UGC (User Generated Content) could remain commentary about these news articles when shared in, but it would require consumers to become creators.
I remember a facebook before any articles was posted there.
News articles were brought in explicitly to get the news crowd there, and keep them engaged.
I wonder how federated news delivery could work - anyone use anything like this.
Remember relatives cheering for Trump, pro-russian narratives, and Anti-vaxx because it was on Facebook? Drinking from the fire-hose of (free but) manipulated content hurts our society and the planet.
Any progress of getting rid of targeted ads is a net positive for people's mental health, and the survival of our species.
If Canada isn't able to cover that niche that Facebook leaves behind, that's another problem entirely.
Meta comment in the interest of improving discussion in the future: this is why you're getting downvotes.
I've seen plenty of comments that include everything else you said and get upvoted to the top, but casual negative stereotyping of whole generations doesn't play as well on HN as it does on other platforms.
Why do you believe this? It's nobody's job to convert their friends to any particular ideology, and if you find someone's worldview clashes with what you assumed it was based on prior behavior, then I'd say that materially changes the relationship.
Imagine making a friend who hung out with a diverse group alongside you, but one day reveals they're actually quite bigoted and starts talking shit about someone in the friend group because, for example, they're homosexual? Would you still want to be that person's friend?
Politics isn't just politics, it has social meaning.
The article author tries to say "Individual Canadians who use the platforms to find links to news are losers since news links will be blocked from the platform" but doesn't actually support that with a reason as to why that's a loss. Feels like a win to individual Canadians to me, even if some are upset at their inability to easily and immediately share clickbait and ragebait articles. I think those are the people we're really cheering on.
We can't let our impression of how things should play out be determined by asking which self-serving powerful player deserves the right of way in policy making.
Have you not just rephrased my "right" and "wrong" as "how things should play out". I'm not sure why someone would do that.
I think I was responding to the idea that because the government was acting in self-serving ways, that we were necessarily cheering on Facebook, and that what facebook is doing is "standing up to...corruption", when their own efforts are a corruption of a different kind. The phrasing there made me feel like I was being made to choose--that I was either cheering for facebook or for their rivals in this situation--and I didn't feel that that choice was accurate. It's possible to think that both parties are in the wrong, even if they are on opposite sides here.
Your follow up post reinforced that feeling as it maintained the idea that one party or the other was in the right, but that post was also a direct response to what I said, and not necessarily a continuation of what you had posted earlier. So by continuing that thread I reinforced my own misinterpretation.
I will try to better understand my own reactions to people's posts in the future, and be better in responding in the appropriate context, not with a shift.
Just because right and wrong can imply the word "should" in a hypergeneric sense doesn't mean I was talking about right of way.
If I was an American/Euro/South American news org I'd be staffing up my Canadian journos. Any org out of reach of the backroom dealing Ottawa private school clique can probably hire some local freelancers and fill the void by the end of the year.
Regardless, Canada isn’t protecting people from facebook. They didn’t ban news sharing, they just wanted to give their media companies a cut.
It's a casino with flashing lights, exciting noise, and free cocktails.
But those average people are the majority of "views" of said paper, that's why all these media outlets are desperate for that ad revenue. They already have subscriber bases that are actual real interest in reading content.
Welcome to the sad reality of our world, crack open a cold one and laugh with the rest of us.
- above average content
- more well-thought-out comments
- a more technical, intelligent, and successful userbase
than the average website.
Or are you really trying to imply that it (and it's users) are not much different from, say, Reddit or a Fox News's comment section or TikTok or Facebook?
Oh really? this one couldn't be bothered for a single complete sentence:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37030073
Don't kid yourself, this place is filled with karma farmers. Stop sniffing your own farts
Being better than average at a couple things is extremely common. It's not delusional to point those things out.
Most websites are good at something (excluding spam sites).
Here's the relevant clip: https://youtu.be/AKN1Q5SjbeI
This is the 2020s equivalent of saying that there can’t possibly be legitimate news culture happening with Comedy Central viewers at the peak ofThe Daily Show with Jon Stewart. It’s just out of touch with the common person.
Are we using the same apps? My FB and Insta feeds were a steaming pile of ads and influencers and other garbage. I stopped using both because posts from people I follow were buried
I’m talking about the endless stream of content that is the bread and butter of social media. Your friends don’t have infinite content to post.
The endless stream of content product (think Reels and TikTok) is what captures 90% of users’ attention.
In that context, yes, you’ll get ads and influencers shilling sponsored stuff, but you can swipe them away instantly. And my argument is that this product is very good for very many people.
“Your feed will be mostly ads”
If that’s the way it’s supposed to work, I want none of it. There was a time I could check FB or Insta a few times/week and see mostly friends/family.
:old man yelling at clouds:
Also, elder Millenials. Snort. Gen-Xer here. I’m not even all that gray. Yet.
Incoming on-brand Gen X comment: it’s funny that they even skip over us when handing out pejoratives.
I mean, we can obviously see why the above is not a viable product no matter how ethical the company making it may be.
I'd note that this isn't even good at the UX/technical level.
I very rarely use FB, but opened it the other day and noticed that that the promo card for reels is always showing up despite me having clicked "Hide" on it several times before. I spent a minute or two clicking "Hide" on it probably 20 more times, and as far as I can tell, it has zero effect. Not good UX. Furthermore, if you click "Report this post" in the dialog after "Hide", you get a consistent "Sorry, something went wrong" popup. Not good technically.
AFAICT, most of what they really take issue with is intrinsic to allowing direct communication between anyone in the world. There seem to be severely anti-democratic implications for many of the critiques of Meta that I hear.
Truly the only place where the techies seem to diverge is that they care about privacy, whereas it is about “fake news” for everyone else.
A thing being "enjoyable" doesn't mean it's good, neither for society or the person(s) doing it.
Not every moment of life needs to be healthy or productive.
I dunno to what extent you use Facebook. But it's not technically great at all, and the UX is total trash.
Age isn't a reasonable excuse at this point. Common access to the Internet has been with us for ~30 years.
People subscribed with money to a newspaper. Which then delivered curated content right to their front door. They didn't go seek it out. Also, most of the newspapers are part of global corporations, even local ones.
I say to a degree vecause there are some distinct differences. At least in my neck of the woods, major newspapers were owned at a national level. Some of the stories came from international corporations (e.g. AP), but what was published tended to be local editorial decisions. You also got the same news as everyone else who subscribed to or purchased single copies of the paper.
Contrast that to online news through social media sites. Chances are the editorial decisions are made in a different country, and there may not even be direct human intervention in choosing what you (as an individual) sees.
[deleted stuff about internet rollout at UVA in the mid-90s]
Shit, that was 30 years ago. Thanks for making me feel old. ;)
To be clear, I'm not saying that boomers aren't smart enough to use technology. It's just that old, comfortable habits are hard to break. Facebook for many of them is a safe, walled garden compared to the wild west internet.
This is a major source of traffic for media, along with say sharing links via imessage.
Almost no one logs onto facebook with the goal of "checking the news". But they see news there and it adds up to a lot of traffic because Facebook and instagram are huge. (The media posts clips to Facebook and Instagram and these can show up in feeds too if the post is popular enough)
In light of that, a world with no news on Facebook would be just fine. If anyone is that uninterested in news that they would never check out a news site directly on their own, they won’t miss it.
Because that's the reason. Folks interested in news tend to talk about it with other folks interested - and that has happened long before the internet. In some cases, it is pretty similar to leaving a newspaper in a fast food place: Let folks you don't see much (or at all) read that stuff as well.
It doesn't always matter if other options are better - folks work with what they have. Similar to wanting to talk to someone more intelligent about the news, but still talking about it with the folks you have around.
I don’t witness that happening though. When I see “news” posted by people on FB, I usually see a despairing one-line intro at most, and a link. Then the comments are a bunch of me-toos or, for those with unkempt friend lists of everyone they’ve ever met, a raucous flame war.
The other “news” is posted by the sites themselves or by large political Pages or Groups. Those are exclusively the “flame war” variety, 1000 strangers screaming into the void pointlessly.
So (imo) nothing of value would be lost by abolishing the whole concept of news on social media.
If you want a place where sane people can have a virtual water cooler discussion about the day’s news stories with friends they know, those friends should just set up a group text or a Discord.
I have taken to using a website I found that combines and aggregates all the mainstream news sites, so I can see from an aerial view what -- if any -- message they're trying to sell that day. And it's weird how close in lockstep these media outlets talk about things.
I see a lot of criticism on the Internet amount to "If they only used the good stuff..." So, where is it?
[1] http://www.parl.ca/DocumentViewer/en/44-1/bill/C-18/royal-as...
Sounds like an easy way to get on the grift train.
Meta, please ban newspapers all around the world!
Look at supermarkets: everything after the department for fruits an vegetables is basically bad for us. Science prooves that. But we have to pass all this convenience food that promises to be cheap and fast and healthy and it isn't. And most people somehow learned that in school but ever since they are being informed by the companies.
I will agree with your objection to the “prove” claim about the science (if only because it’s an overstatement of what science does) but the negative associations between various adverse health outcomes and a plant-based diet are well-supported in the literature: lower risk of type 2 diabetes, lower systolic BP, lower risk of cardiovascular events, lower total cardiovascular mortality, lower rates of certain malignancies.
Facebook... I mean... it wasn't pitched to be that? It was supposed to connect you to each other, not be an algorithmic view into the universe. Sure, sharing news can be a big part of that, and talking about news too, but every site doesn't have to be everything.
Why would my personal social group (i.e. facebook friends) make sense to combine with the random strangers on here who discuss technical posts? Sure there's some overlap in audience but it just doesn't seem like a necessary compromise to make.
If you're in the Facebook ecosystem maybe this is less visible. But if friends plan an event in a Facebook group they are excluding me and others who don't use Facebook for many valid but irrelevant reasons.
One such reason is that pseudo-anonymity is crucial for a lot of people for professional or personal reasons, and it's way easier to support that elsewhere.
Others include data privacy policies.
Maybe there's not a great choice that has the right blend of ease of access and ease of setup. But I think Facebook is demonstrably bad because of the requirements of logging in to read at all and to enforce that your profile has a real name.
No ads.
Thus, no engagement metrics to optimize for because HN isn’t even monetized that I know of (and hopefully doesn’t need to become one?)
With no engagement needing to be goosed we don’t need an algorithm to make sure we see the most outraging things possible. We just see what’s interesting to the whole community.
Radicalization online is a serious problem and I think the reverse qualities of the above, which FB, Twitter, and YouTube are perfect examples of, is a big part of how it happened.
HN pushes us toward the average interests of hackers. FB amplifies whatever interests repeatably get your attention until they become obsessions.
(I stopped following anything or anyone political on FB and YouTube, so that they only makes me more engaged in my nerdy, wholesome interests. I think I’m in the minority though)
It's like you're giving your children heroin, and complaining that your dealer has half-assed parenting controls.
Agreed.
Facebook would really blow my mind if they doubled down on their core mission.
Because people want to share and visit news links. Evidenced by the fact that they shared and visited news links often. Its a bit condescending to suggest you know whats better for people than the people freely choosing to engage in news articles.
Besides, the Canadian law doesn’t even ban news sharing on Facebook. It just institutes a shakedown.
This is a very naive view of what's going on or the impact.
I don't like reading clickbait or ragebait articles that people share. If connections of mine do that on social media too often I usually mute them.
I also don't "get" my news "from" Facebook. As in, if Facebook were to try and suggest news articles to me I would find that very annoying. I use FB Purity to give myself a very sanitized news feed that is configured to my liking.
And yet this ridiculous bill that literally no one in Canada asked for is impacting me.
How?
Because I follow a local independent news outlet that posts stuff about my area that actually matters to me. These are NOT articles that people share and they are NOT shit that Facebook is shoving my face. I CHOSE to click "Follow" on the FB Page for that news outlet so that I could find out about things like weather alerts, crime in my area and local events.
That page is now gone from Facebook.
What is INSANE to me is that this doesn't even seem like a case of Facebook distributing that news. It was that local news outlet that chose to create a Facebook page and create those links themselves in order to distribute their content on Facebook voluntarily. Yet that still, for some fucked up reason, falls under this insane law that no one asked for.
Facebook needs content to survive, as it does not produce anything itself.
News agencies have THEIR content posted on Facebook, giving it value, not the other way around.
Google is exploiting copyrighted content to make profit and create audience.
If the search index of Google was empty, the people wouldn't use Google, it's that simple.
So the newspapers are asking for royalties for feeding that search index.
Granted, I have `disallow: /` in mine because I don't want my stuff scraped, but I still see Googlebot sometimes, and others, try to crawl my site.
It's not a very effective opt-out, because it requires the 'attacker' to honor the file's settings.
Feel free to enable it on your own server and watch the logs for a few days after sharing some links.
I hope daddy government treats you well.
Count on Big Brother to save you, and they will beat you down when it's time as well.
Noting that something exists and including it in reference material should by no means incur royalties.
To be clear, the bill is fundamentally broken. It would require Google or Facebook to pay simply when links to news sites are served, rather than for reproducing or condensing the material in the news article as a "preview" sort of be thing (as in other countries). The bill isn't banning links explicitly, but the government should have seen this coming.
Perhaps they could have listened when the two companies they are trying to impose this on provide suggestions - or maybe modeled it more closely after legislation in other countries where such media taxes have been successful.
Yet they publish articles with the entire headline and backing images marked for free display on Google/Facebook. Almost like they are trying to help the search engines to attract traffic.
But they care a lot. So clearly that exposure must be worth something.
The relevant legislation isn't just taxing the platforms for "content", it's taxing the platforms for merely linking to the content.
Now nobody benefits.
In fact, you could probably make the case Facebook would be made better without news content. It's interesting that they chose to remove all news content for Canadians, rather than just Canadian news. I assume this was a good opportunity for them to try out some user testing.
This. Times 1000. My neighbor's cat's incredible Easter Island vacation photos are much more interesting that 1000 articles about presidential politics.
I'm really quite fine with this experiment happening.
An experiment is when you have a hypothesis about something that could be improved or optimized, test the hypothesis with a subset to find evidence or observe unintended effects of the change, replicate the finding, scale up, or revert depending on the outcomes observed.
A national policy by fiat is somewhat the opposite of what I consider an experiment to be.
Those organizations, being Canadian news organizations, employing Canadians, and making content for Canadian consumers. Aren't those the sort of organizations that should be able to work with the Canadian government and influence Canadian laws?
What sorts of organizations instead of those ones should be able to work with the government here? I think legislation should have outside influence, but I think I'm missing something here, or making the mistake of taking things at face-value.
You can make the same argument about local companies lobbying the government to enact tariffs to protect them from foreign competitors. The people being harmed are the same: consumers who end up with a worse product. How about nobody tries to influence the Canadian government to enact laws that distort the marketplace to their advantage?
Why the hell would I care if the people who are trying to basically legislate themselves into profitability are Canadian or not?
There is no such thing. This regulation is the consequence of a regularly passed law (Bill C-18), that passed with about 210 to 110 majority. If I remember public poling on the issue correctly, on the bill itself popular opinion was pretty evenly split, but the underlying principle of tech companies paying domestic news, had wide majority support.
Framing this as something being imposed on citizens is disingenuous and effectively the Facebook PR line. Just with related media laws anywhere else it has little basis in reality.
(edit: as an aside, I just want to clarify that when I write “lizard people”, I mean to suggest politicians and corporate leadership acting out of self-interest rather than implying a bigoted conspiracy theory. I realized this could come off as anti-semetic in 2023; sorry if that landed poorly for anyone)
As part of the process, the parliamentary committee released a survey asking questions like
* Independent candidates should be able to be elected to Parliament
* The current electoral system adequately reflects voters' intentions
* Seats should be allocated in proportion to the percentage of votes received by each political party
* Voters should elect local candidates to represent them in Parliament
* The current electoral system should be changed
When the committee concluded with https://www.ourcommons.ca/Content/Committee/421/ERRE/Reports..., recommending that Canada adopt proportional representation, the Liberal Party responds with their own survey, asking questions like * There should be parties in Parliament that represent the views of all Canadians, even if some are radical or extreme.
* Governments should have to negotiate their policy decisions with other parties in Parliament, even if it is less clear who is accountable for the resulting policy.
* It is better for several parties to have to govern together than for one party to make all the decisions in government, even if it takes longer for government to get things done.
Yeah...I cant think of any western country with a more (effectively) non linear response of seats vs. vote share than Canada.
Because we do that now. "News" sites with independent journalist filled with misinformation. Aunt Marge telling you what happened, only putting a religious slant on it.
And I can pretty well promise that neither Aunt Marge nor the "news" sites are going to have any news on the war in another country that your neighbor's son just died in, nor a drought that has affected wheat prices globally or things like that.
It isn't that professional journalists always get things right, but its better than Aunt Marge and the "news" sites out there.
Many countries have protectionist laws and this isn’t much different.
I don't think that preserving Canadian culture is a factor in any of this, nor does it seem to be a concern of the current government.
These same politicians have been bringing in an absolutely staggering number of foreigners each year for many years now, with most of them from cultures that are extremely dissimilar from, if not outright incompatible with, what was Canadian culture.
Yet the government is passing even more laws to try to give them cash grabs. These companies should be broken apart and the spectrum sold off to smaller players. Canadians need more competition in both media and wireless / internet access, not less.
Canada appeared to be attempting to emulate countries like Australia, Spain, France, etc that have passed very similar laws. It seems like the tech giants were perfectly happy to just cut ties with Canadian media rather than make a deal however.
Imagine if I recommended you to watch a show on Netflix and I had to pay to give that recommendation. It makes absolutely no sense.
that it, or any portion of it, is reproduced; and
that access to it is facilitated by “any means, including an index, aggregation or ranking of news content.”
"Just linking does not satisfy the first part of the clause according to the bill.
"Any portion" is language that gives away that this is intended to be read pretty broadly. There's no qualifier, no "significant" or "substantial". If the goal were to prevent the kind of abuse that your bus driver analogy suggests, they should have been more specific.
'Making available of news content (2) For the purposes of this Act, news content is made available if
(a) the news content, or any portion of it, is reproduced; or
(b) access to the news content, or any portion of it, is facilitated by any means, including an index, aggregation or ranking of news content.'
https://www.parl.ca/DocumentViewer/en/44-1/bill/C-18/royal-a...
https://lop.parl.ca/staticfiles/PublicWebsite/Home/ResearchP...
Obviously this is entirely beneficial for the news source for this to be shown - this bill is like trying to go after people for copyright infringement for showing somebody a movie trailer (since the movie trailer contains "any portion" of the full feature film).
And just like other protectionist laws, this is a dumb idea and is going to end up hurting consumers.
The underpinning concept in HTML is:
My document can link to your document without asking, and without cost.
This whole, if you send traffic to me you have to pay me for it is backwards.
Hyperbolic and self defeating. If the corruption is incompetent then I guess there isn't much effective corruption. Canada ranks well above even the US on most indexes of corruption. Not liking the current government is a totally different thing than a country being corrupt.
Canada=14th, which is nothing to be embarrassed about.
Even if, for the sake of argument, it was possible to do so, you would have to interrogate the methodology used to produce this value. Note the complexity in analyzing corruption by country. How does one investigate in detail, the governments of almost 200 countries? If one relies on survey results from members of those countries, how was the survey consistently conducted across language barriers, cultural barriers, and legal barriers?
Finally, even if you believe all of those incredibly dubious factors were accounted for, it could be possible that being 14th in a world that is becoming more corrupt does not mean that Canada is improving in that regard.
It's amazing how we can make excuses for everything, as long as we delude ourselves that we somehow have it better than the US.
Don't forget Avril Lavigne, Drake, Gordon Lightfoot, Céline Dion, Joni Mitchell, deadmau5, The Weeknd, and Nelly Furtado.
Just off the top of my head. Interestingly enough I'd never heard of Kids in the Hall before today. But all of those are or were "Big Names" in music.
We have (protectionist, yes) media regulators (the CRTC) that are nominally arm's length from elected governments so it's not likely to change unless the Canadian public decides that this will become a major election issue. Don't hold your breath.
Of course one shouldn't forget what is perhaps Canada's greatest contribution to music: Nickelback.
As a Canadian I was actively trying to forget that one. Thanks :(
:P
Trudeau wasn't wrong. The fact that conservatives pillory him for this rare moment of truth-telling is part of what's turned him into such a breathy-mouthed coward.
But, why do I care? My parents dragged me into Canada at age six, I left as soon as I graduated. Not my country, not my problem.
But it's hard to see how that relates to "running the country".
I've kept my Canadian # for posterity and I'm on a legacy plan for $50 that gets me 15GB and US-Can voice so you can definitely get cheaper ones through retention (the only way to get a good deal on wireless in Canada).
> But it's hard to see how that relates to "running the country".
Agree that's a bit much, they basically rule the CRTC (telecom regulator) which has never made an adverse decision against them to my recollection. The running joke was they had regulatory meeting at the National Golf Club in Toronto.
They do own a fair proportion of TV & radio outlets and political influence but I wouldn't call it running the country.
Disclaimer: Not a conspiracy nut.
Interestingly different from the US I would say the vast majority of Canadians I knew (including my elderly parents) get their Canadian political news from print media rather than TV (acknowledging that biases towards people who attended university and live in cities) which is more for local news if anything. Canadian TV channels are very underwhelming and have no where near the relevance of CNN or Fox News to US society. I would even modestly wager that CNN has a larger Canadian viewership than Canadian news channels.
I expect a significant amount also get it from radio which from what I recall are mostly telecom owned.
It all seemed like it was to prop up Murdoch owned media.
The Australian Gov must have cut an acceptable deal with Google and Facebook though, as both threatened to do what FB has done in Canada.
There are more details to it all, I'm sure. I'd have to go research more as I dont recall them all :-)
Meta has blocked access in Canada, so I wouldn't consider it a threat anymore.
You could claim this is a negotiating tactic, but I suspect time alone will not change these policies.
Neither Google nor Facebook see significant direct value in having news links on their platform - they don't think they'll have a significant drop in user traffic from users not being able to see a few Canadian news sites.
> The analysis by the PBO, an independent body that provides economic and financial analysis to MPs and senators, concluded that newspapers and online media would get $81,550,000 a year, while broadcasters such as the CBC, Bell, Shaw and Rogers stand to get $247,677,000 if the bill becomes law.
First keep the money here, then we'll argue how to redistribute it. News is a tricky subject. In theory there are more clicks but sometimes people don't visit the site at all so it's hard to say.
If this was about diversifying communications providers I think I would side with you instead. It really depends what it is.
I would prefer my domestic companies to be in the strongest position while also allowing outside players - so a mixture. But we are hopelessly on the back leg and need a boost when it comes to funding domestic media. The solution can't be to just outsource everything because there's no way to win against Meta and Google.
For the news source I go to, this means they're pretty reliable and honest - and not so prone to lying or deception. I mean at the end of the day people are people, and different agencies will have some bias, so I check across a bunch. And I avoid anything owned by Rupert Murdoch, as that drives down the quality by a lot. APTN for instance is good, and honestly so is Al Jazeera USA. I've liked CBC, and between the different programs they're pretty good at calling out political bias - especially about their own. (the actual news news on CBC has some center-right bias towards either Liberal or Conservative parties - and will occasionally even air "official lies". Their long form shows on the other hand are much better and will catch out those "official lies". Canada is complicated in its own way).
It's part Canadian protectionism and part desperate ploy to prop up a few large failed media business models.
Canada has a long history of protectionist measures. The shocking part of the bill is the way it exposes the complete technical incompetence of the government. There are many ways to extract a pound of flesh, implementing your tax in a way that is fundamentally incompatible with the web is inexcusable. It will hurt Canada's efforts to be a tech leader.
Cheering on Facebook is cheering against your own interests.
Companies need to learn that they play in and extract resources from our sandbox.
If they want to continue to play in our sandbox, they need to play by our rules. They need to act in a socially responsible way. There are even laws about corporate governance pertaining to this.
You don't have to agree with Canada's laws (I don't), but you do need to recognise that they are their laws. Being hostile like this is a good way to make enemies.
"I, [name], do swear that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth the Second, Queen of Canada, Her Heirs and Successors. So help me God."
> Governments are for the people by the people.
> Cheering on Facebook is cheering against your own interests.
This is so exceedingly broken that I don't even know where to begin. You really can't envision any situation where a government might do something that is hostile to both a big company and "the people"? Where the government might make a decision that benefits a small set of companies at the expense of other companies and consumers in general?
I guess Canada's politicians weren't sociopathic enough to think of such a thing.
The Canadian media is almost universally right wing. Helping these outlets survive is almost certainly against the governing parties interest.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/science/meta-instagram-canada-online...
This isn’t an ideal solution, it’s basically a subsidy that big tech is supposed to pay for, but there is a massive, massive! power imbalance where the platforms are the only winners, so it’s also not the worst rule ever. I don’t know. The overwhelming power imbalance of oligopoly platforms is a thing, I’m not sure what to do about it. The issue is bigger than just news, and this law only partially addresses one aspect of the situation
Google and Facebook have syphoned off a lot of advertising income from these big publishers and they are leveraging their political clout to make politicians pass laws that have nothing to do with journalism and everything to do with serving the special interests of a few powerful publishers.
Yes the fact that too much money stays with Google and Facebook rather than funding serious journalism is a problem. But these laws are not supposed to fix that and they are not fixing it. It's just corruption.
The dispute is just which authority decides what you get to share with your friends and contacts - not that you should be allowed to do so freely.
Yes, owners and creators of Canadian media content. For Canadians.
From TFA:
> The Internet platforms are losers as they comply with an unreasonable law by removing links and making their services objectively worse in order to do so. Individual Canadians who use the platforms to find links to news are losers since news links will be blocked from the platform. And the government is a loser, as having dismissed critics and ignored repeated warnings about the risks associated with its bill, it has now left Canada as the global example of digital policy disastrously gone wrong.
i) I accept what Geist asserts, that the US social media business will be worse without Canadian news. Having Canadian news content in these billion-dollar US companies' products should not be free for these companies.
ii) Canadian media must do better for Canadians. Canadian news is not US news.
iii) US media companies don't want to start paying US journalism either. Rich US companies are fighting to resist the precedent that this law set in Australia and will set in Canada.
I listened to a statement on Front Burner the other day where some facebook homunculus said they are "ending access to news in Canada," which brought forth a real guffaw. I listened to the news yesterday while working in the yard on an AM radio. The only delusion here is on Facebook's part, where they think they are punishing us by removing their heavily-filtered hate machine from our media pool.
They believe they have "captured" our ability to find the news. Anyone who pays attention knows what kind of crap they've been pulling on media outlets since the start, and I frankly don't care that it's Rupert Murdoch benefitting here - better him than Zuck, because we have had Murdoch for half my life and things didn't get really bad till Facebook.
ANYTHING that gets their hands off the media is a good thing.
Social media as a profit center is a failed experiment and it must be dismantled (simple news delivery or not) - distributed communities will make a return as it should be.
I respect your opinion, but to me the situation is more akin to a random algorithm distributing a whole manner of both healthy and junk foods together with no labels. Now we're worried about that the people will no longer know how to get food at all, or that it'll all be junk.
Facebook helped create that problem (accident or not) and that now needs to be undone - staying the course is not a preferable solution. The news outlets also deserve a chance to deliver directly to their readers and viewers - if they're no better off financially that's there problem.
Do they? Or are they simply making the most logical business decision for them? If it costs Facebook more to allow links than it does to not allow links, why should they allow them? Is Facebook really made that much of a better product with the inclusion of news?
Those are gone now. I used to think like you. I'm not a big social media user and it's easy to think of social media as a cesspool of clickbait and rage, but now that Meta has pulled even the pages of these outlets I realized that I'm suddenly not getting severe weather alerts and updates on local events that I was used to getting from a particular small indie outlet. How exactly was Facebook hurting that indie outlet by giving them a platform and free traffic?
Our governments are constantly looking for new ways to shovel money to the big telecom companies (and to protect them from competition), and it needs to be meet more resistance. For those not aware, the PBO analysis showed that the primary beneficiaries of this bill were to be Bell, Rogers, Shaw, and some CBC.
But even if that were not the case, this bill simply makes no sense, and could do a lot of harm.