News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by zartusht on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @07:50AM (#38543163)
> This looks to me like the Western behaviour where they sanction the whole country to death because they don't agree with policies of people in power.

Curiously, it's limited to non-white/non-Western countries. No one is sanctioning Israel for ethnic cleansing, textbook settler colonialism and apartheid going on since 1948.

https://2023.pycon.org.il/

Companies like Microsoft are proudly sponsoring it.

Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by asmor on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @07:58AM (#38543226)
Reductive to pretend this boils down to "don't do events where bad politics" when we're talking about participant safety.

The entirety of the US would get a lifetime ban if we did that.

Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by lozenge on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:02AM (#38543266)
The point is there is no standard that is applied evenly. If there was then the funding would have been quickly denied with a documented reason attached. Stalling something which is going to get approved is just vindictiveness and collective punishment.

Have you not heard what it's like for an Arab or Muslim going through Israeli airports? Sure, they'll be detained and deported at most, but that's enough to exclude the idea of visiting to give a conference talk.

Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by asmor on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:05AM (#38543310)
They're still not the same thing. TSA and Israeli customs might suck, but at worst you get turned around.

You manage to get past, let's say, Saudi customs as a trans person, get ready for jail time for the crime of existing. Not comparable.

Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by lozenge on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:10AM (#38543359)
Why is that not comparable? Israel has a policy and practice which in effect denies Muslims the professional development and publicity opportunities of speaking in Israel-hosted conferences. When deciding whether to give conferences grants, that's incredibly relevant.
Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by dijit on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:25AM (#38543529)
Please don't spread misinformation on a topic as polarised and political as this.

There are legitimate criticisms we can levy against Israel without fabricating a nonexistent reality.

Arab Israeli citizens have the same fundamental legal rights as Jewish Israelis, but they tend to live in poorer cities, have less formal education, and face other challenges that some experts attribute to structural discrimination. In this way you can consider a similarity between the racial tensions in the US.

20% of Israel's population is Arab and the majority among that are Sunni Muslim. However they are afforded the same means of professional development and the same opportunities to speak publicly.

Also I think it's pathetic to discuss religion as if it's something as inalienable or difficult to hide as skin colour, biological sex or ethnicity. Religion is emphatically a choice and not identifying yourself as religious is an option that most people have while travelling.

Religious persecution is wrong but it's a different "level" of wrong even if we conveniently ignore the fact that the same rights exist for all citizens.

tl;dr: You're wrong about what you believe about the state of israel in this case and likening religious intolerance to imprisonment for race, gender, sexuality etc; is also wrong.

Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by lozenge on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:45AM (#38543765)
I was talking about international visitors actually. An LGBT resident of Zanzibar faces the same risks and oppressions whether they are at a Python conference or any other public place. So I don't see how that's relevant. What matters is (a) whether sponsoring would not further PSF's inclusivity goals because not all diverse types of people are welcome at the conference (b) whether the entire country morally deserves to be boycotted, like South Africa under apartheid.

Israeli airport security is racist and that's a fact. Being able to hide your religion is not always possible. PSF put religion, sexual orientation, national origin, and ethnicity on an equal footing in their consideration of diversity. https://www.python.org/community/diversity/

Yes, both Zanzibar and Israel are doing bad things and certain groups are affected. But these arguments only seem to come out when "people like us" are affected (LGBT, not Muslims) and when "people unlike us" are affecting (Africans, not Israelis. Not Floridians. Not...).

Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by asmor on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:39AM (#38543699)
kind of missing the point, when it's not explicitly about citizens, the entire argument breaks apart especially if you consider west bank residents as potential speakers.

> as inalienable or difficult to hide as [...] biological sex

in case you extrapolated from my comment: i'm me, but other people are other people, and "the cis" can, in fact, not always tell. not even usually.

Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by dijit on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:42AM (#38543733)
I guess you can always consider anyone excluded if you try.

Iranian, North Korean and Cuban speakers, for example, would not be able to travel to America (or any US-allied country) as there are very explicit sanctions placed on those countries.

Unless you're claiming Palestine is part of Israel and thus Palestinian citizens are Israeli ones, which would be a very controversial statement indeed.

Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by asmor on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @11:27AM (#38546028)
It's just that you made a weird jump from "people attending Israel-hosted events" to "arab Israeli citizens" and I'm not sure how it happened. Though yes, as I said, I'd consider the difficulty there similar to going through TSA with an arabic name or wrong skin color.
Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by vivekd on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:23AM (#38543515)
That was my initial reaction, I mean was the PSF going to stop sponsoring all conferences in America when Trump won because they think building the wall makes Latino's feel unsafe? Singling out African nations like this does reek of colonial style paternalism
Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by throwaway290 on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:11AM (#38543367)
> No one is sanctioning Israel for ethnic cleansing, textbook settler colonialism and apartheid going on since 1948.

Weird example since Jews are generally the ones who were getting cleansed. They were evicted by extreme Christians, then murdered by Nazi Germans (remember when US and Canada did not accept a shipful of Jews fleeing gas chambers so they had to go back and die?) and 1948 is when Arab League attacked the new country the next day after it was created. Meanwhile Muslim people in Israel lead far better lives than in many surrounding countries with access to good healthcare, education etc.

Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by vfclists on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @08:28AM (#38543573)
You clearly don't seem to see the difference between the condition of Jews today both within the state of Israel and outside of it, and the treatment of Jews in Europe after the rise of Nazism in Germany and elsewhere.

And you know what? Africans had nothing to do with it

Re:An Open Letter to the Python Software Foundation by bakugo on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @07:58AM (#38543234)
>Curiously, it's limited to non-white/non-Western countries. No one is sanctioning Israel for ethnic cleansing, textbook settler colonialism and apartheid going on since 1948.

This is more of a special privilege granted to Israel specifically.