Part of the answer is that people going through airports are often buying expense account ones, and they're quite price flexible.
I bet the government is involved on that decision from your local one.
(If you didn't follow Bridgegate when it was happening, strap in for the most petty government overreach you've ever read about. I've read this article a number of times and honestly, you start reading and you can't look away. It's so good! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fort_Lee_lane_closure_scandal)
The intro blurb skips the appointed director and attributes the closing of the bridge directly to Christie, but Christie acted through a crony at the Port Authority, as can be read further in the Wikipedia article.
A comparable, frankly better looking, sandwich at Whole Foods in Columbus Circle is $7.99.
https://www.wholefoodsmarket.com/product/whole-foods-market-...
7-11 is the worst offender I've seen. Cheap sandwiches or salads for $8+. $3+ for a 20oz soda. No prices listed on anything. Or if they are it's only when you buy two or more.
Profiteering plain and simple.
In a further note, profit has got to be one of the most misunderstood things in economics. Every endeavor of human commerce has to involve profit for at least one party, otherwise the transaction would not occur at all. If you can put together a sandwich for $1 in ingredients and, say, $4 in your time and labor, why would you sell it for less than $5 plus some profit? At exactly $5 you may as well not engage in this business at all, since you've effectively gained nothing.
For the love of god what freakin city are you guys all Stockholm Syndromed on?
Don't be a cheapskate! head over to Zabar's Cafe and pay $29[0] for a ham and cheese sandwich! /s
[0] https://gothamist.com/news/why-does-this-ham-and-cheese-cost...
I guess it depends on how posh you want your sandwich.
You really have to try to get a Subway (the chain) sandwich that expensive. Same with a burrito from Chipotle, although that may be heretical[1].
---
1. https://flowingdata.com/2017/05/02/sandwich-alignment-chart/
Here’s Thundercloud, a popular chain (often described as “a step up from Subway”):
https://thundercloud.com/main-menu/
I also checked Jersey Mike’s, another familiar chain, and a regular size “original Italian” is $9.95 here.
I will say that generally Texas tends to have lower prices on food than coastal metros like NYC/SF/LA, but the airport prices mentioned in the article for NYC still seem absurd.
Texas makes up for not having income tax by having big property taxes. So, you may make out on that exchange depending upon what your family situation is. If you're earning are closer to median, California is probably better than Texas. If you're a high earner, Texas is probably better because California is biting you via income tax.
However, if you're coming to Texas, make damn sure your healthcare situation is sorted out. California is good about healthcare--the exchanges are decent and you can by healthcare retail for the price advertised on the exchange. This shocked me at one point as it meant that a friend could completely bypass the exchanges for healthcare and just buy it. Yeah, you wouldn't get reimbursement like the exchanges, but you could just whip out a credit card and purchase it retail.
Texas, on the other hand, is terrible at healthcare. The Republicans have sabotaged most things from the Federal government. Most of the hospital chains are mediocre and below, and many publicly available health plans are ferociously bad.
Property taxes are proportionately higher than in California but lower on an absolute basis for a similar property due to the large difference in purchase prices.
No state income taxes means most people with decent incomes will come out ahead in Texas.
What the sister comment says about healthcare in Texas is true, unfortunately. Most healthcare providers are private equity backed and treat healthcare as an assembly line. It is difficult to find providers who prioritize quality care over checking boxes.
As for publicly available plans I don’t have personal experience, but I don’t doubt the sister comment’s claims. Best have a good job with a quality healthcare plan.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/12i4fot/29_ham_and_che...
7-11 is ok in Japan or China (or say a Co-op Pronto in Switzerland). I wish we could get those in the states.
It’s about the port authority not publicly revealing what the 3 market comparable prices are.
So if the three vendors names tried to collude, then they would no longer be the lowest prices.
And there you have it, a perfect description of value. The sandwich costs $15 at the airport, because at the airport it’s worth $15. It may be worth less elsewhere, but that’s its value there.
They’re not selling a sandwich, they’re selling a sandwich you can have between flights.
At the airport, the vendor captures most of the surplus value due to their monopoly. Elsewhere, the consumer captures a lot of the surplus value due to robust competition between different vendors.
It's not the same as market price or market value. Market price is what you actually pay, value is the maximum you would hypothetically pay. The difference between the two is the "consumer surplus"[2].
It is situational, but I don't think it varies much in this scenario. You aren't any hungrier inside the airport than you are outside. If food was equally scarce in both locations, you would pay the same amount.
The value is the same in both locations, but the price is higher in the airport. That means consumer surplus is higher outside the airport. The cost to the producer is also roughly the same, so the producer surplus is higher in the airport. The producer has used their monopoly position to take a larger portion of the economic surplus inside the airport.
I think the poster was claiming that in fact the value is not the same. You aren't hungrier, but you are typically more tired, more rushed, and focused on bigger problems than what to eat for lunch, etc. It's a reasonable argument. That doesn't mean it's thing going on.
Literally every bit of theoretical marxism, including the Labor Theory of Value, the "absolute general law of capital accumulation", the "tendency for the rate of profit to fall", and the entire set of predictions around "dialectical materialism" are all debunked by more than a hundred years of history. Can we drop it now, or do we have to be enamored by his fashionable nonsense for another hundred years?
In Shenzhen every single person seemed to be running a business, and it felt like one of the most truly capitalist places I have ever been. In New Zealand people are dependent on their government, and few people try to run their own business. You don’t need to risk much in New Zealand, so most people don’t.
https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_surplus#Consumer_surplus
https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Surplus_value
Perhaps review: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Without the artificial barrier of the security perimeter, you'd be able to order food to be delivered to the airport.
But I meant ordering a pizza and having it delivered, or having a street food van selling sandwiches outside. Neither of those are possible.
Correct. A sandwich is worth more if you want a sandwich than if you don’t.
I always travel with sandwiches that I either make at home or buy. Throw it in your carry on bag and eat it whenever you want.
[0]: some restrictions on liquids or if you’re crossing a border with certain foods
You can technically bring an empty bottle of water or container and fill it up inside of the airport.
Your options would typically be a water fountain, bathroom sink or asking a bar tender to fill it up. Typically if you go the bar tender route you may end up tipping them so you don't escape some cost there.
I've also heard you can bring a frozen water bottle. The idea there is if it were a dangerous liquid then it wouldn't freeze so you're allowed to bring it. The hard part would be ensuring it stays fully frozen while waiting on line.
In the end you can extract X amount of money from all the passengers and that gets split between the landlord and the vendor.
So it's not just that the vendor has a monopoly, if they didn't have a monopoly there would still be some amount they'd pay in rent for the captive audience.
And other people feel better about raising taxes on people if they do so by raising taxes on corporations that then raise prices on people.
If this logic doesn't work, then there are some unstated assumptions.
I guess that the lack of competition isn't the only answer, in many cases there are many restaurants/stores in an airport and all of them are very expensive.
The price of the rent in the airport also has to be taken in account. In many airports the restaurants pay outrageous rent values that won't allow them to sell cheap food.
If you lift the peel off, many times they're still operated by the one contractor that has a contract for the whole airport. Even restaurants that typically don't franchise will still run operations under a franchise arrangement in airports. E.g. The Starbucks employees at an airport will be employed by HMS Host (a common airport food concession contractor).
Another captive element is alcohol. Many places only allow licensed establishments to sell it (ie: bars/restaurants), so no competition from the convenience store type concessions. And may be forbidden to consume alcohol outside licensed establishments so can't just buy a beer if convenience stores were legally allowed to sell it so they don't.
(Can recall good times at Amsterdam Schiphol where you could buy a beer for a not-too-insane markup from the convenience store and consume wherever, while in Philadelphia, you were paying like $10+ for one to consume wherever, ugh).
The real reason is greed. Competitors can work together to fix prices and they usually do. The reason again is greed.
Competition lowering prices only works when the barrier of entry to the market is very low and it's possible for many actors to compete. For SaaS businesses, where competition can virtually scale infinitely, that's true. Not at all for airports, where competition can only be very limited due to material constraints.
It doesn’t need to be anywhere near that extreme. Lots of people pay exorbitant prices for food at movie theatres and those facilities tend to be in commercial high traffic areas with tons of food service options such as malls, downtown streets, etc.
It’s really not hard at all to grab a bite before going into the theatre yet people still end up buying the ripoff theatre food!
And most theatres don't even give you real butter on the popcorn anymore. It's now this "artificial butter sauce" junk.
But all that aside, the process of going to the theater and standing in line and getting your overpriced junk food does add to the experience for many people, even if just due to nostalgia. Waiting in line to buy an overpriced sandwich at the airport is not an experience many people crave or are nostalgic for.
Of course it isn't. You're not going to enjoy a movie more just because you're shovelling puffy sweetened carbs into your face - unless you've been Pavlov'd into it.
Airport food is different, because there's a good chance some of the people who buy it genuinely need to eat.
I beg to differ. It definitely is a part of the experience for me.
The theaters don't make their money showing new movies (most of that goes to the studio) - they make most of their money on high margin concessions, mostly popcorn and soda.
And for infrequent traveler like me, I had no problem in eating airline food when I am coming home from long distance travel or eating outside after leaving airport when there is no food served in plane. If am starting from home its not too much of hassle to wrap a few rolls or sandwiches to carry.
Now for concession food to have authentic movies experience looks more of what marketers would say. I think besides streaming another reason cinema theater attendance is slimming is outrageous price of that authentic experience for large majority of people.
I've long had the "conspiracy theory" that they promote popcorn as part of the authentic part of the experience because it's an item that's most difficult to smuggle in -- with the butter, you'd have to pack it down tight, which would ruin it, and yet it's cheap to make at the theater. Plus they can afford to spend more on a machine than the average person would.
I like how grocery stores carry "theater packs" of candy. Perfect for a special home theater experience, along with some popcorn of course.
Unfortunately I don't have an icee machine at home.
I'd like to see a write up on why that is, because it seems like an insanely stupid arrangement at face value.
How do you have airside transfer when there are no barriers to leaving airside?
Certainly in Australia if you are travelling international you go through outbound immigration control. I'm not sure what happens if you need to get out again for some reason after you "exit" the country. I assume you have to "re-enter" the country by circling through inbound immigration. Perhaps having no land borders makes outbound immigration control more reasonable.
It does seem like the cost of adding some secure departure lounges might be less than circling huge numbers of passengers through unnecessary immigration procedures, security lines, etc
You can do that at a movie theater too. At least, I did it back when I was poor. Well, not with a sandwich, but I got some M&Ms and a drink at a nearby supermarket to take into the theater, because that saves a lot of money.
There is also the question of health code regulations. I know that in any restaurant which is inspected by County health inspectors, outside food is prohibited. So if you make a sandwich and you bring it into a McDonald's and you order a Coke and fries to go with your turkey sandwich, you will probably get kicked out. The main reason is because if something were to happen medically, whose food is to blame? Is it the food you prepared at home and brought into the restaurant? Even worse if you shared it to people who didn't know it wasn't prepared at the restaurant. The restaurant could potentially be liable for medical costs of people who got food poisoning, and their license to prepare food could be jeopardized.
Now, having said all that, this is not the case in airports or on airlines. They all allow you to bring in food you prepared at home, because an airport is not a "restaurant" with one kitchen where food is prepared. Aboard an aircraft, you could also eat your home-prepped turkey and Swiss sandwich instead of a delicious, hot, in-flight Kosher meal. If you get sick, well you get sick. I don't know if airlines can be liable for food poisoning, but they sure are cautious about peanut allergies these days.
They may have a policy against bringing your own food, but I don't think it's a reasonable policy and I don't see any reason to obey it if you don't want to and they don't enforce it.
If you want to make more money from the movie goers, just charge an extra buck for the ticket.
Whether it's silly or not, this isn't some new thing to boost revenue at airports. The US has long prohibited the "importation" of food items through airports. In fact, that was a key theme to the 1971 film, La Mortadella[0].
I'm not saying it's a good policy (I even "smuggled" some wonderful Dutch gouda into JFK myself a few years back), nor am I saying it makes sense in this day an age, but it (IIUC) has nothing to do with trying to make you pay more for food at the airport.
A good point. However, this wasn't vacuum sealed, just the standard wax around the ball of cheese wrapped in paper.
And I wouldn't have been all that excited to wolf down 2+ kg of cheese at the airport.
Did you know that the bananas we have today are different from the ones we had 50 years ago? The standard banana back then was wiped out by a fungal disease. Today’s bananas are all one variety of GMO, and resistant to such fungus.
That’s why produce is particularly scrutinized.
If my limited experience with hospital shops is anything to go by, yes, but it’s not the shop killing your pocket.
The landlord says some variation of ‘you’ll be the only coffee shop’ and the rent is about 8x what is sane.
The shop gets guaranteed business but has to charge a lot to pay the rent.
So, lack of competition inside the airport would not by itself be able to explain this pricing.
Corruption or incompetence within the Port Authority would explain it, and though I will withhold judgment, it's hard to think of what else it might be. It's even easier to jump to that conclusion when they also deny and conceal when asked for an explanation.
That sort of regulation is never very effective. The VA requires that vendors that sell them medical devices do not sell those devices at a higher price elsewhere. They end up buying a lot of SKUs that are only sold to the VA.
It is not the competition. It is about extracting maximum of what the customer could pay. Same reason beer is expensive at the event venues. The second part of your comment explains it perfectly.
[1] https://www.jfkairport.com/at-airport/shops-restaurants-and-...
Despite the "port authority" rules on 'street pricing', the real reason is lack of competition.
A single vendor receives the food contract for the airport, and they now have monopoly positioning and a captive audience. When business X is the only seller, and when the customers are held captive and unable to "go elsewhere" [1] then prices will naturally rise to the maximum the captive audience is willing to pay.
[1] How many air travelers are willing to exit the security perimeter, to then need to take a cab to somewhere (most airports are not located near dense shopping/restaurant areas) to purchase food, to then have to go back through security to return to their flight? And what few even have enough time between flight legs to even consider that "go outside the airport for food" trip as even possible? Plus by the time the "cab fee" is factored in, even if they could find the identical sandwich for 5.50 on the outside, the $10 + tip or more cab fee there and back would make the sandwich $15 or more in the end anyway.