News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by TechBro8615 on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:40PM (#37472582)
I think the bigger issue with measuring blood pressure is that, aside from diagnosed diabetics, it's a measurement done infrequently and at mostly arbitrary times. Your blood pressure reading on the day of a doctor's appointment, right after you've driven to the appointment, made your way through the intake pipeline, and finally sat down in the chair, is not representative of its reading during a typical day in your life. Other factors like recency of coffee or alcohol consumption, exercise and sleep, all combine to make blood pressure a fairly variable statistic with limited diagnostic power when it's only measured infrequently.

Regardless of whether you're lying down, standing up, or sitting in a chair, it would be beneficial to take more frequent blood pressure readings, throughout the day and during typical routines, than it would to only take them every time you visit the doctor. This seems like common sense, and you can even buy blood pressure sensors for $20 on Amazon, but how many people take their blood pressure on a regular basis? Once you're a diagnosed diabetic, then maybe you start measuring it every day - but wouldn't it be better to start such a habit before you become diabetic? After all, if you're continuously measuring a variable then you can notice patterns and anomalies, and take steps to mitigate them - possibly avoiding becoming diabetic before it's too late.

It seems the limiting factor is sensor technology, which is obviously lacking compared to wearable sensors for tracking heart rate. Any health-conscious person with an Apple Watch or similar wearable device can easily track their pulse throughout the day. But no similarly accurate and seamless sensor exists for measuring blood pressure (as far as I know?), so nobody measures it as frequently as they do their pulse. Once we have the technology to accurately and passively measure blood pressure throughout the day, preventive medicine will become much easier, and people will have a better feeling for how their blood pressure responds to small changes in their environment and lifestyle.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by zwieback on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:43PM (#37472604)
Yeah, I have a machine and unless I take measurements very frequently (different times of day, etc.) it's really hard to make sense of the numbers. You really need to get a long term chart to weed out the noise.

I've been getting much better readings at the doctors but then I realized I always ride my bike there, sit in the waiting room for a while and then get a low reading. Not representative!

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by _ph_ on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:57PM (#37472782)
I am not sure, while the values obtained this way might require calibration, it sounds like very controlled conditions to me. The exercise should bring your body into a very controlled state, beyond the physical load very relaxed. So after a short rest, this should be a good time to get reliable readings. But I am not a doctor.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by zwieback on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:22PM (#37473119)
Yeah, agreeed, and I think the BP is a bit lower because I'm warmed up and then rested a bit. My worst BP is in the mornings after getting up and sitting and drinking coffee.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by gryfft on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:58PM (#37472795)
I've been using Google Fit to track my blood pressure over time. I've been measuring every other day. The charts really are helpful.

The biggest correlation with my blood pressure is how regular my sleep is. Once I started militantly waking and sleeping on a set schedule, the numbers came down. They seem to spike for a few days if my sleep gets messed up badly somehow.

I also have been trying to standardize my measurement: same time of day, after sitting quietly alone for five minutes.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by ipqk on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:47PM (#37472648)
> Your blood pressure reading on the day of a doctor's appointment, right after you've driven to the appointment, made your way through the intake pipeline, and finally sat down in the chair, is not representative of its reading during a typical day in your life.

This is a known thing called White Coat Syndrome

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by Gibbon1 on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:54PM (#37472740)
That's actually different. The stress of being at the doctors causes blood pressure to elevate vs more mundane things like running, walking, driving stress. The difference is someone without white coat syndrome will have a lower blood pressure reading at the end of the doctors visit.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by pixl97 on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:59PM (#37472818)
Honestly I think in most US cities the driving stress would drive ones BP far higher. I know one time just right before I got to the Drs office some one almost ran into me, I mean just missed, and my BP was way high still.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by _ph_ on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:53PM (#37472732)
You are so right. Earlier this year I had to spend a week in hospital and they took a variety of measurements every day. It was interesting to see how much variation there was, especially in blood pressure. But one thing was especially interesting, pulse. As I was wearing my Apple watch, I had the values for blood and blood oxygene before they took them. And with pulse, you could clearly see with the graph, how much systematic variation there was. So their single measurement was not great. Best example, the last measurement was taken before I was about to be released, awaiting the doctors sign-off visit. Of course my pulse was off. But the doctor was quite interested to see my pulse for the last couple of hours.

People underestimate how valuable a medical tool the Apple watch already is and how game-changing it can get if they manage to extend the sensor suite - as you say, blood pressure, perhaps also body temperature and glucose level.

Another fun fact from the visit, they did monitor glucose level and one morning they did so directly after waking me up. Which caused the nurse to run to get me an early breakfast as it was very low. Not as if I hadn't known for decades, that I need a slow start and at least a small bite for breakfast to get into gears...

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hedora on Monday September 11, 2023 @09:05PM (#37475762)
I recommend Apple Watches, but if money is an issue, or you just dislike Apple, Amazfit has some nice offerings like this band:

https://www.amazon.com/Amazfit-Fitness-Monitoring-Tracking-R...

Some of the reports it produces are superior to Apple Health (it measures stress, a proprietary overall health score, and I prefer its sleep monitoring analysis).

It’s $39. The 15-25 day battery life claim assumes you disabled most of the functionality.

Insert privacy disclaimer here.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by inglor_cz on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:04PM (#37472875)
There is a device called "holter" that you wear for a day and it measures your BP repeatedly, even during the night.

https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diagnostics/16330-24-h...

I have worn a holter several times. I had better results than in a doctor's office. It seems to be a classical case of white coat syndrome.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:08PM (#37472927)
I suffer from hypertension (which pushed as high as 170/120) and went through a period where I was measuring my blood pressure many times a day to try to essentially hack what the problem was to try to find a natural solution.

What I learned is that, for me,

-salt intake had zero impact

-coffee had no impact

-stress level had almost no impact

-alcohol had no impact

-exercise / activity levels had no impact

The single and only controllable factor I could find, short of drugs, was that if I was cold my blood pressure spiked significantly. I had much higher BP in the winter than in the summer, and could improve it by wearing layers, gloves, etc.

My body decided to go full ham on blood pressure and it was destroying my kidneys. I would be constantly annoyed by the sound of my own heartbeat doing things like trying to sleep.

Telmisartan + Caduet (which is amolodipine + lipitor) and now my blood pressure averages 100/60. And courtesy of the lipitor my cholesterol and triglycerides dropped 60%, from high to normal. Many thanks to the very brilliant people who work in that field and developed those drugs.

Anyways, thanks for coming to my TED talk on the magic of modern medicine.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by BaculumMeumEst on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:29PM (#37473217)
Wow, that sounds like quite an ordeal. Glad you landed okay! I had no idea medication could have that strong of an effect.

I also have been checking my levels a little obsessively, unsuccessfully trying to find ways to drop them. And like you, I noticed that I spike during cold weather. I’m probably particularly sensitive because I have very low body fat.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by manmal on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:56PM (#37473586)
You probably tried potassium chloride/bicarbonate already?
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by BaculumMeumEst on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:30PM (#37473990)
I just tried upping dietary potassium with more bananas and avocados and reducing sodium, haven’t looked in to potassium chloride/bicarbonate
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by manmal on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @02:28PM (#37485372)
Supplementing it is totally different in my experience.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:34PM (#37473303)
Raynauds?
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:39PM (#37473368)
Secondary Raynaud's absolutely. In any below room temperature setting my fingers would be incredibly cold to the point of being debilitating. I ended up being a glove wearer in situations where it looked pretty goofy.

This has dramatically improved/disappeared under the medication listed above.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by url00 on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:50PM (#37473511)
Wow, it sounds so familiar to myself! I have all the same symptoms and went down the path of testing BP and blood glucose with similar results. How did you get the doctor to prescribe the drugs? Or was it a pretty straightforward diagnosis?
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:13PM (#37473789)
Definitely does not sound straightforward given all the things they tested and excluded. It also very atypical and medicating specifically for this would be unusual. That said it sure sounds like it perfectly treats the root problem.

If you have symptoms like Raynauds and POTS (note that POTS can be hard to demonstrate, so may be less convincing to a doctor) then Amlodipine or similar may be helpful. If you take it and you feel lightheaded when standing up, or have trouble with exercise or fatigue, you probably don't need it and it isn't good for you.

You may have more consistently high blood pressure rather than transient spikes if you don't have POTS, or if you don't react immediately to cold temperatures. In that case an angiotensin blocker like Telmisartan may help. It can take weeks to become effective, vs Amlodipine should show effects in just a few days.

If you have high blood pressure then just telling your doctor you want Amlodipine or something will probably be enough- convincing insurance will be harder. Amlodipine can be used off-label for Raynauds. If you don't have particularly high blood pressure and haven't systematically tried to exclude causes it will be harder to convince your doctor. They might let you try it for a bit to see if it helps, and the generic isn't too expensive.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by url00 on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @12:36PM (#37483865)
Thanks for the reply! I'll keep researching.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:23PM (#37473906)
To add to the great reply by hwillis, I just went to my doctor with a concern about my blood pressure and he prescribed amlodipine with follow-up bloodwork to make sure there aren't other factors. When the amlodipine wasn't effective he upped the dose with another set of bloodwork, and then he added telmisartan and lipitor (coupling it in with the amlodipine for convenience) given cholesterol issues with my bloodwork.

There are a lot of different blood pressure medications (like a ridiculous array of options) and I let my doctor decide. There are side effects but I have suffered zero of them, and now that the blood pressure is under control my bloodwork across the board has been improving significantly.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by url00 on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @12:38PM (#37483894)
Thanks for the reply. Yeah it seems like hypertension is right up there with fatigue as one of those more general symptoms that can be really hard to nail down a fix for. I'm glad it all worked so well for you.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by bradknowles on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @04:50AM (#37494018)
I don't like combining drugs, especially something like amlodipine with Olmesartan. Individually, each drug is cheap enough and commonly stocked that I can go into most any Walgreens anywhere and get my prescriptions fulfilled. Do them as a a combo, and suddenly it can only be custom ordered and I have to wait days for it to arrive. And it's also much, much more expensive when combined.

One extra pill to take at night does not make a huge change to my nightly routine of taking all my drugs. So taking one less pill wouldn't be a huge improvement, either.

But the lack of availability and much higher cost of the combined drug means that I don't ever want to do that again.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by xattt on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:52PM (#37473528)
Amlodipine is a calcium-channel blocker which lowers blood pressure by promoting systemic vasodilation. This would have a beneficial side effect of counteracting idiopathic vasoconstriction caused by Raynaud syndrome.

If the drug is taken with food (when drug absorption is highest), some folks will develop edema in their legs for several hours.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by ungruntled on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:54PM (#37473555)
Myself being someone who suspects that they have high blood pressure (based on infrequent measurement), would you mind sharing if you had any recurring symptoms (outside of hearing heartbeat) when your blood pressure was at its peak?
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:05PM (#37473695)
My initial decision to seek treatment was recurring massive migraines that would wake me up in the middle of the night and last for hours. I had known that I had high blood pressure but didn't really track it closely at all, always attributing the few really high readings I did get to white coat syndrome (which is a very real, but it also can be an easy dismissal as well). During one of those migraine sessions I hopped on Amazon and ordered a unit.

It came and I was sure it was defective because it kept measuring 170+ / 120+, which seemed impossible. A few days later I stopped by a pharmacy with one of the big units, and it read the same thing. So I visited my doctor.

He put me on 5mg of amolodipine and it did very close to nothing. Then it was upped to 10mg and still little benefit. It was the addition of telmisartan that completely changed everything for me. The effect was overwhelming.

It's hard for me to really identify the symptoms because I lived with it, I suspect, for many years. It was my norm. I will say this: at my current blood pressure I constantly feel way more relaxed, physically. Like my body doesn't feel in a constant fight state.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by ungruntled on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:13PM (#37473782)
Thanks. This is very helpful to me. I have weekly migraines. I never thought to attribute it to high blood pressure.

For the record, my blood pressure is not nearly as high, but its typically 140/85 as infrequently measured. I’ve never measured during a migraine, but I will now.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:27PM (#37473962)
dizziness can also be a symptom.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by infradig on Monday September 11, 2023 @08:03PM (#37475319)
My story exactly. Chronic headaches before, not one since (over 4 years).
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Sunday September 17, 2023 @11:59AM (#37546462)
Same experience here. After finally treating it (current blood pressure - 96 / 56) my number of headaches of any sort has declined dramatically. It used to be just a normal event that I would lose a day+ a week to monster headaches, where now I have close to none.

One strange thing: In the past I'd get auras and then not long after an enormous headache. I still occasionally get auras...but then it just resolves and the day goes on normally. Very strange.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by rapfaria on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:04PM (#37473679)
Pain on the back of the head constantly, specially at the end of the day.

Been on Olmesartan since then and couldn't be happier

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by zy0n911 on Monday September 11, 2023 @07:33PM (#37475110)
This exact symptom literally happened to me a couple of months ago. It was the kinda pain that started in one shoulder and rounded itself up into my head and front temple, and it _always_ started in the early evening.

After doing a bit of research I got myself a monitor, and sure enough my readings one between 150-170/90ish. I'm also a type 1 diabetic to add to it.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by runako on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:59PM (#37474839)
If you suspect you have high blood pressure, please have yourself checked by a medical professional. Hypertension is known as the "silent killer" due to its frequent lack of symptoms.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by itissid on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:14PM (#37473798)
> I would be constantly annoyed by the sound of my own heartbeat doing things like trying to sleep.

Wait what? explain more please.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:26PM (#37473946)
Ever run real hard and felt your heartbeat in your ears? Like that but always. It can also happen if you have valve or other heart defects that cause enlargement, but that isn't loud in your ears. It's just so loud in your chest that you can hear it. Sometimes other people can as well.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:18PM (#37473861)
Pulsatile tinnitus (didn't know this name before but just looked it up), which is when blood pressure is so high that in quiet you hear your own heartbeat and the whooshing of blood in your veins.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by bradknowles on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @04:45AM (#37493969)
I periodically have that, plus regular tinnitus.

PT is the one thing so far that I haven't been able to get fixed with the four different high blood pressure medications that I'm currently on.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by aantix on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:35PM (#37474041)
What's your potassium level?

Potassium relaxes the walls of the blood vessels. It's a counterbalance to sodium.

Doctors will say 3.5 is fine, but there are several studies demonstrating that as you approach 4.5, the risk of cardiac events drop.

Doctors get very tense about potassium supplementation in fear of hyperkalemia.

But the RDA for potassium use to be ~4200mg. I'm guessing most don't remotely approach the new or old RDA.

If you're taking potassium sparing medications, things are further complicated. K levels would have to be checked more often.

I supplement with potassium citrate. My blood pressure has normalized.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:41PM (#37474121)
4.5 mmol/L. Coincidentally just got a blood test six days ago (this is in Canada and Lifelabs lets you see your own results). I don't go out of my way to consume potassium at this point, but my potassium has been 4.5 steady for all the tests I've gotten over the past year. My sodium has been rock solid at 139 mmol/L as well.

I didn't add it as one of my listed items, but I did try supplementing with potassium before starting with medication and for me it wasn't beneficial, though it certainly would be for people with deficiencies.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by aantix on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:53PM (#37474218)
Hyperaldosteronism.

If someone has a consistently low potassium level, you should see an endocrinologist and get tested for Hyperaldosteronism.

Surplus aldosterone causes the body to retain more salt, which in turn increase blood pressure.

Consistently low potassium, early onset of hypertension, taking three or more BP medications (one of which is a diuretic), all red flags.

Hyperaldosteronism should be pursued.

I had my left adrenal gland taken out to address it.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:57PM (#37474261)
Potassium and sodium are also excreted together, so decreasing sodium/increasing potassium typically results in beneficial impacts on the other.

> Doctors get very tense about potassium supplementation in fear of hyperkalemia.

Supplementing with potassium is not recommended because it's not very effective. 99 mg of potassium citrate gives you only 38 grams of potassium- *you need ~100 pills to get your daily value!* You will see much better results from changing your diet to include more potato (note: 1/4 of the potassium is in the skin), beans, and spinach (although a lot of spinach- 10oz has as much as a large potato). One large potato can give you 900 mg of potassium.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by aantix on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:00PM (#37474282)
>not recommended because it's not very effective

My guess is that it's effective for those that are chronically K deficient, through Hyperaldosteronism or some other condition.

That would still be four large potatoes a day, to hit the original RDA. Every day.

I buy it in powder form to get the high levels needed. https://www.bulksupplements.com/products/potassium-citrate-p...

Agree, the dosing on tablets are ridiculously low.

Eating several large potatoes, bananas, avocados every single day sounds miserable.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by sph on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:59PM (#37474838)
Beans are not recommended if your goal is normalising electrolytes and micro-nutrients. Phytic acid in beans messes with your micronutrient absorption, in other words you absorb fewer than if you abstained from beans (or any other vegetable high in phytates). Quite counterproductive if you're trying to figure out the correct dosage of supplements.

Same with nuts and other seeds. Fine, in moderation. Phytic acid literally is a chemical countermeasure to stop animals from eating the next generation of a plant.

Oxalic acid, abundant in spinach, is another fun one.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by tchaffee on Monday September 11, 2023 @09:10PM (#37475799)
Soaking the beans and discarding that water before cooking them greatly reduces the phytic acid. Beans are excellent for health. You just have to follow the traditional methods of prepping them.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by bradknowles on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @04:42AM (#37493936)
Look out for kidney stones with spinach, and other foods that are high in oxalates.

I've had multiple lithotripsy procedures, thanks to kidney stones.

I wouldn't wish kidney stones on my worst enemy.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by jupp0r on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:39PM (#37474658)
GP mentioned taking Telmisartan, which is potassium sparing and one should be careful with potassium supplementation while taking it.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by aantix on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:47PM (#37474729)
Agree. That's why I noted

>If you're taking potassium sparing medications, things are further complicated. K levels would have to be checked more often.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by eddy_chan on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:02PM (#37474304)
Thanks for sharing publicly. May I ask if the Caduet has any side effects? I'm going through a similar issue. I know that my problem is alcohol, being overweight and middle age (40+). I'm also on Telmisartan which takes it down from 170/100 to about 135/85 on a good day which is still too high for my liking. I might try asking the doc for dual therapy on my next visit and Caduet sounds like a good candidate. My cholesterol also on the high side just outside of normal range! I know I need to lose 20-25lbs but I can't see it happening because of a combo of dad/work life.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:15PM (#37474422)
>I know that my problem is alcohol, being overweight and middle age

The middle-aged part for sure, but I don't drink, I'm an ideal weight and have a mid to high level of fitness -- high cholesterol and a super high BP before medication. Sometimes it just be the way it is.

Caduet comes with a list of warnings, primarily courtesy of the Lipitor (atorvastatin) component. Periodic bloodwork is necessary to make sure there isn't liver damage occurring, etc. I've endured zero side effects of any sort, and my bloodwork has been stellar. With a 10/20 caduet (which means 10mg amlodipine / 20mg atorvastatin) my triglycerides fell from 2.63 to 1.06, cholesterol from 6.33 to 3.64, LDL from 4.23 to 2.2.

Was super surprised at the scale of the improvements.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by sph on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:49PM (#37474748)
Mmm.. I have been measuring my blood pressure for 5 years, twice a day, and I can't say I agree with you.

- Coffee increases systolic by 15 mmHg for 6 hours, so does smoking.

- Lisdexamphetamine (I am diagnosed ADHD) decreases BP by 10 mmHg

- Good sleep for 5+ consecutive days decreases BP. One day isn't enough.

- Rebound hypertension when forgetting my BP meds is a thing. +10 mmHg the next day.

- Low carb diet decreases BP steadily after the first week or so, especially if your metabolism is out of whack (understandable due to the deleterious effect of fructose on nitric oxide production)

- Amateur BP readings (wrong time of day, single measurement, not relaxed enough) can add 30 mmHg easily. Readings taken at the GP's office are worthless for this reason. My advice is measure every 3 minutes until your BP measurement stabilises. The correct reading is the lowest. Sometimes you need 15 minutes to reset to baseline.

- Also important is the delta between systolic and diastolic. Mine is around 40 mmHg, if it's higher than that, it's an indicator of a stress peak (bad sleep, bad day, overwhelmed) that usually resolves after a couple days.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Monday September 11, 2023 @07:06PM (#37474901)
Many people have very different responses to stimuli: Some people see a spike from salt. Many don't. Some see a spike from coffee, while others actually see a decline! I merely gave my own personal observations from my own rigorous monitoring/hacking regime. I found no "do this and improve nn mmHg" simple solution, beyond the stated observation about avoiding coldness. I have zero reason to disbelieve your own observations about your own carbon machine, however.

Some people will be like me, many others won't, but the real lesson is that there are no hard and fast quick fixes.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by sph on Monday September 11, 2023 @07:10PM (#37474933)
Certainly, but I'd like to see the methodology of your experiments if you're able to say that a stimulant like coffee doesn't do anything, nor exercise. It might not do anything in the short term, but I dare you to drink 3x your daily coffee intake and see if you can't see any change, or to increase/quit your fitness routine and whether it doesn't do anything over a year.

I have tracked by BP over 50 kg of weight change, and BP correlates really nicely with fitness level, stress, etc. even though trends are visible over months, not hours.

There certainly are no quick fixes, apart from taking a BP pill (I take telmisartan+amlodipine, the latter replacing a diuretic that made me drier than the Sahara desert)

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @08:13AM (#37479883)
I went a week with no salt (and serious minimization of dietary sodium), no coffee or caffeine of any sort, adjusted my sleep schedule to be idealized, no alcohol (although I was a minimal consumer already and now am a zero consumer), very little sugar or simple carbs, took potassium supplements, etc. After seven days my BP was just as insane. And while people always have a stereotype of people with hypertension, I've been very active and fit over my entire life.

People are different. Someone who has mild hypertension probably can tweak some lifestyle dials and control it. I had severe hypertension with nothing to point the finger at (e.g. obesity, lifestyle, etc). For whatever reason my body was malfunctioning and in a recursive death loop of escalating hypertension.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by sph on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @08:32AM (#37480131)
What is your diet? FWIW I'm in the same boat: both my parents have hypertension, one is a smoker, the other isn't, one is overweight, the other isn't. My mum has taken heroic hypertensive doses to keep hers at bay, for decades. I've been diagnosed with it in my 20s when I was fit as a fiddle... it must be a genetic component, though these days I do believe it's because of a diet too high in carbs than my genes can handle.

Have a look at the effect of fructose on blood pressure. Low carb seems to work well for me, but I'm not consistent enough to see my BP trend down to the point I can throw my pills away. I'm working on it.

And yeah, the entire salt scare is pretty much nonsense that's slowly being debunked. I have a friend who eats more salt than a goat, and he's got hypotension. Go figure. Hyponatremia is not fun, I tend to use salt liberally these days.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by davidjytang on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:19AM (#37543088)
I was replying to another thread. I repeat here. My dad has hypertension due to [Conn's syndrome](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_aldosteronism). The only thing that helped tremendously was surgery.

You could of course argue that if he ate a ton of salt, his blood pressure would surge. But I wish he would've taken the surgery sooner rather than trying to out-diet and out-exercise his genetics as the diet/exercise had really small effect.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by mint2 on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:27PM (#37476701)
Isn’t being cold leading to an increase in blood pressure a well known physiological reaction to cold temps, that will spike BP but not be the under lying cause?
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by spott on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @09:28AM (#37480883)
> many people have different responses to stimuli…

My favorite example of this is from figure 2g of [0]. It shows the time series of blood glucose levels from two participants after eating a cookie or a banana, and they have nearly the opposite responses to each other. It was the thing that convinced me that a ton of modern nutrition that isn’t personalized is basically useless.

[0] https://www.cell.com/fulltext/S0092-8674(15)01481-6

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by gaetgu on Monday September 11, 2023 @07:43PM (#37475176)
I'm sorry—30 mmHg?

Maybe I am misunderstanding, or there is something wrong with my own knowledge, but "30 mmHg" added to systolic seems extremely high.

I am currently an EMT-B student here in the United States, and taking vital signs like blood pressure is our bread and butter. We practice it several times a week, on different people with different body types and different blood pressure baselines. Anything more than ±4 mmHg in a manual reading is terrible accuracy, and anything like +30 mmHg probably comes from someone who doesn't know how to use the equipment.

But again, maybe there is something I am missing. If there is I'd love to be educated and hear about it!

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by sph on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @06:35AM (#37479040)
It's not high if you don't know how to measure your blood pressure. Your BP increases a lot if you're moving around, and not properly rested.

When you're at the GP's office, you might have been rushing to get there, you do a minute of small talk and then they strap on a cuff and tell you "oh my, it's very high", this is the reason. And it happens so often it even has a name: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_coat_hypertension

I have seen dozen of times, because of effort, anxiety, whatever, my BP being 160/110, which drops to 130/85 after 15+ minutes of complete relaxation. Many amateurs (which apparently includes most GPs) simply do not let the BP settle. The medical value of tracking BP is to know its baseline at rest, otherwise it's a meaningless number.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by xxpor on Monday September 11, 2023 @07:52PM (#37475237)
Lisdexamphetamine decreased your BP? That's pretty wild. I specifically have to take by BP before my doctor's appointments to monitor it from going too high. This seemed like SOP for my doc.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by cko on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @12:14AM (#37476882)
If something increases heart rate, sometimes the body will vasodilate to compensate.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by sph on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @06:41AM (#37479086)
[delayed]
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by seba_dos1 on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @03:02AM (#37477675)
Stimulants can act tranquilizing for some ADHD people.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by bradknowles on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @04:37AM (#37493894)
And for some people, drugs like Valium act as stimulants. My dad had that problem. He also had two different medical conditions that were rare enough that they each got separately dramatized on "House, MD". When my mom passed away, I got a copy of his medical file. There were multiple binders, filling multiple shelves.

Just before our wedding, my dad had an crisis, and had to go to the hospital with an infection. He went to Johns Hopkins. They put him in the research wing. The doctors couldn't figure out what the heck to do with him because he was reacting so weird to so many medications. They ended up having to pump him full of vancomycin in hopes that he would last long enough on the three hour flight to get back home where his regular doctor could see him.

People are individuals, and their bodies can react in weird and unexpected ways.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by sph on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @06:46AM (#37479125)
Unmedicated ADHD causes a great deal of anxiety. Making your brain operate as intended reduces anxiety, which lowers your vitals.

That said, whether I'm oversensitive or more attuned than most ADHD people, I take a light dose, which doesn't turn me into a productive robot machine going 1000 mph.

Stimulants follow a U-curve, and I wouldn't be surprised to know that most people take far too much and have to keep increasing their dosage. A single 30 mg dose makes my anxiety skyrocket, I usually take 20mg twice a day, I've recently experimented with lowering to 15mg twice a day and I think I like it even better.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by k12sosse on Monday September 11, 2023 @08:16PM (#37475399)
> Lisdexamphetamine (I am diagnosed ADHD) decreases BP by 10 mmHg

Vyvanse saved my life.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by vrc on Monday September 11, 2023 @09:07PM (#37475771)
Pulse pressure, systolic-diastolic, is far more important clinically than I realized.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK482408/#

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by throwitawayfam on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @02:20AM (#37477461)
Do you have a favorite device you use? I've been considering getting something "smart" to auto log my BP.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by sph on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @06:55AM (#37479184)
I have an "OMRON M7 Intelli IT" machine. It's a good brand.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by llm_nerd on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @10:25AM (#37481815)
Just to echo sph, get an Omron device. Don't waste your time and money with the many random brands.

Omrons are accurate and reliable, and most new models like the Silver have bluetooth and with the Omron connect app will share the data with Apple Health if that's your platform, or you can just keep it in the app and it gives you trends and insights.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by mkoryak on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @02:27AM (#37477499)
I think the problem is that you've been measuring YOUR blood pressure, but you should have been measuring OPs blood pressure.

Maybe if you did that, you wouldn't disagree so much?

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by vjk800 on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @02:42AM (#37477581)
> - Also important is the delta between systolic and diastolic. Mine is around 40 mmHg, if it's higher than that, it's an indicator of a stress peak (bad sleep, bad day, overwhelmed) that usually resolves after a couple days.

Is this universally true or just you? Is there any source for this? My diastolic pressure is always in the normal numbers while my systolic pressure is borderline high, resulting in a pretty high delta (50-60 mmHg). Sometimes I also get numbers in the normal range for systolic pressure, but maybe 75% of the time it's a bit high.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by sph on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @06:51AM (#37479161)
Diastolic is the pressure at rest, systolic is the pressure during a heart beat. The reasonable explanation of a higher systolic than usual is your heart pumping more volume than usual. Usually and in my experience this means being anxious or not completely rested/sleep deprived.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by Vrondi on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @09:28PM (#37491053)
The takeaway is that people vary hugely in their sensitivities and the different medical histories behind the same condition. I know someone who is extremely sensitive to salt, and even on BP meds, they must have quite a low salt diet to control their blood pressure. Even though it isn't much of an issue for others, it is for them.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hedora on Monday September 11, 2023 @08:45PM (#37475641)
So, my heart was pounding and erratic at night, and my blood pressure would spike at random intervals.

The root cause was that I moved to a 2000’ higher elevation, and was dehydrated.

Since winter air is lower humidity, I suggest you drink two extra pints of water per day, spread across three-four sittings.

Will it work? Probably not. But, I’d give it an over 10% chance, and it will cost you nothing.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by pipes on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:09PM (#37476262)
Hydration is a big part too: I have venesections done every two week or so as a treatment for hemochromatosis. I.e. They take 450ml blood and dump it.

If my blood pressure is low before hand, the nurses get me to drink two jugs of water, blood pressure goes up to normal range with in minutes. Same before they let me drive home.

This has turned out to be a really useful tip for me life in general. If I'm feeling shit, I now suspect low blood pressure and force myself to drink two or three pints of water. It usually results in me feeling much better

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by robocat on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @12:25AM (#37476929)
> venesections I.e. They take 450ml blood and dump it.

Blood letting - wow!

> Haemochromatosis

  Haemochromatosis is an inherited condition where iron levels in the body slowly build up
https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/haemochromatosis/
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by davidjytang on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:13AM (#37543057)
My dad has hypertension due to [Conn's syndrome](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primary_aldosteronism). The only thing that helped tremendously was surgery.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by Buttons840 on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:10PM (#37472951)
What you say is true, but at the end of the day blood pressure readings in the flawed doctor's office setting are still correlated with medical outcomes.

I just want to speak against a trend people have to dismiss bad medical news by finding excuses. "The blood pressure reading doesn't count because I was nervous in the doctors office"; it's true, but the guidelines have probably accounted for that. "That medical study doesn't apply to me because it was done on the general population, but the general population is overweight and I'm not"; "that study doesn't apply to me because I do yoga, they didn't study people who do yoga"; etc.

I know it's hard, I'm in the middle of excusing some bad medical news of my own right now, trying to decide what's best for me.

Medicines have risks, untreated conditions have risks, choose your risk, but don't live in denial that the risk exists.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by kalensh on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:16PM (#37473035)
My issue is that blood pressure is being used by many corporations/health insurance plans to determine your premiums. So adding yet another layer of nervousness - you will be paying extra money over the course of the next year if your blood pressure is a little high (threshold is 120/80).
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by pkaye on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:47PM (#37474170)
In the US, your health or medical history can't affect your health insurance premiums.

https://www.healthcare.gov/how-plans-set-your-premiums

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by cogogo on Monday September 11, 2023 @07:15PM (#37474969)
It absolutely can affect your life insurance. Understandably that’s a problem of privilege but it’s a truth.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by pkaye on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @02:26AM (#37477496)
High blood pressure can be quite manageable with medications for most people and one should qualify for life insurance after that.

I know very much about the issue because I had kidney failure due to an autoimmune disease and had to deal with years of dialysis and just recently got a kidney transplant. High blood pressure is a very common issue in kidney failure and even that with the right combination of medications it was mostly manageable.

Its much hard to get life insurance after kidney disease. The best shot is through an employer group life insurance plan. And with my last employer I was able to covert it to an individual plan after I left.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by anonuser123456 on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:59PM (#37473620)
>but the guidelines have probably accounted for that

They have not. The guidelines are against controlled studies with strict protocols on how to take the measurement.

To know your blood pressure relative to the guidelines, you want to be as close to the guideline protocols and possible. That can be a 20/10 point difference or more.

The average physicians office doesn’t follow those protocols unless you deviate significantly. e.g you walk in with 140/90 and they aren’t going to bother. 160/95 and they will recheck you with more care given to the proper measurement technique.

This isn’t to say one should dismiss the numbers when taken properly; I’m just pointing out that calibration is necessary.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by nomel on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:32PM (#37474006)
I'm a nervous person. There have been several times where they had to recheck, because my rate was so high. My watch says my resting rate is 40 to 50 lower. Whatever protocols probably didn't have me in mind.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by Buttons840 on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:47PM (#37474166)
We're talking about blood pressure. Does your watch measure blood pressure?

I think this might be an example of what I was talking about: you think blood pressure guidelines might not apply to you because of something your watch says.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by nomel on Monday September 11, 2023 @08:14PM (#37475390)
My point was to give an example of situational sensitivity. My pulse is easiest/the most fun to see, because it's...on my watch. See [1]. And, they loosely don't apply, which is why I've been told to take measurements at home, before coming in, with an automated cuff. The measurements in the office are not useful.

[1] https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/23989-white-c....

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by darkerside on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @01:46PM (#37484820)
You can't point at nomel conflating blood pressure with heart rate and say, therefore nobody can consider themselves to fall outside the guidelines of traditional medical guidance.

On average, men are taller than women. That doesn't mean every man is taller than every woman. If a woman is taller than a man and says she needs specific treatment because of it, she may be 100% right.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by taneq on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:56PM (#37474815)
It’s called white coast hypertension, I don’t think of myself as particularly nervous but I get this too. I’ve had blood pressure readings in various medicals etc. from 145-160/90, and endured several stern lectures about salt and exercise and alcohol. Finally did a 24 hour ambulatory test and I’m < 130/60 or something in a non-clinical setting.

After this experience I did some reading and as far as I can tell, blood pressure is the least consistent, least rigorous test you can do in mainstream medicine. The “normal” range spans ~10mmHg and yet readings can vary by 10-20mmHg according to each of: stress level, standing up in the last 15 mins, recently having a drink of water (as you do in a doctor’s waiting room), whether your legs are crossed, etc. Without controlling for all of these (which is almost never done properly) they might as well be reading your tea leaves.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by macNchz on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:31PM (#37474589)
I think the purpose of taking BP in a regular doctor's visit is also just screening, not to make a final diagnostic decision. If it's normal they can move on, if not they can do some followups to determine whether it's genuinely an issue. Very many basic screening tests work like that: they're effective at determining something is not an issue, but not at definitively saying it is.

Personally I definitely have some degree of "white coat" syndrome, doctors offices just put me on edge for whatever reason. Several years ago as a healthy 30 year old at a routine office visit, the doctor found my blood pressure to be right on the upper bound of normal. She didn't immediately take any action on it, she just told me to stop by a local pharmacy and use their automatic machine a few times over the following weeks, and to enter the numbers in her organization's medical chart app. I did, it was normal, she sent me an email "thanks, looks good!". Case closed.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by theshrike79 on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @06:44AM (#37479110)
I was specifically told, by my doctor, to take my BP first thing I wake up and have sat down for a while.

My Withings BPM Connect takes 3 measurements automatically at intervals and takes the average of those + saves them to Apple Health.

Before I was taking my BP when I was feeling "weird" and of course it was through the roof, by taking it in the mornings my BP is still a bit high, but not Hypertension Level 2 high.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by serial_dev on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:24PM (#37473166)
People mentioned the white coat syndrome, but that's not the only issue.

I am not nervous when they measure my blood pressure, but I might have been late to my doctors appointment, so of my 25 min walk to the doctor, I was running half of it. I had non-optimal blood pressure values at the doctor, because I was running not to miss the appointment, and as I arrived, I had to immediately go get my BP checked.

After the incident, I religiously measured my BP at home various times a day for a week and my numbers looked okay.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by BaculumMeumEst on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:38PM (#37473352)
I was late to an optometrist appointment a few weeks back. Sprinted up six flights of stairs and into the office. The literal second I got in they called my name and immediately measured BP. The tech looked like they were going to shit themselves.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by redox99 on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:30PM (#37473232)
At least in my country, to diagnose you with high BP they'd have you wear a holter monitor for 24 hours.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by readthenotes1 on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:34PM (#37473297)
That's standard in the US as well.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by bradknowles on Wednesday September 13, 2023 @04:58AM (#37494073)
I've worn a holter monitor. It doesn't measure blood pressure at all. It's just two leads measuring your heart rate activity over a period of time. And not even as good as my Kardia 6L.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by ljosifov on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:30PM (#37473240)
You are spot on. Random once a year BP measurement is not good enough. Doctors are being asked to provide life altering advice while being effectively blind in this case. I have no idea why we don't try harder to make their (tough) job easier rather than just accepting the current (sorry) state. My cars and my computers have more sensors on them than I have on me! That's crazy - I have to drop nearly dead and only then will I go to doctors' for diagnosis and treatment. My car preventative maintenance is miles better.

After being diagnosed with elevated BP, I googled and read what I could and concluded: 1) Cheap "BP monitors" on Amazon just show random readings or the same readings so they are worse than useless: someone may actually use them and believe their readings. 2) There are only few smart watches that have BP measuring function.

I am currently using Samsung Watch Active2, and it seems to do the job. There is calibration that is good for 30 days only. After 30 days it expires and I calibrate it again. Calibration involves making 3 measurements in parallel, watch on one hand and manual BP monitor on the other. After each measurement on the manual BP monitor, I tell the watch App what was measured.

After each calibration I do another 3 measurements in parallel, again using both the watch and the manual monitor. I compare the watch (post calibration) readings with the manual BP readings. Usually the difference is small within few percent. If it is more than 8-10% I redo the calibration. This has happened 2 times in the 25 odd calibrations I have done. Usually the reason is noise instead of perfect silence (person coming in the room and talking, TV being turned on).

I have tried using the watch on Person2 after being calibrated on Person1 - and Person2 got crazy BP readings. So the calibration really does something, it is not nothing.

The watch measurements also approximately agreed with measurements taken over 24h period when I wore BP holter (automated BP cuff that inflates every 30 mins and measures and records the BP).

Over time I have become more lazy with the re/calibration: now several days pass before I re/do it. So I'm acutely aware that any non-100% automated data collection will eventually be abandoned on long enough time horizon. Redoing the same is boring and becomes more so with time.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by atahanacar on Monday September 11, 2023 @09:02PM (#37475748)
>I have to drop nearly dead and only then will I go to doctors' for diagnosis and treatment.

This is a healthcare issue specific to your country. It is not a problem of "not enough measurements".

Regarding using tech like smartwatches for blood pressure measurement, it is currently not possible. They aren't measuring your blood pressure, they are simply correlating optical data like pulse transit time with your blood pressure, which is mostly inaccurate. If you have to calibrate every now and then using actual bp measurements, then you already have enough data and don't need your smartwatch.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:32PM (#37473266)
> so nobody measures it as frequently as they do their pulse. Once we have the technology to accurately and passively measure blood pressure throughout the day

It's surprisingly tricky. The way a BP cuff works (the auscultatory method[1]) is that the pressure is continuously decreased and you listen for the sound of a pulse. When the cuff pressure is higher than your systolic (peak) pulse, bloodflow is blocked and you don't hear a pulse. When the cuff pressure is lower than your diastolic, the cuff is no longer blocking bloodflow at all, and the pulse suddenly becomes much quieter because it's not restricted. It's only between the two pressures that you hear it extra clearly.

So the problem with a sensor is that you can't just measure pressure against the skin. At minimum, it really should actually block off a large vein. You can squeeze the arm as tight as you like but if the brachial vein is not affected then your measurement will be very poor.

You can do fancy computer vision etc to look at special veins/arteries, and coupled with some demographic assumptions you can infer somewhat accurate measurements- but they really miss out on outliers, which is really a lot of the point of taking measurements. This also generally will require an upper arm strap or something, and be fairly tight. Not great to wear always

At some point, I think we will probably see implantable blood pressure monitoring. We do something similar with implantable glucose monitors- which need regular replacement, unfortunately. BP probably wouldn't. Problem is that direct pressure measurement is usually done by tapping off an artery- something that will never be routine. You'd want to do some combination of acoustic and pressure measurement, and it'd need to be calibrated from a base station regularly.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_pressure_measurement#/me...

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by jkingsman on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:37PM (#37473345)
Worth mentioning that BP is about arterial, not venous pressure. Venous pressure is an order of magnitude lower than arterial pressure; usually 0-10mmHg.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:58PM (#37473606)
ty, edited. oopsies!
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by alphanumeric0 on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:40PM (#37474099)
Yes, the most accurate method is via arterial catheter. It's basically a needle directly into the artery.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by boringuser2 on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:41PM (#37474115)
I'm confused.

The technology already exists and is approved by the EU.

https://aktiia.com/

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:28PM (#37474569)
Photoplethysmogram devices like this measure blood volume. That works great for your heart rate. It is pretty terrible for your blood pressure. In theory they measure the speed an artery expands as blood passes.

1. Since they can't measure blood flow, only volume, they can't tell if your BP is low or if they just aren't centered on an artery. They can't measure diastolic, only the difference between systolic and diastolic.

2. Since they don't know the flow, they can't even guess the size of the artery, so they're basically just guessing how much it should be expanding. They also have to know how tall you are to even get close.

3. They measure the derivative of the increase in volume to try to correlate that with blood pressure. That's very variable with the specific artery and the condition of the artery- there's a lot of (primarily age) variance in artery elasticity.

Papers indicating accuracy should be subject to high scrutiny. The device basically starts out by guessing that you're healthy and normal for your age and height. If you take a bunch of people that are healthy for their age and height (most people), the device will perform very well. It will also be practically useless.

If you have ideopathic large swings in blood pressure, like POTS, or fainting, or migraines, a device like this can give you a bit of warning. It will not give you accurate readings or track long-term changes, and those issues are made much worse because of opaque calibrations etc.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photoplethysmogram

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by boringuser2 on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:46PM (#37474712)
Do you think the EU regulatory agencies haven't properly accounted for the claims made by the makers of this device?

It looks very promising and it is clinically approved.

Your theory craft seems to check out, but they could have proprietary technology that Huawei is yet to clone/rip-off, so it's not a well-known methodology. Funnily enough, they actually tested some of their algorithms in China based on their papers, so maybe it is just a matter of time.

That being said, if you have industry inside knowledge, that's a little different.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Monday September 11, 2023 @09:27PM (#37475958)
> Do you think the EU regulatory agencies haven't properly accounted for the claims made by the makers of this device?

Exactly what regulation do you think applies to this device? Do you think it's an approved medical device?

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by boringuser2 on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:39PM (#37476754)
>Aktiia Bracelet G1 has been CE-marked under the Medical Device Regulation (EU)2017/745 as a class IIa medical device.

I'm not trying to embarass you, I was just genuinely curious if you had any special knowledge.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by TechBro8615 on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:54PM (#37474228)
I wonder if there are methods that could take advantage of natural movements throughout the day, where your body naturally emulates what the cuff forces it to do. For example, when you transition suddenly from sitting to standing, is it possible for a sensor to measure some proxy metric that, combined with an accelerometer, can be used to infer blood pressure? If there is some method like this, even if it has large margins of error, maybe cumulative measurements could converge on a fairly accurate reading?

(I'm not a medical professional nor do I know much about sensing, or even really the basics of how blood pressure is measured or what it indicates.)

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by joshvm on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @05:13AM (#37478513)
Maybe a related question, but how good a proxy is cuff pressure for a gold standard method that measures inside an artery? Whenever I've had BP measured for clinical studies (not focused on BP specifically) they used a mix of cuff and continuous fingertip sensors depending on the activity.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @09:53AM (#37481293)
It's pretty good, about +/- 5 mmHg. At worst it can bump you up/down a category- drinking a couple glasses of water can do that too, and the medical treatment would not be any different. The electric cuff machines can be over twice as variable- about 1/20 person-measurements will read off by >20 mmHg, which is a hugely important difference.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by krzat on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @05:39AM (#37478685)
Continous measurement of body temperature, blood pressure and heart rate via implant could be enormously helpful to health for so many reasons...
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by moffkalast on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:35PM (#37473306)
> it would be beneficial to take more frequent blood pressure readings, throughout the day and during typical routines, than it would to only take them every time you visit the doctor

It would be, if the most reliable way to get BP data wasn't to apparently violently compress the upper arm until it physically hurts and leave it like that for a minute. How people can do that on any kind of regular basis completely escapes me, and I'm not convinced it's not actively harmful. The wrist monitors are tolerable but seem to be very sensitive to wrist height.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by scythe on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:56PM (#37473579)
One time a doctor at the on-campus clinic looked at my blood sugar reading said I might be prediabetic. This was an early-morning appointment at a time in my life when I wasn't very used to that and had rushed out of my dorm while scarfing down a bagel that had been hastily topped with the only thing in the cabinet that was in a squeeze bottle — honey!

No blood test over the next decade showed even a hint of elevated blood sugar.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by atahanacar on Monday September 11, 2023 @09:09PM (#37475785)
That is exactly why you need fasting blood glucose for diagnosis of diabetes.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by m463 on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:23PM (#37473910)
I have a garmin watch and one wonderful thing it does is show me my resting heart rate, which is a nice indication of my level of fitness (and correlates with good sleep, sickness, etc)

It also does nice things like a detailed check of my sleep, how I'm acclimatizing to altitude when visiting the mountains, the number of steps I walked and pulse-ox.

I don't know how these correlate to what blood pressure tells you, but I blood pressure will be directly measured in the same way in a few years.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by tguvot on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:35PM (#37474043)
take a look at aktiia. tracks blood pressure through the day. currently under trials in usa to get fda approvalm but you can buy it from eu
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by vonnik on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:51PM (#37474205)
Fwiw, OMRON produces high-quality blood-pressure monitors for consumers.

https://omronhealthcare.com/blood-pressure/

Even these, though, tend to overestimate your actual blood pressure, sometimes by as much as 10 points.

But having one in the home makes it easy to take several readings throughout the day, since each one hardly lasts a minute.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by smartbit on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:17PM (#37476640)
A few years ago their Bluetooth apps didn’t require registration, now the do. So now you’d need to keep track of the measurements yourselves, e.g. using a spreadsheet. Can not recommend Omron anymore.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by frereubu on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @05:06AM (#37478462)
Doctors in the UK use Omron monitors.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by jliptzin on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:54PM (#37474226)
Are you confusing blood pressure and blood sugar? My boyfriend is type 1 diabetic, he measures his blood sugar multiple times a day, but I have never seen him measure his blood pressure.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by hwillis on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:14PM (#37474414)
No- diabetes can have very negative long term impacts on your small blood vessels, particularly in your kidneys. Changes in blood pressure from vascular damage all over your body can be a signal that nephropathy (kidney disease) is not far away. It takes years to accumulate.
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by jliptzin on Thursday September 14, 2023 @12:59PM (#37511558)
Thank you. In theory if the diabetic successfully controls their blood sugar for the vast majority of the time does that limit the damage?
Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by Someone on Monday September 11, 2023 @06:08PM (#37474367)
> Once we have the technology to accurately and passively measure blood pressure throughout the day, preventive medicine will become much easier

How? Do we have any idea what we would do with that data? AFAIK, all treatments we currently have aren’t suited for treating short-duration spikes in blood pressure (do they even need treatment? I wouldn’t know).

Also, why would we need preventive medicine for most people with hypertension? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypertension#Prevention:

“The 2004 British Hypertension Society guidelines proposed lifestyle changes consistent with those outlined by the US National High BP Education Program in 2002 for the primary prevention of hypertension:

- maintain normal body weight for adults (e.g. body mass index 20–25 kg/m2)

- reduce dietary sodium intake to <100 mmol/ day (<6 g of sodium chloride or <2.4 g of sodium per day)

- engage in regular aerobic physical activity such as brisk walking (≥30 min per day, most days of the week)

- limit alcohol consumption to no more than 3 units/day in men and no more than 2 units/day in women

- consume a diet rich in fruit and vegetables (e.g. at least five portions per day);

- Stress reduction”

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by Angostura on Monday September 11, 2023 @08:24PM (#37475467)
I'm in the UK with hypertension. My GP surgery sends me a text message every 6 months or so, asking for a week's readings morning and evening, using a home blood pressure monitor - the message includes a link to submit readings.

Gets rid of most of my white coat hyper tension

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by shepherdjerred on Monday September 11, 2023 @08:25PM (#37475473)
One easy way to check your blood pressure more regularly is to donate blood!

At least in the United States, you'll get your pulse, blood pressure, and iron levels all checked. Additionally, your blood will be tested for some infectious diseases like HIV.

Lots of free testing, and you also get to help someone out!

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by atahanacar on Monday September 11, 2023 @08:55PM (#37475704)
Tracking your blood pressure randomly throughout the day will not be meaningful in any way, just like tracking your pulse isn't meaningful. It will only be annoying, as blood pressure measurement is a mechanical process, unlike heart rate measurements which can be done optically or electrically.

>right after you've driven to the appointment, made your way through the intake pipeline, and finally sat down in the chair, is not representative of its reading during a typical day in your life.

So? It is taught pretty early in med school that before measuring the vitals, you should let the patient rest while you take their story, and ask questions related to things that might change the measurements (did you walk here? did you walk up the stairs? did you drink coffee? did you smoke etc.). And if you still want more measurements throughout the day for various reasons, you can just use holter.

>all combine to make blood pressure a fairly variable statistic with limited diagnostic power when it's only measured infrequently.

[citation needed]

If you are hypertensive, non of the things you've mentioned will matter. Your blood pressure will be high regardless, and it will still be caught. In addition, you can't just diagnose with a single reading anyways.

It is funny to read comments regarding medicine on HN.

Re:Doctors Have Been Measuring Blood Pressure All Wrong, Stu... by lm28469 on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @05:07AM (#37478473)
> Once we have the technology to accurately and passively measure blood pressure throughout the day, preventive medicine will become much easier, and people will have a better feeling for how their blood pressure responds to small changes in their environment and lifestyle.

With 70% of the population being overweight or obese and on a dog shit diet I very much doubt that.

We already know what we do is bad, we know how to fix it, virtually no one does it. If people can't be arsed to even walk 30 min a day I don't think they'll care about continuously monitoring their blood pressure. You can track your pulse continuously with ultra cheap gadgets and it'll tell 50%+ of the population their heart is in bad shape, nobody cares

The best preventative medicine is your lifestyle, if you wait for symptoms you already failed your body and are 10+ years late to the party