* money that is programmed to be returned to the bank unless it is spent by X time
* money that is programmed to only be spent on certain goods or services
* high barriers to entry for businesses who want to allow money to be spent with them
* unaccountable/summary de-monetisation of persons and businesses on the whim of a government
* universal credit/benefits being issued as CBDC instead of fiat currency, creating a two-tier society where only the rich get access to fiat
* money that can have its spending and issuing rules changed quickly and easily by the current government of the day
The US food stamp system does this.
> unaccountable/summary de-monetisation of persons and businesses on the whim of a government
The US police seizure system does this; I submit that if this happens you have a serious rule-of-law problem and already, or are about to, have bigger problems.
> universal credit/benefits being issued as CBDC instead of fiat currency, creating a two-tier society where only the rich get access to fiat
This implies nonconvertibility?
The US police seizure system already is a serious rule-of-law problem due to lack of accountability.
The US police seizure system already is enshrined in the actual law. However, by the "rule-of-law" it is the law. The problem is that particular law, every single word of it.
Next, the bank starts applying negative interest rates when they need to "stimulate" asset prices and keep the stock market from crashing. No longer worried that people will pull cash out of their account to stuff under a mattress, your bank account starts dropping by 5% or 10% per year...
Can't they do this already by increasing money supply or QE? Central bank's can already create inflation which isn't dissimilar to negative interest rates.
Why would they do this? There's already a much more streamlined legal mechanism for this: taxes. Plus, this isn't some new feature. If the government orders you assets frozen/seized, then a bank is going to comply with the order.
> I imagine first there would be a fee for converting to cash (eg. if you "withdraw" 100 digital pounds, you get 90 paper ones).
Again, not new. This is basically an ATM fee. Paper money has costs associated with it, whether that cost is paid explicitly (through fees) or behind the scenes (collecting fees from purchases, selling information about you to third parties, or "borrowing" your deposits to collect interest on it) is pretty much irrelevant.
Nothing you're saying is a "new" feature of digital currency.
More importantly, this wouldn't be a tax on wealth, it would be a tax on savings, meaning it would disproportionately affect the less-wealthy and the less-credit-worthy, who tend to not own significant assets or have the borrowing power to buy them. In terms of the discrepancy with a wealth tax, imagine trying to save money to buy a house, except that the house price grows each year, due to negative interest rates, while your savings account shrinks by the same proportion. Perhaps it doesn't take much imagination, because it's similar to 2020's zero-interest-rate environment, but without the restraint of being bounded by zero.
Are you imagining the government using digital currency to enact some kind of "shrinking money" policy that would have the effect of a negative savings rate? If so, why would they do that, and couldn't they do that regardless of whether the central bank lending rate is positive or negative?
Indeed. The reason why this matters, and becomes possible, with a CBDC is that there is nowhere left to "withdraw" to. Private banks would not offer you any higher rates on savings than the CBDC does (why would they, when they can borrow at the interbank rate for less?). The fact that account holders would withdraw if rates on savings became negative is why central banks presently are unable to reduce the interest rate (significantly) below zero. With a CBDC, "withdrawing" simply means transferring from your private bank account to your CBDC account.
It would not be the government enacting this policy, but the central bank itself, as a necessary step to conducting monetary policy below the zero bound.
Why can't I use them to purchase dollars or yen? How did we get from the BofE issuing a currency that people can use to everyone being forced to use it? (Also, may I humbly suggest the wikipedia article on Gresham's Law, if you're not familiar with it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gresham%27s_law)
I agree that bad things would happen if everyone was forced to use a currency they don't want to use, but that's kind of axiomatic.
The interbank rate has to be lower than 7% I'm sure, but that's what I have in a savings account.
You aren't seriously trying to imply that it would be feasible for a government to decide to seize 5% of everyone's bank accounts at present? Being able to do something in a targeted manner and being able to do that same thing to the entire population at once with ease are not at all the same.
This is actually where a lot of people's perceptions about government tyranny seem to break down somewhat inexplicably. Guns? The police can show up right now and outnumber you so it makes no difference if they're outlawed. Restrictions on movement? The government can already blockade roads if they want to so it makes no difference if checkpoints are allowed to be constructed. Mass surveillance? The government can already wiretap you without your knowledge so it doesn't matter if that process is allowed to be automated.
All of those positions are very obviously false and yet a significant portion of the population seems to struggle with the common underlying concept. Enabling a behavior en masse with little to no friction is not at all the same as something targeted that requires noticeable resource expenditure to carry it out in each individual instance.
This is A) a correct, valid worry and B) isomorphic to the "surveillance" thing, in the sense that the surveillance is just a means to an end. They mostly want the surveillance in order to demonetise the outgroup (however that outgroup is defined).
This is basically a rationing system, like the olden days in China and the Soviet Union, where it wasn't enough to have money, you also needed a ration coupon to buy the good. Everything was rationed not just food, but bolts of clothes, consumer goods of any type, electronics (if you were fortunate enough to be able to afford it).
In this way the regime controlled scarcity and ensured loyalty and favoritism by awarding special rations and coupons for those who uphold the correct ideology and "meritorious labor". Each month your work unit issued a new ration book for the month that is based on your families' allotment of grains, cooking oil, clothing, soap, etc. If you are being a bad boy and you don't get your ration book for the month, you can't buy the goods in the state supply shop and have to go the black market.
Thus pure money wasn't good enough to live well or even to survive in those systems - one needed connections and access and the authorities can cancel your access at any time.
That is what a CBDC has the potential to evolve to and what worries me - a digital ration book. If all a CBDC is is digital cash, then we already have that system (Visa, e-payments, etc) and things won't change much but if a CBDC is a programmable form of money that can be disabled, inflated at will, turned off, or only allowed to buy certain goods - then there is no limit to the amount of tyranny that will be on hand. In a free country common people will not and should not accept it.
It has taken me a while today to get my head round this, but no we don't have digital cash.
Visa, e-payments etc. are all claims on financial institutions (banks, payment providers etc.). Those banks then indirectly have a claim on the Central Bank currency for us.
The only thing that gives private individuals a direct claim on CB currency is cash, which is increasingly less a part of society. This is the Bank of England (potentially) empowering private individuals and making us less beholden to banks.
All deposit takers in the U.K. are agents of the Bank.
Justifying extensions of government power with "but they can already do that" is cowardice at best and disingenuous at worst.
There's of course argument that if it's easier it will do it more often so it costs more. But that's something that will need to be controlled through political system.
Basically development of humanity is making forms of oppression increasingly more painless and predictable to both the oppressor and the oppressed. Predictability and painlessness is good for business so we thrive.
You can't get rid of oppression. Humans will always divide into the ones that hoard power and those who don't with former living off the latter. Best we can do and the best we've actually done is to make this process as painless and as predictable as possible. Currently we are at the stage of territorially divided monopolies on violence. We learned in world wars that "territorially divided" is a very important part.
What kind of opression do you prefer? Filling a tax form every year and paying what you calculated under the threat of arrest (while telling yourself you are voluntarily contributing to society and less fortunate) or being raided by a warband with guns on random intervals taking whatever they please and leaving you only what they at the time believe will let you bounce back so they can raid you again sometime in the future?
Either you are one who enacts or profits from violence or you are affected and robbed by violence. It's a constant setup since the beginning of the human race (or even before that). The only change that evolution of civilization delivers is making the violence predictable and gradual, thus less painfull, thus allowing for more efficient economic activity. If you make oppressors work harder for their cut they'll just take more from you once they do take it.
The main value of democracy is making the oppressed docile and easily subjugated.
And yes, winning election in US is way too costly. Budgets for campaigning should be capped. Other countries manage to sustain democracies with far less. Ultimately it doesn't matter who wins as long as it's not the same faction all the time. In that case unrest wouldn't be suppressed and violence would necessarily get more painful.
Democracy didn't win because it's moral or just. It won because it's most efficient system of maintaining oppression in post industrial technological landscape. You can look at how fragile single party system of China is, or Soviet Union was in comparison to even just rudimentary two party system like in US.
Gringos don't know how good they've had it.
Famously, credit cards prevented microtransactions from ever being a thing, and may have very well lead to the ad dystopia we now live in. Insisting on taking a % cut of every transaction, and not allowing small transactions to occur, has dramatically limited business models across a multitude of industries.
Imagine going back to 1999, before clickbait journalism, when newspapers were incredibly well staffed with fact checkers and when long form journalists could easily spend months upon months on a single article.
Now instead of forcing a race to the bottom of ads and needing to get as many eyeballs as possible, imagine if it was even possible to experiment with a 5 cent per article view microtransaction.
Reddit and Twitch have both shown that users are very willing to invest in microtransaction ecosystems for large enough content platforms.
Saying Visa is the same thing as digital cash is rather inaccurate!
Are those examples we want to emulate in broader society though? At various points in my life, I have used both of those services extensively. I have never spent money on Reddit, despite being a registered user for 12+ years. I lurked for a year or two at least before creating an account.
On Twitch, I did have a free Prime sub that I would use, but I never spent any more on the service. I'm admittedly behind on the meta now, but is it even possible to give a streamer 1 "bit"? Or is there a minimum requirement of 10 or 50 bits? When I watch streams, I see some people donate with bits, but it seems like a way to save the user from making multiple purchases in a row, rather than a new paradigm of wealth transfer. "Hey, I'm gonna buy 500 bits now and donate 50 per stream" as opposed to needing to pull out the credit card on streamlabs or paypal 5 times a week.
Quick note that regular money works like this, although you might not realize this if you grew up in the USA since afaik it has never happened here. Governments re-issue all the money quite often. UK did it in 1971. India did it in 2016. It happened when the Euro was launched.
At least that was the state of affairs until 2008. Since then the system is more or less in decay, at least by standards which where held before.
Now, if your government is of the kind that can realistically announce over the weekend that cash is going to be worthless by Monday unless exchanged, then yeah. Then again, if you live in a place like that, you probably already know to keep your money in foreign currency and use the black market exchanges as needed.
This is one of the main reasons why the US dollar has been the de facto reserve currency.
The rest of it already exists for normal money. Tyrannical control over finance isn't a property of a digital currency, it's a property of the government. Your causality is backwards. A bad government will do that whether they have a digital currency or not, and a digital currency has no moral properties as it's just a tool.
Whether a digital currency makes it easier at the margin to oppress people, I don't think it does. You can imagine how many headaches an imperfect implementation could cause.
If the digital currency is so restricted that people would rather use cash, it will death spiral to zero as merchants who accept it can't trade it for full value to others. The only way around that would be for the govt to backstop it and trade 1:1 with cash, which would defeat the purpose of the restrictions.
but all these could be used by a government to influence the voter behaviour such that they stay in power forever, China style.
you are ready for communism.
You're clearly convinced that governments slide inevitably towards authoritarianism and can only be prevented from doing so by practically restricting their powers, but it's a rather backwards way of thinking about things. An authoritarian government takes whatever powers it wants and wipes its arse with any rules that have been written to supposedly prevent it. If an authoritarian government thinks a CBDC will be useful it can just make one. Not that it would have to, because the government's existing powers are already sufficient to implement all the nefarious schemes people are worrying about in this thread.
The way to avoid the threat of an authoritarian government is to have a fair and well run electoral system, a healthy national political dialogue and a well educated population (not that these things are easy), not to assume the government is inevitably going to go bad and block it from implementing useful policies in a futile attempt to curtail the powers of the dictatorship you've convinced yourself it will one day become.
The solution to that logic is to abolish everything.
Everything else you state can already be done with the existing banking system.
How do you think fraud stops work?
We already have this: if you don't use your budget by xyz date, you lose it
> money that is programmed to only be spent on certain goods or services
Food stamps can only be spent on food, you must meet specific criteria for tax credits, etc.
> high barriers to entry for businesses who want to allow money to be spent with them
Some businesses will absolutely not take your money without extensive KYC already
> unaccountable/summary de-monetisation of persons and businesses on the whim of a government
Banks already arbitrarily shut down bank accounts with no recourse.
> universal credit/benefits being issued as CBDC instead of fiat currency, creating a two-tier society where only the rich get access to fiat
The whole point of money is that it's the common means of exchange, it's not very useful as money if only some people use it.
> money that can have its spending and issuing rules changed quickly and easily by the current government of the day
That's already the case today.
It doesn't apply to cash or my bank account. I do not want that to change. I will not support a tool that would enable this.
> Food stamps can only be spent on food
Those are not cash. Those are effectively gift cards for use at a grocery store.
> you must meet specific criteria for tax credits, etc.
Yet the tax credit is paid in cash. You can do with it as you will once you receive it. I will not support a tool that would change that.
> Some businesses will absolutely not take your money without extensive KYC already
The fact that a problem already exists is not an argument in support of making it worse.
> Banks already arbitrarily shut down bank accounts with no recourse.
Once again that doesn't justify actively making things worse.
> The whole point of money is that it's the common means of exchange, it's not very useful as money if only some people use it.
Many countries apply controls when converting to or from foreign currency. China in particular is known for this. Does that mean that their currency isn't useful to the people who live there? If the poor aren't permitted access to traditional cash they would have no choice but to use the CBDC whether they wanted to or not. At least aside from outright bartering, which is even less flexible.
> > money that can have its spending and issuing rules changed quickly and easily by the current government of the day
> That's already the case today.
No, from the perspective of the individual it absolutely is not. If I have US cash or even a balance in a bank account in the US the government cannot "quickly and easily" modify the rules by which I can spend it. Particularly for paper cash their only options seem to be either to outlaw a particular sort of transaction and hope the police can enforce that (doesn't work, see drugs) or reissue the currency to force me to exchange it for something that they have more control over such as a CBDC.
I at least believe that governments have higher barrier than private entities that have already provably done this.
Of course it does. There is no central registry of who has accounts where and what they’re doing. Records are maintained at the edge. Modern banking is topologically decentralised.
CBDC opens central bank money to the masses. (It isn’t a new idea [1][2].) It has advantages. One disadvantage is it ports over blockchain’s centralised record-keeping. Running a search on everyone who purchased from or donated to X between such and such dates changes from a record request to every bank, credit card company and P2P app that did business with X, a request process which takes time, may cross jurisdictions, tends to require X’s coöperation, and is lossy with some payment methods, into a database lookup.
The quiet power grab is this being, with virtually zero debate, a central bank’s digital currency versus e.g. an independent public bank’s.
[1] https://rooseveltinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/GD...
[2] https://www.investopedia.com/what-is-postal-banking-5217341
And any future authoritarian regime will of course not play by today's rules, and put the opposition under financial scrutiny within a day, and simply starve the people it doesn't like.
I hate banks, but I think I like them better than this option.
Or current authoritarian regimes. We have already seen protesters in Canada have their bank accounts frozen by edicts from the government without any sort of trial or legal process. Truly frightening to think what they would do in a cashless society (which is the ultimate goal of centralized digital currency) to coerce all sorts of desired "behavior".
Every party knows something about me, but nobody knows enough for me to be worried. The current system is pretty good at protecting my privacy, especially given how primitive it all is.
Anti money laundering regulations allow the authorities to gather a full picture if they need to.
Including any accountants or financial or legal professionals you interact with - all of whom are required by law to report any activity they consider suspicious.
I don't see how having the govt foot the unprofitable part of the whole thing for no clear benefit for them (govt already know everything, kinda) will help the financial system at all.
https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/feds/the-macroeconomi...
There are no laws in existance to protect access to currency and if it is successful there will be no way to exercise resistance should government cease to be answerable to the people.
Money needs to be as far from politics as possible, a central digital coin is the opposite.
Anyway, I think governments could regulate better to make payments more of a public infrastructure type deal. The banks will still make a stack of cash on all the other things they do.
Facebook’s goal is mostly to make money. Facebook will not put you in jail, or fine you.
As bad as you think these companies are, they never committed war, crimes or genocides.
There is a massive difference between being tracked by states (who have a monopoly on violence and terrible track records) and advertising firms.
https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2022/09/myanmar-faceb...
I understand the argument but I suspect in practice you will be less susceptible to the predations of your bank and substantially more susceptible to the predations of your government.
At which point you should ask yourself, is it easier for me to change my bank or my government?
Also CDBCs are programmable, Programmable money is a dangerous tool in my opinion. The State could thoroughly control everything you could do with money (e.g. carbon allowances, money that expires etc.), money would literally become vouchers controlled by the government. Pure dystopia.
"This is a good thing" is a very strange conclusion. Yes, let's shrink the private economy and make people deal directly with the government for the most basic unit of commerce, money. I can't possibly see how this could go wrong.
The assumption that CBDC is a good idea because the government is always benevolent and does what's best for the people is incorrect, as demonstrated by the horrible financial mismanagement in the recent 20 years.
I'm sure it will not fail right away, and there will be a sustained period of benefit. But I don't think it's worth the longer-term risk.
Know of any?
Any system of government that relies on a successive chain of responsible people in power is doomed to fail more quickly than anyone thinks. This is why the American idea of "ambition must be made to counteract ambition" is so powerful.
Anyone who has ever tried reconciling separate accounts knows how hard it is. To have it all in one account, and therefore queryable from one single API, is an absolute step function in the direction of surveillance.
Just think about how taboo it is to ask someone how much they make/have, and think about why it's taboo. Financial information is some of the most private information there is. Before you know it, with all of it under one API (or in one account), Equifax will release a product gatekeeping access to this API to "verify" income or assets, but in a far more powerful way than they already do.
This is completely wrong. Centralized, programmable digital currency gives the government complete control over how, when and where you are allowed to spend your own money. Its implementation would be the most dystopian possible development.
The magnanimously negative impact of Brexit on the kingdom coupled with recent outlandishly irresponsible neoliberal monetary policy have put the UK in a precarious situation where member nations are unironically reconsidering membership. Scotland last november gave it serious consideration, and in 2021 Wales seemed poised to give it a go as well. the alternative these states are electing is the EU and if such a choice were to be made it would surely spell disaster for England.
Brexit has also created an unnecessary burden on corporations with a euro presence in that all must now be renegotiated at significant expense. The easiest path is to simply tell this relatively small kingdom of 67 million to trade only in euros, and this in turn would further devalue the pound sterling.
the "Digital Sterling" serves a twofold purpose: to distract from the slow rolling catastrophe of Brexit and other hardline neoliberal policies by offering something that appears to be progress, and as a desperate effort to court business and commerce back to the kingdom.
magnanimous (adjective)
1. Highly moral, especially in showing kindness or forgiveness, as in overlooking insults or not seeking revenge.
2. Great of mind, elevated in soul or in sentiment, raised above what is low, mean, or ungenerous of lofty and courageous spirit.
3. Dictated by or exhibiting nobleness of soul; honorable; noble; not selfish.
(The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, 5th Edition.)
This isn't quite true. Most concern is about how mundane transactions are tracked. Things like how your grandma giving you $5 could now be tracked. Obviously this won't be an issue if physical cash still exists, but it would if that was eliminated. The other aspect of a digital currency is that it allows for much finer detailed tracking. High precision. This is still useful in our ever increasingly surveilled world.
I don't know how the UK works, but in the US banks don't need to report when the inflow/outflow is <$10k. Meaning that for most people Venmo could choose not to report to the IRS for them (no idea if they do or not, but if they do, another business model could not) because their annual transactions don't exceed $10k. So even digitally, your small standard transactions aren't (necessarily) being tracked. This could even include things like tips for servers. Of course, the Fed has recently been pushing for this threshold to come down to $600[0] with an explanation that this targets the rich who have multiple bank accounts that are amassing millions of untaxed income.
I am actually for digital currencies, but I personally think we need to make them like digital cash. That is, they use ZKP transactions with minimal metadata to produce as anonymous transactions as possible. Surveillance capitalism and surveillance states have been a mistake. We had centuries of tracking commerce with physical cash and have learned a lot about how to catch fraud and theft. While anonymous payments can enable some more theft I don't personally believe that any government needs to specifically track what an individual person is spending their money on.As a data nerd, I'd be perfectly fine if we had some homomorphic encryption that allowed for some anonymized analysis on how aggregates of people are spending their money but I still don't think we should be tracking citizens.
[0] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/irs-bank-account-update-change-...
Why is a CBDC necessary for that?
Also KYC is definitely not bothering people that are actually laundering the largest volumes of money. See https://violationtracker.goodjobsfirst.org/industry/financia...
Every single bank you have an account with already has to keep track of know-your-customer information. It's not like the fact that there's a centralized digital currency will give the government more control over you than not. The government can simply tell the banks to hold your assets, put you on a list that prevents payments providers to service you, etc.
The digital currency won't make any of that worse.
The good thing about digital currencies is that'll actually take power away from commercial banks. Right now you need to go through someone like Barclays, HSBC, etc, to get your money. CBDC actually lets you keep your balance directly with the government ledger and avoid relying on banks for everything. This is a good thing.
Beware that commercial banks are obviously opposed to this and will be very vocal about it.