News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by dtagames on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:08AM (#36519864)
I don't think it's wrong to take yourself down in a crazy unproven sub, even if you die. But taking paying tourists (not explorers; tourists) who are not experts and cannot vet the safety of your device -- that's unconscionable and probably criminal had the perpetrators survived.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by engineer_22 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:28AM (#36520069)
> I don't think it's wrong to take yourself down in a crazy unproven sub, even if you die.

I take your point and I dont quible that in hindsight the mission was reckless. But just to bring some more information to the debate, OceanGate had previously taken the Titan to this depth to visit the Titanic. So, it was "proven". The german entrepreneur who is in this [1] article claims to have visited Titanic twice in the same sub.

[1] https://nypost.com/2023/06/21/former-titanic-sub-passenger-d...

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by inoop on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:33AM (#36520133)
> OceanGate had previously taken the Titan to this depth to visit the Titanic. So, it was "proven"

This reminds me of an old joke about an optimist who falls from a 40 story building. As he passes the 30th story he thinks to himself, 'so far so good!'

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by stcredzero on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:23AM (#36521647)
How is your current life different? 1) It's not in freefall. 2) It will last orders of magnitude longer.

Otherwise, we are all in this boat.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by peteradio on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:36AM (#36521889)
The analogy would be an optimist who successfully falls two times due to extreme luck, like falling on a passing pillow truck and then goes for a third try.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by mcpackieh on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:41PM (#36523871)
A man who jumps onto a pile of bubble wrap, but each time he does this a few more of the bubbles pop.

(The submarine got weaker each time they used it.)

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by peteradio on Thursday June 29, 2023 @03:58PM (#36525867)
This is good.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by ThatPlayer on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:27PM (#36526225)
There was that guy who used to demonstrate glass windows as unbreakable by running into it. Until the window popped out of the frame.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by peteradio on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:30PM (#36527015)
IIIIIiiii wasssss stiillllll riiiiiiiiiighttttt........
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by hsjqllzlfkf on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:35AM (#36520163)
> OceanGate had previously taken the Titan to this depth to visit the Titanic. So, it was "proven".

The average HN knowledge of engineering.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by flybrand on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:41AM (#36520250)
Most material science VC deals are done off of data derived from the ‘lucky sample.’

“Scalability turned out to be harder than we thought!”

Or it was statistical reversion to the mean.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by tomjakubowski on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:53AM (#36520401)
p-hacking but for fundraising
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by djhn on Friday June 30, 2023 @02:06AM (#36531105)
Any good material science VC reading to recommend by any chance? Blogs, books, success stories too look up? Individuals or firms you consider better than average?
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by jacquesm on Friday June 30, 2023 @04:33AM (#36532071)
Most material science VC deals will hire a company to do tech DD who in turn will hire a materials science expert.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by Y_Y on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:40AM (#36520242)
There were no errors in the compile
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by engineer_22 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:56AM (#36520429)
your qualification?
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by datadeft on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:29AM (#36521751)
You never need to have a qualification for making a valid observation. These things are orthogonal.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by engineer_22 on Friday June 30, 2023 @06:02PM (#36543011)
That's Okay, I just wish people wiser than me would share their wisdom a little bit
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by MikeDelta on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:07AM (#36520530)
I don't think this was meant as true, hence the quotes. But I can imagine that quite some retail/non-expert customers could use this kind of reasoning to estimate odds and risks.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by hnsh1tpostt on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:09AM (#36520552)
maybe if the we re-write the submarine in rust it wont implode?
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by datadeft on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:27AM (#36521727)
Yes the are not familiar with material fatigue that has to be tested with a lot of repetition to understand how many operations you can perform with a unit.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by eCa on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:47AM (#36520326)
With airplanes, a lot of maintenance routines depends on the number of cycles (takeoffs+landings). No one knows how many cycles this sub was safe to perform, but just because it had successfully performed N dives, does not imply that N+1 is safe (or even N for that matter).
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by jacquesm on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:14AM (#36520624)
> No one knows how many cycles this sub was safe to perform

One less than the number that it did.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by stcredzero on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:23AM (#36521666)
Only if you want 0 dives as a safety margin.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by jcranmer on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:44AM (#36522009)
That is on-brand for the CEO here.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by jacquesm on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:12PM (#36522424)
For this design that may not have been a bad choice.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by stcredzero on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:45PM (#36524906)
"Sir, you should consider having a safety margin that's not a negative integer."
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by jacquesm on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:53PM (#36527970)
"Does it absolutely have to be an integer?"...
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by salawat on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:15AM (#36536407)
I'm fairly sure a safety factor capable of going NaN is not going to go well...
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by sleepybrett on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:19PM (#36522534)
But there is data to back that up on planes that are 'battle tested' you can compute failure rates over a ton of data. With something like this, a custom '1 off'... not unless you build a bunch of them and pilot them to depth (hopefully by remote) and wait for failures.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by asmor on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:46PM (#36523021)
The most obvious instance of this is probably the Comet 1. It took about 3000 cycles (about half of them simulated in a tank) to reproduce the catastrophic failure.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by 111111IIIIIII on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:47AM (#36520333)
This is sarcasm, right?
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by francisofascii on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:52AM (#36520387)
> OceanGate had previously taken the Titan to this depth to visit the Titanic. So, it was "proven"

This situation is an interesting statistical anomaly. Given that the Titan had a carbon fiber hull which was known to degrade more and more after each dive, the probability of failure increases after each successful dive. So you might think your chances of success are better the more times it came back safe, but the chances are actually worse.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by shawabawa3 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:30AM (#36521783)
Not exactly

I would say certainly the second trip was safer than the first, as the first trip ruled out lots of non carbon fibre related failures (e.g. the porthole)

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by tlavoie on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:23PM (#36526188)
I'm not so sure about that, pics of the wreckage being offloaded onshore show that dome being moved with a sling through the hole where the porthole should be. I don't think they would have removed that just to move it, especially before analyzing the debris.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by dragonwriter on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:05PM (#36526680)
The force of the implosion, as I understand it, would destroy the porthole in any case; it being not attached is not an indicator that it was the point of initial failure.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by tlavoie on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:23PM (#36526931)
That is possible, it probably wasn't intended to contain severe pressure from the inside. Of course, being rated to only about 1/3 of that depth from the outside isn't reassuring either.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by johntb86 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @07:29PM (#36528258)
Yes, this was an extremely severe case of water hammer, so no surprise it failed.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by drc500free on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:56AM (#36522191)
It would follow a Bathtub Curve, so it would go down first, then up.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathtub_curve

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by rspeele on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:00PM (#36522253)
That's what it was supposed to do but this time it went down and didn't come back up.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by RajT88 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:16PM (#36523439)
I see you got downvoted. But I will upvote your pun!

If we criminalize puns, only criminals will make puns!

Vote No on Pun control.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by nunuvit on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:01PM (#36526643)
It would not follow a bathtub curve. As the Wikipedia article explains, you have to at least check the in-service products to get a bathtub curve. As this article [1] explains, they did not do that. Therefore, no bathtub curve guarantee.

For argument's sake, let's say it would follow the bathtub curve. You could summarize all the warnings they were given as basically saying that the wear out curve crosses the other two curves all the way on the left. You could also say that they took the bathtub curve for granted, not realizing that it's the result of deliberate work. So again, still no bathtub curve, no matter which way you look at it.

[1] https://abc7chicago.com/missing-titanic-sub-oceangate-lawsui...

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:55AM (#36520426)
It wasn't proven. They replaced the carbon hull of Titan after it started creaking too much from water intrusion. They had no scientific way to evaluate the number of usable dives and how safe and reliable their bonding procedure would be. Rush was just another fake it 'til you make it tech bro who flew too close to the sun with his willful ignorance.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by squarefoot on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:59AM (#36520450)
IIRC, One of the concerns raised with that carbon fiber construction approach was that in case the hull was damaged during a previous mission, they had no equipment to detect that, so it could have been only a matter of time before accumulated fatigue could lead to a catastrophic failure.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by jacquesm on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:13AM (#36520605)
That 'proven' bit is exactly where the rub is, and apparently there was prior damage from some of those dives that wasn't addressed. Taking this device to a certain depth and ascending again only proves it worked that time but brings the eventual failure that much closer.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by hermanradtke on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:39AM (#36521936)
> OceanGate had previously taken the Titan to this depth to visit the Titanic. So, it was "proven".

Surely there was a large amount of tail risk.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by LorenPechtel on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:05PM (#36522312)
Sounds a lot like the reasoning that lead to the Challenger disaster.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by wkat4242 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:00PM (#36527357)
It was a bit different. With the Challenger they started with a target (astronomical) reliability rating, and then calculated back to how each part would have to perform. The problem was they didn't actually verify this under real world conditions.

With this sub the number of safe operation cycles wasn't even part of the design considerations.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by nunuvit on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:47PM (#36527208)
Sure, I can "prove" that my sheet of sandpaper works by using it all day. Does that mean it should work all day tomorrow? It's a useful bit of information ... about how it's approaching the end of its service life. If you don't evaluate how much sand is left before using it again, what is there to debate? Either you don't care if it works tomorrow, or you're about to learn an important lesson on how sand paper works.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by mikeryan on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:27AM (#36520052)
The 19 year old kid on the sub is the one that gets me. Everyone else should have had the wherewithal to make their own choices - but the kid was just going because his dad wanted him to. Stories are out now that he was freaked out by the idea but went as a Father’s Day “gift”.

I feel so horrible for his family. It makes it hard to be cynical about this tragedy.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by huthuthike on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:02AM (#36520487)
That was a rumor that the mother has debunked. She has come out and said that she was supposed to go with her husband, but gave up her seat to her son because he really wanted to go. I'm not sure this makes it better for the mother, but at least he was willing.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by viciousvoxel on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:41AM (#36521017)
The dark, cynical side of me says that could just as easily be an excuse to save face/preserve the image of her husband. It's terrible in any case.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by xeromal on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:16PM (#36522483)
The son not wanting to go was a comment from some random aunt or cousin. I'd trust the mother's word instead of someone cashing in on the drama.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by MagicMoonlight on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:31PM (#36522721)
I wouldn’t. The mother has an incentive to lie, a rando relative doesn’t.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by xeromal on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:44PM (#36522979)
Depends on your upbringing.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by HelloMcFly on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:50PM (#36523099)
Rando relative who wants media attention most certainly does. One my aunts (and her husband) would definitely lie like this to get in the news, no doubt about it.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by RajT88 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:12PM (#36523366)
Can confirm. I have an aunt and uncle (not a couple; different branches) who both would love to go on TV and say all kinds of crazy shit if I had died in the sub.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by pengaru on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:24PM (#36523577)
Except the relative would get in the news if she said "the boy was obsessed with the titanic, he was eager to go!" Any angle would have given her camera time, she just has an incentive to say _something_.

What she said I think more likely has some truth than the wife of the deceased father the statement throws shade on. Aren't we talking about billionaires here? Mom is likely quite concerned about appearances and her future.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by justinclift on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:45PM (#36526460)
> she just has an incentive to say _something_

Bear in mind that some people just like to stir up shit. So they say stuff based on no evidence / their imagination / whatever they suspect will cause controversy.

No idea of the situation in this case, but don't discount it could be that too.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by wkat4242 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:52PM (#36527264)
If you have billions you don't have to worry about your future, save for medical concerns.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by HelloMcFly on Friday June 30, 2023 @10:13AM (#36535272)
I'm only making the case that there are multiple plausible scenarios, so latching onto one without objective information is ill-advised.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by mcpackieh on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:34PM (#36523748)
Lot's of families have disputes, that relative might have motive to lie. We don't know because none of us really know the family. It's all speculation, including the supposition that the mother is lying to save face for her husband.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by netsharc on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:13PM (#36529714)
The mother seemed very honest during her interview with the BBC [1], not playing the "ZOMG I lost my husband and son!!!" angle, but I did think she might've done this to quieten all the "screw them billionaires, they deserved it!" crowd, by showing them that there are actually people grieving their loss.

Also I think she's only done this one interview. Even the question of "How are you?" was answered with contemplation, not hysterics...

1 https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-us-canada-66016162

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by 6D794163636F756 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:22PM (#36522588)
They could easily both be telling the truth. He could have been pressured into it by his father and told his mother he wanted to go while telling a more distant relative his fears caused by his parents
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by weinzierl on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:10PM (#36522394)
This is all speculation but reading the mothers account my impression was that what he really wanted was the speedcubing world record and that this was the lure.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by ramraj07 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:28AM (#36521736)
He’s 19 though? Pretty sure they wouldn’t have taken an actual kid. If you can join the army you can sure as hell go down in a sub to make daddy happy.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by okdood64 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:15PM (#36523424)
> If you can join the army you can sure as hell go down

I hate arguments like these. The same one for the drinking age and joining the army. The world isn't black and white. There are merits to 18+ enlistment and 21+ drinking age both (along with downsides).

It's just noise in the form of words that doesn't go towards any way of proving a point.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by tedivm on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:00PM (#36522252)
Those rumors were started by his estranged aunt, who apparently just wanted a ton of attention.

Don't get me wrong, it's still horrible, and I still believe he shouldn't have gone down there. But he wasn't freaking out and terrified for weeks like his aunt said.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by mrtksn on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:26PM (#36523619)
Here is a video of Suleman, the young man who perished in the sub: https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-66015863

He strikes me as someone who could have had a very bright future, looks like a smart and confident young man.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by chinchilla2020 on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:35AM (#36534623)
He is a billionaire's kid. Of course his future was bright.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by koolba on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:33PM (#36523719)
> Stories are out now that he was freaked out by the idea but went as a Father’s Day “gift”.

It’s said that money just gives you the ability for you to be you. That someone would willfully put his child in that dangerous situation really disgusts me.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by bombcar on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:14AM (#36519922)
A huge part of maturity is realizing that you can’t be an expert capable of evaluating all risk in your life, so outside forces/standards are necessary.

Untrained smart people can be really bad at risk - a good shorthand is: can you get insurance for it and what is the price?

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by MichaelZuo on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:15AM (#36519933)
Huh the insurance test does sound pretty smart. Though I imagine some insurance products might not be quoted at all to any random person?
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by bombcar on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:27AM (#36520054)
It’s not perfect, but it at least gets you thinking.

Because the adjusters have to price the risk objectively - house burn down? Risk relatively low. Submarine go pop? Probably not insurable at any price - either because risk is too high or they can’t evaluate it. And if they can’t, you likely can’t, unless you’re Cameron or someone similar.

That doesn’t mean uninsurable risks aren’t worth taking sometimes. Just be aware and realistic.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by CharlesW on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:36AM (#36520196)
> Probably not insurable at any price - either because risk is too high or they can’t evaluate it.

FWIW, fatal experimental submarine accidents aren't the weirdest thing insurers have insured. https://havenlife.com/blog/craziest-things-insured-lloyds-lo...

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by HWR_14 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:07PM (#36524354)
Those are all just extra insurance against injuries that are well known, e.g. a broken leg. They are just extra payouts in case something happens
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by BoxFour on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:46AM (#36520323)
There are lots of extremely high-risk things that can still be insured. As a simple example you can get a new life insurance policy as an 89 year old with some generic insurance providers—-it’ll cost you, though, obviously.

Even if you put the risk of death ridiculously high (say, 90%) for each trip, it probably wouldn’t be impossible to insure it. The premium per trip would just likely be roughly the maximum payout and so it wouldn’t necessarily be worth it.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by MichaelZuo on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:13AM (#36521488)
That sounds really incredible, a 89 year old getting a new life insurance plan? Can you link to one of the providers?
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by LorenPechtel on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:03PM (#36522291)
It doesn't surprise me at all. The customers of such policies are quite wealthy and have no actual need of life insurance. Rather, it's an estate tax dodge because life insurance proceeds are tax free.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by CSMastermind on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:39PM (#36523815)
They might be thinking of whole life vs term life policies.

Whole life policies are basically investment vehicles that are an attractive asset class to a specific segment of the population because of tax reasons.

For those unaware term life pays out if you die within a certain time period. There's a chance that they won't pay out - you're pooling your risk of dying along with that of other people because statistically you're not all likely to die. So the premiums you pay in go to pay out someone who does in fact die.

For whole life the policy is for well your whole life - so the payout rate is 100% because everyone dies eventually. People take out whole life policies which they pay premiums into and those policies accumulate value allowing them to take out loans against the value of the policy. And because of a tax loophole in the United States this allows you to avoid paying taxes on the (what is essentially) investment dividends.

When I worked in the industry the cut off for term life at almost every carrier was 65 years old, though I vaguely remember people introducing policies for 70 year olds which might be a false memory.

Whole life can obviously be sold no matter how old you are. A 103 year old could probably find a carrier willing to issue them a whole life policy for the right price.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by bombcar on Thursday June 29, 2023 @03:28PM (#36525531)
There was a whole thing called a tontine that basically worked like inverse life insurance.

The insurers just look at the tables and give you what it will cost. It looks like an 89 year old has between 4-5 years life expectancy so expect to pay in premiums about 20% of the payout. Usually the payout is “burial insurance” at these ages.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by rundmc on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:17PM (#36526115)
"inverse life insurance" that's an interesting way to describe a tontine
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by xeromal on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:17PM (#36522501)
The comment your replying to built that in though. They said look at how much the insurance costs. If the insurance is very high, then obviously it's high-risk
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by SirSourdough on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:31AM (#36520103)
I’m sure it’s not the case that any random person can get a quote for something like this, but in the case of Titan the people who can afford the $250k ticket probably can.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by jprete on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:29AM (#36520091)
If someone can't even get an insurance quote, that is a very bad sign by itself that what they're proposing is already too risky.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by ghaff on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:53AM (#36520399)
Or that insurance companies (in general) have no way to evaluate the risk and therefore make a business decision not to play craps with their shareholder's money (and possibly their careers).
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by thunfischbrot on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:19AM (#36521570)
Which is similarly a sign that you might(!) also not be able to evaluate the risk.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by marsten on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:24PM (#36524628)
On the other hand, insurance companies may have no interest underwriting unusual risks when the business opportunity is small. "Deep-sea submarine tourism" is a tiny market.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by steveBK123 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:26PM (#36522641)
Lloyd's of London has entered the chat
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by throw7 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:18AM (#36520681)
Informed consent. I'd even say "rigorous, neutral, informed consent". And it's not only paying customers. Personally, I've always felt more angry about Christa McAuliffe. I'm not sure I'd go all the way with banning the general public altogether, but I suppose I'm open to it still.

Tip: hubris is a tell.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by LorenPechtel on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:10PM (#36522392)
The astronauts weren't informed with the problems with the boosters, either. The recovered hardware said the seals were frequently failing at ignition (as it goes from ambient to 1000 psi), just not to the point of destruction.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by mcpackieh on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:04PM (#36524304)
In fact the O-rings were never working as designed in the first place and NASA (but not necessarily those astronauts personally) knew it from the start. This was recognized early on in the program before the Shuttle ever flew. Those SRB joints were originally meant to have two O-rings as redundancy. But in testing they found that the first O-ring was being extruded, pushed past where it was meant to be into the joint and some hot gases were getting past it, meaning the second O-ring was no longer redundant. It was then determined that 'This is Fine'; instead of changing the design they changed the designation of the second o-ring to acknowledge that it was no longer redundant. They flew with that arrangement even though they already knew the primary O-rings didn't function correctly.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by spiderice on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:11PM (#36522407)
For those, like me, who had no idea what you’re talking about. From Wikipedia:

> In 1984, President Ronald Reagan announced the Teacher in Space Project, and McAuliffe learned about NASA's efforts to find their first civilian, an educator, to fly into space. NASA wanted to find an "ordinary person," a gifted teacher who could communicate with students while in orbit. McAuliffe became one of more than 11,000 applicants.

…

> On January 28, 1986, McAuliffe boarded Challenger with the other six crew members of STS-51-L. Only 73 seconds into its flight at an altitude of 48,000 ft (14.630 km), the shuttle broke apart, resulting in the deaths of all seven crew members

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by wkat4242 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:08PM (#36527465)
Yeah and the worst thing is they probably didn't even die in that 73rd second.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by vkou on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:30PM (#36523667)
> Christa McAuliffe

Wasn't drilling in the actual dangers of climbing onto the Space Shuttle, and that she was taking on the same kind of risk as a test pilot would part of her training?

If so, I don't see an issue. Going to space only looks safe in the movies and press releases, everyone actually working on it knows that it is an incredibly dangerous thing to do.

If it wasn't, NASA really dropped the ball on the training part.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by 1123581321 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:06PM (#36524341)
Perhaps if she was drilled on the risk of institutional failures. Even then, did she have the ability to comprehend them as the actual astronauts would have?
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by stickfigure on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:28AM (#36521748)
> cannot vet the safety of your device

Meh. The release forms were pretty clear. And if you aren't capable of judging the technical merit - well, that is a decision too. You're deciding to take a leap of unknown risk.

We need to stop being this judgy. People should be allowed to make decisions - including the decision to trust someone else - that turn out badly. They paid for those decisions both figuratively and literally. They weren't exactly tricked.

I think the good lesson here is that if you aren't capable of judging the risk of something, you shouldn't participate in it. Some people will violate that rule and some of those people will die. It's ok. People die for stupider reasons and nobody lives forever. It doesn't make the world a better place by trying to eliminate every possible source of death.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by rtkwe on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:41AM (#36521961)
Except basically all release forms include clauses about "risks of serious bodily injury or death" with the understanding that the people running whatever experience it is have done their job and are mitigating those risks. Instead Mr Death Sub here active ignored experts and violated tons of safety rule in favor of making money taking passengers down.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by tartoran on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:29PM (#36522695)
Yes, the risks are still there even with no safety violations. I bet it didn't say in the waiver forms that the viewport was only certified for 1300m and that they were going way lower than that. That should have been in red and bold text. A lot of people aren't qualified to asses risks and trusted the adults who unbeknownst to them were just wishful thinkers.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by stickfigure on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:27PM (#36524657)
> viewport was only certified for 1300m

The 1300m rated viewport was on the (retired/rebuilt) 1st gen sub, not the one that failed. If you pay attention to the photos, the Titan has an obviously different viewport.

If you are this mistaken on such a simple matter of fact, please look inward and maybe reconsider being so assertive and judgmental.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by giantrobot on Thursday June 29, 2023 @03:29PM (#36525543)
Oh, so they got a class rating for the sun and we can readily see all the paperwork about the equipment on this particular vehicle? I'm sure you'll be along soon to link to that documentation.

You won't because it doesn't fucking exist because there was zero certification of the vehicle. There's no way for potential customers to verify any safety claims of the sub.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by stickfigure on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:01PM (#36525905)
The sub was classified as experimental. That literally means "not certified". Everyone, including the people who signed the release forms, knew this.

You can, today, buy any manner of uncertified experimental aircraft and fly them in general aviation. What is the surprise? Experimental vehicles are a thing. If you don't like them, don't fly/float on them.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by PepperdineG on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:42PM (#36526437)
>You can, today, buy any manner of uncertified experimental aircraft and fly them in general aviation.

No you can't. Experimental aircraft have to get certified by the FAA.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by rtkwe on Friday June 30, 2023 @02:19PM (#36539714)
In the US there's only really one category can carry a person and is unregulated and unlicensed by the FAA and that's Ultralights [0]. <254 lbs dry excluding safety and floatation devices, <5 gallons of fuel capacity, <55 knots and there are strict restrictions on when and where they can fly.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultralight_aircraft_(United_St...

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by rtkwe on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:46PM (#36524927)
There's an implicit assumption that the providers/operators aren't being actively negligent both by the customers and backed up by the fact that negligence can pierce these kinds of releases in most cases.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by ofcourseyoudo on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:47AM (#36522046)
> I think the good lesson here is that if you aren't capable of judging the risk of something, you shouldn't participate in it.

A completely unsustainable philosophy. There's a threshold past which a customer certainly would be tricked, and it's possible this situation passes that threshold. We are in situations constantly where we are paying for the guidance and expertise of someone more experienced than us to navigate potentially dangerous situations.

> It doesn't make the world a better place by trying to eliminate every possible source of death.

Straw man.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by monkeynotes on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:48AM (#36522070)
It's not reasonable for regular people to understand the scale of those risks. I've watched video of a previous paying customer talking to Rush about the risks noted in the waiver, and he downplays it so much, almost mocking the very notion that the risk is unreasonable.

Imagine being told that the gluing of titanium to carbon fiber is a risk, but the guy telling you that is saying it's no big deal - just innovation. How are you supposed to have any meaningful understanding of that risk? Like is it a huge red flag or just a YOLO issue? I wouldn't know, I'd have to defer to the "experts" who I am entrusting my life to.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by mrguyorama on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:12PM (#36522416)
These by definition are not normal people. If you can afford a $250k ticket to the Titanic, you can afford to be properly informed about risk. Hell, you could literally hire your own engineer for a full year to evaluate that risk, go over things, and have money leftover to hire a lawyer to go through the CYA forms.

>I wouldn't know, I'd have to defer to the "experts" who I am entrusting my life to.

We shouldn't consider someone an expert just because they run a business. Stockton was clearly not an expert in any of this, except maybe marketing.

Shouldn't at the very least, rich people be expected to have some personal responsibility? They have no excuse.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by monkeynotes on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:33PM (#36522772)
Just because you are wealthy doesn't change anything. How are you supposed to know that the fact the pressure vessel isn't certified is a massive red flag, and not just a way to innovate more quickly? Rush painted industry safety as holding everything back and did not properly communicate that you should probably have an independent engineer review the risks. I mean, he was willing to go to the wreck with you, isn't that a hard endorsement of the risk being mitigated?

Again, watch some videos, he downplays the risk all the time. It's a form of manipulation, like buying a junk car from a used car salesman. Yes you could have a mechanic look at it, but it's such a great deal, if you walk away someone else will snap it up. All along the salesman is neglecting to mention the wheels are glued on because the bolts sheared, and the brake lines are held together with duct tape.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by rand846633 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:50AM (#36522104)
Hardly reasonable and practically not possible, the ideas that every person needs to understand every risk: Ever took any medication? Without the according PhDs??
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by Renaud on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:02PM (#36522270)
They actively sought tourists. Made them believe the system was safe, sufficiently enough to persuade them to get on board and pay $250k.

Had the company not be deluding itself and be more responsible, they would never have opened the sub to the public.

A test pilot or an astronaut are highly technical people who really understand the risks they get into. And they know that dying is not an unlikely event.

Expecting a 16 year old to be technically competent to know he shouldn't have boarded that death-trap is disingenuous.

You can only be capable of judging the risk of something if you're told the honest truth about the actual risk, or if you have enough inside knowledge to assess that risk. Dying because you've been tricked -lied- into thinking it's safe enough, is a high price to pay for anyone. Saying it's alright to die because you've been tricked is pretty callous.

With a company owner who shrugged off safety to the point of deluding himself, do you think the passengers had any honest way of knowing how unsafe that sub really was and make an informed decision?

It's easy to say they should have done due diligence after the fact. It's like blaming passengers from boarding a doomed flight with a maverick pilot who thinks loading the plane by 300% is alright because nothing ever happened before.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by stickfigure on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:56PM (#36525088)
Not a single one of these customers walked in off the street. This is not a mass-market product, it's incredibly bespoke. It's so new and experimental that nobody knows exactly how safe it is. That's why it's literally classed as experimental. There was no trickery here - hell, there are tons of stories from rich folks who declined a trip because they didn't think it was safe.

There's a long tradition of rich people getting themselves killed with experimental toys. Usually it's general aviation. Did John Denver know the risks of having the fuel tank selector valve over his left shoulder? Obviously not, or he probably wouldn't have crashed. But we let people buy and sell airplanes anyway - or at least, we did up until the 80s when we sued aircraft manufacturers into oblivion.

I'd rather live in a world with general aviation and a small but steady stream of deaths, rather than a world with no deaths because we've eliminated general aviation.

I ask you personally: Would you fly on a hypothetical next shuttle launch? Because I think most HNers would, even though the shuttle has historically had about a 2% failure rate. Which, if the 50 dives claimed by the oceangate website is correct, is on par with the Titan.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by comrh on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:14PM (#36522453)
Humans are terrible at judging risk though. I don't think I could accurately judge the risk of driving to the grocery store, let alone a trip to the Titanic.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by omginternets on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:25PM (#36522629)
>The release forms were pretty clear. And if you aren't capable of judging the technical merit - well, that is a decision too. You're deciding to take a leap of unknown risk.

There's an implicit assumption that the risks are somehow reasonable, or at the very least, that the other party isn't being reckless or negligent.

If you ride a roller coaster after signing such a disclaimer, it's still reasonable to expect that people are tightening the damn bolts. And it's insane to expect both roller coasters to remain a viable business and individual riders to check that they are safe. At best, your attitude makes it nigh impossible to conduct business.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by smileysteve on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:12PM (#36524455)
People have died at theme parks, and just as relevantly at local fairs because people aren't "tightening the damn bolts" and because parks didn't hire engineers. How many elevators skip on maintenance and inspection during Covid.

Only a few states have roadworthiness inspections of vehicles; and Tesla autopilot may have driven into a truck; Or we could talk about texting while driving and drunk driving that endanger others, yet 60%/30% of Americans admit to it regularly, while 30k people die.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by omginternets on Friday June 30, 2023 @03:30AM (#36531660)
And?
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by vkou on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:24PM (#36523582)
> The release forms were pretty clear.

They are the same release forms that you'll see when you pay some college kid $90 to take you down some cat 3 rapids.

The difference in risk involved in those two activities is many orders of magnitude. As is the difference in recklessness and 'yolo' mindset of the vendor.

A release form isn't an excuse to operate your firm in an unsafe[1] manner.

[1] 'Safe' is defined 'as safe as can be reasonably made, given what we know'. The Titan did not meet this criteria.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by rfwhyte on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:55PM (#36524137)
No, WE need to be MORE "Judgey" because one of the critical elements you're conveniently leaving out here is WE spent literally tens if not hundreds of millions of dollars of OUR tax money searching for a sub full of rich, arrogant CEOs and Tourists who may have spent their own money going down, but who offloaded / externalized 100% of the responsibility and expense of any potential search and rescue effort to the taxpaying public.

OceanGate had no rescue plan! Their entire "Plan" for what to do WHEN, not if, something went wrong, was to call in the coast guard / navy and have the taxpayer fund their rescue and from where I'm sitting this whole oeuvre of dangerous, rich-guy-ego-stroking vanity bullshit is an egregiously entitled abuse of the commons that should regulated out of existence with extreme prejudice.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by giantrobot on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:50PM (#36524998)
> We need to stop being this judgy. People should be allowed to make decisions - including the decision to trust someone else

The important distinction is whether people can make an informed decision to trust someone. If you're going to take non-expert passengers on some experimental craft and using loopholes like labeling them as "crew" I don't think you can say they're really making an informed decision.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by wkat4242 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:03PM (#36527404)
I don't know. People take all kinds of stupid risks all the time. Life is dangerous, you are guaranteed to die.

Some people might just figure that a once in a lifetime experience is worth it even knowing it's dangerous.

I'm not sure a full risk analysis is really needed here. As long as the participants knew there was a real risk they'd die, perhaps it was worth it to them.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by flangola7 on Friday June 30, 2023 @06:48AM (#36532761)
You can't waive gross negligence. Those waiver forms will be tossed aside the moment they come front of a judge.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by grecy on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:09PM (#36522373)
I prefer to let people make their own choices, otherwise the alternative might just be to ban everyone from doing everything even remotely dangerous anywhere on the entire planet (who's laws will apply?)

If people want to do risky things, that's their business.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by rfwhyte on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:57PM (#36524167)
Bullshit. When the expectation is that we'll fund any potential rescue efforts when something invariably goes wrong with our tax dollars, it becomes the rest of our business pretty damn quickly.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by grecy on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:01PM (#36525912)
Back country skiing? sky diving? Scuba diving? Hiking deep into the wilderness?

All of those require search and rescue type operations, should we ban them?

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by steveBK123 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:32PM (#36522758)
I think there's an argument that even crazy unsafe stuff that only harms yourself shouldn't be exempt from regulatory frameworks purely on the "personal harm only" basis.

Stuff like this triggers costly (and sometimes dangerous) search & rescue parties.

A regular boat has to be registered in most US states. I'm not a boating expert, but it would seem some combination of "well its not a boat" & "International waters" lead to it being less regulated/inspected than Joe 6 packs fishing boat.

Or more specifically, because the sub is taken out to international waters by its support ship, it would seem the sub falls under less regulation than the support ship carrying it, despite being a higher risk profile..

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by asfarley on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:35PM (#36522797)
It doesn’t need to, you could put yourself on a risky-behavior list which would result in skipping the search.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by SketchySeaBeast on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:16PM (#36523446)
Yeah, sign a DNR - Do not recover.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by Thrymr on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:40PM (#36523853)
By international maritime law, any ship at sea is required to assist in search and rescue, if they can do so safely and there is a chance of saving lives. That doesn't mean everyone is required to send expensive assets for deep sea recovery of debris and remains, but for that time that there seemed like there was a chance, however remote, that the submersible might be bobbing on the surface with no way to open the hatch, there was a real legal obligation to search if possible.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by everforward on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:14PM (#36537627)
An interesting counterpoint is that these people are pushing science and engineering forward, and are risking their own time, money and lives in the process. Attempting to rescue them seems like a fair trade.

I don't think this situation is a particularly good example, but I don't think blanket condemning experimental deep sea vehicles is the right response.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by frollo on Friday June 30, 2023 @02:28PM (#36539850)
But they aren't. As we see here, there was a pretty solid wall of consensus saying that the sub was a death trap. Heck, the reason why it was the only submarine built with carbon fiber is something an engineering undergrad can grasp at glance.

Not only that, but we have known how to reach ever lower depths for decades now. A human being has already reached the bottom of the Challenger Abyss. We know how to do this stuff and, while there's certainly room for improvements, ignoring the properties of the materials you're using and not doing proper testing is not how you get any improvement done. At best, all the advancement this tragedy will bring is a more comprehensive regulation of this kind of activities. Which is exactly what the original Titanic brought to the world.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by HWR_14 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:03PM (#36524286)
We have "accredited investors" whose wealth and sophistication makes them able to take financial risks in unregulated markets where scams would destroy naive investors. I think it's perfectly reasonable to say that any billionaire entering a dangerous situation can have or access whatever experts on risk mitigation they want. I have no sympathy towards the "cannot vet the safety" argument.

If it was regular tourists who save up for a once in a lifetime experience, I would feel differently.

Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by sugarkjube on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:50PM (#36524996)
I'm pretty sure they only went because the CEO/owner went along. Seems like a reasonable assumption to make as a customer that the CEO wouldn't risk his life.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by HWR_14 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:19PM (#36526134)
Again, they don't have to make assumptions. They can have their own engineers provide due diligence. These are people who can trivially afford that level of care on an experimental submersible.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by flangola7 on Friday June 30, 2023 @06:13AM (#36532578)
Making the argument that customers should have had their own engineers conduct an assessment if they wanted safety is definitely a solid plan if your goal is to be torn to sheds by the judge/jury.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by HWR_14 on Friday June 30, 2023 @10:09PM (#36545613)
I'm sure the legal case before the judge is "check page 2, subsection 4 of our indemnity clause" and the case is tossed before it even gets to the jury. I'm specifically talking about people trying risky things. And yes, billionaires who want to risk their lives on experimental deadly craft should hire engineers.
Re:Submarine expert tried to dissuade OceanGate CEO, from ta... by fatfingerd on Thursday June 29, 2023 @03:22PM (#36525456)
I don't really see much difference between this and the most expensive/extreme tourist mountain climbing. Plenty of people die on adventures with things where they don't really understand much and put their trust in paid experienced guides.

Its not unusual for a death to be caused by the expert guides being wrong and in the minority of opinion on the right way to do something or planners being wrong on how many tourists can be handled, which tourists are fit enough, etc.

I think many more people who already survived a one time sub trip with that company will ultimately die in safer equipment due to cumulative risk, so one really has to factor in quality of life explanations to argue it is unacceptable, but then maybe from a quality of life POV a once in a lifetime trip was fine.

The real issue I think is the pilot risk which wasn't approaching 100% only because there were other failures that could have shelved the sub besides catastrophic ones.