News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by candiddevmike on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:22PM (#37682853)
I've been meaning to write a blog post on "what if developers were paid the same way as writers and other creatives", namely residuals. I think it becoming the norm for signing away your IP rights for employment is wrong, and other creatives would never do that without ongoing compensation. There's also the guild/union aspect as well, all of which I think would help balance out the feast/famine cycle of our industry.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by eschneider on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:30PM (#37682959)
Stock options are probably a better deal. There's accounting BS with options, but FAR less than you would see with residuals.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by nfriedly on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:37PM (#37683038)
For public companies, sure.

But for a private company, where are the options are essentially a lottery ticket, I think a decent number of folks would choose residuals.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by francoisdevlin on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:41PM (#37683084)
What makes you think the residuals would fare better than the options? The risk is about the same, yes?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by nfriedly on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:45PM (#37683129)
My intuition is that residuals have a higher chance of a low payout, whereas options have a lower chance of being worth anything, but probably a higher value if they do pay off.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by lazide on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:53PM (#37683225)
Residuals for a company which is bankrupt would be zero - same as their stock price.

Also, they could just rewrite the sections of code that are expensive and nuke their costs and your residuals at any point. Unlike a brand or whatever, it’s trivial to redo as it’s not user facing.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by ganoushoreilly on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:45PM (#37683133)
I’d agree, especially if they’re relying on VC funding to power through growth.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by coffeemug on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:46PM (#37683143)
No because with options you may have to wait for your liquidity event forever.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by lazide on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:55PM (#37683249)
If you think any sane founder is going to pay out on ‘residuals’ of any significant amount without a similar liquidity event, I’ve got a bridge to sell you.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:59PM (#37683296)
Some private companies pay dividends on their shares, so they have value to employees even if there is no market for them.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by nfriedly on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:03PM (#37683328)
Yeah, that's a fair point. I've never had any of those shares, but I'm sure they exist. I'd probably take that over residuals.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:30PM (#37682962)
I give you a work laptop, training budget, third-party technical budget, lawyers, accountants, marketing... and I don't get the IP rights?

No deal.

That aside, you're describing already available comp models with equity participation.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by deathanatos on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:40PM (#37683078)
While I know the comment above appears to be suggesting keeping all IP — and I agree that's not workable — there are a number of employers that would also like to own the IP to any love notes I write my sweetheart, photographs I take of my nephew, etc.

Also I've seen some that want moral rights, which I don't think one should be required to give up, ever.

Reform is needed here. I have no qualm about signing over IP developed specifically for the company, on the company's dime. But some IP agreements get absurd about it.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by andsoitis on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:48PM (#37683165)
> there are a number of employers that would also like to own the IP to any love notes I write my sweetheart, photographs I take of my nephew, etc.

What’s a good example of an employer who wants that from someone because that person is an employee?

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by brewdad on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:32PM (#37683598)
If you read the letter of many employment agreements, they try to claim anything you create while under their employ is theirs. Do they want your love letters? Not unless you become famous and they think they can make a book out of them. Do they want the code to that side project you’ve been playing around with? Quite possibly.

Can you afford to fight them if they do try to claim it? Maybe if your side project has already taken off.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @11:05PM (#37684693)
> they try to claim anything you create while under their employ

If written that broadly, that's just sloppy. [0] It benefits both sides to be more clear. There are also nuances to "claim" and what rights the employer may have (e.g. They get a license, but not full copyright.)

IANAL, but I have recently read an IP waiver for a mega firm with heavy R&D and while they get their hooks in most job-related creations, they have exclusions for things orthogonal to your job.

[0] https://pro.bloomberglaw.com/common-misunderstandings-about-...

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by billythemaniam on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:26PM (#37683533)
It is extremely common among research universities where they try to own all your ideas. I remember a professor had a side business cleaning pools which had nothing to do with his research area. The university found out and wanted their cut. He gave it to them because it was better than being fired and sued.

These types of contracts are illegal in CA, but legal in many other states.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:32PM (#37683591)
There has to be more nuance here, e.g. using university email/resources.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:10PM (#37683401)
I'm curious for examples, too.

Otherwise, this is hyperbole or exceptional in the least.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by eminence32 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:53PM (#37683224)
moreover, is there any case law that suggests such things are an enforceable part of an employment contract?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by BolexNOLA on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:41PM (#37683085)
Why does paying for one thing entitle you to own another?

You didn’t give me a laptop. You are giving me a tool contingent upon employment. If I leave the company, you take it back. What am I supposed to be grateful for? Should a janitor thank their hospital for a rolling trash can and mop?

Training? My teachers and mentors have literally no rights to anything I’ve filmed and edited. That’s absurd.

Lawyers and accountants are for you and your company. That is not a gift to me. I cannot just call them for my own personal use at will. They only exist for the company and company purposes.

Marketing benefits you. Why does marketing benefit me at all? They aren’t doing anything for me. They aren’t building my brand and creating an image for me. They’re doing it for you and your company. They’re driving revenue for you.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:29PM (#37683558)
Your first paragraph calls into question universal contract law/rights...?

I don't know how you reconcile that with signing everyday contracts as I'm sure you do.

As for your other premises, I don't know how you can make such general claims, given endless exceptions.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by BolexNOLA on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:50AM (#37688920)
> Your first paragraph calls into question universal contract law/rights...?

I was a freelancer/production house owner for over a decade, I am very confused what you mean by this - I have no idea what you are referring to. A contract is only what is mutually agreed upon by all parties involved.

Either way, I have never signed a contract with anyone that entitled them to my work outside of the scope as dictated by the contract. What you get from me is clear in our contract or it isn’t yous. No one is entitled to anything I shoot or edit unless they explicitly paid for it. Likewise, my shooters only ever gave me what was negotiated explicitly. If that is not explicitly stated, there is no assumption they get the rights to anything I shoot or vice versa.

Go call a wedding photographer and ask for all the raws from their shoot after the fact. They’ll laugh until you hang up.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:09PM (#37693375)
> I am very confused what you mean by this - I have no idea what you are referring to.

You asked how does paying for one thing entitle you to another thing.

You're referencing my comment about supplying resources in exchange for any IP you create, contractually.

I described common contractual terms and you reacted surprised.

It appears you lost the context.

I'd be very curious how you structured employment agreements for your employees (if any) -- not independent contractors.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by BolexNOLA on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:03PM (#37694116)
There isn’t a production studio on the planet that owns the rights to what you shoot when you aren’t explicitly shooting for them. Independent contractors or not. Their teaching you and providing employment is immaterial. Hell even if they use company hardware as long as they get permission.

If i go joyride behind the company’s back sure, there’s a discussion potentially because i violated the rules and jacked company property. But even then…hardly legally enforceable to claim they own the rights and not super applicable since it depends on someone effectively stealing gear to shoot.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:00PM (#37694979)
The root parent here said signing away your IP to your employer is "wrong."

I said that's too general.

Now, you're agreeing with me in saying using gear without permission or using company gear away from intended use is wrong.

As for your blanket statement re: copyright ownership and transfer of rights, it's simply not true to say independent contractors or employees don't sign over all of their creative products in instances. I note how you're also conflating freelance and full/part-time employees.

You have no idea what you're talking about.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by BolexNOLA on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:22PM (#37695299)
> You have no idea what you're talking about.

If this is how we’re going to discuss this then I’ll just head out now. I have no idea what I’m talking about apparently so it’s not like you’re going to give my points or experience the time of day.

Have a good one.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:43PM (#37695546)
I'm not worried about convincing you.

See this legal take (scenario B), rejecting your over-general claims on freelancer's rights over "raw" work product. [0]

In your interest, I strongly recommend reviewing your form engagement contracts with an attorney.

[0] https://www.owe.com/resources/legalities/legalities-33-do-yo...

[dead]
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:05PM (#37683350)
Not what I said or implied, assuming your intent is to be snarky.

However, I've executed deals where developers contribute assets and get royalties/earnout. You can always try to negotiate.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by HumblyTossed on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:47PM (#37683148)
That laptop is a loaner from your IT dept. You didn’t train me. You hired me for my knowledge; remember those four days of whiteboard gymnastics? And you want to make money too, so you need to bring the lawyers and sales staff.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by 8note on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:17PM (#37683474)
I'm not clear why it's a no deal, when in a different industry with the same details but a different IP output, it's a deal?

George Clooney isn't bringing his own cameras and lighting systems to appear in a movie, but he'll still get residuals

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:39PM (#37683072)
Feast/famine? Where? This article identifies the first 2 year dip in real salaries since 2000. And its a 4% drop. With the absolute figure being “only” $169,000 which is almost 400% of the median US salary.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by tempsy on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:44PM (#37683105)
It’s not just inflation it’s interest rates that has a massive impact on anyone who does not already own a house.

A $1M house with a $800k mortgage at 2.5% rates was $3161 a month

At 7.5% rates today it’s $5594

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:56PM (#37683261)
> It’s not just inflation it’s interest rates that has a massive impact on anyone who does not already own a house.

It has a massive impact on anyone who does have a house with an ARM, and some effect if you own a house and were counting on refinancing or entering getting cash out via a new mortgage/HELOC, but if you don’t own a house, the only effect is via a potential impact on inflation specific to rental housing, not an effect additional to inflation.

I mean, it affects whether now is an ideal time from going to owning to not owning, but that's hardly a massive impact generally (massive on that decision, perhaps.)

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by andsoitis on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:46PM (#37683144)
Is the complaint that many people can’t afford a $1 million house?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by tempsy on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:48PM (#37683172)
Software engineers tend to live in higher cost areas where $1M would be below average.

If you live in a median cost of living area $1M would get you a decent, but not amazing, house in a good school district, which is another thing a software engineer parent would probably care about.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by thelastgallon on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:05PM (#37683362)
Plus ~3% property taxes in states like Texas. For a 1m house, thats 2500/month.

Plus repairs and maintenance, there is always something breaking down and labor has become very expensive, materials too.

All of this makes housing unaffordable for anyone who doesn't have rich parents.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:58PM (#37683286)
Irrelevant - that does not substantiate a feast/famine cycle in the engineering profession.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by BolexNOLA on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:02PM (#37683320)
Which is like 35% of one person’s salary. Seems more than reasonable to me for a million dollar home.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by tempsy on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:07PM (#37683384)
not sure what you’re saying is reasonable.

a $1M house with a $800k mortgage would mean something like $8k monthly housing cost with property taxes and insurance included.

If you made $200k gross and contributed to a retirement account you’d net $10k a month or so. Spending 80% of that on your mortgage and property taxes is definitely not sustainable.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by BolexNOLA on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:07PM (#37683386)
Your property taxes and insurance are over $30k a year?

We are also talking about a single salary. We’re not even talking about a dual income household, which is generally the kind of family that would be buying a million dollar home in my experience.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by tempsy on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:12PM (#37683428)
Depends on which state. Texas, Illinois, NJ have 2%+ property taxes so yes that would be $20k a year plus insurance and any HOA.

Dual income is an entirely separate discussion from the financial impact of surging interest rates.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by BolexNOLA on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:18PM (#37683484)
Texas and Illinois are both 1.6%, didn’t bother checking New Jersey.

The average insurance rate is $1700/yr in Illinois based on a cursory google search.

I live in a state that is 2% and is going through a coverage crisis, and it would cost me ~$10-12k for coverage on a 1mill home if I adjusted the value of my home and current insurance, which I had to acquire during this crisis.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by tempsy on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:28PM (#37683549)
Not sure what this argument is for but there’s no such thing as a state property tax rate. Every county has their own rate.

I was thinking of Chicago or Cook County which is 2.19% https://smartasset.com/taxes/cook-county-illinois-property-t...

In Austin aka Travis County it is 1.95% https://smartasset.com/taxes/texas-property-tax-calculator

There are differences depending on the county and school district

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by BolexNOLA on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:54AM (#37688964)
You are the one who introduced rates by state, which I assume you are averaging/approximating, yet when I respond with the same variable you’re surprised and lecturing? I am following your lead man.

This is very perplexing and frankly I just think this is veering into the unproductive.

Have a good one man.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:06AM (#37703573)
I had a similar, surreal exchange with the same user on a different topic, yesterday.

Back to re-weighting "check users comment history" when deciding to keep commenting.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by BolexNOLA on Sunday October 01, 2023 @03:49PM (#37729859)
1) we talked about something completely different.

2) please don’t be that guy. This is such obnoxious online behavior.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by caminante on Sunday October 01, 2023 @06:26PM (#37731573)
To #1, yes. My point remains.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by BolexNOLA on Thursday October 05, 2023 @07:22PM (#37785469)
Dude just piss off please. This site needs a block feature.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by akomtu on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:49PM (#37683186)
Inflation is 25-30% over the past few years, that applies to base pay and stock grants, so those 169k are worth as much as 125k - typical salary 10 years ago. And with the 7.5% interest rate, those 125k buy as much house as 65k in 2013. I don't envy them. Those with median income live in median cities, with median rent and median mortgage.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:56PM (#37683256)
Read the article. Engineering salaries increased in absolute terms but decreased by about 7.2k adjusted for inflation.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by akomtu on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @10:06PM (#37684315)
I don't need an article to do these basic calculations.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by imtringued on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:41AM (#37686966)
The entire point of the article is that it does these basic calculations for you... for every single year since 1994...
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by r00fus on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:27PM (#37682913)
Very interesting idea. How would this work? Would your name on any software give you residuals? How would your % be calculated - based on LOC? (ridiculous) but if not that then how? Would be granular down to the feature? sprint?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by diob on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:28PM (#37682924)
Probably better to go the route of pensions.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by astrange on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:48PM (#37683163)
Just own an index fund, it has better risk-adjusted returns than any of these options.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by paulddraper on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:29PM (#37682946)
That's what equity is, albeit more capital friendly to R&D heavy endeavors
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by renegade-otter on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:32PM (#37682974)
Equity is generally a scam - your "five thousand shares" are going to get you maybe a few hundred dollars during a liquidity event.

Stop asking for equity - ask for a higher salary. Put that extra money into an index fund and it will go FAR more than any "equity".

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by loeg on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:33PM (#37682996)
Equity in public companies is worth a lot more than equity in private companies. You seem to be talking only about the latter.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by paulddraper on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:42PM (#37683095)
Some might say the same about residuals
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by andrewjl on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:37PM (#37683042)
[delayed]
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by HeyImAlex on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:25PM (#37682887)
Isn’t that kinda what stock options are?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by andrew_ on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:28PM (#37682934)
stock options (outside of bigcorps) are monopoly money 99% of the time
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by astrange on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:48PM (#37683171)
Public companies usually give RSUs, which are fine and have much better tax treatment.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by diob on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:25PM (#37682891)
I'd say it's more akin to pensions.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by Mountain_Skies on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:26PM (#37682906)
It's difficult to imagine how that would be calculated and verified for internal systems, which are far more common than public facing, revenue generating systems.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by andersa on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:26PM (#37682898)
They already are. Engineer gets paid $200k so the company can make $20M. Sound fair right?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by xyzelement on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:27PM (#37682922)
It does sound fair, the engineer also gets paid $200k if the product ends up going nowhere, so he doesn't bear the risk. The company also provides lots of things to enable that "20M" to be generated that the engineer doesn't provide, such as sales, distribution, etc etc etc etc.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by eek2121 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:30PM (#37682961)
Book publishers also don’t make much if the book doesn’t sell.

Most technology companies wouldn’t exist without developers.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by xyzelement on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:37PM (#37683040)
// Most technology companies wouldn’t exist without developers.

Hence they pay to hire them, as evidenced by the $200K dev in the prior post. I don't get your point.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by thfuran on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:39PM (#37683065)
Yes, and writers tend to be paid advances much less than a dev salary.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by cgriswald on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:56PM (#37683259)
Writers never have to pay back that advance, however. They just don't get paid from sales until the sales cover the advance. If the book doesn't sell, they still keep the advance.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by HPsquared on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:34PM (#37683007)
Lots of things are "necessary but not sufficient" for the company to make the $20M.

For example they wouldn't have made any money without electricity, should the power company get paid more just because of what someone did with their electricity?

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by Aunche on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:41PM (#37683088)
On the other hand, sometimes the engineer gets paid $200k while the company makes -$20M.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by nrdvana on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:19PM (#37683492)
Rarely does a company make 20M off the work of one engineer. Every 4-5 engineers is another 1M expense, nevermind the other employee salaries. I get kind of annoyed when people look at large aggregate numbers and complain about how different they are from the individual employee pay. Even CEO pay - if they took the entire bonus given to the General Motors CEO and divided it among every employee in the company, it would come out to something smaller than their Christmas bonus. I do think CEOs are generally overpaid and under-liable, but it's not like the CEO salary is directly responsible for workers missing out on the highlife.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by paxys on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:31PM (#37682971)
The fundamental difference is that the tech industry is built on the illusion of infinite growth. If you write a piece of software for a company and it does well, the company cannot return the money back to you because they need it to hire 10x the amount of new developers and create new features and attract more customers, and so on with each successive version. The moment they stop doing that, investors see slowing growth and the whole thing collapses. In fact companies hand out stock options like candy so developers themselves now become part of this game.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by renewiltord on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:44PM (#37683108)
You can get this quite easily if you have the chops to match. Build software and license it to other people. You'll need to be good at the marketing and sales aspect in addition to product development, but if you don't want to you can just give away that to others and take a flat salary.

Software is about the one place where you can select where on the curve you want to be for this. Either all self-owned and licensed (easier than elsewhere because VCs will fund you in software more likely than other businesses), as a solo shop, as an enterprise, or you can be salaried, or receive lots of equity, or a contractor.

No one in software need complain. Almost the entire full spectrum of options exists.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by orangecat on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:45PM (#37683125)
I much prefer getting a 90th percentile salary up front and not perpetually arguing over exactly how many times my code was downloaded or executed.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by phantomathkg on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:53PM (#37683220)
Genuine question, it will not be possible for every single engineers get paid 90th percentile, someone has to get less than that for the statistic to work?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by interroboink on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:58PM (#37683284)
I think they meant 90% across all industries. As in, software developers are well-compensated compared to non-software jobs with similar education, etc.

I don't know the full extent of how true that is, but I think that's what they were saying (:

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:58PM (#37683278)
As long as less than 10% of the labor force is engineers, it is.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by rhplus on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:59PM (#37683289)
I think they mean across all job categories.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by SoftTalker on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:46PM (#37683146)
This is a solved problem for the music industry, why could it not be adapted for code?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by tzs on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:29PM (#37683564)
If coders were payed the way musicians are paid a few coders would make a lot more money than they do now and most would make a lot less.

A few musicians become big stars and can make a lot of money for themselves and for musicians who work with/for them. It falls off rapidly from there.

It would probably actually be worse for coders than it is for musicians, because the big money making projects in coding usually involve a lot more people and a lot more up front investment. A few people who led the project or wrote the truly innovative parts would get most of the royalties. The people who do the more routine parts (which is most of almost all projects) that any decent programmer could have done will get only a small amount.

For anyone curious what it is like for a musician, here's an interesting video from a well-known YouTube guitarist who is managing to make a living as a guitarist, going over a variety of ways that a guitarist might make money [1]. He looks at local gigs, touring with a mid level act, touring with a top level act, busking, cruise ships, studio work, teaching private lessons, university instructor, endorsement deals, and content creator.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ch7t9KGcOPk

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by nrdvana on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:01PM (#37683313)
And the music industry solution is absolutely horrible. Every single venue that might have someone play copyrighted music is required to pay large annual sums to the RIAA, or get sued. There are armies of RIAA lawyers who go around to basically every business with a lobby and threaten to sue if they don't pay into the pool. There are entire companies who exist just to install licensed players in offices that are known to comply.

Just imagining how awful this would turn out if applied to the world of software makes my skin crawl.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by jprete on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:57PM (#37683264)
It’s not solved for the music industry at all! Publishers are perpetually looking for ways to give artists crappy deals on residuals, and artists make almost all their money on touring and merch. And that’s for the successful ones, most musicians are not successful enough to even think about making money from publication.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by eschaton on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:58PM (#37683285)
Except it’s not really, the traditional ASCAP/BMI royalty structure and reporting gives extremely heavy favor to the most popular music and everyone else gets basically nothing, while their royalty schedules for streaming amount to basically nothing.

If anything, musicians need to follow WGA and SAG-AFTRA and DGA’s lead and get proper streaming royalty schedules, anti-AI-training clauses, etc. into their standard contract structures.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by rcstank on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:50PM (#37683191)
I don’t want it. I’m fine with how my compensation currently works.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by rhplus on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:01PM (#37683310)
Not looking forward to the day when I have to wait tables, while hoping that my software hits the big time.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by butlike on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @10:20PM (#37684416)
Because a song is "done" and software is constantly updated.

That's ignoring masters and remixes, but I think my point still stands

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by Waterluvian on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:46PM (#37683145)
I was actually thinking about it the other way around.

Why do residuals exist? I am paid to do X. I did X. My code is no more special than the shingles put on my roof. I hope the roofers don’t return for residuals again.

What I prefer is the “get the same relative raises as the CEO” that the auto union is going for.

But I’m also not a gambler. I want to know exactly what my compensation is for the hours of my life I’m giving away.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by thesh4d0w on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:52PM (#37683210)
Two writers make an episode of TV. One sucks and is aired once, the other is amazing and gets replayed constantly for years.

Should their work be valued the same?

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by eks391 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:08PM (#37683395)
Their pay should be what the contract agreed it to be, regardless of how popular it was.

Imagine someone makes a popular show. They are hired by another company in hopes of a repeat, but it flops. The company doesn't get to hold back the money because it wasn't "replayed constantly for years" or a more measurable contribution to their companies worth, unless that was written in the contract that the performer would assume the risk. But usually companies accept the risk, which is why the risk holder, such as a CEO or lenders, make more money (or lose it all if the risk fruitioned ill)

In markets like freelancing, authorship, etc; where the risk is assumed by the creator specifically, their performace can directly influence their pay. Most people would prefer a steady, risk-free paycheck though, which is why your contribution is most likely less influential to your pay, except in the case of when you go out of your way to get a new contract via promotion or job hunting.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by deelowe on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:16PM (#37683464)
I don't understand, isn't residuals in the contract?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by salty_biscuits on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:01PM (#37683312)
Depends on if the result is due to skill or luck?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by coffeemug on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:48PM (#37683162)
Most developers are a 2023 equivalent of 1973 assembly line workers. Very few do creative work.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by nonethewiser on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:04PM (#37683341)
Or engineers. Do engineers own the rights to the electrical housing designs they make?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by Aunche on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @07:54PM (#37683228)
> what if developers were paid the same way as writers and other creatives

The 10% of Facebook/Google/Bytedance engineers who work on ads would be stupidly rich. The remaining 90% of engineers who work on cost centers would get paid minimum wage. If you want these residuals to be remotely equal, the metrics that determine them would be so convoluted that you might as well just pay people in stock options or RSUs.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by fragmede on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:46PM (#37683696)
Ads is shooting low. You want your code to be in the network driver in the kernel for every packet received or sent.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by linkjuice4all on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @09:15PM (#37683937)
Hopefully that network driver doesn’t rely on my ‘isOdd’ code which happens to rely completely on my other ‘isEven’ project.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by anotherhue on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @09:50PM (#37684199)
pfft. I want residuals when the instruction pointer is incremented.
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by butlike on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @10:18PM (#37684405)
So the change request is to change the variable name so we can stop paying the engineer who negotiated higher residuals.

Also what is a code contribution. If I write the "if" statement or the functional unit?

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by ramesh31 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:04PM (#37683342)
The multiple of ongoing productivity gain is built into your salary.

The reason we make six figures is a combination of our skills and the fact that the work that we do will be useful beyond ourselves.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by hibikir on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:24PM (#37683523)
There are many ways to do this, and most lead to some dark incentive nightmares.

-If a dev get a percent of total company revenue, then you really don't want to hire many!

-If you have a basket of revenue for developers, and then they split it based on whether they worked there for the last X years, then it's the devs that don't want other people hired: The pie shrinks

- If it's by code getting executed and how much revenue that brought, then the difference in value of which team to work in becomes amazing. It's also a great idea to rewrite other people's code: This inner loop of the main revenue generating code is a goldmine. GDPR compliance? worth little

- If instead of by execution or LOC we go by system contribution, we instead get yearly rewrites or very long tenures, as people protect the systems they worked in.

Either way you slice it, the good of the company is only of tangential value, as barring a growing startup, optimizing your slice of the pie becomes far more relevant than helping the company's goal, any more than just remaining employed, and therefore capable of protecting your contribution level. It would need massive changes to the way we work to avoid massive profiteering dysfunction. The culture of software would be so different as to be borderline unrecognizable. Not unlike what would happen to plumbing if they could charge per gallon that flows through the pipe, or times a toilet is flushed.

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by happytiger on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:33PM (#37683606)
Is that not what equity in a startup is? Or stock grants?

What would be the systematic advantage of attaching a new system to track IP residuals be?

Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by yibg on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @08:36PM (#37683627)
So most developers would have to wait tables to make ends meet while they try to make it big?
Re:Inflation Bites U.S. Engineering Salaries by paxys on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @09:24PM (#37684000)
Tech companies and movie studios have very different business models. Tech is built on the illusion of infinite growth. If you write a piece of software and it does well, the company cannot return the money back to you because they need it to hire 10x the number of new developers and create new features and growth hack more customers, and so on with each successive version. The moment they stop doing that, investors see slowing growth and the whole thing collapses. Instead these companies hand out stock options so developers themselves now become part of this game.