News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by dietrichepp on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:36AM (#36846209)
This is for math.

In Latex, you get these symbols with \mathbb{}. They are most commonly used to represent to represent number sets, like the set of all integers Z (from the German), set of all natural numbers N, set of complex numbers C, set of all real numbers R, rationals Q, set of quaternions H (named after Hamilton), or an unknown set F (for β€œfield”). This explains why many of the letters in this series exist in the basic multilingual planeβ€”because R is very commonly used, but A is not. You can find ℝ in the basic multilingual plane at U+211D.

I don’t know why people are interested in the X symbol. It’s just there to complete the alphabet. There are many other ranges like this used for writing mathematical formulas, like the range of bold letters, fraktur, script, etc.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by tmccrary55 on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:42AM (#36846277)
Because Elmo
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by throw0101b on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:04AM (#36847326)
> Because Elmo

Please do not sully the good name of the Muppet by associating him with the tech billionaire…

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by krger on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:12AM (#36847425)
Elmo (and specifically the value-extraction-by-merchandise craze CTW created around him) pretty much single-handedly destroyed the original ensemble cast spirit of Sesame Street, so it's actually pretty apt.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by masukomi on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:42AM (#36846278)
because elon renamed twitter to "x corp", bought the x.com domain and shoved this character on it.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by mkl on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:44AM (#36846304)
He (or a company of his) has had the x.com domain for decades: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X.com
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by spread_love on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:49AM (#36846360)
No, it changed ownership many times since 1999.

> On July 5 2017, Musk repurchased the domain name X.com from PayPal

They even took a little jab at him when it happened

> "We are delighted to sell the domain x.com back to its previous owner"

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by pilsetnieks on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:00AM (#36846489)
I'm sorry to be the one to let you know but 1999 was over two decades ago.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by mkl on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:09AM (#36846608)
I think you missed the point: the domain has not been in Musk's control that whole time, as I had thought. His company X.com had it, then PayPal got it when it was created in a merger of X.com and Confinity, and PayPal kept it after Musk left, but then Musk got it back.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by tsimionescu on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:06PM (#36850172)
This doesn't contradict what you're saying, but note that the company was only re-branded to PayPal after Musk left it. I think it was just named Confinity after the merger.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by deadbunny on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:08AM (#36846592)
> On July 5 2017

2017 is not 1999

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by gilleain on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:17AM (#36846702)
Given the start of this thread was about N, C, X etc ...

We could even say "2017 > 1999", giving an ordering over these numbers.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by spread_love on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:11AM (#36846642)
I'm delighted to let you know that you missed the point. It was a very short comment.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by misnome on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:29AM (#36847683)
I'm sorry to be the one to let you know but 2017 was under two decades ago.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by RoryH on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:43AM (#36847078)
Was this message posted on x.com?
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by MisterTea on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:18AM (#36846726)
Am I crazy or was x.com at one point x-drive, the early online storage company?
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by onesphere on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:55AM (#36849978)
I get a β€˜godaddy parked’ page for x.com (not even a β€˜y’ or a β€˜z’): https://thetaplane.com/x.com
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by dietrichepp on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:55AM (#36846422)
The bird is a lot more recognizable, no? Maybe even beautiful?
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by booleandilemma on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:29AM (#36847689)
I thought the same thing. The bird is endearing.

Changing it to X is something some edgy teenager would do. I can't help but wonder if he's trying to destroy twitter on purpose.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by solardev on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:10AM (#36848278)
This whole Twitter saga is like what happens when a cat catches a bird and doesn't know what to do with it so just slowly tortures it to death for the hell of it
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by NoNotTheDuo on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:57AM (#36848085)
Not only the bird, but all of the associated verbiage. For example, Tweet and Retweet. Do those go away after changing the name and logo?
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by solardev on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:06AM (#36848230)
Yeah lol, Musk wants to call them xs now. Like "your x last night was pretty great" or "will you share your x with me again?"

Not even kidding. https://apnews.com/article/twitter-x-logo-blue-bird-musk-068...

> In response to questions about what tweets would be called when the rebranding is done, Musk said they would be called Xs.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by account42 on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:35AM (#36849681)
By coincidence, a lot of people I know have already been calling them twats.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by brazzledazzle on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:37AM (#36849706)
Clearly none of the marketing or branding people stayed on. Or he ignores them.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by treve on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:14AM (#36849334)
I imagine the former will become xcrete.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by simplicio on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:30AM (#36848588)
Also people less likely to assume its the brand for a pornography site? Feel like people have developed a habit of avoiding (or seeking out) anything with a prominent "X" in the name on the Internets.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by yurodivuie on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:57AM (#36850013)
It sounds like Elon had the domain and it was burning a hole in his pocket. That's the only explanation, honestly.

Twitter as a brand becomes less valuable the more he alters it, since he's such a polarizing figure, so changing the brand to break continuity seems pretty counterproductive. It just reminds people that Elon is still fiddling with it.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by kergonath on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:05PM (#36850155)
> It sounds like Elon had the domain and it was burning a hole in his pocket. That's the only explanation, honestly.

I think he just thinks he’s getting his revenge and that everyone will see how his terrible idea of x.com was actually genius back in the day. Like a particularly expensive midlife crisis. A bit like some dudes who start playing guitar because they could not back in the day, when it was a useful tool to make friends and look cool.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by jona-f on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:59PM (#36851883)
Hey, I started playing guitar as an adult and it's one of the biggest pleasures in my life. Also, I'm very mediocre.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by kergonath on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:17PM (#36852144)
Haha sorry, no offense meant. Some people don’t do it for bad reasons ;)
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by nerdbert on Monday July 24, 2023 @05:03PM (#36854164)
> It sounds like Elon had the domain and it was burning a hole in his pocket.

Yeah I wonder if he "sold" it to Twitter, and if so, for how much.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by kergonath on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:59AM (#36850062)
Yeah, but not kewl enough.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by coev on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:45AM (#36846312)
He owned x.com decades ago and it was part of paypal's acquisition, then they sold the name back to elon a few years ago
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by orlp on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:44AM (#36846307)
𝕏 is used as a symbol for a generic metric space. E.g. if your result is generic over ℝ², β„‚Β³, etc, you can write 𝕏.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by red_trumpet on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:18AM (#36846727)
I'm a PhD student in algebraic geometry and have seldom seen this. IME "X" is a generic name for all kinds of spaces (metric, topological, complex analytic, algebraic...), but I don't remember ever having seen "𝕏".

That said, in principal everyone is free to call their spaces how they like. It just makes it easier to read if one sticks to familiar notation.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by orlp on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:32AM (#36846932)
You're right I should've used "as a symbol" not "as the symbol". It's not terribly common.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by red_trumpet on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:51AM (#36847164)
Now that I think about it, most double stroked characters really represent "concrete" objects, not generic ones. Like β„™ for projective space, or 𝔸 for affine space. Also 𝔽 is often used together with an index 𝔽_q for the field with q elements.

On the other hand, Wikipedia[1] agrees with you, that 𝕏 is "occasionally" used for metric spaces.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackboard_bold

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by orlp on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:35AM (#36847769)
As a counterpoint, 𝔽 when not fixed to a particular size is arguably still generic over "any field", and 𝔾 is most definitely generic for "any group", even if fixed to a particular size.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by red_trumpet on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @04:07AM (#36859380)
There might be small cultural differences at hand here. As a German, I prefer "k" or "K" for fields (as in "KΓΆrper"), and I think I've seen 𝔾 mostly as 𝔾_a or 𝔾_m for the additive and multiplicative group. shrug
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by dietrichepp on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:07AM (#36847365)
My experience with 𝔽 is β€œvector space over a field 𝔽”, which is not a concrete object, but I have probably seen F written in a normal italic style more often.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by dataflow on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:21AM (#36848438)
I've seen β„™ used for probability.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by runarberg on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:34PM (#36851519)
I’ve also seen β…† as the differential operator and 𝔼(X) as the expected value of X. I think I’ve also seen πŸ™_x, and β…ˆ, and β…‰ but I don’t remember for what.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by brewmarche on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:30PM (#36852349)
I know πŸ™_X as the indicator function (also called characteristic function) of X in measure theory and probability theory, but I’ve also seen 1_X or Ο‡_X.

β…ˆ and β…‰ can be basis vectors or imaginary units although I’ve never seen them in blackboard bold in my lectures.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by ginnungagap on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:37AM (#36849712)
In set theory blackboard bold P, Q and C are very often used for arbitrary (forcing) posets
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by nephanth on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:20PM (#36856085)
I've seen (and used) \mathbb{P} and \mathbb{E} for the probability & expectation operators (so not really a "concrete" object in your sense?)
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by dietrichepp on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:48AM (#36846351)
Thanks! I am always a little curious about how these symbols are used. That makes perfect sense to me.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by dclowd9901 on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:08AM (#36846596)
Cause β€œX” is a cool letter. Just ask David X. Cohen.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by jhoechtl on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:24AM (#36846815)
> I don’t know why people are interested in the X symbol.

It's the new symbol for and domain name of the social? network formerly known as twitter.

[dead]
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by dang on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:54AM (#36849970)
Can you please not break the site guidelines by fulminating, name-calling, snarking, and so on? It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.

You may not owe $CEO better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by astrange on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:10PM (#36850236)
Not to mention the X.org logo.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by formerly_proven on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:31AM (#36846918)
The "bb" in "mathbb" isn't for "math, baby" (although accurate), but short for "blackboard bold". These letterforms don't originate with blackboards though, using outlines for thick verticals goes back centuries. They're sometimes called open face.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by enriquto on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:07AM (#36847353)
> This is for math.

Heh.

The "tabs vs spaces" debate of mathematical typography is whether these symbols should be used at all in printing, or reserved for actual blackboards. In LaTeX you can have actual boldface letters, so you should write a boldface letter R to represent the real numbers and so on. Using "blackboard bold" in print looks terribly off to some (many?) people.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by jdrek1 on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:36AM (#36847774)
> In LaTeX you can have actual boldface letters, so you should write a boldface letter R to represent the real numbers and so on.

Almost [1] every single student absolutely hates that notation in scripts. Bold is used to draw attention, it should not be abused as being part of the variable/type. Just use the proper symbol.

[1] And I'm only saying "almost" to account for the possibility of there being like 5 super weird people on this planet that think otherwise. I don't know a single person who thinks this is a good idea, even the professors writing their scripts like that think it's stupid and are only doing it due to some nonsense fear of it otherwise not printing correctly due to one single bad experience with a shitty printer in 1950. Or maybe there's some other historical reason for this, but in 2023 I'd classify not using the better notation as malicious.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by folkrav on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:21AM (#36847570)
Funny. Coming from a non-math background, having only one symbol to deal with feels less confusing than switching around symbols based on the medium it happens to be written on. Did one of the symbols come "first"?
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by enriquto on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:29AM (#36847684)
Here you have the whole history:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackboard_bold

Summary: boldface came first, in print, and was widely used. Much later, some mathematicians started to write blackboard bold on blackboards (because actual bold would be very untoward to write on a blackboard). Then, the usage was backported to print.

I find it ugly, a sort of breaking "suspension of disbelief", I don't know how to explain why. Some sort of "anachronistic" feeling, like watching a movie about the roman empire and some soldiers wear watches.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by dietrichepp on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:42AM (#36847849)
It sounds similar to the division between β€œmath” and β€œmaths”. It looks wrong depending on where you grew up.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by dataflow on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:24AM (#36848479)
We can compromise by switching to mathematic.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by dietrichepp on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:40AM (#36848805)
I’m very well acquainted, too, with matters mathematical.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by BobMackay on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:06AM (#36849206)
I understand equations, both the simple and quadratical!
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by bamfly on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:12PM (#36851209)
Seems like you've got a solid math grounding. If you're looking to expand on your history knowledge, I'd recommend taking a look at Creasy:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fifteen_Decisive_Battles_o...

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by chungy on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:38PM (#36851567)
They were spoofing Modern Major General.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by bamfly on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:38PM (#36851572)
So was I :-)
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by irrational on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:56AM (#36849069)
Don’t you mean mathematics?
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by catiopatio on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:49AM (#36847963)
It’s a useful convention; I’m not sure why you dislike it other than some invalid conception of purity.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by enriquto on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:56AM (#36848058)
Maybe because my favorite math books do not use this convention, but another equally valid and useful convention: regular boldface.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by catiopatio on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:16AM (#36848375)
The point isn’t to be β€œright” β€” whatever you define that as.

The point is to be understood.

Use blackboard bold when it’s what people are most familiar with and will engender the least confusion.

You call this the β€œtabs vs spaces” debate, but I’ve literally never heard anyone advocate your position until you did, just now.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by enriquto on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:32AM (#36848633)
> I’ve literally never heard anyone advocate your position until you did, just now

Many mathematicians concerned by typography use real boldface. For example: Terence Tao's blog, Donald Knuth, Paul Halmos (author of "how to write mathematics"), and the famous journal "Publications Mathématiques de l'IHÉS" which is the undisputed gold standard in mathematical typography. They use real boldface for the number sets N, Z, Q, T, R, C.

I've never seen a boldface R to mean a set different than the real numbers.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by tel on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:36PM (#36850675)
* * *
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by BlackFingolfin on Monday July 24, 2023 @05:39PM (#36854582)
> "Publications Mathématiques de l'IHÉS" which is the undisputed gold standard in mathematical typography.

It is? Do you have any supporting evidence for this claim?

I just had a look at a bunch of recent articles, and I would very much dispute it. I saw nothing extraordinary, and found the fonts they used rather ugly (though of course that is highly subjective). The use of bold face to highlight theorem/definition/etc. numbers is IMHO very questionable. The boldface letters you praise stick out like a sore thumb, feeling as if they were being emphasized and highlighted when they clearly are not meant to be.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by enriquto on Monday July 24, 2023 @06:25PM (#36855094)
> It is? Do you have any supporting evidence for this claim?

I don't have any evidence to support this claim. I always thought about it as self-evident, because it was in that journal that Grothendieck published his work, and the same style is used in by the legendary Hermann editor from Paris and by Bourbaki. But I cannot find any non-partisan source of my claim. As for non-neutral sources, you have for example the congratulations on the typesetting by DieudonnΓ©e [0] (who was a member of the IHES), or a more recent article by Haralambous about the Baskerville variant used by the institute [1]. I will retire my claim of "undisputed" if you find a source that says that the pinnacle of mathematical typesetting is something else :)

[0] https://expo-patrimoine.ihes.fr/?page=9&lang=en

[1] http://www.numdam.org/item/CG_1999___32_5_0/

You also have this semi-anonymous blog post [2], that laments the decline in quality when the journal in question was acquired by Springer. Quote:

> How good was the typeface? It was so good, some people submitted their papers to IHES precisely for the beauty of the typesetting

[2] https://www.galoisrepresentations.com/2014/08/15/the-decline...

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by skoob on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:32PM (#36851477)
That's pretty typical for how typography develops. Majuscule and miniscule letters were just two different styles of writing the same letter. But eventually, people started using majuscule (i.e uppercase) letters to give emphasis to the beginning of sentences or certain words, like names.

Italic typefaces were created by Italian type designers to mimic the cursive handwriting of the time. They weren't meant to be mixed with roman style typefaces. However, typesetters who had access to both roman and italic fonts started to use italic for emphasis when typesetting texts in roman type.

And of course blackletter is also just a style that originally tried to mimic earlier handwriting.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by paulddraper on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:55PM (#36851803)
> having only one symbol to deal with feels less confusing than switching around symbols based on the medium it happens to be written on

See: the entire Latin alphabet.

Sans-serif symbols for screens, serif symbols for print.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by folkrav on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:30PM (#36880431)
Fair
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by mcphage on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:01AM (#36848143)
> In LaTeX you can have actual boldface letters, so you should write a boldface letter R to represent the real numbers and so on.

Why use the wrong symbol, when you can just use the correct (ie, blackboard bold) symbol?

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by marcelluspye on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:08AM (#36848256)
I hated when textbooks/papers did this. Half the time you can't tell if they meant to use the bold letter or if the printer was just being generous on that character. Made legibility quite a bit more difficult. BB letters are unambiguous.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by Skeime on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:09AM (#36849267)
I strongly disagree that the bold symbols are better, even though they’re what blackboard bold was originally conceived to approximate. The reason: Bold font draws attention (ask a typographer about type color), but usually, the bolder symbols are not the ones requiring that attention. (If I read a text about real analysis, I know that the domains and codomains will be the real numbers, for example.) The blackboard bold versions stick out much less when looking at the greater composition of the page.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by enriquto on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:25AM (#36849508)
I respect your opinion, and agree that with some particularly "thin" fonts (most notably, Computer Modern and its variants), the associated bold symbols are too exaggerated and produce and ugly effect.

But there is certainly some dependency on the font. For example, the Baskerville used by the Publications de l'IHÉS is a much thicker font, and the bold letters flow very naturally. Look for example here

http://www.numdam.org/item/PMIHES/

The publications in the sixties and seventies, which are scanned, are very beautiful and the bold letters mix smoothly in the text. You cannot see them "from far away" as happens with Computer Modern.

Curiously, the modern pdfs look slightly different, with apparently thinner fonts. This may be an effect of printing, that smears the ink a bit and produces slightly thicker type?

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by account42 on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:30AM (#36849605)
Then there's always that one prof that uses both on the blackboard. Also Fraktur. Also bold Fraktur.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by computerfriend on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:43PM (#36850785)
Do you have a source for this? I have never come across this debate and personally find the blackboard bold convention to be useful, as well as very visually elegant.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by enriquto on Monday July 24, 2023 @05:33PM (#36854522)
It seems to me that it is part of the folklore. Note: not the folklore of math! The folklore of mathematical typesetting, which is a tiny community.

You can find many old and new math texts using either convention. Most often readers won't even notice. There are authors who are adamant against blackboard bold, most famously Donald Knuth and Jean-Pierre Serre. Others simply use regular boldface because of tradition, or because it's the default style of the journal. Most people don't care too much. But I have also heard people expressing strong opinions on each side, that's why I made the analogy with tabs-vs-spaces. Nothing too serious.

Elegance is entirely subjective. I have the opposite opinion: if we can do real boldface in print, which is the original usage, what's the point of using a black-board version? We have the real thing! But I also understand the opposite opinion, voiced elsewhere in this thread, that open bold lettering is a new case, like italics or fraktur, and we can use it freely in print.

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by snarfy on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:27AM (#36847651)
They are an accessibility nightmare. I read a comment here recently from a blind person that had to give up on math education entirely due to all of the symbols not being supported by screen readers. It was pretty sad.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by thebooktocome on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:30AM (#36847702)
One blind mathematician I know prefers reading LaTeX over pdf math for exactly this reason.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by blincoln on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:19PM (#36850396)
I avoid using oddball Unicode characters for this reason,[1] but I also feel like at this point the can of worms has been unleashed, and the screen reader authors are going to have to adapt to a more hostile environment.

It seems like one approach might be something like this, assuming none of them are doing it already. If this is TLDR, the key feature relating to the topic at hand is the point about handling mathematical symbols, so skip everything except that one.

* Pre-parse the entire page and count the number of characters that would be read using a multi-word description. While doing this, create sub-counts of characters that fall into each Unicode script (Latin, Cyrillic, mathematical notation, etc.).

* If the number of characters that would be read using a multi-word description exceeds a user-specified threshold, prompt the user for how to proceed.

* First, tell the user how many different Unicode scripts (and blocks if necessary[2]) are contained on the page. For each set, prompt using the following logic if the user hasn't already set a default:

** If a script/block/whatever consists of abstract symbols, like the mathematical set, offer to read it using the closest approximation in the character set it's derived from. e.g. for 𝕏, read it as "X" instead of "mathematical double-struck capital X". Read both 𝜸 β„Ύ as "gamma" instead of their lengthy "mathematical..." descriptions.

** If a script/block/whatever represents a spoken language, offer to do one of the following:

** Read it as if spoken by someone fluent in the language.

** Precede it with "the following [n] [script name] characters" and read each one individually, without any leading per-letter indicators, e.g. for "ΑΒΓΔ", "the following four Greek characters: alpha, beta, gamma, delta". Optionally include per-letter capitalization indication, but only if the user has previous enabled that option.

** Replace it with a count and the script name, e.g. "five hundred characters of Chinese script". Provide a way for the user to interrupt the narration and expand that section instead of omitting it.

* Allow the user to store all of the prompt answers as defaults and not prompt them again unless the user resets the option. e.g. "always read mathematical symbols as the closest Latin letter approximation".

* Maybe remind the user that it is an option in edge cases like "this entire page would be read as 'a series of 53,198 symbols you've suppressed reading'".

[1] One of my first full-time jobs, decades ago, was doing UI development with a focus on accessibility.

[2] Pretty unbelievable that the Unicode consortium has taken the position that an apparently unlimited number of stylistic variations on Latin letters should get their own Unicode renditions, but that basically every other culture's character sets gets merged into one style of character even if there are extensive historical reasons to have different renderings, and also has the time to keep adding corner-case emojis, but can't be bothered to provide a single way to easily differentiate "Cyrillic" from "Latin" as well as differentiate "mathematical notation" from "Latin".

Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by hfkwer on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:41PM (#36850759)
That's on screen readers developers. And I don't know when that comment you seem to remember dates back to, but I have had several blind students in my math lectures over the past decade. They seemed did fine.
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by mananaysiempre on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:23AM (#36848460)
The command is called \mathbb for β€œblackboard bold”, and Unicode names these characters DOUBLE-STRUCK, because they were used in handwriting and on typewriters to represent what would normally be printed in bold type. (You can still find books that use 𝐑, 𝐂 and not ℝ, β„‚, etc.)
Re:Unicode Character β€œπ•β€ (U+1D54F) by eesmith on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:25PM (#36852286)
Ooh, I found a use in the wild! https://www.ams.org/books/memo/1023/

  The central theme of this paper is the variational analysis of
  homeomorphisms $h \colon \mathbb X \xrightarrow []{{}_{\!\!\mathrm
  {onto}\!\!}}\mathbb Y$ between two given domains $\mathbb X ,
  \mathbb Y \subset \mathbb R^n$.