF.
Since diversity and inclusivity are core values, I'll dodge the question and just say it's inclusive by design.
I’m avoiding visiting lot of countries where I know that people like me are not safe. Sometimes to the astonishment of my family "but, seriously, there’s no risk. It is a touristic country". Yep, but they put people I feel connected to in jail. I will not go. But I would be glad if they have more hacker-type events.
One country where I don’t feel really safe anymore is USA (at least some part of it). Lot of people cannot attend conferences because they can’t enter USA. Yet, it probably makes sense to still fund conferences in the USA.
So why not everywhere else, even if some people cannot attend?
And it is absolutely true that it is a western double standard. Football tournaments in gulf states and all.
I was more upset the top comment in this thread is "shitting on human rights is just a difference of opinion" apologetics.
expecting this from every conference could potentially put conference organizers at risk for criticizing their local laws or culture.
at best this information can be shared by global institutions. so the PSF could issue their funding accompanied by such a statement
"Our country taxes alcohol stupidly high, and nudity is 100% OK"
And
"Women are second class citizens and owned by their male counterparts. And we put gay people and trans people to death."
As much as I hate saying it, it doesn't matter who the individuals in a country are, and how tolerant they are. The laws by the ruling power are what you have to follow.
And fuck no going to a country based on Muslim Sharia. I know their book, and their brand of hate. Call it 'islamophobia', but I'd also be enslaved or executed if I stepped foot on their territories.
Also, if they know I am an apostate, and they ask me that at the border, I'll have to choose between death because I am an apostate, and death by a likely more painful method because I am an apostate and I also lied to a customs officer.
All the while that Id be put to death for my own religious choices and LGBTQ persuasion.
Frankly, most of the African and Middle Eastern governments are shitholes with laws that would execute and/or enslave us and our women relatives. (This also barring the 13th amendment, which I also highly disagree with its allowance of slavery.)
But we're supposed to be tolerant of that extreme intolerance? Fuck, and, no. I'm all for shunning those countries until they change their laws and respect things like religious choice, sexual choice, and bodily choice.
(Note: Tanzania, according to Pew, 95% of the people "believed that homosexuality is a way of life that society should not accept". So yeah, roll a D100, 95 or more means they're decent. Not good odds.
(Note, the USA has done the type of foreign intervention that time and again, to terrible effect. Me? I'll just stay the fuck away from countries that want to execute me for being.)
Tanzania is exactly that case, with a 2007 Pew survey finding that 95% +-4% that "believed that homosexuality is a way of life that society should not (be) accept(ed)".
Let them fix their own problems first to a point that *being* isn't criminalized with lifetime prison or execution.
It's probably safer to start with TV shows first, or hosting conferences in safer places nearby, until the culture is changed.
I would strongly discourage anyone at risk from visiting a country where their existence is a crime from visiting such country.
How long ago were the LGBTQ people also at risk in the Western world? I understand organisations like PSF have their codes to abide by and safety of attendees is and should be a priority.
But if your main mission is to promote python in the whole world. It's not impossible to issue an advisory that LGBTQ people are advised to do this or that about a given location. Python coders have nothing to do with politicians.
supposed to be, right, let's stop talking about this before I violate the unwritten rule of good tone trumps everything on HN.
Your own life choices regarding body modifications and suchlike don't need to be held over everyone else in those regions who will benefit from these conferences.
Probably not, identity groups all over the world have been brought into direct conflict over limited resources thanks to new communications technology shrinking the world.
LGBTQ is a very powerful political movement in America.
Well, PSF is not feeling safe about the conference and are skipping it.
Different countries have different customaries. Where I am from, it is considered impolite not to respect the host's rules while attending as a guest.
At some point you have to scan your passport.
The US already had cases where travelers have had to disclose social media use [1]. I don’t think it is a stretch for this process to be copied for more nefarious uses.
1. https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/31/20837448/social-media-dhs...
> no one is going to ask your sexual orientation at the airport
This is not ensured, even if the Tanzanian people are themselves renown for their hospitality.
Is reality really that hard for some people? I geniunely don't understand how navigating society can be so difficult?
Even in most western countries, tolerance for that is weak now, and was absent in living memory.
You... probably should refresh your memory of the centrality and significance of militant activism, particularly in the context of the AIDS crisis by groups like ACT-UP, in the gay rights movement then.
> but the majority of the hard work was done via cultural insertion using movies and so on.
No, much hard work had to be done to acheive the level of influence in powerful institution to do “cultural insertion using movies and so on”.
Here in the US there are states that, sadly, aren't that supportive of human rights. And rather than handwring over "should we hold an event there?" they just never consider those places. Because there's no such tension.
At least Western governments have the idea of Universal Human Rights ( https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-huma... )
And being 'accepted' or not is wholly different than 'executed' or 'jailed for life'.
And for me, it's simple: don't go to most of Africa or anywhere in the Middle East. They're shitholes not worthy of my money or my presence.
Versus "we respect all humans, including minority views and consensual actions".
Or, well, even being. Remember, these countries (which are Muslim theocratic based), that simply being homosexual, regardless of practices, is enough for life imprisonment or execution by the state.
If the expectation of not being murdered by an ass-backwards state that codified 1200 year old laws is "white privilege", then your definition is laughably busted. The term you're really looking for is "civilized", with stress on civil.
(The USA is also sliding into theocratic dictatorship, with re-implementation of idiotic 2000 year old christian "laws" codified. And again, religion itself is the problem. Same with Israel. Same with India. It all goes back to religious fanatics demanding everyone follow their brand of shit.)
And that's where you crossed over into being racist
Is a government employee or politician a race now?
People are *born* gay, bisexual, heterosexual, asexual. And these un-civil-ized people think that by imprisoning and/or murdering gay and bisexual people, you can make the problem go away. (Protip: it's as successful as the 'War on Drugs' in other words; it isn't successful and will never be. But it will be great at continuing misery.)
Until they can start treating fellow humans with respect and dignity, I say we quarantine them. And when they start acting and treating fellow humans decently, and not by some dusty old book that belongs in museums (Torah, Bible, Koran), then keep them in the proverbial corner until they can behave.
The point with many of these questions is so that they can detain you on suspicion of being dishonest on your visa questionnaire, and then investigate more thoroughly.
You also have (if a non-citizen) extremely few, if any rights at points of entry. A lot of laws around searching of persons and devices are if not void, substantially loosened.
So you may lie. You should probably also hope that somewhere in your photos there's not a picture of a magic mushroom you saw last year while walking your dog...
And of course, while suppressing all that, don’t forget to enjoy local “hospitality”, the Python event - networking, creativity, conversing with your peers, learning and exchanging ideas.
So, if someone attends with their partner, are you suggesting they "just... not" show any affection towards them while they're there? No hugging, no hand-holding, no pecks on the cheek? No resting a head on a shoulder?
"Stating your sexual preference" is more nuanced that standing at passport control and blurting out "I'm gay!". Not stating it can involve changing the whole way you behave around the person you're closest to in the world.
...where straight people do not have to make any such changes.
> Where I am from, it is considered impolite not to respect the host's rules while attending as a guest.
That kind of assumes that the hosts rules are at least somewhat fair. If straight people can act naturally around their partners, but people with other sexual preferences have to police all their normal behaviours all the time, lest they are impolite enough to break the hosts rules, should those rules really be considered worthy of respect?
Yes, I expect that absolutely. We also expect that behavior from students in high school during class. There's a time and place for things, and attending a conference in a country where such things are considered illegal is neither.
> That kind of assumes that the hosts rules are at least somewhat fair. If straight people can act naturally around their partners, but people with other sexual preferences have to police all their normal behaviours all the time, lest they are impolite enough to break the hosts rules, should those rules really be considered worthy of respect?
I am terribly sorry and I get how you feel and yes, this is unfair, but those are the rules made by the country. If a software conference is the hill you want to die on for your values, I respect that, but please also respect that most people just don't care or are fine with respecting the rules, so the conference can take place with or without you. And no, there is no magic country that has no unfairness towards any group, there will always be groups that have it easier in some countries than in others, so in my opinion it's fair to conduct conferences in different countries. There will never be 100% fairness in the world.
First, let me say I agree with this, as with the rest of the points made in the Python Africa letter. It's spot on.
> There's a time and place for things, and attending a conference in a country where such things are considered illegal is neither.
My issue is, saying "can't you... just not?" (IMHO) massively trivialises how much of a sacrifice you're asking non-straight people to make. "can't you... just not?" seems to imply an incredulity why this would be any kind of imposition for non-straight people, and they should, like, get over it, man.
It is a reality that LGBT+ people have to face, and make their own decisions about, but that doesn't mean it's fine to make it out like no big deal.
> this is unfair, but those are the rules made by the country.
I get that. And also, that anyone attending needs to respect the fact that publicly disobeying the rules can have serious consequences.
Should the rules be obeyed? Probably. But are they worthy of respect? Fuck no.
> most people just don't care or are fine with respecting the rules,
I think you mean "most people not affected by the rules just don't care...". The same could be said for any civil rights struggle in the past. For a long time, most men didn't care or were just fine with respecting rules that discriminated against women, and most white people didn't care or were just fine with respecting rules that discriminated against people of color.
When people who are not affected by such rules stand up against them, that really helps.
sure, but then shouldn't organizations like PSF take that into account when considering funding? by sponsoring the event they're endorsing it. so you could also see how it's not that great to endorse an event where you should warn attendees "hey don't gay it up bro they will beat you down here. just hide your shameful activity until you get back home."
"Don't be a woman or if you are a woman just mask that and subject yourself to men while in the country that discriminates against women. Please, women, don't make this a political thing. When in Rome..."
I very much agree with the point of your post. I will also say that in many of those same countries, even as a straight person, you're not getting a hotel room with your partner without marriage, either.
A person in a same-sex relationship has the extra burden of having to think about those things, or miss out on those experiences (and even that in itself has detrimental mental effects for many in the long-term).
Why is what the parent said offensive? Is it necessary for everything to never offend anyone ever?
Depending on where you state that, in what social situation, you might get all sorts of reactions, from antisemic support, to more nuanced support or rejection, but you won't lose your job, won't be injailed, aren't threatened by death penalty or any form of violence (while amount of violence against Jews, by some subcultures, is rising ...)
And yes, political figures like Greta Thunberg are criticized for their statements. But a) it's a political statement by some political figure and b) there aren't threats but newspapers etc. dismissing the statements in articles. Which again is very different from the threats towards gays in different regions of the world.
Based on those I know who fall under that category it's exactly what happens. Some even have explicit policies on their websites about which countries they'll travel to. What's happened here has nothing to do with safety whatsoever.
Do not free/open source software activity or geek culture feel like more close to leftwing?
p.s., this comment doesn't try to refute you.
Stallman fir example was very clear about free software having nothing to do with communism, but of course people take just what they want from facts and ignore what they don’t want/like.
But, as i grow older, i realise itself not just software and it, it’s like that in most things.
To get back to LGBTQ rights, there also should be some standards. The standards should perhaps not be as high as western nations would like but they should exclude the worst places in the world. The story sounds like the PSF had at the time not yet decided what standards should be in place for subsidizing conferences. They should correct this omission because keeping a conference organization with this kind of uncertainty is not good.
Just to also point how the grandparent comment's remark kind of misses the point.
How do you reconcile these two statements? Populists by definition appeal to public sentiment, to the detriment of principals or morality. If no one cares, why are they wasting their time?
It's like the old joke "no one goes there, it's too crowded."
In most African countries, people are still uncomfortable with LGBTQ, and the general show of love in public but not hostile to the extent of enacted laws
Remember most LGBTQ activism is sponsored by the west, so politicians use that to heat up the population about family, bill gates, blah, blah, that's where I used the word populism.
Stop talking. You're embaressing yourself. Stonewall. The AIDS crisis. The ongoing trans panic in red states and the UK.
What you're perceiving is corporate interests reflecting long-fought grassroots success in normalizing queer people, riding on whatever makes them look good. It's like saying the thermometer is responsible for heat.
There recently has been quite a bit of rollback in that regard too. Trans Lifeline has a yearly deficit of over a million dollars through loss of corporate sponsors, for instance.
And maybe do a reality check on legal rights in "the west". I'd recommend https://www.rainbow-europe.org/
I think highly of people on Hacker News and I think you have some room to improve to meet this challenge!
I'm more or less on the same camp, but I am not African I come from another similar challenging demographic for the mainstream axis of tech (USA and Europe) and I'm reflecting a lot about it and I think we're going back to the "equal but separate" world in tech.
One thing that you should keep in mind is that a lot of folks within PSF have some pressures regarding optics and at the end of the day they are on the hook in their local conferences, companies, and local meetups, even if they personally do not believe in those restrictions.
At the time that I had the same issues at some local/national conference for other "X software foundation" the concrete action that we took was to de-risk and get local companies on board, individuals, and move forward.
I do not want to sound cynical, but I think those folks should get rid of PSF baggage and its "control by money", high horse cultural posturing, the politics and start small without all this.
Counterpoint (quotes from Wikipedia about Tanzania, where the conference was held):
> 95 percent of Tanzanian residents believed that homosexuality is a way of life that society should not accept [2007 survey]
> same-sex sexual acts (even in private and consensual) are criminal offences, punishable with life imprisonment
> On June 19, [2013] Human Rights Watch and the Wake Up and Step Forward Coalition released a report including several detailed allegations of torture and abuse of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) individuals while in police custody.
> In 2018, a so-called "witch hunt" was declared against gay people in Dar es Salaam, where gay men were forced to endure anal examinations and torture.
About LBGTQ
This looks to me like the Western behaviour where they sanction the whole country to death because they don't agree with policies of people in power.
I am an African. And I live in a country where such laws targeting LGBTQ has been enacted. FYI, Most people here have no idea what LGBTQ means and those who do don't give a damn. Those leading the making of laws and noise making are just populists after their bread. [These are facts, hoping they still matter]
If you feel so strong about attending the conference, no one is going to ask your sexual orientation at the airport. Tourists are coming in everyday. Qatar has just hosted the world cup, how many LGBTQ people were jailed? If you don't feel safe, just skip the conference or attend online.
You know very well that coders are among the most reserved people on earth, why punish them for their government rules?
I hate posturing. I thought this kind of behaviour is to be left to politicians and 'national security' advisers.
Will the world ever go back to reality?