News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by vessenes on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:16PM (#36988767)
Pretty sophisticated attack vector: low voltage attack on AMD secure execution environment during boot. I wonder how many tries you need to get whatever bits you need in the right place. Also, I imagine you only need to cut 12V wires to do this, but I admire the willingness to get in there direct on these systems. I'd be a little nervous to make those cuts personally.

Buried in the article is the claim that this will let them pull the RSA private key the car owns out for other uses -- while this is likely to remain a very niche attack vector, that's got to be really bad news for someone in vehicle security at Tesla. On the other hand, post jailbreak you could anonymize your location on Tesla's servers, which would be nice.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by striking on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:41PM (#36989128)
> I wonder how many tries you need to get whatever bits you need in the right place.

For the Xbox 360, the "Reset Glitch Hack" (which worked similarly) would just try over and over again until it got it right. A computer is happy to try tens or hundreds of times on your behalf.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by jsheard on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:01PM (#36989402)
However the next Xbox added active countermeasures against glitching attacks which force a reboot if the clocks, temperatures or voltages go outside of reasonable bounds, and that's never been defeated. Glitching attacks can be very powerful, but they have a limited shelf life if the hardware manufacturer cares to prevent them.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7VwtOrwceo

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by striking on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:25PM (#36989717)
Definitely. Not arguing that this can't be fixed, but rather outlining how a similar successful attack was made more reproducible.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by judge2020 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:23PM (#36988871)
Anonymizing your location - until you put in route and your car asks for traffic information from teslas servers.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by d4l3k on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:42PM (#36989138)
If the map can't talk to Tesla it'll use Google maps directly. I usually don't allow connections to Tesla on my rooted Model 3
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by adamgamble on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:51PM (#36989280)
I also would like to subscribe to your newsletter.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by d4l3k on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:55PM (#36989329)
I've got a blog if you're interested haha https://fn.lc/post/

I've been hacking on my car and creating my own self driving models

Code is at https://github.com/d4l3k/torchdrive

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by seanthemon on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:27PM (#36989737)
Very cool, am going to eat this up. FYI some of your images won't load for me, shoots me a 502 here https://fn.lc/post/diy-self-driving/
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by d4l3k on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:16PM (#36991191)
Not sure why they aren't loading, seem to be fine now

They're also at https://github.com/d4l3k/fn.lc/tree/master/static%2Fdiy-self...

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by acer589 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:41PM (#36993071)
Is that legal?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by kortilla on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:25PM (#36994288)
Is getting married at 15 in Georgia?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by zoover2020 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:44PM (#36989186)
Hoe did you root yours? Did you lose out on any functionality?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by d4l3k on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:59PM (#36989382)
There's some functionality loss but it's mostly been mitigated. I have a custom app I wrote since I can't use the stock app.

The one feature I miss is that there's no voice commands since that requires Tesla's servers but at the same time I also haven't been bothered enough to plug in a custom backend

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by lrem on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:08PM (#36989500)
wait

So the company that goes "we don't need physical buttons since we have voice commands" also goes "you don't need those in underground parkings"?!

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by majikandy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:25PM (#36992904)
It’s ok, the voice commands are barely understood anyway. At least in the UK they aren’t. Gets it drastically wrong and messes up your navigation destination, because you asked it to open the glovebox “navigating to Columbia”
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by malwrar on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:55PM (#36990124)
How does this work with their charging network? Are you still able to use their chargers, or are you stuck with home charging & third parties?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by d4l3k on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:15PM (#36991167)
Supercharger auth is between the car and the charger and doesn't require an internet connection. I get billed the normal way via my Tesla account since the VIN is registered
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by wholinator2 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:43PM (#36991563)
Oh no, don't give them ideas. It'll become the HP instant ink of car charging
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by nikau on Friday August 04, 2023 @11:37AM (#37001483)
Your L2 charging wire is low on copper, please replace the entire cable.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by judge2020 on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:02AM (#36995672)
Are there api keys for google maps in the car? Or does it emulate some client like a browser or android phone?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by FirmwareBurner on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:30PM (#36988959)
>that's got to be really bad news for someone in vehicle security at Tesla.

It says in the article: "Generally, these exploits are shared with Tesla, and it helps the automaker secure its systems."

So it's only a matter of time till Tesla patches it.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by capableweb on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:33PM (#36989001)
More relevant quotes from the article:

> The group of hackers claims that their “Tesla Jailbreak” is “unpatchable” and allows to run “arbitrary software on the infotainment.”

And the full quote of what you put:

> Electrek’s Take

> Generally, these exploits are shared with Tesla, and it helps the automaker secure its systems.

> In this case, the hackers said that despite the exploit, they believe Tesla’s security is better than other automakers.

Doesn't seem like the security researchers actually shared the exploit with Tesla, at least as far as I understand.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by kelnos on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:55PM (#36989321)
The information in this article alone is likely enough for some Tesla engineers to sit down and figure out the exploit themselves.

And if this research group wants to enable regular people to "jailbreak" their cars, they have to publish their full methodology anyway.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by vorticalbox on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:57PM (#36989350)
That's likely because it's a hardware issue, nothing really for tesla to do.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bumby on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:24PM (#36989687)
Apologize for my ignorance, but isn't it up to Tesla to define what hardware they want to integrate? Or is there no design alternative?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by avrionov on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:34PM (#36989830)
What they meant is that it is not possible to fix it without replacing the hardware.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bumby on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:08PM (#36991955)
I see. But replacing the hardware would still be very much in the purview of "Tesla's problem" if you think they are a car manufacturer.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by filoleg on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:29PM (#36995162)
Yes, but it is unpatchable for any currently existing cars on the road, I believe that's the point they were trying to articulate (though not super well).

And yeah, you are correct, Tesla can close up that exploit in their newer hardware revisions.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by pitched on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:38PM (#36989891)
Changing hardware would mean a recall and this doesn’t seem to warrant it.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by Knee_Pain on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:46PM (#36990002)
But how much time until the hardware is changed? And all the current models?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by neuralzen on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:24PM (#36994284)
They will share the details at Blackhat next week
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by denysvitali on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:33PM (#36989009)
Although this seems unpatchable without an HW upgrade
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by samstave on Thursday August 03, 2023 @01:40PM (#36989105)
On the black-hat-flip-side ; This is exactly what a Black Hat would want to say - preventing from Tesla stating that they "aint got shit" from the hackers...

So hackers can claim they called tesla, and tesla can ignore it and we no wiser

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by mgiampapa on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:24PM (#36989695)
Just like we used to have cable box guys willing to sell you an unlocked box for premium channels, we are eventually going to have feature unlock guys that you go do and for a small fee perform some slightly more technical hack to enable features that are already there.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by technothrasher on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:28PM (#36989751)
This market already exists for things like enabling Navigation on VW/Audi cars. People were offering to enable the hidden Android Auto support on my Porsche Macan for $600, which I almost went for until I found the scripts and instructions to do it myself.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by jxf on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:41PM (#36989930)
Hidden as in it's not available normally, or hidden as in it's a paid feature?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by avree on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:02PM (#36990242)
It was built, and then disabled, as Porsche wasn't comfortable with Google's policies around data collection from Android Auto. You can pretty easily figure out how to turn it back on.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by mgiampapa on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:44PM (#36989957)
I did the same on a Mazda CX5 a few years back, but it was a software only hack to get root first. I suspect the actual physical hardware modification line is the one that most users are going to be unwilling to cross unless they are in the "Download a Car" crowd.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by littlestymaar on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:41PM (#36990742)
> I suspect the actual physical hardware modification line is the one that most users are going to be unwilling to cross unless they are in the "Download a Car" crowd.

Idk, hardware modification of the first Playstation that allowed to play ripped games became mainstream very quickly in my country (France) and you could even go to some shops that sold Playstations to get it done. It only stopped when it was made openly illegal.

“I paid for this shit, I do what I want with it” is a very powerful sentiment (and a legitimate one actually: corporation adding “Digital Right Management” system to deprive people from their property right is dystopian as hell).

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by acer589 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:38PM (#36993044)
Okay, but in that PlayStation example you DIDN'T pay for the games, but still decided to 'do what you want'. How is that legitimate but attempting to prevent it not?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by filoleg on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:43PM (#36994856)
Because you also prevent legitimate uses of such "feature", such as playing games you purchased legitimately from other regions, as that "feature" also allows to defeat region-locking. As for why not just buy those same game versions released in your region, some games were just never released in some regions. Another common use is running legitimate homebrew software.

So logically, it isn't modding/unlocking the console itself that's illegitimate. But it can be used for certain illegitimate actions, yes (along with legitimate ones).

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by littlestymaar on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:03AM (#36996899)
This, or you want to have a backup of your disk because your younger brother isn't especially gentle, or you want to have a second copy of your game so that you can have one at Dad's home and one at Mom's.

And these use-cases aren't only legitimate, in France they are even legal and in exchange we pay a tax whenever we buy a media storage device (Taxe sur la copie privée).

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by WarOnPrivacy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:30PM (#36993920)
> hardware modification of the first Playstation that allowed to play ripped games became mainstream very quickly

I remember this. Chip on chip iirc. The period is stored in my memory because it was also when DVD media first broke the $1/disc barrier. It wasn't very good media at $1 per but exciting times nonetheless.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by hunter2_ on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:07PM (#36994594)
By the time I got around to booting "backup" discs in that system, it could be done just with a dongle (like a GameShark type thing, maybe? Can't remember) although unlike a soldered-in mod chip, it required booting with any genuine game and quickly swapping to any copy of another game, using a spring to defeat the lid sensor thus avoiding a subsequent check for a genuine disc.

Not quite as convenient, but lack of invasive mod was the tradeoff.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by harshalizee on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:23PM (#36990507)
Doesn't the Mazda CX-5s all ship with Android Auto and Apple Carplay by default?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by mgiampapa on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:34PM (#36993501)
2016 Didn't, I also enabled the built in navigation while I was at it.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by BonoboIO on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:11PM (#36990360)
$600 is not cheap. What model year do you have? Does Porsche not provide an update or possibility to upgrade.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by fragmede on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:53PM (#36990900)
If you're in the market for a recent Porsche, which go for let's say ~$100k, $600 is cheap to you. Cheaper than the time you'd spend on doing it yourself really, but doing it yourself is half the fun.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by mrguyorama on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:33PM (#36991414)
If $600 is something you have to think about, you should never own a Porsche.

If you can't afford to maintain an expensive car, you can't afford to purchase an expensive car.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by WarOnPrivacy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:32PM (#36993932)
> If you can't afford to maintain an expensive car, you can't afford to purchase an expensive car.

Depends on how you acquire it. I can get a couple BMW's for cheap to free but I've heard too many repair stories around the campfile to blind dive into that particular rabbit hole.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by robterrell on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:52PM (#36990886)
This is how I got CarPlay on the used BMW I bought. Gave some guy in Thailand my VIN and $60, he sent me firmware to install, and now I drive around with working CarPlay and the vague notion that I've maybe been p0wned in ways I don't fully understand.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by knodi123 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:14PM (#36991163)
When your car idles, it's contributing to his Folding@Home account rank
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by TedDoesntTalk on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:41PM (#36991526)
More likely it’s mining crypto.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by jjkaczor on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:43PM (#36991552)
Heh... or mining coins... or these days, factoring LLM's...
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by tmpX7dMeXU on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:49PM (#36993147)
Simpler times.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by nobleach on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:54PM (#36992540)
Wait, CarPlay is a "premium" feature on a BMW?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by greenthrow on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:51PM (#36993167)
On older models. Current models come with it.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by filoleg on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:39PM (#36994817)
Current ones instead charge you a recurring subscription for seat heating, right?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by no_wizard on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:05PM (#36990281)
The only hack on cable style TV I remember is you could buy modified satellite authentication cards for DirectTV for a time - usually on eBay or similar sites - and they worked. No idea how long, I had an uncle that had one though, got all the premium channels etc.

I doubt any of this works anymore though

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by fragmede on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:58PM (#36990964)
If you want a rabbit hole, start with Christopher Tarnovsky at Defcon https://www.wired.com/2008/05/tarnovsky/
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by darkclouds on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:57PM (#36991771)
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bonestamp2 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:05PM (#36991900)
I remember being out for a beer run with a friend during these days. On the way there he pulls into a parking lot and stops in front of a nail salon. He said, "Come on" and I followed him into the nail salon. There were about 10 women in there, not a guy in sight... he goes up to the desk and pushes a button that looks like a doorbell.

One of the ladies doing the nails says, "He no work here no more, check dry cleaner across the street." We get back in the car and I'm like, "What was that all about?". "My DirecTV card got disabled and that's where I get it reprogrammed".

We go across the street to the Dry Cleaners. There are three ladies in the lobby watching TV, and a guy behind the counter. He asks the man, "Is Ken here?" The man says, "I'll check" as he walks into the back. Now, the man was coming from the back when we came in, so I assume he already knows if Ken is there or not, but Ken probably only comes out if he recognizes my friend.

Sure enough, Ken comes right out all smiles and they have a quick chat. My friend hands over his card and Ken says, "we had to get new equipment, it's now $100, ATM next door".

Ken disappears for about 10 minutes and comes back. My friend gives him cash and away we went. About 4 months later, he had to get it reprogrammed again.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by tmpX7dMeXU on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:52PM (#36993182)
That guy’s name? Jimmy McGill.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bonestamp2 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:17PM (#36993387)
No, it's all good man. ;)
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by Biganon on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:12PM (#36993818)
Why did you take the car to cross the road?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bonestamp2 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:41PM (#36994015)
It's a big busy road with a median in the middle. There were no crosswalks nearby, and we had to go back that direction anyway. Why do you ask?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by kortilla on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:21PM (#36994261)
This is America
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by toKillTheChick on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:31AM (#36995499)
To get to the other side...
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by nobleach on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:00PM (#36992628)
I worked for a cable company in the mid-90s. The amount of boxes that disappeared (and couldn't be located) was insane. The folks that procured them also used a "bullet blocker" (basically a resistor) to avoid the box being disabled.

In the satellite realm, DishNetwork was always the easier service to hack. The FTA scene was completely overrun with folks buying 3rd party tuners. Once Dish switched to an encrypted signal, a few vendors (nFusion if I recall) even could rotate keys in a matter of hours to decrypt Dish's new encryption schemes. I doubt any of that works these days simply because there's no reason to push too hard for content that is likely available via easier means.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by jandrese on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:04PM (#36993298)
I read an article about the early DirecTV hacking days and the cat and mouse game the hackers played with the company. DirecT cards were smart cards that ran programs for the decryption path. The hackers kept just duplicating whatever DirecTV sent down to keep them workign, mystery bits and all. Then one day a final update came out and those weird bits turned out to be a specially designed program that bricked all of the hacked cards. I'm sure that was a temporary setback for the hackers but it was a great story.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by kortilla on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:22PM (#36994275)
Didn’t this happen recently with a usb to serial port vendor or something like that? Vendor released a new driver that bricked all of the knockoff ones…
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by yjftsjthsd-h on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:53PM (#36995297)
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by rebolek on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:12PM (#36990380)
Let me tell you what's wrong with this:

Nothing.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by kevincox on Friday August 04, 2023 @08:40AM (#36999146)
I think it is slightly more complicated than this. Removing these "artificial" locks raises the price of the base model. This can lead to people on a tighter budget from being able to afford it at all.

For this particular instance I don't feel too bad for a number of reasons:

1. Tesla is a luxury product so people on a tight budget will likely find a better value solution elsewhere.

2. The way these locks are implemented greatly restricts user freedom on the whole car so they see somewhat unethical to me.

But in general I believe that making one model and artificially locking it can be ethical. It is just taking advantage of economy of scale (by only making one model) without removing your base price point.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bri3d on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:25PM (#36991299)
This has already been the case on European navigation systems (Audi and VW MMI/MIB) for many years now.

VW Audi Group developed an entire infrastructure called SWaP (Software as a Product) and FEC (Feature Enable Codes) many years ago, and ever since, there has been a cottage industry in bypassing the system to enable features like CarPlay, Navigation, and Performance Monitor which are usually locked by software trim levels.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by hunter2_ on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:29PM (#36995158)
It's always awesome seeing your comments about VW stuff. I've been using VCDS over 10 years now with nothing but various trims of Golfs for even longer than that. Luckily my Mk7 R came with all the FECs I'd ever want, stock! The secret menu doesn't show anything interesting in the diff between supported and installed.

Do you think there will ever be "off the shelf" / "staged" tunes maintained as open source projects for all the common cars, maybe not quite as user-friendly as the Cobb ecosystem and the like, but good enough to make $600+ tunes a thing of the past for DIY types who are into mucking about but want the peace of mind that comes with using maps that enough other people are already using? Not that tuners shouldn't be paid for their work, but I feel like they could focus on the custom tune segment and be ok.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bri3d on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:09PM (#37004426)
All of the tools needed to do this are already there. However, maintaining this kind of project would be a thankless task riddled with bad users, regulatory/legal issues, and isn't likely to build a strong community for various reasons, so I don't think anyone has been highly incentivized to do it.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by mrguyorama on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:32PM (#36991401)
Internal employee controls have gotten way more sophisticated, and cared about since it's one of the things you need to do for business focused information security.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by Prickle on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:35PM (#36991452)
This is true, but if I remember correctly, Apple has a very similar issue with user locked devices.

Employees have opened their own "stores", where they remove activation locks, or unlock iphones remotely for a small fee.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bonestamp2 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:51PM (#36991682)
Be careful though, some automakers are tracking software mods and voiding warranties. Example: https://www.motorbiscuit.com/beware-dodge-challenger-mods-do...
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by Faaak on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:06PM (#36992696)
I don't think how that could work with the Magnuson–Moss Warranty Act ?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bonestamp2 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:38PM (#36993037)
* * *
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by rconti on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:08PM (#36994599)
One advantage of having blown through the warranty on my Tesla already!

On the other hand, I don't think my car has any unlocked features I want. I mean, I didn't pay for FSD / Autopilot but I'm not sure I'd use either.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by awad on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:08PM (#36991950)
Mod chips for consoles and mod chips for cars don't seem too dissimilar
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by sleepybrett on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:10PM (#36991982)
I had a friend that made a tidy sum in college by selling replacement chips for high end cars that overrode some governors built into the firmware.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by berniedurfee on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:57PM (#36993239)
And gray market chips you could swap into your US Robotics Sportster modem for dual standard 56k baud compatibility!
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by progman32 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:05PM (#36994167)
I unlocked a whole extra gallon on my i3's fuel tank (just about doubling its capacity) just by poking it with a computer, there's definitely people around willing to pay for this service.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by throwaway894589 on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:20PM (#37004586)
This is because if the gas range was longer than the EV range it wouldn't qualify for the US federal EV tax rebate so BMW software limited the range. In europe it's not limited.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by klysm on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:29PM (#36989767)
I don’t understand how you can defend against low voltage attacks like this.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by jsheard on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:31PM (#36989793)
The Xbox 360 was broken by voltage glitching, and Microsoft succesfully prevented it from happening again with the Xbox One. It's covered in their security deep dive: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7VwtOrwceo

In short, there's a hardware watchdog which reboots the system if anything weird happens with the clocks/temps/voltages, and they audited their bootloader to ensure that even if you somehow manage to sneak one glitch past the watchdog, no single branch condition being inverted will lead to a compromised state.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by 14 on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:09AM (#36995389)
That is really cool. I personally installed the reset glitch hack on several Xbox 360. Immediately thought about that when seeing this article on the Tesla
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by weebull on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:40PM (#36990734)
Make sure all security critical state is initialised to known values at reset, then have very tight tolerances on your power watchdog to initiate reset.

However, that doesn't make for a stable system when powered from batteries.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by ddalex on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:32PM (#36989813)
> you could anonymize your location on Tesla's servers

I already anonymise my location on Tesla's servers by simply not owning a Tesla

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by moffkalast on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:40PM (#36989913)
Ah, but where's the challenge in that?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by coolspot on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:48PM (#36990031)
Your car is filmed and recognized by other teslas.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by jcuenod on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:03PM (#36990253)
That's why I also rotate license plates and repaint my car twice a year.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by zapdrive on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:10PM (#36990351)
I also change my facial hair style 4 times a year. Will start getting plastic surgery twice a year starting next year.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by 867-5309 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:42PM (#36990751)
sounds like a slippery slope to voluntary hip surgery for gait correction
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by cool_dude85 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:22PM (#36991256)
I always wondered if this could be beat by putting a pebble in your shoe or something.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by fleshdaddy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:20PM (#36992852)
It’s been a long time since I read it but I think that’s exactly how it was beat in Cory Doctorow’s novel Little Brother.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by silisili on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:42PM (#36991541)
Not sure if it's changed now, but just wearing flip flops used to defeat gait recognition...
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by wongarsu on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:30PM (#36990612)
Against face recognition you could use CV dazzle makeup [1] to look less like a face. However I wouldn't recommend using that approach for your vehicle

1 https://dangerousminds.net/comments/foil_facebooks_facial_re...

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by fho on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:48PM (#36990826)
I think that's actually quite common on new car models. The dazzle paint job makes it harder for the press to see the shape.

E.g.: https://www.bmw.com/en/automotive-life/prototype-cars.html

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by zapdrive on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:56PM (#36990932)
I don't want my car "harder to see" going at 100 miles down the highway.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by myself248 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:30PM (#36991374)
Oh no, it's super easy to see, just harder to tell if it's a coupe or a sedan or whatever. New lines in the body panels get drowned out by the pattern, etc.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by ukd1 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:15PM (#36992061)
I always wondered if this still worked with a IR/UV camera too...?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by rascul on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:49PM (#36992482)
I vaguely recall reading (probably in the book All Corvettes Are Red) that the C5 Corvette was driven around with Camaro body panels to fool the media.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by vondur on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:15PM (#36991165)
I wonder how the face painting antics of Death Metal bands would hold up to face recognition software?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by Accacin on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:56PM (#36992563)
Sorry for being pedantic, but it's usually Black Metal bands that wear the face paint that you're thinking of :)
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by mcbuilder on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:26PM (#36990554)
I just inked an adversarial CV tattoo onto my face, worked great until that image leaked into the training data.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by zapdrive on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:57PM (#36990952)
Should have tattooed a QR code that auto downloads a malware that bricks A100s.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by jancsika on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:57PM (#36990948)
That's why I wear an rpi connected to four lcd's on my face that display randomly chosen beard tiles.

It's also why I started Our Lady of the Anonymity Pool where we gather for music and fellowship, and to recharge and distribute beard screens to our congregants and visitors.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by alinaval on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:22PM (#36992147)
Phillip K Dick imagined a "scramble suit" that did just that in a Scanner Darkly, continuously randomizing the users facial features.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by Jerrrry on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:38PM (#36995217)
This is currently possible in real time on consumer mobile hardware, looks neat
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by brenainn on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:50AM (#36996800)
The film has a good representation of it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2aS4xhTaIPc
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by knodi123 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:13PM (#36991147)
That's why my license plate is shaped like 3 different light bulbs, and is hidden in a grid of light bulb shaped objects.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by zoky on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:50PM (#36992489)
Oh hey, I just did your license plate as a CAPTCHA!
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by culi on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:40PM (#36991516)
you're joking, but there's a whole genre of "adversarial fashion"[0] dedicated to making clothing that spams these sort of public data recognition services. Hoodies with license plates, face masks with weird facial features, etc. Often optimized against actual neural networks too

[0] https://adversarialfashion.com/

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by syx on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:38PM (#36992332)
That’s really cool, I wonder effective these designs really are! This reminds me of a font that came out 10 years ago ZXX [1] that was presumably designed to hide from OCRs.

[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/zxx-fonts-that-google-cant-r...

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by JohnBooty on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:40PM (#36992363)
This is awesome, and thanks for posting this. I had no idea.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by pests on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:05PM (#36992679)
Gait detection renders any of this obsolute sadly.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by berniedurfee on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:50PM (#36993162)
Something something silly walks
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by squarefoot on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:10PM (#36993342)
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by downWidOutaFite on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:06PM (#36993308)
Luckily my gait is not in an adtech company's database and sold to the government, like my face probably is.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bbarnett on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:28AM (#36996167)
How do you know?

ID phone Bluetooth on passing, or even facial rec, then it gets tied to gait, and it's forever tied.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by froggit on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:58PM (#37004292)
Just keep your phone down in your third pant leg instead of using a rock.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by kibwen on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:08PM (#36993326)
If you're willing to go to the lengths of adversarial fashion, you're probably also willing to walk around with a stone in your shoe, or in high heels.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bbarnett on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:26AM (#36996144)
Pfft. Stilts, 10 footers, that's the key.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by cosmojg on Sunday August 06, 2023 @09:17PM (#37028805)
Or dance like you've never danced before: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R46cX0AjzT4
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by gonzo41 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:40PM (#36993561)
And cost at scale renders gait detection detection and most face detection at scale useless. The sexy movie detection methods all suck.

Go with what works. Just id people via their phones with a dirtbox.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by xattt on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:04PM (#36993756)
A third pant leg sown on one side with a rock on the bottom will (probably) throw off some algos.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by blackrobot on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:42PM (#36994020)
This is a good idea! https://youtu.be/BNhriA2xq9E
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by froggit on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:55PM (#37004240)
And set off hella red flags for everything else (probably wouldn't be too much of a problem if you just say "it's to foil gait detection" when you get interrogated about your third leg. people tend to be cool with all kinds of weird shit as long as it's for a reason). Could maybe work if gait detection is the only adversary in your life for sure.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by paradox460 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:14PM (#36993830)
Put different insoles in your shoe every day
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by rasz on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:35AM (#36997589)
gait analysis is up there with bite marks(https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/apr/28/forensics-bi... )/jeans wear marks(https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1917222117) and other FBI post hoc ergo propter hoc fraud.

If it worked this would be a solved case https://www.fbi.gov/contact-us/field-offices/washingtondc/ne...

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by culi on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:09PM (#37001929)
snake oil
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by jliptzin on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:26PM (#36993441)
I wonder how effective that is considering storage costs are very cheap and an AI can easily filter out images that are either “car” or “not car”
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by john_the_writer on Friday August 04, 2023 @08:00AM (#36998742)
Not hotdog?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by steve_adams_86 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:36PM (#36995209)
This made me realize that recent openAI tech is able to cut through misleading or confusing images, even finding the potentially inferred humour or absurdity layered in the images. I wonder how we’ll find a way to trick that kind of technology as well.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by rapnie on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:31AM (#36996640)
This is really cool. Though the Capable Design site with its animations is a bit adversarial to me browsing it.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by seanmcdirmid on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:19AM (#36995767)
This is actually a common practice. Thieves will jack someone’s plates (prefer that they don’t notice) after stealing a car. It is pretty effective, since most people don’t realize their plates have been swapped until they have been pulled over for vehicle theft, so the cops aren’t even looking for the right plate for a few days, and by then they’ve already swapped again.

Better put an apple tag in your car just in case.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by rasz on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:32AM (#36997557)
You use license plates? pleb!

Why Steve Jobs Never Had License Plates on His Car https://abcnews.go.com/Technology/steve-jobs-car-apple-ceo-l...

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by gumby on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:27PM (#36990565)
This is a plausible attack vector, parallel to the profiles Facebook, Linkedin et al maintain for people who don't have accounts.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by cozzyd on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:31PM (#36990625)
fortunately I only own a bike...though maybe this makes me ineligible for some Illinois class action lawsuit...
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by EMCymatics on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:26PM (#36990546)
Yeah, how much do you trust Musk and company?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by closewith on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:01PM (#36990213)
That can't be legal? Not in the EU, anyway.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by ballenf on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:10PM (#36990344)
Are you saying dash cams are illegal broadly there?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by anamexis on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:14PM (#36990396)
In Germany, dash cams specifically are a bit of a gray area, but for example CCTV of any public areas is generally illegal.

https://europe.autonews.com/automakers/tesla-warns-its-camer...

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by someplaceguy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:45PM (#36992429)
I think EU countries are supposed to be using the same legal privacy framework, although the exact way the laws are phrased and interpreted might differ from country to country.

I believe in Spain, generally speaking, it is legal to record your interactions with someone when you are in public.

But I think many people are not aware that this is legal, including some police officers, because privacy laws are perceived to be quite strict.

Similarly, I think dashcams are actually legal, even though most police probably think they are not.

I think these recordings can even be used in court cases, and in fact in many cases it's probably the reason why they are legal, otherwise it would be hard to see a legitimate purpose that would override the privacy drawbacks.

However, there are restrictions. Indiscriminate recording (i.e. CCTV) of public areas is illegal, as in Germany. This is also true for the entrances of personal homes: you are only allowed to have CCTV outside if it's pointing directly at your door, not the street in general (and you must post a sign).

An obvious restriction is that I think you are not allowed to publish a recording without either anonymizing the people in them or getting their permission.

An interesting restriction that comes to mind is that a few years ago, there was a court case of a man who was caught filming children on a school playground while positioned outside the school, which at the time it was presumed to be for sexual purposes, I think because of the way he was doing the recording (big lenses, I think?) and because he didn't have a legitimate motive for doing that (like being the parent of one of the children, or filming a documentary, etc).

He was sentenced and received a large fine, but I think the legal reasoning was that children on a school playground are expected to have a legal right to privacy, even though it's a public school. So the judge considered it the legal equivalent of filming someone in their private home from outside.

I'm very happy for cases like these where common sense prevails over legal / ideological dogma (even though I'm also aware of the dangers it can pose when laws aren't interpreted to the letter).

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by someplaceguy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:36PM (#36993011)
> you are only allowed to have CCTV outside if it's pointing directly at your door, not the street in general (and you must post a sign).

I forgot to mentioned that I highly disagree with this restriction.

It's really, really bad for home and personal security: pointing the CCTV at your door does absolutely nothing when a robber / kidnapper enters your house while wearing a ski mask.

However, pointing the camera outside could much more easily catch them in the days previous to the crime while they were staking the house (obviously it's not very feasible to stake a house wearing a ski mask).

Or at least, it would deter them much more heavily and possibly prevent a not-insignificant proportion of serious crimes.

I am similarly an extremely big critic of self-defense laws in European countries, which basically leave you completely defenseless in your own home even if you or your family are being kidnapped, due to the huge asymmetric advantage that an attacker has over you.

Or at the very least, you risk going to jail for many years if anything goes wrong.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by gnatolf on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:16PM (#36993379)
A vast majority of kidnappings are done by family members. It's a movie thing that a ski mask vigilante enters your home to kidnap you. I'm almost 100% positive there's virtually no risk of being kidnapped at home by ski-mask wearing criminals that staked your house previously.

Or, if you are in that specific, very small target group for e.g. ransom etc, you probably should've been investing in home security beyond a front door camera anyways.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by someplaceguy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:20PM (#36993871)
> Or, if you are in that specific, very small target group for e.g. ransom etc,

I am, as are many thousands of other people, in different fields. Although some of my personal circumstances contribute to my risk being especially high, even within these fields.

> you probably should've been investing in home security beyond a front door camera anyways.

I am, to an extent that has been called unreasonable by multiple "normal" people (fortunately my closest family has always been highly supportive).

But the camera issue, gun restrictions, and strict self-defense laws in Europe are huge limitations that all contribute to vastly decreased personal security for me and my family. And I've been advised by experts in this area, so it's not like I'm setting an unreasonably high standard.

It's also a fallacy to think that there is any single set of measures that will protect you. It's not like you can just hire a bodyguard and suddenly you are safe, in fact this can make things even worse in some circumstances.

Physical security can be as much about being careful and adding security layers / friction / risk / deterrents as other forms of security such as infosec. In fact, infosec is also a part of physical security nowadays, as well as other concepts.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by hutzlibu on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:34AM (#36997140)
"gun restrictions, and strict self-defense laws in Europe are huge limitations that all contribute to vastly decreased personal security for me and my family"

Even in germany it is quite easy to legally own a gun. All you have to do is be a member of a Schützenverein ("shooting club") for some time.

What is indeed very hard, is get permission to carry a gun with you.

But your main point seems to have been about home security and having a gun in your home is very possible. Unless you live somewhere with tighter gun laws than germany?

(Also most abductions for ransom happen outside, easier to snatch someone from the road, than come into his home)

"To add to all that, attackers have a huge asymmetric advantage during an attack, as they have the surprise element."

But you can also surprise them with security, they were not aware of and after that initial attack advantage, time is on your side. (Emergency call and panic room).

"It's not like you can just hire a bodyguard and suddenly you are safe, in fact this can make things even worse in some circumstances."

Yeah, because a common bodyguard mainly creates visibility. And the best defense is to not let the attacker know you exist as a target. But there are security guards, that are not visible to the bystander.

And all in all I have to say, that you do sound quite paranoid. And I cannot think of too many professions, where that paranoia in europe is warranted and where you do not have professional security assigned to you, or where you do in fact get permission to carry a weapon. If the walls you build around you are too tight, you eventually just build your own prison.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by someplaceguy on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:48AM (#36997670)
> But your main point seems to have been about home security and having a gun in your home is very possible. Unless you live somewhere with tighter gun laws than germany?

No, you are completely right, I had forgotten about that possibility!

Indeed, my main worry with gun laws in Europe is about home security, where the advantages can outweigh the drawbacks if you have a high risk profile, not about carrying them in public which I think could lead to other problems.

The hunting guns are much better than nothing, that's for sure!

> (Also most abductions for ransom happen outside, easier to snatch someone from the road, than come into his home)

From my experience (i.e. the many cases I'm familiar with, not that I've been a victim), this is not true, although I'm also familiar with cases like you describe.

But perhaps I'm simply not familiar with the cases that you know about, or about general statistics. I'm more familiar about cases similar to my risk profile.

> But you can also surprise them with security, they were not aware of and after that initial attack advantage, time is on your side. (Emergency call and panic room).

There are scenarios of home invasion for kidnapping purposes that I'm familiar with, which have really happened in Europe not too long ago, and which are impossible to defend against without extreme measures or very significant lifestyle changes, even taking into the account what you just mentioned (which I'm obviously familiar with) but I really don't feel comfortable sharing more information.

> Yeah, because a common bodyguard mainly creates visibility.

Indeed, but even ignoring that (and the cost which is usually not a problem in these circumstances) there can also be quite a few more drawbacks that you didn't mention, but again, I don't really want to get into it.

> And the best defense is to not let the attacker know you exist as a target.

Not always possible, but completely agreed in-so-far as you can achieve that as much as possible!

I consider this to be one of the most important goals, assuming you are not a famous person already.

But even then, over the years there have been literally dozens of people who have become familiar with the riskiest part of my situation due to things that are completely outside my control, like different types of legislation which actually force me to disclose the most critical parts of my personal information to dozens of strangers for different (although usually similar) reasons.

Several databases also contain this critical information.

These strangers I mentioned are unlikely to lead to problems themselves, but information can travel easily or be leaked, and it's still an increase in risk.

> And all in all I have to say, that you do sound quite paranoid.

Yes, I'm 100% aware of that :) Don't think I haven't been told this by many people who are not entirely familiar with my situation.

That said, all of the people who have been aware of the details of my situation have shared exactly the same worries as me, and this includes people who have motivation to tell me the harsh truth rather than simply humoring me.

But of course, I try to share all of my details with as few people as possible, for obvious reasons.

In these kind of high-risk stakes, I make sure to really seek honest feedback rather than confirming my biases, because I just want to get the most useful information to make the best decisions I can, accepting that I can be very ignorant about things which I knew almost nothing about (like physical/personal security). The professionals who have assessed my situation have been really clear about all the stupid, unrealistic worries that I had, as well as all the things that I should be really worried about. They have also provided me with a numerical estimate of my personal risk (hopefully much less biased than my perceptions), along with justifications.

Yeah, I know I may be unreasonably paranoid, but on the other hand, are you really paranoid if they are really out to get you? lol!

> And I cannot think of too many professions, where that paranoia in europe is warranted and where you do not have professional security assigned to you, or where you do in fact get permission to carry a weapon.

Indeed, but there are many drawbacks to the solutions you are proposing and not many benefits in my particular situation, although I admit my situation is unusual. But really, I am already sharing more than I am comfortable with.

> If the walls you build around you are too tight, you eventually just build your own prison.

Indeed! That's why you need a good balance and accept some risk, because it's simply not possible to completely avoid it. But since I could afford to, I couldn't help but to take the most reasonable and "lowest hanging fruit" steps I could take to protect my family, under the circumstances.

Imagine not caring very much and then something really bad happens to your child or spouse, how would you feel?

Now, I can at least say that I did put a lot of effort into it, so even if something bad happens, it will be much, much easier for me to accept that the circumstances were simply outside my control.

This actually touches on something I was told by the security professionals I mentioned: some (although very few) of the security measures we've decided to take don't actually provide a meaningful amount of security, but even a tiny incremental improvement disproportionately contributed to us becoming more worry-free / experiencing greater piece of mind and being happier (but of course, this only works if it doesn't continuously affect your quality of life).

And the other thing to mention is that no matter what you do, some things are simply outside your control, so there's no point in obsessing over them, it's just something you have to accept. I think we have been extremely good in this area.

So I am happy to report that after the initial effort was finished (which lasted a few months), we have been able to live with a lot less worries and almost no decrease in quality of life for quite a few years already :)

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by hutzlibu on Friday August 04, 2023 @07:13AM (#36998317)
""Yeah, because a common bodyguard mainly creates visibility."

Indeed, but even ignoring that (and the cost which is usually not a problem in these circumstances) there can also be quite a few more drawbacks that you didn't mention, but again, I don't really want to get into it."

I actually worked a bit in security and so I can tell that some of the other disadvantages are, that most security guys are treated badly, get very lowly paid and their morals are low - so their motivation to potentially sell you out (or not wake up when you need them) is actually quite high. Some high profile companies might be different, but I know I would not trust a common security company with anything (And the company that I worked for had a good reputation and was involved with securing government buildings, but I was a bit shocked to look behind the facade, it all only works, because most criminals are unprofessional as well)

Otherwise you do sound reasonable that you take the appropriate steps, but like you said, it is all about the right balance and yes, you have to accept some risk in life.

But of course, now I am really curious about your risk profile. Seems to be quite an unusual one.. but I can understand, that you don't want to share details. Because unlike often cited here, Security through obscurity is a real thing.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by singpolyma3 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:55PM (#36993679)
CCTV's only purpose for home security is for possible intruder to see it and decide to not intrude. If they come in and you get them in vidi then what? Who will you show it to? Police? What are they going to do?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by someplaceguy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:26PM (#36993902)
> CCTV's only purpose for home security is for possible intruder to see it and decide to not intrude. If they come in and you get them in vidi then what?

If your CCTV can only film inside your house, it will not be able to record the identity of a sophisticated attacker.

> If they come in and you get them in vidi then what? Who will you show it to? Police? What are they going to do?

If you are able to record their identity (this is much more likely if you can film outside your house, within an area they would use to stake it), then there are several advantages:

1. Even if you are kidnapped or your house is robbed, it is more likely that the attacker's identity will be recognized, either during this attack, before another attack or even after they are caught in another attack, which would help to increase their sentences.

The chance this will help stop the current attack is minor, although not impossible if law enforcement acts in an expertly fashion (huge "if", I know).

2. For the same reasons above, it is also a huge deterrent, as it greatly increases the risk of the attack (for the attackers, of course), so it also helps to prevent you from being attacked.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by chemmail on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:36PM (#36993017)
Not to worry, chinese made cams broadcast everything for everyone on the internet to see. Nothing closed circuit about that!
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by closewith on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:13PM (#36990387)
Dash cams are much more tightly regulated in the EU than elsewhere (you become a Data Processor and have all the responsibilities that comes with that).

Private ANPR in public spaces is unlawful in I think every EU state?

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by liber8 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:24PM (#36990532)
Coming from an American perspective (where, when you are in public, you have basically no expectation of privacy), this seems insane.

Does this mean that if I'm filming a vlog at Brandenburg Gate (which inevitably includes video of other people in the background enjoying the area), I'm in violation of privacy laws?

Does that mean if I take a video selfie of me and my family members (which, again, includes images of others in the background, and which is automatically uploaded to icloud) I'm a data processor and am in violation of privacy laws?

I assume there is some line here, but I can't think of the logic separating a person's dashcam from my examples?

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by littlestymaar on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:37PM (#36990687)
> Does this mean that if I'm filing a vlog at Brandenburg Gate (which inevitably includes video of other people in the background enjoying the area), I'm in violation of privacy laws?

No (at least not in France, which also has pretty stringent privacy policy so I think it's still a relevant answer) you can film people or cars in public streets but you cannot do any kind of data processing on the things you film (you can't keep a database with the license plates you have on your personal videos for instance).

In short the line is: pictures and films by themselves are OK [1], but doing anything with the personal info you get from those video is forbidden.

[1]: (under conditions, you must not cause harm in the process: for instance no “happy slapping” videos)

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by monksy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:43PM (#36990772)
There are differences between private photographs and commerical products.

Vlog/youtube would be considered to be potentially commerical .. so you would probably be responsible fore GDPR and likeness recording. (The onious is on you to blur)

Video selfie/photograph personal/non shared use - you're free do this

https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/photography-laws-germany

I am not a lawyer, nor is this legal advice.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by klausa on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:50PM (#36990863)
Broadly speaking the line is: someone in the background, appearing briefly: fine.

Taking photos of specific people in public without their consent: not fine.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by codedokode on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:47PM (#36991613)
> Does this mean that if I'm filming a vlog at Brandenburg Gate (which inevitably includes video of other people in the background enjoying the area),

I don't know about the law in Germany but I think it is very impolite in any country. You should ask people's permission before putting them online. On Japanese TV they blur out faces of people passing by for example when filming an interview in the street.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by closewith on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:02PM (#36991845)
As other have pointed out, the rules on photography vary from country to country within the bloc. However, the rules governing data protection and the processing of personal data (including photos) come from the GDPR, and very basically say that any processing of personal data requires a valid legal basis.

There is an exception for personal use - the household exemption - but as soon as you cross the line into commercial operations or certain activities such as publishing, creating databases, etc, you lose the benefit of that exception.

That doesn't mean you can't continue, just that you now need a legal basis and need to follow the rules (inform data subjects, allow the right to be forgotten, etc).

So in general, dashcams are fine (unless a local law prohibits them) as you have a legitimate interest in recording your driving in case of an accident. Creating a facial recognition or ANPR database with the same footage would be unlawful, however.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by ukd1 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:18PM (#36992096)
Why is A[LN]PR unlawful for private citizens to perform on their own footage? (e.g. using https://www.openalpr.com)
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by closewith on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:38PM (#36992328)
It's unlawful as it means you lose the household exemption, and so need a legal basis for the processing. You also need to inform others of the data collection in advance, the purpose for which the data is collected, and the contact details of the data controller.

Private ANPR-equipped vehicles are rare (and outright illegal in some EU states), but when you see them they'll have large decals with the above information on all sides.

Facial recognition is considered biometric data, which is special category data under the GDPR and forbidden to process except in very strict circumstances. Apart from law enforcement/government, it is more or less impossible to lawfully process biometric data with informed consent from the data subject. The household exemption does not apply.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by avar on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:20PM (#36992118)
The European perspective is broadly to have the "freedom from", whereas the American one is the "freedom to".

You've got the freedom to aquire an arsenal, I don't, but I prefer the freedom from other people gunning down my kids, which by extension limits the narrow personal freedoms of myself and others.

Likewise, the American perspective is to draw a hard line on "in public", the European one is more nuanced.

Yes, you can film your vlog without fear, but a random pedestrian in Berlin also has the freedom from being associated with your public vlog.

Therefore you have a responsibility to either get their permission to broadcast it, or to anonymize them.

A useful way to think about it is to shift your view from "can I do X?" to "will I bother anyone else by doing X?".

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by caf on Thursday August 03, 2023 @08:11PM (#36993810)
A useful way to think about it is to shift your view from "can I do X?" to "will I bother anyone else by doing X?".

I don't think that's particularly useful, because the answer to the second is trivially Yes, regardless of the value of X.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by ux-app on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:43PM (#36994416)
>the answer to the second is trivially Yes, regardless of the value of X

then don't do it?

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by filoleg on Thursday August 03, 2023 @10:36PM (#36994800)
Your response to "by that metric, essentially almost everything is disallowed" is "well yeah, just don't do it". I don't think that stance would sit well with most.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by hutzlibu on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:45AM (#36997221)
There are still many people bothered by the fact, that I as a men have long hair.

I am sorry to dissapoint you and those people, but for now I keep my hair.

You cannot please everyone and I think it is a path into madness to even try it. There are maaany things people feel bothered about …

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by avar on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:12AM (#36997412)
Are you suggesting that someone could shut down all human activity on the European continent by declaring that everything bothers them?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by tremon on Friday August 04, 2023 @09:04AM (#36999396)
There is a lot of leeway to be had between "will I bother anyone else by doing X" and "will anyone else be bothered by me doing X": it's active interference versus passive objection-taking. Socially aware people can learn the difference.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by Ylpertnodi on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:20PM (#36991243)
Fucking hell, here we go again: "Dash cams are much more tightly regulated in some parts of the EU than elsewhere."

It depends on the eu country of which there are several...including an ex-eu country.

How it comes accross: One of the things i hate about America is that in new york all the californian building restrictions and zoning are killing free speech.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by closewith on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:46PM (#36991605)
With respect, the GDPR is a Regulation and this applies uniformly across the bloc. Enforcement varies, obviously.

TBH your comment comes off as very condescending and ill-informed.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by Knee_Pain on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:08AM (#36996040)
GDPR is to be implemented independently in each country. There is room for interpretation, it's not a granitic ruleset from above
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by closewith on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:10AM (#36996943)
No, that's not correct.

When talking about the EU, there are two types of laws (well, three if you include treaties), Directives and Regulations.

Directives are common goals which much be transposed into law by each country and there is indeed differences in implementation. An example of a directive is Directive 2012/27/EU on energy efficiency. It set goals on energy efficiency (and minimum targets), but each country implemented it's own legislation to transpose the Directive into law, and those implementations varied wildly.

However, EU Regulations are a different kettle of fish. Regulations are EU legal acts which are immediately enforceable as national law in all EU states. GDPR is a Regulation and so applies uniformly across the bloc.

Regulations are designed to harmonise legislation across the entire bloc. Obviously there are differences in enforcement, but the ultimate arbiter is the CJEU and decisions are binding in all EU states.

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by mahathu on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:11PM (#36992733)
Preach it brother
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by holri on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:34AM (#36995521)
In Austria there are illegal.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bigbillheck on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:12PM (#36990375)
I don't think they're all that concerned about the law.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bonestamp2 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:28PM (#36991346)
Which part? Lots of German cars use cameras to recognize cars for various safety and convenience features.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by thefounder on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:02PM (#36990238)
Just like on social media/chat apps
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by brador on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:02PM (#36990232)
>Your car is filmed and recognized by other teslas. - coolspot

Is this true?

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by xavdid on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:07PM (#36990315)

  - filmed: definitely
  - recorded: not sure (probably not long term)
  - recognized: unlikely
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:22PM (#36990493)
Recorded, definitely based on the fact that Tesla employees were sharing various "funny" clips from these cams among themselves.

https://www.reuters.com/technology/tesla-workers-shared-sens...

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by nonrandomstring on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:20PM (#36992126)
Teslas, Roombas and Rings...

https://cybershow.uk/episodes.php?id=12

Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by WeylandYutani on Thursday August 03, 2023 @06:19PM (#36992836)
I thought the Chinese were being paranoid about Tesla but really anything from the US can be used to spy on your military bases.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bonestamp2 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:49PM (#36991652)
Tesla owners can use the cameras as "dashcams" and save the recordings. Here's an example from r/dashcam: https://www.reddit.com/r/Dashcam/comments/15ezdjd/tesla_dash...
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by Too on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:50AM (#36995604)
Recorded, yes. Tesla uses the fleet to collect video data for training their algorithms. This has been shared in multiple presentations from Tesla.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by steelframe on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:57PM (#36990949)
That's why I cycle everywhere. With my phone switched off and stowed in a Faraday bag.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by ModernMech on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:05PM (#36991888)
I drive a firetruck, so I'm invisible to Teslas.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by painted-now on Thursday August 03, 2023 @05:32PM (#36992264)
That's why I only hang out in the metaverse and don't leave my home anymore. Umm, ...
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by holri on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:27AM (#36995483)
That is why I ride a bicycle.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by 93po on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:42PM (#36990758)
Cool
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by chaps on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:23PM (#36995132)
What kind of car do you have? Your car almost definitely shares its gps location to the manufacturer and downstream data brokers.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by zootboy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @11:28PM (#36995157)
Lol, not my 2005 Toyota. It doesn't even have anti-lock brakes, much less a GPS phone-home system.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by chaps on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:34AM (#36995519)
Hah, fair enough!
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by ddalex on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:09AM (#36996930)
I have a Volvo, and it's not connected to any freaking thing, so if it's sends the location, that would be magic.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by brewtide on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:44PM (#36989962)
Semi related question I suppose. Do the Teslas simply use GPS for their location information? If so, couldn't one spoof the GPS using a hackRF or similar?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by ballenf on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:13PM (#36990388)
Targeted by the FCC seems worse than violating a Tesla clickwrap agreement.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by myself248 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:33PM (#36991421)
Only an idiot would let their GPS spoofer onto the air. You unplug the antenna cables from the receiver and pipe the spoof signal in there.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by comboy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:47PM (#36991621)
I have no idea about Tesla specifically but normally you'd also you cell and wifi information (in their case probably also information from other teslas around) and additionally you have accelerometer and the whole "self-driving" computer to estimate where the car is and where it's going. It's also a known attack vector and likely covered because GPS signal is really weak so it's easy for somebody outside the car to try to make a mess.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bushbaba on Thursday August 03, 2023 @02:52PM (#36990087)
Isn’t this a huge risk to AMD’s confidential compute offering. It’s a major security flaw.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by kccqzy on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:58PM (#36990961)
I have reviewed the threat model carefully before. AMD never claims that their confidential compute offering is immune to attacks involving physical access. I assume what you mean by confidential compute is technology like AMD SEV SNP? Those are very different in that they allow you to run a trusted virtual machine on an untrusted hypervisor. This attack is completely different; it's akin to breaking Secure Boot on a PC.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by closewith on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:00PM (#36990203)
Can you not turn off vehicle tracking?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by speedgoose on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:36PM (#36991467)
Since a few weeks you get a classic consent screen for various categories of tracking. At least in Norway. You can turn everything off but I think some data is still sent to your phone through the Tesla servers. And I assume it’s not end 2 end encrypted.
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by bastardoperator on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:49PM (#36990842)
Definitely sophisticated, but something console hackers have been doing for quite some time now including the boot flow. I'm wondering if a Tesla vehicle/computer is more sophisticated than say a PS5?
Re:Hackers manage to unlock Tesla software-locked features by dhx on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:15AM (#36996082)
This is the same attack (and same people who developed) faulTPM[1] that was previously discussed[2]. This article is the same people demonstrating that attack against Tesla vehicles. The paper[1] and previous discussion[2] address the underlying problems with AMD's Secure Processor (AMD-SP) that is embedded in their CPU SoCs and previously and more commonly known as Platform Security Processor (AMD-PSP).

Unlike a web browser where W3C AntiFraudCG folk propose that websites would blacklist all impacted AMD-SP hardware and create massive amounts of e-waste[3], Tesla likely can't do much about this attack because Tesla (not users) would be responsible for a very expensive change of vehicle hardware.

If it's not an easy-to-execute attack like faulTPM, there are more complex (but becoming more mainstream and cheaper) IC reverse engineering methods like polishing the die down to take photos of each metal layer and regenerating VHDL, FIB editing an operational IC to bypass tamper detection methods, etc[4].

A security architect of the Xbox One presented a talk[5] a few years ago which provides some good background too. Largely the Xbox One has managed to avoid piracy because they made it economically not worth anyone's time to attack due to competitive pricing models versus high cost of attack. Similar to use of Denuvo for a month or two after release of a PC game, attackers aren't going to bother if their work amounts to nothing a month later.

Hacking a Tesla to enable additional features is worth a lot of money, so the economics are quite different. It's also different economics for printer cartridges, "pay to enable more features or performance" network equipment, etc. The cost of IC reverse engineering / FIB editing attacks (or other future attack methods) will keep reducing. IC tamper detection features will get more complex. Perhaps attackers will even get an advantage once they can readily reverse engineer 3nm ICs and defenders can't do much other than implementing ever more complex and obfuscated IC tamper detection features and VHDL logic (kind of like a Denuvo situation in hardware).

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.14717

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35787195

[3] https://github.com/antifraudcg/proposals/issues/19

[4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6390Zqca3Mg

[5] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7VwtOrwceo