News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by londons_explore on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:16AM (#36183939)
This article doesn't explain one interesting bit:

It is important that these crushed stones stay clean. If dirt gets in them, known as fouling, filling the gaps between the stones, then eventually it will cause a derailment.

Briefly, the stones move slightly as each train passes above them. The tracks 'float' on the denser stone. This effect helps keep the track straight and level - higher regions get pushed down, while lower regions raise themselves up.

Fouling stops this effect, and eventually the track will become so uneven that a derailment happens.

To prevent this, a big part of railway maintenance involves digging out all the stones, washing them to get rid of sand and soil, and putting them back. Usually done every 25 years or so.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by noja on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:31AM (#36184020)
> To prevent this, a big part of railway maintenance involves digging out all the stones, washing them to get rid of sand and soil, and putting them back. Usually done every 25 years or so.

Is this that? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WqLynLWLd8Y

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by dotancohen on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:45AM (#36184080)
I think that the title suggests that is repositioning the stones (ballast). This video seems to be of the cleaning process:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XWjUZJtR610

I could be wrong, I had never heard of this fascinating maintenance until this very moment.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by bombcar on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:03AM (#36184650)
I love the response:

>BOURLEZ RENOVATION

9 months ago

Why is it?

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Sharlin on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:42AM (#36185177)
Tamping is also of critical importance when tracks are first laid; they’re quite uneven at first (visibly wonky) and the tamper evens out the ballast to achieve the extremely smooth geometry required.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by codethief on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:46AM (#36184083)
I know nothing about this topic at all but, having browsed Wikipedia for a bit, the machine from the video looks very much like a tamping machine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tamping_machine (The video title also says "tamper")
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by olejorgenb on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:50AM (#36184108)
In the comments they say that "tampering"[1] is done once every year and the wiki page does not mention cleaning as an objective. Tamping is done to readjust the ballast making the track more more level and durable. (One can infer it does some cleaning as well - getting rid of the topmost dust layer)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNFUgTJR6jw seems to be the full cleaning procedure

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tamping_machine

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by codethief on Sunday June 04, 2023 @05:02AM (#36184149)
According to the description of the video you posted, the ballast cleaning machine is then followed by a track laying machine, https://youtube.com/watch?v=tMXfU8blPMM . What an incredible machine!

> they say that "tampering"[1]

I believe you mean tamping. :-)

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by zo1 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:40AM (#36184822)
Looking at that machine I'm amazed that we as a society are not advancing further. We have incredible engineering feats like that, yet at the same time, we have rampant poverty, homelessness, polluted oceans, smog clouds, and thousands of others.

That thing is a moving synchronized orchestra of a mini-factory, carrying it's own inventory and moving on the same railway track that it's servicing/fixing. And here I am, can barely coral a bunch of juniors to fix a basic CRUD app.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by hgsgm on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:51AM (#36184888)
Controlling rocks is easy. Controlling people is hard.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by datavirtue on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:43AM (#36185187)
The various cults make it look easy.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by FartyMcFarter on Sunday June 04, 2023 @01:46PM (#36187673)
They target the most vulnerable people.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by ttjjtt on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:40PM (#36188819)
I’ve known several people who have been recruited into a particular death cult and they are/were very high performing individuals with very stable backgrounds ie strong social network with plenty of resources of all kinds. Confident upper middle class successful entrepreneur types.

You haven’t described accurately who is at risk from cults, at all. Think of the idea that every religion could be reasonably described as an established cult.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by CPLX on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:24AM (#36185060)
Austrians have a long history of coming up with efficient engineering projects involving trains.

Worth noting though that until more recently they had some challenges focusing on the right goals.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by roelschroeven on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:57AM (#36184132)
No, that's a tamping machine: it packs ballast to level tracks. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tamping_machine
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by weinzierl on Sunday June 04, 2023 @05:38AM (#36184295)
That was more insightful than the whole article. Another thing I was curious about but not answered from the article is if there are any alternatives.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by A321321 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @05:46AM (#36184327)
Yes, there is. High speed rail quite often uses ballastless track [0]

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballastless_track

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by fsckboy on Sunday June 04, 2023 @06:02AM (#36184379)
TL;DR "ballastless track" is track rigidly set in concrete instead of the aforementioned floating, but it must be done to very tight tolerances and is expensive
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by weinzierl on Sunday June 04, 2023 @06:24AM (#36184461)
If the tracks are rigidly set in concrete, how do they deal with thermal expansion then? Roads made from concrete usually have gaps every couple of meters, but you can't have that many gaps in railroad tracks I suppose.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by bombcar on Sunday June 04, 2023 @06:59AM (#36184624)
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by michaelt on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:01AM (#36184636)
First of all, in the images shown in that article the rail clips are rigidly set in concrete, and the rails are clipped in place. With enough force they can slide longitudinally in the clips.

Second, in most modern rail installations the track is pre-tensioned to deal with thermal expansion. The track is stretched with a hydraulic tool and welded while under tension, so thermal expansion just means reduced tension. This is why trains on modern rail lines don't make the familiar click-clack sound.

(How much tension is applied depends on the country and weather - you can choose between tolerating high temperatures and tolerating low temperatures. This is why in the UK, there are sometimes train stoppages in very hot weather)

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by atentaten on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:51AM (#36184887)
>trains on modern rail lines don't make the familiar click-clack sound.

What does the click-clack sound have to do with thermal expansion? Is it because the track is expanding as the train moves over it, if so what’s causing that sound signature?

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by mauvehaus on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:59AM (#36184920)
It comes from the wheels passing over the joints in the track segments. Track that isn't continuously welded is made of individual pieces of rail joined at the ends with a fishplate:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fishplate

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Ensorceled on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:59AM (#36184925)
The expansion gaps.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by ThePowerOfFuet on Sunday June 04, 2023 @09:22AM (#36185391)
The sound is produced by the wheels passing over the small gaps between the unwelded sections of rail.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by donavanm on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:07AM (#36184667)
Theyre not set “in” concrete. The rails are still connected to the sleeper/tie via a fixing plate/spring/shoe, allowing horizontal movement between them. There are still gaps with the concrete bed for that thermal expansion as well.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by tififtivfj on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:59AM (#36185261)
No. I think your understanding is faulty. The rails are hundreds of meters long: the longitudinal expansion would still have to be accounted for somewhere.

The rails are firmly fixed, longitudinally as well as laterally, with pretensioning in order to minimise stress as they heat up. This is true with ties as much as with a concrete bed.

https://interfacejournal.com/archives/644

"There are a number of ways to increase the resistance of rail to buckling. The first and most common is the use of rail anchors to limit the longitudinal expansion of the rail. Anchors come in a variety of designs, but they all apply several thousand pounds of clamping force on the base of the rail. When applied properly against each side of the crossties, the anchors prevent expansion of the rail in the longitudinal direction."

The general approach is described here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rail_stressing

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by jhallenworld on Sunday June 04, 2023 @10:32AM (#36185885)
Interesting! One argument I see against hyperloop is the need for expensive vacuum bellows to deal with thermal expansion. I wonder if there is a locked in place solution like this that could eliminate the need for them.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by numpad0 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @01:30PM (#36187524)
I don't think you could just pre-tension rails so much and be done with it somehow, considering... temperature of a rail can probably stretch between -10 to +50C, and coefficient of expansion for steel is 12*10^-6/K, let delta T = 60K and joined rail length = 1km, the expansion can be +/-36cm(~1.2ft). At some point, the error can be more than one rail segment worth, and maybe it's just me but I can't imagine that amount of expansion just solved by clever tensioning alone.

Usually they are joined to a rail with a slant cut or a tongue section at ends, and let ride into the opposing cuts/tongues, IIUC.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by newaccount74 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @06:17PM (#36190117)
The pre-tensioning isn't what prevents expansion.

The rail can only expand if it can move. If the rail is clamped down tightly to the sleepers, and the sleepers are tightly packed in the ballast, then it just doesn't expand. The only thing that happens is that stress increases / decreases as temperature changes.

The pre-tensioning is only to ensure that the average tension in rail in the course of an average year is in a certain range.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by numpad0 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @11:43PM (#36191988)
wtf.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by delta_p_delta_x on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:04AM (#36184655)
To add on, a lot of underground mass rapid transit uses ballastless track, too.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Sharlin on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:38AM (#36185151)
And street-level light rail, for the obvious reason of sharing the street (even if not lanes) with other vehicles, as well as aesthetics.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by moooo99 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @05:49AM (#36184341)
> if there are any alternatives.

There are. There are ballastless tracks that utilize a continuous concrete slab instead of the crushed rock ballast. Their main benefit is that they are lower mamintenance than their counterparts, but their upfront cost tends to be higher and construction takes longer, making them difficult to retrofit onto existing stretches (would require long closures).

However, the low maintenance nature of this style makes it popular at locations where maintenance is very difficult (long tunnels, etc) or where loads are particularly high, either due lots of use or high speeds, like with new HSR construction.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by jojobas on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:34AM (#36184795)
High speed rail track also don't use expansion joints, the rails are continuously welded, which means that instead of expanding/contracting with seasons, they pack quite some tension or compression, which is basically worn by the strength and friction of these concrete slabs.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by CPLX on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:14AM (#36185005)
They do use expansion joints they’re just a little more modern now. Look up “breather switch” for examples. Another common technique is to install the track already heated so it can’t get even larger and buckle.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by jojobas on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:30AM (#36185103)
They only use them where needed for other purposes (i.e. electric isolation). They don't require joints for thermal purposes.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by chiph on Sunday June 04, 2023 @10:11AM (#36185741)
They do (sometimes) preheat continuous welded rail during installation to prevent buckling. The temperature used will vary based on the local environment (Minnesota will use a lower destressing temperature than Florida). Shorter sections of track (like in a switching yard) may not be destressed at all because there isn't enough length to cause a buckle.

> Compressive forces result from stresses induced in a constrained rail by temperature above its "stress free" state, and from mechanical sources such as braking, rolling friction and wheel flanging on curves. The temperature of the rail at the "stress-free" state is known as the rail neutral temperature (i.e. the temperature at which the rail experiences zero longitudinal force). Initially, the rail's installation temperature or "anchoring temperature" is the rail's neutral temperature. Hence, at rail temperatures above the neutral, compressive forces are generated, and at temperatures below the neutral, tensile forces are developed. Track maintenance practices address the high thermal load problem by anchoring the rail at (neutral) temperature of 95 -110 F. This high neutral temperature range prevents the generation of excessively high buckling forces even when the rail temperatures reach 130 -150 F.

https://www.volpe.dot.gov/infrastructure-systems-and-technol...

Some railroads that experience wide summer vs. winter temperature differences may choose to install expansion joints. Like most things, there are trade-offs, like increased maintenance costs and increased chance of derailment at the joint.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Animats on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:13PM (#36187952)
Welded rail buckling in hot weather has become a real issue with global warming and wider temperature swings.[1][2] Australia has especially bad problems, due to wide temperature swings and very long runs of straight track.

[1] https://toolkit.climate.gov/topics/transportation-and-supply...

[2] https://thelincolnite.co.uk/2015/07/kink-in-track-freight-tr...

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by moooo99 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:27PM (#36188109)
There was a lot of reporting regarding the same issue in the UK last year

https://www.itv.com/news/anglia/2022-07-19/why-cant-uk-roads...

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by chiph on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:49PM (#36188905)
When I was in London in the early 2000's, the Central Line was closed because of the heat damaging the tracks (they never used the word buckle in their announcement, but that was probably what happened). If they have a track problem that far under ground, it's a serious heat wave.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by moooo99 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:04PM (#36189056)
> If they have a track problem that far under ground, it's a serious heat wave.

Unintuitively, parts of the London underground are notorious for being extremely hot. Especially the central line is super hot due to the material the tunnels are dug into being an extremely good insulator/heat store.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/lauriewinkless/2017/06/22/sweat...

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by namibj on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @02:06PM (#36216765)
It's also that they don't cool the tunnels like they really really ought to (just feed frozen water into the tunnels and drag the meltwater back out if it won't drain by itself, say by fitting some cars with slush sprayers like how manure is sprayed from the back of a tanker on agricultural fields, or dropping ice cubes spread-about).

Use ice-based AC for the passengers, not heat pumps dumping into the tunnels.

Change the breaking resistors to not be on the train, but the rectifier stations, and make them vent outside. Or change them to dump heat into what's a big insulated kettle that gets filled with ice or at least disposes the resulting hot water outside, not hot air into the tunnels.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by whiplash451 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @10:26AM (#36185839)
Just curious: what's the benefit of installing them pre-heated vs installing them at air temperature with a slight expansion space between them? I assume that when they are installed pre-heated, the first thing they do is cool down and contract.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by shaoonb on Sunday June 04, 2023 @11:15AM (#36186262)
Expansion gaps limit the speed the trains can run at.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Someone on Sunday June 04, 2023 @12:44PM (#36187085)
Isn’t the main issue that they cause a lot more wear on train wheels, making it a very bad idea to run them at speed?
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by systems_glitch on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:22PM (#36188057)
Must be something like that, we used to run 120 MPH on bolted rail and steam.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by istjohn on Sunday June 04, 2023 @01:03PM (#36187264)
Perhaps they just go into tension when they cool? I believe tracks would have much more strength in tension than in compression.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by andylynch on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:35PM (#36188191)
They do indeed. Railway tracks under compression from overheating are prone to bend like spaghetti (this is bad!).
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by namibj on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @01:52PM (#36216575)
One reason why inductive breaking (Wirbelstrombremse) is only allowed on "feste Fahrbahn" (ballast less track) for Germany's high speed ICE (inter City express) trains, at least as a service brake.

On some ballasted track they're allowed for emergency breaking ("Schnellbremsung"), as they can interfere with equipment like axle counters.

This is done because they have to wait for the track to cool before they are able to safely drive on it after it got heated.

These are btw just a linear induction motor with the field coils locked to standstill.

I have since wondered about using this for traction, as it's likely not too efficient but ought to have potential for a much simpler drive train, using much longer parts of rail under the vehicle to get the desired force with a low slip (and thus low rail heating).

Say, for vehicles that don't normally need (this much) acceleration, and would thus prefer few/no driven axles.

We are at a point where power electronics are cheaper than some traditional transformer technology, and being able to deliver high accelerations (on the order of 3~6 m/s²) near zero speed to regional trains could vastly improve their average speed.

Just make the people have a wall/backrest and those forces are harmless. Turn them around for the next stop if you want to brake that quickly or use it to catch up a small train car to a full trai;, have two stories, walkway backwards on top, forwards bottom, and drop the tail off from the through train after it has exchanged people. Don't need seats there, just walls at, like, shoulder width pitch, to let people stand with their back in the right direction.

If only track pairs were more cleanly parallel, you could just have bridges and let people transfer to and from the fast through train using a local access facilitator train. That in particular would also let you catch a connecting train without either of them slowing down (a lot) to provide this opportunity, which might even be the bigger benefit.

Sadly trains take ages to board lengthwise as European track clearance gauge doesn't allow for two proper unidirectional lanes of people traffic with decent cross section left for seating, so you'd have to spread the arrival/departure shuttles between front and back for a single dominant people traffic direction (from arrival seat to their transit seat and onwards to their departure seat).

I guess you could work around by using distinct small shuttles that maybe briefly combine for aerodynamics, in relative breaking distance w.r.t. service brakes, and respond to a switch that doesn't reach a safe locked end position by unfolding wave breaker barricades into the gangway (articulated so that they naturally support people leaning against them due to deceleration forces, so they get kinda pushed into place by people using them) and alerting passengers about the imminent rapid coordinated deceleration. A couple seconds notice should suffice to let people move to hold onto their stuff that'd otherwise go flying from a G of deceleration.

Coming to a stop from 300km/h takes 2.3km (27.8s of travel) at 1.5m/s² (the AFAIK limit for normal standard train carriages to match how the passengers behave), but at 10m/s² it only takes 247m (4.2s of travel).

This would be the minimum dead space/time to stop safely in case a switch fails to transition. Regroup convoys between branching points a bit, and you could run at current-day capacity levels despite most carriages not stopping at any given station (the others just skip past as they didn't branch off).

Honestly I still wonder if suspension rail system Eugen-Langen isn't better for high speed people transport due to the severe passive tilt capability (+-15° in production for a century; +-30° tested (the production deployment wasn't authorized to anywhere near it's tilt angle speed limit for many years, and the frequent stops/stations didn't make that angle look restrictive for the technology at the time: the track isn't even banked as far as I know!)), especially because you don't typically want to share track between high speed people transport and generic mainline rail traffic.

Not needing the extensive tunneling/wide-span bridging ought to make the track suspension requirement worthwhile... Particularly with how cheap we can make steel truss sections in automated factories, and e.g. sling it under the track for transport to installation site. Drop it for the irregular junction areas, and just put cheap normal rail to wheel the segments across the junction.

Roller coaster technology has made the needed fast track switches a proven technology, too. (It's really similar to a suspension rollercoaster just with motors and an electric "3rd" rail.)

I for one can't wait for full ETCS Level 3 to become a thing used in production.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Zardoz84 on Monday June 05, 2023 @06:52AM (#36194668)
Expansion gaps, generates the "classic" train noise.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by psychphysic on Sunday June 04, 2023 @01:49PM (#36187689)
I believe it's also louder, with a worse ride.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by moooo99 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:24PM (#36188072)
At least anecdotally I can say worse ride performance is not true. Lower noise emission is hard to tell as a passenger, but seems to to be the consensus in the literature I found. Thats probably among the reasons these tracks are usually only installed on stretches not running through any towns/cities.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by namibj on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @02:10PM (#36216842)
Nah, just use noise absorber instead of bare flat concrete; e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escher_Stra%C3%9Fe_station shows some tactics for silencing ballast less track (not in the wiki article itself, sadly).
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by landemva on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:08PM (#36189095)
I have run a locomotive in a tunnel on concrete slab. Low temperature range for the air. The air had high humidity due to persistent water leakage. We didn't do much track maintenance and simply went slowly on bad sections of rail.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Zardoz84 on Monday June 05, 2023 @06:52AM (#36194663)
I see this type of ballastless tracks on the big train stations on Madrid (Spain)
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by matthewmacleod on Sunday June 04, 2023 @05:56AM (#36184359)
The alternative is generally some form of ballastless or slab track – https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballastless_track - essentially rail fixed directly to a concrete substrate using a variety of different approaches. Lower maintainance costs at the expense of higher installation costs, and most often seen on high-speed systems, tunnels etc.

There are also various forms of baulk track – https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baulk_road - in which the rails are supported longitudinally with regular tie-bars to maintain gauge. I don’t think this is used much outside of some specialist applications.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by throw0101b on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:00AM (#36184934)
> To prevent this, a big part of railway maintenance involves digging out all the stones, washing them to get rid of sand and soil, and putting them back.

This is called "ballast cleaning" if anyone wants to do a search:

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNFUgTJR6jw

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballast_cleaner

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by noveltyaccount on Sunday June 04, 2023 @09:57AM (#36185654)
Cool video. That machine is incredible.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by myself248 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @11:03AM (#36186138)
Wild.

The workers seem to be wearing the amount of PPE that I'd want if I was just walking along downwind, but nowhere near the amount I'd want if I was working in the thick of things 8 hours a day. I wonder what their lung disease rates are like.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by cratermoon on Sunday June 04, 2023 @12:07PM (#36186702)
The ones I see are wearing N-95 masks or equivalent. I'm no expert, but based on what I've learned since early 2020 I'd say that's plenty, provided they only use them for one day and toss them out.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by MarkusWandel on Sunday June 04, 2023 @01:22PM (#36187456)
Steam locomotives, at least, used total loss lubrication. Their brakes were made of asbestos. And a good preservative for railroad ties was creosote. Never mind the stuff they spray to keep vegetation at bay. So even I would probably be wanting to wear an N95 mask if exposed to dust from that stuff all day.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Gare on Sunday June 04, 2023 @06:49PM (#36190301)
> And a good preservative for railroad ties was creosote.

Still is. There is even an EU exception to the ban because no replacement was good enough.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by cratermoon on Sunday June 04, 2023 @10:06PM (#36191458)
Pro tip: never use railroad ties or any part of a railroad tie in your campfire.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by swader999 on Monday June 05, 2023 @07:33AM (#36194910)
Don't use any kind of treated wood.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Symbiote on Monday June 05, 2023 @06:48AM (#36194638)
In this case it's a high speed line which will never have seen a steam locomotive, and where most trains will use dynamic braking (returning the power to the electricity grid, or else dumping it into resistors).
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by wussboy on Sunday June 04, 2023 @10:25AM (#36185837)
I think I made a Factorio like this once.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Invictus0 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @10:47AM (#36185999)
Prior to this machine existing, was ballast just not cleaned and there were more frequent derailments?
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by wizzwizz4 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @10:55AM (#36186062)
According to the Wikipedia article:

> In the 19th century and early 20th century, ballast was shoveled or forked, then screened by hand using portable devices.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by londons_explore on Sunday June 04, 2023 @11:09AM (#36186206)
"Here is 1000 miles of railway. Each yard of that railway has 1000 lbs of crushed rock under it. Your job is to pick it all up, put it through this sieve, and put it back. I will employ you for $1 a month for 50 years to get the job done. Do we have a deal?"
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by morkalork on Sunday June 04, 2023 @11:54AM (#36186583)
Throw in room and board and you've got yourself a deal!
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by cratermoon on Sunday June 04, 2023 @12:08PM (#36186719)
Mostly the railroads employed thousands of immigrants from China, treating them pretty much how you'd expect Americans to treat migrant labor. https://americanhistory.si.edu/american-enterprise/new-persp...
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by lttlrck on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:15PM (#36187977)
"Americans"

You have a valid point, they were treated like shit but talk about broad-strokes...

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by cratermoon on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:17PM (#36188577)
As an American, I am not afraid to acknowledge the true history of my country.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by stormfather on Monday June 05, 2023 @10:28AM (#36196633)
Did any country at that time period treat migrant laborers better?
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by pbhjpbhj on Sunday June 04, 2023 @12:14PM (#36186781)
Ha. That takes me back to a job I had once ...

No-one asked, but ... I worked at a power station one Summer, my job was to clean the filters at the bottom of the cooling tower. The filter was a stack of plastic bricks; each brick about 1m x 1m x 2m that were a mesh of orthogonal perforated plastic panels with a spacing of maybe 8cm or so. The filter was stacked about 5 "bricks" deep. We washed the bricks under a running hose of about 20cm diameter, standing in water all day; shaking out the mud. The bricks were heavy because they were full of what seemed like river mud. The detritus from the bricks fell down into the pond below the cooling tower, about 20m beneath us. Small skid-steer cat loaders dug out the pond.

I had a runner's build and was being paid £2.70 an hour (late 1990s); the other guys had weight-lifter builds and were on >£10 (they travelled around the country doing the same job, there wage was good money for low-skilled work at the time). I found out that the agency were being paid about £10 for me ... stood in dirty water all day, with the fall risk, the low wage, ... wasn't great. Then I had to quit because of injury after a few weeks. Knee was never the same.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by namibj on Tuesday June 06, 2023 @12:12PM (#36214991)
That's not a filter, that's structured packing to give the water a large surface area to evaporate from. Or possibly used as a drop catcher with spray nozzles underneath; either way the gas stream hits the surface without excess wasteful turbulence.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by ycombinete on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:24PM (#36188644)
I’m guessing this machine ate hundreds/thousands of jobs
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by iancmceachern on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:07AM (#36192135)
And took hundreds to design and build
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by toomuchtodo on Sunday June 04, 2023 @10:52AM (#36186037)
The railroad tie/“sleeper” page is equally interesting:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railroad_tie

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by vinhboy on Sunday June 04, 2023 @11:06AM (#36186177)
That's probably like one of the coolest purpose built machine I've ever seen. In my head I originally thought they did it by hand, lol.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by mjrpes on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:25PM (#36188090)
You'll love the railway track laying machine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMXfU8blPMM
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by cshimmin on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:15PM (#36189168)
Yikes, that guy just sitting underneath the moving gantry loaded with tons of sleepers... And then the other fellow crawling in between the wheels of the whole machine _while it is moving_... Do they not have something like OSHA wherever this was filmed??

Also, disappointing they didn't actually show the new railstock being laid, just the ballast and sleepers :/

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by dx034 on Monday June 05, 2023 @05:26AM (#36194148)
That was filmed in Germany, I would think safety rules are similarly to the US. Maybe it's not as dangerous as it looks at first glance.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by throwbadubadu on Monday June 05, 2023 @07:11AM (#36194782)
Definitely! A train on the train, lovely real yo dawg (:
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by SECProto on Sunday June 04, 2023 @11:37AM (#36186439)
Great video. Most neat parts for me:

- Removing the ballast from a section at a time to do the cleaning means that the rails and sleepers are floating in the air (~1:30 to 2:35)

- They're doing all this work, including transferring waste to another train, underneath catenary wires. low clearance!! (3:40 to 5:20)

Also important to note, they aren't so much washing the stones (though that may be part of the process), they're sieving (grading) the stones to remove everything that's under a specific size (looks like they're removing everything that passes a ~25mm/1" sieve, but scale in a video can be deceiving). Rail ballast is very uniformly graded, i.e. every piece of aggregate is about the same size. Vibrations over time will cause edges of the stones to chip and wear down, with these chips contaminating the ballast. It also leads to rounding of the aggregate, so there's less interlock between the particles.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by rootw0rm on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:08PM (#36188501)
reminds me of how specific they were with crushed stone sizes while developing the first roadways for cars
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by SECProto on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:24PM (#36189247)
I don't know much about the earliest car roadways, do you have a link with some info?

Granular gradation is still a major part of modern roadway construction, there are just certain standards that are very typical so they get used without too much thought required. For some applications a visual inspection is enough, but there's generally some standard proportion of sieve analysis required (eg. 1 test per 10000tonne produced), along with proctor tests (to determine maximum dry density) and frequent nuclear densitometry. I've even seen loads of aggregate get rejected due to the large aggregate being too oblongated.

When you get into concrete or asphalt mix design, the aggregate standards can be even more strict - chemical makeup of the stone can be important to avoid alkali-silica reaction; minimizing fines increases the strength of asphalt mix but creates a tougher riding surface; etc etc etc.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Symbiote on Monday June 05, 2023 @06:43AM (#36194609)
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macadam#McAdam's_methods, but it's the first roadways for carriages, not cars.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Breza on Monday June 12, 2023 @08:27AM (#36292347)
> A workman could check the stone size himself by seeing if the stone would fit into his mouth.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by ethbr0 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @10:33PM (#36191615)
The sequencing was fascinating!

I'd never considered how much "it helps to have rail, to replace rail" impacted the process -- but it makes sense as everything is incredibly heavy! (Rails, sleepers, aggregate)

From that perspective, of course you'd excavate and clean the track ballast while you're also on the same track. And same with sleeper and track replacement.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Symbiote on Monday June 05, 2023 @06:38AM (#36194577)
We don't see any tank wagons, and there would be no other possible water supply, so I don't think they are washing the stones. Given it gets rained on anyway, I doubt there would much benefit.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by jccooper on Sunday June 04, 2023 @12:16PM (#36186813)
Here's a bit closer look at the mechanics: https://www.plasseramerican.com/en/machines-systems/ballast-...
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by gleenn on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:09PM (#36187899)
SSL cert expired 1 day ago on this linked page FYI
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by mgerdts on Sunday June 04, 2023 @12:31PM (#36186959)
The next video in my feed explained a more complete rehab, including replacement of the sleepers (ties) and rails while allowing the adjacent track to stay in service. F’n amazing.

https://youtu.be/7zsyMxRnQ68

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by fdomig on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:05PM (#36187863)
Awesome. I didn't expect my country to appear as an example for such an engineering masterpiece. Thanks for sharing.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by qingcharles on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:37PM (#36188792)
Unreal. I was stood on the platform two days ago wondering why tracks have ballast and how it was kept so clean, and today I'm watching the most incredible process and machinery that answers my question. I have a totally new respect for train tracks now.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by WastingMyTime89 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:43PM (#36189394)
I worked for different parts of the national railway company of my country (France) for four years (circulations management and scheduling mostly - briefly on a CBTC system and the first studies on autonomous driving). It’s hard to understand how complicated it is to keep trains running if you haven’t experienced it.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by rkagerer on Monday June 05, 2023 @02:05AM (#36192948)
I wonder how that will compare to keeping Starships running to/from Mars.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by red-iron-pine on Monday June 05, 2023 @11:59AM (#36198251)
Aviation and Space has a lot of challenges, but also a lot of flexibility.

Planes, for example, can share the same geographic location -- just at different altitudes; e.g. 25000 ft vs 33000 ft vs 45000 ft., etc. After a certain altitude there isn't anything. No clouds, no birds, just air; set your auto-pilot and go. Takeoff and Landing can be hairy, and you gotta worry about mountains, but that's about it. A basic radar makes it easy to see, and not hard to broadcast by radio.

Same basic idea for space. Gotta get out of orbit and not get cooked by radiation, but otherwise there is a whole lotta empty, and it's not hard to see what's going on with things like radar.

On the ground it ain't so simple. Someone stuck on a rail, avalances, bridge collapses, hills vs inclines, snow / ice / rain / high-winds, and no ability to multiplex, so scheduling gets even harder since there are only so many ways into or out of a location. Trains full of high explosives or toxic chems drive right through downtown areas, often multiple times a day. From a crime and security perspective, airports are locked down pretty hard, while most people could probably just drive to a siding near them and fuck around; you can derail a train with a $400 block of steel you can order online. Communication and signal loss is also way more complicated, esp. if you're going through a mountainous or remote area.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by geophph on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:37AM (#36192330)
What a great rabbit hole. Thanks for sharing!
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Animats on Sunday June 04, 2023 @01:58PM (#36187772)
That's a quality job. I've been in a station when a Caltrain ballast replacement train came through. Caltrain just had a hopper car full of ballast rock dumping on new rock. A railroad tie was being pushed by the wheels of the hopper car to smooth the ballast. I was amazed that didn't result in derailing the hopper car. It was really low rent. I assume they followed up with a ballast tamper at some point, but it wasn't part of the ballast dump train.

Caltrain outsources much of their maintenance of way work, and it shows.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by AnimalMuppet on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:57PM (#36189516)
They'll[1] usually follow[2] that with a machine that picks the rails and ties/sleepers up and lays it back down on top of the newly-dropped ballast.

[1] For some value of "they". I don't know if Caltrain does it that way; most mainline US railroads do.

[2] That is, within a few days. Not necessarily within the time of someone hanging around to watch.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Animats on Sunday June 04, 2023 @05:29PM (#36189766)
Here's a video of that operation.[1] Yes, they really did level the ballast by putting a spare railroad tie ahead of the wheels of the hopper car. This was before the upgrade to concrete ties.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UWvuYdVV5-Q

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by chiph on Sunday June 04, 2023 @09:38PM (#36191295)
That was 23 years ago, but still looks low-rent. Here's how Brightline & the Florida East Coast Railroad are doing it in Florida for their double-track (mostly) expansion to Orlando.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vINzBkK1d-k

Note that the ballast hoppers have a solar panel on them to charge a battery, which runs a motor to actuate the hopper doors. Much better than a couple of guys with a wrench.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by ChuckMcM on Sunday June 04, 2023 @06:27PM (#36190179)
Thanks for that video link, curious how they do this on single track. Perhaps pick up the waste further down with the dump cars on a siding?
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by agumonkey on Monday June 05, 2023 @07:21AM (#36194846)
looks like dna transcription
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by kqr on Sunday June 04, 2023 @11:02AM (#36186126)
How the heck did we figure this stuff out? Honest question.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by jb1991 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @11:10AM (#36186221)
And this is just the kids stuff! Imagine getting people to walk on the moon.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by swader999 on Monday June 05, 2023 @07:41AM (#36194963)
Left foot, right foot. Repeat.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by dheera on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:11PM (#36187925)
Stupid question from a software person: Why don't they just pour cement, epoxy, or tar over all the stones to fix them in place, fill in the gaps, and prevent dirt from getting in them?
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by tedunangst on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:22PM (#36188059)
How does the water drain through them?
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by dheera on Sunday June 04, 2023 @02:26PM (#36188108)
Again here's my software mind:

(a) If you fill all the gaps, water can't get in in the first place, and it doesn't need to drain. Abstract out the problem.

(b) If water can still get in, it can also get out.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by grishka on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:20PM (#36188604)
Except sometimes water falls out of the sky and it needs to drain somewhere.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by dermesser on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:45PM (#36188869)
The rocks also need to be able to move a bit for elasticity, and have sharp edges. For that you also replace a part of the ballast every few years. That's hard to do when everything is sealed. Even with such "glue", the lifetime couldn't be eternal, after all.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by micromacrofoot on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:36PM (#36189348)
water snow and ice will readily destroy anything solid, better to drain it away - this is partially why roads need constant repaving
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by panick21_ on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:01PM (#36190381)
Three is this thing called slab track, and that's essentially what you are talking about, just without any stones.

https://grn.ams3.digitaloceanspaces.com/wp-content/uploads/D...

Truly almost all new lines should be built this way, its simply a far, far better method. Slightly higher capital cost but far less maintenance.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by viewtransform on Sunday June 04, 2023 @06:01PM (#36190012)
Apparently, trains do not derail that easily.

Army Experiments In Train Derailment (1944) https://youtu.be/agznZBiK_Bs?t=15

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Zardoz84 on Monday June 05, 2023 @06:49AM (#36194647)
There was a famous train accident in England thanks to dirty ballast stones, bad drainage, and rainy day.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by abrookewood on Monday June 05, 2023 @07:41PM (#36205953)
Thank you! I saw one of these yesterday and I couldn't work out why it was such a large machine given that the only thing it seemed to be doing was moving ballast slightly away from the tracks.